Not a question of who sang it better, the Maestro chose to sing Ustaad Mahdi Hassan's composition speaks of his appreciation of the latter. A legend is never shy of appreciating merit or class no matter even if it comes from someone else. I believe no other sher could be more apt for this as Ghalib once said " Rekhta ke tumhi Ustaad nahin Ghalib, kehtein hain ki agle zamane mein koi Mir bhi tha."
To poet Meer Taqi Meer...Wish one day i will visit his grave in Lucknow oneday...And will tell him even a Bengali boy turn into middle aged man hearing you, still love you and feel your pain of 200 years ago still from Bangladesh...
It's first sung by Naseem Bano itself only for the film pakeeza later on sung by many singers including the greatest legend of undivided India ustad mehdi Hasan sahab.... immortal lyrics of Mir Taqi meer and heart touching music of the greatest legend Naushad sahab.......
Neither mehdi hassan or Jagjit composed this master piece is a thumri composed by Ghulam mohammed the great composer of Film Pakeezah originaly sung by Naseem Bano
Jagjeet will alway be close to my heart and I miss him dearly but he should never have tried singing Mehdi Hasan ever! Jagjeet should also not have attempted to decipher the couplet for he ruined the meanings altogether 😕
मेहदी हसन की आवाज़ सड़ी gadhaiya जैसी नकसूर, जीभ लपेटती हुए है। मेहदी हसन जितनी बुरी आवाज़ ढूंढना मुश्किल ही नहीं बल्कि नामुमकिन है। वह आवाज़ को ऊपर नहीं ले जा पाता उसकी आवाज़ कांपने लगती है आरोही स्वर में। ऐसा उसने यूट्यूब पर मौजूद एक वीडियो इंटरव्यू में ख़ुद बताया है।
He's 500 times better than Mehdi Hassan. Infact Mehdi Hassan copied Nasreen Chopra's dhun because Naseem Chopra has sung this ghazal much before Mehdi hASSAN. Shut the fuck up.
What mehandi hassan sang is not even 0.1 percent of mina kumari the original singer who sang this song in pakizaah move it was actually used as background song
Not a question of who sang it better, the Maestro chose to sing Ustaad Mahdi Hassan's composition speaks of his appreciation of the latter. A legend is never shy of appreciating merit or class no matter even if it comes from someone else. I believe no other sher could be more apt for this as Ghalib once said " Rekhta ke tumhi Ustaad nahin Ghalib, kehtein hain ki agle zamane mein koi Mir bhi tha."
Compliments
Wonderful 👍
To poet
Meer Taqi Meer...Wish one day i will visit his grave in Lucknow oneday...And will tell him even a Bengali boy turn into middle aged man hearing you, still love you and feel your pain of 200 years ago still from Bangladesh...
what i could hear from talks somewhere that his grave no longer exists . Railway line came up there .
Oh!me too from Bangladesh!
When God made Jagjit jee ..jay Jagjit hare..
Both legends can never be compared.
Kyaa baat hai. Jagjit Singh Aur Mir ko Salaam
It's first sung by Naseem Bano itself only for the film pakeeza later on sung by many singers including the greatest legend of undivided India ustad mehdi Hasan sahab.... immortal lyrics of Mir Taqi meer and heart touching music of the greatest legend Naushad sahab.......
Ohoo bhut hee dil ko chune vale gazl
Wah mehandi Hassan and jagjeet both great apna jagah
Neither mehdi hassan or Jagjit composed this master piece is a thumri composed by Ghulam mohammed the great composer of Film Pakeezah originaly sung by Naseem Bano
zindgi ko saath le jati apki awaz jgjit jii...miss u srr
Miss you ustad ji 🥺🙏
Sheer brilliance, sheer class. The Mastero.
Great..
Miss you Jagjit ji.
💕💕💕💕
This is not jagjit singh ji’s voice. I can bet.
THANKS 4 REMASTERING THE AUDIO
BETTER THAN MEHDI HASSAN VERSION
He is criticized coz he is non muslim. Its a shame on communal people...
क्लासिकल गायकी में परिपूर्ण ग़ज़ल सम्राट की आवाज़ बुलंद, मर्दाना, स्पष्ट और मधुर है।जबकि मेहदी हसन की आवाज़ बुरी, अस्पष्ट, नकसुरी है।
Aur aapka yeh vaktvya aapki moorkhta ke siva kisi chiz ka parichayak nai. Kripa mooh se tatti karna band karian. Aur dafa ho jaye
ऐसा मत कहिए please🙏🙏
Jagjeet will alway be close to my heart and I miss him dearly but he should never have tried singing Mehdi Hasan ever! Jagjeet should also not have attempted to decipher the couplet for he ruined the meanings altogether 😕
मेहदी हसन की आवाज़ सड़ी gadhaiya जैसी नकसूर, जीभ लपेटती हुए है। मेहदी हसन जितनी बुरी आवाज़ ढूंढना मुश्किल ही नहीं बल्कि नामुमकिन है। वह आवाज़ को ऊपर नहीं ले जा पाता उसकी आवाज़ कांपने लगती है आरोही स्वर में। ऐसा उसने यूट्यूब पर मौजूद एक वीडियो इंटरव्यू में ख़ुद बताया है।
It is not 1% of Mehdi hassan.....
He's 500 times better than Mehdi Hassan. Infact Mehdi Hassan copied Nasreen Chopra's dhun because Naseem Chopra has sung this ghazal much before Mehdi hASSAN. Shut the fuck up.
What mehandi hassan sang is not even 0.1 percent of mina kumari the original singer who sang this song in pakizaah move it was actually used as background song
Are we not too ignorant to judge these legends? sit back and feel blessed that you are getting to hear them.
@@ShafikKhan-zq8kn ye plain monotonic tone me gaye hoay ghazal agr Mehdi Hasan se behtar hai to Bhai apke music sense kafi ziada hi ache hai 🥲🥲
Hari Haran ne Irfan Gabol k TH-cam channel pe Mehdi Hasan k craft aur perfection pe bat ki hai wo sunny laiq hai.