I noticed that right before Kanami begins the solo Miku is playing the guitar part. In an earlier concert, I think 2019, Kanami did it all. I can't specifically point to other songs, but I noticed during the 4 concerts I saw in the US, that Miku has taken over a lot of parts to let Kanami be more creative. It didn't drastically change the sound of the song, but I love seeing that Miku has progressed so much that she is able to take over some of the parts. Miku keeps getting better, I'm so proud of her. You know, the day will come when we will be able to see Miku shred as well. She has the best sensei.
This live performance is an absolute masterpiece. I don't know whether to smile or cry. I think I'll do both. God I do love these talented ladies so much.
The word is that Kanami purposely hit a bum note to distract from the suspicion that she is an Alien Rock Goddess gracing us mere mortals with her presence. Normally I'd call that as BS but when it comes to Kanami it's got me thinking it could be true. Cheers from Oz and VIVA the Maids peace and love Po 👍🎼🥁🎤🎸🍻 anothe
Miku has a great tone here - nice and thick and distorted. She leaves Kanami free to do her normal madness. And it seems to me like Miku and MISA are joined at the hip - like the leading to the solo, Miku starts it and then MISA joins and adds the bottom to it. Just beautiful.
@@armynurseboy I suspect that Miku's Zemaitis has a strong part to play in her tone as well. It's certainly lovely thick and juicy - the tone that is. :)
Love this clip! Everyone is amazing! ... Another reviewer mentioned how much Kanami's hands are moving, when they don't have to. And then, he was like, "Oh, she's pulling off to let the sound ring out, a la AC/DC." ... Just like me, you sound like a proud parent, "Hey, is that Miku?" 🙂
Miku looks like she enjoys playing guitar now and tbh they wouldn't be the same without her. She is the heart and soul of Bandmaid. So endearing with her bow legs and pigeon toes.
That little riff right before kanami’s solo used to be done by Kanami…. It’s great that Miku now does it. Shows how far she’s come and how much Kanami trusts her
I adore them all, bow to their charm and musicianship, and will fight anyone who dismisses them, but I like Kanami the most. It's her Buddha-serene expression of confidence on her face when she performs that knocks me out. I think she truly mastered the zen of emptiness reflected by her effortlessly appearing guitar playing.
Miku's backing vocals make this song for me. Saiki pours so much emotion into her singing, and then Miku doubles down on that with her wails, you can feel the protagonist's pain and desire, it's beautiful.
I was already a fan when I first saw the old video for Puzzle live. And Kanami had been who I focused one previously just because she is so good. But when I saw the video I was blown away by Saiki's voice and how she literally put every emotion she had into the song. That is when I realized why Miku wanted her in the band. IMO one of the best new singers out there. Incredible voice only getting better.
I have been comparing Miku from live 2017(Shinkiba) to this,we all know how far she has come as a guitarist,but this blew me away,and it's Kanami's fault I went down the pigeon hole,on this song live at Shinkiba Studio Coast Tokyo '17,it was an ugly cry moment,the guitarist and band I had been searching for,always beautiful reviews,thank you Champ.
The new Blu-Ray sounds really, really good - when I first put it on and you could hear the normal pre-show crowd chatter, it was like you were right there in the middle of the crowd. And clarity of sound is fantastic throughout the disc. If I had one complaint it would be that MISA's part could be a little more distinct in the mix, but overall the sound, and it goes without saying, the performance is fan-freaking-tastic!!
I thought thing on those two triplets. It's faint in the studio version and the 2017 LIVE show only Kanami played it, but this show she brought all the girls in on the triplets....sounded great!
And of course it sounds much better on the bluray than on TH-cam (logical). The bluray sound is both wide and punchy (it's rare, it's often one or the other) and very clear. Very good work (I would have loved a little more Misa in the bass spectrum but the separation between her bass and the bass drum is very effective).
This song, the guitars primarily steal the show, and you can see Saiki's outstanding performance here. Nevertheless, look deeper and you realize the MISA and Akane were truly amazing too, just incredible. I'd go as far as to state that the song actually sounds completely epic mainly due to these two! Of course, that's just the opinion of a wee little fan, and I'd be appreciative if a discussion follows on how my viewpoint might be wrong (or even correct).
The concert came alive when this was played. I thought Saiki's voice sounded tired throughout much of the concert, particularly not quite hitting and/or sustaining the high notes - she did pretty well on this song considering. Also, it's so clever separating the lines in the final verse.
I found that Saiki's vocals were a little flat for a good chunk of the original live broadcast and although I haven't compared it with the video releases, I'm pretty sure they did a little post-production on her vocals for the DVD/Blu-ray... which I totally understand.
@@motley22crue Yes, they've done exactly that before. On previous broadcasts, there were occasional songs where she was flat on the high notes and they reprocessed it for the DVD/Blu-ray.
Maybe...I didn't notice because her voice was so powerful, both vocally and emotionally live. Just being there myself and witnessing it was magical. People around me at the concert was also commenting how powerful and great Saiki's vocal was...or have become.
