'Charlie Sees Vampire Bella & Renesmee' Scene | The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn - Part 2
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.พ. 2023
- Charlie (Billy Burke) goes to the Cullen house to see Bella (Kristen Stewart) and meet his granddaughter, Renesmee. He accepts she is now recovered and this is her chosen life, but he does not know what has changed her or where Renesmee came from, but she's 'adopted'.
#TheDollarTheater #Twilight #BreakingDawn
Subscribe to The Dollar Theater here - bit.ly/3o9KQZF
Watch The Full Movie Now: www.lionsgate.com/franchises/...
Follow Lionsgate on Twitter - bit.ly/3y3LGvy
Follow Lionsgate on Facebook - bit.ly/3bhliot
Follow Lionsgate on TikTok - bit.ly/3y3JjZV
Lionsgate presents: The Dollar Theater’s official TH-cam channel! Come for the ONE DOLLAR MOVIES, stay to enjoy clips of all your favorites. Subscribe and stay tuned... more ONE DOLLAR MOVIES coming soon! - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
Twilight is really the story of the suffering of this poor broken man just trying to have a relationship with his daughter but then vampires decide to ruin everything for him. He decorated a whole room for her with purple and everything. Poor Charlie.
Charlie is a vampire hunter.
Agreed, poor Charlie :/
True 😔
Very well concluded...never thought it this way before but yeah,poor charlie!
He is in fire country go watch it
As a parent, first thing that would have went through my mind is SHE’S IN A CULT WITH THESE WEIRDOS 😂
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Intervention asap
And you would be right.
A plastic surgeries cult or sth 😂
I swear this whole scene gives that vibe
The utter exhaustion and pain in that man’s eyes when he asked her if she’s okay BROOOOO Charlie did not deserve to be put through so much shit
but his son in law's side of the family is so rich.
Hi good nagnit
This shows that Jacob did the right thing knowing it was unfair for her to skip out on her father as he would’ve never see her again
@@CapricornGilberti think it'd been better. Least he'd have been able to mourn one final time and be done. Now, yeah, he has his daughter but his future with her will be clouded with uncertainty that he can never know the truth of. Like how his daughter doesn't seem to age over the years. His granddaughter doesn't age beyond a certain point. Or how Jacob is putting the moves on his granddaughter when hes supposed to be 20 years older. And what if the Volturri gets ANOTHER wild hair up their ass and the Cullen's gotta leave anyways, somewhere down the line? Least if he got word she died he can mourn properly one final for sure time
@@rogergarrison4271Listen I’m team Charlie but no. Because id rather have those wonders and have the relationship and memories vs not. Him grieving her would have been catastrophic for Charlie. He was so heart broken when she left him and said she was going back to Florida. Charlie just loves his daughter and wants to have time and space with her. He’s willing to deal with whatever just to have that. Hell he saw Jacob turn into a werewolf. He gon be alright lmao.
I love Charlie!!!! Poor guy suffered and was left in the dark so much in this series
I witch Bella could tell her dad
@@lathafalls7675 Me too
Its a movie
@@lathafalls7675 i witch he would to
@@lathafalls7675wish. A witch is someone who’ has powers. A wish is a strong desire or hope for something that is not easily attainable.🤣🤡
The “watched a kid I’ve known his whole life turn into a very large dog” will never not crack me up
“My daughter looks like my daughter…. but doesn’t.”
I feel the misery in Charlie's eyes. It's so emotional thinking about his daughter like that.
You do know hes acting and this is a movie right............
Respuestas 💖💖😍😍🤜🤛
I thought he looked disappointed because of the CGI baby
Hi good night Edward cullen Roberto Pattinson I am the one in the profile photo the original and official the baby mama you and my husband and truth the original and official the profile photo I'm alive
Great actor !
Charlie - "She's got your eyes, Bella"
I love that line from Charlie.
Followed by, "Did they put those eyes in with CGI too?"
