I don't know anymore. Key's voice is just so perfect, I can really feel the pain of breakup that he wants to convey. His acting too, he looks so devastated.. Taeyeon as always, is amazing. I am in love with this song, the vibe, eerie vibe all perfecto.
Every Taeyeon collab is a blessing her voice suits everyone.. Key and Taeng's voice don't overpower each other it blended so well I'm in love.. as expected from Kim Siblings ^~^
This song hit HARD. Both the lyrics and the music are just heartbreakingly compelling. Congrats, Key, Taeyeon, you have me in ruins and I absolutely love it.
is it possible that his vocals have gotten even better with time, kibum sounds so refined here. his vocal chemistry with taeyeon is perfect ♡ i am so happy for their collaboration together
I wish this song to become the best song because it is not Easy and it's rare for me to love a song from the first time of hearing. I'm truly obsessed with this 💙❤
Lately, when I see SM's older generation idols' solos... I'm thinking how much they've been craving to show the color of music they'd love us to see. You've got the Key to everyone's heart. Please just let us see more color of yours, now and in the future too!!!^^
Aww but actually. And also, they must’ve had so many years working and revising and learning the emotions of their heart and the music they wanted to produce. It’s so amazing to see these people develop and branch off from something they’ve been doing for so many years. 🥺
KEY's voice sounds like a frustrated lover who is unable to move on and TAEYEON's voice sounds like a lover who has however difficultly moved on but still there's something which she can't forget...loved this masterpiece.. And lyrics are so beautifully penned down and sung...it really resemble genuine feeling and meaning of people , going from these emotions... I wish for English version too!
BAD LOVE 뮤비 뜨기 전에 선공개였는데 초고퀄이라 선공개곡 중에 내 최애였음 기범오빠 특유의 몽환적인 멜로디랑 신디사이저 악기 소리 그리고 태연언니의 피처링인데 독보적인 보컬로 오빠랑 둘이 보컬 잘 어울렸음ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 너무 좋아❤❤❤❤
@@twicebiggestgroup967 i understand that this is just a mindless troll but dude key and taeyeon are probably two of the only idols it's just factually incorrect to call flops LMAO
@@dibidubu4168 I think that person secretly has a crush on key or taeyong, bcoz he keeps revisiting this mv to post such comments;)increasing views of this mv.
Taeyeon's part heals my anxiety. Her soft voice, the deep tones, the melody and beats... When I listen to her I take a deep breath, like saying "it's okay, breath, you can manage this"
SHINee discography never disappointed whether as a group or solo, and here Key once again show us a great song!Key and Taeyeon , two talented and great singer in one song??No doubt a new masterpiece is born!
I'm a little late to this but I'm so glad he's making a solo comeback. Out of all the SHINee members, Key's music suits my taste the most and I missed it. Definitely one of my most anticipated comebacks. And a collab with Taeyeon? Never knew I needed this but I love it
Same. I love Key’s style. His album Face was criminally underrated with so many bops. This song is amazing. My bias is Taemin, but I listen to all SHINee guys equally. I love Onew’s voice the most & Jong is in his own league. I know Minho doesn’t sing solo much but his voice is also beautiful. I love SHINee in case you didn’t notice! :)
Absolutely hit song. Love it. If this song produced in American market, it would be top in Billboard. can’t express my opinion. Thank you for giving us this amazing song SM and Kims.
SM really got the jackpot when they got the Kim Siblings. Key and Taeyeon really exudes that aura. Most importantly, they have the overflowing talent and versatility that every idol wishes to have. Thank you for this amazing collab.
Key really is underrated. On so many levels, his music just advances yearly. I wish this man would sell out so many arenas. He’s so talented. I’ll always support Key! I’m glad this popped up on my recommendations again.
Shawol, please ignore any bot/fake hate comments, they are fake spam. Please do not hate other idols or group because of these fake/bot account, do not hate other fandom because of these! Do not misbehave, we need to behave and focus on our SHINee, Our Key! Love you Shawol 💎
Kibum just knows exactly what he was doing this pre release song. Anything he puts out is so refreshing and amazing. He works so hard and it would be a lot if everything can support him to the fullest ❤️
you can like SM or hate SM but you cant deny that SM has the most talented and versatile artist in the whole kpop industry SM really understands the assignment and no one can compete with the artists If someone makes a new debut you don't have to be afraid because SM only looks for the best trainees
How is it that they compliment each other so well with their voices and also visuals. They both look and sound so damn perfect in this song!! I have always loved Shinee’s solo songs and this too isn’t an exception. The songs only keep getting better!