I still think (by just a little) the 2017 Studio Coast performance and playing of Puzzle feels better overall. It has more musical impact for me. It's also like the audio and mix at the Garden is harsh digital, and Studio Coast is satisfying vinyl. And the audience weren't masked or asked not to sing or yell (because of COVID restrictions). Thx, Champ!
Hi! Champ, thank you for your wonderful reaction again. However, your face looked tired, and I was a bit worried that your right cheek and mouth were swollen. Please take care of yourself.
@@TheChampOfMedium That is a possibility. I did notice 4/30/23 GG podcast that you didn't have that look/condition anymore. Though stroke tends to make it droop versus not moving.
It wasnt one note, the other was corrected for this version, u actually prefer the original live version that had like two errors since you know its live
I noticed that right before Kanami begins the solo Miku is playing the guitar part. In an earlier concert, I think 2019, Kanami did it all. I can't specifically point to other songs, but I noticed during the 4 concerts I saw in the US, that Miku has taken over a lot of parts to let Kanami be more creative. It didn't drastically change the sound of the song, but I love seeing that Miku has progressed so much that she is able to take over some of the parts. Miku keeps getting better, I'm so proud of her. You know, the day will come when we will be able to see Miku shred as well. She has the best sensei.
I am always thinking Saiki breath. She hardly gets a break. Same for Kanami. Non-stop.
This live performance is an absolute masterpiece. I don't know whether to smile or cry. I think I'll do both. God I do love these talented ladies so much.
MIKU's background vocals!!!
they get better every performance
Absolutely my favorite version of Puzzle, RIGHT HERE. Miku is captivating, Kanami is straight up heroic. Really, really World Class!💪🏻🤘🏻
The word is that Kanami purposely hit a bum note to distract from the suspicion that she is an Alien Rock Goddess gracing us mere mortals with her presence. Normally I'd call that as BS but when it comes to Kanami it's got me thinking it could be true. Cheers from Oz and VIVA the Maids peace and love Po 👍🎼🥁🎤🎸🍻 anothe
Miku has a great tone here - nice and thick and distorted. She leaves Kanami free to do her normal madness. And it seems to me like Miku and MISA are joined at the hip - like the leading to the solo, Miku starts it and then MISA joins and adds the bottom to it. Just beautiful.
That EVH can make some nice sounds.....
I love the tone she has now, its perfect for their rhythm section.
@@armynurseboy I suspect that Miku's Zemaitis has a strong part to play in her tone as well. It's certainly lovely thick and juicy - the tone that is. :)
Love this clip! Everyone is amazing! ... Another reviewer mentioned how much Kanami's hands are moving, when they don't have to. And then, he was like, "Oh, she's pulling off to let the sound ring out, a la AC/DC." ... Just like me, you sound like a proud parent, "Hey, is that Miku?" 🙂
theyre all my children
pretty sure I'm the band's uncle
Miku looks like she enjoys playing guitar now and tbh they wouldn't be the same without her. She is the heart and soul of Bandmaid. So endearing with her bow legs and pigeon toes.
How can Kanami be so perfect ? - skill level, - Japanese
That little riff right before kanami’s solo used to be done by Kanami…. It’s great that Miku now does it. Shows how far she’s come and how much Kanami trusts her
Gotta love to see the progress... sounded perfect. And I think i like that riff with Miku's tone better.
I adore them all, bow to their charm and musicianship, and will fight anyone who dismisses them, but I like Kanami the most. It's her Buddha-serene expression of confidence on her face when she performs that knocks me out. I think she truly mastered the zen of emptiness reflected by her effortlessly appearing guitar playing.
Miku's harmony vocals are outstanding and she finally gets a short lead guitar solo...OK, chord lead, but still...ya know?
It's a riff, not a solo but she did pretty well indeed 👍
@@realdocloco Semantics much?
Our Pigeon continues to improve and fly even higher, po! We are all very proud of her!
Miku's backing vocals make this song for me. Saiki pours so much emotion into her singing, and then Miku doubles down on that with her wails, you can feel the protagonist's pain and desire, it's beautiful.
I was already a fan when I first saw the old video for Puzzle live. And Kanami had been who I focused one previously just because she is so good. But when I saw the video I was blown away by Saiki's voice and how she literally put every emotion she had into the song. That is when I realized why Miku wanted her in the band. IMO one of the best new singers out there. Incredible voice only getting better.
I have been comparing Miku from live 2017(Shinkiba) to this,we all know how far she has come as a guitarist,but this blew me away,and it's Kanami's fault I went down the pigeon hole,on this song live at Shinkiba Studio Coast Tokyo '17,it was an ugly cry moment,the guitarist and band I had been searching for,always beautiful reviews,thank you Champ.
The new Blu-Ray sounds really, really good - when I first put it on and you could hear the normal pre-show crowd chatter, it was like you were right there in the middle of the crowd. And clarity of sound is fantastic throughout the disc. If I had one complaint it would be that MISA's part could be a little more distinct in the mix, but overall the sound, and it goes without saying, the performance is fan-freaking-tastic!!