Gots her double chin too
But Bella does not have "her eyes" anymore. She has red vampire eyes.
Red only if you drink human blood. Plus she had contacts in@@lulub1433
Humm
Did anybody else notice that small detail when Charlie hugged his daughter and he felt how "cold" she was
cold and hard
she was cold to Charlie even before she was a vampire.
Yes, I don't understand why SHE didn't just tell him alone. She is worried about the Volturi finding out, BUT BELLA, YOU ARE A SHIELD! Their powers don't work on you.
@@ShortymayShortymay because they can read Charlie's mind and if they find out that he knows. They will come after him. Better safe then sorry. She cared for her father's protection, safety and life
@@StonedTotheBones0000 So true, but come on. He just seen Jacob turn into a werewolf. I'm quite sure he knows that she is a vampire or something else, even if she didn't tell him and Renessme is aging and growing faster than he is losing hair. The lawyer has suspicions ( he knows)about Alice and Jasper since they don't age after all those years working for them and now about Bella. The Volturi hasn't come for him.
I feel so bad for Charlie. He went through so much, with no explanation. What a secret to have to keep from your own dad...
His fault. He literally said in books that he doesnt want to know too much. Just basics. No strange things. He was kinda happy as a granfather and he had Sue to explain him some things (like Renesmee fast growing).
Read books and then comment.
Hi good nagnit ❤❤❤
I think Charlie kinda figured it out. Even though Bella didn't right out tell both in books and movies. She hinted to him. After seeing Jacob become what he was. I think he figured out Bella wasn't at least human.
Better off that way. Fathers need to know nothing about their daughters.
it's risky cuz Edward can read his mind and and the Vultury can read from Edward
it's to safe Charlie's life
3:08 his confused face when hugging her is because she is cold and her skin probably feels different, but he just accepts it because he loves her. It would be like hugging her corpse, but she is “alive”
She also as hard as rock coz vampire r strong af
Charlie was the best character in the whole series. I felt so bad for him, he honestly was trying his best to be a good parent
When Bella's father hugs her, he noticed that she was cold.
And hard
I know the look on his face gave me chills
If he'll find out eventually, he'll probably keep it to himself to protect her
I just noticed that
He knows what she is.
Bro I will never get over why they couldn’t just use a real baby 😂
That's not a real baby🙆♀️🤦♀️
😂 it's shite!
What you don't think it's cute? 🤣🤣
Ikr that cgi baby was creepy af.
Yes that was really off putting. You can fine a baby with older sisters that you can cast if you want the child to have similar features as the character ages.
“Can you live with that?”
“Can I live with that….”
Charlie out here giving the real performance in this series.
Charlie has to be the most well adjusted person in the world.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂❤❤❤❤❤❤
“She’s got your eyes Bella”
The baby: 👁️👄👁️
CGI baby is one of the greatest cinematic choices of all time
Lmaoooo😭😭😭
Watching this as a teen drooling for Edward VS watching this as an adult drooling for Charlie, how the hell did that happen!?
ayo 😭😭😭
😂😂😂😂🤷♀️
Doesn’t the time fly
It is a very natural evolution :D :D :D
Lol
The CGI baby I can't.
What does CGI mean?
@@shiorilumine2003 Computer Generated Imagery. Sometimes it's done so well you can't tell it apart from reality, and then other times you get Bella's baby and you have to take a time out to settle your stomach.
@NightRunner417 oh ok thank you for tell me.
at least that same CGI baby was able to find work some years later as adult Luke Skywalker in the season two finale of The Mandalorian. Apparently he was referred by his fellow actor/friend 'semi- CGI baby' Grogu.
@@al28854 🤣🤣
The really trippy part is that he also managed to somehow go back in time even later in life to play the part of Tarkin in Rogue One. Dude really gets around!
