i just hope that they will not disband after their 10th anniv. it breaks my heart if that happened .. what i mean is that what ever they do individually in the future i just hope that mamamoo will be intact as mamamoo 😓
Today RBW announced Wheein has not renewed her contract but will stay in Mamamoo activities till December 2023 under a mutual agreement. You should watch a live performance of this song.
AND IT WAS WHEEIN AND HWASA WHO SANG AT THE END TOO! Like I'm sure every Moomoo's who had time to watch their guestings and interviews know about Wheein and Hwasa's journey as childhood bestfriends who had the same dream of being a kpop artists, whom auditioned together in Seoul, far away from their families, and luckily both became part of Mamamoo. Like, damn that hit hard. That was the most tearjerking part for me, next was the last chorus where Hwasa belted without musical support.
I'm glad you enjoyed it! these girls make me want to slide off my chair almost every time i listen to them. Just becomes a giant fan-girl blob on the ground really.
@@jvoxfox i'm like one of the biggest moos out there and seeing you genuinely fangirl over mamamoo is just amazing haha also the quality of your reaction videos are 💯 ☺
As always, you have now been infected like so many of thier world wide fans. You are now one of us. You did so well with this video. Please keep this up with Mamamoo.
FYI just in case you haven't found out yet.... Wheein decided to not extend her contract with her label RBW entertainment😭😭😭... But she had agreement with RBW to keep participating in Mamamoo's activity as a member until December 2023
I've heard that as well. I'm deeply saddened but not entirely surprised Wheein chose not to re-sign. The kpop lifestyle hasn't always been easy for her as she's known to have stress & anxiety issues.
Wait what, what's the difference between a contract and an agreement to participate? I hope they continue as Mamamoo for ten years, even if only a few months a year one can do amazing things, right? And have all the time left for solo stuff, a social live and kids maybe?
@@teambellavsteamalice when they say contract they usually mean an exclusive contract. From what I understand about this situation is that Wheein would still participate in group activities (and it sounds like there is a written document which imo means we can expect MAMAMOO content and not a long hiatus. When this agreement comes to an end in 2023, this agreement would be up for renegotiation - a lot of people seem to think this means she will leave, but it's not like once groups resign they are signed forever) - the same constraints to a group's activities should still apply like member scheduling. Wheein, however, is free to sign with another agency for her solo activities, so wherever she decides to go and what she wants to do, she could be more active or less active - but for sure the future will cater more towards her musical preference and her overall image as an artist, celebrity, individual.
Years later, this still makes me get tears. When it first dropped I was SO SCARED this was going to be their goodbye song because of the timing; I HATE goodbyes so it made me get tears. Thinking about everything they went through to stay together as a group makes me get tears. Thinking about how close they HAD to become in order to stick together (even during times when they were PISSED OFF at each other, maybe even hated each other for a minute), just so they could carry that entire fledgling company...nobody in the Entertainment Industry has worked any harder than these four ladies. That makes me get tears. They bonded over that sort of hard work. They did it all together. They became family to each other. That makes me get tears. This song is just SO LOADED. And it was a ballad. Damn. So all of that put together, I still cry watching the original and watching reactions to it. I am re-visiting your reaction here just because you are so open about your love and respect for them as PEOPLE, not just as artists.
Always a pleasure watching your analysis and fangirling! Thank you for this reaction. I recommend checking out their Mdromeda Band Live version of Where Are We Now. It's probably my favorite version of the song, it's just too beautiful. They also did a Band Live of their debut song, Mr. Ambiguous. Definitely a must-see after today's news 🥺
This might sound odd, but the fact that Wheein and Hwasa have been best friends and truly love each other since middle school really stands out as there being true good in the world for me.
Not that odd. I feel the same. Their continued friendship is great but that has been done before, we hear about life-long friends many times. But life-long friends who managed to get in the same group together? I don't know anybody else who has done that. If I find out it has been done before, that still won't make their relationship any less special. :)
"Do whatever you want, I will buy it." Exactly! In Korean music industry they established themselves as vocal powerhouses so early in their career that it just became a fact, that we will get what we expect of Mamamoo: quality, harmonies, musical excellence, emotional connection. And when they won their first round of promotionals against other K-pop groups - without any dancing, no lively, excitable grooves - it is testament to their power!
