Thank you Shankar, just recently i shifted my bias from ETF and started investing in similarly priced or even lower cost index fund (considering ETF price fluctuations vs actual NAV and also the other charges like STT, stamp duty, etc) Maybe in a next video it would be very nice to see how the returns of ETF compare with index fund over a long period given that ETF price (at time of purchase) during market hours may be different than the actual NAV of the ETF, whereas in case of index fund there are no such discrepancies.
Pranav Impact cost is the hidden cost as rightly said by Sankar sir which differentiates etf from index funds, inflow and outflow impact also takes toll on unit price in index funds which is not in case of etf. Moreover,NAV is wrong term you used in case of etf unlike index funds.
Very useful information about investment in MFs and I have invested in Mirae Assets Nifty small cap 250MQ100 MF, after seeing your earlier Video, Thanks
The most important advantage is as you mentioned the NAV of MF is beyond our control and doesn’t feels right any time you invest in it. ETFs are far better with less expense ratios and no lockin periods. Hope the Fund houses will introduce more ETFs than MFs in future.
Thanks very much nath sir.. Very much awaiting for this video that too mainly from you.. Recently very much obsessed with your videos that too in the extent I'm searching for everything I came across (reg investment related topics) from your channel to get your views on that particular subject.. Thank you sir.. Please do a video for beginners in investment too..
Dear Shankar Nath. Excellant presentstion and very informative. Thank you. May I request you for a presentation video on Smart Beta ETFs. There is always so much learn from your videos.
Sir your English speaking skills and vocabulary are mind blowing, please suggest some tips on that too. I was more focused on the way you are speaking.
Hi Shankar! Apart from my already balanced mutual fund portfolio (comprising one each of large, mid & small cap funds) how do i pick the right ETF and add it my portfolio which could balance it well and generate good long time returns?
Hello. Pls watch today's video (link: th-cam.com/video/R_f2HenF1cQ/w-d-xo.html). It's very relatable to your question and my quest was to create a balanced, structured & almost passive portfolio structure. I'm guessing that's what you are hinting at aswell
Excellent channel spreading awareness in a systematic and elucidating manner.thanks so much. It would be great if you can start a PMS mimicking the strategies you have unearthed especially for preferential shares buying 😊
Your videos are amazing. You might want to put out a video on the making of ur videos as your narration and content is off the charts. 👍👍 Didn't really get the explanation behind impact cost and why inflow/outflow does not impact ETFs. Goes to basics of how an ETF operates vs an index fund I guess which I'm a bit short on.
Again Great Work Sir!! Really Liked this insights, especially on Inflow and Outflow impact on ETF vs index funds part. I will think about adding ETFs as a part of my portfolio. I wish you to have more subscribers. 🙏🙏🙏
I'm not sure. On a more broader level, unless the tax liability is low (0% or 10%), dividends won't make much sense. It's better to redeem units from time to time and pay capital gain on them. This way the taxation is lower. With re: your question, please explore -- www.valueresearchonline.com/stories/51500/are-dividends-on-etfs-credited-to-the-investor-s-account/
Shankarji, your video insights are very useful. Can you make video on how to select mutual funds or ETF and also list a few with comparison on tax savings with indexation benefit. as we know investment not more than 65% equity and 35% debt get indexation benefit. but this are funds and etf are hard to find.😅
very helpful video. Covering almost everything. I have been trying to understand the allocation of units done when invested during NFO period. So do we receive the units as per the NAV or as per face value in case of investment done in the NFO period. Eg. If invested 2100/- in ICICI Oil and Gas ETF at face value Rs.10 during NFO period and the fund opened at 12.74 how many units are we to receive. I would be very obliged if you could help to make me understand this.
Thank you, glad you liked it. My understanding is that you should receive 210 units (2100 divided by 10). If you are looking to invest some money in an NFO, please do observe this & also let me know
Sir kindly make a conclusion in next video. Eg. Will it be good to buy 50 lakh worth ETF lumpsum or we should go with Index funds? What will be more charge efficient?
