Kim Nam Jun that’s the thing... i wonder if the people training them ever notice that their stage presence and the real vibe of the song dont match. and i wish they would’ve focus on that as well instead of just judging their singing/dancing like??
@@siroof7552 yeah her range is low. It doesn't mean that she's a bad singer I'll give you a few examples of good singers with low ranges Jisoo(Blackpink, Lead Vocal/Visual/oldest/actor. My fav vocalist in Blackpink) Jennie (Blackpink, Vocalist/ Main Rapper. She's a very good singer considering that she's a main rapper(a good one too) but she gets very unstable when trying to sing high notes and sound like she's straining.) Moonbyul (MAMAMOO, Main rapper, Main Dancer, Vocalist . Although her voice is very deep, she's really good at singing, her voice is really stable and soothing but same thing, not good at high notes) Yuqi ((G)idle , Lead Vocalist, lead dancer. Her voice is deep and soothing too but she can't sing high notes)
Just an ARMY who loves IKON she's an ex idol! She debuted with group Berry Good the song is Love Letter. In the MV she is the blonde one if you want to check it out!!
*i'm sure the coach were forced by mnet to praise them. I mean the coach are both from sm which has the most talented vocalist like snsd exo suju rv nct fx shinee. Impossible for them to praise vocal which has lower level than the non vocalist in their company vruh*
One trainee from the show, Jessica Lee exposed that most of the reactions are fake. They were asked to react to a blank screen. And interviews are recorded for hours, as the producers won’t let you go before you say what they wanted
also it’s possible they could take reaction shots from a different performance and edit them so it seems like they’re reacting to this performance when they’re not
1:35 That man is Wendy’s vocal coach 😭 Imagine having to hear the downgrade from Wendy’s vocals to theirs 🤭 (Except Kim Nayoung- she carried the performance)
@@woah9637 that it’s too much. Few of them were like 13 in korean age that time. Like do you want to sing it? Let’s see if you would do any better than them.
@@Sky-rb1sh thats a terrible excuse. They r going professional. Age is no factor. If you don't hit the standards then I don't see why they can't be criticized
Few of them are 12-13 that means they didn't get a lot of vocal training and stage experience. you cant expect them to fully excute their highnote as well as wendy or any of the members. They aren't even fully trained and have years and years of experience. No one is perfect at singing at first, it all comes down to training and practicing. They are just kids back then, I see that having excuses is normal since they are terribly bad but that doesn't mean that they were destined to be. They didn't get as much as experience, if they do then it wouldn't be for you too judge their vocals. Yes I permit that it was terrible performance but you shouldn't be throwing that much hate. literally calling them trash is just way too far.
The yellow shirt girl is a mess. Sorry but I think she’s the worst among the trash group. Nayeon was the only one who did good or maybe wonhee did fine.
@@Sky-rb1sh this group is full of little kids and your first thought is to call them trash when they probably never got any training. there’s 2 12/13 year olds in this group. putting down literal CHILDREN is not ok.
@@twicesdoorknob3670 At least instead of giving her the chorus and important parts she could of get a part that’s comfortable with her range, instead of making it cringey.
@@Sky-rb1sh but you cant just call them trash group. The song is really hard to perform, and they are all not proper trainees and the group mainly consists of kids. Constructive critiscm is ok but dont go too far please.
It's red velvet's fault for making the song look easy to be performed. Only red velvet can own their song. Many performance covers have failed. It's a fact.
@@seulgivssheep8416 pd48 trainees slayed peekaboo performance tho.. but its sad that gyuri voice cracked at one highnote.. but she did great at other parts
@@flop.anywaystanloonastanta8107 Yeah i was going to say the same, both groups slay peek a bo, one thing, is that mnet snake edit Alex Christine voice (i think she is called like that) bc she sound a bit weird singing in korean since she is from America, and gyuri little mistake but still slay !
flop. anyway, stan loona stan talent yeah, I think the red side of red velvet is the one that is hard to cover because many people don't understand the red side.
Multi Fandom-er why? I'm just saying that she is the best vocalist in that group. I'm not disagree on what he/she said. So pls.understand before you replied to my thoughts.
*The girls except Nayeon appears* Mentors: "Wow! Daebak! So cool! Her voice is so good!" *Nayeon hitting the high note* Mentors: "OkAyyyy...." REALLY SOUTH KOREA?!
i can actually imagine how Red Velvet will react to this Joy : pretends to smile Yeri : still pretends to he happy Seulgi : *speechless* Wendy : *oH yEah gIrl ! YOu rOCks iT* Irene : 👁👄👁
3 years later but i never mentioned how girlie from 0:48 to 1:10 absolutely bodied this. She carried the performance. Her high note near the end needs some work, but aside from that, she's great! (The girl with the deeper, more mature voice that sang from 0:59 to 1:04 was also good, she has a lot of potential, but her voice just doesn't fit this concept.) But back to the girl with the white shirt, red skirt, and yellow socks. She's the closest person- not just in this group- but the closest person i've ever seen to nailing Rookie concept aside from Red Velvet. She could be an idol. How far did she make it in this competition? Did she win?
