Average Line Distribution per song Hanni: 29.5 | 23.3% Hyein: 26.7 | 21.1% Danielle: 26.6 | 21% Haerin: 24.1 | 19% Minji: 19.9 | 15.7% Variation: 14.3% Color of Zone: Green
@@Citricgumito wth? Minji has a great voice and improved in her vocals, you can’t tell me she gets an F Edit: Hanni and Dani have AMAZING voices and vocals. You can’t give them a D. Clearly you’re rating them for all the wrong reasons.
Exactly! Hyein is just going to get even better in the future. She’s got a really good vocals and her voice tone is my favourite. It’s very distinctive.
I love Danielle's voice so much like when she sings you can feel the emotion and you can hear how happy she is singing. I hope in the future she gets more lines and can show off her voice a lot more.
@@vanha-1202 ya, I know but she is the second-best vocalist I am not saying she should get a lot of lines but the thing is after super shy era I don't see a lot of comments about her anymore.
I’m Minji biased and it actually isn’t that bad, maybe just a little bit more lines but since she isn’t lead or main vocal I think she’s okay. Just maybe a few more lines.
I hope they utilize haerins and minjis especially minji voice more in their future title tracks these girls are crazy popular and deserve it tbh. also dani minji and hanni also slayed so hard their voices is clearly more suited for current nj songs. tbh imo if you give a bit of hanni lines to minji it all balances out perfectly so every member has about 20% of lines. but more than line distrubution what matter is wether or not the members voice suits the song or not. Ive seen a lot of bunnies call nj members worst singer/ dancers. If your a tokki you shoudnt be doing that atall. but i think currently its more about whos voice suits the songs more and pretty sure that minji and haerin will get better songs dont worry atall bunnies. Newjeans have oe of the fairest line distrubutions in kpop so I think bunnies should celebrate it.
in all honesty i think their line distribution matches each of themselves and fitting cz if u think abt it minji, haerin, dani also shines in every comeback especially in the recent ones like how sweet, bubblegum, right now, and supernatural. i think it fits them perfectly already :)
period. this is exactly how it should be. if hyein’s tiktoks were counted in asap, she’d be first but either way, im living for this ranking. minji my girl, we gonna get you some more lines, don’t worry
After hearing her fantastic rap in their cover of “Tell Me,” Minji is definitely being underutilized ☹️ But Hyein honestly has the most beautiful and versatile singing voice, so I’m actually surprised she got surpassed, though Hanni’s prominence in the “OMG” era was obvious. Anyway, this is very interesting and sometimes unexpected, and I love the way you executed it all 😁
I love Haerin's voice so much but I feel like it used to be more powerful in the past?? Like during debut era in Attention and especially Hype Boy, I feel like she was singing with a more full voice (listen to her first voice in Hype Boy for example, during the "got me feeling YOUUU") whereas in newer songs, she always uses a softer tone
Yes you guys are right , I also felt her voice was really strong in hype boy and attention , and definitely the CEO and producers are not letting her use her actual voice and giving her less lines , if she would have sung the chorus part of supernatural, it would have sounded amzing
minji's line is not bad at all, someone has to be at the last place and technically, she is the weakest vocalist in the group with no sense of vocal support and they arent really a hiphop group for her to rap much, so her lines actually make sense
@@MariaLopez-u8wher position is not rapper. stop making stuff up. she’s just a weak vocalist, you can just say that and stop there. she’s not a rapper and new jeans songs don’t even have rap
@@delulusheep I know ur talking about technique, but do you have any proofs for that? That Dani’s technique > Hanni’s technique. Are you a pro? Cuz from what I read from some Vocal Analysis Page they say Hanni > Dani or sometimes Hanni = Dani
Haerin stans are really getting upsetting. Haerin has never been mistreated. shes the 2nd worst vocalist, right above Minji (who is also their best rapper) it makes sense these 2 are the bottom 2. there is no reason for Haerin to get more lines than she already does. plus are we ignoring Minji being 100 seconds behind 4th? Bunnis will scream mistreatment/unfair until it comes to Minji
I guess mhj should not debuted haerin and minji if she's only given them minimum lines. 🙄 how will they grow when mhj always give the most parts to hanni,danielle and hyein? the only haerin has or atleast more distribution lines is hybe boy and cookie.
