@@vincenzostr4488 It might sound like an exaggeration but I think Bob is above the Nobel. As Leonard Cohen said, giving the Nobel to Dylan is like pinning a medal on Mount Everest for being the highest mountain!
and on top of it all, all the many versions of individual songs to be able to remember the finalized lyrics instead of those that were abandoned or shifted elsewhere to other songs...incredible
I can dig that, I love this fricking song. How good are you when an absolute gem like this just gets thrown out on the discard pile? Ain't Bobby so cool?!
The comments say it all but in my opinion he is so far ahead of anyone else it' almost doesn't make sense. Effortlessly using the English language like no one before or since. An absolute pleasure for the audience of millions, and with such a massive catalogue, there's still more greatness to discover. We are so privileged.
That about sums it up, very well said. Just this one song (left off the album no less) is just mind blowingly beautiful and composed. And the drums sound f**cking great!
So strange thus didn't go in the album. It's my favourite Bob song by a country mile. Amazing lyrics, gorgeous melody, unusual guitar rhythm and the sum of the parts is just awesome
Indeed. it's so familiar & unusual all at once. Carries me in & along, & moreover, at this juncture in my life- I could write these words & know & mean them, had I been the vessel for this song to be born into, it's that true & personal.
When “Biograph” came out in 1985, this song blew us all away. Such a masterpiece left off “Desire.” But back then, vinyl was king, and vinyl only holds 40-45 minutes of music.
He did it live in 1975, so really it coulda been on blood on the tracks, Crazy how this song was left off any album, with scarlett riviera on the 🎻 , this is a masterpiece.
@@jamesatkinson9940 Incorrect in part. His only performance of it was on July 3, 1075, six months after the recording of Blood on the Tracks was finished and five months after it was released. It's the same month he met Levy and ended up recording Desire. It couldn't have gone on BotT. Completely correct that it should have been on the album, along with Golden Loom. Giving Joey the boot makes room for both: 11:05 Joey 4:29 Abandoned Love 4:25 Golden Loom
Che meraviglia!!! Brani che ti attraversano l'anima,il cuore la testa, e ti lasciano dentro un senso di piacevole nostalgia, per un amore perduto ma sempre vivo. Grazie Bob, grande poeta e musicista unico!!!
Bob Dylan is pure gold and always my favorite song writer and singer , he has a large range of different vocals to match any song he writes. I hope before he or I live this world I can go see him perform live. 🙏🏻✌️
There is no one who can create magic with lyrics like this man can. Sometimes he throws unexpected things in, like ‘The Spanish moon is rising on the hill’ How well he sums up aspects of the human condition, wanting to let go but holding on in differing ways
It's been almost 60 years that I have been following this guy, but his lyrics and music have stood the test of time. He is someone who helped shape my life and outlook. Keep going Bob! John McFarlane Bonnie Scotland.
The genius keeps amazing. Tunes, poetry, rhytms, moods, vocals, presumed meaning. The genius filled a giant box with lifes experiences for everybody to relate to. Consolation and beauty for along the way.
Bob Dylan: To be grateful given the many experiences of this brokenhearted world, is to find that you are not part of it, and to birth your masterpiece anew. God's Will for you. In all of this you'll be Victorious.
Great song. How many artists can afford leaving such gems out of their albums? To me, it is somewhat magical because it works on several levels, like so many Dylan masterpieces. Maybe not only about a failed relationship. Maybe also the soul trying to break free from the ego and earthly ties? Physical gold vs. an immaterial treasure?
3 points to make: 1) Funny in the ‘modern’ day that this is the version most familiar to me. 2) Unfathomable that Dylan could cut this from an album for not being good enough! 3) Scarlet Rivera is pure genius.
Listening to Bob form Six grade and now I’m 54 love the man and his music First time I heard this song love it there always a great song. That pop up from the Archives that I think ever peace of music that the man makes is amazing 💜🎼🎶
“Who’s gods are dead/and who’s queens are in the church”is a particularly ambiguous lyric that I’ve never been able to reckon with. I love these kinds of moments in how writing where the verse starts to wander into a strange space that only he occupies. I can’t make sense of that line but whenever I hear this song it brings a smile to my face for being so intriguingly elusive. Only he has access to that inspired space. This song being a particular high point, and, as he’s wont to do repeatedly over the years , he left this mini masterpiece off of desire. I’m wondering even if the bitterness and pain of it would have fit more on blood on the tracks. The great thing, like Blind Willie Mctell and Dark Eyes it resides in truly inspired and beautiful place
`it’s not that difficult; folkie, protest singer, electric rock star, late 60s surreal genuis, Nashville country, John Wesly Harding, a Simple Twist of Fate, bohemian gypsy, christian period, awful 80s period, Americana crooner, older statesman. Master.
