Debate, discussion has gone to such lows that such a simple process of Questioning and answering with civility feels like an unprecedented Marvel to us.
Answers can be given respectfully without getting defensive. Usually a calm confidence is seen when the clarification being asked for has a rational justifiable answer.
@@curious1731 My God are you nuts.... What was Atal Bihari Bajpai, or sushma swaraj or in current government officials Jayshankar Or nitin gadkari.... Are they not BJP
@@curious1731 Oh if you had been to erstwhile North East and visit the roads now you won't say it. But how can I forget you are disrespectful of the current foreign policy too which is the talk of the year world over so there's no chance you will ever see light. No need for replying, God bless us all Indians
What about ur educated south Indian MP giving vile remarks about gaumutra and north Indians. As a country if we r still busy wd linguism, community biases then I can surely say we haven't progressed even in these 75 yrs. Kudos to people like u.
@@aakanchaanand2223have you ever heard speeches of smrithi, Meenakshi lekhi , jyothiradithya sindya etc. There are so many who speak well irrespective of region.
@@athi482 Bro either way his message is clear stop dividing the country , as SOUTH INDIAN ive never seen people call " Wo, thats a really well educated NORTH Indian (profession)
He should arrange to send clarifying documents to finance minister Central. And see the result. That will give proud feeling to the person who executed good action out of the way. No harsh statements. I am not a politician not interested.
Exactly, this is where all the citizens gets influenced by sweet talks, we can't blame the politicians everytime, we has citizens should change these politicians too.
Agree with you! Case is if state non-bjp.. they will ask docs first.. if comes with docs... Ask for Docs ++.... If comes with docs ++.. then will ask for Docs ++ pro .... So on.... Until rule down
Dr Sashi Tharoor is an extempore orator, is a real pride for all Indians on a par with the high quality of speeches made by V K Krishna Menon and Sir C P Rama Seamy Iyer .
VK Krishna Menon was the worst defence minister of India. We lost 1962 war because of him. He used to make Generals fight with each other by spreading rumours about their wives. And he did so in the paranoia that Army would do a coup on the government.
Well said hope the modishah RSSBJP goondas and police are not sent calling you anti national, urban naxal, anti Hindu ,and file a FIR. Like they do to anyone who say a thing about this regime.😅
Some programs have to be introduced,if necessary by amendment, in such a way that States should collect the taxes and pay to the union government of India.
You don't know how the constitution and states function...…most state govts are too powerful, have larger work force and most importantly excessively corrupt. They change budgets, spend money on whimsical things that govts are not supposed to do. Sania mirza making crores of money in gifts while farmers are committing suicides and Olympians getting peanuts if they dont win something are smallest examples. 90% of execution is with state govt, while Centre controls taxation and have control of spending and accountability. Its a decent check and balance.
I beleive this mother chor is from tamilnadu probably a boot licker for DMK so that is why he is using the word union government. pelt him with stones never let fake tamilans to enter India other status they are super poison
@@leelamani3758 Not really. Just like he found Dr. Jayashankar for the role of Foreign Affairs minister, Modi should find a competent candidate for the role of the financial minister. This one does not even have a PhD. Look at the Tamil Nadu financial minister for a second.
It's only because this absence of transparency of public service, the mistrust between the State and the Centre in so called federal structure of our constitution that after 58 years of our becoming independent India, we had to promulgate such declaratory statute like RTI Act just to ascertain that State i.e the Government is not telling what it ought to its subjects i.e the citizen.
@@clashon4846 It's not about comparisons with a government that hasn't been in power for 8 years now. It's about asking the current government to do its job better. Competition between parties must come into the picture only once every 5 years. Rest of the time, we should be focused on whether the ruling party is doing what we need them to.
Mdm have you cleared due amount of thousands of crores to be paid to Tamilnadu , then why is the Tamilnadu finance minister Mr PTR stating there's huge money that the centre owns Tamilnadu in terms of GST collected , please brief , if you R not sitting , then why R files sleeping ?
@@sabi56847 who says ? tamilnadu got the most load from mudra and also it has the most subscribers of JIO tamilnadu people oppose ambani from JIO Network only
@@SAFFRONINFERNO Tera mai baap Bhajpa ne, toh party with difference kehata hai... Ek taraf loans maaf, aur dusre taraf middle class aur majdur ko dabo..
Written off, not waived off. Written off means recovery is started. But balance sheet if bank is recapitalized. Just because some people defaulted, doesn't mean bank will stop functioning right? So, recovery can happen in parallel. And the past losses can be filled in parallel.
@@srinivasrao369 Lol...For the sake of 1.4 billion Indians...He should have just continued selling Tea.....I wonder who was making the tea that he was selling.....