Very informative, thank you. Is it possible to show us the different well performing ETFs performance over time and also what stocks are held in those ETFs, thanks
@shankarnath: quality content as always! 👍. I know there is a striking difference between a small case and an ETF. But, can you pls do a video on what would be the rationale in picking between two for a long term investor? Asking this in the context of this small case: "Top 100 Stocks" by Windmill Capital. Basically they have just added two ETFs (nifty 50 and Junior bees) under it and routinely update the weightage between two during their rebalances.
Hello, nice video. Can you pls make a video comparing a mutual fund index and similar etf if we had invested same amount for same period of time after all taxes and other cost. So we can know exactly that after (say 5-10 years) which investment will be better.
Looking for this video since last year. Thank Sir you gave us a complete guide about etf/ index fund. I have a little confusion about taxation part. As the person who did received short term capital gain on his capital during the year then his gain is taxable @15% of the profits. My question is that if his taxable income is less than the taxable limit still he is liable to pay @15% or not?
shankar ji , Please make a video on Leveages , how to build Leverages to buy shares and pay off the leverages gradually. Could not find it anywhere. . Please take it ... This is very essential . I know you read all comments. I follow up hence have asked this question.
Thanks a lot for sharing the valuable information on ETFs.I have a very basic question.Is there a possibility that an ETF can be discontinued from trading in exchanges after a certain period of time?If yes what would happen to our units that we are holding?
Sir, the daily trading volumes in Pharma, IT, Banking, Auto, and Real Estate ETFs are usually quite low. There is big buy-sell spread. Plz guide. Thanks
Another advantage of ETF is, consolidation of assets. You don't need separate tracking for mutual funds & stocks you hold (& saving annual maintenance charges on COIN, though Zerodha had abolished these monthly charges of ₹50/month later) Shankar ji, would await your data backed educational vdo on international REIT investment options
Sir, at 12:08, the part with creating new shares when there are buy orders is not clear. Does it mean that somehow etf are also 'derivative' in some aspects?
Pls read these two articles: 1. www.schwabassetmanagement.com/content/understanding-etf-creation-and-redemption-mechanism 2. www.nseindia.com/products-services/etfs-creation-redemptions
just saw this video by pure chance, Shankar i must compliment the clarity, simplicity and logical approach towards making this video. great going, i am a subscriber to your channel now. hope to see such content in future also.
Dear Sir, please make video on REITs and special about foreign country like the USA where real estate is more regulated and how to invest them from India.
Wow.. Finally u made weaKend a weeKend... Thanks ji for brining another wonderful video. Ji, is there a way to track quantum of exposure mutual funds have to a particular share? Thanks in advance for your help :-)
Most welcome. I don't remember specifically which platform, but I've seen 2-3 platforms offer mutual fund exposure to specific shares. Pls check out a few of them.
Wel jo one talk about liquidity in etfs, you cant invest like mutual funds and liquidate them, also nav of etf vs price of etf ( error ) born by investors, doenst make eft very good choice yet excep for traders or for pwople who are traders, or choose only in vert few etfs..
The market price will typically exceed the NAV if the fund is in high demand with low supply. This is what is currently happening with international ETFs after the SEBI instructed mutual funds to halt fresh subscriptions in their overseas ETFs from April 1 onwards
l've been thinking of purchasing icici nifty alpha low vol etf and later while checking the app I've found that the same icici nifty alpha low vol etf fof has a much lower expense ratio. The difference is huge .42% vs .1% Can you explain why? Is the expense ratio of etf fof is really .1% or am I missing something. same goes for Tata Nifty India Digital ETF Fund of Fund - Direct Plan - Growth which is 0.07% but Tata Nifty India Digital ETF's expense ratio is 0.40%.. are there hidden expenses with fof else why would people even go for etf or mutual funds if they can get fof for that much less expense ratio... am I missing something...
I haven't tried it. But generally liquid ETFs have the lowest tracking error and impact cost .. so I guess Zerodha or most liquid ETFs should be similar and efficient
I have been investing and trading in ETF for more than 5 years now. I wish if there could be ETF for commodities like crude, steel, iron and even for Bitcoins, usd/Inr etc. as we have for silver & gold, it could help investors to get a less risky exposure while reaping their benefits.Thank you.
How is ETF wrt dividend declared or bonus issues by underlying companies….will a person holding RIL through N50 ETF get the proportionate shares of Jio Financial Services.