I can't count how many times I've played this song on TH-cam, TH-cam Music, and Spotify. The song is just spot on. Thank you for this masterpiece, MasterKey.
This song has only been out for 4 days, but I'm obsessed. I'm endlessly humming this and it feels like I've always know this song. This is Key's talent, and it simply cannot be replicated.
This is just wonderful. They don't overpower each other. Blends well together. The chorus is addictingly catchy. EXCELLENT DELIVERY, TAENGKEY. Edit: Just found out that Charlie Puth's brother, Stephen Puth co-wrote this.
CAN WE talk about Taeyeon’s low register!!! Those notes she hits are insane and sounds so angelic. And so does Key. Their voices are just. Perfect. Especially combined.
![[C.C.] KEY invited his friends over to celebrate his pet's birthday🎉 #KEY #TAEYEON #CHANGSUB](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/09hW5uTk7wY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[도깨비 OST Part 1] 찬열, 펀치 (CHANYEOL, PUNCH) - Stay With Me MV](/img/n.gif)
I love blond Kibum, he looks so stunning with this hair.
I didn't like it when I first saw it, but yes, he looks amazing with this styling! 😍
IKRRRRR FRRR
Yes! This hairstyle and color suits him so well!
Conuerdo..... se ve.perfecto.
Key is the first member that i like his blonde hair.
AS EXPECTED FROM KIBUM. PERFECTION. ANOTHER MASTERPIECE. THE BEST COLLAB EVER.
KEY's acting really made the lyrics and the atmosphere of the mv more intense. He's really amazing!
Agree
아제발 키탱 노래 한곡만 더내줘 나 아직 이노래 못벗어났어!!!
“And I hate that I hate that you're happy without me
and I pray and I pray
I want you to regret more than I do”
The lyrics 😭❤️😭❤️😭❤️😭❤️
I don't know anymore. Key's voice is just so perfect, I can really feel the pain of breakup that he wants to convey. His acting too, he looks so devastated.. Taeyeon as always, is amazing. I am in love with this song, the vibe, eerie vibe all perfecto.
Key strikes again with beautiful melody and honest lyrics. This song is probably my fav from all of his solo work.
Just now, maybe his album have more great songs 😻😻😻😻
@@silasila614 YESSSS ...... I can't wait to hear his new album.
yesss!
this is a criminally underrated song
Essa música era para ser a Anitta e Austin Mahone cantando… seria “your body” 😢
This song is kind of a song that i would listen nonstop and without getting bored. Chef's kiss.
Key’s and Taeyeon’s vocals together are so beautiful. The whole song gives me such a calming vibe like it’s so amazing.
so accurately expressed
But then it comes the lyrics hahaha perfect for that d head.
yeah but the lyrics say otherwise... this whole song just radiates pain TT
@@lychee4031 at least it is danceable pain, let's dance cry everyone
The transition between Key's chaotic scene and Taeyeon's calmer side is CRAZY!!!! I LOVE IT
I GOT CHILLS
May 2023 and this is still one of my favorite collaborations! Thanks kibum for so much art
This is easily one of Key's best songs, the emotion in their voices and the instruments are beautiful...I love it so much.
th-cam.com/video/tdTjENFlkp4/w-d-xo.html
....... . ... . ....
He slayed this
Shawols 🤝 Sones
stanning the most talented and legendary OG groups/individuals to exist in the history of kpop
Their vocals have me crying. Angelic.
Same here.
Exactly
th-cam.com/video/tdTjENFlkp4/w-d-xo.html
....... . ... . ....
키 솔로 노래 다 너무 좋아ㅠㅠ
If this song is produced in America, this would top the charts in one night! Key and Taeyeon's voice truly match each other.
Yup as brother of Charlie Puth who write the song
someone said it!!!!! yes!!
Agree!!! That's my First thought after i Listen to this song. Its more to American Music
Girl! I totally agree with you! So true!
TRUE..
key's and Taeyeon's vocals and visuals are impeccable. I hope that we will get to see them perform Hate That live one day.
This song is perfect for a long night drive while playing on loop. SM artists are built different.
THIS
Agree
Noted for my next drive
you'll end up crying, lyrics hits so hard.