It's pitty to note that almost all State Governments, barring a few ,there involves no Professional approaches among State Government officials, so is the Office of CM. They have little mechanism to check Data they prepare for submission to Finance Ministry for authentic validations. State's careless official approaches suggest that their dedication to Official Jobs rest with uncared supervision by those who are entrusted with. Union Finance Minister rightly pointed out the genuine lapses of office management without any Accountability where data mismatched gets vibrant. Moreover, why do such lapses of internal office management of State become a point of Issues to be discussed at Parliament? Enforcing Accountability at local State Level can ensure responsibility of operating official instead of abusing the platform of Parliament. MPs tend to make mockery at Parliament with imaginary Data with clear intentions to waste valuable times at Parliament in the name of Personal Selling. This trends are increasingly becoming near to dereliction of Duties & Responsibility among State Level functionaries as Fashion. Any discussion must be constructive & authentic.
@@yesb4258 Sithharaman said "Many state governments believe that their GST compensation is pending.The central government needs the necessary papers as the money belongs to the taxpayers. Hence, the compensation will be settled once the centre obtains the papers, Sitharaman said. "The moment I receive the papers, the AG certification, even if there is a contention between the Centre and a state, it has to be sorted out. I cannot be sitting on somebody's money," she said.
@@yesb4258 Johnathan Swift states: As the wireless readers has its readers So the greatest liar has its believers You need to know who is the biggest liar of our country.. Namo
Yes so give the necessary papers...it's not that all the amount is pending...the documents which the state govt couldn't give to centre have been holded
True. My can't the state gov of Kerala, TN and etc can't provide proper GST collection document to claim their refund. Is there any fraudalent act involved in the GST collection like in the TN like charging GST for GST exempted goods and charging 20% extra for food like yogurts, and packaged milk instead of 5%.And the 15% goes into the DMK's pocket. The GST collection must be placed under the central gov supervision not the state gov. These MPs of these states asked the same question and become after he or she wad told to submit the GST collectible verification documents.🤦♀️
This is what a normal discussion in a parliament looks like in parliaments all over the world but it is due to the fish market image which is so engraved in the two houses that a normal conversation between MPs like this seem like some utopian world.
Congress is shit. That has been established when they didn't elect him President. It's a party filled with followers, not leaders. All slaves of the establishment, afraid of change, and short-sighted. Even the G-23 who signed the petition to Sonia Gandhi about reforms in the organization betrayed Tharoor by backing that spineless oldie who couldn't even settle the Rajasthan Chief Ministry conflict without Rahul Gandhi. Congress doesn't deserve Shashi Tharoor.
@@Pranav_Bhamidipati , you guys are shit. Congress is the heart of India that sacrificed to give us freedom. Congress built India by building World famous IIT, ISRO, DRDO, AIIMS, BRAC etc which made India biswaguru. BJP and modi desh ko bechne aaya, 45 years unemployment crisis in Modi's corrupt rule aur tum unpadh bhakt ko berojgar bhakt banake chor diya
@@Pranav_Bhamidipati , but BJP andha bhakt use the same language as you did. May be you are BJP's chota bhai AAP supporter. But it doesn't matter. Would you like to discuss in Google meet? I hope i can your misconceptions in few minutes. I can send the Google meet link
These required papers not submitted by opposition by govt party in states. Where are BJP govt. no need any clarification or required papers to release the funds.
I think you're overrating her a little. Shashi's concerns are valid. Why is the work not being done yet? And "not needing outside advice"? I don't think you understand how democracy works. As an MP, it's Dr. Tharoor's job to fight for the interests of his constituency, even if it means asking the cabinet ministers to do their jobs better.
@@Pranav_Bhamidipati im from kerala, its better not to provide the fund to current state authorities bcoz nothing is given to the people, state govt authorities are corrupted
What about OROP2 for Armed Forces Pensioners ! Due from 1st July 2019. But after Supreme Court direction also Finance Minister is sitting with the file. A true lire
I don't understand as a accountant I tally all the ledgers. But these central and state governments accounts never tallying. That too hundreds of crores difference.
Usual answer, the office bearers of the finance ministry, are they not answerable to their minister, if she needs any clarification? Will it take years to sort out the issues, even between the governments? I was thinking only common people face problems in the government offices.....
Why papers required from states to claim their part of GST. The union collects and should have accurate account on collection. I can relate the union Finance behaviour similar to an Accountant in a company when it comes to payable
Many projects pending lack of funds. Categorizing which fund or income can be alloted during disaster management. Water tax huge but employees and machine involvement or to low. Where are the remaining funds. 4 or 5 years once roads are laid, how much property tax fund utilized. Whether central government gets its shares all to be accounted. This can be done city wise so network technology also low, sql query to get details about dispensionary spending can be derived along with employees salary in those sectors
The centre cannot release funds if earlier expenses are reconciled. This is what we could. make out from FM spesch. It is for the states to reconcile the accounts and get it certified by AG. What for AG is there?
