Was That ‘Shirk’ Dialogue Justified? | Meray Paas Tum Ho | Weekend in Review | Something Haute
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- Was That ‘Shirk’ Dialogue Justified? | Meray Paas Tum Ho | Weekend in Review | Something Haute
Ehd e Wafa 1:08
Ishq Zahe Naseeb 11:45
Alif 18:40
Meray Paas Tum Ho 26:16
Don't forget to subscribe to our channel: bit.ly/Subscrib...
Facebook: bit.ly/Somethin...
Instagram: bit.ly/Somethin... - บันเทิง
Is anyone going to address the fact that Danish literally can’t take Mehwish back? They are LITERALLY divorced. And she never got remarried so...
What did this lady meant when she was insisting Danish to forgive Mahwish???....Arey bhaee unka divorce hua hai separation ni!!!
duriyyamustafa This lady is a typical stupid feminist.
I feel like everyone has conveniently forgotten the laws of talaq in Islam.
Islam me aik ya 2 talaq k.bad 3 months k.adar rujo ki gunjaish hai or agar zada time hogia hai to.nikah kerk wapsi honsakti hai usi mard k.pas.shart ye hai k talaq nama me ya wese 3 talaq na ho, after 3 talaq kisi or se married hona zarori hai jisay halala kehte hen
Lekin mostly hamare han 3 talaq di jati hai ya talaq nama me likha jata hai jiski waja se usi mard k pas wapsi ki gunjaish khatam ho jati hai or kisi or se shadi or phir talaq k baad mumkin hai jo sharyi tor pe ho
If a person dies without repenting of his “shirk” then he/she is bound for hell but his / her door of repentance is open till their death ! And yes the word “shirk” should not have been used , it’s a specific terminology used for Allah SWT !
Yes, 2ndly why this whole scene when danish already told in previous episode to friend salman in office that: maf krdia mehwish ko
That is for people who aren’t muslims. Once you’re a muslim and you proceed to do shirk after that then you can’t be forgiven. Being a muslim you already know there is one God, the one supreme leader if you knowing this then put another on the same status then that’s shirk and there is no repentance for that. Non whatsoever!
Firstly, the "shirk" dialogue happens when Danish's friend asks "why is it that women can forgive men while men can't do that. we need to set an example that here's a man who has forgiven his wife". And then the shirk dialogue happens as a response to why women can forgive and men can't. So technically, cheating on a wife isn't equal to shirk but cheating on your husband is?
Secondly, for believers, the word shirk can only be used in the context of God. And no man should claim that his partner committed shirk in the relationship because by saying so he automatically puts himself superior to his partner. Mind you, shirk is not synonymous to cheating. Shirk is a term that is specifically used when a worshiper isn't loyal to his creator.
And lastly, Kalil ur Rehman previously used the same argument in "Zara yaad Kar" where the philosopher mother schools her daughter by saying that "just like God, a man also acts as a protector but does not forgive shirk" .
So please don't give Khalil ur Rehman the benefit of doubt.
Totally agree!
Agree
Exactly. This dialogue reminded me of Zara Yaad Kar where the girl's mother states the same point of view. Very problematic.
Totally agree
Well said!!
I totally agree with Amna saying there is too much philosophy in Meray Paas Tum Ho. It drives me crazy. Do humans talk like that in real life?
Maha Tanveer Amina app nay yeh to suna ho ga agar Allah appnay illawa kisse ko sajdha kernay ko kahta to wo shoher ko sajdah kernay ko kahta that’s y shoher ko majazee khuda kahtay hain
Yes maha s0metimes in a very serious m0de I'm talked like that🙄 nd then my Mamma said bs kr tu kitaben prh prh kr tera dimag ghum gya h😂🤦
I would love to see aamna interviewing Mr Khalil ur rehman
Oppss
She will never
that'd be something to watch 😂
Oh he would never sit with someone like Amna who would rip him to shreds. That's why he chose some obscure blog where he could bully the interviewer to be silent while he went on a rant.
iram khan 😂👌🏼 you spoke my heart!
I stumbled on something haute accidentally while watching a missed episode of meray pas tum ho and since then I'm completely hooked to 'something haute'
What a fine accident
- Hassan
Some time I enjoy your show more than dramas
amen
True
me 2
True
Salma Khalid several times more
I mean Allah and bandas relationship is of creator and worshipper.