Yes I agree
Key has worked so hard all his life. All the success that he has deserved.
Such a hard worker
He’s one of my ultimate biases in KPop. My first bias of SHINee too. That boy has something. For all his diva qualities he has such a sincere heart!
this man came all the way from daegu when he was still a boy. he deserve the love.
*The vocals, the visuals, everything is immaculate.*
And that's on periodt.
th-cam.com/video/tdTjENFlkp4/w-d-xo.html
....... . ... . ....
key is an absolute chameleon of a performer. he can take any vibe and make it his own. beautiful song, as expected of the almighty key.
우와 저번에 봤을 때가 900만대였는데 드디어 1000만이다 축하해🩵🩵
The lryics are so accurately written no one says but this is what everyone feels . Key and taeyeon are amazing.
Every Taeyeon collab is a blessing her voice suits everyone.. Key and Taeng's voice don't overpower each other it blended so well I'm in love.. as expected from Kim Siblings ^~^
This song hit HARD. Both the lyrics and the music are just heartbreakingly compelling. Congrats, Key, Taeyeon, you have me in ruins and I absolutely love it.
Absolutely absolutely loved love love this song since it came out. Key and Taeyeons voice complement each other so well.
is it possible that his vocals have gotten even better with time, kibum sounds so refined here. his vocal chemistry with taeyeon is perfect ♡ i am so happy for their collaboration together
I guess with time you get more expirience and find a vocal technique that suits you? does this make sense? xD
This actually is a hit song. Like seriously the melody is catchy and it’s dare I say a VIBE
There is nothing imperfect about this song.....vocals, visual, lyrics just everything is perfect ♡♡♡♡♡
th-cam.com/video/tdTjENFlkp4/w-d-xo.html
....
th-cam.com/video/e6ha84DArms/w-d-xo.html ..
This song deserves to chart in billboards
Damnn i can feel the emotions of key in his voice
Kibum's voice + taeyeon's voice + this clip = MASTERPIECE
Fr
🖤🖤
Key is so underrated as an idol, hopefully he gets the attention and love he deserves this comeback!
th-cam.com/video/tdTjENFlkp4/w-d-xo.html
....
th-cam.com/video/e6ha84DArms/w-d-xo.html ..
Key is a great artist
Please support key🙏💙
@@shineeandshawolskeysforeve1820 yes let's stream this more
I wish this song to become the best song because it is not Easy and it's rare for me to love a song from the first time of hearing. I'm truly obsessed with this 💙❤
th-cam.com/video/-eKbCOyN9h0/w-d-xo.html
BLACKPINK new song 😊
.
.
.
Why is it so underrated?? It's beautiful, so real and relatable
beautiful songs are usually underrated T.T
Literally, Artist Kibum is very creative and talented. You should listen to the song "Gasoline".
Lately, when I see SM's older generation idols' solos... I'm thinking how much they've been craving to show the color of music they'd love us to see. You've got the Key to everyone's heart. Please just let us see more color of yours, now and in the future too!!!^^
Aww but actually. And also, they must’ve had so many years working and revising and learning the emotions of their heart and the music they wanted to produce. It’s so amazing to see these people develop and branch off from something they’ve been doing for so many years. 🥺
I'm obsessed with " hate that I hate that you're happy without me "
Same Lol
Yess sm stan i am sm stan too 👏💖💗
That's the hook line of this song and it worked perfectly !
@@Lyf4rMusic thats main line of song lol 😆😂
th-cam.com/video/tdTjENFlkp4/w-d-xo.html
....
"I pray you're more painful than me baby" This is something refreshing not like others wishing happiness to your ex
どタイプすぎる曲、最強の2人のコラボで最高すぎる
Key is so talented, he is known to be that funny guy and he just prove how gorgeous, emotional and sincere he can be!
KEY's voice sounds like a frustrated lover who is unable to move on and TAEYEON's voice sounds like a lover who has however difficultly moved on but still there's something which she can't forget...loved this masterpiece..
And lyrics are so beautifully penned down and sung...it really resemble genuine feeling and meaning of people , going from these emotions...
I wish for English version too!