Shri Om Birla's favourite go to word is "NO". Thinks of himself to be a Principal of a primary school and treats the oposition MP such as the likes of Shri Shashi Tharoor and others as if they are some indisciplined students of that school. Well what else can one expect from Om Birla ji, who happens to be from a party which has a notorious and unenviable record of creating and causing the most and the worst disruptions in our country's Parliament history. Khali jab dekho, jaha dekho, jidhar dekho, apni zabaan se sirf No..No..No.. shabd nikalta rehta hai. Lekin es problem ka solution actually inke ya kissi aur insaan ke paas nahi hai, philhal. Jab tak Modi aur Shah naam ke bhoot inke sar par par mandrate rahenge, tab tak ye, No.. No.. No.. bolte rahenge aur opposition bhi baaj nahi ayega, woh sunkar. So, unfortunately, were in a so called deadlock and stalemate for the long haul. Unless and until the people of our country decide to teach this Modi-Shah duo a lesson by giving a right royal hiding in the upcoming Parliamentary General Elections of 2024. P.S.- That is if no untoward and so called unexpected incident happens before the run up to that. For example, like if China ups the ante and goes to war with India.
Shasi Blunder man who pointed out that Kerala is yet to receive Rs 4,486 crore as GST compensation for the year 2017-18. ......he dont know exact figure just shoot in english
So ,until &unless these fraud people are kicked out from politics ,ther is no way . U see after 20 yrs service a government servant get pension but these politicians get full pension if get elected in elections . So to get dedicated politicians this Pension system should be abolished but no party will agree to abolish pension system . Or to get elected 5 times .= 20 yrs .
Mr sashi tharoor is much more having ability than our finance minister, earlier Defence Minister. If Congress party as well as Gandhi family may realise his ability, then they did definitely elect this person as the President of Congress.
Comical. Kerala's state FM who can't even provide the proper GST collectible verification documents is rooted to become the President of the corrupted Congress party. These MPs kept getting nose cut from Nirmala and kept silent when asked about these documents. How can a person this disresponsible can be considered as the President of a party? Oh, yes. We just become the 5th most largest economy in the world. We have just released 2 satelites into the space. We have own own Vandhe Bharat trains which are on par with the Euro trains and better than trains in Malaysia, Singapore, USA, Australia and Saudi Arabia ( which had better infrastructure than India during Congress rule)and we are close to having our own bullet trains and bigger highways. We are now peaceful without any terror attacks in Jammu and Kashmir that much. We definately need Congress party to have Taj Hotel attacks. How dare of us to even dream of becoming a global super power? Even, now India have become the envy of the world. How dare Modi was ranked 1st in the PEW rating for his leadership? We need to be poorer and backward like we were when Congress ruled India. We must only travel in a dilapidated trains which we used to travel when we young. We should not be innovative and be a weak nation to be bullied around by all the developed nation. Oh yes, we just improved our transparency and reduced the corruption in our country. We definately need Congress to increase our corruption level. Lastly, there us still some innocent Tamilzh Sri Lankans left in the Sri Lanka with misery. Too bad, Modi sympathised them and asked Sri Lanka to hear their plight for being discriminated. If Congress is in power, the poor Tamilzh in Sri Lanka will be murdered by now as the Sri Lanka gov will be heavily funded by Congress like they did during their rule. All the extremists can stab any non-Muslims and run free coz they will not be executed by the Congress people for Muslim's vote bank. Congress, we need your help 2 destroy India. 🙏 No Indians born in India will vote for a Congress party. Only traitors do. Thank you, Modi for making India the greatest it has ever been. Bharat Matta Ki Jai
The way Mr.Tharoor is spoke into by the honourable chair is so shameful. The chair does not have a single competency other being a member of a particular political establishment.
Speaker Sir, shouted No the house remain silent. A very obedient students he has got. We read that the house belongs to opposition. I don't know I might be wrong.
.you fellow always doubt.....I dont know how GST amounts are paid but here is a fact I expect. so state govts cant submit bills because they get budget allocations for one project and spend on something else. Earlier state govts use to pass this off making contractors wait for years but its not happening any more. So I did a project in my village, money was paid by center to state, my state govt used it for their whimsical project .......I still did not get paid nor the beneficiary got his so called double bedroom house. We should ask more accountability rather than cribbing at something happening good.
Debate, discussion has gone to such lows that such a simple process of Questioning and answering with civility feels like an unprecedented Marvel to us.
This is beauty of Democracy ...
Ugliness of demo "crazy".Beauty my foot.
Answers can be given respectfully without getting defensive. Usually a calm confidence is seen when the clarification being asked for has a rational justifiable answer.
U canr expect that from bjp..definetly not from sitaraman..a rude women.
@@curious1731 My God are you nuts.... What was Atal Bihari Bajpai, or sushma swaraj or in current government officials Jayshankar Or nitin gadkari.... Are they not BJP
@@englishlearningwithnandita atalji was a gr8 man..sushma swaraj i respect
Gadkari jayashakar ..all modi clan are of same breed...all talk no action..