The girl from 0:491:051:41 is the only one that has a good vocal in this performance, I think her name is Kim Nayeon. She saved it, but in 1:51 in the high note she just screamed
Yves owns my ass nope. Wendy sings it and hits the note. This girl strained, but it's understandable. It might not be in her range, but since she's the only one who can sing, she probably had to take it
I love how bada is trying so hard to be positive about this performance even though shes like one of sm's og main vocals. The sm vocal trainer can't even say anything nice so hes just stays quiet during 99% of the performance 😂
poor the girl in 0:52 she's only one can sing. And the rest, i already know why they can't be famous. Come on girls, don't destroy any song anymore 😂 please
o come on,.. one of the girls is in my class in school..i think that made me realize how destructive hate is. yeah they didnt do all to well but ,, mmm
So I came here because I heard bad comments about the performance but I didn’t expect it was THIS bad. Like wtf. All they have is visual. The main vocal girl who did high notes carry the whole team. Girl with yellow shirt and girl with mercy shirt and the girl with yellow skirt is just ughh. They were bad really bad. I don’t stan fromis 9 but their group seem to be doing fine with Love Bomb. But This shit was bad. Too much aegyo. Off beat dancing. Tearrible high pitch singing it literal gave me anxiety. I rarely press the dislike button but who cares it was damn bad.
Only the girl at 0:59 or 1:20 is in the final group and she improved seriously a lot so don't worry, Fromis_9 members are really talented and well rounded lmao. But yeah this was awful. Plus the song choice was seriously the worst. Rookie is a really tricky song. Might sound cute and easy at first but it's like one of the hardest Red Velvet songs to pull off (tbh all RV songs are tho lol) as it really doesn't need any cutesy.
I came after watching Red Velvet's purple outfit performance for Rookie and saw the comments, so I came to see for myself and- *I was found dead* I mean the girls at 0:25 and 0:50 were good but I can't say the same for that girl with the yellow shirt and the buns- BUT I'M 100% SURE THEY TRIED THEIR BEST EVEN IF IT SOUNDED A little uhm bad-
I know that they are still rookies but damn only one person fits this song. EDIT: idk why they keep their voices in a high pitch. I believe that this is not some cutesy song whatsoever.
Cause they didn’t make a mistake, this is just bad. The trainees probably thought it was good for them cause they didn’t make any mistakes, however they are completely terrible
well, the shows are really different, most Produce trainees had at least 1 year of being trainees in a company and most IS contestants had 0 experience and no company.
i can imagine how Red Velvet will react to this : Joy : /smiles awkwardly Yeri : “ what tf is this lmao “ Seulgi : pretends to like it Wendy : 👁👄👁 Irene : trying really hard to hold her laugh anyway what tf is this voice lmao 1:24
Que queee park sun was eliminated during the second elimination if I'm not wrong But she's not part of the final group (only Jiheon is in the group from this performance)
This live is a whole new level of bad. Not only were they like half a beat late in singing to practically half the song, but they were stiff and awkward, had unnatural tones, couldn't hit the notes properly... especially the girl in yellow. Good god who let her do Seulgi's part? She can't follow a beat to save her life! I thought the beginning was bad enough when the "yeah" left her mouth, but I didn't think her sense of rhythm would be all over the place too. Most of the girls here have many improvements to make, especially the girl in the yellow shirt who should have been eliminated by now.
What's funny is that the coaches were praising them (aside from the serious coach from Unnies who looks like he's just nodding to act like he agrees), and the reactions of the other trainees on the room.
if anyone is curious, the girl at 1:20 is Baek Jiheon and she debuted in the final group. She’s super talented, but this song selection was just not it. Looking at how talented she is now compared to how she sounds here, I won’t judge the other girls either bc who knows, they could be hella talented too
Those who can't see or hear what's wrong with this and think this is good are probably 4th gen stans The bar is too low 😂 The 1 girl did great she's literally carrying the group
how is irene-i mean she may look and seem cold but she's really sweet-yeri, and joy rude? or are you assuming that? also yeah, that doesn't really make you sound any better... lol
0:49 & 1:47 saved this performance. Sorry but this was so bad & their voices were really annoying (except Kim Nayeon) , I don't understand why they were all cheering .-. This proves that it takes more than looks to debut as an idol. Also I can't believe that annoying one (i forgot her name) who sang off beat got the highest score ffs
same.... I was like why are they smiling and clapping???? Did I miss something or??? If they performed in my school people would be booing them. This girl once performed Katy Perry's "Firework" and she wasn't even bad but her voice was really soft so no one cheered...
To the ones commenting on the original comment, you do realize that the girl wants to become a singer and she is on a show to be judged on her voice. Maybe her voice was high pitched because of her age and maybe not but it doesn’t change the fact she didn’t sing the song great.
@Aesthetic Choco wtf u know what im also 2005....... °○° .... reads all the comment makes me feel like im nominated " the meanest gurl in 2005 born line" (or watever...):v
...I mean, I know the girl in the yellow shirt was like 13 in this video but why was she given sooo many parts when it could've been given to the other girls
this performance is legendary. in a bad way- edit : y'all getting so pressed yes i know they're kids and they still have a lot to improve and all im just saying the performance itself is bad IN MY OWN OPINION, but ngl can't stop watching
Popular opinions: 0:26, 1:15, 1:59, 2:20 this girls' voice are cringe, just facts. 0:38 she is not so lost 1:01, 1:21 just okay 1:12 - 1:22 one of the worst parts What the hell am I doing here? 0:49 Somebody knows were can I find Kim Nayeon and stan her forever?
