Ailee is the only one without a dominant backtrack and she still slayed them all. She has the soul and skill. She has a astoundingly powerful voice that no one deny. She even made it her own. Props to Queen Ailee for being so goddamn amazing. ❤️
ailee is one of the best female vocalist of kpop. all her notes were well supported and they were powerful. she was actually 1 semitone above the others I think but she still slayed. she is a good to great vocalist claimed by professionals and taeyeon is only considered competent.
@Neko Charm there has been some analyses done and there were tiers or ranking systems made to clearly see the different technical levels between each vocalist. That's all..i suggest you to read them to further understand..and the analysts literally watched and listened to hundreds of videos of the artists to analyse them. So, they do KNOW..
I don't think it's fair to compare singers having to sing over Taeyeon's original to not having to. Ailee sounds better because she didn't have to try to match. Still they all sound good, lol.
For me, Taeyeon"s voice really is the perfect fit for Shake That Brass. I love Amber and Ailee's version but I thought that Ailee's voice was too strong that it didn't fit the song that well.
jajjangsoo totally agree. Ailee's voice is wonderful but I think its too strong and seems like overwhelm other voice. Taeyeon's voice so sweet and strong enough so taeyeon would be more suitable.
Taeyeon and Ailee both did a good job. Taeyeon is a mature and steady vocal who can carry that part of the song perfectly. Ailee has a deeper, huskier voice that sounds really nice with Amber's. Both their voices fit well with the song. 👍👍👍
Well the song was more built for Taeyeons voice but Ailee is a better vocalist. Luna kind of disappointed me because she's generally much stronger than that. I don't like the fact that the girls were dubbed over with Taeyeon's voice during the belt note because it's a lot harder to judge. But I think it's like 1. Ailee 2. Taeyeon 3. Kei 4. Luna 5. Wendy
1. Ailee (Best high note, the most stable and she has a good singing technique) 2. Taeyeon (She has a beautiful voice, sing stability) 3. Wendy (Maybe her high notes is not very good, but she has finished her line in the perfectly way. Her vocals is great, very beautiful) 4. Luna (Beautifully singing, beautiful voice. Good at handling song but her voice is so low that I think her power is not strong enough) 5. Kei (She can control her high notes but they are not high enough. She has revealing the backing vocals, weakest vocals of all) That is my opinion, do you agree me?
Well I guess some point of ur opinion I agree. But out of all these girls Kei is the only rookie. So yeah I'm not that surprise u would place Kei last.
I like Kei and Ailee the most. I just love how clear Kei's voice is and i think it really matches the song. And no need to explain Ailee, she's the queen.
1. Ailee (has a legendary voice and she can easily hit high notes) 2. Taeyeon (great and a strong vocalist, can also reach high notes specially in her part and she also has a nice husky high voice) 3. Wendy (collaborative in reaching the high note but not as much as Taeyeon and Ailee.) 4. Kei( ok vocalist but cannot prefer the high note as Taeyeon and Ailee) 5. Luna (Great vocalist but cannot reach the high note like Taeyeon and Ailee)
^ you dont carw if she is bias. As you said its his/her opinion so if you dont like the rank then give your own damn rank and put luna in the first place. Im not being bias here cause for me im putting taengoo in the first place but its her opinion so shut your damn mouth and give your own damn ranking
+Elle D youre angry because your bias is placed in the last spot.. Dont mock others on being biased when you yourself are biased. Its pathetic. I agree that luna shouldnt be put on the last place but dont act like you know vocals just because you like luna. Who cares about what sm staffs say? They can easily say anything they want on whoever they like and support, and it is sad that you shape your opinion based on their words and not your ears.
My opinion 1. Ailee (She made it so easy to reach the high note or either sing) 2. Kei (Her clear voice is nice and she didn't have problem with the high note) 3. Taeyeon (The real version + her husky voice is cool) (They all have unique and strong voices) And 4. Luna (That high note seemed easy for her but tbh her voice is just as good as normal...) 5. Wendy (It looked like she found a bit difficult in the high note and her voice isn't that special)
Honestly, Wendy is a much singer better than Kei with a slightly better technique, though I'm not saying Kei is bad because she is also my bias from Lovelyz. Kei's version was worst considering she was really, really out of tune with the high note at the end.. I would agree Wendy had some slight trouble, but she sounded fine before the high note. I'd rather hear that than bad intonation.