@@SAFFRONINFERNO oh modi cell
@@curious1731 Oh if you had been to erstwhile North East and visit the roads now you won't say it. But how can I forget you are disrespectful of the current foreign policy too which is the talk of the year world over so there's no chance you will ever see light. No need for replying, God bless us all Indians
Good to see a civil debate thanks to our well educated south Indian MPs.
Educated South Indian MPs sir realy
@@radhikaprabhu4738 *really
What about ur educated south Indian MP giving vile remarks about gaumutra and north Indians. As a country if we r still busy wd linguism, community biases then I can surely say we haven't progressed even in these 75 yrs. Kudos to people like u.
@@aakanchaanand2223have you ever heard speeches of smrithi, Meenakshi lekhi , jyothiradithya sindya etc. There are so many who speak well irrespective of region.
@@athi482 Bro either way his message is clear stop dividing the country , as SOUTH INDIAN ive never seen people call " Wo, thats a really well educated NORTH Indian (profession)
Need responsible ministers who really work, not just giving sweet statements.
He should arrange to send clarifying documents to finance minister Central. And see the result. That will give proud feeling to the person who executed good action out of the way. No harsh statements. I am not a politician not interested.
what more responsable answer u needed
Which statement made you feel it is sweet? I want to touch your godly level of brilliance? Pls help me
Exactly, this is where all the citizens gets influenced by sweet talks, we can't blame the politicians everytime, we has citizens should change these politicians too.
Agree with you!
Case is if state non-bjp.. they will ask docs first.. if comes with docs... Ask for Docs ++.... If comes with docs ++.. then will ask for Docs ++ pro .... So on.... Until rule down
Dr Sashi Tharoor is an extempore orator, is a real pride for all Indians on a par with the high quality of speeches made by V K Krishna Menon and Sir C P Rama Seamy Iyer .
VK Krishna Menon was the worst defence minister of India. We lost 1962 war because of him. He used to make Generals fight with each other by spreading rumours about their wives. And he did so in the paranoia that Army would do a coup on the government.
We don't want orators or good English speaking Maps.
We want good MPs who can understand Indian ethos and are grounded
We are proud of you sir sashi Tharur is great intelligent leader
@@lilydsilva5274 great n intelligent leader? Your comment is the joke of this millennium
Bullshit roor
She is right. She doesnt SIT on files, she merely SLEEPS on them.
It is most f the states melodrma they hike their demand without giving support back up papers--. So problem is not with the FM
🤣🤣
Well said hope the modishah RSSBJP goondas and police are not sent calling you anti national, urban naxal, anti Hindu ,and file a FIR. Like they do to anyone who say a thing about this regime.😅
🤣🤣😂
🤔😇😧
Subject to correction, it is Public Tax Payers amt, that every body must understand. Particularly People Representatives.
Bureaucracy in India is really messed up. I hope it improves.
crazy how everyone thinks they know everything 💀💀💀
I thought India is bad but British parliament is worse. I have never such immaturity in any parliament. They act like they are in some teenage movie
how
@@namratagogoi2763Bureaucracy is not the behavior in Parliament. It is different.
States should claim their gst part in terms of usd then only the value is meaningful for pending amount from 2017 to be received in 2022
USD transactions with in independent Hindu Bharat ? It only happens in a Banana republic !
@@SadguruPrernaTrust their is no country called Hindu Bharat. Only India that is Bharat.
@@tejesheconomics4072 have you heard of Hindu-sthan
@@homefrontsai Not in Indian Constitution. It is just a non formal name. India don't recognise the name not in Indian Constitution.
@@homefrontsai It is Hindustan not Hindu Bharat and certainly not a Hindu Rashtra!
Mad Sitharaman is expert in manipulative statements
She clarified well....kerala the xm itself is a lier
@@SAFFRONINFERNO andhbhakt spotted
If one has right to call another mad it can b paid with same coin rather forcedully
@@SAFFRONINFERNO CHAL RE... TU AUR TERI BJP HAI BEGGAR JO JANTA KE CHANDE PAR ZINDA HAI AUR ASLI PAPPU BHI MODI HAI
@@parameswarrao3900 I'VE 2 BETTER OPINIONS THAN MAD.. 1- INCAPABLE 2- FAILED
Some programs have to be introduced,if necessary by amendment, in such a way that States should collect the taxes and pay to the union government of India.
you are free to give your family wealth to PM cares...direct to modi...why union govt.
You don't know how the constitution and states function...…most state govts are too powerful, have larger work force and most importantly excessively corrupt. They change budgets, spend money on whimsical things that govts are not supposed to do. Sania mirza making crores of money in gifts while farmers are committing suicides and Olympians getting peanuts if they dont win something are smallest examples. 90% of execution is with state govt, while Centre controls taxation and have control of spending and accountability. Its a decent check and balance.