Human relationships cannot be compared to that.
I agree with amna
Yusra Siddiqui 100 percent
Amna is a extremist. She took the extreme explanation. When a person commits an affair this is involving partners with your spouse. So daft you people are. it's poetic not literal.
I agree with Amna too ..zina ki maafi hai n shirk ki maafi Nahi..totally wrong dialogue!
@@zubairsadiq4475 Thanks for enlightening me...I had no idea what is the difference between literal and otherwise ...I guess i still have a long way to go!!! There is a purpose behind every dialogue wriiten and this completely went over board....The comparison is not just inappropriate, its indecent and unacceptable. There is no room for comparisons to be made. If this same dialogue was used in context of a woman ....the male highnesses would have been on the streets giving FATWA!!! Besides the hippocratic writing and double standards reflect exactly what I have heard the writer utter in his interviews.
Khuda shirk zindagi mn maafi manngnay py maaf krdeta hy. Maut k bad ni krta
And i agree with Amna. Who are we to compare ourselves with God
This is what was missing from the argument. This clarity is what people don't know or forget about. Amna is spot on in this.
IMHO by using the word shirk, writer has committed shirk. This word is specifically used in reference to God & should not be used symbolically in any other manner. However, it is not uncommon for writers to test boundaries of acceptance by viewers.
he did not compare himself to God. Why would he.
Aamna's analysis and objections on the shirk Wala dialogue makes more sense.
Dua ka ayatul kursi wala scene boht phenomenal Tha. Like amna I don't like chekhain marte rote huy death scenes
Amna is absolutely right on word "shirk" she describes better and it shouldn't be or it can be handle different way
In both Alif and MPTH.. two very wrong dialogues have been used abt Allah's forgiveness. Atleast consult someone with knowledge, before using such dialogues. Although, its also common sense but still somehow they are getting it wrong. Allah forgives all sins including shirk as long as a person asks for forgiveness and doesnt die in a state of shirk. If there was a sin which Allah would never forgive then this life would be meaningless and hopeless.. 🤦♂️
In alif it was wrong unho n shirk ka nam ni Lia kha bdy S bda gunah Allah b maaf ni krta... Bhai tmhy Kia pta Allah maaf kry GA ya ni.... Wo Ghuffor.r.Rheem h..... R hm janty b hn k husn e jhan n shirk ni Kia tha Phr wo fzool dialogue bolny ka Kia scene tha
@@sadiawali4973 yes u are right....
@@sadiawali4973 hmm.... Can't talk in detail about which I dnt know much
@@sadiawali4973 yes it's true.... I m lover of alif.... I have read novel when it was coming in episodes... I m fan of umera Ahmed writing
Empath 1.0 yes, in Alif too!!
the shirk dialogue was actually not acceptable. I agree with Amna.
No Fantasy it’s acceptable i think you also need Islamic knowledge like amina🙄🙄
Great reviews as usual guys 👍👍
Here is my opinion abt the qs u put up in ur review:
1) Ehd e Wafa: I completely agree with Hasaan abt the character of Saad " too good to be true" but Ahad's performance makes it as likable as possible. 😊
2) Alif: Yes, Hassan second ur opinion regarding the attitude of Momina's parents. In the start of this episode, Sultan offers to pick Momin's luggage as a kind father would do and they are naturally concerned abt her wellbeing, it's just that they find it very hard to digest the death of their only son at such a young age, which I find quite realistic.
U guys should also praise Hamza and Manzar Sebhai's acting in particular. They are exceptional!!
3) MPTH: This time I second Amna's opinion, though Hassan justified his opinion greatly. " Shirk" with reference to "Allah" is a very huge and powerful thing to say. U cannot most definitely say this as a joke or for something like human relationships. Yes, Mehwish broke the bond of sanctity of her marriage, even went so far as to commit "Shirk" but is this sin as unpardonable as the sin of associating partners with Allah??
That's my opinion abt this dialogue. Open for debate...
Very well said💯
After seeing the maham scene ( 2.5 crore wala) I feel that Khalil rehman sattiya gaye he
Fouzia Siddiqui agree
He’s clearly demented
Mere paas tum ho ; every one is philosophical except Mehwish and Shahwar, straight fwd and great entertainers :D
Most annoying award goes to Wathira
2nd most to abba k pechay pari Ms Hania
Right
Is it Bathira or Wathira?
hahaha shukar he principal sahiba k further scenes nahi thay werna woh bhi kum philosphy nahi jharteen
The whole concept of this writer is that man can marry more than one women and could have in relationship with more than one women but women can't have two relationship at a time
Lekin having extramarital relationships with more than one women isn't shirk in Islam, right?