Julia! Thank you for reacting to Mamamoo again, while I don't understand vocal technicalities I really enjoy watching you break it all down! Not since Sesame st have I being entertained while also learning 😅
Julia, thanks for reacting to this. I always look forward to your Mamamoo reactions because it’s really nice to have someone who has a really good ear musically! You hear stuff that other reactors don’t notice and I love it when you point out those things. 👏🏼 Regarding Wheein / Mamamoo resigning with RBW - Hwasa, Solar and Byul’s renewed contract will most probably end by 2023 as well, but they can all still continue as “Mamamoo”. After 2023 they can renegotiate with RBW (together with Wheein too) and they can resign once more or continue on another agency and still promote as a group. We can’t tell for now if they will want to continue as a group after 2023 but I hope they do. If not, I’m positive their friendship will continue on forever and their music will always be in our hearts ❤️
Really like ur videos! Not just bcs u are a fellow mamamoo fan but also bcs u clearly explains the technicality in singing. I who do not have any vocal trainings can understand it and appreciate singing more! Keep it up! I love how u break down each members technicals. Its like im watching nba sportscasters, singing version hahaha
They all sound beautiful individually but together they are more than the some of their parts. Thanks Julia without you I may never have heard it. Hi to the fans and it is very cold in Brisbane tonight.
This is probably my favorite Mamamoo song so far. They are busy pushing it so performing live frequently. I think I have watched every live version of this that is on youtube 😊
Say Julia, just wanted to drop you a line and say that I thoroughly enjoy your content. You have one of the most pleasant voices on YT and every video you drop is a pleasure to watch. Much success, From an American
MAMAMOO 4EVER They are legend, they are talented, they are our life. Whatever their decision later after 2023, we will always stand for them and cherish them, as oong as they all happy, we also happy.
Thanks for your reaction! WAWN is a great song, but because it's a ballad it didn't get as much attention as it deserves. At least you can recognize how good it is and appreciate the vocal performance.
I wonder if because Egotistic, Gogobebe and Hip were so big that the Korean market weren't prepared for a ballad again. It's strange because they have had some big selling ballads - Starry Night was a huge hit (it and Decolcamanie are their biggest selling songs)
Mamamoo vocals are on a whole different level and they never fail to just blow me away, absolute queens. Speaking of queens, if you haven't heard it yet, you should absolutely check out Ailees killing voice performance and I'd love to see you react to dreamcatcher too. Especially Boca and Scream as well as Siyeons solo song Paradise. Love your breakdowns :)
Loved your reaction Julia! Mamamoo are so amazinggg in this comeback. In regards to Hwasa's voice in Killing Voice that you mentioned, there is indeed some vocal backtrack that layers the girl's voices at certain points that caused "strangeness" you noticed. This is the norm in Kpop (though Mamamoo are obviously able to sing without it!), all groups that sing "live" (which are very few....) use backtrack to layer their vocals and create harmonies although sometimes it's so loud that it obscures their voices entirely. At that point are they even singing live? Anyway, compared to other groups, Mamamoo does this sparingly and in this new comeback, there is none at all! I hope you check out their live performance of this song, its fantastic!
Julia my heart is broken and I'm crying right now watching your reaction. But at the same time i feel honored and privileged to have known them. I hope we all get to spend time with them in the few years they have as a group. Btw, you look as beautiful as ever...😊
I would love to see you analyze Moonbyul’s vocals in detail like you do the other three by reacting to some of her solo tracks! I would love to hear your thoughts on Absence and Snow in particular :D Thank you for the emotional and super informative reaction!
I enjoy watching ur reactions. Your breaking down the entire song was wonderful. Most of all I come to see your reaction videos for one main purpose. To see your smile. Most beautiful smile. Makes ma bad day good again.
I love how you appreciate Moonbyul's voice! I'm new to your channel but if you didn't know yet, she was originally a vocalist, however, they needed a main rapper in the group so she trained to become a rapper! She is an AMAZING artist
this song made me cry so many times cuz of their voices, the lyrics, everything... Its about their path. And today hits harder. However im not sad about the news, i was mentally prepared long time ago. I want the best for them and i respect and cherish all their personal decisions. I love them and im glad that i get to know about them back in 2017. Forever moomoo
the music industry will have a lack in a bunch of matters without mamamoo... idk what the hell im going to listen to after mamamoo... well, i guess mmm discography on repeat
Hi Julia, I love your reaction so much balancing technicality and sensuality, analyzing and appreciating the nice work of the four gorgeous ladies. You, Rahim, Sygneh, Katriinka are the four reactors I love most. Thanks again.