I beleive this mother chor is from tamilnadu probably a boot licker for DMK so that is why he is using the word union government. pelt him with stones never let fake tamilans to enter India other status they are super poison
GST itself is a wrongly drafted and implemented scheme. Earlier it was good.
@@s.t.chandrasekharbabu132 oh yeah then why did PTR is still in the council ask him to get out of the council asap
The FM is not good, they need to change her.
You wish to have a chor F.m.according to your convenience.
@@leelamani3758 Not really. Just like he found Dr. Jayashankar for the role of Foreign Affairs minister, Modi should find a competent candidate for the role of the financial minister. This one does not even have a PhD. Look at the Tamil Nadu financial minister for a second.
As if you know about her fully. Do not comment if you don't know
If she would have received the proper papers from Kerala Govt 700cr would have been released by now , Please send the correct paper - Kerala 😂
Cite sources and validated reasons, not opinions.
Mr. Tharoor is Highly Qualified no Comperisen
Not an economist
For washing Sonia's towels . What is the qualification for ?
@@SadguruPrernaTrust neither is nirmala
@@shakkuiyer nirmala bhi do rahe na modi ka chai cup
Nirmala is licking BJP shoes
It's only because this absence of transparency of public service, the mistrust between the State and the Centre in so called federal structure of our constitution that after 58 years of our becoming independent India, we had to promulgate such declaratory statute like RTI Act just to ascertain that State i.e the Government is not telling what it ought to its subjects i.e the citizen.
She doesn't sit on files , because she is sleeping, not knowing the Rupee fall , Onion and other comodity pride rise ect.
onion was cheeper in Congrees reign??
Are she doesnot eat onion😂😂😂
@@clashon4846 It's not about comparisons with a government that hasn't been in power for 8 years now. It's about asking the current government to do its job better. Competition between parties must come into the picture only once every 5 years. Rest of the time, we should be focused on whether the ruling party is doing what we need them to.
Most disastrous FM. After former education minister S Irani..
Yes... Appoint your mother
Cry baby.. cry next 25 years...
how..care to detail
@@coorgiand6820 Only detail i can see is, he or she must be madarasa
Filthy attitude.! Change it.
Any new minister can learn a lesson or two from the manner in which hon'ble minister answers questions in Parliament.
Exactly
Mdm have you cleared due amount of thousands of crores to be paid to Tamilnadu , then why is the Tamilnadu finance minister Mr PTR stating there's huge money that the centre owns Tamilnadu in terms of GST collected , please brief , if you R not sitting , then why R files sleeping ?
Becuase PTR is an assh)le and he creates numbers out of Imagination without supporting files.
@@Intusr R U better educated and experienced than PTR , truth' is bitter for people like you
Tamilnadu pay more to central,get less in return,tamilnadu money going to states like UP ..etc..
@@sabi56847 who says ? tamilnadu got the most load from mudra and also it has the most subscribers of JIO tamilnadu people oppose ambani from JIO Network only
Govt has written off Rs10.5 Lakh Crores/- as bad loans.....
Just imagine
@@SAFFRONINFERNO Tera mai baap Bhajpa ne, toh party with difference kehata hai...
Ek taraf loans maaf, aur dusre taraf middle class aur majdur ko dabo..
@@SAFFRONINFERNO tujh jaisa Bhakt hai toh vajpa thik hai
@@SAFFRONINFERNO haath ... Tujhse baat karna bekar gai... Ja jake k doodh pe
You have not gone through the entire text.Though it is written off , recovery proceedings are on
Written off, not waived off. Written off means recovery is started. But balance sheet if bank is recapitalized. Just because some people defaulted, doesn't mean bank will stop functioning right?
So, recovery can happen in parallel. And the past losses can be filled in parallel.
Excellent for your speech &knowledge,
You are asking wrong question to wrong person, she doesn't know anything about economics.
True
Ask her bosses
@@srinivasrao369 Lol...For the sake of 1.4 billion Indians...He should have just continued selling Tea.....I wonder who was making the tea that he was selling.....
She us M.Phil in Economics from JNU.
Do you?
Its always great to see shashi tharoor sir
It's pitty to note that almost all State Governments, barring a few ,there involves no Professional approaches among State Government officials, so is the Office of CM. They have little mechanism to check Data they prepare for submission to Finance Ministry for authentic validations. State's careless official approaches suggest that their dedication to Official Jobs rest with uncared supervision by those who are entrusted with. Union Finance Minister rightly pointed out the genuine lapses of office management without any Accountability where data mismatched gets vibrant. Moreover, why do such lapses of internal office management of State become a point of Issues to be discussed at Parliament? Enforcing Accountability at local State Level can ensure responsibility of operating official instead of abusing the platform of Parliament. MPs tend to make mockery at Parliament with imaginary Data with clear intentions to waste valuable times at Parliament in the name of Personal Selling. This trends are increasingly becoming near to dereliction of Duties & Responsibility among State Level functionaries as Fashion. Any discussion must be constructive & authentic.
