Love your design, very stylish, very strong. However one weak spot: the foundation. Not the concrete part, enough strength to carry the weight. But I see only 12 screws total attaching the whole greenhouse to the concrete. A little uplift by wind could take that quickly apart. At least double the number of screws, anchor bolts would be better and it would also be a good idea to attach those brackets to the wood with bolts and nuts instead of screws. Would be a pity to see in a storm that whole beautiful structure being sucked into the air ... just because of 12 screws.
Your craftsmanship is truly an amazing art form, that is absolutely incredible. I can’t wait to watch the rest of this build. Great job and thank you for sharing! 👍
I know I'm about three years too late to the party but I gotta say . . . I LOVE this design!! Not a word said and you spoke volumes!! Well . . . . except at 3:10 when I swore I heard you mutter something under your breath. :) Well done!!
I really like these designs. Simple and effective with plenty of height. I think what I would have done differently is build a ridge piece into it so that the each side buts up against it.
I hope you treated the heck out of that flake board. Any moisture like that in a gh will destroy it in short order. Let us know how it holds up. Sometimes good old plywood is worth the extra $. Having said that it looks great👍😎👌
@@pugsymalone6539 I am not sure of the flexibility of cedar. BUT that being said, if your cedar boards weren't too thick, and if they were as knot free as possible and if you steamed them before you them in the jig hot, then I believe they would work out fine.
@@pugsymalone6539 I just found a channel yesterday that showed building the Gothic arch trusses in greater detail and with instruction. He was building a styroaircrete shed. To get his arches he cut his stock to half inch thin and he bent those strips into his jig, gluing laminations as he went. It looked less labor intensive. I definitely want to give it a go, whether for a shed, greenhouse or as a roof on another structure. If you are interested the channel was ... Stephen Williams.
@@renaissancewomanfarm9175 Hey good neighbor, thanks very much for sharing this with me. I'm going to build a Gothic Arch structure to shelter firewood, so I'll definitely check it out. Thanks again!
Можно проще сделать - вместо клея использовать болты M6. Верхнюю косынку можно не делать - сразу крепить к коньковому брусу (50х50, закрепить под 45град). Если использовать поликарбонат, то горизонтали не нужны. бетонные столбы тоже не нужны.
Hello. Thank you very much for video list of greenhouse (3*5*2,8). Please tell me what board size (width, thickness and length)? Bar length? How many boards did it take in meters? What glue was it glued to? Thank you in advance for your reply. Respectfully!!!
I'll bet there's lots of people using a Bluetooth or earbuds to watch videos. Can you imagine how loud and sharp the noise was when you threw those bundles on the floor. I really appreciate you thinking about the rest of us.
if you leave a space at the top you can do a ridgepole i would do 8' sections make them modulrar easy to put up and take down of course you would have 2 touching every 8' but that would make it much stronger and 1 person could easily put up by themselves i have made them this way and there very handy
This is great! Any way to achieve R-30 insulation value on the ceiling and R-13 on walls with a structure like this? Could something like this ever pass Florida primary dwelling building code for Structural, Energy, Wind?
Really nice craftsmanship, however the fact that all that beautiful raw lumber will begin to decay almost immediately due to this being a greenhouse and moisture, heat and cold are continually breaking down the structure. I'd be concerned. Without the raw wood being treated thoroughly, especially where it meets the soil it will become a dinner plate to termites and other species of unwanted bugs. To put this much effort into building such a nice structure and not consider how the elements will break down the raw wood is disheartening. Maybe there are other considerations I'm not taking into play, such as environmental but being a retired Contractor I would weigh that factor and protect my build for its longevity. P.S. I really appreciate the video editing. It moves along nicely, and hearing the audio at greater speeds is humorous and entertaining. Great job.