Charlie was always my favorite character in these movies. I know watch him in anything I find out he is in. He is a very good actor. This scene had me in tears because he just wants to hold on to his daughter and he knows that somehow the baby is theirs. He looks at her with so much love. It was funny when Jake turned into a “Really Big Dog”! 😂
You mean a werewolf
@@lathafalls7675 No I meant “Really Big Dog” in quotation marks because that is how Charlie says it to Bella. It is a quote. If I had meant werewolf, I would have said it. Pay attention when you read for comprehension instead of just reading over it and become the correction police because you missed grammar markings!!
Have you seen "Revolution" ? He is one of the main character. It's a really good TV show, kind of a mix between The 100 and The walking dead (without zombies though)
@@CamilleDechorgnat yes, I saw it! I loved it! He was so hot in that show. He’s been in a few things and I’m really glad to see him every time!
@@maribiddle5859 the show was so good ! I'm devastated that they stopped it after season 2 😨 Do you know where I can watch it again ? I tried streaming but the quality is meh 🤢
His daughter died. If only he knew. Really sad and heartbreaking if you think about it.
It's not like she died, she's still there, her mind emotions and everything, that isn't death, like she said she just had to change, she might not be human anymore but death is something else, that's her body and mind, she just looks more beautiful and she's harder than a statue, and cold...but it's still Bella, not a robot, or a clone, or an illusion or a ghost or anything like that, it's literally still his daughter Bella, just frozen
I love how even though his curiousity is just dying to know what happened. He trusts his daughter. I think maybe deep down he knows something "supernatural" happened to her but he just doesn't know exactly WHAT it is. But he trusts his daughter. If I were Bella, I'd have just told him. "I'm not telling you for your safety".
The Volturi could kill him. There are not many humans who know about Vampires. There are a few in Volterra serving directly to the Volturi, hoping to be changed (and not eaten). But usually no one knows...
Your right i think he knows has a hunch because she is different she looks different acts it too. Funny how he said You don't turn into one of them dogs too LOL Jacob she wishes LOL.
As a cop, that would raise every red flag under the sun, and probably a few fire proof ones sitting right on the surface of it. The slightest hint of danger, and he'd spit in the Volturi's eyes trying to discover it.
I mean it's easy to put together Jake a wolf the others are not...vampires would be the obvious choice
He knew about it.
Jacob did tell him that they couldn't tell you for your safety.
And, the only thing he could knew that they're not normal.
this part was so sad. Charlie deserved better and Bella was out of her mind.
Aro can read every thought you ever have. If anyone told him, the volturi would find out eventually and use it as an excuse to attack the cullens. Even if Bella, on her own decided to tell charlie (since she is immune to telepathy), Edward would have read Charlie's mind, and then the volturi might find out next time Aro read edward's mind.
@@katringeorgsdottir8459 Didn’t Edward have trouble reading Charlie’s mind?
@@Cris212 totally forgot about that. I guess it depends on how unclear his thoughts are to edward
@@Cris212 No he didn't. I read all the books and I don't ever remember that being a thing. In fact, they used his mind reading to know when he was coming up to her room so he could leave, and he tells Bella what he's thinking sometimes
@@fullfire0 in midnight sun, Edward says Bella got the mind shield from Charlie. Unlike other's loud thoughts, he could only get the context of the thoughts. Not all the information
Charlie knows his own daughter when he sees her and yet instinctively he felt something was off!
I love the "need to know, I guess" line as he fully knows it's her true daughter and not adopted and its falling into place that something is defo up but its better he doesn't know the truth/full extent
Yep, the "she's got your eyes, Bella" - he knows Renesmee is hers but he's not saying it
Ekaqdqcskk😅
How did the baby's face render even made it to the final production? 🤣🤣🤣
Well how did Cedric die and become Edward
If you think that is bad, you should see the original puppet they wanted to use.
Look up Chuckesme and you'll be grateful for this rendering
Nothing beats the fake baby in American Sniper. Laughable.
by not hiring Industrial Light & Magic
Acceptance and love is in every reaction that her father gives. Coming from that much love she could be a wonderful Mom.