*Fact : KEY Visuals Aren't Jokes, They're Really Masterpiece.*
BAD LOVE 뮤비 뜨기 전에 선공개였는데 초고퀄이라 선공개곡 중에 내 최애였음 기범오빠 특유의 몽환적인 멜로디랑 신디사이저 악기 소리 그리고 태연언니의 피처링인데 독보적인 보컬로 오빠랑 둘이 보컬 잘 어울렸음ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 너무 좋아❤❤❤❤
I rilly love this song… if only I cud sing along in Korean
I can’t get enough of this song. It will be the last song I’ll be singing every day. Key and Taeyeon did so well. I’m so proud of you Key.
This song's vibes is another level... SHINee is unexpected but all masterpieces... Taeyeon too. LOVE THIS
*keyflop and flopyeon*
The song is amazing! I can't stop listening to it 😭❤️
@@twicebiggestgroup967 i understand that this is just a mindless troll but dude key and taeyeon are probably two of the only idols it's just factually incorrect to call flops LMAO
Very Charlie Puth vibe ~
@@dibidubu4168 I think that person secretly has a crush on key or taeyong, bcoz he keeps revisiting this mv to post such comments;)increasing views of this mv.
Key and Taeyeon have such angelic voices and with such a soft, sad and melodic song it's bound to be a masterpiece.
th-cam.com/video/tdTjENFlkp4/w-d-xo.html
....
Taeyeon's part heals my anxiety. Her soft voice, the deep tones, the melody and beats... When I listen to her I take a deep breath, like saying "it's okay, breath, you can manage this"
They're perfect together their voices are angelic 😭
Ikrrr❤
No one does it like SM Artists. They've got the best vocalists. Prove me wrong!
Key's music taste is really something. His discography is entirely on a different level.
Definitely he makes timeless music ❤️ I love it
Love that he is not stuck only in asian music styles
@@bluaaahhhh yes his sound is more of a feeling to me.
Still listening to this .!!
key & taeyeon is the collab that we NEED. The vocals, the song, the music, the mv, them themselves, EVERYTHING ARE MASTERPIECE
yesss 👏🏽 👏🏽
This is so beautiful! 😘
SHINee discography never disappointed whether as a group or solo, and here Key once again show us a great song!Key and Taeyeon , two talented and great singer in one song??No doubt a new masterpiece is born!
This is the kind of song you just don't get tired of listening.
True
Agree
이 노랜 진짜 너무조야..
I'm a little late to this but I'm so glad he's making a solo comeback. Out of all the SHINee members, Key's music suits my taste the most and I missed it. Definitely one of my most anticipated comebacks. And a collab with Taeyeon? Never knew I needed this but I love it
Yess
We have waiting for it
my bias is Onew, but i listen to Key's and Jjong's music the most... funny how music taste works:)
Same. I love Key’s style. His album Face was criminally underrated with so many bops. This song is amazing. My bias is Taemin, but I listen to all SHINee guys equally. I love Onew’s voice the most & Jong is in his own league. I know Minho doesn’t sing solo much but his voice is also beautiful. I love SHINee in case you didn’t notice! :)
@Min - It was just released a day or two ago, so really new !!
Been here since 2012 and he has never ever failed to me NOT A SINGLE TIME. So proud of him, and Taeyeon too.
periodt. key never fails
what a song...it gives a heavenly feeling only because key and taeyeon sang this song!!!!
These lyrics cut deep, deeper than a sword
Absolutely hit song. Love it. If this song produced in American market, it would be top in Billboard. can’t express my opinion. Thank you for giving us this amazing song SM and Kims.
I agree!
Exactly!!
SM really got the jackpot when they got the Kim Siblings. Key and Taeyeon really exudes that aura. Most importantly, they have the overflowing talent and versatility that every idol wishes to have.
Thank you for this amazing collab.
What to expect from a SHINee member, other than a masterpiece.
I still listened to this song til now
The song, the lyrics, the visual, the harmony... This song is art. The album is art. Kim Kibum is a genius
SM artists are whole at another level.
Masterpiece upon Masterpiece!!
Their voices go well together.
the combo is perfect
True
Really
Key really is underrated. On so many levels, his music just advances yearly. I wish this man would sell out so many arenas. He’s so talented. I’ll always support Key! I’m glad this popped up on my recommendations again.
2 years later and still one of the best collabs
KEY made another masterpiece with this song. The fact that this is his first collaboration with Taeyeon makes it more meaningful!
This is masterpiece
This song is seriously so beautiful and their voices together is just a +++ I love this song so much. It’ll be listening to it a lot.
♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
Their voices are perfect together
I really love this song
Fact: This song is so sad to listen but also give make everyone healing
th-cam.com/video/tdTjENFlkp4/w-d-xo.html
....
