Tibet Nepal relationship is not only view from trade but you should look from religious point of view. Lot of Bajracharya used to teach vajrayaan Buddhism to Tibetan in lichivi and malla dynasty.
Mac Mahon line in 1914, Tibet declaring independence in 1913 and British general younghusband attacking Tibet in 1904, Nepal war with Tibet, and you miss Zorawar Singh rajput attacking Tibet and taking ladhak but he also died during the war. Tibetan were force d to sign 17 point agreement. India supporting Nepal defense during that time (early 50’s). Thank you for highlighting all this. Definitely I will buy your book and learn more. The speaker is so humble not like your previous speaker (the hydro expert) so mush condescending.
I first thought of the speaker - being Indian trained/educated - to have more exposure to India and a focus on Npela-India dynamics. Nice to know about his research into the Nepal-China dynamic as well! BTW there are some extensive audio issues, which I had not encountered with the podcast before, with some words getting out of hearing range -- maybe the speakers moving out of the microprohone's effective range/direction. Please pay attention to this. Good luck! Please keep bringing more about Nepal and regional geopolitical history... People need to know more.
Tibet was Never Part of China . There was Nepal Tibet border not Nepal China border. BRI is bullshit ! जहा जहा चीनले पुग्यो त्यो देश कँगाल , उदाहरण : पाकिस्तान , श्रालँका , बर्मा , उत्तर कोरीया , अफ़्रीकी देश हरू । यी चीनीयाहरूले पाए पछी केही छोड्दैनन । तिब्बत त कब्जा गरे गरे , हुँदा हुँदा सगरमाथा पनि कब्जा गर्न खोजेका थिए ( उत्तरी सीमानाका पीलरहरू पनि सार्नेकाम गरे) । एक चीन निती भन्छ तर नेपालको आन्तरिक राजनितीमा छीरेर शाँसद किन्न पनि भ्याए । यीनीहरूलाई Hello , Hi भन्ने तर बिश्वास गर्न योग्य चाँही छैन ।
दाई ईतिहासविद, मानवशास्त्री, भाषाविद डा. अजित मान तामाङ ज्यूलाई पोडकास्टमा डाक्नुपर्यो। मलाई लाग्छ हामीले नेपाल र काठमाण्डु (नेपाल-नेबाल) भ्यालीको पाईला पाईलाको बारे र हर एक मौलिक शब्दको अर्थ सहित प्रमाणित ज्ञान प्राप्त गर्न सक्नेछौ। धन्यवाद 🙏🙏
Padma Sambhab is very important figure on Bajrayan Buddhism in Nepal valley too. Newar traders had business for thousands of years. But proof? The research must be done in this subjects.
@@dipakmandal2248 I did not know so detail but he was teacher of Nalanda/Bikramshila. He went Tibet through Nepal Mandal where he stayed few years there. Big influence on Newar Bajrayan Budjism in Nepal Mandal.
@@dipakmandal2248 Right, he might be from Swat Swat valley because North Pakistan and East Northern Afghanistan were Buddhist Areas. When you dig, you will find mostly Buddhist artifacts. Takchhesila Mahabihar was there. Gsndharv Buddhist art developed there. It was Buddhist trail to China. PADMA SAMVAB was historical person. You know where historical person is usually born. Mythological and historical explations are two different things. Buddhism is most scientific religion. We must promotion scientifically. Buddhism does not give any preferenser where he comes from but what you do.
A great research based podocast on nepal tibet relation highlighting socio eco -politico dimension not covered in text book of history of Nepal-came to know something new not elaborated in my five decade of study as a student of socio - politico and eco on hlmalayan belt
Brother, till date NO NEPALI has had the courage of telling the true story about our socio-economi-politico relationships with Tibet for more than thousand years. Sadly, currently, almost all of us believe and subscribe the Chinese version of the narrative which is based on a big lie. More so the Bahun/Chettri power apparatus is completely unaware of the vibrant relationships that existed between the two people of Nepal and Tibet. Tibet was taken over by China and Tibet is no longer a free country-its that simple! What can one do if we all like the emperor's new cloth !