Of times gone by Beautiful sad but strong Love Song ‘My heart is downing me’ and ‘I wear the ball and chain’ or Harrrppp free playing into ‘The New’ ..🌺👌🎶🌞🌹❣️Thankyouu🌺
I think I read somewhere that this is the song that Jimi Hendrix referred to when he spoke of Dylan having relations with a much younger woman (underage). How true that is I don’t know and would hate to spread something that is not true, maybe someone else could clarify. But the lyrics make enough sense without admitting to anything of that nature.
The greatest of all time. How can one man have such a massive discography and each song has so many different versions!
for this reason he is a Nobel
I know I love that. He can sing the same song so many different versions but each one is great
Shakespeare indeed.
@@vincenzostr4488 It might sound like an exaggeration but I think Bob is above the Nobel. As Leonard Cohen said, giving the Nobel to Dylan is like pinning a medal on Mount Everest for being the highest mountain!
and on top of it all, all the many versions of individual songs to be able to remember the finalized lyrics instead of those that were abandoned or shifted elsewhere to other songs...incredible
When he's finally gone, they'll open his vault and find a million of these.
the Shakespeare of song.......
Top 5 Bob Dylan songs. I'm not even fucking kidding.
I love this song but to put it in his top 5 would be a stretch. But it's your top 5 so ok
1. Angelina
2. Hard Rain
3. Making a liar
4. Tangled
5. I and I
I can dig that, I love this fricking song. How good are you when an absolute gem like this just gets thrown out on the discard pile? Ain't Bobby so cool?!
The comments say it all but in my opinion he is so far ahead of anyone else it' almost doesn't make sense. Effortlessly using the English language like no one before or since. An absolute pleasure for the audience of millions, and with such a massive catalogue, there's still more greatness to discover. We are so privileged.
That about sums it up, very well said. Just this one song (left off the album no less) is just mind blowingly beautiful and composed. And the drums sound f**cking great!
America's poet laureate.
Another in a seemingly endless canon of musical greatness from our boy Bobby...truly a modern day Shakespeare...in the alley.
Greatest musician of our time
Ever!
Chi altri potrebbe scrivere una canzone simile e toglierla dall'album in uscita ?Solo lui, Mr Bob Dylan...
So strange thus didn't go in the album. It's my favourite Bob song by a country mile. Amazing lyrics, gorgeous melody, unusual guitar rhythm and the sum of the parts is just awesome
When it’s Bob, that’s when the magic starts.
The Everlys covered this. Their version, also, is awesome.
Mother Father of all creation is here in physical flesh ❤🎉 please phone home in these urgent moments! We love u. Luna❤🎉
Indeed. it's so familiar & unusual all at once. Carries me in & along, & moreover, at this juncture in my life- I could write these words & know & mean them, had I been the vessel for this song to be born into, it's that true & personal.
@@ResearchSoundLab Great songs are so relatable. Just like you when I first heard this song a few years ago, it described my feelings to a tee
How long must I suffer such abyooooose....
After all these years, hearing a Dylan tune for the first time is a real treat.
Geezus... here sits a life-long Dylan fan, who had never heard this until 2023... why wasn't this touching song included on his 'Desire' album?
Same here! What a great find. Bob Dylan is the gift that keeps giving.
Same!!
Was released in 1985. But he never played it live.
Good question. Dylan often left gems off his official albums, e.g., Dignity, Series of Dreams, and Caribbean Wind, just to name a few.
Great song. Melody and words
When “Biograph” came out in 1985, this song blew us all away. Such a masterpiece left off “Desire.” But back then, vinyl was king, and vinyl only holds 40-45 minutes of music.
Vinyl wasn’t ‘King”. It was all there was back in 1976.
@@europainvicta3907 There were cassettes in 1976. And a few 8-tracks still around (they were awful).
He did it live in 1975, so really it coulda been on blood on the tracks,
Crazy how this song was left off any album, with scarlett riviera on the 🎻 , this is a masterpiece.
@@jamesatkinson9940 Incorrect in part. His only performance of it was on July 3, 1075, six months after the recording of Blood on the Tracks was finished and five months after it was released. It's the same month he met Levy and ended up recording Desire. It couldn't have gone on BotT.
