I like this version because they show that she is well off and is beautifully dressed she doesn't need his money.She is also just the right mix of beautiful and plain. THe music is also wonderful.
In the book, she comes back and teases him until he stops sulking, rouses from his depression and rises to her challenge. This is decidedly a different vibe.
I love this version. The book is ultimately the best version, of course, and will forever hold my heart, but there is something about the absolute deep, heartfelt joy and emotion in this scene that is just.. wonderful. To me, it is one of the most sincere, satisfying and beautifully done film endings
@@jorvikaengelskvinna7157 Glad I'm not the only one who found it irritating. Apart from anything else who goes up to a blind person and then just stands there in silence when they ask who's there?
@@jorvikaengelskvinna7157 the only real flaw - they somehow missed/skipped book`s most famous oneliner "Reader, I married him". The rest doesn`t matter - it`s screen adaptaion first of all
Perhaps you have never seen the 1995 adaptation of Persuasion with Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds? The full feature is currently free on TH-cam. I felt the same way as you until I stumbled on this wonderfully paired actors portrayal in the movie.
I know this ending is abrupt and doesn’t reflect Brontë’s ending, but to me it’s a work of art and so well acted…. I have watched it over and over through the years. This is a wonderful version, even with the omission of so much of the novel.
My definitive favourite is the BBC's television series with Timothy Dalton and Zelah Clarke. My least favourite is the Ruth Wilson version which, in my view, is poorly scripted and plays out like a soap opera.
@@ac1646 The Timothy Dalton version is very likely my favourite version but it has the luxury of being a series that has much more time to include much more of the story. I do like this version, but if I'm honest I would still choose the Orsen Well and Joan Fontaine film ending over this one. It gives a better sense of the end of the story and their relationship. The Timothy Dalton one would still have the number 1 spot though. The Toby Stephens one would run a very close 2nd I think. Not sure about the others.
Nevertheless, this scene is so poignant, so well acted. One example of what can actors of the highest caliber can accomplish. Notwithstanding the few liberties that version takes in the end, the scene fits perfectly the narrative which had gone so far. Given the time constraints - which the Dalton version didn't have as much being a series - this 21st century version nails it totally. I am moved to tears by that final scene, every time.
I wish this clip had continued to the dialogue where he doesn’t believe she could accept him in his current state. Jane has become more confident and teases him into believing. I first saw the Orson Welles/Joan Fontaine version and their images stuck with me. I see Rochester as dark and brooding and not a handsome man.
I love this movie to the point that I watched it twice for two consecutive nights. 😂It has that mysterious charms almost like a thriller because of the music and the scenes when there were weird things happening in Thornfield hall. It got an overall heavy vibe but I sure loved how Jane and Mr Rochester developed feelings for each other. ❤ the classics way
I watched that version for the first time last night. It was sensational. It's the only one I know of which shows Rochester has lost the use of a hand, as well. That's part of the subtle and overt moral undercurrents throughout the book. Rochester's "punishment" takes the "If your right eye causes you to stumble" and "If your right hand causes you to stumble" verse literally. That can't be a coincidence. 🤔 Best wishes from Vermont 🍁
@@mortalclown3812I just finished watching it! The black and white cinematography and Bernard Herrmann's music are absolutely stunning. Have a safe and interesting week 🍁
I get that they had to cut some of the book material because of film length BUT who made the insane decision to cut the ending of the novel which is the best part: 1. Rochester's disbelief that Jane is back 2. His jealousy of St.John and Jane actually TROLLING him about it omg 3. His regret and redeption which is so important to fully forgive him 4. The reveal of their supernatural bond 5. His second proposal and Jane again TROLLING him before saying yes 6. Their cuddling and flirting and happiness together Idk I don't get how this is not worthy of being included. There were other scenes that could have been cut instead (like half of the Moorhouse parts, sorry). It's like they tried too much too be an arthouse film and were reluctant to show an actual happy romantic ending.
I red Jane Eyre many times as a teenager and this is my favorite version. Sure is short, is not 100% accurate, but it nails the tone and themes so well. Plus they're such great actors...Mia's Jane is my favorite for sure, Ruth Wilson seemed too flirty imo
The novel always works better as a series. Trying to fit it into a two hour film means cutting out a lot - and deciding what there won't be time to tell. Most versions cut down or cut out the St. John interlude. The Emily Mortimer version reduces the Lowood section to a few scenes - Helen dies almost as soon as she shows up. My preference is for television versions which are able to show much more of the story. That said, I just enjoyed the 1944 Joan Fontaine version which burns through the novel in 97 minutes; stunning black and white photography and a score by Bernard Herrmann. Best wishes from Vermont 🍁
A beautiful scene and adaption. However Orson Welles and Joan Fontaine will always be my favourites as they captured my young romantic heart after I had read Charlotte Bronte's wonderful novel.