The philosophy of great Kalil ur Rehman
Wait , Who said that ?
Aamina interview with Khalil ur rehman would be a mega hit on you tube. U should sit with him and ask all your questions .
Amna, I am willing to work with you to bring him down-
yes aminah, get him...i mean please take his interview so that we can understand why his views and writings are so twisted
i interpreted shirk dialogue same as aminah did...it didnt make any sense at all and totally tried to bring a man's status to God
No offense to him but he wouldn't be able to answer her questions.
Wat he is saying about shirk he is absolutely right.
Mere pass tum ho: definitely a zabardasti ki episode. shirk wala dialogue was a deliberate use of a totally unnecessary refrence to shirk and Allah. just an attempt to create a social media stir and hype during the week.
Great to see Amna back with a BANG..! She raised some very interesting and debatable points, which I am going to discuss in my next comment.
Both Amna and Hassan give entertaining & witty reviews, which is truly a pleasure to watch❤💞
I completely agree with Amna about the shrik dialogue. Eveyone is trying to be very philosophical in Meray pas tum ho sometimes with no “Sar payr “.
On that 'shirk' dialogue, I think I agree with Amna absolutely that the use of word 'shirk' was very offensive as this is used for Allah only, by the believers; for us 'shirk' is worshipping someone else than Allah. Using 'shirk' was as if we are equating the Allah with that man, it could've been much much better if they've used 'muhabbat mai sharakat'. 'Muhabbat mai sharakat toh Allah b maaf nhi krta, (insaan kaisy krskta a)" It is not as offensive as the word 'shirk' is.
Mehwish has done 'muhabbat mai sharakat' but she definitely hasn't committed 'shirk'.
I agree with Amna at the shirk point, I felt like a man shouldn’t compare himself to God and that’s exactly what Danish did. In my opinion
but ye bat b sach hai k shoahar ko mijazi khuda b kaha jata hai thats why he compared may b its my opinion
By using word 'shirk' he is not comparing himself with Allah. Shirk is just an arabic word. For God sake don't make this word sacred. It just mean 'to join partners'. Here there isn't discrimination also on gender. If husband also do the same mistake wife has the right to do the same. But again if I have to voice my thoughts any person who cannot forgive his/her partner or any person, it is the person itself who suffer a lot rather the person who did wrong. That why we say 'Maaf karne wala bada hota hai'. Because one who forgives will become selfless and is more pious and He/She doesn't have any more ill feelings towards that person.
Ye dialogue he galat tha shirk wala..!
Allah shirk maaf kar deta hai, koi bhi mushrik jab bhi shirk se tauba karta he to Allah shirk bhi maaf kar deta he... !
But if you have developed a true relationship of Toheed with Allah, then no shirk is forbidden.
Unko maaf karta ha jinhon ne pehly kabhi usy ni maana...jo muslman ho aur shirk kary to maafi ni
Allah said already shirk ki maafi nahi hai toba toh baat ki baat hai...har gunnah maaf karo gaya per shirk Nahi
Allah shirk maaf krdeta h magr uss wqt jb aap tuba kren dil se ar phir shirk krna chor dain laikn baghair tuba k Allah har gunah maaf krdega sewae shirk k
Allah shirk maaf karta hai jub insaan sachay dil se tauba karta hai. Lekin agar halat e shirk me mur jaey to Allah ka wada hai maf nahin karay ga.
But I vote with Hasan ki baat
I totally agree with amna's point of view on "shirk" dialogue... she's such a talented grl masha ALLAH.
Yess I agres! Go Amna 💜
Lol 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂
I laughed so hard over when amna mistakenly said that sameer's step mother and jhangir would hook up .. lmao
Loved aminas point of view about the two women conversations in this drama . (MPTH)She does have a valid point on shirk conversation n everything. She did an amazing job 😘
Amina I agree with you that word “shirk” shouldn’t be used in this conversation at all!