0:26 2:20 is the main vocal of ho1iday, this is just not an easy song 1:15 is a twelve-year-old girl 1:59 is also a really hard part because of the staccato 1:01 is fine 1:21 this is about sun right? yeah she has a fair amount of potential especially now that she's training at starship 1:12 on - she still has problems with this, she doesn't open her mouth enough when singing (especially since she smiles constantly) and stifles the sound 0:49 she used to be in berry good and now has a youtube channel! by the way plz try not to send too much hate to these girls, half of them are really young
![Idol School [9회]애절+아련, 시간을 달리는 5명의 소녀들 ′시간을 달려서′장규리,김은서,이유정,김나연,조유리 @학기말고사 170915 EP.9](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tJhROYRObYo/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol School [9회]애절+아련, 시간을 달리는 5명의 소녀들 ′시간을 달려서′장규리,김은서,이유정,김나연,조유리 @학기말고사 170915 EP.9](/img/tr.png)
![Red Velvet - Rookie [Music Bank HOT Stage / 2017.02.24]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oYIPa0t372w/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol School [4회]귀염울렁증 극뽁!♬ 'Cheer Up' 신시아,이나경,이채영,송하영,김은서,타샤,빈하늘,김주현 @ 1차데뷔능력고사 170803 EP.4](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wFi0139GIvk/mqdefault.jpg)
*sounds like a bunch of girls singing in a karaoke bar*
Except Nayeon
Nayeon is that one friend who takes Karaoke seriously
IT DOES LMAOOOO
omg ikr, what did i just watch-
bunch of drunk girls lmaooo
I either come here if:
-Depressed
-Bored
-Just want to look at the comments
skksks same
im the third one lol
ambvvr You're right haha, i am here because the comments
Third lmao
Im the 2 and 3
Forget Peek A Boo and Really Bad Boy. This is the real horror concept.
So savage
I feel bad for laughing but this is seriously so damn funny. 💀
!
*HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAH*
😏😏😏😏
i can hear yeri in the background saying 'thats not cute'
Somebody said me that Yeri really doesn't like this music
@@lunap5521 Mostly because of the choreography
Luna :P she said it was because the movement used a lot of breath that it is hard to sing.
It’s terrifying
*des not cute wendy 😔*
I just realised that I'm good at singing
Lololol
🤣
Gurl same😂😂
Sameee
Same lmao
0:15 when I heard that "yeahhh" I suddenly understood, this was gonna be a bloody mess
Sofía LMAO!!! Same fam same 😂😂
I don't like this girl, she don't sing well, and she too skinny my gosh, scary
That 'yeahhh' had me dead 😂
Sofía .
I heard it & went oh fuck issa bout to get butchered
no one:
*their minds: AEGYO = GOOD STAGE PRESENCE*
i liked
Thing is, this is not an aegyo song. They would have worked better with something like Pick Me, Liar Liar or Very Very Very
Kim Nam Jun that’s the thing... i wonder if the people training them ever notice that their stage presence and the real vibe of the song dont match. and i wish they would’ve focus on that as well instead of just judging their singing/dancing like??
lu na really have no idea why they’d ever pair up this cute group with an honestly very sassy sounding song
wow it’s not like they’re kids
Nayeon carried this honestly. Everyone else sounds like drunk ppl at a karaoke place
Bork PomPom too be fair they are kids
@@justcupcakeaka Yes, but then they shouldn't be in competitions like this.
@@justcupcakeaka can you list their ages if you don’t mind I’m curious 😂
@@echouniverse idk the others but the girl in the yellow shirt with the buns is literally 13
0:25 that girl is actually pretty good too for me
0:52 I'm sorry for this girl, she is the only talented one...
Andy Buga kim nayeon! She debuted before she was part of berry good.
That's her?
Omg, I love berry good since the Angel era so I didn't know about her. Now I'm cheering for her!
Mark Gabriel Cayat WHY IS SHE HERE OH NOOO💔
agree she saved the show😭
Andy Buga she was with berry good during debut but she left after that. She was no longer w them during Angel
0:49 the only girl who deserves to be praised, her voice is really good.
Her name is Kim Nayeon
xtherealsunshinex have you heard her high note! ITS SO TRASH
@@siroof7552 yeah her range is low. It doesn't mean that she's a bad singer I'll give you a few examples of good singers with low ranges
Jisoo(Blackpink, Lead Vocal/Visual/oldest/actor. My fav vocalist in Blackpink)
Jennie (Blackpink, Vocalist/ Main Rapper. She's a very good singer considering that she's a main rapper(a good one too) but she gets very unstable when trying to sing high notes and sound like she's straining.)
Moonbyul (MAMAMOO, Main rapper, Main Dancer, Vocalist . Although her voice is very deep, she's really good at singing, her voice is really stable and soothing but same thing, not good at high notes)
Yuqi ((G)idle , Lead Vocalist, lead dancer. Her voice is deep and soothing too but she can't sing high notes)
I really like the one at 0:59
@@silvanaarmijos5315 Thanks!
0:50 she is the only one who didn't completely murder the song
What’s funny about your comment is the time stamp shows the girl with the worst singing 😂
Echo Universe it doesn’t
1:06 is the girl
nobody:
me and my multiple personalities at 3am:
hyewon obsessed
This made me laugh more than it should’ve
yas ableism
@@user-nd5lg2rj2j girl shut up
@@oliviahye5183 not a girl and no thx
@@user-nd5lg2rj2j who?