Completely correct that it should have been on the album, along with Golden Loom. Giving Joey the boot makes room for both:
11:05 Joey
4:29 Abandoned Love
4:25 Golden Loom
Could have replaced Joey with this imo
Che meraviglia!!! Brani che ti attraversano l'anima,il cuore la testa, e ti lasciano dentro un senso di piacevole nostalgia, per un amore perduto ma sempre vivo. Grazie Bob, grande poeta e musicista unico!!!
Energy, emotion, moving, raw..... classic Dylan.
The greatest poet of our times!
Not just of our times but I believe of all time.
He is not a poet.. he is a performing artist..the best ever.
My first hearing of this. 😊
Stone cold masterpiece.
Perhaps the greatest Dylan song.
I see you in the street and I begin to swoon... brilliance
I love this era of Bob Dylan.
Hello Dear, it’s nice meeting you on here!
APPSOLUTELY
Desire and fiddle era is best Bob.
How good It felt for Dylan to know Mexico
It baffles me how many songs this guy has written, endless catalogue of songs!!
Back when they didn't for the music and nothing else.
I love this man, may God protect him and keep him safe.
Hello, how are you doing? its nice meeting you here
Just five seconds of the magic harmonica and I am covered in goose bumps and tears.
Scarlet Rivera's violin is also great.
Mother Father of all creation is here in physical flesh ❤🎉 please phone home in these urgent moments! We love u. Luna❤🎉
@@LOVEHAS1JOYRAINS2wtf?
i love this song, visions, verbal art, certainly a masterpiece. bless you zimme
Bob Dylan is pure gold and always my favorite song writer and singer , he has a large range of different vocals to match any song he writes. I hope before he or I live this world I can go see him perform live. 🙏🏻✌️
1975 was a heavy year for me.
There is no one who can create magic with lyrics like this man can. Sometimes he throws unexpected things in, like ‘The Spanish moon is rising on the hill’ How well he sums up aspects of the human condition, wanting to let go but holding on in differing ways
It's been almost 60 years that I have been following this guy, but his lyrics and music have stood the test of time. He is someone who helped shape my life and outlook. Keep going Bob! John McFarlane Bonnie Scotland.
Right there with ya, John.
The great Rob Stoner on bass and harmony vocals.......Rolling Thunder Band.
Huh, I thought it was a woman on the background vocals.
Hi Rob Stoner
I love Rob Stoner playing and vocals.
Everybody, sometimes in his life, has been a abandoned love...
The genius keeps amazing. Tunes, poetry, rhytms, moods, vocals, presumed meaning. The genius filled a giant box with lifes experiences for everybody to relate to. Consolation and beauty for along the way.
Haven't heard this for ages. An excellent song.
Bob Dylan: To be grateful given the many experiences of this brokenhearted world, is to find that you are not part of it, and to birth your masterpiece anew. God's Will for you. In all of this you'll be Victorious.
(amein)
My favorite
One of my all-tine favourite songs, and to Dylan it is just another unreleased tune!
What a prolific songwriter Big Bob Dylan is amazing 👍😄🎸
Let me feel your love one more time before I abandon it. My favorite Dylan lyric.
Mine is 'if I,could only turn back the clock to when God and her were born.'
The ghost of lectricity howls in the bones of her face
Let me feel your love one more time before I abandon it, Montserrat...
He's really something special!❤
Truly love his essence
Fabulous song. Pity it took so long for everyone to hear it. X
the master
Great song. How many artists can afford leaving such gems out of their albums?
To me, it is somewhat magical because it works on several levels, like so many Dylan masterpieces. Maybe not only about a failed relationship. Maybe also the soul trying to break free from the ego and earthly ties? Physical gold vs. an immaterial treasure?
A magical version of Abandoned love.
All Dylan song are about love and betrayal.
Mother Father of all creation is here in physical flesh ❤🎉 please phone home in these urgent moments! We love u. Luna❤🎉
One of his finest 🎸
❤️ Rob Stoner with Dylan here.
Gotta LOVE Rob Stoner.....!!!
@@randytolen9531 with all my musical heart ❤️
@@SeeCSeesCC you've got great taste!
@@randytolen9531 you too Randy!
@@SeeCSeesCC thank you Cindy!!
"I march in the parade of liberty
But as long as I love you I'm not free"
Bob the marvel of humankind
GOAT!!!! Ive been listening to this man since I was 16. I’m 40 now. 52 concerts! Dylan is absolutely beyond comparison
I'll be there 2024
❤ Love this song so much❤
This song should be on desire, is a great tune.
Fantastic song. Sends shivers down my spine. Lyrically magnificent. Perfectly performed.
Very perceptive comments, direct clear and right on.