Totally agree! That much effort spent and structure is going to fail in a year or two. Not going to last through 3 seasons being covered. People will start to build like this without realising that it is going to rot very soon. 20mm Pine planks ? ))) Bad Idea
Out of curiosity, and as a beginner to carpentry, how would you treat the wood to last a long time when building a greenhouse like this? or should I be considering other materials?
@Norbury53 Thanks so much for the very informative reply! don't think anyone has replied so thoroughly on youtube before. Really appreciate it! I'm doing a lot of research into setting something like this up for the garden, but It's a really unfortunate fact that eventually wooden structures seem to rot away and spending thousands on something I'm not sure I still want standing in 30 years is another argument entirely.
@@joshthemighty7700 Just keep it off the ground Josh and it'll last years. A lot of folk over-engineer unnecessarily. Benni's done the right thing here by sitting it on stilts.
absolutely, he is so wrapped up in how fucking great he is that actually what and how it is doing is unimportant. The god of instruction. I dislike every one of these ninnies I find. Dont know if it hurts but it certainly cannot help the egotist.
@@g.r.4853 Maybe just get a basic understanding of woodworking and woodworking tools before making such a dim-witted comment. Very clear what he is doing and perfectly brought to your screen.
I wonder if one could find a way to do this with PVC rather than wood, as wood is prohibitively expensive here. The main issue would be the join of the two pipes at the top. Any ideas?
Just a question. Why didn't you put your bracing in the concrete footings while poring it but instead drilling then in after? You mustn't have wind at all. But build came together well.
I hate this video. I can’t stand it when I see someone do something much better than I have done when I know I have much better tools. You have used creativity and smarts to create a wonderful project with what looks like limited tools. This is what makes a true craftsman in my opinion.
That looks like a great project, I’m going to get someone to come next week and build me a workshop, then I’ll buy all the tools $20k should cover that part 😂😂😂
Валерий, а чего собственно амер помалкивает? За год вполне мог бы язык подтянуть! Хотя бы до уровня понимания комментариев! Ему лайк за смелость, а вам за прецедент: почему наши стесняются комментировать понятное видео на не понятном языке ?!
I thought about the size the greenhouse should've been and I tried different curves and lengths in google sketch up. So I decided to take the 3m battens. It is important to use knotless wood. Otherwise it would break if you bend it.
Добрый день дорогой друг. Скажи пожалуйста как ты изгибаешь древесину? я пробовал - у меня ломается при изгибе Good afternoon, dear friend. Tell me please, how do you bend wood? I tried - it breaks when bent
This man has excellent woodworking ing skills. Very good video. An arch structure is inherrently strong and structurally effcient.
PPE
Love your design, very stylish, very strong.
However one weak spot: the foundation. Not the concrete part, enough strength to carry the weight. But I see only 12 screws total attaching the whole greenhouse to the concrete. A little uplift by wind could take that quickly apart. At least double the number of screws, anchor bolts would be better and it would also be a good idea to attach those brackets to the wood with bolts and nuts instead of screws.
Would be a pity to see in a storm that whole beautiful structure being sucked into the air ... just because of 12 screws.
Your craftsmanship is truly an amazing art form, that is absolutely incredible. I can’t wait to watch the rest of this build. Great job and thank you for sharing! 👍
The stringer jig is a great setup. That application can be used in aeroplanes' wing fusilage encircling the webs and spar caps.
Amazing I can see a lot of applications to that.. I can see a light weight sleeping platform in a pick up truck. etc
Лучшая технология, что я нашел на Ютуб. Спасибо автору. Под Москвой будет хорошая теплица этой весной.
Great design! However, I'm curious as to how you calculated the correct curvature when making your jig for the ribs.
Beautiful work. Thanks for the post from an admiring hobby woodworker. And gardiner.
I know I'm about three years too late to the party but I gotta say . . . I LOVE this design!! Not a word said and you spoke volumes!! Well . . . . except at 3:10 when I swore I heard you mutter something under your breath. :)
Well done!!
I really like these designs. Simple and effective with plenty of height. I think what I would have done differently is build a ridge piece into it so that the each side buts up against it.