0:49 girl saved this performance
Just an ARMY who loves IKON she is nayeon,plz support her
pun yoyo Yes I will support her. She caught my attention.
Just an ARMY who loves IKON she's an ex idol! She debuted with group Berry Good the song is Love Letter. In the MV she is the blonde one if you want to check it out!!
Kim na yeon safe this group...
Nah she just made it less disappointing lmao
I just realized how Red velvet is amazing idol group........
this performance actually help people who thinking RedVel are not good to re-thinking........
RV=Real Vokal
Oka Juniari *vocal but yeah
*i'm sure the coach were forced by mnet to praise them. I mean the coach are both from sm which has the most talented vocalist like snsd exo suju rv nct fx shinee. Impossible for them to praise vocal which has lower level than the non vocalist in their company vruh*
One trainee from the show, Jessica Lee exposed that most of the reactions are fake. They were asked to react to a blank screen. And interviews are recorded for hours, as the producers won’t let you go before you say what they wanted
Eunice Chen woah 😨
also it’s possible they could take reaction shots from a different performance and edit them so it seems like they’re reacting to this performance when they’re not
1:35 That man is Wendy’s vocal coach 😭 Imagine having to hear the downgrade from Wendy’s vocals to theirs 🤭 (Except Kim Nayoung- she carried the performance)
@@jyr6453 honestly, he looks so disappointed but was trying to smile on TV
This just proves that Red Velvet songs are hard to cover
Nah these people r trash.
But still red velvet must've been cringing to this
@@woah9637 that it’s too much. Few of them were like 13 in korean age that time. Like do you want to sing it? Let’s see if you would do any better than them.
@@Sky-rb1sh thats a terrible excuse. They r going professional. Age is no factor. If you don't hit the standards then I don't see why they can't be criticized
Few of them are 12-13 that means they didn't get a lot of vocal training and stage experience. you cant expect them to fully excute their highnote as well as wendy or any of the members. They aren't even fully trained and have years and years of experience. No one is perfect at singing at first, it all comes down to training and practicing.
They are just kids back then, I see that having excuses is normal since they are terribly bad but that doesn't mean that they were destined to be. They didn't get as much as experience, if they do then it wouldn't be for you too judge their vocals.
Yes I permit that it was terrible performance but you shouldn't be throwing that much hate. literally calling them trash is just way too far.
@@Sky-rb1sh damn chill, what I said was like 4 months ago. I don't even like kpop anymore so I'm not gonna debate about kpop
Imagine Bae Yoon Jung reacting to this
Nomnom Animations oh no. Blood will spill
HAHAHA
Imagine these girls joining produce 101
oh no. world war z will be coming lol
F CLASS
0:38 I'm still confused that the judges thought that part was GOOD, when it was actually one of the worst.
omg i was searching for this comment like i thought that im the only one with a working mind
I really liked it.. also really like 0:59
@@Mat-xy7gb true i really liked that part with the blue dress girl, I was kinda sad that she didnt have more lines because she was stable
Riolen Same.. Also very disappointed that she didn’t get many points
Totally Agree Dude👌
Why the yellow girl so many lines. Shes out of tune. So cringe...
she was 12 internationally.. she's getting proper training now.
The yellow shirt girl is a mess. Sorry but I think she’s the worst among the trash group. Nayeon was the only one who did good or maybe wonhee did fine.
@@Sky-rb1sh this group is full of little kids and your first thought is to call them trash when they probably never got any training. there’s 2 12/13 year olds in this group. putting down literal CHILDREN is not ok.
@@twicesdoorknob3670 At least instead of giving her the chorus and important parts she could of get a part that’s comfortable with her range, instead of making it cringey.
@@Sky-rb1sh but you cant just call them trash group. The song is really hard to perform, and they are all not proper trainees and the group mainly consists of kids. Constructive critiscm is ok but dont go too far please.
0:49 this girl just saved the whole performance
Red velvet are calling their lawyer rn
Edit: HOLY SHIT I didn't expected to get a lot of likes lmaooo
naah... the fact that sm vocals coach and heechul is in here along with bada.. sm wouldnt do a single thing lol
Reffi Eka Wulansari , it's a joke dude.
Reffi Eka Wulansari lol!! Triggered much?? Issa joke.
LOL imagine Baechu on the phone saying "please defend our song Rookie!" with a concerned face 😅
ISSA JOKE YEOROBUN XD
2:30 literally the best part
BAHAHHAHAHA😭
NO OH JY HUGGUGYU💀
They : Yeah.. alright
Me : Scroll through comments and found yours, then click at 2:30
And the video just ends, LOL ㅋㅋ
Thanks
@ok don't take it seriously girl, she just pointed to the end of the song
That’s why you don’t cover Red Velvet when you are not vocally prepared.
It's red velvet's fault for making the song look easy to be performed. Only red velvet can own their song. Many performance covers have failed. It's a fact.
Right? People's alway thought that RV's is an easy.. Rookie and Red flavor already proven..
@@seulgivssheep8416 pd48 trainees slayed peekaboo performance tho.. but its sad that gyuri voice cracked at one highnote.. but she did great at other parts
@@flop.anywaystanloonastanta8107 Yeah i was going to say the same, both groups slay peek a bo, one thing, is that mnet snake edit Alex Christine voice (i think she is called like that) bc she sound a bit weird singing in korean since she is from America, and gyuri little mistake but still slay !
flop. anyway, stan loona stan talent yeah, I think the red side of red velvet is the one that is hard to cover because many people don't understand the red side.