@@TheArmstrong1969 thank you for clearing it up for me. I wasn't reading the book in English so maybe the translation was poor. And it seemed characteristic behavior for him, too, so I got confused after watching one of the movies.
Далтон и Кларк эталонные. Вулкан и Эльф. Шарлотта Гейнсбур тоже хорошо справилась с ролью. Есть в её Джейн что-то от Жанны Дарк. И Теккерей сравнивал Шарлотту Бронте с этим историческим персонажем. Только вот гармоничного дуэта с Уильямом Хертом не случилось...
If you read the book, that’s literally one of her character traits. It’s about how she’s a passionate person on the inside and not just the sad beige young woman who overcame poverty and childhood trauma and neglect.
Did you version George c Scott only one has more of bertha Timothy Dalton version house is correct clothes even lady in attic are you aware most movies based on stretch book author made.thats what i mostly buy over years from readers digest maybe even eBay.not too sure about what's online internet being down so much over years the trying fix books instead letting computer do it's job
I remember reading Jane Eyre in high school, and the beginning of the book was so interesting and bleak. However, once Jane left the school and went to work in the Rochester house, it just got boring and annoying.
![A LOVE STORY I Jane Eyre and Mr. Rochester [ 2006 ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dwWqY3JX4F4/mqdefault.jpg)
![A LOVE STORY I Jane Eyre and Mr. Rochester [ 2006 ]](/img/tr.png)
I like this version because they show that she is well off and is beautifully dressed she doesn't need his money.She is also just the right mix of beautiful and plain. THe music is also wonderful.
I just love this scene for the vulnerability, humility and raw love that gets expressed…both such fine actors.
Mia Wasikowska is such a good actor.
The Toby Stevens/ Ruth Wilson one will always be my fav, but the musical score of this adaption is a masterpiece
My choice too. They got it right😊
In the book, she comes back and teases him until he stops sulking, rouses from his depression and rises to her challenge. This is decidedly a different vibe.
Yes, this version is quite disappointing.
I love this version. The book is ultimately the best version, of course, and will forever hold my heart, but there is something about the absolute deep, heartfelt joy and emotion in this scene that is just.. wonderful. To me, it is one of the most sincere, satisfying and beautifully done film endings
@@jorvikaengelskvinna7157 Glad I'm not the only one who found it irritating. Apart from anything else who goes up to a blind person and then just stands there in silence when they ask who's there?
@@jorvikaengelskvinna7157 the only real flaw - they somehow missed/skipped book`s most famous oneliner "Reader, I married him". The rest doesn`t matter - it`s screen adaptaion first of all
The musical score for this film is just beautiful..
One of my favorites. So romantic, tragic, beautiful.
it really is.
SOBBING THIS MOVIE SPEAKS DIRECTLY TO MY ROMANTICIST HEART...CHARLOTTE BRONTE WAS A GENIUS...THE SHEER POETRY OF HER WRITING IS INSURMOUNTABLE..
I've seen and enjoyed every version and I think that this one is my favorite.
Same!!
Michael Fassbender is awesome
No, he's not.
So many beautiful Jane Eyre movies and serials over the years, casting and chemistry ❤ - wish Persuasion had some of that
I love the 1997 version of Persuasion with Ciaran Hinds and Amanda Root.
@@mizjohsmy favourite too!
@@mizjohsabsolutely!
Perhaps you have never seen the 1995 adaptation of Persuasion with Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds? The full feature is currently free on TH-cam. I felt the same way as you until I stumbled on this wonderfully paired actors portrayal in the movie.
Love that dog have one just like it. Loving and loyal 🥰
What kind of breed is he? l want one.
According the story Rochester gets some of his sight back. He marries Jane and they have a family.
Yup, his sight comes back just in time to see the birth of their son. I wish they’d put that in there, it’s the best part
why are you spoiling
@@sofivardanyan3386It isn't a spoiler. It's just a tiny part of the whole. Simply a breathtakingly beautiful sentence.
@@hollyfischer1644 It's only been 177 years...
@@onawal931sofi is a little behind on the his reading list
I know this ending is abrupt and doesn’t reflect Brontë’s ending, but to me it’s a work of art and so well acted…. I have watched it over and over through the years. This is a wonderful version, even with the omission of so much of the novel.
I sooo loved their chemistry here. "Jane Eyre" was one of the first books I read as a young girl and I still can relate to her
I loved this movie but I still think Ruth Wilson's portrayal of Jane is the best one.
Samantha Morton for me. but Ms. Wassikowski does a very good job here.
@@davidhutchinson5233 Wassikowski did a wonderful job
My definitive favourite is the BBC's television series with Timothy Dalton and Zelah Clarke.