Tô viva ❤❤
“Jacob put your clothes back on” lives rent free in my head forever.
I can see the pain of a father.
'"Can I live with that? Well, I don't know. I just saw a kid I knew his entire life turn into a very large dog.'"
@@castlenovelist97BOOKS what happened to that kid
"It's got your eyes Bella"
When you see what the doll they used actually looked like, I imagine that would have been hard to say while keeping a straight face hahahaha
She
@@alexsera3966 honestly, "it" feels far more appropriate lmao
Tbf, in this scene they did use a real baby but changed the face with CGI. The real baby was WAY cuter!
I like how in the book, when Charlie accepts it, he sits down & watches the game. He spends the whole day with the Cullens. & I think Seth & his sis comes too.
Poor Charlie seeing that she's okay but knowing somehow he's lost the daughter He knew
Charlie deserved better. He was such a good person, so mistreated by everyone he loved.
Whatever else I have to say about twilight the relationship between bella and charlie was absolutely beautiful
Amo você tô viva graça a DEUS E TODO PODEROSO AMEM
🤍🤍🤍
lies
Charlie's reaction after noticing that Bella and Resnesmee have the same eyes bittersweet, realizing in that moment he has a biological granddaughter, but has no idea how that could be since Bella's pregnancy was much, much shorter than an average woman's. I stopped being a fan of Twilight years ago, but the way this scene is portrayed is very sweet
I chalked it off to Charlie believing Bella was pregnant when she got married and hid the pregnancy because Bella wouldn't want Edward blamed... or targeted by Charlie.
@@theninjacat7200 never thought about it like that; good point
Just to think that Charlie is thinking that his barely 19 year old daughter just got married and adopted a baby and with her new appearance similar to the rest of the Cullens, probably thinks shes in a cult
She was
@@Black.Sabbath No she was in a coven. A cult is when a group of people have something they worship
@@johnnyc8669 Bella worshipped the idea of immortality. The diamond skin.
I'm so glad the world is charlie stans. He's the real star
❤❤❤
❤❤❤❤
the dud that played the dad literally has the best acting in the entire show
Every fortunate father has an opportunity to see his offspring thrive and this story helps to see that journey's difficult emotional trauma. Not easy but worth every moment.
Hi good morning ❤❤❤
Charlie.. We felt so sorry for this man ever since he came in the picture.. Such a greathearted oldskool sheriff. He deserves way more credit 💯
The moment he held her, and you can see the look on Charlie's face, was so heartbreaking. I think he knew what happened then.
So he definitely felt that she is cold to the touch. It looks like he reacted to it when he hugged her.
Also, not only did his daughter get married right out of high school, but now she and her husband 'supposedly' adopted a baby, all this as supposed teens.
And he is going to eventually realize his daughter isn't aging.
The older I've gotten, the more I realize how terrible the plot was.
I feel really bad for him.
It's so sad when you realize his daughter actually died.
I cant get over the CGI baby LMAO why didnt they use a real one.
Real baby is rare commodity in America or something right?
because the thought of vegetarian vampires isn't creepy enough until you see one holding a CGI baby vampire.
They did. There’s a BTS where she pulled Kristen’s hair😂
Idk....
Because real babies can't stay focused on one thing and that's not good for acting in a movie
I wonder what renesmee was thinking seeing charlie and whether edward could read her mind lol
You mean her “grandpa”
Lol in the book, Renesmee kind of tempting to bite her grandpa. But, Bella and Edward warn her so she trying her best to behave.
It also told that actually Bella hold on to her so that she wouldn't bite him or show him her talent.
In the book she loved him immediately. Bella and Edward told her to behave with him and not to bite him and she doesn't. She loves her grandpa and despite his confusion he just accepts that she's a special child because there's no fathoming all the details
Charlie needs to live longer, he has skills and could help protect his granddaughter and help bridge the wolf clan / vampire family structure. The two grandfather's would also make a wonderful family unit, I miss these stories.