@@Kep1er_OT8 Hyein has shown thw ability to support/almost can support and has a better tone than Haerin, Haerin is more comparable to Minji as both cannot support and are less stable than Hyein
@@daily_update87 they all provide somethign just like every idol in every group. go far back as Wonder Girls, are you saying Yubin shouldnt have been in that group because she never sang and only rapped? everyone provides something. all of NewJeans can sing. Hanni Dani and Hyein just happen to be better than the other 2 girls. plus Haerin is their 2nd best dancer and Minji is their best rapper. they all debuted for a reason. please stop being a pity stan because im sure the girls dont even care about line distributions as much as yall do
@@TayTaysSupremacy when haerin didn't cracks her voice all the time. especially in encore. 🤷 how will show her potential when she's not given a chance? mhj always give her low notes parts. unlike her hybe boy and cookie days. haerin suites higher notes.
How?? Before i start saying anything I'm a minji bias but u can't compare minji to e:u minji get good lines sure she shoudl have more but she isn't mistreated alot
No real surprise. The three extroverts are at the top and the two introvert at the bottom. Minji is a servant leader so she won't be up front as much, unless the others aren't up to the task, but all five can do anything.
@@guujikitsune Extroverts are more willing to do and try new and different things. The Introverts are okay with extroverts being out front. Introverts may even be better, but they allow the eagerness of the extroverts. Introverts are often reluctant heroes.
this is so annoying, NewJeans has one of the most fair line distributions amongst k-pop groups which is distributed by vocal ability, and yet fans are still unhappy about it…
minji not being first in anemone at all??? my bias 😢. haerin only having first in zero is also sad-she gets a lot of the “killing parts” though so it kind of makes up for it
Minji should leave this group. If they wanna give her less lines because her "voice is too deep", "the other members fits more" or "she's a rapper", then this group is not for her. She's just there to be a leader and visual.
The reason why their new songs are not getting much recognitions is only because they stopped giving lines to haerin. Like did they forget how everyone got obsessed with her voice in HypeBoy, the song that made them this popular. Also no hate but both Danielle and Haerin are better vocalists than Hyein......
Attention, hybe boy and Supershy. Hyein got most line. Their music style changed this comeback. Besides she start getting less lines than 30 sec. I like her lines the most but the starting chorus is a bit off and a monotone. Besides without hyein in the group performance, the dance performance look pretty lackluster and yeah, waiting for her comeback ot5. Bye.
@JJ-cj4fc Its not about who got the most parts, it's about who got the parts suitable to the song, and in recent songs Haerin and Minji's voice suited a lot more than Hyein
Ok but I dont think you guys understand that this isn’t completely unfair (except for the fact that minji just now started getting lines), but aside from that producers usually choose who sings what lines and most idols dont even care about getting a lot of lines.
Haerin is the second worst singer in NewJeans and the second last in lines. makes perfect sense. she is also a worse dancer than Hanni. Visual is subjective, but most people agree Minji is the visual.
Yall toxic haerin stans don't even deserve to be called fans🤦♀️ Hyein is very talented, and so are all the members. Why can't you appreciate that and move on? You guys nitpick at hyein when she is the second in line distributions when it's clear hanni has most lines in their songs, yet yall blame hyein, and for what? she doesn't pick which lines she gets.
@@NæptuneMymaybe because Hanni is their best vocal while hyein is their 2nd worst vocal and always gets the most screentime, center and killing parts.
@@Kep1er_OT8 You clearly have been mistaking her parts for someone else’s. Easy mistake. Took me a while to realize they were all hers, too, because she’s capable of a sound so unlike her regular voice.
