Transgender Clinic Whistleblower Speaks Out
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- 💥Join us on our Journey to 1 Million Subscribers💥 Marcus Evans is a Psychoanalyst in private practice and formerly served as Consultant Psychotherapist and Associate Clinical Director of Adult and Adolescent Service at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust.
Join our exclusive community on Locals! triggernometry...
OR Support TRIGGERnometry Here:
Paypal: bit.ly/2Tnz8yq
www.subscribes...
/ triggerpod
Find TRIGGERnometry on Social Media:
/ triggerpod
/ triggerpod
/ triggerpod
About TRIGGERnometry:
Stand-up comedians Konstantin Kisin (@konstantinkisin) and Francis Foster (@francisjfoster) make sense of politics, economics, free speech, AI, drug policy and WW3 with the help of presidential advisors, renowned economists, award-winning journalists, controversial writers, leading scientists and notorious comedians.
Join our exclusive community on Locals!
triggernometry.locals.com/
OR Support TRIGGERnometry Here:
Paypal: bit.ly/2Tnz8yq
www.subscribestar.com/triggernometry
www.patreon.com/triggerpod
I wish to be a Vulcan, I know in deep my heart I am a Vulcan, Vulcans are admirable beings: calm and rational. I will deport myself calmly and rationally in the manner of Vulcans. I shall undergo surgery to have my ears adjusted to look more pointy. Outwardly I will look and act in all manners like a Vulcan. It would upset me greatly if someone said I was not a Vulcan.
Your videos are not loading. I seem to be seeing this on a more regular basis. Always on topics that will trigger the you-know-who's.
We have
We have to a couple days and I see it on a few nights at Christmas but it won’t let me know when I’m done and I’m going to go get back with my dad so I’ll get a good day for Christmas so we will be happy with that I have the kids in a little like a little and I’ll get together soon love Christmas to Christmas you guys love Christmas and I have Christmas presents and I’ll have Christmas with Christmas love this weekend hope your family will get better good here and I’ll see what I know when I’m going in and I’ll see if we have to a little and see what we are looking to have a Christmas party to do you want us out of Christmas tree in Christmas tree for you a big Christmas party and we will be here at all in this time we are all in love Christmas and we have to be there soon we have Christmas presents and I love the kids Christmas tree love this tree tree I have Christmas to my grandparents and my aunt I hope all of my kids love this place I have to
Vulcans are also humourless, so I’d say you fucking nailed it.
Mr. Evans and his wife are unbelievably principled and courageous to put their financial well-being at risk to protect children. It's frightening that their Facebook page and Twitter accounts discussing the evidence about this issue were taken down.
Although I want to be sympathetic to this guest, I am skeptical. He was not only a part of a government monolith . . . but a senior member in it for years. With good pay and status. Was that consistent with the concerns he is expressing . . . now that he is a victim of that monolith (?)
@@QED_ Very common these days :(
@@QED_ why do you feel it necessary to keep reposting the same comment?
@@sandrapertot6457 For the same reason YOU feel it "necessary" to post a comment at all: you want the person you post to . . . to see the comment. If that reason is the same for Person A as it is for Person B . . . how is Person A going to see it if you only post it to Person B (?) What can't you understand about that simple posting dynamic . . . (?)
Its cool to be diffrent apparently, your not sick your just diffrent and want to express your true self. Thats great but I belive you shouldn't be incourgeing a child to be a different gender . Some now are as young as 4 in the USA, I mean at least wait untill the child is 18 years old, I was a tom boy as a young girl, didn't want to be a boy or a lesbian, thank good all this wasn't about then. I belive the parents have a lot to do with it. Also the media. Its just not on. I'm not against people being what ever gender they want to e when they reach 18 years old, even then does an 18 year old really no there own mind , I didn't, I asked my 4 gron up kids that question and they all said no. Maybe the parents wanted the opposite gender child. Ffs maddness to me. Let kids be kids for as long as possiable.
He is a very brave man , I worked in the NHS and despite the PR bullshit , whistleblowers get no support and many end up leaving post because of bullying , The NHS has become a bureaucratic nightmare , HR are there to silence and bully staff, Everyone is scared to speak out , especially at the moment , This man is a true hero
Although I want to be sympathetic to this guest, I am skeptical. He was not only a part of a government monolith . . . but a senior member in it for years. With good pay and status. Was that consistent with the concerns he is expressing . . . now that he is a victim of that monolith (?)
This is why I oppose government-run healthcare in the US.
@@Attmay The same type of pressure exists on clinicians in private services, they must conform to the policies of the owners. Government healthcare may have its problems but at least it gives everyone access to affordable healthcare.
@@sandrapertot6457 gives = redistributes. The government has nothing to give away.
@@QED_ he's afraid of being lynched....the people are waking up......slowly.
"The political tail, wagging the clinical dog". Spot on.
The financial tail wagging the medical dog. It's the money involved for these reassignments that ride it. If there was no money, the trail would dribble out.
I feel as if having a transgender child is the new rescue dog. These parents I meet talk about it like it makes them superior because they recognized it very early and got child the help they need, but the connection with the child dosnt seem right. More like a wokeness trophy!
Munchhausen by Proxy seeing as this gentleman liked to hype up the Tavistock and Portman as being psychological experts and pioneers they seem to ALL be missing this obvious diagnosis.
@M T ooh random meaningless word games, love them...
Existence?
I totally agree
Ah yes, because gender dysphoria isn't actually a thing and people become trans because they want a trophy. As we all know, you can just walk right in and get hormones without any process whatsoever
@@otosolence4745 in Washington st. The schools are going to start doing it without parents knowledge! And in Oregon you can just say give them to me, it is that easy! I know at least 20 people personally who have transgender children rite now! All under the age of 13, slot of these kids I know well and in some cases I think it's the parent projecting their need to be relevant. These parents are using as a form of clout, bragging on Facebook. I'm in no way saying it's not a real thing I also have trans friends and most are in agreement with me!
As an autistic woman myself, I find it sad but not surprising that there's an overrepresentation of autistic people who come out as transgender. I wouldn't doubt anyones gender identity in person because I respect people as individuals, but overall in my opinion a big portion of these trans autistic people are likely simply just mistaken. There are SO many factors that can lead an autistic person (at least female, since that's where my perspective is from) to wrongfully assume they're trans.
For one we autists tend to have a pretty poor sense of self - which includes gender. Then there's the lack of social awareness and skills that makes us pretty non-conforming in general, paired with how we often see things "in black and white", which could easily express itself as "well I don't act and feel like a girl... so then I MUST be a boy". Or even seeing the typical super feminine, oversexualized instagram type of model and celebrity and thinking "well every other girl I know wants to be like that, and I don't. So I must be a boy". (Add that to massive amounts of anxiety + the normal teen angst everybody goes through). I've been there myself, I've had those thoughts. But I also had the support to realize that there is no "right" way to be a woman, and that me happening to like more stereotypical male things, and disliking the female sterotypes literally didn't matter at all - those are outside expectations that don't reflect me as a person at all. In my opinion, an individual being autistic is a massive red flag when it comes to being trans and should very thoroughly be looked into.
What also helps is to think about other cultures in the world. Because the fashion and typical appearance of women in various native tribes are very different from Instagram who*es with ugly overdone make-up. And women from native tribes are as much women as women from "civilized" world. Maybe they are even "truer" women because they live the natural way in harmony with nature. Forced oversexualization is just a thing in our culture but it´s not universal.
very insightful and thankyou for sharing this
So many clinicians are idiots. You'd think they'd understand everything you've said working in the field, but sadly, they're just as indoctrinated as so many other professions.
When did science become "going along with the status quo ideology."
Such an important comment. Thank you.
As a fellow autistic woman thank you for so eloquently putting how easy it is to fall for the trans option. I am very worried about what is happening to both my fellow lesbians as well as my fellow aspies. You left a very important and needed comment and I hope everyone reads it.
I love this man and his wife very very much. They have done so much to fight against this terrible stuff.