❤❤❤❤❤❤
This scene makes Me cry because he really does love his Daughter even if he wasn't the greatest Dad he tries and I can't imagine him knowing that she actually died he technically lost her. She is dead basically he would be so devastated and she knows it because he's almost lost her so many times and for him to know she died while on the honeymoon and thry all didn't tell him would devastate him even more. I just cried.
She is not dead, what are you talking about?
In fact, in this lore the vampires are SO alive that they can impregnate girls ! 😂
@@luckydevil1601yes but vampire women can't get pregnant nor give birth as the body needs to change a ton for pregnancy. They are infertile. The men's sperm is viable just like an older women becomes infertile during menopause yet men can still knock a woman up in their 80s.
@@luckydevil1601She did die in the books. She's resuscitated and given the vampire vemon as a last ditch resort directly into her chest to restart her heart, and it works. In the books she's a corpse lying on the table after practically being bisected. Jacob performs CPR relentlessly on her corpse refusing to give up on her and as he's doing that Edward finally snaps out of the shock of her dying and the birth of the daughter and bites her all over and injects a vial of his vemon directly into her heart valves
@@luckydevil1601Yes she is vampires are a soulless being dead but alive like zombies and she died her heart stopped litterly and Edward's venom brang her to life. She talking to her Dad she's dead and she knew it devistate her Dad the truth. Google it or read the books.
I like that Charlie knew something changed
Renesmee almost seems like she's going to turn into "Chucky" and start atacking people with a big knife 😂😂😂
Billy Burke is a fantastic*and underrated actor). I loved him in the series "Zoo"!
So wtf Bella gonna tell her dad when he's all gray in the head and wrinkly while she still looks in her early twenties many years later!?
he's not dumb. he's knows there something up. i don't see him being surprise 20 years down the road
I honestly don’t think it will be an issue. They’ll be able to smell when he’s close to death, or at least Carlisle will. Then, they’ll probably tell him everything. And they’ll tell him that Bella and his granddaughter will live forever. It would bring be great joy knowing that my children will live forever. It’s not like the Volturi would care if he was close to death, plus they’d probably never have a reason to see them again, at least not for the next like, 500 years or so. So Charlie will eventually know, and I think it will bring him great peace.
They can’t
Jordan Davis 19 And Tell Her in
He knows Bella is now like the Cullens and won't age but he doesn't know why. He's seen Carlisle live in the town for decades and saw that he never aged and it freaked him out but he knows that Bella is more like the Cullens than him now as he puts it.
From Charlie's perspective it looks like she lost her daughter to a cult.
1:27 Yass this is what I call, natural acting!!!!
I have to say Kristen Stewart did a good job acting as a vampire. Her acting in the previous four was not great but much better in this one.
In the first 4 it was perfect, yes, Bella is exactly like that, without expression and a little discouraged
❤❤❤❤
I love Charlie so much and his concerns for Bella.
That scene with the music at 3:17 and Charlie's line "I've missed you Bells" is so beautiful , it hits different. Kinda describes early marriage life where we're separated from our parents who raised us till then. It's so touching, from a married person's perspective.
Charlie is a real one. He deserved so much better.
It's a wonder that dad don't go crazy. That is a lot of changes to accept.
Why would he? He actually didnt know that much cause in books he just didnt wanna know /opposite in the movies as we see;he can accept that Bella is different, she still looks like her
Poor Charlie fr I just want to give him a hug
It's amazing that this story is being told with green screens, pulley systems, dolls, and all the extra thing's it takes to make this work. Thank you all for this opportunity to see and hear this fantastic story. Living in the real world is a gift and breaking all the rules to allow us to think about family and relationships is priceless.
It is PALPABLE how much Robert Pattinson hates being Edward 🤣
They should have made it so Charlie was let in on everything and got time with his grand 😭 I would have been crying for sure 💙!