![[MMA2023] NewJeans - FULL Performance | #NewJeans #SuperShy #ETA #CoolWithYou #GetUp #ASAP #MMA2023](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MfO1FenJbKI/mqdefault.jpg)
![IVE ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from ELEVEN to REBEL HEART]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ecAZjzAbZis/mqdefault.jpg)
Average Line Distribution per song
Hanni: 29.5 | 23.3%
Hyein: 26.7 | 21.1%
Danielle: 26.6 | 21%
Haerin: 24.1 | 19%
Minji: 19.9 | 15.7%
Variation: 14.3%
Color of Zone: Green
This is pretty much supernatural distribution
How to determine the variation of a line distribution??
Haerin is still below 20%
how did you calculate variation?
shut up
Dani has my favorite voice but Hanni and Hyein both have great voice and vocal abilities. They’re all stable and keep improving.
Hanni D+
Danielle D
Hyein E+
Haerin E+/E-
Minji F
@@Citricgumito Hanni D-
Danielle E+
Haerin E+
Hyein E+
Minji F+
@@Citricgumito wth? Minji has a great voice and improved in her vocals, you can’t tell me she gets an F
Edit: Hanni and Dani have AMAZING voices and vocals. You can’t give them a D. Clearly you’re rating them for all the wrong reasons.
i'm glad that Hyein is second, her vocals are incredible for her age, she's only improving, it's not for nothing that IU wanted to do a feat with her
Exactly! Hyein is just going to get even better in the future. She’s got a really good vocals and her voice tone is my favourite. It’s very distinctive.
She doesn't deserve 2nd place
@@ewixxi she deserves to be kicked out of newjeans
@@Kep1er_OT8yes she does so stop moaning
@@Kep1er_OT8yes she does stfu
I love Danielle's voice so much like when she sings you can feel the emotion and you can hear how happy she is singing. I hope in the future she gets more lines and can show off her voice a lot more.
She had more lines and recognization from Super shy era 😊😊
@@vanha-1202 ya, I know but she is the second-best vocalist I am not saying she should get a lot of lines but the thing is after super shy era I don't see a lot of comments about her anymore.
im in love with all their voices I prefer Danielle’s voice but really Minji raw voice has so much potential we hope to hear her more ❤
Minji!😫😫😫😭
IKR 😢😢😢😢
I’m Minji biased and it actually isn’t that bad, maybe just a little bit more lines but since she isn’t lead or main vocal I think she’s okay. Just maybe a few more lines.
I hope they utilize haerins and minjis especially minji voice more in their future title tracks these girls are crazy popular and deserve it tbh. also dani minji and hanni also slayed so hard their voices is clearly more suited for current nj songs. tbh imo if you give a bit of hanni lines to minji it all balances out perfectly so every member has about 20% of lines. but more than line distrubution what matter is wether or not the members voice suits the song or not. Ive seen a lot of bunnies call nj members worst singer/ dancers. If your a tokki you shoudnt be doing that atall. but i think currently its more about whos voice suits the songs more and pretty sure that minji and haerin will get better songs dont worry atall bunnies. Newjeans have oe of the fairest line distrubutions in kpop so I think bunnies should celebrate it.
MINJI DESERVES MORE LINES
Hanni deserves to have the most lines, she is perfect in both vocal color and technique
But she is always first ㅠㅠ others have good vocals too ㅠㅠ
in all honesty i think their line distribution matches each of themselves and fitting cz if u think abt it minji, haerin, dani also shines in every comeback especially in the recent ones like how sweet, bubblegum, right now, and supernatural. i think it fits them perfectly already :)
Hyein either gets a lot of line or gets almost nothing
She never gets "almost nothing" u be exaggerating 😭 she always has lines
@@lachainedestrucsnulle1211keep those damn opinions to urself 😒😒
Guys let's not put this into a debate
Y'all are fighting like 2 yr olds
Minji-ahhh😢she should deserves more😭😭
She needs to sing better then
i hope they will let her rap more
no hate, I love minji’s voice too, but other members really sing better than her😢Newjeans fighting💪💪💪
@@Nina-xo555she does but she mainly raps
period. this is exactly how it should be. if hyein’s tiktoks were counted in asap, she’d be first but either way, im living for this ranking. minji my girl, we gonna get you some more lines, don’t worry
Finally, a video without missing any newjeans song
Hanni deserves it all ! ! 👏. The most unique and melodious voice
I like hyein voice
It’s obvious there type of music caters to Hanni’s range and tone…so it’s only fitting for her to take the most lines.