I am not sure but pls read this and verify: www.livemint.com/money/personal-finance/is-cpse-etf-a-good-tax-saving-option-under-elss-category-1563214720833.html
Currently doing a SIP in motilal mon100 ETF from 3 years. But now that there are no indexation benefit and taxed at tax slab. Is it a good idea to continue it? I am looking to invest in this for minimum 5-10 years. So hopefully if the government changes the rules to debt fund ETF then it's good.
I have just discovered this channel and watching some of this videos as a beginner investor, i can say this is a seriously underrated channel.
Thank you!
Another advantage is that ETFs are also pledgable.
Mutual funds can also be pledged.
What's that?
Only if in demat format right?
@@joshiprabhu a very few brokers allow that.
zerodha allows
If I sell Nasdaq 100 ETF after 12 months holding, the applicable tax would be 10% LTCG or as per my income tax slab?? Please guide.
Tax slab
As per tax slab since this is not an Indian equity investment
Thank you Shankar, just recently i shifted my bias from ETF and started investing in similarly priced or even lower cost index fund (considering ETF price fluctuations vs actual NAV and also the other charges like STT, stamp duty, etc)
Maybe in a next video it would be very nice to see how the returns of ETF compare with index fund over a long period given that ETF price (at time of purchase) during market hours may be different than the actual NAV of the ETF, whereas in case of index fund there are no such discrepancies.
Thanks for the suggestion
Pranav
Impact cost is the hidden cost as rightly said by Sankar sir which differentiates etf from index funds, inflow and outflow impact also takes toll on unit price in index funds which is not in case of etf.
Moreover,NAV is wrong term you used in case of etf unlike index funds.
That was quite comprehensive video with a-z about etf. Thanks a lot .
Glad you enjoyed it! 🙌
Very useful information about investment in MFs and I have invested in Mirae Assets Nifty small cap 250MQ100 MF, after seeing your earlier Video, Thanks
Most welcome!
The most important advantage is as you mentioned the NAV of MF is beyond our control and doesn’t feels right any time you invest in it. ETFs are far better with less expense ratios and no lockin periods. Hope the Fund houses will introduce more ETFs than MFs in future.
Thanks very much nath sir.. Very much awaiting for this video that too mainly from you.. Recently very much obsessed with your videos that too in the extent I'm searching for everything I came across (reg investment related topics) from your channel to get your views on that particular subject.. Thank you sir.. Please do a video for beginners in investment too..
Most welcome and thanks for the suggestion
Dear Shankar Nath. Excellant presentstion and very informative. Thank you. May I request you for a presentation video on Smart Beta ETFs. There is always so much learn from your videos.
Glad you found this useful. Thanks for the suggestion
Sir thank you so much . Give better understanding about ETF
Most welcome
Very well explained. Came to this channel by chance. Subscribed.
Sir your English speaking skills and vocabulary are mind blowing, please suggest some tips on that too. I was more focused on the way you are speaking.
Hello, it all comes down to practice. The more one writes, the better he/she gets at it. The same applies to speaking.
Hi Shankar! Apart from my already balanced mutual fund portfolio (comprising one each of large, mid & small cap funds) how do i pick the right ETF and add it my portfolio which could balance it well and generate good long time returns?
Hello. Pls watch today's video (link: th-cam.com/video/R_f2HenF1cQ/w-d-xo.html). It's very relatable to your question and my quest was to create a balanced, structured & almost passive portfolio structure. I'm guessing that's what you are hinting at aswell
New to your channel. Binge watching your videos this weekend but I wish I had watched this video on ETF before 4th June! 😅
Welcome aboard! Here's to exploiting more 4th June-like events!
Excellent channel spreading awareness in a systematic and elucidating manner.thanks so much. It would be great if you can start a PMS mimicking the strategies you have unearthed especially for preferential shares buying 😊
Thanks for the suggestion. I am glad you like my work!
Your videos are amazing. You might want to put out a video on the making of ur videos as your narration and content is off the charts. 👍👍 Didn't really get the explanation behind impact cost and why inflow/outflow does not impact ETFs. Goes to basics of how an ETF operates vs an index fund I guess which I'm a bit short on.
