I’ve since outgrown Thomas, but I’ve recently been intrigued by TWR, and I returned to this channel. I really like this video, since Edward was my #1 as a kid. Can’t wait until you do Percy!
I'm not going to bash or criticize your opinion, but I know why Edward's face is off for his 2002-2011 face. It was based on the promotional art rather than the actual model, unlike his 1993-2002 design! This is why Take Along Emily has a red running board and why Bachmann's first wave has some... inaccuracies.
When I was a kid, I had and still have most of the characters they made for this line. Yet for some reason, I never owned a normal Edward. I had literally the only alternate version of Edward they made, but not a default one. I had a 1992 Edward tender, but no main Edward body. It took me 9 years, but I finally got Mattel’s take on Edward and the 1992 version the same year, and this past Christmas I got both a 2001 Edward and a 2022 Edward. It’s so nice to have this exemplary character in my collection at last. After looking at all the Edwards I have, I’d say the 2001 version is my favorite. It captures Edward’s face spot on and I feel like having the simpler details and smaller scale really helps sell that Edward is an old engine. That’s not to discredit the other ones however, I absolutely adore Mattel’s take on him and while I prefer Learning Curve’s old faces, Mattel’s 2013 redesign definitely wins in the CGI department.
Especially considering that as Edward is the no. 2 blue wise, old, kind tender engine, the reason for Thomas being no. 1 as I once heard is Thomas became the most popular character in the Railway Series.
I love this new series man. I feel like the 2002 Edward isn’t that bad. The face decently shows his friendly and caring personality, the details are nice, but the wheel arrangement still kind of ruins it. The 2013 and 2022 Edward versions are spot on. I need to get a version of both as soon as possible. I can’t wait to see your Henry review.
Yeah, I actually somehow respectfully preferred the original version of Edward where the coal in his tender looked more like an actual wooden carving of lumps of coal.
Personally, I feel that the 2003 Edward gets it the best, as from the images I've seen the 90s one looks weird, and I prefer classic series over CGI series
Here’s how I’d rank Edward’s models: #1 2003 Edward, I don’t care what anyone says, this Edward is fantastic. 10/10 #2 2013 Edward, Great Face. 9/10 #3 The Original Edward from the 90s, the Edward that started it all. 7/10 #4 2019 Edward, Horrible Tender and Body style, but good face. 4/10 #5 2011 Edward, The face dosen’t look like Edward at all. 3/10 #6 2022 Edward, I’m sorry but I’m not a fan of this model. I get that they needed to add extra wheels, but elongating him is not the way to do it, I understand that Edward’s basis are this long in real life, but these are supposed to be based of their tv counterparts, in which their models are much shorter. He dosen’t look as bad as James, but he still looks pretty bad, also, I really don’t like the face on him. It dosen’t remind me of AEG like he other engines faces, but this is a really bad default face. 2/10 #7 2017 Edward, Horrible Face. 0/10
Some eagle-eyed viewers may notice my 2017 Edward has a tender from a different year. Don’t know how that happened but here we are! 😂
daily uploads???????!
Oh No 🤭
Yes, I noticed that
That was the first thing i noticed when you showed the 2017 version. I was like "hold on, that tender is form learning curve not Mattel"
Britt Allcroft just died fly high 🕊️
Bro hearing your voice brought back so many memories watching your videos as a kid
These back to back uploads are leaving me flabbergasted 😂
It has me quite perplexed
@ I’m just gobsmacked
@supremegalaxycentral yes I can agree that I am quite astonished
Edward was always one of my favorite engines as a kid. Disregarding HiT era portrayal, his kind personality really resonates with me.
I’ve since outgrown Thomas, but I’ve recently been intrigued by TWR, and I returned to this channel. I really like this video, since Edward was my #1 as a kid. Can’t wait until you do Percy!
You know it's good when TWR is pumping these out daily!
When you finish, you should make a compilation video of all of these
Loved this! I watched the Thomas one yesterday, i didn't expect for you to upload another one so quickly, tho i don't mind it. Keep it up!
Nice evolution of Edward in the Wooden Railway range! I really like the 2013 Edward along with the 2022 Edward with his 4-4-0 wheel arrangement!
Edward is definitely one of the best characters in my book! It’s really nice how they upsized Edward in 2022. 🚂
Shockingly I’ve never ever seen the Early CGI Edward model/toy 😭😭 Great video by the way. I Love Edward
The 2022 Edward is honestly the best-looking Edward because of the wheel configuration.
Agreed
Awesome Job Also I Love Edward The Blue Engine He’s One Of My Favorite Characters
I think Edward is the best of the TWR 2.0 engines. That late 90s face hits the sweet spot
Good old iron Edward is my all-time favourite character from The Railway Series and Tv series. I'm always respect for him for old and wiser.
I often forget Edward was released during Thomas Wood
Love to see the 2022 Edward with a classic happy face, same for Gordon, Percy, Toby and Rebecca
I'm a huge fan of Edward, too, dude!