OMG.... Thats so true
*it's just a big flop*
Shawol, please ignore any bot/fake hate comments, they are fake spam. Please do not hate other idols or group because of these fake/bot account, do not hate other fandom because of these! Do not misbehave, we need to behave and focus on our SHINee, Our Key! Love you Shawol 💎
An original fact in a while 🎉
We truly heal while cry dancing, Key is making a mess of our feelings 🥲💃
Blending two beautiful voices of two incredibly talented people usually gives you a masterpiece. Here’s a proof of that.
Kibum just knows exactly what he was doing this pre release song. Anything he puts out is so refreshing and amazing. He works so hard and it would be a lot if everything can support him to the fullest ❤️
key, you are really a blessing to this earth..even if people don't give you what you deserve,we are here with you always...key fighting...
you can like SM or hate SM but you cant deny that SM has the most talented and versatile artist in the whole kpop industry
SM really understands the assignment and no one can compete with the artists
If someone makes a new debut you don't have to be afraid because SM only looks for the best trainees
I love SM
How is it that they compliment each other so well with their voices and also visuals. They both look and sound so damn perfect in this song!! I have always loved Shinee’s solo songs and this too isn’t an exception. The songs only keep getting better!
key's mini album is out on 27 sept!! he is doing a solo beyond live concert before that! do stay tuned
*SM* is giving best of the best songs these days !!
Each song is Fab
Each Artist are talented
Love it!
Agree
True
agree!!!!!!? absolutely!!!!
*Fact : TAEYEON Visuals Aren't Jokes, They're Really Masterpiece.*
I want part 2 of this song🥹🥹
this song is really for someone who cannot accept the fact that the one they love is much more happy without them.
This song is a masterpiece
Totaly western and kpop mix
When it's SHINee, it's quality whatever as group and as solo! All members are amazing and Taeyeon is incredible too! 😘
Cette chanson mérite plus d'amour
May thier friendship will be like this forever supporting each other like this.
How come they were worried and nervous about how their voices would fit each other, this is NEAT
His fashion, personality, voice, visuals, humor, just everything needs more attention.
th-cam.com/video/eYKWpXdiAUw/w-d-xo.html . . . . . STAY
#shinee song #attention! 😘 #dontcallme #atlantis
I Have to Agree with you ! Don't Sleep ! On PRINCE KEY ! ❤️💖
I can't count how many times I've played this song on TH-cam, TH-cam Music, and Spotify. The song is just spot on. Thank you for this masterpiece, MasterKey.
This is not just a collab between best friends but this is also a collab between legends.
Truth has been spoken
This is why i love kibum's music, he doesn't do too much, he sticks to his own style
taengkey is fun to watch on amazing Saturday and i love their collab too!
This song has only been out for 4 days, but I'm obsessed. I'm endlessly humming this and it feels like I've always know this song. This is Key's talent, and it simply cannot be replicated.
same
Same
Same
Samee
This song is a masterpiece PERIODT.
th-cam.com/video/IiqPul4YGko/w-d-xo.html
Red Velvet's 😊
.
.
*masterflop**
Keep going, Shawols!!!!!
I’m still come here to listen this song!
This is just wonderful. They don't overpower each other. Blends well together.
The chorus is addictingly catchy. EXCELLENT DELIVERY, TAENGKEY.
Edit: Just found out that Charlie Puth's brother, Stephen Puth co-wrote this.
Very well spoken
KEY IS REALLY ON POINT THIS ERA. I love the energy he's been giving.
and it's just the beginning!!!
Where is his solo album
@@Adaobieistyping he has a Japanese album and a Korean release + repackage. The álbum for this song will be released 27 next month, it's a pre release
@@Adaobieistyping 27th september!
CAN WE talk about Taeyeon’s low register!!! Those notes she hits are insane and sounds so angelic. And so does Key. Their voices are just. Perfect. Especially combined.
Yes
this mv is perfect for such soft, gloomy and smooth song, Kim siblings are so beautiful
Their voices blend so well!! Hope this would not be the only collab they'll have.
Ikr
Key is so talented ! I feel bad for people who don’t know his existence
They are missing out
I want to hear some more of his music now !!
@@mjj1434 he is gonna release his 1st mini album soon
True but it's ok
Shawol always here for him and SHINee
@@mjj1434 idk if u know already but he has an album called Face