You're an absolute G yourself xx
Indeed Kellie you are also a very brave adult female.
If we ever get through this then it’s because of people like them and people like you Kellie-Jay.
Heroes of our time, all of you. ❤️
And we love them and you too!
There are increasing numbers of people detranstioning with regret about all they have lost, including loss of breasts, loss of fertlity - so what was missed in their assessments?
Common sense and enforcement of boundaries.
@@viviennedunbar3374 and perhaps true compassion.
You should see how many women regret breast enlargement, lip fillers and facelifts! We should stop them too right?
@@tleewright1 yeah because has you get older those become huge medical problems
but doctors can't make money if these surgeries go down
@@reynellfreeman8761 you think they dont get enough income from cis women surgeries? thats hilarious. Trans who actually opt for surgery is a tiny number. If they relied on that alone they would already be broke
These companies are taking advantage of those who have serious health complications already, mentally and physically
Seems to be the case to me too... Although my core beliefs says this whole institution should be shut down asap and some people from management should go to jail, but in the UK ... it's rather just a 'heavy topic' or an uncomfortable discussion. Which in an of itself is quite telling. I would still keep these services for adults, because hey, free will... But these stories with kids.. are blood boiling.
Read Jemnifer Bilek and her exposes on the pharma money behind this. In America it's estimated to be a 6 billion a year business fof these companies and growing.
@@jackiebiggs7071
Of course,this was logical.Medicine can't say this is scientific,because the medical books say the gender is determined by the dna.So is just a comercial trick.
For adults, I don’t think “free will” holds up. In some cultures there’s been fringe groups of men castrating themselves into eunuchs. That’s an example of people doing what they want to their OWN bodies. What we have instead is medical care providers profiting off of OTHER people’s bodies while providing no medical benefit to them. Actually it’s inducing physical health problems when there wasn’t any.
@Carrie Halliday to the end if profit. In the US thd pharmaceuticals for trans is now estimated to be worth 6billion dollars a year and growing.
I’m very old, so maybe out of touch, but when I was growing up there were lots of little boys who were very timid who grow up to be very masculine and lots of little girls who we used to call tomboys who grew up to be very feminine and in my lifetime we have grown to fully accept homosexuality when it appears in an individual - so why on earth is society embracing transgender ideology.
Iain Dennis - I was one of those tomboy little girls right upto 14 years of age and yes, I sure love being a woman - the people today are messing with kid's minds with the bs they practice now. I am so very thankful that I was born before all of this nonsense.
@@avrillee7369 thank you so much for replying, how very kind. We must, however difficult with our helicopter parenting, let our children grow up and be themselves at their various stages of development - social media does not help and the Tavistock needs closing down and its staff barred from working with children.
Trans is completely different from been a femine male or homosexuality. I'm trans and know since I was around 7 I'm nearly 50 now. I've not transitioned but my life has been completely destroyed by the dysphoria. All I want is to be able to be who I am and be accepted by society
Iain I have a nephew who used to dress up at a princess when he was 4. He's just signed up for the marines and is as 'man' as they come. You aren't old. Government is authorising life changing and often irreversible.decisions on children. Unconscionable. Of course if you (as in one) want gender reassignment as a legal adult that's your choice. But not before.
@@staceypark7408 I can’t imagine what you’ve had to go through and all I can hope is that you are treated with love and respect.
Of course being a tomboy etc is different from being trans, I think what the original poster was saying is that we should be waiting until the person is old enough to understand who they really are as well as the full implications, long term effects, etc of medical intervention.
What are your thoughts on age limits etc? You knew from a very young age but yet chose not to medically transition as an adult. May I ask why? I don’t have any personal experience in this regard so I’m genuinely curious!
You guys are the new main stream now as far as I am concerned. This is what real TV should be covering.
I agree.
from one Fisher to another Fisher
@@grahamfisher5436 great minds
They're absolutely fabulous aren't they? Why would anyone watch the BBC when you can watch these guys? That's why they want them shutdown. Get them on alt tech, they won't be around for much longer.
My Grandfather played a very important role in WW11 and it had a terrible effect on his life .
So
my name is Graham Fisher..
and I have put myself forward to be Vaccination test patient..
if by doing so helps others.. I step Up
@@grahamfisher5436 You can't inherit heroism unfortunately.
It takes a very brave person to blow the whistle on this subject, especially seeing what has happened to Dr David Bell. Thanks and I'm sure this is going to be a very good episode indeed
Who is he?
I think David Bell's disciplinary case has been dropped. Let's hope he now goes public, as well.
@@janeayres8772 oh that's interesting! Good news I hope, thanks!
Political ideology should not be allowed to interfere with a medical or psychological diagnosis and treatment, particularly when it comes to children.
@Cogsilen Flux totally agree. Facts and truth matter.
@sha la they can’t stop virtue signalling out of fear because liberal politics now is a 24/7 witch hunt
Indeed, the political and cultural norm that people with a certain set of genitals have to behave a certain way should not be pushed on our children.
For that to be the case then you'd need to have the NHS privatised. Until then medical diagnosis and treatment will continue to be used as a political football. Just in the same way as it is being used as a weapon against dissent over CV18+1.
@@1Three8Fiver how would that stop politics from medicine? You are aware that private businesses participate in politics right?
Great interview. This is why people try to shut down the discussion, because the dissenters can be so damned reasonable.
Although I want to be sympathetic to this guest, I am skeptical. He was not only a part of a government monolith . . . but a senior member in it for years. With good pay and status. Was that consistent with the concerns he is expressing . . . now that he is a victim of that monolith (?)
@@QED_ to me that makes the fact he’s speaking out now even more powerful, not less.
@@Uppernorwood976 That's fair.
because trans people control the media? the dissenters are amplified on dozens of youtube channels and have hundreds of thousands of subscribers and viewers. funny they spend so much of that time, like trump, claiming to be the victim of a non existent witch hunt, that they are being denied the right to speak. they seem reasonable because they only ever speak in safe spaces that allow their rhetoric to go unchallenged. that is propaganda framed as a conversation. anyone can be 'so damned reasonable' when they are unaccountable.
@@ginaritchie451 have you not seen any of the backlash JK Rowling has copped? Maya Forstater? Helen Watts? The head of British Doulas?
Francis and Konstantin must have some next-level jedi shxt against TH-cam censors otherwise they wouldn't try...
This is canary in the coal mine stuff.
I'd come back here and say told you so, but won't be able to. 100% they're on the chopping block.
@@SkeletonModel91 yup. Transevangelism has left a trail of shattered & abandoned individuals and families i its wake.
They normally ask pretty neutral questions (Am only 5mins in so maybe that's not the case)so that's probably where the lienience comes into it.
There are other youtubers who discuss this. They are safe. *But not for long.*
Never replied,, but as someone who knows psychology, this man has his eyes on the ball. One DOES NOT jump to conclusions, one DOES NOT just accept the "analysis" of the patient before hand. You always look at the surrounding complications, as you would in a solid argument, to fish out the true basis of the problem. Not being willing to do that is a problem on it's own merit on the part of those who bring that argument to the table.
th-cam.com/video/q3Ub65CwiRI/w-d-xo.html
Spot on
We live in a society that is looking for the “quick fix” ! Life is not that easy it is complicated and it’s a journey unto ones self
Unfortunately, this is the crazy world we live in.
Patrick, are you Dutch? Are you familiar with Stichting Voorzij? We are the only women's organisation advocating for a more careful approach to treating dysphoric children. We're also lobbying for keeping the word woman as' adult human female' in law. www.voorzij.nl
Isn't it a sad state of affairs in these comments that we think this is going to be banned purely because of the subject
The Federal Dept of Right Think will be paying this fellow a visit. He will be getting a 90 days all expenses paid vacation at one of their resorts and spas.
because videos get banned purely because of critiquing this subject.
Shut up. You tube is full of trans gender critiques! The movement against this is going well so just enjoy it. Conspiracy nobheads!