I am with Aamna on the shirk dialogue. Our relationship with Allah is one of worship, obedience and acceptance of Him as our Creator whereas our relationship with another human is one of partnership, equality, romance, sexuality, Therefore to compare shirk with Allah ( to say one worships a second being) to that of shirk with a human (one sharing their love/ romance etc with another human) is completely wrong!
I'd like to Imagine what the reaction would be if this dialogue were said by a woman about her husband. Is it that kind of "shirk" if a husband married twice (assuming he can do both justice) and therefore unforgivable???????
Hassan asked why Duas father had to die and it is a valid question
I can tell from my own experience that after calling off my unhappy long engagement we had extremly similar discussions and fights even in the car
At times we would have to scream for our father to drive slower
I dont know what it is with speed and anger that can turn easily into deathly situations but to me it was close to home
The whole situation made all of us watching rather uncomfortable leaving us teary eyed
We are fortunate neither of us died that day in the car though it can be someone elses reality
hassan needs to stop mansplaining, amna very well said about shirk!
It is KRQ and his shirk dialogue that Hassan is supporting
This episode of MPTH was a bit confusing and had some meaningless moments. To begin with Maham, who once slapped and threw out her hubby's mistress, came to meet her. In my opinion, this confrontation scene was unnecessary. It's not as if Maham came to insult Mehwish but she insulted herself. The question remains: Why is she having the soft corner for Mehwish, who ruined her home and offering her money as the 'salary' for staying with Shehwar for 5 months???With due respect for the writer, Mehwish didn't share the status of Maham's, as she was merely the lust object for her sweet hubby. Secondly, why just target the woman alone for infidelity? Since there was also a man who was disloyal to his wife. So there has to be an equal punishment for both. After all the fiasco, Maham still wants her husband back and claims her money(The salary) as Shehwar's! Too much confusing. As for the end of the play, Mehwish won't die or be killed, as she already attempted to commit suicide. Apparently, she seems to have no regrets for what she did to her family. For her ex-husband, why is she so possessive? Coming back to the most contradictory line of Shirk, it seems as if Humayun is a demigod or something to say such a thing. Comparing himself with the God is absolutely worthless, as he is only a mortal. Danish and Hania's relation might not be a better choice as this gives a negative thought, like Mehwish left her husband for Shehwar so in return, Danish got married to Hania(as a part of taking revenge) and moved on. What is going to happen in the last two episodes is partially predictible.
I live in sweden and study with lot of arbi speaking people, i confirmed from them, even in arabi language shirk word is not used between human... it is used for Allah and man only.
Please convey to people.
40:53 Amna u should definitely interview Khalil ur Rehman Qamar v also want to know his story
Definitely , that'd be real fun to watch Amna interviewing Khalil :P .. i totally agree with you Potti Girl !
Potter girl larayee ho jani hai
@@itsmeayana3220 maza ayega dekhne mai lol😉😜
Khalil ur Rehman Qamar k mostly drame isi trah k hte hain potraying betrayal stories of married women...
I remember that another drama named "TOH DIL KA KIA HUA" was also same story like MPTH, n even the female betrayal women was also played by Aiza Khan as Maya...
So, yeah i think there is definitely something happened in his life like betrayal from women where he just pursue all of them as the same.
@@SarahShakeelmic watch sadqay tumhare it's based on his life
I totally agree with Amna on the Shirk issue ...there was no need to use such a word only use for Allah Almighty
It's very simple Amna and I totally agree with you. The drama is incredibly offensive to women. Khalil is an un-closeted woman hated and this is his love letter for his entire gender. Dude has been jilted by someone in real life for sure LOL
And Hassan needs to let Amna talk when she is trying to explain something. Poor thing couldn't finish a sentence during the shirk conversation.
agree Hassan tends to raise his voice when he interrupts amna, not cool, its a malady of the subcontinent men, cant wait for their turn to talk, listen to Indian political shows, if you want proof
@@geetagavin totally agree with you. Very unprofessional.
I agree w Amna on the usage of the term of shirk, but it was very interesting to see both the point of views. But yes shirk is an unforgivable sin, clearly versed in the Quran. I love the fact that Hasan and Amna come up with completely different arguments, justify them and then agree on disagreeing- it’s so refreshing!
Amna and Hassan thank you so much for pointing out the Maham and Mahwesh scene. It really boiled my blood. Maham also said that jo mard ghalti kare tou uss k saath life achi guzarti hai(something like that)😡😡.