Lmfao. And your reason is? Yeah, I don't think you have a legit reason to say so. You obviously don't have ears to even notice how bad Kei's was. Come back when you are reasonable. : )
Lmao. You don't have a left reason either. Everyone who has working ears said Wendy was the worst on here, and other TH-cam videos too, so please, sit down.
The only thing that wasn't the best were her runs. But other than that, she was more on pitch than Kei. If you don't know what that even is then my 6 years of music training must've meant nothing then. : ) And besides, I did give my reasons, so why don't you reread my comment.
This shows why taeyeon is queens of main vocalist. Only Luna was able to sing that run in the end. Ailee could have done it but she hit a high note there instead.
This is my opinion; 1.Taeyeon (She's the original singer n that part suits her incredible voice) 2.Ailee (She slayed it! I love it coz she done it with her own style! And that's Ailee. That high note doe) 3.Luna (She did great. And her voice sounds stable too) 4.Kei (Although she's pretty new, she did a great job. Her high note was on point too.Proud of her) 5.Wendy (She's my fav mem of RV. I really like her vocal. But she was lacking something. Yet, her performance was great too!)
1. Kei (People need to go easy on her 'cause she's a rookie. Her voice sounded the clearest to me) 2. Ailee (She had a small advantage since it was performed in Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook. Her voice was a little too soulful though) 3. Luna (Luna is underrated and she's my bias in F(x), but I couldn't hear her voice clearly. She suits this song the best IMO) 4. Wendy (Wendy is also a rookie and her voice is good, but it wasn't as clear and her note wasn't good) MY OPINION!!! I didn't include Tayeon since she didn't sing live but I know she would have been great. She suits this song the best along with Luna.
Daphne Song errggghhh... kei have the worst technique around there. ailee is the best (resonant, runs with precicions and pitch accuracy, and musicianship), second was luna (good notes, but her runs were sloppy), the third is wendy and taeyeon (atb the same level) and the last, kei.... she's the worst... not the best....
fudanshi akut excuse me, Kei is just a 20 year old girl who debuted in Lovelyz just in November 2014. She's a rookie and her voice is actually even better than Jin or Sujeong (in Lovelyz). Her voice is fresh and clear all the time. When I first knew the 8 girls and listening to Candy Jelly Love and Good Night like Yesterday, the only voice that I can recognize is Kei. Don't judge her like she know nothing! She's the main vocal in Lovelyz and she didn't make any appearance like the unnies before but she sings really well (like not enough experiences. I know.) So plz, I think Kei do have talents. My list is: 1. Ailee (well, duh, her voice is strong) 2. Luna 3. Kei (I think she do sing better than Wendy) 4. Wendy (she's my bias in Red Velvet along with Seulgi, but I think she didn't sing really well.) Plz don't blame on my English. i'm Chinese
sinyin 30 i never said that kei doenst have tallent. she have tallent but compare to wendy wendy have A LOT potential. all that kei have is just a beatiful tone. just it. wendy? not only have a good voice but also have a good technique. she supports her voice batter, place her voice better than kei. kei can hit high note but not with good technique. wendy is aWAY better so, if you said she didnt sing well, then you should say "very bad" for kei.
Hell WTF ? Ailee and Luna are much better than Taeyeon... and Wendy is a bit better than Taeyeon. So WTF are you saying ? 1.Ailee 2.Luna 3.Wendy 4.Taeyeon 5.Kei
Ailee her voice hear like 'Sengau' and his breathing not long but ailee have a power, so taeyeon is better than sing this part because taeyeon stabil better than ailee... This list : 1. TaeYeon 2. Ailee (ailee have a short breath) 3. Luna 4. Wendy 5. Kei
Taeyeon's was through the MV, so you don't know if they auto-tuned her voice or fixed it up, they obviously used the best take of what she did. Ailee's was live, and Ailee is still vocally better than Taeyeon.
