He best video on ick to date…Thank you! Informative and realistic…Keep you fish healthy and well fed without jeopardizing overall creatures in your tank with “snake oil”…
The only issue with setting up a QT tanks is not just space, but it is also for the fact the tank needs to cycle and salt water takes 6 months to establish
Just curious, Is there any scientific research to prove your statement that you made in the video where you said that "garlic will boost the fishes immune system". Personally I think this video is missing one very key component. Since we all know there is no reef safe ich medicine or treatment per se, eg 'kick ich', and your title says "how to get rid of ich", you should have showed the exact steps of using proven methods such as copper, 'to get rid if ich' and then salt and peppered your video with the anecdotal stuff like ruby reef and the botanical.. and no method of Tank Transfer Method?? Sorry but this video needs and upgrade : ))))
Garlic is a antiparasitic that is a fact. The main peice all these videos miss is you need to siphon your gravel everyday for the 4 weeks if you leave the fish in. I have a tried and true ick treatment method on my channel
Kick ich does not work I used two big bottles in a 120 gallon shut down sump completely went strictly by instructions and on days to dose I added same time at 9pm one measuring cup is 8oz I put in a cup and a little more then a half. Did it for a month and the cost of this stuff , and it failed. Not catching fish for quarantine but having a time catching the blue tang.
You missed the best in-tank treatment: a UV sterilizer! I cleared ich in my 180g with a 40w sterilizer. It took a few ich cycles before it was gone, but the parasites were fewer and fewer with each outbreak. The tank remained ich free for a year before I eventually took the system down. It had a bunch of tangs in it, too!
Maybe it wasnt the UV but the fish immune system working against the parasite each outbreak. UV wont kill the parasite, you need 280 mj/cm2 and the commercial UVs dont reach that high
@@Cocomann It was an amazing coincidence then, because I had ich rampant in the tank for months until the instant I installed UV. ;) Sure it's probably not a 100% kill rate, but over time not enough individuals lived to sustain the culture... it's a numbers game. At least that was my experience.
@@mnelson10000 empiric experience, therefore not reliable as "the best in-tank treatment". good for you that you could "erradicate" such problem, still didnt make it past one year. cheers.
@@Cocomann Not sure why you put "erradicate" in quotes when I didn't use that word, but I did manage to eradicate it. The tank only ran another year because I moved, but I appreciate your concern. Cheer to you too, brother!
I second the UV sterilizer. The key is to oversize and go with a low flow rate. I have a 36w rated for 200gals on my 75 and set it to the lowest recommended flow rate. Also got rid of any visible ich AND in a couple of weeks eliminated all patches of nuisance algae in my tank. No it won’t permanently kill anything, just prevent it from multiplying to dangerous numbers.
You can add copper directly into your tank but, if you ever plan on adding corals or inverts into your system, it will be very difficult to remove any leftover copper.
@@ayshika I don't use corals if your fish can handle it which most can handle the heat I would recommend 10 days at 90 then slowly go back to where you keep it I had my tank up to as high as 93 and fish were fine
@@irecon-_516 no it can survive for up to 8 weeks without fish host otherwise it dies it does not use coral hosts Edit: can confirm as I just treated my 65 gallon reef for ich I had to remove all the fish into quarantine with copper for 8 weeks and haven't had any problems since adding them back to the tank. The parasite simply does not live without fish to host them.
I’m treating ick in my display tank I have invertebrates so I pick a reef safe medication I start 3 days ago my blue tang is ok but no great yet I’m trying to be patient but is hard while I’m dealing with this a noticed that one of my fish is no eating a Cream angel like a week ago and I haven’t see her eat + her eyes are cloudy my water is good I tried different food, I’m putting vitamins to the water but nothing. I brought Metroplex with Focus because in my research said could be parasites but I can use it if she is no eating? I appreciate a soon help.
It has to be tuned correctly but yea it can. I found out you have to have a strong enough bulb and turn over enough water to make it effective because it did not work for me
This is one of the most "professional looking" video on marine Ich, but with the WORST info. Everything you said is so wishy washy. The worst part... the emphasis of using immune system to beat Ich.
Way too much anecdotal, unproven, and assumptive commentary for this to have come from you guys at MD. Should’ve just stuck to the facts that we already know about ich and it’s life cycle. Sorry guys, but I think you missed the mark with this one.