Fun recording note from the latest MMMTV episode was that in the ending harmony, Hwasa recorded hers first and made the phrasing choices on the final Where Are We Now. This was planned or discussed before hand, so when Wheein recorded her vocals she joked about how she had to try and match her, guessing when Hwasa was going to say we now after the pause.
Their live vocals for this song is even better than the studio version, like the case all the time. I SUGGEST YOU SEE THOSE LIVE PERFORMANCES. Many more live vocal harmonies. The Yoo Hee Yeol and the It's Live performances are the most impressive ones, I mean all the others are impressive on their own, but those are the higher tier ones.
Greetings from Brazil Julia 🤝 it's also winter where I live and mamamoo makes me shiver as well 🥰 i love your analysis, it's so deep and well detailed.
Another wonderful ballad they've done is "Meeting" on Immortal Songs 2. Moonbyul has a significant singing part at the beginning too. It's a real piece of ear candy.
4:58 you need to watch her solos, especially the ones she sings more like Absence and Ddu Ddu Ddu or her Trying to Say Goodbye cover. Her voice is beautiful! The start of her singing in mamamoo songs was in Paint Me, if you want to watch too (such a beautiful song) 💜
Please check out some of Moonbyul's solo work! She has an incredible belt in her cover of 서툰 이별을 하려해 (just searching for covers by her works! She had done a lot of beautiful covers) and her solo album (Dark side of the moon) has a ton of really amazing songs that let her express her vocals more freely. I think you'd have a blast especially watching her MVs, she's so creative and expressive with her singing and dancing :) To name a few of my fav songs from her - A miracle 3days ago, ILJIDO, Eclipse, Absence, Weird Day (w/Punch), The Lady (w/Bumkey) I hope you'll check out her work and enjoy it!
Actually, all of four of them will have another decision to make about the same time. The others may have renewed with RBW but their renewal is 2-3 yrs. The only difference with Wheein is her solo stuff will no longer be with RBW. Let's hope all four of them will remain together as a group while still doing their solo stuff, be it with RBW or with a different company after Dec 2023
Please react to their Star Wind Flower Sun.. If you want to hear Moonbyul singing and harmonizing with Wheein ..and if you want to get emotional too 😆 over these tiny girls ...
Julia, please check out Moonbyuls Second World performances and you will see our androgynous baby really shine. You will be as proud of her as the rest of us all are. Thanks
I always liked Mamamoo since I first heard of them last year but think I’m turning into a fan now. Might end up a Moo Moo ....Thanks for this reaction. I also like Mr Ambiguous and keen to learn more of their songs. Have you heard House of Cards by BTS? There’s a live in concert version with eng subs. It’s one of my favourites. Also BTS Tiny Desk performance and Fix You cover (original Cold Play). Subscribed 😉
![HONEST REACTION to [MV] 마마무 (MAMAMOO) - Where Are We Now](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mqzkp0FL1A8/mqdefault.jpg)
We have 2.5 more years of these wonderful vocal performers. I for one... got really emotional listening to this piece.
me too!! wish I knew about them a little sooner
Hahaha 2.5 more wonderful eargasms! They are just insane!
I love the positivety!!
Welcome to the radish farm to become a Moomoo!
i just hope that they will not disband after their 10th anniv. it breaks my heart if that happened .. what i mean is that what ever they do individually in the future i just hope that mamamoo will be intact as mamamoo 😓
The way you love these girls is adorable.
i cannot control it anymore
@@jvoxfox Yes, let your MooMoo run free.
When you're surprised and at the same time not surprised with their vocals.
Today RBW announced Wheein has not renewed her contract but will stay in Mamamoo activities till December 2023 under a mutual agreement. You should watch a live performance of this song.
The last line "The two of us shared the same dream, where are we now" hits different now that wheein didn't extend her contract...
i didn't realize that and now i'm depressed
Every time I see this comment, it hits me like new again
Yes, spot on. Wheein bailing out just simply stated......IT SUCKS!!!
Same dreams but different paths...
