I don't know if I can blame Huaisang. The guy just isn't confrontational. This doesn't devalue his feelings. I'm still sad that while he had the potential to break the ongoing cycle of revenge, he instead became a contributor by using those closest to him.
This captured my entire feelings for huaisang. As much as i love this boy to pieces, knowing he had to resort to underhanded methods that toes the line of the morally dubious at best in order to reach his objective just like guangyao did, the cause of his pain in the first place, hurts my soul. Albeit the difference between them is that huaisang isn’t as cruel or power-hungry as JGY though NHS can be just as ruthless when he is pushed to the edge. And that’s exactly what happened. Guess in the end there’s no other way to truly beat a mastermind other than outsmarting them in their own game.
I would say that the difference between Huaisang and Guangyao is that, first H trusted LZ and WY. He trusted their experience, and determination and sense of Justice. He trusted they would not leave the mystery unsolved, that they would find justice for his brother. He also seemed to try to minimize the damage that would be done to bystanders, inasmuch that he could while avoiding suspicion from G. (Concerning Yi City, I need to revisit the arc to see how much of hand H had in luring the Juniors there). I also think that if Xichen were to confront H about the deception, H would have pointed out everything he missed, the consequences of Xichen's different ways to deal with the revelations, then go about his day. Mean while, G didn't trust Xichen. The actions he took from to avoid the downfall that he orchestrated for WY. The hurts he caused where out of injured pride and fear. Everything he said at the Temple that was aimed at Xichen seemed to be placations, as if everything could be excused if Xichen wasn't affected.
@@lettuce5201 A true neutral who sought to fix the injustice done to those he cared about. He did some good, some bad. He tried to follow the law and when the law failed he resorted to chaos.
It makes me sad he became this way, but he couldnt help but learn from those around him. He saw hpw WeiWuxian was treated despite his justful ways, saw his brother die, saw how the manipulator came out on top😢😢
Honestly I remember back when I first encountered the series (I only watched the drama/animated back then, just started the novel) and was quick to misjudge Huaisang's character for someone who was lazy and didn't want to put in the effort to be a cultivator. It was only when the truth came out why he refused to pick up a Saber and the fact that he lost his brother did I begin to better understand him. It's not easy to be forced into a singular path when you wish for freedom and choice to live your life the way you want it to. Granted, responsibility and honor is important as well as loyalty to ones land and Clan, but to force someone to wield a weapon that over time will make you go insane and die in a brutal death. Honestly I could understand Huaisang's fear and hesitation, as well as having passion for something that isn't just involved with war and bloodshed (I love art just as much and honestly if that boy wants to paint fans, let him do it!). It's never easy to be different and to fall into conflict with family, and while I understand Mingjue's morals, forcing his younger brother and belittling him for having a different perspective only caused the rift to grow larger. I also couldn't fault Hauisang for his mastermind plan, because no matter what, Mingjue was his brother and he wanted justice for the murder. It's honestly such a messy and tragic situation and I feel sorry for the Nie family.
I don’t think I’ve ever seen a Nie Bros animatic before, and even though I didn’t expect it, this was really good! Lovely animatic! Huaisang’s look at the end tho 0.0
Everybody says Nie Huaisang did everything only for the revenge but no, I don't think so. He did want revenge for his brothers death, but he also knew that if someone didn't stop Jin Guangyao, whatever happened to his brother would happen to a lot more people and well, with those two motives combined, I don't only not blame him, I praise him for his secret coup d'etat!!!
Oh my god. Just. Oh my god this was so good. Right out of the gate I had tears because the song fits the Nies so well and the art is excellent. Great job on an instant favorite!