HAHAHAHAHA
0:52 They should've just let her sing the whole time...
Gabrielle Williams i think she did well for that part
Gabrielle Williams you know why?
Because she is the one who got the best vocal...
Crystal Bread Girl Sujeong oh god can’t you read? The person said she should’ve sung the whole song
Multi Fandom-er why?
I'm just saying that she is the best vocalist in that group.
I'm not disagree on what he/she said.
So pls.understand before you replied to my thoughts.
Seriously
*The girls except Nayeon appears*
Mentors: "Wow! Daebak! So cool! Her voice is so good!"
*Nayeon hitting the high note*
Mentors: "OkAyyyy...."
REALLY SOUTH KOREA?!
the high note was not it
she didn’t really sing the note tho
Still, she sounded the best ;-;
@@theTH-camrfr the point is that she's the only one who actually sound good
@@user-mc4fn5fc7c okay
i can actually imagine how Red Velvet will react to this
Joy : pretends to smile
Yeri : still pretends to he happy
Seulgi : *speechless*
Wendy : *oH yEah gIrl ! YOu rOCks iT*
Irene : 👁👄👁
Lol
Lmao wendy hahahah this is accurate and i love her for it
Only the girl at 0:49 is good
And for the others I’m so sorry
Yes. I feel the same way. 0:49, 1:40 .
김태연 she carried the whole group lol
what's her name?
; her name is Kim Nayeon
Ikr she is not the best but she did soo good and better than the rest!👍
they even made the girl who sang the IU 3 high notes in PD101 better...
I CHOKED
OHMYGOD
But that girl from PD101 CAN sing, she purposely bombed it "for the attention" (correct me if im wrong guys)
LMFAOOO
She did it in purpose cause she wanted to stand out among those 100 other trainees
1:42 she carried the whole performance
0:49 girly carried the WHOLE performance
why did they give the girl in the yellow shirt such a big role
Because she is sub-singer 1
jiminie pabo
but why
This gives me hope that I actually could be an idol
Hahahhahahaha u gives me reason to be happy today
I laughed so hard😂😂😂
Same xdxd
😂😂😂😂
Brugh same
3 years later but i never mentioned how girlie from 0:48 to 1:10 absolutely bodied this. She carried the performance. Her high note near the end needs some work, but aside from that, she's great!
(The girl with the deeper, more mature voice that sang from 0:59 to 1:04 was also good, she has a lot of potential, but her voice just doesn't fit this concept.)
But back to the girl with the white shirt, red skirt, and yellow socks. She's the closest person- not just in this group- but the closest person i've ever seen to nailing Rookie concept aside from Red Velvet. She could be an idol. How far did she make it in this competition? Did she win?
She didn't win but she is/was an idol! Her name is Kim Nayeon and she was in Berry Good. As far as I know she has a TH-cam channel.
i swear they would’ve been decent if it weren’t for the girl in yellow, her voice stands out too much😰
The girl from 0:49 1:05 1:41 is the only one that has a good vocal in this performance, I think her name is Kim Nayeon. She saved it, but in 1:51 in the high note she just screamed
That is a high not that needs to be screamed lmao. Wendy does it too it's not a bad thing.
I agree 100%
I strongly agree
Yves owns my ass nope. Wendy sings it and hits the note. This girl strained, but it's understandable. It might not be in her range, but since she's the only one who can sing, she probably had to take it
preach .
I can not imagine this group without nayeon.😂😂
Kpop Macaron modeun ge YEAH!
Kpop Macaron and Yoojung too
Kpop Macaron who is nayeon?
Agustina 01:43 she is ex member of berry good..
Kpop Macaron oh thanks :)
I love how bada is trying so hard to be positive about this performance even though shes like one of sm's og main vocals. The sm vocal trainer can't even say anything nice so hes just stays quiet during 99% of the performance 😂
Flashbacks to people attacking the underage girls with literally no idol training WHICH WAS THE POINT OF THE SHOW.
not to mention they were malnourished to the point of losing their periods LIKE???
poor the girl in 0:52 she's only one can sing. And the rest, i already know why they can't be famous. Come on girls, don't destroy any song anymore 😂 please
Linh Tran Ariel the girl in all dark blue can sing too
Linh Tran Ariel If they have visuals they'll be famous in Korea. Its sad that few ppl actually care about talent these days ;-;
o come on,.. one of the girls is in my class in school..i think that made me realize how destructive hate is. yeah they didnt do all to well but ,, mmm
Linh Tran Ariel they need to stick to dancing, omg.
0:27 isn't bad too. She got visual, energy, moves, and overall girl group member qualifications done.
Red Velvet, if you're watching this. Don't watch this.
Edit: I didn‘t expect to get so many likes lol xD
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA the accuracy
Lol
Lara c: U
*just realising that Red Velvet slayed this concept without overcuteness or creepiness*
Girl with the yellow shirt really out here sounding like elmo 💀💀
So I came here because I heard bad comments about the performance but I didn’t expect it was THIS bad. Like wtf. All they have is visual. The main vocal girl who did high notes carry the whole team. Girl with yellow shirt and girl with mercy shirt and the girl with yellow skirt is just ughh. They were bad really bad. I don’t stan fromis 9 but their group seem to be doing fine with Love Bomb. But This shit was bad. Too much aegyo. Off beat dancing. Tearrible high pitch singing it literal gave me anxiety. I rarely press the dislike button but who cares it was damn bad.