AND IT WAS WHEEIN AND HWASA WHO SANG AT THE END TOO! Like I'm sure every Moomoo's who had time to watch their guestings and interviews know about Wheein and Hwasa's journey as childhood bestfriends who had the same dream of being a kpop artists, whom auditioned together in Seoul, far away from their families, and luckily both became part of Mamamoo. Like, damn that hit hard. That was the most tearjerking part for me, next was the last chorus where Hwasa belted without musical support.
Okay this is officially THE BEST REACTION VIDEO ON WHERE ARE WE NOW 😌
I'm glad you enjoyed it! these girls make me want to slide off my chair almost every time i listen to them. Just becomes a giant fan-girl blob on the ground really.
@@jvoxfox i'm like one of the biggest moos out there and seeing you genuinely fangirl over mamamoo is just amazing haha also the quality of your reaction videos are 💯 ☺
@@jvoxfox pls notice, your fan from ph here.
As always, you have now been infected like so many of thier world wide fans. You are now one of us. You did so well with this video. Please keep this up with Mamamoo.
FYI just in case you haven't found out yet.... Wheein decided to not extend her contract with her label RBW entertainment😭😭😭... But she had agreement with RBW to keep participating in Mamamoo's activity as a member until December 2023
Nooo... Wheein 😭😭
I've heard that as well. I'm deeply saddened but not entirely surprised Wheein chose not to re-sign. The kpop lifestyle hasn't always been easy for her as she's known to have stress & anxiety issues.
Wait what, what's the difference between a contract and an agreement to participate?
I hope they continue as Mamamoo for ten years, even if only a few months a year one can do amazing things, right? And have all the time left for solo stuff, a social live and kids maybe?
@@teambellavsteamalice when they say contract they usually mean an exclusive contract. From what I understand about this situation is that Wheein would still participate in group activities (and it sounds like there is a written document which imo means we can expect MAMAMOO content and not a long hiatus. When this agreement comes to an end in 2023, this agreement would be up for renegotiation - a lot of people seem to think this means she will leave, but it's not like once groups resign they are signed forever) - the same constraints to a group's activities should still apply like member scheduling. Wheein, however, is free to sign with another agency for her solo activities, so wherever she decides to go and what she wants to do, she could be more active or less active - but for sure the future will cater more towards her musical preference and her overall image as an artist, celebrity, individual.
Exactly 😭😭😭 i keep on being emotional thinking what if this is their last song together 😭😭😭 where are you now wheein 😭😭😭
Years later, this still makes me get tears.
When it first dropped I was SO SCARED this was going to be their goodbye song because of the timing; I HATE goodbyes so it made me get tears.
Thinking about everything they went through to stay together as a group makes me get tears.
Thinking about how close they HAD to become in order to stick together (even during times when they were PISSED OFF at each other, maybe even hated each other for a minute), just so they could carry that entire fledgling company...nobody in the Entertainment Industry has worked any harder than these four ladies. That makes me get tears.
They bonded over that sort of hard work. They did it all together. They became family to each other. That makes me get tears.
This song is just SO LOADED. And it was a ballad. Damn.
So all of that put together, I still cry watching the original and watching reactions to it.
I am re-visiting your reaction here just because you are so open about your love and respect for them as PEOPLE, not just as artists.
The song is amazing but the las harmony between Hwasa and Whee in is absolutely my favourite part, just blew my mind
tbh i've been waiting for your reaction even before the album release
That's awesome! Let's see if we can get the moomoos together for the premiere :D
ditto
My first thought upon hearing this: Wow! Will this blow Julia's mind as it did mine? The goose bumps come in waves. Can't wait!
Always a pleasure watching your analysis and fangirling! Thank you for this reaction. I recommend checking out their Mdromeda Band Live version of Where Are We Now. It's probably my favorite version of the song, it's just too beautiful. They also did a Band Live of their debut song, Mr. Ambiguous. Definitely a must-see after today's news 🥺
This might sound odd, but the fact that Wheein and Hwasa have been best friends and truly love each other since middle school really stands out as there being true good in the world for me.
Not that odd. I feel the same. Their continued friendship is great but that has been done before, we hear about life-long friends many times. But life-long friends who managed to get in the same group together? I don't know anybody else who has done that. If I find out it has been done before, that still won't make their relationship any less special. :)
I think this is my favorite song of theirs. Thank you for your comments as always.