Yes. Absolutely right.
Well these depts are all lead by our glorified IAS officers … even at the State level
Absolutely right
GST payment will be cleared after year after year..
But pending since 2017.. ??
Sasi tharroor would have been lied
@@yesb4258 Sithharaman said "Many state governments believe that their GST compensation is pending.The central government needs the necessary papers as the money belongs to the taxpayers. Hence, the compensation will be settled once the centre obtains the papers, Sitharaman said.
"The moment I receive the papers, the AG certification, even if there is a contention between the Centre and a state, it has to be sorted out. I cannot be sitting on somebody's money," she said.
@@yesb4258 Johnathan Swift states:
As the wireless readers has its readers
So the greatest liar has its believers
You need to know who is the biggest liar of our country..
Namo
Yes so give the necessary papers...it's not that all the amount is pending...the documents which the state govt couldn't give to centre have been holded
Yes , it’s all about the papers 😂 - Kerala, Just give the right paper and take your money 💰
There is a reason for nirmala jis arrogance. These questions are deliberate with different intentions
True. My can't the state gov of Kerala, TN and etc can't provide proper GST collection document to claim their refund. Is there any fraudalent act involved in the GST collection like in the TN like charging GST for GST exempted goods and charging 20% extra for food like yogurts, and packaged milk instead of 5%.And the 15% goes into the DMK's pocket. The GST collection must be placed under the central gov supervision not the state gov. These MPs of these states asked the same question and become after he or she wad told to submit the GST collectible verification documents.🤦♀️
കുറഞ്ഞവാക്കുകളിൽ കൂടുതൽ കാര്യങ്ങൾ ചോദിക്കുവാനുള്ള ശശി തരൂരിന്റെ ആ കഴിവ് അപാരം തന്നെ.
but kerala governmentinu vendi chodicha tharoorine verum oombnakki kalanju. bloody ldf.
Best deaf finance minister of india. Never listen to anybody.
Did you even listen to what she said
so let's say kerla says due is 120 , but center calculation says 100..why not make atleast 100 payment and just continue discussing remaining 20.
Big brain 🧠
Not less that I don't agree.
Pattu. Book ile ചില്ലറ കണക്ക് പോലെ allade ഇത്. 😂
Please improve digital India. Papers will not work in this digital era.
Kisi ko kuch samaj nahi aya 🤣🤣
Bill passed 😂😂
😂😂😂😂
Why is the FM so panicky while replying..
Insecure
She doesn't know the details and nothing give back gst anyway
Incompetent
She is great 👍
@@shhanmadshaiku5129 bruh she is a economic graduate from JNU
This is what a normal discussion in a parliament looks like in parliaments all over the world but it is due to the fish market image which is so engraved in the two houses that a normal conversation between MPs like this seem like some utopian world.
And how it is possible for you FM to write off rs.4000000000000/-or 12000000000000/- rupees for the corporates?
Dr Shashi Tharoor jindabad, Congress jindabad
Sashi Tharoor ko congress president banna tha
Congress is shit. That has been established when they didn't elect him President. It's a party filled with followers, not leaders. All slaves of the establishment, afraid of change, and short-sighted. Even the G-23 who signed the petition to Sonia Gandhi about reforms in the organization betrayed Tharoor by backing that spineless oldie who couldn't even settle the Rajasthan Chief Ministry conflict without Rahul Gandhi. Congress doesn't deserve Shashi Tharoor.
@@Pranav_Bhamidipati , you guys are shit. Congress is the heart of India that sacrificed to give us freedom. Congress built India by building World famous IIT, ISRO, DRDO, AIIMS, BRAC etc which made India biswaguru. BJP and modi desh ko bechne aaya, 45 years unemployment crisis in Modi's corrupt rule aur tum unpadh bhakt ko berojgar bhakt banake chor diya
@@mrsarkar6933 How did you assume I support BJP? You're an idiot, aren't you? Re-read what I said.
@@Pranav_Bhamidipati , but BJP andha bhakt use the same language as you did. May be you are BJP's chota bhai AAP supporter. But it doesn't matter. Would you like to discuss in Google meet? I hope i can your misconceptions in few minutes. I can send the Google meet link
These required papers not submitted by opposition by govt party in states. Where are BJP govt. no need any clarification or required papers to release the funds.
Hope Only South States Required all those pappers
Why don't they use google drive
Oh you want our vulnerable tax data in US servers?
This is not only Kerala most non BJP ruling states have the same issue
How can it be opening for so many years
Good debate....great
Digital India why papers
By papers she means documentation. That's so obvious
Wow, Big brain. 🤡
more like smooth brain 😂@@ashwinpremnath2821
She is one of the best central ministers who needs no outside advice to do her job expeditiously and meticulously.