Keep the display fallow for at least 72 days(the longest officially recorded ich life cycle) . Fallow tank is fishless. Marine ich can only attach to fish non corals or inverts. Fish no fish to host it will die off
good day, thank you for having this video, i am having issues with my fish 7 of my tangs died plus my clownfish 2 of my other fishes what should i do, can you please help me. ich parasite and marine velvet not sure what it's in my tank, i do have corals in my tank also i took my old 32 biocube out put the fishes in there i am giving them copper, I also bough Dr.G's i sow it in your video what should I do with my 130 gal? change the water or i have a sand in my 130 gal also i wan the tank to be ich parasite and marine velvet free. how should i completely kill all the parasite that's killing my fish not having fish in my 130 gal tank and I do have sand in the tank you think after 2 months it will be clean tank? I do have 4 clean up shrimps in my 130 gal tank
Hyposalinity IS the truly only way to be success at eradicating Ich. I know, because I done it before in a reef tank full of fish and fishes were dying left and right. Until I setup a quarantine tank and put all the fishes in, even the very sick. The result, I saved all the fishes and after 3 months, I put all the fishes back into my tank. I haven't had any problem for over 12 years.
What happens if you have a 180 gallon tank with over 50 fish in there ? Where are you gonna house them? As a matter of fact , what happens if you have damsels or other rock dwellers in there ? They’re hard to catch !
The problem with this video is that Ich doesn't care what you feed your fish. If ich is in your tank it will eventually take over and kill all your fish. Simple as that.
He best video on ick to date…Thank you! Informative and realistic…Keep you fish healthy and well fed without jeopardizing overall creatures in your tank with “snake oil”…
The only issue with setting up a QT tanks is not just space, but it is also for the fact the tank needs to cycle and salt water takes 6 months to establish
Yea if you want a reef tank you should have a permanent QT also. It has come in handy several times in my first year of reefing
"separating fact from fiction", proceeds to recommend using garlic XD
Just curious, Is there any scientific research to prove your statement that you made in the video where you said that "garlic will boost the fishes immune system". Personally I think this video is missing one very key component. Since we all know there is no reef safe ich medicine or treatment per se, eg 'kick ich', and your title says "how to get rid of ich", you should have showed the exact steps of using proven methods such as copper, 'to get rid if ich' and then salt and peppered your video with the anecdotal stuff like ruby reef and the botanical.. and no method of Tank Transfer Method?? Sorry but this video needs and upgrade : ))))
Garlic is a antiparasitic that is a fact. The main peice all these videos miss is you need to siphon your gravel everyday for the 4 weeks if you leave the fish in. I have a tried and true ick treatment method on my channel
none there is none
@@cleanbigboystoys wrong and the amount you would need is toxic to the fish. Its not the garlic itself that is an anti parasitic
to many experts on these comments 😂
Kick ich does not work I used two big bottles in a 120 gallon shut down sump completely went strictly by instructions and on days to dose I added same time at 9pm one measuring cup is 8oz I put in a cup and a little more then a half. Did it for a month and the cost of this stuff , and it failed. Not catching fish for quarantine but having a time catching the blue tang.
You missed the best in-tank treatment: a UV sterilizer! I cleared ich in my 180g with a 40w sterilizer. It took a few ich cycles before it was gone, but the parasites were fewer and fewer with each outbreak. The tank remained ich free for a year before I eventually took the system down. It had a bunch of tangs in it, too!
Maybe it wasnt the UV but the fish immune system working against the parasite each outbreak. UV wont kill the parasite, you need 280 mj/cm2 and the commercial UVs dont reach that high
@@Cocomann It was an amazing coincidence then, because I had ich rampant in the tank for months until the instant I installed UV. ;) Sure it's probably not a 100% kill rate, but over time not enough individuals lived to sustain the culture... it's a numbers game. At least that was my experience.
@@mnelson10000 empiric experience, therefore not reliable as "the best in-tank treatment". good for you that you could "erradicate" such problem, still didnt make it past one year. cheers.
@@Cocomann Not sure why you put "erradicate" in quotes when I didn't use that word, but I did manage to eradicate it. The tank only ran another year because I moved, but I appreciate your concern. Cheer to you too, brother!
I second the UV sterilizer. The key is to oversize and go with a low flow rate. I have a 36w rated for 200gals on my 75 and set it to the lowest recommended flow rate. Also got rid of any visible ich AND in a couple of weeks eliminated all patches of nuisance algae in my tank. No it won’t permanently kill anything, just prevent it from multiplying to dangerous numbers.
What if i only have fish in my tank and no inverts and corals in it
Can i direct it on my tank?
You can add copper directly into your tank but, if you ever plan on adding corals or inverts into your system, it will be very difficult to remove any leftover copper.
What kind of fish do you have or plan on having in your tank?