Charlie does know it’s his granddaughter. He knows in the books the second he sees her eyes. And he does spend time with her. He just doesn’t know the details about Bella’s pregnancy and the vampire transformation
@@meekgeek22 yeah I’m the movie I mean, I heard the books were completely different I just haven’t read them now I’m gonna have too because I definitely want to see how that played out 💙!
@@Shantekah_98 nahh they’re pretty much the same. Only tiny little details are different. I’m re reading them again now
@@meekgeek22 thank you 😊
Problem is if Charlie was let in on everything... he'd know too much, and could be considered a threat by the Volturi (At least if I remember correctly, it was a while ago I read the series)
They'd track him down and have him killed
Poor dad. Basically she treated him like shit and left him. Guy likely could have committed suicide losing his only child.
the turn into a large dog took me out 😂
There's a reason why Charlie was always my favorite. 😢❤
“I’m back from my full body plastic surgery makeover in Switzerland, dad!”
I like to think when Charlie and Sue got together she filled him in. Sue wasn’t bound like the Vamps on telling about the Cold ones especially since Jacob phased in front of him. That’s why Charlie accepted the way things were at Christmas.
Billy Burke, you ROCK! ❤️🧡💛💚
@3:06 after reading the book and her describing the burning torture she endured while being in the same vicinity as Charlie, I can’t imagine what Bella was going through during that embrace.
LMAO why that baby look like that.
😂😂
Why can’t I stop re watching these movies. .?
Nice video ✨❤️
Notice how Charlie didn't touch Renesmee... If he did, she probably could have shown him things, which would have complicated the situation even more.
It wouldnt complicate anything, cause in books they told her to not touch him, renesmee was really smart and knew what she can and cannot do.
+ later on their meetings she didnt do that that thing with thoughts either
I think they used the CGI coz if they find a normal baby to act in this there won't be any acting at all. The baby was supposed to look like she 'knew' her surroundings, like when she saw Charlie there was some reaction there. The human-vampire baby also grow faster than an average one, so Renesmee should not be like a normal baby...? It looked creepy and weird but there's a purpose.
can't risk the non CGI baby actors getting eaten by the adult vampire actors on set before the director says 'action'. That would be causing an unsafe working environment.
she is creepier in the book, has adult proportions, a fully developed brain and teeth, and prefers human blood.
Bella as vampire daughter she can remember some memories with her dad and many memories were forgot we can a see a little
bit emotion in her face i feel very sad for charlie its makes me very cry and bella father is a braveman at all❤❤
Watched this as a teen now im a mother myself and boooyy do these scenes hit differently, i feel for charlie so much more now that i did then.
This dad can't be more open minded to life 😅
From Charlie's perspective, the Cullen's are a cult that Bella's gotten tangled up in and is too brainwashed to leave. So, no.
4:06
crying hysterically
3:50 Charlie is exhausted because of Bad CGI Baby 🥲🥲
The baby looks cute even though it was just CGI.
Oh Charlie is sad
I love this
3:09 he noticed how cold she is. Good attention to detail.
Charlie is the main victim here, and Bella being a total brat and just doing things she wants if I ever behaved like her, you might as well call the funeral place my mother would have set me straight. She’s done nothing but put Charlie in anguish with her mood sings and being desperate to be a vampire
1:54 oh come on! NO, no more going away!
I love how Charlie calls Jacob a giant dog 😂
Charlie caught so many strays.