Ailee is awesome! Her singing techniques are perhaps the best among them :)) Taeyeon is great too, I think she can do as great as the CD version or even better when she sings live. Her live is always amazing
My choice 1.Ailee (Everyone know, no need explain) 2.Taeyeon (Although she has a beautiful voice and a stable voice, I think ailee is better than her with her powerful voice.) 3.Luna (Stable and on pitch, but still wait for some little improvement) 4.Wendy(Not stable in live, but listen to the other version than this, I think she is better than Kei. Also, I think she will have great improvement of her powerful voice.) 5.Kei(It's ok at first, but at last u can hear that her skills is not that good. Other point, her voice is not powerful enough but she still have a beautiful voice tough) Well. I think Wendy and Kei still have a great improvement and of course I know that they just dubuted for about 1 to 2 years . I have a great hope on them.
1. Ailee (strong vocals and stage presence) 2. Taeyeon (well, she's the original, has amazing vocals and her stage presence is powerful) 3. Kei (she moved really well on the stage and cooperated great with Amber) 4. Luna (of course good vocals, confident smile) 5. Wendy (a bit awkward, but nice voice and she is really pretty)
i think 1. Ailee, she's just Goddess 2. Kei, Taeyeon (Their voices are similar) 3. Wendy (Her voice is really strong, but not here) 4. Luna (I don't know, what to say. Actually, i don't know her voice and its ability)
Luna is the best singer in SM when it comes to technic, but since it had a loud backtrack she had to stick to Taeyeon's version of the high note and so she couldn't do her best...
+Dragenye luna is actually on the same level as chen. they're both competent to good vocalists and taeyeon is only considered competent vocalist so they are 1 lever above taeyeon. ailee is one of the best kpop female vocalists out there. she is considered good to great vocalist which is like 3 levels above taeyeon.
ailee’s is the best. the other girls all bring something unique, so it’s nice hearing all the different versions. ailee’s sounded the most clean, the most impressive, and just more pleasing to the ear holes though.
That's what makes Ailee so superior. kpop idols' generally sing karaoke style, ie they don't put their own spin to it. they just sing like how the original singer sings it. it's what people call musicianship. the fact that Ailee's able to change the original and give her own version of it is commendable. I don't know if you're very familiar with Ailee. she never covers any song exactly like the original singer. what she's doing is really hard and not many idols are skilled enough to do it
what i mean is that i doesn't seem right for me, it might change in other person's point of view btw its my opinion, again for me it kinda doesn't suit it but its different for yah so yeah
![Amber & Ailee - Shake That Brass / Uptown Funk [Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/aW9D5VJ11RU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Amber & Ailee - Shake That Brass / Uptown Funk [Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook]](/img/tr.png)
i think ailee did the best because she has the strongest vioce in my opinion i think the others did a good Job too
totally agree, I think ailee and kei did it best tbh
agree 100% and ailee has a distinctive voice so you can tell it's her singing
i definitely think that ailee did better amongst them with her strong voice.
I agree
Me too. I love the extra ad-libs that Ailee did!
Taeyeon and Ailee is the best
True
taeyeon and ailee for sure
True
Ailee is the only one without a dominant backtrack and she still slayed them all. She has the soul and skill. She has a astoundingly powerful voice that no one deny. She even made it her own. Props to Queen Ailee for being so goddamn amazing. ❤️
ailee is one of the best female vocalist of kpop. all her notes were well supported and they were powerful. she was actually 1 semitone above the others I think but she still slayed. she is a good to great vocalist claimed by professionals and taeyeon is only considered competent.
savagekook ・ Finally, there is a person to end this nonsense battle
savagekook ・ yes bcz it was sketchbook
@Neko Charm the person just gave a well-researched facts, that's all..
@Neko Charm there has been some analyses done and there were tiers or ranking systems made to clearly see the different technical levels between each vocalist. That's all..i suggest you to read them to further understand..and the analysts literally watched and listened to hundreds of videos of the artists to analyse them. So, they do KNOW..
Taeyeon so good
yeah
True
my ranking:
1.Ailee(of course,she's the queen)
2.Taeyeon
3.Luna
4.Kei
5.Wendy
Same~
+Kemuel Avena Same :D
same....ailee she's d one..
same
+Kemuel Avena ailee sounded hela nasally tf? she does too much anyway lol.
I don't think it's fair to compare singers having to sing over Taeyeon's original to not having to. Ailee sounds better because she didn't have to try to match. Still they all sound good, lol.
;-)
But there is no different to Taeyeon between sing it in live or not :)
Thats true, there was no MR. Good catch.