Only thing that completely kill ick is heating the tank to 90 that's my method and works and kills it all
for how long. does this not affect your corals
@@ayshika I don't use corals if your fish can handle it which most can handle the heat I would recommend 10 days at 90 then slowly go back to where you keep it I had my tank up to as high as 93 and fish were fine
It would kill every thing for sure
@@rhombifer566 never had a problem
@@17schiavo ?
Can you add fish to a tank after a fish died from ich? Like, do I just hope that the next fish has a good immune system?
No you wait 6-8 weeks running the tank fallow (with no fish) and the parasite will die off without any hosts (fish) within this time.
Why are you a top comment
@@jessedunda2130 but then it can live in corals no?
@@irecon-_516 no it can survive for up to 8 weeks without fish host otherwise it dies it does not use coral hosts
Edit: can confirm as I just treated my 65 gallon reef for ich I had to remove all the fish into quarantine with copper for 8 weeks and haven't had any problems since adding them back to the tank. The parasite simply does not live without fish to host them.
@@jessedunda2130 sweet gotcha, so when the fish are in quarantine do you have to clean the tank often or? And how often do you add copper
I’m treating ick in my display tank I have invertebrates so I pick a reef safe medication I start 3 days ago my blue tang is ok but no great yet I’m trying to be patient but is hard while I’m dealing with this a noticed that one of my fish is no eating a Cream angel like a week ago and I haven’t see her eat + her eyes are cloudy my water is good I tried different food, I’m putting vitamins to the water but nothing. I brought Metroplex with Focus because in my research said could be parasites but I can use it if she is no eating? I appreciate a soon help.
I would suggest trying American Marine Selcon, you soak the fish food in it and it helps with fatty acids, vitamins, etc
What happen?
is garlic extreme reef safe?
The content of the video was on point and valuable. if the entirety of the video is considered then criticism would be hard to drum up.
HOWWWW is Melaleuca Oil used to help with ick? Surely not in their food? Just put it in the tank water? HOW? Thanks . Tim
Does a UV steriliser kill the parasite in its free-swimming stages?
It has to be tuned correctly but yea it can. I found out you have to have a strong enough bulb and turn over enough water to make it effective because it did not work for me
This is one of the most "professional looking" video on marine Ich, but with the WORST info. Everything you said is so wishy washy. The worst part... the emphasis of using immune system to beat Ich.
Way too much anecdotal, unproven, and assumptive commentary for this to have come from you guys at MD. Should’ve just stuck to the facts that we already know about ich and it’s life cycle. Sorry guys, but I think you missed the mark with this one.
Not possible to remove all fish.
So if I remove all fish and treat with copper and afterwards transfer to a non copper qt tank will the ich die in the display after a couple months?
Keep the display fallow for at least 72 days(the longest officially recorded ich life cycle) . Fallow tank is fishless. Marine ich can only attach to fish non corals or inverts. Fish no fish to host it will die off
good day, thank you for having this video, i am having issues with my fish 7 of my tangs died plus my
clownfish 2 of my other fishes what should i do, can you please help me.
ich parasite and marine velvet not sure what it's in my tank, i do have
corals in my tank also i took my old 32 biocube out put the fishes in
there i am giving them copper, I also bough Dr.G's i sow it in your
video
what should I do with my 130 gal? change the water or i have a sand in
my 130 gal also i wan the tank to be ich parasite and marine velvet
free. how should i completely kill all the parasite that's killing my
fish
not having fish in my 130 gal tank and I do have sand in the tank you
think after 2 months it will be clean tank? I do have 4 clean up shrimps
in my 130 gal tank
bruh it’s not that hard to type proper english. will help u a lot in life too
Hyposalinity IS the truly only way to be success at eradicating Ich. I know, because I done it before in a reef tank full of fish and fishes were dying left and right. Until I setup a quarantine tank and put all the fishes in, even the very sick. The result, I saved all the fishes and after 3 months, I put all the fishes back into my tank. I haven't had any problem for over 12 years.
how to get formalin
ahh that intro didn't grow old well hehe
Non of them work.. only one thing does, take the fish out of tank.. treat
What happens if you have a 180 gallon tank with over 50 fish in there ? Where are you gonna house them? As a matter of fact , what happens if you have damsels or other rock dwellers in there ? They’re hard to catch !
The problem with this video is that Ich doesn't care what you feed your fish. If ich is in your tank it will eventually take over and kill all your fish. Simple as that.
Cupermine.
Nooooo that will kill everything including some delicate fish.. never use cupramine in your reef tank. EVER!