Hanni ❤❤❤❤
definitely feel like minji deserves more lines!!
In bubble gum you forgot Danielle adlibs and in Gods to, same to Hanni
5:30 - 5:33 Hanni, Danielle, Hyein, and Haerin did a 1 2 3 4.
That's exactly what I thought of too,but with"1,2,3,4 (Hyein,Haerin,Hanni,Danielle),you make me feel like 11 (Minji)
i noticed that lol
Whenever I listen to Danielle's voice it's giving calm and peaceful mind ❤
MY MINJI IS LEFT BEHINDD
haerin has the perfect voice for choruses!! More love for Haerin and Minji!!
What’s happen with Right Now? 😢😢
copyright reasons i think
My minji🥲 she didn't even touch top 2 in any of the songs🥲She deserves more lines
After hearing her fantastic rap in their cover of “Tell Me,” Minji is definitely being underutilized ☹️ But Hyein honestly has the most beautiful and versatile singing voice, so I’m actually surprised she got surpassed, though Hanni’s prominence in the “OMG” era was obvious.
Anyway, this is very interesting and sometimes unexpected, and I love the way you executed it all 😁
we need to fix the gap with minji.... hopefully she gets her well deserved first place soon :D
Erm…
Their line distribution is fair but Minji deserves better
Minji😢😢
Where is the song be who you are?
Hanni deserved it❤
Haerins falloff 😖
I love Haerin's voice so much but I feel like it used to be more powerful in the past?? Like during debut era in Attention and especially Hype Boy, I feel like she was singing with a more full voice (listen to her first voice in Hype Boy for example, during the "got me feeling YOUUU") whereas in newer songs, she always uses a softer tone
she's not the one decided it. it's mhj 😒if only haerin given another like hybe boy era.@@pinklemonaze9982
Yes you guys are right , I also felt her voice was really strong in hype boy and attention , and definitely the CEO and producers are not letting her use her actual voice and giving her less lines , if she would have sung the chorus part of supernatural, it would have sounded amzing
@@pinklemonaze9982 yeah but surely thats not her decision, the producers choose their lines and the way they should sound in the songs
All because hyein decided to steal all the lines as usual
please do X:IN 💗
Hanni:📉📉📈📈📈📈📉📈📉📈
Hyein:📈📈📉📉📉📉📈📉📈📉
PLS HYEIN GET A LINE😭✨🌷
Danielle has my fav voice❤wish her higher that this
Minji atleast deserve 2nd place 😢
Minji needs more lines
How come do they have 20 songs (including zero,be who you are and gods) and all are so good and listenable?
That's only new jeans ❤❤❤❤❤
Please do wayv
Minjiii😢😢❤❤
#Hyein #혜인
#Danielle #다니엘
#Minji #민지
#Haerin #해린
#Hanni #하니
Minji speak up ‼🗣
Newjeans ft. Minji
its saurrr sad
Hanni deserves being first, her voice is truly one of a kind
minji's line is not bad at all, someone has to be at the last place and technically, she is the weakest vocalist in the group with no sense of vocal support and they arent really a hiphop group for her to rap much, so her lines actually make sense
Yea she is the rapper of the group and some people say it’s her voice when it’s her position which is rapping
@@MariaLopez-u8wher position is not rapper. stop making stuff up. she’s just a weak vocalist, you can just say that and stop there. she’s not a rapper and new jeans songs don’t even have rap
Minji deserves more😢😢😢 i know he is not a vocalist but she can rap😢😢
Hanni got last for only 1 song?😮
And for a GOOD reason. The lyrics...