True
Then they should've done their own version..but why didn't they?
Holy shit Ailee killed it.
And yes, these fine ladies are the best female vocalists K-Pop currently have.
Yuju and sejeong...
She wasn’t actually singing. She laughs during part of it.
@@adamsmoberly
She was still singing lmfao.
For me, Taeyeon"s voice really is the perfect fit for Shake That Brass. I love Amber and Ailee's version but I thought that Ailee's voice was too strong that it didn't fit the song that well.
jajjangsoo omg yes
jajjangsoo agree 100%
agree!!!
Really? I felt like her voice helped. Like the song was hype but you needed something to kick start the engine once it got closer to the ending.
jajjangsoo totally agree. Ailee's voice is wonderful but I think its too strong and seems like overwhelm other voice. Taeyeon's voice so sweet and strong enough so taeyeon would be more suitable.
always Taeyeon...because his voice sofe and strong in one
Awidh Agus omg yes
Agree... and *her
I think Ailee and Luna were the best
they were.
1. ailee
2. luna
Not really taeyeon and luna are on same level but aliee is better
Jhopeis Mine taeyeon’s is the recording version, she’s great live but she struggled sometime w this part live
At least Taeyeon and Luna sung live. Ailee laughs while she’s singing, and not the type where it’s possible to do both.
@@adamsmoberly
Ailee has better vocals than both of them sit this one out lol.
Taeyeon and Ailee both did a good job. Taeyeon is a mature and steady vocal who can carry that part of the song perfectly. Ailee has a deeper, huskier voice that sounds really nice with Amber's. Both their voices fit well with the song. 👍👍👍
Well the song was more built for Taeyeons voice but Ailee is a better vocalist. Luna kind of disappointed me because she's generally much stronger than that. I don't like the fact that the girls were dubbed over with Taeyeon's voice during the belt note because it's a lot harder to judge. But I think it's like
1. Ailee
2. Taeyeon
3. Kei
4. Luna
5. Wendy
The same idea here...
+Catz1a same here~
same~
kei is 3rd *-*
true ♡
1. Ailee (Best high note, the most stable and she has a good singing technique)
2. Taeyeon (She has a beautiful voice, sing stability)
3. Wendy (Maybe her high notes is not very good, but she has finished her line in the perfectly way. Her vocals is great, very beautiful)
4. Luna (Beautifully singing, beautiful voice. Good at handling song but her voice is so low that I think her power is not strong enough)
5. Kei (She can control her high notes but they are not high enough. She has revealing the backing vocals, weakest vocals of all)
That is my opinion, do you agree me?
Well I guess some point of ur opinion I agree. But out of all these girls Kei is the only rookie. So yeah I'm not that surprise u would place Kei last.
Wendy is a rookie too :x
+Kang Mynnie oh lol I was thinking abt ailee Luna Taeyeon.I forgot abt wendy. but Wendy is from rv? rt?
Yes, she's from SM's RV
+Kang Mynnie luna va antes que wendy
Taeyeon ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
True
태연-루나-웬디
스엠 여돌 메보 라인 웅장하다
닮은 듯 다른 그녀들
i think the best :
1 ailee
2 luna
3 kei
4 taeyeon
5 wendy
I like Kei and Ailee the most. I just love how clear Kei's voice is and i think it really matches the song. And no need to explain Ailee, she's the queen.
Yasss! True that! I love kei's voice!∩__∩ and ailee just slayed it!=￣ω￣=
Ailee was definitely the best^^ her voice is just so good and strong*-* but Kei was the cutest :D
girl same! they were 1 and 2 for me
yes. and i totally agree that kei is the cutest. 😁💕
Same
Now!
#1 Ailee
#2 Chungha
#3 Taeyeon
#4 Luna
#5 Wendy
#6 Kei
Taeyeon is the best for me!! :)
1. Ailee
2. Kei
3. Taeyeon
4. Luna
5. Wendy
I agree
No.......kei the worst Wendy no 1
Yan Yu YOU ARE REALLY FUNNY :))) STUPID FANGIRL ! KEI VOICE IS BETTER THAN WENDY !
Zhi Min 1.Ailee 2.taeyeon 3.wendy 4.luna 5.kei
I love the way Ailee mumbled at 1:09 like singing is the easiest thing in the world for her OMG
JinO Chil i love that mumbeling so muchhhh i just cant stay away from the repeat button
1Taeyeon
2 Ailee
3....