@@andsowot I don't see any movement against this going well. What fishtank are you living in? I only hear my supervisor's words for instance a couple of months ago, threatening me at work to stop talking about this to my colleagues ... see, that's really going well in lefty circles, companies for the commie piece of shxts.
Indeed it is.
Its called being a Tomboy, but I grew out of it. Thank God I had parents that didn't over react.
Yes, that plus school nowadays/children's social lives, being SO artificial and in their own little, cliquey world. A much less balanced ( in life, nature, outdoor work etc ). , & way more sexualized & " what's trending " environment too. Then, there's the modern diet and how vastly different even the "same" foods are compared to most of history by far ( milk & meat being raised on lots of 'cides, gmos & soybeans, in manurey feed lots & more ) to vaccines ( number of & what's in em) to the combo of all of that & so much more from body products to OTCs to less nutrition density & variety in the diet.
me too
Lol and I never did grow out of it- but yeah thank god my parents didn't overreact too.
It's not too late for you to transition. Let Tavistock set you up with some testosterone injections.
Exactly, me too! Imagine if they told you gender is a social construct. Most of the time it's because girls have an instinct that they like boys (or vice versa) before we understand sexual attraction, we notice boys are somehow just 'better', we grow out of it when we realise boys actually like girls :)
Konstantin, you asked why the dynamics of those who transitioned had changed in recent times to be girls rather than boys transitioning - girls easily succumb to social contagion - in my youth it was eating disorders - ideas like this spread amongst girls , then for the next generation it was self harm - this is a trend - a fashion if you will . We like to think we are so unique and special when we are a teenager - and currently transitioning is a great way to become very special and popular amongst your peer group. I think it will pass as most fashion trends do , but a sad situation for the girls who have and are being damaged by this trend , thank goodness people like Marcus are speaking out .
Thank you for interviewing him.
@DragonFox LOL, I was just going to write that. Thank goodness that was all I was offered, otherwise, as a Tomboy who prayed to be a boy when I was a kid, I'd be in trouble now.
At my very liberal high school there weren’t any kids identifying as trans, but within a year of going to college half my gay friends were identifying as trans, especially soft butch lesbians. I understood why because when I went to college and got in touch with the LGBT group, so many lesbians were transitioning that I was frequently assumed to be a trans man, people used male pronouns by default, and asked how long I had been on T when I hadn’t taken any.
I had walked in finally confident that I was a lesbian after years hanging onto the bi label thinking I was just a late bloomer for men (but not women) and feeling completely alienated from female-majority social groups and at ease in male-majority social groups and hated the pain and physical disadvantages of female biology that had no silver lining because pregnancy horrified me and my female body meant most women would not be interested no matter how in shape I am but the more fit I was the more men would want me and I wanted to be a nondescript blob to men as much as they were to me. The idea going around was “this is the new name for our experience. This is what we do now.” Not intentionally coercive, but as a matter of fact observation of the social norm. As more and more women who had spoken as proudly butch lesbians started testosterone, then even conventionally feminine women identifying as men, just being a plain ol’ lesbian made you the odd one out, and the more your peers adopt this new framework, you doubt more and more your own framework.
Some people just latch onto an incorrect explanation and switch to the correct one on exposure or greater reflection, as I did when I realized I had mislabeled myself as bi throughout my teenage years before accepting being lesbian. People are equally capable of latching onto multiple incorrect or ultimately unsatisfying explanations. But at least misidentifying your sexual orientation doesn’t restrict your adult sexual behavior in any way, as mis-identifying gender can lead to permanent sexual dysfunction when affirmation and a medical path are taken. If a teen identifying as gay meant that if they later realized they were bi or straight that as an adult they would have difficulty having fulfilling heterosexual sex (or vice versa with a gay kid identifying as straight), then I would strongly discourage that.
It's spreading more amongst girls than amongst boys not because girls are less resilient than boys, it's because there's less benefits in pretending to be a girl. Boys aren't convinced being a girl is all that great when being male clearly is an advantage. Eating disorders where widespread and still are, not because girls are impressionable, but because pressure to be thin is on girls and girls only. Regarding self-harm, this is very well documented, when boys are disturbed they tend to take it out on others, when girls are distributed, they tend to take it out on themselves. Bollocks to this idea that girls are more impressionable.
Girls specifically bond more with social trends. It's why bands and celebrities get so huge. Teenage girls have a MASSIVE economical social market because they're more likely to take up interests as a group.
@@redfoxonstilts Thank you for writing what I was about to. Look at the stupid image of feminity that is promoted to girls by popular culture (and by trans and drag queens): big boobs, lipstick, high heels, preciosity, compliance. Enough to want to transition in my opinion. We've gone a long way backwards since the 60s
For anyone contemplating medication: I was abused as a kid, have been psychologically tortured on acid and nearly drowned with my children watching from the beach amongst other odd things. Pills didn't help me get better, just layered a false acceptance over my daily routine. What truly helped me was cognitive therapy as it allowed me to rearrange my memories of those events from the perspective of an adult, and view them from a distance, literally rewriting my brains pathways to remove feelings of guilt into something much healthier - I was unlucky, and yes, things were really shit for a while, but most importantly, it really wasn't my fault.
Watching this made me cry, because so many kids are being messed up, and it's not their fault. Patience is paramount; don't jump towards a simple solution as your brain is not a simple thing.
Thanks KK&FF for your choice of guests.
I totally agree with you. I had a similar upbringing that I have poeticised. Thank God for good people out there that saved me from myself.
This is a frighteningly abusive prospect.....and it’s totally irreversible. This is definitely child abuse.
@@Wanamaker1946 just know God loves you and you are His child
It is a battle for your soul. Be strong in the Lord and the power of HIS might!
I really do feel like a minority as it seems the majority of trans comes from bad backgrounds and never mention gender dysphoria. I had an amazing childhood with both parents, at school I wanted to date the straight girls and boys that had a crush on me I thought was gay. Hitting puberty made me realize I have to do something about this. I got referred to Travistock in 2016 luckily enough they opened a service near me so I didn't have to travel there. Best thing I have ever done.
@@alexh6767 well I'm sorry to have to say this but please realize that people like you are the worst homophobes. There's nothing wrong with being gay.
Excellent interview on a very difficult topic. Well done all three of you. I am so relieved that my daughter's teens happened 10 years ago, completely devoid of this kind of pressure at school and in the wider world.
@Tony Amari mmm somebody needs a psychiatrist I think.
I have feeling it'll be something of the magnitude of the Rotherham Report...
@Carrie Halliday no it won't, I'd really like to think this will happen but the psychotic left will burn the books and the the people who write them and call them fascists...There is absolutely no rethinking, they act like the Germans in WW2 and their minds will reject any thought of doubt, wrongdoing or guilt. The left always gets a free pass for every genocide they commit. Remember the left controls schools and social as well as mainstream media. The world knows about Hitler's deeds but only few people know about the tens of millions dying in China or the Soviet Union, Cambodia, Korea, South America, Cuba... The list goes on and on and yet nobody sees the pattern...
@Carrie Halliday unfortunately at the rate the world is going it could be 200 years..
Or like the whole "repressed memory" molestation scandal of the 90s. Never happened, was debunked, but barely a peep.
@@ln1299 true I barely remember it but I was only a teen back then...
@@ln1299 The repressed memory molestation scandal? I’ve never heard about this. Not sure if I want to find out
God, he's right. The only other thing I would mention is the erasure of women as a sex which is perturbing and convoluted beyond belief.
th-cam.com/video/q3Ub65CwiRI/w-d-xo.html
@@chewcab8008 Please. Get. Help.