Imagine Amna and Khalil ur rehman sitting 🪑 face to face 😂 😂 😂.
Lol😂
Lol same! The moment I saw that sequence with Dua’s father recklessly driving the car. I was sure as anything k someone’s going to die.
Amazing performance by alizeh.... When it was death scene I thought now we will see how she will portray that emotions and she completely nailed it.... Roty huy poori ayat ul kursi prhna... Phr emotions b show krna ... I think it gives me goosebumps whenever I watch it.... I think this episode belong to alizeh
The SHIRK dialogue meant that if khuda who forgives each and every sin of humans beside Shirk so how can a weak human tolerate if his/her spouse SHAREEK someone and betray .. ofcource humans are not ghafoor o raheem as Allah
Exactly ...same thinking. ...
Well said exactly
Allah will forgive shirk if a guy or girl repent before her death but it will not be forgiven after death,
Muhammad Ahmed why can’t khuda forgive shirk?
I would love to see amna' interview with khalil ur Rehman
Me too
13:43 that hayeeeeeee 😂😂😂 Amna is soooo cute ❣️
My most favorite part in Ishq Zehnaseeb was when Gohar says "Bas kardo, band kar do yeh drama". Same girl, same!!
I totally agree with amina on the review and particularly about the shirk dialogue in meray pas tum ho
Honestly, I am hating this drama after watching the recent episode. Characters were too judgmental.
Totally agree with Amna about shirk dialogue. And giving verdict on peoples sins. In my opinion 17 episode should be the last episode. And disregarding islamic rules on talaq etc matters.
Amna you have translated my thoughts into words regarding the shirk dialogue of mere pas tum ho. I definitely agree with you that khalil ur rehman should not have used that word and I also agree that a lot of dialogues in this drama are related to what Allah will forgive or not. I think we as humans should not talk about what Allah will forgive or not because He is Ar Rehman and Ar Raheem, the Most Merciful. It's sad to see Khalil ur Rehman's view about women. And another weird part is i remember in the last or second last episode Danish said that, Allah ki kasam maaf krdiya use (when he was talking to his friend in his office related to mehwish) And now he is saying shirk toe Allah bhi maaf ni krta. I think the writer should decide whether danish is ready to forgive her or not.
Totally agree with you 👍
Dua's acting was really awesome...
There was a dialogue "Jab shohar muzrim ban jata hain tab uske sath bakiki Zindagi acchi guzarti hain."
Said by Maham.
I was waiting for the review of this dialogue.
You people are best!! Loved your all week in review!!!
For Alif, there were many revelations being unveiled for Momin. Now, the only thing he needs to know as to why his dad had left home and died. Momina is charismatic and in the upcoming episodes, her appearance will further glorify her character and prompt Momin to be a part of his spiritual film as Husn e Jahan.
Completely disagree with Hasan regarding this dialogue. With Amna on this one.
I watched one of his interviews. I was aghast at what he said!! The man is a complete misogynist and totally removed from reality! It was very unkind and unjust of him to conveniently absolve men from the blame of extra marital affairs by saying " aurat mein na karne ki salahiat hoti hai , mard mein nahi". With one sentence he put the entire burden of guilt on women and gave men impunity. It's appalling to think that male chauvinists, who never miss any opportunity to pull out their superiority card , their power card, their brawn card (essentially , their masculinity card) will pull out a "weakness" card and use it as an excuse to finding themselves incapable of saying"no" to women. How convenient!!! How clever!!
He further said " jab mard bewafai kare to ghar kharab hota hai aur jab aurat beeafai kare to nasal". Again he seems to be living in a bubble of his own where he seems oblivious of the ugly and stomach churning effects of the evils men inflict. How come he hasn't noticed that the effects of their evil deeds reverberate for generations too. If only he paid more attention to the cruelties men carryout (and are capable of), he would be less of a misogynist and more of a misandrist.
And his ultimate arrogance and ignorance is too visible in the shirk dialogue. How dare he attempts to raise the status of a petty human being ( in this case a man) to that of Allah. JUST HOW DARE HE!!!As far as I am concerned, he's the one committing shirk by writing such dialogues.
I agree with Amma. Again a flaw of khalil ur rehman’s mindset which is completely sick!
Also would love to watch amma interview him. 😛
I agree to what Amna said about using the word "Shirk". Shirk is a big term to be used for a human and is only related to Allah. This was the most unnecessary dialogue in the drama.