My poor heaaaart!!!! I'm mush when it's about these two, I love Huaisang so much, poor baby turned into something his brother might have hated, all because he loved his brother so much. And this, oh my god, this is a beautiful punch in the soul.
this is actually so amazing,,, the line about putting youth in a casket fits so well... after that day he couldnt be free and young again,,,, also I love the ending, fatal journey my fav underrated movie
Don't mind me just gonna go cry in a corner cause OH MY LORD MY FEELS! Huaisang feels like the definition of "He did what he had to do" . He's not a very confrontational person but he knew who was behind what happened and needed some way to bring it to light. And while the methods were far from ideal he did what he had to do to bring it all to light, and honestly I think the way he did it might've been the only way he Could do it. He's not confrontational and Guangyao is charismatic and good with deception. He proved multiple times that he could talk his way out of just about every problem he faced. I really don't think Huaisang would've been able to get any justice if he hadn't taken the route he did with bringing Wangxian into it. The two really are a power couple each with their own respective strong suits that fit perfectly for task. The whole series is people having to cope with countless poor situations in the best way they can and a lot of good people died and a lot of bad ones did too, on top of the random npc's who just got dragged into this mess. He did what we had to do, and ultimately it worked for the greater benefit of several people who got answers to unasked questions, resolutions to unsolved problems, and a chance at redemption and a happy life. He did what he felt he had to do and boy did he win in the end. Or at least as much as you can win when your brother's still dead.
Aaaaaa this is so gooooood, the Nie Brothers really do something to my heart and you captured so much of that here, and then the switch in the end from the literal death of Nie Mingjue to the metaphoric fall from heroism that Nie Huaisang sees in Jin Guangyao - aaaaahhh!!!!! That's so good!!!!!!
Oh my goodness that was so so so good!! Your lines are so pretty btw like yes. I love the Nie brothers so much, i think they might be my favourite characters in the novel so I was very excited to see Huisang!! Thank you so much this looks so good!!
this is so well done!! you really nailed huaisang and nmj's expressions and emotions, this song fits them so well!! that bow at the end... WOW. this is amazing!!
There was a book. It said something that describes him well. If one has the power to kill everyone, I don't see why they don't use it to kill their enemies if they can. While I all those who don't have power will just make plans.
I EXPECTED THIS TO BE ABOUT WWX AND PREPARED MYSELF TO CRY
AND THEN I WAS SUCKER-PUNCHED IN THE GUTS
SAME 😭
I don't know if I can blame Huaisang. The guy just isn't confrontational. This doesn't devalue his feelings. I'm still sad that while he had the potential to break the ongoing cycle of revenge, he instead became a contributor by using those closest to him.
This captured my entire feelings for huaisang. As much as i love this boy to pieces, knowing he had to resort to underhanded methods that toes the line of the morally dubious at best in order to reach his objective just like guangyao did, the cause of his pain in the first place, hurts my soul. Albeit the difference between them is that huaisang isn’t as cruel or power-hungry as JGY though NHS can be just as ruthless when he is pushed to the edge. And that’s exactly what happened. Guess in the end there’s no other way to truly beat a mastermind other than outsmarting them in their own game.
I would say that the difference between Huaisang and Guangyao is that, first H trusted LZ and WY. He trusted their experience, and determination and sense of Justice. He trusted they would not leave the mystery unsolved, that they would find justice for his brother. He also seemed to try to minimize the damage that would be done to bystanders, inasmuch that he could while avoiding suspicion from G. (Concerning Yi City, I need to revisit the arc to see how much of hand H had in luring the Juniors there). I also think that if Xichen were to confront H about the deception, H would have pointed out everything he missed, the consequences of Xichen's different ways to deal with the revelations, then go about his day. Mean while, G didn't trust Xichen. The actions he took from to avoid the downfall that he orchestrated for WY. The hurts he caused where out of injured pride and fear. Everything he said at the Temple that was aimed at Xichen seemed to be placations, as if everything could be excused if Xichen wasn't affected.
I will meaningfully contribute to this conversation by saying that he's something between lawful good and chaotic neutral
@@lettuce5201 A true neutral who sought to fix the injustice done to those he cared about. He did some good, some bad. He tried to follow the law and when the law failed he resorted to chaos.