4....
5....
I think only Tae and Ailee did amazing.
1. Ailee (has a legendary voice and she can easily hit high notes)
2. Taeyeon (great and a strong vocalist, can also reach high notes specially in her part and she also has a nice husky high voice)
3. Wendy (collaborative in reaching the high note but not as much as Taeyeon and Ailee.)
4. Kei( ok vocalist but cannot prefer the high note as Taeyeon and Ailee)
5. Luna (Great vocalist but cannot reach the high note like Taeyeon and Ailee)
^ you dont carw if she is bias. As you said its his/her opinion so if you dont like the rank then give your own damn rank and put luna in the first place. Im not being bias here cause for me im putting taengoo in the first place but its her opinion so shut your damn mouth and give your own damn ranking
+Elle D youre angry because your bias is placed in the last spot.. Dont mock others on being biased when you yourself are biased. Its pathetic. I agree that luna shouldnt be put on the last place but dont act like you know vocals just because you like luna. Who cares about what sm staffs say? They can easily say anything they want on whoever they like and support, and it is sad that you shape your opinion based on their words and not your ears.
+Aisyah Yusroh preach 🙌🏻
My opinion
1. Ailee (She made it so easy to reach the high note or either sing)
2. Kei (Her clear voice is nice and she didn't have problem with the high note)
3. Taeyeon (The real version + her husky voice is cool)
(They all have unique and strong voices)
And
4. Luna (That high note seemed easy for her but tbh her voice is just as good as normal...)
5. Wendy (It looked like she found a bit difficult in the high note and her voice isn't that special)
Honestly, Wendy is a much singer better than Kei with a slightly better technique, though I'm not saying Kei is bad because she is also my bias from Lovelyz. Kei's version was worst considering she was really, really out of tune with the high note at the end.. I would agree Wendy had some slight trouble, but she sounded fine before the high note. I'd rather hear that than bad intonation.
^
No, Wendy was the worst and always will be.
Lmfao. And your reason is? Yeah, I don't think you have a legit reason to say so. You obviously don't have ears to even notice how bad Kei's was. Come back when you are reasonable. : )
Lmao. You don't have a left reason either. Everyone who has working ears said Wendy was the worst on here, and other TH-cam videos too, so please, sit down.
The only thing that wasn't the best were her runs. But other than that, she was more on pitch than Kei. If you don't know what that even is then my 6 years of music training must've meant nothing then. : ) And besides, I did give my reasons, so why don't you reread my comment.
1.taeyeon&ailee
2.luna
3.kei
4.wendy
I
love
ailee❤️
솔직히 처음 들었을 때는 태연이 진짜 쩐 것 같았는데 에일리 진짜 넘사벽….
no taeyeon no fun!TAEYEON
Yes
My ranking:
1. Taeyeon
2. Luna
3. Ailee
4. Kei
5. Wendy
ailee is the best 😤
what Ailee1
it's my idea. Because Ailee's voice not suit this song
What Ailee best voice+Thuy Trang
but her voice not suit this song
This shows why taeyeon is queens of main vocalist. Only Luna was able to sing that run in the end. Ailee could have done it but she hit a high note there instead.
I think that Taeyeon's voice is the best!!
True
This is my opinion;
1.Taeyeon (She's the original singer n that part suits her incredible voice)
2.Ailee (She slayed it! I love it coz she done it with her own style! And that's Ailee. That high note doe)
3.Luna (She did great. And her voice sounds stable too)
4.Kei (Although she's pretty new, she did a great job. Her high note was on point too.Proud of her)
5.Wendy (She's my fav mem of RV. I really like her vocal. But she was lacking something. Yet, her performance was great too!)
1. Kei (People need to go easy on her 'cause she's a rookie. Her voice sounded the clearest to me)
2. Ailee (She had a small advantage since it was performed in Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook. Her voice was a little too soulful though)
3. Luna (Luna is underrated and she's my bias in F(x), but I couldn't hear her voice clearly. She suits this song the best IMO)
4. Wendy (Wendy is also a rookie and her voice is good, but it wasn't as clear and her note wasn't good)
MY OPINION!!! I didn't include Tayeon since she didn't sing live but I know she would have been great. She suits this song the best along with Luna.