@@deecee5922 Brands of sanitary pads and tampons have gradually been dispensing of any reference to women, womanhood, the words “female” or “feminine”, or even the female symbol. We’re now “people with a cervix” or “people who menstruate”. There’s been campaigns for cervical cancer screenings which went down a similar route, but as yet I haven’t seen the same being done to men. Prostate cancer campaigns and erectile dysfunction adverts still target men. And the legal and societal implications of gender self-ID will not affect men anywhere near as much as women. We’ve already seen rates of sexual assault skyrocket in female prisons where trans women have been allowed to cohabit with female prisoners. The person who thought that was a good idea is either an idiot or a misogynistic sadist.
@@deecee5922 - The word Woman is not used anymore to describe us, since some men get triggered. We are now referred to a vagina havers, uterus havers, breeders, bleeders and birthing bodies.
Spot on hunny.
(to parahrase) "The push to shut down debate & rational discussion throughout every area of society" - that certainly sounds like the what's going on.
I will debate you. Most of y’all have garbage ideas anyways.
@@cubonefan3 "Most of ya'll have garbage ideas anyways."? I can see you're far too formidable a debater for me.
@@Cotictimmy He's what they call a "master-debater"
I have endometriosis, which is both a hormonal imbalance and a physical condition that requires hormone therapy and surgery (as well as pain controll).
I got cancer from the hormones I was pushed into taking without ever checking my hormone balance (birth control pills that were given to me without ever checking if I needed them or not, it turned out my hormones were too high already and years of more, synthetic hormones put me over the edge and gave me cancer. Not only that, but then I found out they could check my hormone levels just by a doing a simple blood-test that revealed I had to stop hormones and have chemotherapy. And they added “OH MY GOD, WHY DID YOU TAKE THESE HORMONES”?
Well, every doctor I went to pushed them on me to get rid of me. I had to fight for the surgery or to even be believed.
This is important because I needed the help because endometriosis is among the most painful chronic conditions in the world, but now they’re giving these hormones to healthy kids.... they don’t even have to prove anything like so many women in pain still have to in order to be taken seriously and be treated for endometriosis, but they’re now pushing hormones on more people just like that...
I can’t even find the words...
are you referring to lupron & similar?
I really hope you are doing ok now! I too have endometriosis and it's awful. Which drug were you given? Was it lupron in the US?
.
Wow so sorry this happened to you my friend has it and every 3/4 years needs surgery as it wraps round her bowel I only thought it effected the ovaries till she explained the only reason I can see for this push on hormones is financial incentives xx
I was diagnosed with endometriosis too, very painful, menstrual hemorrhage for many months, and was recommended opioid painkillers, and hormone therapy (contraception), and a simple drug for cramps and future surgery.
No way I took the hormones, I know contraceptives and synthetic hormones cause cancer, my sister's oncologist told her when she was 20 and had a breast tumor.
So no way I would take opioids you become easily addicted and affect your liver and kidney too like all meds, surgery no way, I am not jet in menopause and it could provoke it abruptly and my hormones go crazy, so I did take the cramp/Spam medication and Advil and pray like it was no tomorrow. And one day I heard a voice that said in Spanish: In Jesus I trust, right now (ya!). And my pain, bleeding stopped at that moment.
By the way my obgyn told me that he has had many women going through similar hell after covid vaccination. I was not Vaxxed thank God, but did spend a weekend with 2 receantly Vaxxed friends and days after hell broke for me.
Thanks FF & KK great interview. Big thanks to Marcus Evans and his wife for being so brave in speaking out. We salute you.
That's crazy
Brave man with a brave wife.
@Yuri Bezmenov: I want to agree with you. But may I be skeptical (?) This Man is rejecting what has become public policy in psychiatry . . . now that he is a victim of it. But do you have confidence that he equally questioned other such public policy . . . when he had no personal stake in it (?) I have no such confidence. In fact, I'd be willing to bet that he accepted conventional wisdom many times . . . to have ascended to the senior position that he did. His unsolicited, self-defensive remarks about believing in psychiatric drugs, for example . . . seem to me a red flag.
@@QED_ like a lot of people, he has probably been blissfully naive about where all this is coming from.
If you weren't aware of Gamergate, Evergreen, Bill C16 and Peterson, if you hadn't joined the dots and seen the Grievance Studies Papers with Boghosian, Pluckrose and Lindsay, you could be forgiven for thinking Mermaids were just a group of do gooders and it would have taken the shit hitting the fan to wake you up to all this.
As a trans woman I've been shocked to see how many social media influencers have encouraged transitioning. Gigi gorgeous who came out as a gay boy, then trans, then non binary human, then in a straight relationship, then in a lesbian relationship, then her partner decided to transition too. Gigi has approximately 5 million followers. Asifa lahore who was a gay boy who did drag and then transitioned to become female. Her best friend who lives with her decided to transition too. You also have prominent figures in the uk such as munroe bergdorf who thinks all this is normal ....ITS NOT.
I totally agree with you. I'm post-op i transitioned in my teens back in the 80s.
@@kelly-kx2io its crazy isn't it that our voices aren't heard. I do not agree with rose of dawn or blaire white who are pretty much very right wing in their beliefs. Admittedly Rose comes off quite well here but all her other videos on her channel she is awful. Blaire is possibly the worst person on socials but her name is brought up many times I wish there was a voice that represented me
@@Altaw33l There are a few older Post-op Transsexuals who have channels on youtube but guess what they do not talk about trans stuff at all they do not even disclose that they are. Which makes perfect sense to me. They had an issue fixed it and moved on with their lives. Not like today where folks decide they are trans on a Monday and are shouting it from every platform they can by the Friday. Doing the exact opposite of what we did all those years ago. For me its kind of counterproductive why broadcast such a personal issue. I only resurfaced after my partner died hoping to find a widows support group. but there was none and what i did find shocked me. How being trans as they call it is now trendy and the in thing to do. Support networks in place coaching each other on what to tell the psychiatrist's to beat the system. I have even witnessed it in action in chatroom and forum's. And as you say youtuber glorifying it too and turning it in to a money spinner with naïve gullible audience's with vulnerable minds soaking their every word like its gospel and applies to them. Its a sorry state of affaires. Whose gonna be around to pick the pieces up for those who fall in to the trap and wreck their lives ? It wont be the trans army as they reject and shoot down those who fall by the wayside or have differing opinions'.
@@kelly-kx2io People like you should be exposing this sort of thing more.
@@Altaw33l How about your own voice?
Thank you for speaking up about this. There are so many parents out there who are heartbroken for their teenage daughters who are painting their parents as transphobic and oppressive. We know there's more going on, and have felt extremely gas lit, estranged and psychologically abused by the so called professionals who should know better.
Not just professionals. In Canada, the state has stepped in to "protect children" and will take your child out of the home if you don't agree with their gender id.
Corporations aren’t interested in helping people, it’s always about the bottom line. In the 1950’s, corporations claimed smoking was not harmful. In the 1960’s and 70’’s , sugar filled breakfast cereals were part a healthy breakfast. Now these medical corporations are claiming that children are better off transitioning.
You're right, the business of business is business. It is YOUR responsibility to reject what corporations throw at you. You have that choice. You don't have that choice with government. They make the laws largely without your input or consent, and you are forced to follow them, however unjust or outrageous they are.
@@bobleglob162 Exactly, it's pretty easy to filter out the bullshit from the corporation's. In regards to the Government I guess the choice is through the ballot box. However people are just fucking stupid so we are always going to end up with laws we disagree with.
@J P: That's why, although I want to be sympathetic to this guest, I am skeptical. He was not only a part of a government monolith . . . but a senior member in it for years. At good pay and status. Was that consistent with the concerns he is expressing . . . now that he is a victim of that monolith (?)
And in the 1980s and 1990s they told us fat makes you fat, yet we got even fatter and it hasn't stopped yet.
@@QED_ Agreed, but anyone who comes forward no matter what against this abuse "cult" Im in and applaud, this must not go on,
History will look back on the transgender era as we look back on the height of East Germany and say “what the hell ?” .
I'd argue the parallels to a different portion of German history are more striking: that of the Weimar Republic
@@theaudiocrat I’d agree , especially the T4 program , while rhetoric is more modern and ‘sympathetic’ in tone the ideology is very similar .