Only the girl at 0:59 or 1:20 is in the final group and she improved seriously a lot so don't worry, Fromis_9 members are really talented and well rounded lmao. But yeah this was awful. Plus the song choice was seriously the worst. Rookie is a really tricky song. Might sound cute and easy at first but it's like one of the hardest Red Velvet songs to pull off (tbh all RV songs are tho lol) as it really doesn't need any cutesy.
hahaha dont worry fromis9 isn’t from any of this except for that girl that carried the whole team the one with the red and white shirt
@@teabbags actually baek jiheon is in Fromis9 and is singing this song^^
@@nctsgrass can you give me their names pls?
@@fattydoggoproductions4541 Fromis_9 members names?
I hate this more then I hate myself
Julia Paulina omg 😂
lol I cannot!!
Hahahaahahaha
i agree but please use (THAN) when comparing things :D (THEN) is used when a thing happens after another
oml XD
I can hear Yeri saying "that's not cute"
I came after watching Red Velvet's purple outfit performance for Rookie and saw the comments, so I came to see for myself and-
*I was found dead*
I mean the girls at 0:25 and 0:50 were good but I can't say the same for that girl with the yellow shirt and the buns-
BUT I'M 100% SURE THEY TRIED THEIR BEST EVEN IF IT SOUNDED A little uhm bad-
I was from there too... 😂😂😂 but unlike you im not watching this, its on pause while i read the comments.....😂😂😂
Exactly, they did her best
Lol same i was from there too
I know that they are still rookies but damn only one person fits this song.
EDIT: idk why they keep their voices in a high pitch. I believe that this is not some cutesy song whatsoever.
the one who wears dark blue r quite good tbh
its bc theyre all like super young like in their early teens except for a few like nayeon
CapslockCat this song is hard af!! even the rv members had a hard time..
Nayeon is the only good one here
*opens youtube*
*sees video*
yellow girl : yeah al-
*closes youtube*
Sobra to lol
ME
My face cringed so bad that my boss asked what happened?
They are kids don't be so cruel 😒
Enaiat Mohamed kids or not, i never cringed so hard
1:53 im dying at how he just says "ok."
Lowkey same
Nayeon, Yujeong and Jiheon saved this performance
who is yujeong?
I prefer somi( 1:00) than jiheon here
I’m sorry but jiheon sounded kinda bad here
@@riayanami just my opinion I don’t think her voice went well with this song
Still can't understand why Kim Nayeon didn't get more votes. She was far the best in this group
nenieengel they only care about visuals or how cute the idol is, not their vocals. Sad world in Korea.
She looks like After's Schools Uee
mari Honestly tho..Korea is all about looks. It's sad how that I am Korean and some Koreans be saying that I am ugly or not pretty enough.
Ikr. I knew her from her former debut group (berry good) and it is sad to see she still didn't make it until now to be an idol.
Bagus
Produce: *jang gyuri etc does a small mistake on singing*
Trainers: :O oh no...
Idol school: *this*
Trainers: :O wow good job!
The difference...
Cause they didn’t make a mistake, this is just bad. The trainees probably thought it was good for them cause they didn’t make any mistakes, however they are completely terrible
HELLO GUYS the trainers of produce have always been better at their job 🤷🏻♀️
well Gyuri made a very obvious mistake amongst her amazing singing but this performance was just a trainwreck from the beginning.
well, the shows are really different, most Produce trainees had at least 1 year of being trainees in a company and most IS contestants had 0 experience and no company.
@@sunjingles7829 but should there be a trainer that judge them while practicing is the tone fine or too much?
0:39 the trainer's so done with the sh*t she just pretending
i can imagine how Red Velvet will react to this :
Joy : /smiles awkwardly
Yeri : “ what tf is this lmao “
Seulgi : pretends to like it
Wendy : 👁👄👁
Irene : trying really hard to hold her laugh
anyway what tf is this voice lmao 1:24
Trainers: OH SHE DID SO WELL 0:36
Trainers: oh she did okay 1:50
EW GIRL 0:39 they made a comment on this girl
@@rebeccarosas6441 oof yeah i was looking for this comment to delete the reply ty
they were praising them for different thing
0:39 was praise for a 14 year old girl who barely speaks any korean.
Maybe during practice, the first girl was not doing good, and the second girl was doing better.
How can the judges praise them wtf JUDGES WTF
Bright lotus no actually mnet is an evil...they edited the judges reactions and change the reactions to other performance videos
The reactions are fake
Ayesha Ramos how did u know that?
you gotta listen carefully to the background audio when they react...u can hear it is not the same song.
the boy beside the girl jugde is sm vocal trainer which means he's expert in vocal thingy i bet his ears are bleeding
Jiheon react to this after she debuted of fromis_9 : *KILL ME PLIS*
Which one is she???
@@laxmilamsal8297 1:19
She is Jiheon,she debuted on fromis_9
@@laxmilamsal8297 1:20 she only get 1 line😔
the girl with the red skirt and red and white top wasn’t actually that bad 0:50
Can I just ask if that yellow shirt girl made it cuz oh boy her voice gives me anxiety
Que queee she did
Nayeon My Savior oh boi rip this group ....