My least favourite is the Ruth Wilson version which, in my view, is poorly scripted and plays out like a soap opera.
For me, Mia Wassikowski's interpretation of Jane Eyre was, by far, the best I have ever seen.
Ruth wilson is an amazing actress!
The most complete and comprehensive and unchanged story was the one with Timothy Dalton. No change in dialogue or scenario. A perfect portrayal.
Agree; this was too short. There is so much more angst ridden dialogue in the book.
@@ac1646 The Timothy Dalton version is very likely my favourite version but it has the luxury of being a series that has much more time to include much more of the story. I do like this version, but if I'm honest I would still choose the Orsen Well and Joan Fontaine film ending over this one. It gives a better sense of the end of the story and their relationship.
The Timothy Dalton one would still have the number 1 spot though. The Toby Stephens one would run a very close 2nd I think. Not sure about the others.
I totally agree. Timothy Dalton embodied Mr. Rochester as written in the book.
Nevertheless, this scene is so poignant, so well acted. One example of what can actors of the highest caliber can accomplish. Notwithstanding the few liberties that version takes in the end, the scene fits perfectly the narrative which had gone so far. Given the time constraints - which the Dalton version didn't have as much being a series - this 21st century version nails it totally. I am moved to tears by that final scene, every time.
I wish this clip had continued to the dialogue where he doesn’t believe she could accept him in his current state. Jane has become more confident and teases him into believing. I first saw the Orson Welles/Joan Fontaine version and their images stuck with me. I see Rochester as dark and brooding and not a handsome man.
Also in the book he looks worse...I seem to remember that he loses a hand and an eye and the one that remains has limited vision.
@@graphosconcept3427 he is blind from the eye but recovers partial sight after two years
I’ve enjoyed all of the versions, but George C Scott will always be Mr. Rochester for me. Plus, the haunting John Williams soundtrack was classic.
I agree.
God no.
Same.❤❤❤❤❤❤
This is the best version I’ve seen and I’ve seen a few!
I love this movie to the point that I watched it twice for two consecutive nights. 😂It has that mysterious charms almost like a thriller because of the music and the scenes when there were weird things happening in Thornfield hall. It got an overall heavy vibe but I sure loved how Jane and Mr Rochester developed feelings for each other. ❤ the classics way
I love the one Timothy Dalton did
That one is my all-time favourite!
The trouble with all the adaptations is that Jane and Rochester are always good looking, in the book they are both unattractive.
@@jemmajames6719 mmm it's ok for me everyone who read the book can visualise them how they like
@@jemmajames6719 but Timothy Dalton was SO GOOD, I forgive him!!!
My whole life and all time favourite...
Can spend whole life to read n feel this creation...Jane Eyre..my own voice..
So many great versions but my favorite is with Samantha Morton and Ciaran Hinds.
Yes... and Welles' Rochester.
Both brilliant.
Yesss
Haven't seen that version, will have to!
I watched that version for the first time last night. It was sensational. It's the only one I know of which shows Rochester has lost the use of a hand, as well. That's part of the subtle and overt moral undercurrents throughout the book.
Rochester's "punishment" takes the "If your right eye causes you to stumble" and "If your right hand causes you to stumble" verse literally.
That can't be a coincidence. 🤔
Best wishes from Vermont 🍁
@@mortalclown3812I just finished watching it! The black and white cinematography and Bernard Herrmann's music are absolutely stunning.
Have a safe and interesting week 🍁
This movie literally changed my life
My favorite book growing up.
Never saw this version.
Best Jane Eyre
It’s also my favorite of the Jane Eyre movies.
Love all the versions.
I liked this version but to me the BBC adaptation with Ruth Wilson as Jane and Toby Stephens as Mr. Rochester is my favorite.
Man this version was so good. ❤
My favorite version is the one with Orsan Wells
Никто не сыграл лучше Тимоти Далтона и ЗИЛы Кларк, никто.
Amo esta novela!! ❤❤
Esse filme é muito lindo!!!!!! O meu preferido é com Joan Fontaine e Orson Welles❤❤❤❤❤
Timothy and Zila - the BEST!!!!!!
Magnifique interprétation !
The only flaw in this Jane Eyre version was pretending either Mia Wasikowska or Michael Fassbender are remotely ugly...😅
I get that they had to cut some of the book material because of film length BUT who made the insane decision to cut the ending of the novel which is the best part:
1. Rochester's disbelief that Jane is back
2. His jealousy of St.John and Jane actually TROLLING him about it omg
3. His regret and redeption which is so important to fully forgive him
4. The reveal of their supernatural bond
5. His second proposal and Jane again TROLLING him before saying yes
6. Their cuddling and flirting and happiness together
Idk I don't get how this is not worthy of being included. There were other scenes that could have been cut instead (like half of the Moorhouse parts, sorry). It's like they tried too much too be an arthouse film and were reluctant to show an actual happy romantic ending.