Loving these style vids nice work twr ❤
One Of My Favorite Trains In Thomas & Friends!
I'm not going to bash or criticize your opinion, but I know why Edward's face is off for his 2002-2011 face. It was based on the promotional art rather than the actual model, unlike his 1993-2002 design! This is why Take Along Emily has a red running board and why Bachmann's first wave has some... inaccuracies.
0:32 I think they should have made his wheel arrangement more accurate because the customers would know he is Edward (because he is blue).
?
Will you do a wooden railway review of James, Percy, Toby, Gordon, Henry, and Emily. And other characters like Duck?
When I was a kid, I had and still have most of the characters they made for this line. Yet for some reason, I never owned a normal Edward. I had literally the only alternate version of Edward they made, but not a default one. I had a 1992 Edward tender, but no main Edward body. It took me 9 years, but I finally got Mattel’s take on Edward and the 1992 version the same year, and this past Christmas I got both a 2001 Edward and a 2022 Edward. It’s so nice to have this exemplary character in my collection at last.
After looking at all the Edwards I have, I’d say the 2001 version is my favorite. It captures Edward’s face spot on and I feel like having the simpler details and smaller scale really helps sell that Edward is an old engine. That’s not to discredit the other ones however, I absolutely adore Mattel’s take on him and while I prefer Learning Curve’s old faces, Mattel’s 2013 redesign definitely wins in the CGI department.
Edward is my favorite character
Fun fact: Even though Thomas is the number one engine. Edward was the first character to be created by the Rev. W. Awdry.
An Excellent Video, Edward is a Great Character.👍
Love My Boy Edward 🥰
I have the late 90s Edward model. And I probably like that one best, because of that.
I like it better when your reviews don't feel scripted
Edward is the Goat!
My favorite wooden Edward will always be the Brio one, I love that thing so much
I remember when you I was watching your old videos that was from reuploads and they were like every day
I like the tired out expression Edward from the Edward the great set 😁👍
the legend is back
The engine that started it all
Especially considering that as Edward is the no. 2 blue wise, old, kind tender engine, the reason for Thomas being no. 1 as I once heard is Thomas became the most popular character in the Railway Series.
I have remembered owning the tired Edward from the Edward the great set atleast his face was like the episode
Need a TWR Eddie someday
I love this new series man. I feel like the 2002 Edward isn’t that bad. The face decently shows his friendly and caring personality, the details are nice, but the wheel arrangement still kind of ruins it. The 2013 and 2022 Edward versions are spot on. I need to get a version of both as soon as possible. I can’t wait to see your Henry review.
I’m excited to see Henry next he along with Edward are in my top 10 for favorite characters
Honestly I actually want to reinvest into buying wooden railway models again since the newest Edward variant just feels and looks right
I think I have an idea about which engine will be covered next... 😁
I have only two Edwards. The snowy minis Edward and the Wood Edward. I plan on getting the 2022 Edward to use his shocked face.
Can't wait to see Henry
Nice Job
very awesome can't wait to see henry
Should have gave edward 3 wheels and made the first one small,hed looked better and distiguishable.
Awesome job
I like the 2002 Edward.
keep being the best youtuber ever
Great video!
As a kid, I never understood why Wooden Railway made Edward have four wheels until now.
When will you bring your series back
Yeah, I actually somehow respectfully preferred the original version of Edward where the coal in his tender looked more like an actual wooden carving of lumps of coal.
I wanna get the 2022 wooden railway Edward for my birthday.
I have the TOMY (2009-2012) version of Edward. Which I customized into my own model. It had looked horrible and the chassis was misaligned.
Did you hear that Britt Allcroft Passed away 😢
Your 2022 Edward has its face printed on slightly lower than it should. Is this like a pseudo factory error?
Great review the same great work as Thomas the tank engine
Do Henry next.
;)
Do Henry and Gordon pls
Personally, I feel that the 2003 Edward gets it the best, as from the images I've seen the 90s one looks weird, and I prefer classic series over CGI series
Here’s how I’d rank Edward’s models:
#1 2003 Edward, I don’t care what anyone says, this Edward is fantastic. 10/10
#2 2013 Edward, Great Face. 9/10
#3 The Original Edward from the 90s, the Edward that started it all. 7/10
#4 2019 Edward, Horrible Tender and Body style, but good face. 4/10
#5 2011 Edward, The face dosen’t look like Edward at all. 3/10
#6 2022 Edward, I’m sorry but I’m not a fan of this model. I get that they needed to add extra wheels, but elongating him is not the way to do it, I understand that Edward’s basis are this long in real life, but these are supposed to be based of their tv counterparts, in which their models are much shorter. He dosen’t look as bad as James, but he still looks pretty bad, also, I really don’t like the face on him. It dosen’t remind me of AEG like he other engines faces, but this is a really bad default face. 2/10
#7 2017 Edward, Horrible Face. 0/10
I typed this at 12:00 January 3, 2025
14th
Hi, can you please pin my comment!