I think you're overrating her a little. Shashi's concerns are valid. Why is the work not being done yet? And "not needing outside advice"? I don't think you understand how democracy works. As an MP, it's Dr. Tharoor's job to fight for the interests of his constituency, even if it means asking the cabinet ministers to do their jobs better.
@@Pranav_Bhamidipati you missed the whole point. Sashi was exposing cpm n kerala FM 😄.
@@Pranav_Bhamidipati im from kerala, its better not to provide the fund to current state authorities bcoz nothing is given to the people, state govt authorities are corrupted
What about OROP2 for Armed Forces Pensioners ! Due from 1st July 2019. But after Supreme Court direction also Finance Minister is sitting with the file. A true lire
Fail incompetent FM 👌🤣😂
I don't understand as a accountant I tally all the ledgers. But these central and state governments accounts never tallying. That too hundreds of crores difference.
Why can't we put proper system inplace.??
Money laundering helps the rich while common citizens bail the government.Pandora files show how unaccounted wealth is stached by shell companies.
I feel pitty on kerala assembly after seeing this house
Well, u had to mention, which is yet to be submitted and why u needed it.. There is not point in what she has said now.. Anybody can say that..
Kerala finance minister instead of saying pending...please send the papers required to center...Kerala govt need money to give the money to mp.
Usual answer, the office bearers of the finance ministry, are they not answerable to their minister, if she needs any clarification? Will it take years to sort out the issues, even between the governments? I was thinking only common people face problems in the government offices.....
Why papers required from states to claim their part of GST. The union collects and should have accurate account on collection. I can relate the union Finance behaviour similar to an Accountant in a company when it comes to payable
Why don't u go n sit there 😂. Did u listen to the whole conversation. Pay attention to every word including the last line from the minister.
Show the right papers and get your money 😂
Worst and most incompetent Finance minister
You may appointment someone else
jess PM wese uske mantri
Where in war 6.9 % growth rate
@@amitkosa5387 s jaishankar , nitin gadkari , ashwani vaishanav
coz she didn't speak in Chinese Ying Yang?
I don't understand why both the officials sit together and sortout.Kerala is not in another planet.
Many projects pending lack of funds.
Categorizing which fund or income can be alloted during disaster management.
Water tax huge but employees and machine involvement or to low. Where are the remaining funds.
4 or 5 years once roads are laid, how much property tax fund utilized. Whether central government gets its shares all to be accounted. This can be done city wise so network technology also low, sql query to get details about dispensionary spending can be derived along with employees salary in those sectors
Huge fan of Dr Tharoor
Waste fm of nation
No opinions please only reasons with validation.
The centre cannot release funds if earlier expenses are reconciled. This is what we could. make out from FM spesch. It is for the states to reconcile the accounts and get it certified by AG. What for AG is there?
Is the movie sitharaman named after her?
The finance minister is simply blaming the law and order of the state. She is the one who is responsible for all this delay in payment
SOUTH INDIA will not get anything but will have to continously shell out the taxes to Delhi
Well Shashi Tharoor did not add a single of his own comment yet personel comments are made on him
This speaker shouts unnessarily it's a healthy discussion
What an auspicious and fantabulous sign ?
She's not really not fit to be an finance finance minister.
Your reasoning mister?
You are very fit...
hehe...jokers.
Yes you don't sit on files you sleep on them
Pinarayi certified account deatails cannot be trusted.Only AG approval is a must for the kind information of 100% literate state .
Problem that ministers are like to watch first show of a theatre picture
Shri Om Birla's favourite go to word is "NO". Thinks of himself to be a Principal of a primary school and treats the oposition MP such as the likes of Shri Shashi Tharoor and others as if they are some indisciplined students of that school. Well what else can one expect from Om Birla ji, who happens to be from a party which has a notorious and unenviable record of creating and causing the most and the worst disruptions in our country's Parliament history. Khali jab dekho, jaha dekho, jidhar dekho, apni zabaan se sirf No..No..No.. shabd nikalta rehta hai. Lekin es problem ka solution actually inke ya kissi aur insaan ke paas nahi hai, philhal. Jab tak Modi aur Shah naam ke bhoot inke sar par par mandrate rahenge, tab tak ye, No.. No.. No.. bolte rahenge aur opposition bhi baaj nahi ayega, woh sunkar. So, unfortunately, were in a so called deadlock and stalemate for the long haul. Unless and until the people of our country decide to teach this Modi-Shah duo a lesson by giving a right royal hiding in the upcoming Parliamentary General Elections of 2024. P.S.- That is if no untoward and so called unexpected incident happens before the run up to that. For example, like if China ups the ante and goes to war with India.
@handsomeboy_69 why mone? Why do you ask? Acha nahi laga, kya??
Speaker has understood everything
Shasi Blunder man who pointed out that Kerala is yet to receive Rs 4,486 crore as GST compensation for the year 2017-18. ......he dont know exact figure just shoot in english
Even media's are notorious .