@@shavagreycastle About the Yi City arc: He's the one that led the juniors on a path of animal murders to Yi City.
Huaisang and Mingjue both look so young here, they didn't deserve what happened 😭 This is a really nice animatic!!
It makes me sad he became this way, but he couldnt help but learn from those around him. He saw hpw WeiWuxian was treated despite his justful ways, saw his brother die, saw how the manipulator came out on top😢😢
Honestly I remember back when I first encountered the series (I only watched the drama/animated back then, just started the novel) and was quick to misjudge Huaisang's character for someone who was lazy and didn't want to put in the effort to be a cultivator. It was only when the truth came out why he refused to pick up a Saber and the fact that he lost his brother did I begin to better understand him. It's not easy to be forced into a singular path when you wish for freedom and choice to live your life the way you want it to. Granted, responsibility and honor is important as well as loyalty to ones land and Clan, but to force someone to wield a weapon that over time will make you go insane and die in a brutal death. Honestly I could understand Huaisang's fear and hesitation, as well as having passion for something that isn't just involved with war and bloodshed (I love art just as much and honestly if that boy wants to paint fans, let him do it!). It's never easy to be different and to fall into conflict with family, and while I understand Mingjue's morals, forcing his younger brother and belittling him for having a different perspective only caused the rift to grow larger. I also couldn't fault Hauisang for his mastermind plan, because no matter what, Mingjue was his brother and he wanted justice for the murder. It's honestly such a messy and tragic situation and I feel sorry for the Nie family.
I don’t think I’ve ever seen a Nie Bros animatic before, and even though I didn’t expect it, this was really good! Lovely animatic!
Huaisang’s look at the end tho 0.0
He has that "will construct a decade long plan to kill you and destroy all youve worked for while reviving my dead friend" kind of look 😂
@@icedkappe248 We got a WWX outta it so I'm just gonna *pretend not to see it *
Everybody says Nie Huaisang did everything only for the revenge but no, I don't think so. He did want revenge for his brothers death, but he also knew that if someone didn't stop Jin Guangyao, whatever happened to his brother would happen to a lot more people and well, with those two motives combined, I don't only not blame him, I praise him for his secret coup d'etat!!!
Oh my god. Just. Oh my god this was so good. Right out of the gate I had tears because the song fits the Nies so well and the art is excellent. Great job on an instant favorite!
thank u! 🥺 I knew i had to make this when i first heard the song ughh 😭
My poor heaaaart!!!! I'm mush when it's about these two, I love Huaisang so much, poor baby turned into something his brother might have hated, all because he loved his brother so much. And this, oh my god, this is a beautiful punch in the soul.
This is so sad.. Nie Mingjue really was the best brother..
My mind can’t compute from being mesmerized by this animatic and sobbing hysterically.. this is so good but so sad!! 😭😭
Glad i could convey my feelings of pain 🤣🤣
this is actually so amazing,,, the line about putting youth in a casket fits so well... after that day he couldnt be free and young again,,,,
also I love the ending, fatal journey my fav underrated movie
the young Nie brothers scenes 😭🥰😭🥰😭🥰😭 and oh, baby Nie Huaisang seeing what his brother went through 😭😭😭 this was so good!!!
Don't mind me just gonna go cry in a corner cause OH MY LORD MY FEELS! Huaisang feels like the definition of "He did what he had to do" . He's not a very confrontational person but he knew who was behind what happened and needed some way to bring it to light. And while the methods were far from ideal he did what he had to do to bring it all to light, and honestly I think the way he did it might've been the only way he Could do it. He's not confrontational and Guangyao is charismatic and good with deception. He proved multiple times that he could talk his way out of just about every problem he faced. I really don't think Huaisang would've been able to get any justice if he hadn't taken the route he did with bringing Wangxian into it. The two really are a power couple each with their own respective strong suits that fit perfectly for task. The whole series is people having to cope with countless poor situations in the best way they can and a lot of good people died and a lot of bad ones did too, on top of the random npc's who just got dragged into this mess. He did what we had to do, and ultimately it worked for the greater benefit of several people who got answers to unasked questions, resolutions to unsolved problems, and a chance at redemption and a happy life. He did what he felt he had to do and boy did he win in the end. Or at least as much as you can win when your brother's still dead.