Where Are We Now? Here, fangirling together with Julia 😂❤️❤️❤️ Always love your Mamamoo reactions. Thanks Julia ❤️❤️❤️
"Do whatever you want, I will buy it." Exactly!
In Korean music industry they established themselves as vocal powerhouses so early in their career that it just became a fact, that we will get what we expect of Mamamoo: quality, harmonies, musical excellence, emotional connection. And when they won their first round of promotionals against other K-pop groups - without any dancing, no lively, excitable grooves - it is testament to their power!
Yeeeeah def going to Korea to watch them live hopefully somewhere in between these next 2.5 years T-T
Here I am again, over two years, where has the time gone?
Julia! Thank you for reacting to Mamamoo again, while I don't understand vocal technicalities I really enjoy watching you break it all down! Not since Sesame st have I being entertained while also learning 😅
I love it when really talented vocalists gets the attention they deserve.
Julia, thanks for reacting to this. I always look forward to your Mamamoo reactions because it’s really nice to have someone who has a really good ear musically! You hear stuff that other reactors don’t notice and I love it when you point out those things. 👏🏼
Regarding Wheein / Mamamoo resigning with RBW - Hwasa, Solar and Byul’s renewed contract will most probably end by 2023 as well, but they can all still continue as “Mamamoo”. After 2023 they can renegotiate with RBW (together with Wheein too) and they can resign once more or continue on another agency and still promote as a group. We can’t tell for now if they will want to continue as a group after 2023 but I hope they do. If not, I’m positive their friendship will continue on forever and their music will always be in our hearts ❤️
I cannot be happier that they broke the 7 year "curse"- that doesn't happen often 😭
Really like ur videos! Not just bcs u are a fellow mamamoo fan but also bcs u clearly explains the technicality in singing. I who do not have any vocal trainings can understand it and appreciate singing more! Keep it up! I love how u break down each members technicals. Its like im watching nba sportscasters, singing version hahaha
i'm glad you're enjoying the videos! :) thanks for leaving such a lovely comment.
Their voices always kills me......😭😭 Idk why am I crying 💜💜💜
it's ok... you are not alone with the tears. this song also makes me want to cry.
They all sound beautiful individually but together they are more than the some of their parts.
Thanks Julia without you I may never have heard it.
Hi to the fans and it is very cold in Brisbane tonight.
Dang i was hoping you'll react to this and you are!! I'll be back for the premiere ^^
See you there!
MAMAMOO is still 4 till '23.
Let's support them even when
they are 3. Let's SUPPORT our
puppy too. Let's love them.
This is probably my favorite Mamamoo song so far. They are busy pushing it so performing live frequently. I think I have watched every live version of this that is on youtube 😊
Say Julia, just wanted to drop you a line and say that I thoroughly enjoy your content. You have one of the most pleasant voices on YT and every video you drop is a pleasure to watch.
Much success,
From an American
Finally!!! I was waiting this alert so much...
MAMAMOO 4EVER
They are legend, they are talented, they are our life.
Whatever their decision later after 2023, we will always stand for them and cherish them, as oong as they all happy, we also happy.
YUPPPPP EVERYONE SAY THANK YOU JULIA
So keen to share this with all the moomoos
I'm in love with Wheein's floaty voice and harmonies
MOONBYUL's Absence is a very good song, and she sings really well, listen to it.
ooh.. yesss
Yes! And she wrote the song after watching a Kdrama! I love the lyrics, her absolute beautiful voice, and the whole MV.
Thanks for your reaction! WAWN is a great song, but because it's a ballad it didn't get as much attention as it deserves. At least you can recognize how good it is and appreciate the vocal performance.
I wonder if because Egotistic, Gogobebe and Hip were so big that the Korean market weren't prepared for a ballad again. It's strange because they have had some big selling ballads - Starry Night was a huge hit (it and Decolcamanie are their biggest selling songs)
The ending is the cutest thing, they finally got the ice cream from Dinga Dinga
WAW icecream cone shot reminds me of Wind Flower McD icecream cone shot. This one looks happier and more light-hearted. ❤️
I was waiting for your reaction!! Thank you!!