@@theaudiocrat I would say the Nazi era with the amount of censorship there is.
Respectfully, in Wiemar there was the Magnus Hirschfeld Institut für Sexualwissenschaft (Institute for Sexuality Studies) which was doing "research" about the kinds of things discussed in the video above, and far worse, like doing adult things with children. And they were rather open about it. There was understandably popular revulsion at this, and the "institute" attempted to lend the veneer of academic legitimacy to it all. This was one of the reasons why the NSDAP gained grassroots support and was popularly elected in Germany. People were tired of the undermining and open mockery of their culture, morality and way of life, and weren't given a voice in the popular media
People are often shocked to learn there were fewer books banned under the NSDAP than books that were banned afterward. We need to learn from history (without prejudice) lest we become it
At least when we look at the history of East Germany we can grasp to understand what popping hormones like Gummibärchen can do to someone. There is a significant amount of health issues in the former East German athletes (especially in women) who got all sorts of hormones to make them win against their western counter parts (without their knowledge of course, as they were only given "vitamins"). Those women and even their children are heavily effected by this to this day.
Why can't I get Josef Mengele out of my head?
What an absolutely brilliant interview! Really great to hear a true expert’s view - who actually has a nuanced & humanistic approach. And fantastically sensitive questions from KK & FF. Thanks guys!
the children need to be sacrificed in the name of wokeism. the new socialism. and the lefties want their free money
I was very much a tomboy as a kids, I'm 25 now and very happy to be a woman. I feel so sorry for these kids with Alphabet Mafia Parents. I genuinely feel this will all fall apart as people realise how crazy it all is.
Alphabet Mafia, yah that is creepy and accurate
It’s starting to unravel
Sadly, transgenderism will leave generations behind who may be unable to work because of their poor physical and mental health conditions, and they won't be able to have biological children on their own. Think about the consequences of that.
Wait a few years when we see the physical and psychological dysfunction of the kids who transitioned. There is little data on the long-term effects of this.
Alphabet mafia parents. Brilliant! You nailed it!
i was what people called a tomboy, i played with the boys, did the things boys did, i loved being outside, but not once when i was younger did i want to be a boy. people like to stereotype, put certain activities the children do in a box, just because i was a little girl who liked playing outside and in the dirt doesn't mean i wanted to be a boy. now, i am an all natural woman who likes to turn wrenches🙂
And that's the thing. Being trans isn't about changing your identity because you're identifying with typical gender roles of the opposite sex you were born. Trans men/women can have interests, do things and style themselves that are more masculine or feminine too just like everyone else, but that doesn't make them any less valid.
@@laurastack4633 trans people literally identify with sexist stereotypes of the opposite sex, what are you talking about? Gender dysphoria is fueled by homophobia. I'm a lesbian myself and from the day I was born I was gender non-conforming, and society made pretty sure that that's not what is wanted. Being a homosexual who feels more comfortable fitting into the "mold" of the opposite sex also fuels gender dysphoria. That still doesn't mean you're born in the wrong body. Its society that homophobic and sexist. This whole trans ideology is just the new woke homophobia. Woman/man is not a feeling
This video will be taken down faster than I say 'brontosaurus'.
I doubt it. I think what has happened at Tavistock is coming out and nobody is going to like it except about 10% of the population. If this video was done five years ago, maybe.
@@Notallowed101 [ Google disagrees ]
I had the same thought... hope we’re wrong
@@Notallowed101 Unfortunately, what's acceptable to a UK audience isn't necessarily what TH-cam deems acceptable to a US audience and TH-cam (well, 'big tech' in general) seem to think they have the right to force US standards onto everybody else at the moment.
Why? for talking about something. It's not that bad here, is it?
Thank god that people are examining this more closely
Not enough people, our youth, esp in Universities, believe it's ok if you identify as a 6'9" Chinese woman when looking at the person they are a white 5'8" male. They say "it's okay if it makes you feel better." Then the interviewer says "well I'm going to identify as an (animal) is that okay with you?" Again they give the same answer they are taught in the Universities. Most of their bathrooms are open to everyone - there is no gender specific bathroom. Look on TH-cam and you will see people going around at Universities interviewing students and asking questions that get some of them stumped as to what to answer and then the next question leads on from there - in a logical sequence - and these kids just get stumped or give a pat answer because THEIR beliefs make no logical sense. Ask them what gender you are and they look at you like, "uh oh." I want to know what women and men would think if a woman took off her top on a hot day on campus - like guys do - when on a lunch break or studying under a tree an see what people say. The administration will intervene and make a dress code. They are damn hypocrites and they get themselves boxed into situations they struggle to find words or philosophies to get out of.
@@synergy2222 wtf. you are very wrong in so many ways. Anyone can tell you that gender exists. We are just trying to help people identify with the gender that they are meant to be. Or they could be gender fluid, non binary etc. It’s not that hard.
Schools are also playing a part too & colleges with all this too aswell as social media. It's such a serious issue and not to be taken so lightly which it seems to be by authorities too etc. To me it's a form of child abuse, kids aren't allowed to be kids, they're made to grow up way to quickly and such a worry.
Premiers at 7? Well that's unless the police get to him first 🤣.
Seriously though £100 on this whistleblower is getting arrested for "hate speech" in the near future.
You mean "wrong think"...
off to the gulag!
@@insomniacbritgaming1632 Aren't they almost the same thing? It's sad and a bit scary.
There is a nice boy who lives near me and plays with my kids. At 10 he decided to be a girl. 18 months after hearing this he has explained to my little girls he's taking medicine to be changed into a girl. He now has breasts and a distinctly feminine shape. Surely this can't be a legal thing to actually take a 10 year old to the doctors off the strength of the child's decision and to get hormones? It must be very difficult for people who feel their in the wrong body but surely the time for decisions with such gravity is not at 10
the children need to be sacrificed in the name of wokeism. the new socialism. and the lefties want their free money
Criminal he will get cancer for sure
X to doubt on the feminine shape. Probably just the clothes, at best some fat. If you dig up his skeleton in a hundred years, you will have skeleton of a young man with severe osteoporosis probably.
It's legal and they're doing it all over the US and it's extremely sad for these kids
Bet this gets blocked! Not on the list of permitted topics and may contravene the directed speech regulations!
th-cam.com/video/q3Ub65CwiRI/w-d-xo.html
Sensationalist comment.
Remember the naughties? The golden age of the internet. You could truly say the truth and it was okay.
its a private platform sweatie
(im not being serious, get a life)
@@BuJammy Well, that's why these private companies pay taxes, so that public investments can be made and infrastructures maintained... oh wait!
I read an interview that Keira Bell had in "womanspalceuk" and when she was asked "what do you think about this global push?" Keira responded "follow the money"....
Bang on. Big pharma for a start.
@@katiepert7746 I really dont think its coming from medicine. We know the people behind the push, the people forcing doctors to affirm all patients are the LGBT radicals. Political leaders and advocates in LGBT affairs, supported generally be the left.
@@tubester4567 Yes agree there's a massive ideological push and 'no debate' from various groups but a lot these groups are given big donations from people / associations linked to pharmaceutical companies. I would embed links if I had a clue how to! If you're interested have a Google.
@@katiepert7746 I dont buy it, trans people are a tiny minority of people. Theres a lot better ways for drug companies to make money than giving drugs to trans people.
@@tubester4567 true they are a tiny minority but if the trend continues and, as has been noted, there's been a huge increase in the last 5 years of girls transitioning, they'll be money to be made.
I read an interview with a GIDS 'doctor' who said that if a child is referred to them then to not start immediate treatment would be harmful to the child. He didn't seem to countenance that immediate, experimental treatment could also be harmful to a child.
You can tell this is a decent bloke trying to do the right thing. We need more the same
Although I want to be sympathetic to this guest, I am skeptical. He was not only a part of a government monolith . . . but a senior member in it for years. With good pay and status. Was that consistent with the concerns he is expressing . . . now that he is a victim of that monolith (?)