Daphne Song Taeyeon SANG it live on SMTown..that is her only time singing it live tho..but she HAS a live performance at least..:D more than nothing
Daphne Song errggghhh... kei have the worst technique around there. ailee is the best (resonant, runs with precicions and pitch accuracy, and musicianship), second was luna (good notes, but her runs were sloppy), the third is wendy and taeyeon (atb the same level) and the last, kei.... she's the worst... not the best....
fudanshi akut excuse me, Kei is just a 20 year old girl who debuted in Lovelyz just in November 2014. She's a rookie and her voice is actually even better than Jin or Sujeong (in Lovelyz). Her voice is fresh and clear all the time. When I first knew the 8 girls and listening to Candy Jelly Love and Good Night like Yesterday, the only voice that I can recognize is Kei. Don't judge her like she know nothing! She's the main vocal in Lovelyz and she didn't make any appearance like the unnies before but she sings really well (like not enough experiences. I know.) So plz, I think Kei do have talents.
My list is:
1. Ailee (well, duh, her voice is strong)
2. Luna
3. Kei (I think she do sing better than Wendy)
4. Wendy (she's my bias in Red Velvet along with Seulgi, but I think she didn't sing really well.)
Plz don't blame on my English. i'm Chinese
sinyin 30 i never said that kei doenst have tallent. she have tallent but compare to wendy wendy have A LOT potential. all that kei have is just a beatiful tone. just it. wendy? not only have a good voice but also have a good technique. she supports her voice batter, place her voice better than kei. kei can hit high note but not with good technique. wendy is aWAY better so, if you said she didnt sing well, then you should say "very bad" for kei.
Daphne Song 1.Ailee 2.taeyeon 3.wendy 4.luna 5.kei
the fact that Ailee forgot the lyrics but people doesnt seem to care because she's awesome like that
Mikki Amane yeap she did. watch again
1:09 she forgot the lyric and mumble things and laugh it off. i will not call u that. ;)
1:09 she forgot the lyric and mumble things and laugh it off. i will not call u that. ;)
Mikki Amane haha it was after 2 secs i guess? haha no prob!
For me:
1. Ailee
2. Taeyeon
3. Luna
4. Wendy
5. Kei
Luna and Ailee for me, Wendy and Kei's runs were so sloppy.
Yes ailee is amazing!!
ya ailee' voice is always stable n strong
i agree that kei n wendy r singing out of tone
Karen Fong tune**
Karen Fong i agree
agreed their runs were sloppy.. it could be because they're rookies or they just don't have that agility in their voice
taeyeon
bich dao Do omg yes
bich dao Do agreeeeee
Agree!!!
of course Ailee is won.
I mean Ailee is almost flawless but her voice is just to powerful and too strong for the song
1. Ailee (queen)
2. Taeyeon (princess)
3. Luna
For me
1.Taeyeon is the best
2.Ailee is very good
3.Luna is very good too
4.Kie is good
5Wendy her voice is strong but not in this song
+111111111111111🙆🙆🙆
I am totally agree with you ❤ Taeyeon is the best ❤
Seanrhylee Cesario agreeeee
Seanrhylee Cesario
Hell WTF ? Ailee and Luna are much better than Taeyeon... and Wendy is a bit better than Taeyeon. So WTF are you saying ?
1.Ailee
2.Luna
3.Wendy
4.Taeyeon
5.Kei
1.Ailee
2.Taeyeon
3.Wendy
4.Luna
5.Kei
Kpop Girl's Paymy luna is better
1.taeyeon
Ailee her voice hear like 'Sengau' and his breathing not long but ailee have a power, so taeyeon is better than sing this part because taeyeon stabil better than ailee...
This list :
1. TaeYeon
2. Ailee (ailee have a short breath)
3. Luna
4. Wendy
5. Kei
Tae - Ai - Lu - Kei - Wen
1.taeyeon
Taeyeon of course, but ailee was impressive with her powerful voice as usual but she changed the actual part so wasnt impressed by that.
You just said my mind
taeyeon 😍😍
that's called musicianship...
+TheMschelsea91 Agreed. That's what true artists do.
Taeyeon's was through the MV, so you don't know if they auto-tuned her voice or fixed it up, they obviously used the best take of what she did. Ailee's was live, and Ailee is still vocally better than Taeyeon.