Aaaaaa this is so gooooood, the Nie Brothers really do something to my heart and you captured so much of that here, and then the switch in the end from the literal death of Nie Mingjue to the metaphoric fall from heroism that Nie Huaisang sees in Jin Guangyao - aaaaahhh!!!!! That's so good!!!!!!
This is so beautiful and sad.... Nie Mingyue never wanted his brother to be so obsessed with revenge but who could control that...
this hits more than cramps bro-
this is so far one of the best mdzs animatic ever🥺 the song fit NHS and the relationship with his brother sm omh.
This is heartbreaking...
This song really has a special deep meaning and makes it more amazing when matched with their story
Welp that hurt right there-🥲👉🖤
Nie Huaisang is so clever. AMAZING.
Oh my goodness that was so so so good!! Your lines are so pretty btw like yes. I love the Nie brothers so much, i think they might be my favourite characters in the novel so I was very excited to see Huisang!! Thank you so much this looks so good!!
Aa this is absolutely amazing :(( the song you chose matches perfectly
This was amazing! I love the your art style, and how the lyrics fit soooooo well. Thank you for your efforts!
this is so well done!! you really nailed huaisang and nmj's expressions and emotions, this song fits them so well!! that bow at the end... WOW. this is amazing!!
The beauty of this video had me on the verge of tears the entire time aAa
this is absolutely lovely!!! thank you for making it
This is beautiful
I dont even know what fandom this is but I love it
Its from the novel/donghua Mo dao zu shi, english name the grandmaster of demonic cultivation! Highly recommend 🥰
how dare you make me feel for these two euuewnskfjlnkdgf IM CRYING SO HARD THIS ANIMATIC IS SO GOOD????? EJSIDFDG
Baby huaisang is so innocent and sad, my poor heart!
There was a book. It said something that describes him well. If one has the power to kill everyone, I don't see why they don't use it to kill their enemies if they can. While I all those who don't have power will just make plans.
Perfect song and perfect application! Also, your art was great!
Thought this would be about Wwx but dang this is ×100 better than I expected!
It is really well done 😭❤️ the last clip of huaisang reminds me of the scene from untamed...it's perfect
0:42 literally killed me. I am dead now.
You kept the iconic scene from the drama!!!
Asfhgfhkl I love this so much!!! This is too good!!
Please- this is so beautiful,, everyone's story is so tragic,y heart- ;-;
I wasn't expecting this 😭
GOD I LOVE THIS. THE NIE BROTHERS HAVE A SPECIAL PLACE IN MY HEART AND THIS IS SOOOO💗💗💗
This is. So. Good. It made me feel stuff. Rlly good
I think it would have been kinder to actually stab me, this is SO BEAUTIFUL, I'm crying
The animation is so smooth!
Love your interpretation of this, it's absolutely fantastic GREAT JOB!! Made me very emotional :') loved this so much thank you for sharing your work
thanks! loved it! now im crying
OMG the way you draw is just amazing!! I thought this was about wwx but I'm very glad there's something about my baby Huaisang too
THATS SO GORGEOUS HOLLY-
nie mingjue best big bro 🥺
Wooow your animation is amazing i love it !
It's pretty well-done. Thank you
damnnn, this is beautiful.
This is the reason why I can't hate Nie Huaisang nor Shi Wudu.
Oh se
No estoy llorando
Mis ojos están haciendo agua control;"^";
MY BABY BOY
this is so cool! i love it!
This is so good, and really underrated!
im sobbing ❤
Before I watch the video let me mentally and physically prepare for the worst (best) animatic I'll ever see in my life
Edit: 😭💀
Heartbreaking at 😭
WOW
♡♡♡♡♡ i love this!!!