So ,until &unless these fraud people are kicked out from politics ,ther is no way .
U see after 20 yrs service a government servant get pension but these politicians get full pension if get elected in elections .
So to get dedicated politicians this Pension system should be abolished but no party will agree to abolish pension system . Or to get elected 5 times .= 20 yrs .
Mr sashi tharoor is much more having ability than our finance minister, earlier Defence Minister. If Congress party as well as Gandhi family may realise his ability, then they did definitely elect this person as the President of Congress.
And that is really not possible till 2024 ........Rahul Gandhi duba ke hi manenge congress ko🥲
Comical. Kerala's state FM who can't even provide the proper GST collectible verification documents is rooted to become the President of the corrupted Congress party. These MPs kept getting nose cut from Nirmala and kept silent when asked about these documents. How can a person this disresponsible can be considered as the President of a party? Oh, yes. We just become the 5th most largest economy in the world. We have just released 2 satelites into the space. We have own own Vandhe Bharat trains which are on par with the Euro trains and better than trains in Malaysia, Singapore, USA, Australia and Saudi Arabia ( which had better infrastructure than India during Congress rule)and we are close to having our own bullet trains and bigger highways. We are now peaceful without any terror attacks in Jammu and Kashmir that much. We definately need Congress party to have Taj Hotel attacks. How dare of us to even dream of becoming a global super power? Even, now India have become the envy of the world. How dare Modi was ranked 1st in the PEW rating for his leadership? We need to be poorer and backward like we were when Congress ruled India. We must only travel in a dilapidated trains which we used to travel when we young. We should not be innovative and be a weak nation to be bullied around by all the developed nation. Oh yes, we just improved our transparency and reduced the corruption in our country. We definately need Congress to increase our corruption level. Lastly, there us still some innocent Tamilzh Sri Lankans left in the Sri Lanka with misery. Too bad, Modi sympathised them and asked Sri Lanka to hear their plight for being discriminated. If Congress is in power, the poor Tamilzh in Sri Lanka will be murdered by now as the Sri Lanka gov will be heavily funded by Congress like they did during their rule. All the extremists can stab any non-Muslims and run free coz they will not be executed by the Congress people for Muslim's vote bank. Congress, we need your help 2 destroy India. 🙏 No Indians born in India will vote for a Congress party. Only traitors do. Thank you, Modi for making India the greatest it has ever been. Bharat Matta Ki Jai
The way Mr.Tharoor is spoke into by the honourable chair is so shameful. The chair does not have a single competency other being a member of a particular political establishment.
The way modiji, amit shah ji, yogi ji plz watch video is available in youtube bkl
Chair is lately being less honourable with senior leaders...Time ro have a time check.
Kaahe ka digital india . Abhi bhi paper paper chal rha hai to .
UPI
You get to know clearly when you are a central government employee....
By paper she means documentation
You dumb
Paper means Documentation...DUHH 🙄
Speaker Sir, shouted No the house remain silent. A very obedient students he has got. We read that the house belongs to opposition. I don't know I might be wrong.
Good FM
She is great.During pandemic she efficiently manage the economy.
Perfectly said.
It is time for a new finance minister
Without 😂 knowing anything why are you FM ma’am curd rice
The way she says 4th decimal if you want it..Nobody asked you madam . Kindly keep your arrogant in your house..
I am no fan of either of these MP's but this is what a parliament needs.. well-informed debate, without being personal or getting agitated
Shahi tharoor 🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️
Congress party zindabaad ❤️
Worst FM we have ever seen
In what way ?
I am happy both from the south are raising and discussing useful agenda in a responsible way
So it is 3rd year, & they haven't figured out what necessary papers to give. Come on ma'am ☺️
.you fellow always doubt.....I dont know how GST amounts are paid but here is a fact I expect. so state govts cant submit bills because they get budget allocations for one project and spend on something else. Earlier state govts use to pass this off making contractors wait for years but its not happening any more. So I did a project in my village, money was paid by center to state, my state govt used it for their whimsical project .......I still did not get paid nor the beneficiary got his so called double bedroom house. We should ask more accountability rather than cribbing at something happening good.
Worse finance minister india ever have?
Who is finance minister
Want to see Shashi Sir as PM of India ❤
The debate we never knew coming
Ma'am not eat onions
They eat taxpayer money 😂
good quiestion & good answer... beauty of democracy
And Kerala govt got no money 😂
See balance amount of gst receivable
What is "MOJO"
Sort it out and release the GST compensation Madam FM
Sitaraman is pretty much typical 60+ aunty
Lost all her capacity to even take some criticism
Rahul Gandhi is 54 and still youth leader, if you are supporting congress this is a point. By the way cite sources to your view point.
Nirmala mam please resign for well being of the people of this country
A = All taxes, central government not giving states the tax money that is due them ( El )
You are the best