Brilliant design and craftmanship.
Really impressive design! Seems very simple and cheap, but still works and looks great :)
Awesome 👏🏻. Love your design , and use of common pine.
Great job, you do such good work. Could I use 4" pine and not worry about it braking? I want to bend a 12' board. It is for the top of a 10'x20' shed
Anywhere there is a knot is always a chance it will break. The bigger the knot the higher the probability
Hey Benni, great project. I am very interested to read more about your experiences after two years. Are you still happy with your construction?
Отличная работа! Отдельное спасибо за модель!
I hope you treated the heck out of that flake board. Any moisture like that in a gh will destroy it in short order. Let us know how it holds up. Sometimes good old plywood is worth the extra $. Having said that it looks great👍😎👌
Great project but first need to build a shop, buy all the tools, etc. Could you produce a kit?
Fuck, had my TV turned up all the way and the beginning scared the shit out of me lol
Like that.
Easy simple and elegant construction
this is an awesome video. Thanks for sharing. I'm psyched to build mine.
Класс, просто восхищаюсь вами! Чисто, точно и изящно!
I'm very impressed! And it looks very attractive. I think I would prefer it in cedar though for durability.
I'm not sure if cedar is flexible enough to accomplish this...?
@@pugsymalone6539 I am not sure of the flexibility of cedar. BUT that being said, if your cedar boards weren't too thick, and if they were as knot free as possible and if you steamed them before you them in the jig hot, then I believe they would work out fine.
@@renaissancewomanfarm9175 sounds right. Drop me a line if you give it a try.
@@pugsymalone6539 I just found a channel yesterday that showed building the Gothic arch trusses in greater detail and with instruction. He was building a styroaircrete shed. To get his arches he cut his stock to half inch thin and he bent those strips into his jig, gluing laminations as he went. It looked less labor intensive. I definitely want to give it a go, whether for a shed, greenhouse or as a roof on another structure. If you are interested the channel was ... Stephen Williams.
@@renaissancewomanfarm9175 Hey good neighbor, thanks very much for sharing this with me. I'm going to build a Gothic Arch structure to shelter firewood, so I'll definitely check it out. Thanks again!
Bamboo is another Choice for me. From Pondicherry India.
Можно проще сделать - вместо клея использовать болты M6. Верхнюю косынку можно не делать - сразу крепить к коньковому брусу (50х50, закрепить под 45град). Если использовать поликарбонат, то горизонтали не нужны. бетонные столбы тоже не нужны.
If you should build it again, what would you make different ?
Hello. Thank you very much for video list of greenhouse (3*5*2,8).
Please tell me what board size (width, thickness and length)? Bar length?
How many boards did it take in meters?
What glue was it glued to?
Thank you in advance for your reply.
Respectfully!!!
What about using Larch, it’s used a lot in boatbuilding!
Is it just me, or would the sound made by the planer make a great AC/DC opening riff?
Young man....you are an abosolute LEGEND....ghotic green house for tomatoes.....hahahaha.....may God bless you and your ideas
Not only it's a gooood job but also the video is very good, understandable and excellent rhythm
Very good use of a pvc concrete post in soil
what kind of wood did you use?
I'll bet there's lots of people using a Bluetooth or earbuds to watch videos. Can you imagine how loud and sharp the noise was when you threw those bundles on the floor. I really appreciate you thinking about the rest of us.
if you leave a space at the top you can do a ridgepole i would do 8' sections make them modulrar easy to put up and take down of course you would have 2 touching every 8' but that would make it much stronger and 1 person could easily put up by themselves i have made them this way and there very handy
Which wood do you use ?
Thank for your answer
Bruno from Brittany
Fun to watch. I should make a small one of these for practice. Hmmmm
Joe do You avoid wood memory to get back straight posituon?