This song means so much more now 😭 my heart, my feels. I wish I joined the Fandom earlier 😔😪
Mamamoo vocals are on a whole different level and they never fail to just blow me away, absolute queens. Speaking of queens, if you haven't heard it yet, you should absolutely check out Ailees killing voice performance and I'd love to see you react to dreamcatcher too. Especially Boca and Scream as well as Siyeons solo song Paradise. Love your breakdowns :)
Omg yes, Dreamcatcher vocals are no joke tho, and best of all: they do rock
yesss.. Dreamcatcher 🥰
Loved your reaction Julia! Mamamoo are so amazinggg in this comeback. In regards to Hwasa's voice in Killing Voice that you mentioned, there is indeed some vocal backtrack that layers the girl's voices at certain points that caused "strangeness" you noticed. This is the norm in Kpop (though Mamamoo are obviously able to sing without it!), all groups that sing "live" (which are very few....) use backtrack to layer their vocals and create harmonies although sometimes it's so loud that it obscures their voices entirely. At that point are they even singing live? Anyway, compared to other groups, Mamamoo does this sparingly and in this new comeback, there is none at all! I hope you check out their live performance of this song, its fantastic!
Julia my heart is broken and I'm crying right now watching your reaction. But at the same time i feel honored and privileged to have known them. I hope we all get to spend time with them in the few years they have as a group. Btw, you look as beautiful as ever...😊
Perfectionist they are....
I would love to see you analyze Moonbyul’s vocals in detail like you do the other three by reacting to some of her solo tracks!
I would love to hear your thoughts on Absence and Snow in particular :D
Thank you for the emotional and super informative reaction!
aaaaaa finally! :D
can't wait for this reaction!
me too! see you at the premiere! :D
I have been waiting for you to post this. I love Mamamoo and this song.
Thank you Julia.. Was waiting for this badly.. Always love your reaction
Finally 🥰 thankyou ..
More about Mamamoo please ❤️
I feel so blessed that Mamamoo is finally coming to the US to tour. I have tickets for "My Con". This could be my only opportunity to see them live.
i really like your reactions and your analytics and your tips on vocals!!! thanks Julia❤❤
I enjoy watching ur reactions. Your breaking down the entire song was wonderful. Most of all I come to see your reaction videos for one main purpose. To see your smile. Most beautiful smile. Makes ma bad day good again.
I love how you appreciate Moonbyul's voice! I'm new to your channel but if you didn't know yet, she was originally a vocalist, however, they needed a main rapper in the group so she trained to become a rapper! She is an AMAZING artist
favourite youtube vocal coach
thank you so much julia for supporting them❤️ i really really really enjoy all of your mamamoo reactions🥰
Your reaction was well worth waiting for, Julia. Beautiful analysis of this beautiful ballad.
I rlly love your reacts, I learn while i have fun and btw everytime I hear waw I have goosebumps, this song is wonderful.
Yess....was waiting for this
this song made me cry so many times cuz of their voices, the lyrics, everything... Its about their path.
And today hits harder. However im not sad about the news, i was mentally prepared long time ago. I want the best for them and i respect and cherish all their personal decisions. I love them and im glad that i get to know about them back in 2017. Forever moomoo
the music industry will have a lack in a bunch of matters without mamamoo... idk what the hell im going to listen to after mamamoo... well, i guess mmm discography on repeat
Your reactions are good.
Mamamoo sing very emotionally.
Every time I hear this song I cry… not normal cry BUT UGLU CRY AND I DONT KNOW WHY…. AM I THE ONLY ONE ????
Hi Julia, I love your reaction so much balancing technicality and sensuality, analyzing and appreciating the nice work of the four gorgeous ladies. You, Rahim, Sygneh, Katriinka are the four reactors I love most. Thanks again.
I really love your reaction, even it is 2 years later. Thanks
Thank you, as always, Julia! as a moo I'm in tears again bcoz of how beautiful this song arrangement is and how adorable the ladies are.
Oi, I ABSOTIVELY LOVE Mamamoo way too much and COMPLETELY fine with it....🔥👑🔥👑🔥👑🔥👑
Fun recording note from the latest MMMTV episode was that in the ending harmony, Hwasa recorded hers first and made the phrasing choices on the final Where Are We Now. This was planned or discussed before hand, so when Wheein recorded her vocals she joked about how she had to try and match her, guessing when Hwasa was going to say we now after the pause.