3 points to make: 1) Funny in the ‘modern’ day that this is the version most familiar to me. 2) Unfathomable that Dylan could cut this from an album for not being good enough! 3) Scarlet Rivera is pure genius.
incredible, ive never heard this song before, it is incredible
I listen to this song every day. Great song in all senses, voice music and poetry. Dylan the king. ❤👍👍
I thought everybody had "Biograph", but apparently not. I was listening to this back in the late 80's in that box set. Everybody should get it.
That opening line beyond beautiful. The words how it’s sung..
Oh my Bobby ....no words,......
He's so great! Been listening since '62 and never get tired of him... Always something new.
So this song was an outtake from Desire... Dylan is the kind of artist who can keep this kind of gem out of the album, crazy !
Just woke up with this stuck in my head, have only heard it once or twice, crazy
My Love stay here.
What a song. 💕💕💕💕💕
Best of Dylan ever
Ahí tienen o tenemos,al mejor de todos los tiempos,Bob Dylan,es tan dulce escucharlo que daría la vida por escucharlo siempre hasta que muera.
Brilliant !
What a great song!!
Somebody's hearing me. This is such a great album. I cherish this as much as all the others! Thanks Much Bro..Keep em comin.
Thanks ❤🍇
this song hurts so bad fr i am putting myself in pure agony listening to this
Bob your killing me ,sing another ,best song writer bar none 🤜🤛🇨🇦❤️
I liked my comment,¿?Love ya all 🤍
Melhor de todos .
Real talk hell yes
Reminds me of Dad, and Mom
Listening to Bob form Six grade and now I’m 54 love the man and his music First time I heard this song love it there always a great song. That pop up from the Archives that I think ever peace of music that the man makes is amazing 💜🎼🎶
LOVE this song.
Abandoned love doesn't it hit to the core
LURVE THIS SONG. it's magical
“Who’s gods are dead/and who’s queens are in the church”is a particularly ambiguous lyric that I’ve never been able to reckon with. I love these kinds of moments in how writing where the verse starts to wander into a strange space that only he occupies. I can’t make sense of that line but whenever I hear this song it brings a smile to my face for being so intriguingly elusive. Only he has access to that inspired space. This song being a particular high point, and, as he’s wont to do repeatedly over the years , he left this mini masterpiece off of desire. I’m wondering even if the bitterness and pain of it would have fit more on blood on the tracks. The great thing, like Blind Willie Mctell and Dark Eyes it resides in truly inspired and beautiful place
I have listened to geniuses and giants.. Thank you B.D.
My favorite Dylan song!💜😺
Most artists have one thing to say. I can't count the number of ways this great artist has reinvented himself.
`it’s not that difficult; folkie, protest singer, electric rock star, late 60s surreal genuis, Nashville country, John Wesly Harding, a Simple Twist of Fate, bohemian gypsy, christian period, awful 80s period, Americana crooner, older statesman. Master.
@@europainvicta3907 The 80's included Infidels. Not too shabby. What he left off the album could make anyone's career.
@@letsifciao amico! 😊😍😘💘🌅
That is the genius of Bob Dylan 👍🏴😄
Just love this ❤
Wonderful song❕
I love this song. His voice has so much emotion in it.
So good, love it xx
Love singing thiis
Greatest poet and singer. It s my Best song,i like to sing it and play it.
I agree with you
nice one bob
Caporal Maestro Juan Bob Román
Alegría!!
when you just can't let go.. in spite of your better judgement
Of times gone by Beautiful sad but strong Love Song ‘My heart is downing me’ and
‘I wear the ball and chain’ or
Harrrppp free playing into ‘The New’ ..🌺👌🎶🌞🌹❣️Thankyouu🌺
Lovely to sing togetherrrrrrr
Love this song! Why did he abandon this?
Maybe cause it was painful, related to his ex wife Sara. Tho one of my favorites!
it was allegedly dropped from the album in favor of 'Joey'.
I think I read somewhere that this is the song that Jimi Hendrix referred to when he spoke of Dylan having relations with a much younger woman (underage). How true that is I don’t know and would hate to spread something that is not true, maybe someone else could clarify. But the lyrics make enough sense without admitting to anything of that nature.
@@tyronnecraig9242 seems unlikely considering Jimi Hendrix had been dead for 5 years when this song was written.
Good
Prophet no 1
Uma verdadeira viagem ao tempo.
Uma das grandes canções de Dylan!
Absolutely
Immenso Bob
Inacreditável deixarem ela fora de Desire para colocarem Joey. Se sem ela Desire talvez seja o melhor álbum de Dylan, com ela certamente seria
@@davidrowson3494ciao David! 😊😍😘💘