Thanks for the suggestion & feedback
This topic was a long awaited video from you.,.Thanks
Thx for your patience
Very informative presentation on ETF . Thanks Mr Shankar 🌸🌸
So nice of you. You're most welcome
Again Great Work Sir!! Really Liked this insights, especially on Inflow and Outflow impact on ETF vs index funds part. I will think about adding ETFs as a part of my portfolio.
I wish you to have more subscribers. 🙏🙏🙏
Thank you for your kind appreciation. Glad the video was helpful!
Only investing who helps in understanding market instruments in easy manner rather flaunting his wealth, intelligence.
Glad you liked my work
bingo what a timing :)
Very informative as always...thourogh study on topic and command on subject 👏
Thank you. Glad you liked it
Shankar, thank you so much of information in very simple way.
You're most welcome. glad you liked it
Kudos to your efforts. Thanks for sharing the knowledge. Keep it up :)
My pleasure
Excellent content. Do we have any ETFS in India that pays quarterly dividends?
I'm not sure. On a more broader level, unless the tax liability is low (0% or 10%), dividends won't make much sense. It's better to redeem units from time to time and pay capital gain on them. This way the taxation is lower.
With re: your question, please explore -- www.valueresearchonline.com/stories/51500/are-dividends-on-etfs-credited-to-the-investor-s-account/
Shankarji, your video insights are very useful. Can you make video on how to select mutual funds or ETF and also list a few with comparison on tax savings with indexation benefit. as we know investment not more than 65% equity and 35% debt get indexation benefit. but this are funds and etf are hard to find.😅
Thanks for the suggestion. You can try valueresearchonline.com to find balanced ETFs.
Watch at .75x make more understanding n thank you for this mind blowing ETF mantra
Good information sir nice🎉
Sir how mutual funds or etf adjest devidents pls do vedio sir
Thanks for the suggestion
I see difference between nifty 50 and nifty bees day change. Is it a opportunity for arbitrage? Change in a volatile market like elections is upto 5%
Nah, don't use this for arbitrage. It'll be next to impossible for you to make money from it
Kindly do a video on best ETF'S to invest
Thanks for the suggestion
very helpful video. Covering almost everything. I have been trying to understand the allocation of units done when invested during NFO period. So do we receive the units as per the NAV or as per face value in case of investment done in the NFO period. Eg. If invested 2100/- in ICICI Oil and Gas ETF at face value Rs.10 during NFO period and the fund opened at 12.74 how many units are we to receive. I would be very obliged if you could help to make me understand this.
Thank you, glad you liked it. My understanding is that you should receive 210 units (2100 divided by 10). If you are looking to invest some money in an NFO, please do observe this & also let me know
Shankar excellent info. Sharing with my team👍
Thanks for sharing
Sir kindly make a conclusion in next video. Eg. Will it be good to buy 50 lakh worth ETF lumpsum or we should go with Index funds? What will be more charge efficient?
Thanks for the suggestion
Very informative, thank you. Is it possible to show us the different well performing ETFs performance over time and also what stocks are held in those ETFs, thanks
Thx for the suggestion. You can extract the list of top ETF performers from a platform like moneycontrol.com and check the constituents there.
@shankarnath: quality content as always! 👍. I know there is a striking difference between a small case and an ETF. But, can you pls do a video on what would be the rationale in picking between two for a long term investor? Asking this in the context of this small case: "Top 100 Stocks" by Windmill Capital. Basically they have just added two ETFs (nifty 50 and Junior bees) under it and routinely update the weightage between two during their rebalances.
Thanks for the suggestion
What an amazing, comprehensive video 💯💯🙌🙏
Glad it was helpful!
Hello, nice video.
Can you pls make a video comparing a mutual fund index and similar etf if we had invested same amount for same period of time after all taxes and other cost.
So we can know exactly that after (say 5-10 years) which investment will be better.
Thanks for the suggestion
Looking for this video since last year. Thank Sir you gave us a complete guide about etf/ index fund. I have a little confusion about taxation part. As the person who did received short term capital gain on his capital during the year then his gain is taxable @15% of the profits. My question is that if his taxable income is less than the taxable limit still he is liable to pay @15% or not?