Well, most of us would suppose that (that he's a decent bloke trying to do the right thing) but the most obvious sign of the insane times we live in is that a massive proportion of the population are actually seeing his efforts as "evil" and "fascist". These days, I'm totally baffled by everything. Especially how willingly so many people abide by these new 'standards'.
Spot on, just what I said , very together man. We do need many more people like this. X
@@QED_ Why are you constantly posting the same comment? If people read the thread, they will have read it before.
@@johnneville403 I've already answered that TWICE in this thread . . . and you demonstrably haven't read EITHER. So you see . . . everyone (including you yourself) doesn't read (or could be expected to read) every comment. If you want to engage a person with a comment . . . you post to that person . . . regardless of what you've posted to anyone else. Why is that so difficult to understand (?)
Having only started researching this transgender phenomenon, I have variously heard this week the transgender issue as being described as a "cult", "a contagion" and "rabid". Quite frankly, given the miniscule size of the transgender population, I am completely shocked at the almost Orwellian grip it seems to possess over every last and little person throughout the civilised world, castigating all in its wake as, "transphobic". Absolutely shocking.
There’s an article in the _Spectator_ on a guide produced by the Dentons law firm for NGOs advancing their “transgender agenda.” You can also just look up the Dentons document itself. It advises pro-trans groups to avoid media coverage when they can help it, avoid public scrutiny, and focus on attaching their desired policies to larger, more popular measures.
In Canada and Australia, laws are being passed that ban “gay conversion therapy,” but in reality they punish therapists for even questioning a child’s belief that he or she is trans. Activists have equated one’s sexual orientation-which most agree is virtually impossible to change-with one’s “gender identity,” which no one can even adequately define and which the same activists also believe is fluid.
Like you, I remain shocked by the hold of this “movement” over society’s institutions. I think these tactics are part of the puzzle.
talking as a transgender person who does not subscribe to this ideological wave: it's the power of moral blackmailing. i suspect it's a two way perverse pact: i (minority) ask for what ive always wanted by weaponizing my (often true) historical status as a victim; on the other hand i (mainstream society) feel powerful by accepting my status as a tyrant (all rebellion is a form of worship) and in addition i get the chance to be both extremely powerful and extremely good, if i welcome their requests. minorities have the power to make the mainstream society feel like they are God. Must give quite a kick in times of cultural, environmental, political decay. But this is the weak point of moral blackmailing: you can make someone stronger than you feel guilty as long as they consent to it. Someday, and the day is getting closer, the majority will reach their limit of tolerance. Then there will be a backlash and it will go down hard. As a transgender person I'm very worried about the next decades.
@lightgrey I agree. As ethnic minority too I feel the same fear as you. I never had a negative experience in this country but fear backlash in coming years. And I've had it up to here with woke agendas 👿😠
@Chris, to my mind that shows that the ideology has sufficient political and financial backing to have so much control over over narrative. That should have shown us there was something amiss.... also I generally become suspicious when big corporates start talking fairness. Yeah, right.
@@lightgrey5365 I'm gay and in a similar vein, I don't subscribe to LGBT which is what I see as an organised religion that gets rammed down everyone's throats.
There is too much pressure on clinicians time due to limited resources to assess underlying psychiatric/developmental conditions. Departmental targets have to be met. In addition , as Marcus said, alot of these children come coached by the Internet and peers to answer questions correctly. Just my thoughts.
@Carrie Halliday I would be interested to hear what that is as I don't know.
This is just another form of conversion therapy - if these children still feel the same way when they are adults then sure they can make up their own minds and transition but there has to be some safeguarding. It would be irresponsible for medical professionals not to look at why the numbers have increased so dramatically.
It feels as though some adults are grooming these children to validate their own transitions.
It’s also a financial harvest.
They make opposing conversion therapy illegal.
There are many detransitioning videos are on TH-cam, all really young people that I have seen. Sad the damage done to their bodies.
what medical practitioner would support a child asking to have their eyes or legs removed
so why give them puberty blockers or surgery that will impact their lives forever
what is the difference
@@jeanhenly710 I completely agree it's like we are living in a real life horror movie.
Spot on
I wanted to be an astronaut when I was little, I wanted to be a doctor and then I wanted to be a dolphin...
Didn't mean my parents shot me into space or gave me a badge or even took me to get surgery to become a dolphin
...
Just saying
I wanted to be Dracula when I was 10 because I thought sleeping in a coffin sounded cozy. When I was 14 I wore my brothers' clothes and played baseball better than most teenage boys. Good thing my parents didn't enroll me into the Satanic church, or give me a mastectomy and testosterone. I'm a well adjusted woman and love being a wife and mother.
@@lynnv8501 wow uh I'm not too sure what to say about that...
I doubt that trams people are satanic...
Great Grammer by the way but it seems life philosophy has been poisoned by religion...
Best wishes to you
Gerald Broflovski wants to know your location
Are you stupid being a surgeon isnt a gender
@@taylormade9971 I'm not saying they are. But someone in the line of Dracula very well could be. You clearly missed the point.
There's gona be a lot of lawsuits in 15-20 years time for all the people who wrongly transitioned 🙈
Any doctor who is involved in this maiming of a child for life should be jailed for life.
I disagree. I'd be willing to bet most of these people simply wish to help those who are suffering, and have been misled into believing it's kind to tell those who are uncomfortable with their personal, biological, immutable reality as mammals that they can alter their sex at will. Which is a lie, but they don't really know that.
@@Epscylon whats funny is that all of the transphobes we transfolk unfortunately have to face literally all sound the same because all their knowledge probably came from before the internet at this point, it's pretty sad that these transphobes also get satisfaction from making us trans people feel worse because those transphobes probably, without a doubt, grew up as spoiled guttertrash children.
@@VortexKiller2 projecting much?
@@ww-nj2hm no just spittin facts
I think the big push-back will start when a critical mass of kids grow up, and start the wave of lawsuits.
Society and public discourse has become dominated by "feelings" and what people say they feel - spot on. In theory, yes, we should be able to talk and act (and make decisions) from the heart as well as the mind, as Marcus Evans rightly urges. The problem is that people increasingly take their "feelings" to be fact, and believe what they feel "is objective". So this also needs to be highlighted: how to enable people (children, teens and adults, whatever their age) to discern between feeling and critical thought.
Also schools never encourage kids to critically think anymore, it all comes down to the poor schools the Western World is sending their kids to for the last few decades.
The feminisation of our institutions.
People are talking a more and more childish view of the world instead of thinking like adults
People are becoming more naive than ever it seems I mean some actually believe healthcare can be "free" and I guess think that Doctors will be operating on patients out of the goodness of their hearts lol or that only whites can hate others for being a different color than them and so on and I think a lot of this trans stuff is population control,for some reason the global elite want to get rid of a bunch of us I guess to lower Co2? or they're just hateful PiecesOfS or ?
@@thegreenbikerider6189 Exactly! all the coddling and nannying of college kids the internet,speech,etc has gotten out of hand and since women are having less and less children of their own to raise/care for/nanny it's only going to get worse.I think the need to mother/nanny is inherent in women just look at all the cat ladies.I have a niece and she had a doll that she called her baby yet she was basically just a baby herself and she played with the doll in a totally different way than my nephews played with toys.Women need to start making or getting more kids of their own and minding theirs and their children's own damn business.Women trying to nanny/control grown men who they don't even know is not going to go well for them or society
This politicization of the NHS has been going on for some time, probably way longer than I suspect; I saw it back around 12 years ago where we had to do mandatory yearly training; the mandatory training was called 'Clinical Governance'. Part of the training included questions about staff/patient dynamics, and, not understanding what was going on at the time, it irked me that they were kind of telling you how you should feel about others' religious beliefs, sexual orientation, race, gender etc. What got on my nerves was the underlying implication that staff were potentially mistreating patients (consciously or unconsciously) based on those categorizations because of personal prejudices; but as far as I could see, staff around me treated patients pretty well and with dignity, irrespective of their 'labeled' identity. It just irritated me that the organization was implying that I might be treating other people less well because of their identity and that it was the NHS's job to tell me how I 'should' be thinking.