Yes, actually I thought she never got last 😂
Some songs adlibs are counted others not
that , that is interesting
this is very fair
Main vocalist on top🔥hanni deserves at the number one spot 🥶
another W for Hanni
in "Attention" Minji is in third place
minji why 😢
Danielle deserves to be first
And Hanni does not?
@@lilijonas8015she does but dani has better techniques
@@delulusheep I can tell ppl love Hanni's voice, it sounds like honey
@lilijonas8015 yes no doubt her voice is like honey but u didn't get my point.
@@delulusheep I know ur talking about technique, but do you have any proofs for that? That Dani’s technique > Hanni’s technique. Are you a pro? Cuz from what I read from some Vocal Analysis Page they say Hanni > Dani or sometimes Hanni = Dani
Not Hanni and Minji have 200s differences!!😢
Supernatural wrong i think
Haerin stans are really getting upsetting. Haerin has never been mistreated. shes the 2nd worst vocalist, right above Minji (who is also their best rapper) it makes sense these 2 are the bottom 2. there is no reason for Haerin to get more lines than she already does. plus are we ignoring Minji being 100 seconds behind 4th? Bunnis will scream mistreatment/unfair until it comes to Minji
I guess mhj should not debuted haerin and minji if she's only given them minimum lines. 🙄 how will they grow when mhj always give the most parts to hanni,danielle and hyein? the only haerin has or atleast more distribution lines is hybe boy and cookie.
Haerin is a better vocalist than hyein
@@Kep1er_OT8 Hyein has shown thw ability to support/almost can support and has a better tone than Haerin, Haerin is more comparable to Minji as both cannot support and are less stable than Hyein
@@daily_update87 they all provide somethign just like every idol in every group. go far back as Wonder Girls, are you saying Yubin shouldnt have been in that group because she never sang and only rapped? everyone provides something. all of NewJeans can sing. Hanni Dani and Hyein just happen to be better than the other 2 girls. plus Haerin is their 2nd best dancer and Minji is their best rapper. they all debuted for a reason. please stop being a pity stan because im sure the girls dont even care about line distributions as much as yall do
@@TayTaysSupremacy when haerin didn't cracks her voice all the time. especially in encore. 🤷 how will show her potential when she's not given a chance? mhj always give her low notes parts. unlike her hybe boy and cookie days. haerin suites higher notes.
Minji reminds me so much to everglows E:U
How?? Before i start saying anything I'm a minji bias but u can't compare minji to e:u minji get good lines sure she shoudl have more but she isn't mistreated alot
BRUH Minji is the last❗️❓:(
Not right now being copwrited 😪
Haerin😢
Мой топ:
1 Хэрин
2 Ханни
3 Хён
4 Минджи
5 Даниэль
Slayyyyyy ❤😊
No real surprise. The three extroverts are at the top and the two introvert at the bottom. Minji is a servant leader so she won't be up front as much, unless the others aren't up to the task, but all five can do anything.
What being introvert and extrovert have to do with singing?
@@guujikitsune Extroverts are more willing to do and try new and different things. The Introverts are okay with extroverts being out front. Introverts may even be better, but they allow the eagerness of the extroverts. Introverts are often reluctant heroes.
ya know minji is extroverted and hanni and hyein are introverted, right? minji is estj, hanni and hyein are both infp, they said it themselves
Oof such an incorrect statement lol
hanni and hyein are introverts and minji is a extrovert lol
this is so annoying, NewJeans has one of the most fair line distributions amongst k-pop groups which is distributed by vocal ability, and yet fans are still unhappy about it…
my haerin deserve😢
minji not being first in anemone at all??? my bias 😢. haerin only having first in zero is also sad-she gets a lot of the “killing parts” though so it kind of makes up for it
3 seconds ago ❤😊
All are great, but Dani is my girl!