Most welcome. Kindly consult a tax advisor for specifics
shankar ji , Please make a video on Leveages , how to build Leverages to buy shares and pay off the leverages gradually. Could not find it anywhere. . Please take it ... This is very essential . I know you read all comments. I follow up hence have asked this question.
Thanks for the suggestion
Thanks a lot for sharing the valuable information on ETFs.I have a very basic question.Is there a possibility that an ETF can be discontinued from trading in exchanges after a certain period of time?If yes what would happen to our units that we are holding?
Most welcome. I'm sorry, I am not aware of the process. However I did find an article on this which might be helpful -- blog.shoonya.com/etf-closures/
Do we have to pay STT on index funds also? Please clarify.
Sir, the daily trading volumes in Pharma, IT, Banking, Auto, and Real Estate ETFs are usually quite low. There is big buy-sell spread. Plz guide. Thanks
I'm sorry, what's the question? It's not clear
Another advantage of ETF is, consolidation of assets. You don't need separate tracking for mutual funds & stocks you hold (& saving annual maintenance charges on COIN, though Zerodha had abolished these monthly charges of ₹50/month later)
Shankar ji, would await your data backed educational vdo on international REIT investment options
Thanks for the suggestion
Sir, at 12:08, the part with creating new shares when there are buy orders is not clear. Does it mean that somehow etf are also 'derivative' in some aspects?
Pls read these two articles:
1. www.schwabassetmanagement.com/content/understanding-etf-creation-and-redemption-mechanism
2. www.nseindia.com/products-services/etfs-creation-redemptions
You are simply great. Very very honest opinion
Thank you very much! 🙌
just saw this video by pure chance, Shankar i must compliment the clarity, simplicity and logical approach towards making this video. great going, i am a subscriber to your channel now. hope to see such content in future also.
Welcome aboard!
Dear Sir, please make video on REITs and special about foreign country like the USA where real estate is more regulated and how to invest them from India.
Thanks for the suggestion
Wow.. Finally u made weaKend a weeKend... Thanks ji for brining another wonderful video.
Ji, is there a way to track quantum of exposure mutual funds have to a particular share? Thanks in advance for your help :-)
Most welcome. I don't remember specifically which platform, but I've seen 2-3 platforms offer mutual fund exposure to specific shares. Pls check out a few of them.
Quite a good video,, thanks for sharing this,
My pleasure. Glad you enjoyed it
Excellent presentation
Very genuine effort
So nice of you. Thank you!
Mr shankar, grt vdo as always.hats off to u. Can u pl make an elabotate vdo on investing in US stocks/etfs..
Thanks for the suggestion
Wel jo one talk about liquidity in etfs, you cant invest like mutual funds and liquidate them, also nav of etf vs price of etf ( error ) born by investors, doenst make eft very good choice yet excep for traders or for pwople who are traders, or choose only in vert few etfs..
You are a gem 💎
Thanks for making learing so easy ❤
Thanks! I'm glad you like my work
Kindly explain why in the case of ETFs the quoted price is always higher than the NAV?
The market price will typically exceed the NAV if the fund is in high demand with low supply. This is what is currently happening with international ETFs after the SEBI instructed mutual funds to halt fresh subscriptions in their overseas ETFs from April 1 onwards
l've been thinking of purchasing icici nifty alpha low vol etf and later while checking the app I've found that the same icici nifty alpha low vol etf fof has a much lower expense ratio.
The difference is huge .42% vs .1%
Can you explain why?
Is the expense ratio of etf fof is really .1% or am I missing something.
same goes for Tata Nifty India Digital ETF Fund of Fund
- Direct Plan - Growth which is 0.07% but Tata Nifty
India Digital ETF's expense ratio is 0.40%..
are there hidden expenses with fof else why would people even go for etf or mutual funds if they can get fof for that much less expense ratio... am I missing something...
. 42+.1=.51 in fof but in etf stt sebi turnover fee actually etf & fof cost remain same
@@englishsongsothers8561 thank you 🙏🏻
How does nifty etf pay dividend and what is taxation. Thx
Dividend if there, reinvested
@@santoshkenguva4326 so no taxation at buyer end for dividend payout. Only capital gain is applicable
Sir, SIP on Index ETFs are a good option or going with one time investment during the dips?