Que queee park sun was eliminated during the second elimination if I'm not wrong
But she's not part of the final group (only Jiheon is in the group from this performance)
LMAOOO
She sounds like a robot
This live is a whole new level of bad. Not only were they like half a beat late in singing to practically half the song, but they were stiff and awkward, had unnatural tones, couldn't hit the notes properly... especially the girl in yellow. Good god who let her do Seulgi's part? She can't follow a beat to save her life! I thought the beginning was bad enough when the "yeah" left her mouth, but I didn't think her sense of rhythm would be all over the place too. Most of the girls here have many improvements to make, especially the girl in the yellow shirt who should have been eliminated by now.
ishipthatfishycouple and the fact that even their dance is not that good is really... damn.
Rhythm is big I agree. I'd prefer a regular voice with rhythm, than a echoing singing voice that isn't on rhythm.
i like nayeon’s voice(the one who sang at 0:50 )
yeah, she's the only person who has decent singing vocals in the group hahahahahahaha
What's funny is that the coaches were praising them (aside from the serious coach from Unnies who looks like he's just nodding to act like he agrees), and the reactions of the other trainees on the room.
if anyone is curious, the girl at 1:20 is Baek Jiheon and she debuted in the final group. She’s super talented, but this song selection was just not it.
Looking at how talented she is now compared to how she sounds here, I won’t judge the other girls either bc who knows, they could be hella talented too
Every once in awhile I come back here just to remind myself how good the original song is. Red Velvet are an absolutely talented group.
O no... These poor girls........
They gonna grow up and see this, then regret life....
Me: Woah, they are so pretty * yellow shirt girl starts singing * what the--
I almost threw my laptop.
Same here
Zedekiah Bell she sounded terrible and I’m younger than her
@Zedekiah Bell I've seen you comment this at least twice; just because she's young it doesn't make her above being judged, just saying
She is internationally 12 years old that time and her 13th birthday is months later.
even my singer 8-year-old niece sing better than her
Me : "omg it's a rookie cover! I love the song, let's hear it"
Her : *"y-"*
Me : *closes the whole youtube app*
but u leave the comment here
Those who can't see or hear what's wrong with this and think this is good are probably 4th gen stans
The bar is too low 😂
The 1 girl did great she's literally carrying the group
_red velvet reaction to this_
irene: *speechless*
wendy: *constructive cristicism*
seulgi: *"uhm okay uhm uhm"*
joy and yeri: *"LMAOOOOOO WTF AHHAHSBDBDJEIBRRJ MERONG MERONG MERONG MERONG HDBDHRBRBFBRKSKSKAKAKKAKSKSKSKKS"*
hawoo yeri would straight start cursing
Nah
Wendy will just smile
And kill them in their sleep
Yerin: that's not cute😂😂😂
I am Joy and Yeri to a T lol
So accurate lmao
even the intro was bad, she's supposed to flick her head up, not try and pop her skull off her neck
啊啊啊 ikr! It looked so messy and strange
啊啊啊 Lmao!!! My thoughts exactly 😂
Yea, it look so messed up
this is the funniest comment i've encountered in this video. thanks for making me laugh after a tiring day XD
Omg HAHAHAHHA 😂😂😂😂
the fact SM vocal trainers are smiling i----. the girl at 0:49 saved this already cursed cover of rookie skfgjgkdf
They’re trying their best, but this song is extremely difficult. Red velvet makes it look easy
on a positive note the girl at 1:40 has potential
Deflextion she was in a group that’s why
yes
She the best one here
Deflextion this
The high note was not so good
Red velvet, I'm sorry sweeties you don't deserve to be disrespected like this
Bangtan's Bae revesluts are so rude (just like irene, yeri and joy). be thankful that there are people covering your excuse of idol group
Lee Sujin Center queen of Mixnine why are you calling reveluvs (idk how to spell) mean when you are being kind of rude also?
how is irene-i mean she may look and seem cold but she's really sweet-yeri, and joy rude? or are you assuming that? also yeah, that doesn't really make you sound any better... lol
EXACTLY!!!
@@cowmantits you calling idols rude is actually ruderr
The best part is at the end, when you can hear their tired breathing into the mics that MNET didn’t cut out for some reason 💀
*inserts Yeri's voice : THAT'S NOT CUTE*
0:49 & 1:47 saved this performance. Sorry but this was so bad & their voices were really annoying (except Kim Nayeon) , I don't understand why they were all cheering .-. This proves that it takes more than looks to debut as an idol. Also I can't believe that annoying one (i forgot her name) who sang off beat got the highest score ffs
Cosmic LOOΠΔ Sun? She actually got the second highest score for vocal skills after Natty.
In the first evaluation, that is.
Cosmic LOOΠΔ ye 0:49 was pretty good
Just that her "yeah" was more of screaming and not singing...
same.... I was like why are they smiling and clapping???? Did I miss something or??? If they performed in my school people would be booing them. This girl once performed Katy Perry's "Firework" and she wasn't even bad but her voice was really soft so no one cheered...
0:18 *DaNg DaNg Hi* idk why but the way she said it made me laugh so hard
she sounded like distorted bells omg
@@suchismithakn i heard it like tangdangbi....
I laughed with all her lines.