Minji should leave this group. If they wanna give her less lines because her "voice is too deep", "the other members fits more" or "she's a rapper", then this group is not for her. She's just there to be a leader and visual.
Yeah exactly it’s not fair mhj is waisting her talent minji fitted aespa’s concept way better btw
The reason why their new songs are not getting much recognitions is only because they stopped giving lines to haerin. Like did they forget how everyone got obsessed with her voice in HypeBoy, the song that made them this popular. Also no hate but both Danielle and Haerin are better vocalists than Hyein......
Attention, hybe boy and Supershy. Hyein got most line. Their music style changed this comeback. Besides she start getting less lines than 30 sec. I like her lines the most but the starting chorus is a bit off and a monotone. Besides without hyein in the group performance, the dance performance look pretty lackluster and yeah, waiting for her comeback ot5. Bye.
Bfr Haerin is 4th at vocals. She doesn’t sound good during performance.
@@HaylaBeole Haerin definitely better and more stable than Hyein. Fight with the wall...
@@notaCasualListener not someone who is liking themself. To me hyein sounds better.Anyways upto u.
@JJ-cj4fc Its not about who got the most parts, it's about who got the parts suitable to the song, and in recent songs Haerin and Minji's voice suited a lot more than Hyein
I dont know why Haerin only fans are always toxic espesially from her chinese fans, why she attracts these kind of fans???
Because haerin carries this mid group, might as well call it haerins group
@@Kep1er_OT8funny
Fr I honestly feel bad for her she doesn’t deserve all these fake and toxic fans
@@Kep1er_OT8the group isn’t mid
@@Kep1er_OT8the group is top1 in Korea right now. Mid? In your dream 😂
Hi
MINJI GOT NOTHING THAT TOTALLY NOT FAIR
Imagine being the most perfect idol in vocal, dance and visuals and being second last. MHJ it's so full of garbage
Ok but I dont think you guys understand that this isn’t completely unfair (except for the fact that minji just now started getting lines), but aside from that producers usually choose who sings what lines and most idols dont even care about getting a lot of lines.
always Haerin fans who are never happy.. even though she always had decent lines
Mb bcuz the others r also so talented lol
why are haerin fans so weird? lol (love her tho, yall just complaining bout smth stupid. In that case, I'm praying for more minji lines 🤧)
Haerin is the second worst singer in NewJeans and the second last in lines. makes perfect sense. she is also a worse dancer than Hanni. Visual is subjective, but most people agree Minji is the visual.
Haerin deserves so much better and its all because hyein is sleeping with min heejin to steal all the lines
Sorry but Hyein has better vocal than Haerin
Yall toxic haerin stans don't even deserve to be called fans🤦♀️ Hyein is very talented, and so are all the members. Why can't you appreciate that and move on? You guys nitpick at hyein when she is the second in line distributions when it's clear hanni has most lines in their songs, yet yall blame hyein, and for what? she doesn't pick which lines she gets.
@@ewixxi"haerin is my bias" so hyein stans have resorted to lying now?? Y'all are shameless 😂
@@NæptuneMymaybe because Hanni is their best vocal while hyein is their 2nd worst vocal and always gets the most screentime, center and killing parts.
@@Kep1er_OT8 she isn’t the 2nd ‘worst’. Just because the other members are better doesn’t mean she is worst- there’s a difference.
The hyein favoritism
Hyein isn't even first bro. She's literally the least popular member so how is that favoritism. You're not a Haerin stan, you're a hyein hater.
And we cheer 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Considering she is clearly the best singing voice of the group, I was surprised she got surpassed by anyone.
@@ninjagamer1359 "best singing voice" you need mental help
@@Kep1er_OT8 You clearly have been mistaking her parts for someone else’s. Easy mistake. Took me a while to realize they were all hers, too, because she’s capable of a sound so unlike her regular voice.