1.Ailee&Taeyeon
2.Kei
3.Luna
4.Wendy
1. Taeyeon
2. Ailee
3. Wendy
4. Luna
Ailee sent literal shivers down my spine. I still have goosebumps!
Love her
Ailee is awesome! Her singing techniques are perhaps the best among them :)) Taeyeon is great too, I think she can do as great as the CD version or even better when she sings live. Her live is always amazing
Wendy and Luna did it live tho.
AILEE!!! and then Luna but Ailee 100%
1. Ailee
2. Luna
3. Taeyeon
4. Kei
5. Wendy
agree
+Yokiko fujin me too
+Karla Medina Agree 200%
1. Taeyeon ( She's the oficial and the best )
2.Ailee
3.Luna
4.Kei
5.Wendy
1.ailee
2.tae
3.kei
4.luna
5.wendy
Does anybody notice that ailee wasn't even trying?
Ailee ♡♡♡♡♡
Tae yeon ♡♡♡♡
Kei ♡♡♡
Luna ♡♡
Wendy ♡
true😝♥
+mery sweet I agree
Luna did better than Kei
That Is My Prerogative don't think so!
mery sweet Well you're entitled to your wrong opinion. Jkjk well sort of lmao!
I love ailee but Taeyeon's voice was the perfect fit for the song
Ailee's version is the best, her voice has so much power and I like how she belted that high note....Kei's voice is perfect for the song though
1-TAEYEON QUEEN
Taeyeon the best for me
Second Ailee
For me:
1. Ailee (of course, she's the queen)
2. Kei
3. Taeyeon
4. Luna
5. Wendy (I guess she was too nervous, she can do better)
Taeyeonnn
1.Taeyeon
2.Luna
3.Ailee
4.Kei
5.Wendy
My choice
1.Ailee (Everyone know, no need explain)
2.Taeyeon (Although she has a beautiful voice and a stable voice, I think ailee is better than her with her powerful voice.)
3.Luna (Stable and on pitch, but still wait for some little improvement)
4.Wendy(Not stable in live, but listen to the other version than this, I think she is better than Kei. Also, I think she will have great improvement of her powerful voice.)
5.Kei(It's ok at first, but at last u can hear that her skills is not that good. Other point, her voice is not powerful enough but she still have a beautiful voice tough)
Well. I think Wendy and Kei still have a great improvement and of course I know that they just dubuted for about 1 to 2 years . I have a great hope on them.
actually Wendy is a much stronger vocalist. she's better than Taeyeon technically. but yeah, this song doesn't suit her
TheMschelsea91 yeah, but she really needs more pratice.
HARA GU she needs practice on her runs that's for sure
NO...!!! TAEYEON IS THE BEST
Crafty Reign yyour opinion of course
1. Ailee (strong vocals and stage presence)
2. Taeyeon (well, she's the original, has amazing vocals and her stage presence is powerful)
3. Kei (she moved really well on the stage and cooperated great with Amber)
4. Luna (of course good vocals, confident smile)
5. Wendy (a bit awkward, but nice voice and she is really pretty)
to be honest taeyeon has the natural voice that goes with this song but ailee just slayed it with that high note
Ailee definitely... Others are good but Ailees got the soul.
i did't love taeyeon so much but she win beacuse her voice is so strong and so beatiful🌝💐💛
i agree with you
+فهد الحربي I pefer ailee
ailee sounded much stronger btw
Fahad I found Ailee much better
Taeyeon voice is the best . no one can ever beat her , saranghae Kim taeyeon ❤❤❤
why did she have so many people sing it? i love ailee and luna’s, they have such strong voices.
1:taeyeon 😍😍😍😌👌
True
It would be hard to choose between Tae Yeon and Ailee if it was a ballad song. But when it comes to powerful song, Ailee slays all the way
Taeyeon! because Amber choose her in her music video
역시 에일리는 넘사벽..
Ya'll can say that Ailee did this part the best. But Taeyeon's can really blend well with the song vibe.
Well duh she started it
1.taeyeon
2.ailee
3.luna
4.wendy
My Ranking :
1 Taeyeon
2 Ailee
3 Luna
4 Kei
5 Wendy ..
# Shake that brass is the best
#Fighting
Taeyeon is the best💟💟💟
다 잘 하는데 이렇게 들으니까 태연이 너무 넘사다..