Please watch my video on SIP + Lumpsum for a better understanding of this
Sir govt employee ETF kar sakta hai??
please make a video on SME companies and best listed SME companies on the exchange please !!
Thanks for the suggestion
a dedicated video on how to use Chart Ink for fundamental analysis will be great
Thanks for the suggestion
Can you please elaborate on balanced etf.i have not seen till date
The only person who spreads real knowledge
Thank you very much!
Thanks so much for this video
You are so welcome!
Excellent...explanation on ETF
Glad you liked it!
Good & Clear Explanation 📸
Thank you 🙂
Thank for the nice video.
Thanks for watching!
Pls make video on government capex related ETF.
#shankarnath
Thanks for the suggestion
Hi sir does Etf profits undergo compounding like mutual funds
Yes, ETFs compound -- similar to mutual funds
Much much needed video...... thanks #shankarnath ❤
Most welcome!
is there website or app to calculate ETF returns?
Most of them offer it. Valueresearchonline.com & moneycontrol.com are two platforms I can think of
Sir, conclusion pls which is best index vs etf when considering taxation?
Can you share your own research with re: taxation on index fund & ETF? This way I can comment on it as I'll know the context
Excellent information
Thank you
after a long time,basic video I can understand 😂😂😂..thank u bro
Most welcome
Super explanation
Glad you liked it
Can you cover tax free bond and how toninvest in them?
I can try. Thanks for the suggestion
As usual, lucid and excellent explanation of complex stock market topics, by Sri sankarnath.
Thank you
Sir hindi mein ye video banaiye
Thanks for the suggestion
Ur view on liquid case by zerodha?
I haven't tried it. But generally liquid ETFs have the lowest tracking error and impact cost .. so I guess Zerodha or most liquid ETFs should be similar and efficient
GREAT VIDEO!!
Thanks 🙌
can you pls list the balanced etfs currently available? So far, i have known abt equity, debt, silver & gold etf apart from few international etf...
I have been investing and trading in ETF for more than 5 years now. I wish if there could be ETF for commodities like crude, steel, iron and even for Bitcoins, usd/Inr etc. as we have for silver & gold, it could help investors to get a less risky exposure while reaping their benefits.Thank you.
I think you should share your etf journey for learning purpose. either trading or just investing . any insight about rebalancing. and more.
So how is it going, the etf journey, so far?
It has been a good learning journey so far.
Learning is good but what about returns, are they good and reasonable?
Yes the returns were good and that is why I wish if we could have ETF for commodities, forex and even cryptos .
Very knowledgeable!
Glad it was helpful!
How is ETF wrt dividend declared or bonus issues by underlying companies….will a person holding RIL through N50 ETF get the proportionate shares of Jio Financial Services.
Same doubt for me.
The dividend part was covered in the video. Same principle applies for bonus shares
Is there something like ELSS or tax saving ETFs?
I am not sure but pls read this and verify: www.livemint.com/money/personal-finance/is-cpse-etf-a-good-tax-saving-option-under-elss-category-1563214720833.html
Sir kindly make video of etf vs index fund
Thanks for the suggestion
good topic.
Thanks!
I want such vedio,,, thanks thanks,,, a lot
Most welcome
❤
Epic! Well explained again Shankar.
Thanks
Suggest best etfs sir
Thanks for the suggestion
Excellent one....
Glad you liked it
Is it wise to use buy on dip strategy on niftybees or bankbees?
Hi Shankar! Could you please have a deep dive on Icici bharat 22 etf in your next video?
Thanks for the suggestion
Thanks a lot!
Welcome!
Thank You
You're welcome
Currently doing a SIP in motilal mon100 ETF from 3 years. But now that there are no indexation benefit and taxed at tax slab. Is it a good idea to continue it?
I am looking to invest in this for minimum 5-10 years. So hopefully if the government changes the rules to debt fund ETF then it's good.
Good One
Thanks!
Thank You.
Welcome!
Very well explained... thanks...
Glad you liked it. Thanks!
Mirae asset fang+ etf has been a very good one when fang stocks were badly hit 2 years ago. Fast fwd from that day. The etf has almost given 200%