To me, they were trying to interfere with my whole moral framework, yet they were simply my employer and I was providing my services to them as an employee and that is where I felt it was supposed to end. It was one of the things that made me want to leave the NHS which I eventually did. But it is only in the last few years with all this focus on intersectionality that I now understand what was going on back then. I knew nothing about political ideals back then, but just on a purely personal basis, it felt as though they were overstepping the mark. It was almost like a religion with the pastor telling you what is right and wrong and why you must adhere to it; it felt so intrusive, like they were the arbiters of my value system. Serious alarm bell were ringing back then.
I worked in clinical governance for years...the topics for mandatory training are taken from the statutory training you are required by law to undergo e.g. health and safety...others are from the themes emerging from complaints investigations and incident investigations...these themes may well be different in your area than mine so topics may be slightly different for you...
tinymaths, i really hope you left the NHS. you sound like an unreformed and indignant bigot who lacks self awareness. the training was probably designed for people exactly like you. that is why it pressed your buttons.
It is a cult. Look at the response to your perfectly reasonable post from Gina Ritchie. A hate filled, aggressive and irrational response because you are challenging her desire for moral certitude and superiority.
acute observation, I think you've put it succinctly, they are attempting to dictate your 'belief systems' by mandatory training programs hoping that you will not realize exactly what the NHS is doing to you as well as others, re-training your moral framework to be more acceptable to the new wokeness, a bankrupt moral framework devoid of any absolute truth.
as a psychologist I say that no one should go through a 'sex change' process. It is a terrible, sadistic fraud
Horrific experimentation. Frankensteinesque
Only the unfortunate less than 1% of our entire population should be able to claim gender dysphoria because of a mutation...
I think there are a very small percentage that transition or surgical alteration is the best way to treat the dysphoria (or is it dysmorphia?). But the number should be small.
I’ve used this exact word - sadistic - to describe this trans ideology juggernaut.
Your profession disagrees with you.
I'm studying psychology with the goal of becoming a therapist, specifically for children and teens, im worried with my beliefs (that are similar to yours), that I won't get anywhere in the field nowadays.
hopefully therapy isnt about beliefs, nor the therapist's nor even the patients'. just ask questions the neutral way and each will find their truth when not judged
The Tavistock sounds like an out of control, multi-headed beast.
Absolutely they are, and were exposed long ago, by brave people like Bill Cooper (passed away more like they make him die), Fritz Springmiers works also exposing them, long ago,
This video will be lucky to survive the day
This bloke has well and truly got his head screwed right,
It makes such a refreshing change to hear someone discuss this subject with a large dose of common sense
the children need to be sacrificed in the name of wokeism. the new socialism. and the lefties want their free money
Looking forward to this. Always bringing interesting stuff. Keep up the good work. You're amazing hosts!
Large segments of our world are under the spell of a dogma.
Yeah like religious lunatics
yeah its "group think" it works especially well on people who feel they dont fit in.
We need an "unwoke consumers union"
Thank you so much for covering this.
All other arguments considered, this is deeply worrying, and even scary. Basically, big multinational media companies and drug companies are saying “you’re respectful, science-backed view is wrong- we don’t even care that you just want the best for these children”. It’s just so heartbreaking
It’s scary that when people try to research this issue they are attacked. When really we need lots of research to find the best ways to treat people
Thanks for this really interesting interview, and bravo to Marcus and his wife for standing up on this. I'm a member of the British Psychological Society and there is often a debate about whether psychologists should have the ability to prescribe medication in the way psychiatrists do. I hope it never happens because I've seen firsthand how parts of the psychological profession are politicised and subject to groupthink. It seems to me that GIDS was heavily politicised and deferred to the opinions of ideological lobby groups (often masquerading as charities) rather than following hard evidence. Extremely limited research with poor methodology was used to justify an ideology. It's no wonder psychology struggles to be seen as a science.
the children need to be sacrificed in the name of wokeism. the new socialism. and the lefties want their free money
I am going to say it in advance: This video didn't censor itself.
As a former student of psychoanalysis and Dr. David Bell at the Tavistock I found this fascinating. Thank you.
th-cam.com/video/q3Ub65CwiRI/w-d-xo.html
@@jglammi That's still psuedoscience no matter how many times you link it.
@Charlie Francis I already explained the severe methodological flaws in Blanchard's studies. Again, there's a reason his views were kicked out of the new DSM.
@Charlie Francis No, the reason is because the data is flawed, for the reasons I laid out and which you have been unable to address.
@Charlie Francis Well let's see. On the one hand we have clear methodological flaws that you can't explain away, and we have the considered weight of professional opinion. And on the other hand, we have an internet ranter who believes what he wants to believe because he wants to believe it. What a pickle.
Absolutely brilliant discussion
Thank you for covering this important topic. The trans industry is as bad as cigarette industry, marketing to kids in school curriculums. Very scary, and one day will come class action lawsuits.
Isn't it funny how lots of experts in the mind are coming out of the woodwork echoing the same sentiment?
Just expressing common sense!
This webcast is fantastic. Thank you
Great to give this man a voice. It feels very sinister in the lengths that some organizations will go to silence peoples concerns. I can only hope that people put an end to this child abuse and return to sanity. While expressing our personality through more than just a 'feeling'.
Gender disphoria can be very temporary thing! I had gender disphoria during my childhood and teenage years, but it didn't last. I can't imagine what would my life be like if I made a mistake and transitioned or if I did something with my hormones and later regreted... My life would be a living hell. Some autistic children have this temporary disphoria, people should be aware of that and don't let their children do something they could regret in the future!
I honestly think that a lot of what today is seen as gender dysphoria is nothing more than young people going through puberty. I'm not saying it does not exist but that many are misdiagnosed with it.
In so many cases it seems they don't take the proper time to look into what is going on with young people but just go with how they feel in this or that way and they get stamped as having gender dysphoria and boom there you go.
It's big business this stuff.
John's Hopkins has 40 years of research on this. 80% of children with disphoria grow to accept their birth gender as adults.
Anyone has 'dysphoria' about something on their body. And this trans craze is just the new version of anorexia, cutting, etc. Exacerbated by online grooming and unfortunately by the false association with the LGB community.
So, IF a child gets a sex change (say age 4-20) and later in life, as an adult, they realize it was a mistake or aren't able financially to keep taking the meds to keep their hormones in check, WHO takes care of their medical NEEDS? Who is going to be held Responsible for these Children having this done to them? I mean, IF a 4- say 20 year old is NOT allowed to smoke a cigarette or drink alcohol HOW are they being Allowed to make such a HUGE decision as CHANGING their SEX?!?! I BELIEVE in allowing the choice, I just DON'T BELIEVE CHILDREN should be allowed to make such a Literally LIFE CHANGING decision. My daughter use to dress her little brother in dresses and we had NO problem with that, but playing dress up is a FAR CRY DIFFERENT from a Parent WANTING a child of the opposite sex and encouraging that child to BELIEVE that they ARE the opposite sex. It's interesting how ALL of a SUDDEN we have ALL these Children "WANTING" sex change. And ALL of these movie "stars" ALL of a SUDDEN being homosexual and bisexual? I see it as ANOTHER FAD.
The fact that someone challenged the clinic in court is evidence enough that the methods of the clinic need to be reviewed and reformed. It’s incredible that this cannot be discussed openly in a mature manner.
as someone who experienced gender identity issues and who knew others who transitioned then wanted to go back or did go back ...and also seeing psychiatrists and therapists requiring many years of integration before transitioning, this current drive through / walk- in clinic style of practice appears to be about money and not healing and freedom to be you.
Fascinating interview, thank you Marcus
I can't wait until these kids grow up, realize they've been tricked, and start suing. I can see a battalion of lawyers marching up the ridge already!