Amna u r wrds touched my heart...offcourse takleef dene walay rishtay....ahhhh seriously thy r btr thn b alone...so true indeed.
True
Sooo true..........
Hasan and amna please watch khalil's latest interview.. You'll know the context of this shirk dialogue... He actually believes that mard is like God! He said that mard ki fitrat khuda jesi hai.. And no he doesn't mean this dialogue is not gender specific...
Hassan explained SHIRK thing in the best possible way.👌
Right
Nope.. Allah will forgive if people repent in their life time and stick to it... Allah will not forgive shirk if we die in that state. Mushrikeen e makkah repented and became muslims.
No Hassan is wrong here ...Amna is right about the wahdaniyat of Allah The one and only and shirk is not allowed ... Maaf karay ga ya nahi Allah knows the best but we can’t casually use the shirk to describe sherakat in human relationships ..
I don't know about the usage of the word SHIRK is right/wrong but I think the way the writer used that example was human is flawed and not that capable of forgiving people. Amna was saying he was comparing himself to Allah SWT, though It's not about man comparing himself to Allah SWT rather degrading himself and quoting the highest & most merciful. Truth is Humans don't forgive easily but Allah SWT does. That's it!
@@aimannaseem9443 The use of work shirk by writer is a mistake or arrogance. Since the writer is pretty articulate in his dialogues writing it cannot be a mistake. It's his arrogance to use this specific word to test boundaries of acceptance by the viewers. The literal meaning of shirk (sharing) cannot be used in any other context than with God. To clarify my point, I give another example. The word Raaziq is also specifically for God. Such words cannot be used in any other contexts.
Amna, I love your hair colour. What brand and colour is that? Thanks
I was waiting for this ❤
Watching MPTH after two years of its release... And now after every episode I come and watch your review on it bcoz it is so apt regarding every situation... I really like both of you and the way you put forward your opinion without any hesitation... Hassan you are my favorite critic of this age... Lots of love and respect from India❤️
I got angry at my kid for interrupting me watching this review😂
Mee 2
ashas82 that’s so mean poor baby 😢
Almas Lakhani not that much , just a little 😁
Momin was a rebel and had resentment in his adolescence. He was lost in world of glamor later. Now he's trying to reconnect with past, God and himself and finding answers.
Hassan you are very wrong about that shirk dialogue. I totally agree with Aamna
You both r ammmmazing.. I mean how you both started the debate of shirk n how you both end by convincing each other.. Beautiful chemistry dats y v like you both reviewing together.. Amina u r right at ur point n Hassan u r also right at ur point
First of all Hassan , so cute watching you wearing jacket and proclaiming the cold in Karachi. BTW Amna you the man, Lahore has frozen over completely. So kudos to you surviving our winter. Second, please ignore the people who say that you guys bully each other or Zehra (who is so sweet and very intuitive? profound? ). And missing Amna's colourful nail laquer as I have started to inspiration from your colour schemes. Keep doing the good work, people!
Are uh the nemrah niazi czn?
@@amirsidiqui9136 Precisely. We Niazis ALL are related to each other. One way or another. Who is Nemrah Niazi btw?
@@alittlerayofpitchblack6305 nemrah ahmed niazi she is the bhatiji or imran khan her dad is the first czn of khan famous writer ?
I started crying with Dua I was feeling her pain and very emotional
I agree with Aamna they shouldn’t use the word shirk it’s very serious why a man always thinks he is Khuda for women
I completely agree with Amna. It’s like beating the dead horse ! Okay we get it Mehwish did wrong but why so much of humiliation and degradation of women .
Exactly
I’m Sumera from Manchester, yes I agree with Amina about shirk dialogue there shouldn’t be used that term that’s shame
I totally agree with Amna's opinion on " shirk" dialogue 👍
I agree with Amna that word shirk should havent been used.
Actually sawera's apology and the check ' was more humiliating than then the slap, though it was not clear that what the makers want us to see that she insulted her again.
Giving check of 2.5 crore was a payment of spending the time with that man. Humiliating, simply.
Agree with Hassan's explanation on shirk dialogue
Word shirk wasn't justified at all in my point of view !
It really will be quite exciting to watch Amna interviewing Khalil ur Rehman Qamar!