This is great! Any way to achieve R-30 insulation value on the ceiling and R-13 on walls with a structure like this? Could something like this ever pass Florida primary dwelling building code for Structural, Energy, Wind?
I like it but a bit labor intensive for what I want. Will keep the truss idea in mind for later projects. Thanks, great project.
Really nice craftsmanship, however the fact that all that beautiful raw lumber will begin to decay almost immediately due to this being a greenhouse and moisture, heat and cold are continually breaking down the structure. I'd be concerned.
Without the raw wood being treated thoroughly, especially where it meets the soil it will become a dinner plate to termites and other species of unwanted bugs. To put this much effort into building such a nice structure and not consider how the elements will break down the raw wood is disheartening.
Maybe there are other considerations I'm not taking into play, such as environmental but being a retired Contractor I would weigh that factor and protect my build for its longevity.
P.S. I really appreciate the video editing. It moves along nicely, and hearing the audio at greater speeds is humorous and entertaining. Great job.
Totally agree! That much effort spent and structure is going to fail in a year or two. Not going to last through 3 seasons being covered. People will start to build like this without realising that it is going to rot very soon. 20mm Pine planks ? ))) Bad Idea
Out of curiosity, and as a beginner to carpentry, how would you treat the wood to last a long time when building a greenhouse like this? or should I be considering other materials?
@Norbury53 Thanks so much for the very informative reply! don't think anyone has replied so thoroughly on youtube before. Really appreciate it!
I'm doing a lot of research into setting something like this up for the garden, but It's a really unfortunate fact that eventually wooden structures seem to rot away and spending thousands on something I'm not sure I still want standing in 30 years is another argument entirely.
@@joshthemighty7700 Just keep it off the ground Josh and it'll last years. A lot of folk over-engineer unnecessarily. Benni's done the right thing here by sitting it on stilts.
Josh The Mighty creasote works the best , leaves a bad taste in their mouth.
Перед сборкой надо олифить или отработкой прописывать , красить. А так, молодец, хорошая идея. Высокая и радиус собирает всё тепло.
Just wondering where you got the angles for the roof cuts. Nice work but no details.
Great project and I wanted to compliment on the video production. Excellent.
great build. what offsets did you use for the block from the edge of your table and the distance between your end blocks. thanks
Probably trial and error: the correct answer comes up quickly.
Seems to me that the plece of wood you cut to connect both bows at the top ... will block the 2x6 at the top they connect to. What am I missing?
Great video, this is a very nice design. Is the lower boards pressure treated to protect from wood rot?
OTTIMO video e OTTIMO tutorial
👍👍👍👍 👋👋👋👋👋👋👋👋
This is an excellent video, thank you Benni.
+Adam Harman thank you so much for your comment, I really appreciate it.
That guy was amped. 4 cups of coffee and a donut, minimum....
Awesome 👍
What was the point with glue when there are screws anyway?
Me: Oh maybe i can do this on my own.
Also Me after 15 sec: I don't even know what the first machine is, nor do i know why he is doing it.
absolutely, he is so wrapped up in how fucking great he is that actually what and how it is doing is unimportant. The god of instruction. I dislike every one of these ninnies I find. Dont know if it hurts but it certainly cannot help the egotist.
@@g.r.4853 Maybe just get a basic understanding of woodworking and woodworking tools before making such a dim-witted comment. Very clear what he is doing and perfectly brought to your screen.
Excellent skill...
It is a very good job...
Your math skills rock!
Отличная работа!
Большое спасибо!
I wonder if one could find a way to do this with PVC rather than wood, as wood is prohibitively expensive here. The main issue would be the join of the two pipes at the top. Any ideas?
You can heat PVC and bend it quite a bit. Don't forget to install a ridge beam along the long axis.
Excellent job
Hello, a brilliant project. What did the project start with, what was the basis? I want to make a greenhouse 4 meters wide.
Excellent lesson!
👍 Самому захотелось такую теплицу сделать.