괜히 믿듣탱이라는 말까지 나오는 게 아니구나 싶음
Ailee was the absolute best 😜
Ailee's slaying. Korean female singers, don't ever try to compete with Ailee. She's almost insurmountable.
i think
1. Ailee, she's just Goddess
2. Kei, Taeyeon (Their voices are similar)
3. Wendy (Her voice is really strong, but not here)
4. Luna (I don't know, what to say. Actually, i don't know her voice and its ability)
Luna is the best singer in SM when it comes to technic, but since it had a loud backtrack she had to stick to Taeyeon's version of the high note and so she couldn't do her best...
+Dragenye luna is actually on the same level as chen. they're both competent to good vocalists and taeyeon is only considered competent vocalist so they are 1 lever above taeyeon. ailee is one of the best kpop female vocalists out there. she is considered good to great vocalist which is like 3 levels above taeyeon.
+iamnoturmum Nop, Luna and Chen are only a HALF lvl over Taeyeon, they are between Competent and Good.
Шутчан I don't think taeyeon and kei has same voices lol
I think teayeon did a great job well it the original version and also ailee because of her powerful voice ..
for me:
1. Ailee
2. Taeyeon
3. Kei
4. Luna
5. Wendy
Im Sone,But I think Ailee Is The Best
2.Taeyeon
3.Wendy
4.Luna
5.Kei
Are Its Just My Feeling?I Feel I Hear Taeyeon's Voice When Kei Finish Her Long Note
+Choi Mio I think so too
+Choi Mio Yeahhh... I think so..
Me too i'm sone but i totally agree
me too
Taeyeon no.1🥇🥇🥇🏆
Taeyeons wins the original Queen
I think....Ailee is better then they all
1.Ailee
2.Taeyeon
3.Luna
4.Wendy
5.Kei
+AngelsOfAce Park ChoA where is kei from?
+TzeXin Chew Lovelyz
Avril Pallar thx
yeah yeah .. ❤️❤️❤️❤️
kei and ailee owned it
1-Ailee
2-Luna
3-Taeyeon Kei
4-Wendy
1) Kei
2) Ailee
3) Taeyeon
4) Luna
5) Wendy
same here 😘
RLFI cover group kei is the best!!!
They're all amazing, but I'm disappointed that taeyeon didn't sing in live, so I'll choose Ailee and Kei, I Like how ailee do the High note :Dc
For me
1. Taeyeon
2. Ailee
3. Luna
4. Wendy
5. Kei
ailee was the best i think because she put her own twist on it but luna did the best for coping how taeyeon originally did it
ailee’s is the best. the other girls all bring something unique, so it’s nice hearing all the different versions. ailee’s sounded the most clean, the most impressive, and just more pleasing to the ear holes though.
for me :
1. Taeyeon
2. Ailee
3 4 5 other people
For me taeyeon and kei was the best tho, i like ailee but the changing the tone kinda is not good for me
That's what makes Ailee so superior. kpop idols' generally sing karaoke style, ie they don't put their own spin to it. they just sing like how the original singer sings it. it's what people call musicianship. the fact that Ailee's able to change the original and give her own version of it is commendable. I don't know if you're very familiar with Ailee. she never covers any song exactly like the original singer. what she's doing is really hard and not many idols are skilled enough to do it
what i mean is that i doesn't seem right for me, it might change in other person's point of view btw its my opinion, again for me it kinda doesn't suit it but its different for yah so yeah
+TheMschelsea91 i can do IT C: but i have to listen and enjoy to that song
+Wonho's Property That's musicianship, man!
+Wonho's Property It suits because she was able to change and convey the emotions and her note was consistent and resonance.
에일리가 쓸었네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Taeyeon ♡♡♡
I think
1.Taeyeon
2.Wendy
3.Ailee
4.Luna
5.Kei
But truly Taeyeon always
I'm a huge fan of Ailee, and I loved her voice best out of all the singers. But I think that Taeyon's voice fitted this song best.
besides Taeyeon (since she's the original one), I like Luna the most :)
My opinion
#1Ailee
#2 TaeYeon😍
#3 Luna
#4 Wendy 😍
#5 Kei