Moc krásné ❤
Está peli me encanta, es preciosa, no me cansaría de verla ...😍😍😍
michael fasbender is such a good actor
Fassbender
I red Jane Eyre many times as a teenager and this is my favorite version. Sure is short, is not 100% accurate, but it nails the tone and themes so well. Plus they're such great actors...Mia's Jane is my favorite for sure, Ruth Wilson seemed too flirty imo
Melhor filme de todos os tempos ❤❤
Лучшая экранизация, актриса потрясающая,
The novel always works better as a series. Trying to fit it into a two hour film means cutting out a lot - and deciding what there won't be time to tell.
Most versions cut down or cut out the St. John interlude. The Emily Mortimer version reduces the Lowood section to a few scenes - Helen dies almost as soon as she shows up.
My preference is for television versions which are able to show much more of the story.
That said, I just enjoyed the 1944 Joan Fontaine version which burns through the novel in 97 minutes; stunning black and white photography and a score by Bernard Herrmann.
Best wishes from Vermont 🍁
Closest to the book
The version with Jo Anne Whorley and Charles Nelson Riley was my favorite.
Film meraviglioso
I have this movie ❤
i like this one best !!
Лучшие Рочестер и Джейн Эйр-это Тимоти Далтон и Зила Кларк!!! ❤
Honestly, she's much to pretty for the role but she plays it so well that I forget.
Bellissima la.musica!
Penso che la geneire di zeffirelli sia un capolavoro perché rispetta esattamente il romanzo della bronte' .
Eu amei e ❤️ esse filme jane eyre
Que lindo ❤
A beautiful scene and adaption. However Orson Welles and Joan Fontaine will always be my favourites as they captured my young romantic heart after I had read Charlotte Bronte's wonderful novel.
Cómo se llama la película
Jane Eyre
Samantha Morton was really great too
Rochester lost an arm in the fire
I read the book once and I thought he faked blindness there. Maybe I misunderstood. Or that detail was changed in the movie.
In the book he is blind. After two years he see again from one eye.
@@TheArmstrong1969 thank you for clearing it up for me. I wasn't reading the book in English so maybe the translation was poor. And it seemed characteristic behavior for him, too, so I got confused after watching one of the movies.
Mi sueño eres tú💜
AM CITIT CARTEA IN VREMEA LICEULUI....EXCEPTIONALA.
А этот рыжый Рочестер, где у тебя шрамы после пожара? Ну конечно,эта чёртова классика
Estuviera bien si hicieran una 2 película ❤
Loved Toby Stephens and Ruth Wilson version better it's the best ❤
Далтон и Кларк эталонные. Вулкан и Эльф. Шарлотта Гейнсбур тоже хорошо справилась с ролью. Есть в её Джейн что-то от Жанны Дарк. И Теккерей сравнивал Шарлотту Бронте с этим историческим персонажем. Только вот гармоничного дуэта с Уильямом Хертом не случилось...
❤
Lackluster reunion compared to the book. Sorry!
If "Sad Beige" were a woman...
If you read the book, that’s literally one of her character traits. It’s about how she’s a passionate person on the inside and not just the sad beige young woman who overcame poverty and childhood trauma and neglect.
I love Jane Eyre but 'sad beige' is too funny lol
Is he still rich? Does he lose his money when his house burns down?
I think he's still rich. After all, he is a large landowner, and the lands have not gone away.
Это не моя Джейн Эйр,это хвалебная песнь тонкой талии героини вот и все
Did you version George c Scott only one has more of bertha Timothy Dalton version house is correct clothes even lady in attic are you aware most movies based on stretch book author made.thats what i mostly buy over years from readers digest maybe even eBay.not too sure about what's online internet being down so much over years the trying fix books instead letting computer do it's job
Something a little toooo ASMR about this scene. Bleh…
If you are not going to keep the language (substance) of the novel, then go and do something else.
ძაან კარგი კონვერსია მაგრამ ცუდად დამთავრდა ხუთივწუთი კიდევ რომ გარრხელებინათ რა იყო თითქოს ბოლო აქ მოგლეჯილი
No, bad director. These are the wrong lines, way too modern and not Victorian. Disappointing Mr Rochester and even Jane.
That scene alone was enough to convince me to never watch this movie version. Jane Eyre would never have kissed him in such an open setting (outside).
Jane Eyre doesn't exist.
It’s not Jane Austen, it’s not a London St.
The character. You know what the poster meant.
I remember reading Jane Eyre in high school, and the beginning of the book was so interesting and bleak. However, once Jane left the school and went to work in the Rochester house, it just got boring and annoying.
Terrible adaptation.
The dog in the book is described as a Landseer Newfoundland-seriously-movie people can’t read? Go figure!