Awesome design👌🏾👍🏼💜
WOW! VERY INTELLIGENT! João from Brazil
Excellent! I like the precision of the work! Great Job!
Too bad about the footings being off though.
Just a question. Why didn't you put your bracing in the concrete footings while poring it but instead drilling then in after? You mustn't have wind at all. But build came together well.
You did this so well!
Hi benni, nice project man! Nice design with the double layer arches! Cool to see!
wow ! that was easy to watch video . Good craftsmanship in your design and layout . Where is part 2 ?
Thank you. Part 2 is now online.
I wish my hands could move that fast when working for real.
hello Benni, give me the layout of the guides you attach the wood to make the curvature you attach to the sergeant
Greatheful work
You got good toys!!!
Круто. Мне понравилось. Лайк.
What is that wood, its very plastic.... that is fresh wood or one season?
SHOW !!!!! PARABÉNS AMIGO VOU FAZES ASSIM OBRIGADO POR COMPARTILHAR !!!!
Benni, can you give dimensions of your arch layout on the table and how to cut the end blocks to make the arches.
Hi Chuck, I will upload a video soon to answer a few questions. Benni
Thank you, your workmanship and attention to detail is great.
Beautiful work!
Congratulation, this is a great build and great video
I hate this video. I can’t stand it when I see someone do something much better than I have done when I know I have much better tools. You have used creativity and smarts to create a wonderful project with what looks like limited tools. This is what makes a true craftsman in my opinion.
That looks like a great project, I’m going to get someone to come next week and build me a workshop, then I’ll buy all the tools $20k should cover that part 😂😂😂
You can build it with a $15 hammer and a $15 saw for tools.
NordboDK 👍
i tried to rebuild this but the arch/2 doesnt stay in its intended shape. Any suggestions?
Great innovation, thank you, are they 1x3x10, how much is the cost?
Looks like 1x2...
How much material did it take and what was the total cost of the project
Do you have a picture of the ridge pole? I’m not sure how you attached it...
Молодец жаль что я не понимаю английский хочу такой же каркасник-гараж
Валерий, а чего собственно амер помалкивает? За год вполне мог бы язык подтянуть! Хотя бы до уровня понимания комментариев! Ему лайк за смелость, а вам за прецедент: почему наши стесняются комментировать понятное видео на не понятном языке ?!
@@serven21 чертеж и 3д модели интернациональны. Автор предоставил 3д модель.
@@zloy3glide добрый день, скиньте пожалуйста чертеж или 3д модель. Хочу тоже такую сделать.
Ruslan Absalyamov ссылка в описании есть.
Чё тут делать то
Weird ya didn't layout a Jig form.
Easy to sell that kinda intelligence,
After YER done with it.
Beautiful.
все здорово. легко и технологично. не хватает только добавить диагонали на первом и последнем пролёте.
bravissimo capolavoro!
We love your work! 😍
Comme un pingouin dans le désert q
Your video is amazing
What size wood did you use?
Thank you, the battens I used were cheap sized 24x48mm ones. I plained them to 20x44 mm, because the surface was pretty rough.
Thank you for the reply. I will work on getting some wood around that size
How did you figure out the length you needed for that arch?
I thought about the size the greenhouse should've been and I tried different curves and lengths in google sketch up. So I decided to take the 3m battens. It is important to use knotless wood. Otherwise it would break if you bend it.
Молодец!!👍
Bravo super
How did you make the think to put the first piece of wood in to make it keep the bowed shape while you put is all together?
the whole project made of 1x3 nice
love the design!
Добрый день дорогой друг. Скажи пожалуйста как ты изгибаешь древесину? я пробовал - у меня ломается при изгибе
Good afternoon, dear friend. Tell me please, how do you bend wood? I tried - it breaks when bent
Kann die Datei leider nicht öffnen trotz vorhandenem Sketchup Programm
bonjour quelles dimensions ont les lattes de départ ? merciiii
Beautiful