He is a shitty misogynyist he would never dare to face a sane and fierce upright woman like Amna issani
Hasaan you are just awesome.... We all love you ❤ and i have a request as well please please take a interview of either hamza or naimal please 🙏🙏🙏
Amna and Hassan - if you guys have watched KRQ’s previous drama Zara yaad kar, it had the same “shirk” dialogue- that a husband is called Majazi Khuda because he has a quality similar to Allah- he will provide sustenance to the wife but will not forgive betrayal. I found the dialogue problematic then but it was being said by a woman so I sort of agreed.
I agree with Amna , betrayal shouldn’t be forgiven in a relationship by either genders as relationships are built on trust , but the word shirk shouldn’t have been used. That’s a v strong word and should only be used for Allah.
Worshipping other than Allah is called shirk. On the other hand, betrayal with a spouse is called infidelity. Urdu me pata nahi infidelity ko Kya kehte.
It somehow doesn’t feel right to use the same terminology for human beings which Allah used for Himself.
Yes I agree with Amna 's point of view with "shirk"...
26:19 they start talking about meray pass tum ho, your welcome
I agree with Amna , that we should leave the decision of forgiveness of sins on God . Abd in my opinion that one shouldn’t die in condition of shirk . There is always room of forgiveness TIL your last breath
Alizeh Shah has done two incredible scenes one in “Jo tu chaey” when her grandmother passed away, and the second one in “Ehd e Wafa” when her father died. And her mother said that you are not even our daughter not only my daughter, you can confirm. Amna this time I totally agreed with Hassan in the matter of saying “Shirk”, it was used only as a reference not with exact meaning, related to Allah. Actor playing the character Aisha's real name is Rehmat Jamal.
now we want interview of khalilurehman kamar interviewed by amina🤣
I completely agree with Hassan about the 'Shirk' dialogue clarification, but its confusing and maybe they should have chosen a better word or shed more light on why he cannot forgive betrayal!
On the shirk dialogue- my husband’s response was exactly like Hassan and mine was exactly like Anna’s, maybe it is how men and women perceive this concept.... I had a similar long discussion with my husband where he thought it is not a big deal and I thought it definitely is😂
Wonderful review. But sorry Mam Amna, regarding SHIRK dialogue, I have same perception as of Sir Hassan. I just loved that dialogue & it didn't look problematic at all. The context of that dialogue says it all.
The shirk sentence made it seem like Danish is comparing himself to Allah, as if he and Allah are on the same wavelength re forgiveness,it seemed rather pretentious and made Danish seem supercilious.
I agree with amna here. I also felt that he was comparing himself with Allah.
Touba hai
I agree they should not use the word shirk it’s completely use in religion only
I perceived the shirk dialogue exactly how Hassan did, and I loved it. But after listening to Amna, I also agree that the word shirk should not have been used as it’s only for Allah swt
Amna has a point about the useage of the word Shirk. Alot can be said, of this overreach of the word by the writer.,.. Opinion from Mumbai.
Amna didn't get the meaning of shirk dialog...
@SomethingHaute
The reason to show that scene (Maham offering 2.5 crore to Mahwish) is that Mahwish is no more greedy now and have realized that money is not everything and the actual love and relationship matters more than money, that's why she refused to that money.
exactly right because at the end she never took the cheque
Being a man I also felt degrading related to Sonia Aiza scene, this is something dragging and over daramatise things and what is Shirk, there is nothing related to Shirk mentioned except one God Allah, I believe this specific word also an act of over daramatisation. Well said ji
I completely agree with hassan.
He's right about shirk.
For more explanation word ‘shirk’ watch ‘Zara yaad kar’ which is also written by Khalil ur Rahman Qamar.
The daram MPTH reminds me of a vry famous dialogue kisi ko sheeda't sy chaho to puri duniya tm ko us sy milany ki khoshis mai lg jti h and in this drma sounds like danish ko dhoka do to puri script aur dramy ka her character dhokaybaz biwi ko sza dny mai lg jta h 😂
Am I the only one here who actually enjoyed the dialogue and had no idea people could turn it elsewhere as well! It was very clear that Danish was saying that he was incapable of forgiveness as he was just a human... In no way was this dialogue aiming at comparing him to Allah ( which would be absurd)
I agree that this drama might have some very problematic dialogues, but the only thing wrong in this one is that they tried conveying a philosophy to people who become very rigid as soon as they hear any religious innuendo .