This was one of the best BM shows Ive seen, the whole thing.
I thought thing on those two triplets. It's faint in the studio version and the 2017 LIVE show only Kanami played it, but this show she brought all the girls in on the triplets....sounded great!
I hadn't heard this off-note from Kanami, you really have golden ears. And you've been a strong, strong reactor so far. Didn't expect less.
Thank you for your reaction. After I saw this live video I went back to Just Bring It and listen through the entire album again. Loving it.
And of course it sounds much better on the bluray than on TH-cam (logical). The bluray sound is both wide and punchy (it's rare, it's often one or the other) and very clear. Very good work (I would have loved a little more Misa in the bass spectrum but the separation between her bass and the bass drum is very effective).
This is a song where EVERYBODY goes ham! Love it. ...and, is it just me, or does Kanami seem to be channeling Lindsey Buckingham?
This song, the guitars primarily steal the show, and you can see Saiki's outstanding performance here. Nevertheless, look deeper and you realize the MISA and Akane were truly amazing too, just incredible. I'd go as far as to state that the song actually sounds completely epic mainly due to these two! Of course, that's just the opinion of a wee little fan, and I'd be appreciative if a discussion follows on how my viewpoint might be wrong (or even correct).
tbh, in almost every band maid song, you need them all... they wouldnt be the same if any one of them wasnt doing their thang
The concert came alive when this was played. I thought Saiki's voice sounded tired throughout much of the concert, particularly not quite hitting and/or sustaining the high notes - she did pretty well on this song considering. Also, it's so clever separating the lines in the final verse.
I found that Saiki's vocals were a little flat for a good chunk of the original live broadcast and although I haven't compared it with the video releases, I'm pretty sure they did a little post-production on her vocals for the DVD/Blu-ray... which I totally understand.
@@motley22crue Yes, they've done exactly that before. On previous broadcasts, there were occasional songs where she was flat on the high notes and they reprocessed it for the DVD/Blu-ray.
Maybe...I didn't notice because her voice was so powerful, both vocally and emotionally live. Just being there myself and witnessing it was magical.
People around me at the concert was also commenting how powerful and great Saiki's vocal was...or have become.
@Fume Z I heard others that attended the concert also talk about how great Saiki sounded
I wonder if they've rewritten Miku's parts in their early songs to take advantage of her growing skill.
This song yes, earlier version was more MISA with also no Miku guitar. 2016.
I knew some stuff sounded different, chat was telling me it was the same and i was like nahhhhh
Same thing with Play. The call and response used to be between MISA and Kanami, but the newer version was MISA and Miku.
Blu-ray TGT concert and BTS US Tour 2020 were both excellent. I felt so sorry for Kanami at the end of the US tour, but she pulled through like a pro.
It's pretty accurate to the studio version all right
I still think (by just a little) the 2017 Studio Coast performance and playing of Puzzle feels better overall. It has more musical impact for me. It's also like the audio and mix at the Garden is harsh digital, and Studio Coast is satisfying vinyl. And the audience weren't masked or asked not to sing or yell (because of COVID restrictions). Thx, Champ!
If you were only allowed one song to showcase Maid Rock...this would do fine 👌👊🤘🤘🤘
Hard to disagree there
@@TheChampOfMedium I take it you've seen the acoustic version, Saiki and Kanami only...? Epic flip of this song...beautiful.
MISA!!! MISA!!! MISA!!! 🥃🥃🥃
Saiki just killed this song
Yup! Wrong note = LIVE
KANAMI.
MISA MISA MISA!!!!!
You have to watch the live version of Puzzle from 2017, it's Epic!
Champ has already seen and analyzed it.
@@zolitoth2458 For a hot second I thought this comment was Champ responding about himself in the third person lol
thats fair i do do that sometimes
@@TheChampOfMedium I would have given you a +1 if you had only said "that's fair The Champ do do that sometimes"
Hi! Champ, thank you for your wonderful reaction again. However, your face looked tired, and I was a bit worried that your right cheek and mouth were swollen. Please take care of yourself.
I think that's just my weird face lol
I see the left side of his face, mostly his mouth and cheek, not moving.
@@seizetheday5008 maybe i had a stroke and didnt know about it
@@TheChampOfMedium That is a possibility. I did notice 4/30/23 GG podcast that you didn't have that look/condition anymore. Though stroke tends to make it droop versus not moving.
@@seizetheday5008 well it seems fine now so idk maybe i ate some bad fish and was having an allergic reaction... lol im aight tho
It wasnt one note, the other was corrected for this version, u actually prefer the original live version that had like two errors since you know its live
to be fair... i know theyre live anyway lol but a little rawness to remind you is always a happy accident in my book
Yeah the original live sounds waaay better even with the big fail at the start of kanami solo
She missed a note?
lmao just the one in the middle of the other thousands
one and only band