Okay fuck this scene so hard. Charlie was the most sympathetic and most wronged character in this whole series. Dude is in the dark this whole franchise about the supernatural shit going on. He doesn't see his daughter for like 2-5 months, she gets pregnant with a demon baby, dies, and gets brought back as a fucking vampire, then when he sees her again she tells him "something's different, I just can't tell you. Also this is probably the last time we're gonna see each other." And he just takes it all. And then to top off this depressing cake, when he hugs her, he mentions that she feels cold. (Vampires are cold.) And like, I just fucking teared up because this dad just trying to do his best for his asshole, dumbass daughter, and her fucking gang of freaks show up and they ruin they're lives. Not to mention the actor playing the dad is really great in this scene, his performance was really believable so that's probably also why I got so emotional. But there is one thing wrong with this scene...
the fucking CGI baby coming around the corner and sucking all the emotion out of the moment.
They hadn't seen each other for a month. It was exactly one month and one day between the wedding and their reunion...
Charlie would have had to have known what was going on or at least had some sort of idea. You mean to tell me he never asked or wondered why the baby grew at such a fast rate?
I fell like on some level he knew
@@lakeishabriggs11 hope you didn't hurt yourself when you fell. Or did you mean feel?
@@Lions1986 lol I meant feel
seeing some on you know his whole life turned into a werewolf can change your perspectives in life, including the relationship with your child.
they're gonna make him a vampire problem solved
I feel sorry for her that Daddy parent absolutely amazing 🤩🤩
1:17 Edward: “let’s give them some privacy”
Lmaoo as if the whole house can’t still hear them! Literally!🤣🤣💀
I feel in my heart of hearts that when the special effects guys were told to make the baby they decided to make it as bad as possible to laugh at all of us fans....In any case, it is what it is. And I feel that in a few years when Twilight is a classic, they will correct it.
I would never forgive this family for turning my daughter in a walking and talking cold corpse if I was Charlie
Imagine him getting older and watching her frozen in time. Not okay
Even its been a long time movie but still I love all the scene of Twilight all of it love u all ...❤❤❤
I know some may not remember this from the book, but when Charlie asks how long Renesmee had to live, I think Jacob or Carlisle said she had 4 months.Then Renesmee waved at him.
Dood that look he had after hugging her and realizing it isnt right, knowing that she wasnt really his daughter anymore and just giving up on it... got me. It got me. Bella is a hoe for doing this to her dad.
Edward:Charlie.
Renesmee:Grandfather. 3:28
It’s been more than a decade and only now i saw this clip. 🤣
What confuses me is if he’s under the impression the baby is adopted how is he gonna say she has Bella’s eyes 😂
That was him alluding to the fact that he thinks she might be Bella’s bilingual child because Renesme looks like her. The adoption story is clearly not fully going over with him
@@oihcam22 I don’t think that’s the case cuz how would it make sense that she had a baby in the 2 weeks that she was “sick” it takes 9 months to carry a child and then ontop of that the baby had a fast growth rate that already made her look 3 months old.
@@treehugger4203because Charlie realized that something supernatural is going on but it’s ‘need to know’ information. So he’s made the connection that Nessie is their biological child but he’s willing to play along and say adopted so there’s no issues
@@oihcam22you meant biological right? Lol
He knows it's bs and they're just saying it to sheild him. In the books he knows it's Bella's daughter the moment he sees her eyes. They decide that he'll be told things only on a Need to Know basis to protect him and also to protect themselves from the Volturi. Also to stop Charlie having a heart attack as the Jacob wolf turning nearly killed him from shock lol. He just accepts eventually that Bella is like the Cullens now and that Renesme is special due to her growth and abilities. The adoption story is for the whole world so he helps protect their secret by going along with it but he does know it's Bella's bio kid. Bear in mind she gave birth within a few weeks so there's no dancing around it. Also Charlie has always known the Cullens are strange as he's seen Carlisle never age despite living in the town for decades.
She should tell him everything he deserves that
If she did he would die
That would have put his life in danger at some point with the volturi...
To do so would have put him in grave danger. Best they build their relationship on what they have now.
I like that every cut to Charlie, he blinks, but every cut to Bella, she just stares deeply into the empty abyss to show she’s dead
He would be in danger if he knew.
The Way He Looked While Hugging Bella. 🤣