Mamamoo really do be hitting different. Where are we now MV touched my heart. First time i cried because of a mv✌️i adore them
the lyrics that wheein and hwasa sing at the end always get my in the feels because of their 10+ years of friendship pursing their dream together
Waw!!!! Loved your reactions
lucky for you, they have TONS of live performances of this already 😂 would love to see your reaction to that ☺️
Their live vocals for this song is even better than the studio version, like the case all the time. I SUGGEST YOU SEE THOSE LIVE PERFORMANCES. Many more live vocal harmonies. The Yoo Hee Yeol and the It's Live performances are the most impressive ones, I mean all the others are impressive on their own, but those are the higher tier ones.
Greetings from Brazil Julia 🤝 it's also winter where I live and mamamoo makes me shiver as well 🥰 i love your analysis, it's so deep and well detailed.
I love theem so much! Hope they come to brazil again 🇧🇷
Julia, I was waiting for your reaction.. Thank you very much!
Stunning as always Julia
Wow really enjoyed this technical musical analysis!!
I truly love your reactions, keep up the great work 💪
Yes!! Been waiting for this reaction!!
Been waiting for this yass
Another wonderful ballad they've done is "Meeting" on Immortal Songs 2. Moonbyul has a significant singing part at the beginning too. It's a real piece of ear candy.
Yesssss!!! It's so cool to see people becoming moomoos, I love to see you fangirling, so cute hahaha I hope you can react to their solo stuff too ☺️
I just absolutely love your mamamoo reactions 🥺
4:58 you need to watch her solos, especially the ones she sings more like Absence and Ddu Ddu Ddu or her Trying to Say Goodbye cover. Her voice is beautiful! The start of her singing in mamamoo songs was in Paint Me, if you want to watch too (such a beautiful song) 💜
Please check out some of Moonbyul's solo work! She has an incredible belt in her cover of 서툰 이별을 하려해 (just searching for covers by her works! She had done a lot of beautiful covers) and her solo album (Dark side of the moon) has a ton of really amazing songs that let her express her vocals more freely. I think you'd have a blast especially watching her MVs, she's so creative and expressive with her singing and dancing :)
To name a few of my fav songs from her - A miracle 3days ago, ILJIDO, Eclipse, Absence, Weird Day (w/Punch), The Lady (w/Bumkey)
I hope you'll check out her work and enjoy it!
Its sad wheein will leaves Mamamoo soon at the end 2023 so lets appreciate them as long as they are together.
Actually, all of four of them will have another decision to make about the same time. The others may have renewed with RBW but their renewal is 2-3 yrs. The only difference with Wheein is her solo stuff will no longer be with RBW. Let's hope all four of them will remain together as a group while still doing their solo stuff, be it with RBW or with a different company after Dec 2023
Thank you for this!! I love your reactions so much
Please react to their Star Wind Flower Sun.. If you want to hear Moonbyul singing and harmonizing with Wheein ..and if you want to get emotional too 😆 over these tiny girls ...
So excited for this! 😊
Mamamoo our queens 💟💞💫💗
i love Mamamoo and Where are we now but i only wanted to say that you're really pretty :) ^^
Adults who always complain about K-pop not having a mature concept hey MAMAMOO is here for you. 😊
It's always something special to see your smile and joy you keep pouring out in your vids..... ❤️❤️❤️
You being adorkable because our mamamoo is one so moomoos become too.
Omg love your reactions to Mamamoo 💖💖
Your reactions always are so special🥰🥺thanks for educate us in music ♡
You need to react to their live version for this. Breathtaking
Julia, please check out Moonbyuls Second World performances and you will see our androgynous baby really shine. You will be as proud of her as the rest of us all are. Thanks
So ready for this reaction 🤩
Yay for melting but also a shout out for the wine corck tip. Thanks 😃
They have a live performance of this. Can’t wait to see you react! ❤️
I always liked Mamamoo since I first heard of them last year but think I’m turning into a fan now. Might end up a Moo Moo ....Thanks for this reaction. I also like Mr Ambiguous and keen to learn more of their songs. Have you heard House of Cards by BTS? There’s a live in concert version with eng subs. It’s one of my favourites. Also BTS Tiny Desk performance and Fix You cover (original Cold Play). Subscribed 😉