Unfortunately that's not going to make up for what they've lost... It seems to me that there is an absolutely terrible, brutal weeding out of genes from the gene pool going on right now.
@@annaamalia9708 that's exactly what it is, nothing more, nothing less, unless we add population control just for kicks and giggles
I think the suicides will go trough the roof.This is just sick.
I've had the same thoughts when thinking about the ideological aspects of it.
But when I think of the actual humans, all those children that need to be sacrificed on this altar of political ideology, I am very sad.
Sure, we could just let it progress and wait for the blowback - but many will be victims and have their lived completely ruined.
A lot of those whom transition from female to male (especially between the ages of 16 - 19), end up detransitioning. And the body dysphoria is even worse then, as their voice is now deep and most often they have facial/body hair, both of which are said to be irreversible. Not to meantion, the results of top surgery. Personally, and thankfully, I don't know why people are so attached to their gender. I view my body as a vehicle in which to experience being alive. It has VERY LITTLE to do with who I am over all, or why I'm hear, which for all of us is a miracle in itself. When I was a kid, I kind of did wish I was a boy so I could experience peeing standing up. I got my butt spanked by my aunt for trying it anyway (at her house) and peeing all over the toilet...probably the floor too. No worries, I added padding under my pants 😄
Peeing standing up is overrated especially if you’re drunk (wet feet)
This is terrifying
Great interview - I love hearing Marcus Evans
A child or teenager “fixed in their views”
Color me shocked
(That’s sarcasm BTW)
This is in part a problem created by the lack of - rites of passage - rituals in our society
Absolutely.
@Benjamin Boyce explored this.
Also part of the problem of learning how to “be” from “instigram”
Absolutely. I believe that this is an interconnected problem with a western society that has no interest in producing healthy adults.
Interesting perspective
Can't drive or drink before 18. Yet you can have life changing drugs
Speaking as a trans person....I agree with this man.
Can I ask why you said trans person and not trans man / trans women? Thanks.
@@thegreenbikerider6189 because I'm trans and a person. Why does the specificity of my gender identity and presentation matter to my comment?
Hi Joanna, having skimmed the comments I think you may be the first trans person to comment on this video. Could you elaborate on why you agree with it? For what it is worth, I agreed with it in its entirety.
@@johntracey3502 Hi. The most salient point for me was regarding the notion of doubt. If there is no doubt in the trans persons' mind, they are probably making a mistake. This is something I was acutely aware of and battling before I transitioned and in cases where people have no doubt, or those around them have no doubt, there is likely to be a problem.
This goes much more for children. I don't have an specific age cut off in mind, but I do believe that there is a sliding scale of stupidity when it comes to the younger children being given blockers.
There are no longitudinal studies that support this treatment that I can see and while many trans people wished they didn't have to go through the hell of puberty retrospectively, it seems myopic to take this view prospectively, since there's no way the individual can know how they will feel once this starts.
I'm also very much against most trans activism, the victim mentality and the way certain notions have become doctrine within institutions.
Lastly, I'm not into self-ID - there should be very thorough vetting at a psychological and family level before a formal diagnoses and treatment should be given. In a limited sense, I'm a biological essentialist with a hypotheses about the aetiology of the condition, rather than a social constructionist, as in my youth.
As if puberty wasn’t tough enough we tell kids they can change gender
Ah yes, because children don't go through a process and can walk in and get hormones
@@otosolence4745 Yes, that was the point of the lawsuit and THEY LOST.
I’ve always felt that transitioning is the solution to a non-existent problem, or at the very least the most extreme solution to an easily solved problem. A bit like having your leg removed because you have an itchy foot. Surely if a young boy were to play with dolls the best thing to do is explain to him that traditionally these were seen as girls toys but nowadays children can play with whatever they want, what you should not do is question the child as to what gender they think they are and put them on puberty blockers! Besides which, how can a child truly feel what gender it is until their proper hormone levels kick in? Male children will eventually develop high levels of testosterone and female children will develop higher levels of oestrogen. The best thing to do in my eyes is marry up gender and sex to mean the same thing and if someone feels female merely state that they have a more traditionally female personality type. We need to stop using sledgehammers to crack nuts.
That's so utterly dumb it hurts to read.
@@alexnorth3393 your membership of the flat Earth society is waiting for you. If you don’t like logic, science and common sense, then you might want to educate yourself and cut back on the soy products.
@@richardcharlwood9997 Science is not on your side. You have no idea what you're talking about. But continue with your little fragile soy nonsense.
Re playing with dolls. My Uncle as a child only wanted to play with my mums dolls, pram etc. This was way back in 1940’s. He grew up married and had 10 kids. He was a lovely engaged dad.
I didnt like dolls or girly things when I was a little girl. I wanted to wear a cowboy outfit and play football and do woodwork. I was a tomboy until about 12. I didn't like dresses until I was about 14 but I didn't like anything frilly. This trans agenda is being pushed unceasingly and it is mucking childrens minds up.
Thank you for being brave, all three of you. It’s so reassuring to hear sanity
When people make these arguments against this happening it's out of love and care and not out of hate. The fact they say that is so wrong, I feel this way out of love
Just gonna watch this insightful, interesting long form discussion before it gets taken down for ‘wrongthink’. Sorry, I mean ‘violating community guidelines’.
Download it!
Yawn
That was a great interview. I think I am going to rewatch it later and take notes!
Negotiation with the external world - beautiful
Speechcrime has been detected. Safety and compliance teams are en route.
Despite NHS doctors constantly telling me pills werent the answer (that's anti-depressants, not cyanide), all the help they actually offered in 4 years was pills. What's scary is that I recently reached maximum dose and started to have side effects, including the development of breast tissue (despite being male). This is because, it turns out, one of the anti-depressants contains the hormone prolactin that encourages the development of breast tissue in woman during puberty. Now, this is an anti-depressant that is approved to be given to kids over the age of 7. Imagine how that would fudge with your body. And, most trans people are on anti-depressants too... of course not all contain the same stuff, but from my research and experience they DO all have suppressive effects on sexual development and drive. It is also not healthy for girls to receive an unnatural dose of these hormones, especially before they've matured. I wouldn't be surprised if the seemingly rather dispensing of these drugs is having a wide reaching, unintended consequence for people.
I think you are hitting a major point. Even in the US too many doctors and counselors want to shove a pill or pills at you. Not saying all meds are bad, but that should never be the first go to option.
th-cam.com/video/q3Ub65CwiRI/w-d-xo.html
I remember I went to a GP because I was stressed about exams and developed insomnia. I just needed a couple of sleeping pills so I can have a night's sleep before my few exams. He prescribed me a full course of antidepressants. For being worried about exams.
Sorry, it is not possible to change the gender.
It is only cosmic surgery.
It’s hormones which changes more than appearance, sane trans people know they are not biologically changing their sex, it’s more of trying to feel as comfortable with yourself as possible. Please don’t look at the crazy left and think “ah yes all trans people are like that” it’s not true.
as a psychologist let me say that we cannot change our sex
But we can align the mind and body to the extent that medical science currently allows.
Lol trans people know that
Experimental and kids in the same sentence makes me nauseous
Thanks for this fascinating and important conversation, gents.
Ta very muchly. ☝️😎
What a great guy to speak up and out like this, thank goodness kids have people like this gent who aren’t ideologically captured still looking out for their interests. The biggest gift you can give a child is to let them be themselves WITHOUT impacting the future they can’t yet imagine let alone foresee.
Right on hunny. X
Another fascinating show, chaps. In my view, I may not agree with some points made by your interviewees, but I always want to hear what their views are so that I can be better-informed. I want that freedom of choice and I don’t want some faceless entity in big-tech censoring certain views while blatantly allowing violence, hatred and bullying to be sent by others. I’m an adult and I want to be treated as one - not as some weak-minded politically-pliable simpleton. Thanks for having such interesting guests with such diversity of experience & opinions.
You are one hell of a courageous man. Kudos