WHATS HER NAME
I heard DANG DANG EE
거짓말 안 할 텐데 이번 공연은 끔찍 했어 다행이 나연이 무대를 구했다!
how dare the girl in yellow even attempt seulgis part gahddamn
1:56 *nice high note, saved the performance*
1:58 loOkIE lOoKiE
JAHAHAAHAHAHAHA OHMYGOD
WELL THEY GOT THAT SAME WITH RV SO WANDA GOT TRIGGERED JK HAHAHA
Hahahahaha
@@kit1042 well at least RV pronounced "lookie" goodly, unlike the ones in this video.
Even the high note was bad
Irene's part at the beginning is like the iconic and easiest part of the song, and she ruined it!!!
the disrespect to RV!!
Try Park Sun girl, like you can do better XD
To the ones commenting on the original comment, you do realize that the girl wants to become a singer and she is on a show to be judged on her voice. Maybe her voice was high pitched because of her age and maybe not but it doesn’t change the fact she didn’t sing the song great.
@Aesthetic Choco wtf u know what im also 2005....... °○° .... reads all the comment makes me feel like im nominated " the meanest gurl in 2005 born line" (or watever...):v
@@jiminiepabo8521 I can
@@jiminiepabo8521 It's Not Hard Lmao
...I mean, I know the girl in the yellow shirt was like 13 in this video but why was she given sooo many parts when
it could've been given to the other girls
most of the contestants here were literal children at the time you guys are going too far. 😭
tbh the one with yellow shirt's voice is so... ugh, idk. even her rap part makes me cringe, sorry.
elflawless theres no rap in this
That girl at 0:49 was so good
The girl with the yellow top is just....her pronunciation of Irene's 1st line (not 1 2 line) gets on my nerves lmao
True-
@Moonflower OFFICIAL We know,but I don't think a 12 year old should sound like a 6 year old though...Her voice is too high pitched
@Moonflower OFFICIAL using her age as an excuse for her bad performance is basically an insult to people her age or younger who could actually sing
2:30 protect your ears
0:15 i don't want to be a hater but once i heard that, i cried.
0:18 yeez that girl sounds like a tomodachi mii
G G I DIED HAHAHAHAHAH
She’s a cutie tho! But yeah her voice is pretty high...and squeaky.
Someone just kick her already
Can u tell me What's her name?
Ánh Nguyệt Triệu park sun
People in the comments are so mean like,,, they are literally childs.... stop
How much they pay the trainer to say that? Or how much the yellow shirt gotta pay to even be in the show
She's only 12 here and korean she's 13 , , we don't have to expect more
this performance is legendary.
in a bad way-
edit : y'all getting so pressed yes i know they're kids and they still have a lot to improve and all im just saying the performance itself is bad IN MY OWN OPINION, but ngl can't stop watching
ah yes we love y’all mocking 12-17 year olds who mostly have no training and experience (except for two)
@@reliomese2873 ok and..? they're children trying to follow their dreams, stop bashing them
stupidhead Why the hell are they trying to be idols when they’re in sixth grade then?
stupidhead ps in regards to the sixth grade part, I’m American
@@caramelle0191 Because they can??? If they would have made it to the group and as the show progressed, they most likely would've improved.
This performance shows that even this song titled "Rookie", it is definitely not for rookie to sing
lol love this comment!
they're not even in the rookie level tf??
watched this months ago and came back after discovering fromis_9 that girl from 1:19 is a reveluv and I knew she hated this moment
Kim Nayeon is good no doubt since her childhood bestfriend was GFRIEND's Eunha & SinB and highschool friend of GFRIEND'S Yerin
Popular opinions:
0:26, 1:15, 1:59, 2:20 this girls' voice are cringe, just facts.
0:38 she is not so lost
1:01, 1:21 just okay
1:12 - 1:22 one of the worst parts
What the hell am I doing here?
0:49 Somebody knows were can I find Kim Nayeon and stan her forever?
Please support Kim Nayeon she is doing vocal covers she has a TH-cam channel th-cam.com/video/WfcgncTWsc0/w-d-xo.html
aww i kinda liked the one at 0:26
Literally Epiphany me too lol
0:26 2:20 is the main vocal of ho1iday, this is just not an easy song
1:15 is a twelve-year-old girl
1:59 is also a really hard part because of the staccato
1:01 is fine
1:21 this is about sun right? yeah she has a fair amount of potential especially now that she's training at starship
1:12 on - she still has problems with this, she doesn't open her mouth enough when singing (especially since she smiles constantly) and stifles the sound
0:49 she used to be in berry good and now has a youtube channel!
by the way plz try not to send too much hate to these girls, half of them are really young
@@user-nd5lg2rj2j THANK YOU FOR SOME GOOD NON CRITICISM ANSWER.
After watching this performance, people must realize how hard Rookie is and how RV doing a really great job in every performance.
Chistrina Marpaung agree agree agree
Yeah. RV jjang!
Yess
Even tho there's more girls here it sounds like there's less singers than at red velvet.
no one:
the one who sings in chorus: luhkei luhkei my supah luhkei lukhi
1:06 that girl should debut
Truee
she was in berrygood
Why does this have so many dislikes? It's a great comedy lol
HAHAHAH
Lol😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Wtf hhhahahahahahhaah lol lol ....
That's the reason it has so many views. People come for comedic purposes.
This comment 😆😆😆😆