Tibet and nepal were like brother and sister until nepal backstabbed and started being moneyminded and later ruined the century old good relationship 😑😑😑
Tibet was Never Part of China . There was Nepal Tibet border not Nepal China border. BRI is bullshit ! जहा जहा चीनले पुग्यो त्यो देश कँगाल , उदाहरण : पाकिस्तान , श्रालँका , बर्मा , उत्तर कोरीया , अफ़्रीकी देश हरू । यी चीनीयाहरूले पाए पछी केही छोड्दैनन । तिब्बत त कब्जा गरे गरे , हुँदा हुँदा सगरमाथा पनि कब्जा गर्न खोजेका थिए ( उत्तरी सीमानाका पीलरहरू पनि सार्नेकाम गरे) । एक चीन निती भन्छ तर नेपालको आन्तरिक राजनितीमा छीरेर शाँसद किन्न पनि भ्याए । यीनीहरूलाई Hello , Hi भन्ने तर बिश्वास गर्न योग्य चाँही छैन ।
Tibet and nepal had a golden relationship when nepal was a bhudist region . After the arrival of hindu ruler in nepal , and the decline of bhudism in nepal , the relationship between gorkha of nepal and tibet become intolerant and hostile . Today nepal play a very cheap role as a puppet of china .
Nakara bardi. After the arrival of Hindu rulers re. First Historical King Of Nepal vanera chininey Mandev was a Vaishnavite. Atibadi Angkaji Putra khali dharma ra jaat gari bascha.
Can't agree more when you said Nepal was never an independent country but an offshoot of British influence though it was ruled by Ranas who pretended to be independent
Tibetan bigyaharulai Nepal bhot 1718 history sodhata mula timiharu sab British le bhari bokayera layeka indians Himali range ma borders brders ma rakhiyeka bhariya haru hun, timbro bajelai sodha timro gauma 1 ghar athawa katera vanda ghar thiyena yo sav Nepal united nation ko member bannu aghi banaka kalpanik kathaharu hun. Same story Tibetan lai layera sodha timle Nepali nagarikta xodera vagnu parne abastha aucha
shushant must have at the least read the book and his questions would have been better. nonetheless its a pleasure reading and listening to Amish. Kudos
When he says India is displeased with "fast tracking" of the constitution drafting. The issue is with Madhesi discontent. It is primarily with sighing of the pact with Madhesi Movement, that ultimately made possible for first CA elections, with Indian Ambassador as a witness, to give ek madhesh-ek pradesh. Kuro ko churo yo ho bhai.
We have 2 nepal one urban nepal where everything is taught in english, spoken english in schools and other one is rural nepal where everything is taught in devanagari. So its not our fault we speak like that. fault is our national school policy.
Bahun lai bhot sabda sunney bittikai allergy huna thaalxa. Bloody racist people. It was a excellent history of Nepal, Himalaya and Tibet. So sad Indian hindu fugitive kings Destroyed it all and even try to suppress this history
There are several Nepali languages in Nepal. Khas Parbate/Gorkha language is only one of Nepali languages. Calling Nepali language is 2nd main Discrimination in Nepal after caste discrimination. English should use pararell communication language with Khas Parbate/Gorkha language.
@@NiranjanMalakarI am also Maithili speaker . Still I think Nepali should used for communication because more than 70 % people can understand Nepali. On the other hand only few people can understand English properly. And why to love foreign language more than our own country languages.
तिब्बत चिन को भूभाग नभएको भए, नेपाल आज भारत को प्रान्त हुन्थ्यो। मङ्गोलिया लाई चीन बात अलग गर्ने राष्ट्र रूस हो। Western were interested in Tibet, so it became a part of china. Western were interested in Sikkim, so it became a part of India. Same can happen to ........
Tibet was Never Part of China . There was Nepal Tibet border not Nepal China border. BRI is bullshit ! जहा जहा चीनले पुग्यो त्यो देश कँगाल , उदाहरण : पाकिस्तान , श्रालँका , बर्मा , उत्तर कोरीया , अफ़्रीकी देश हरू । यी चीनीयाहरूले पाए पछी केही छोड्दैनन । तिब्बत त कब्जा गरे गरे , हुँदा हुँदा सगरमाथा पनि कब्जा गर्न खोजेका थिए ( उत्तरी सीमानाका पीलरहरू पनि सार्नेकाम गरे) । एक चीन निती भन्छ तर नेपालको आन्तरिक राजनितीमा छीरेर शाँसद किन्न पनि भ्याए । यीनीहरूलाई Hello , Hi भन्ने तर बिश्वास गर्न योग्य चाँही छैन ।
Sushant Bro can you please invite Senior journalist Dev Prakash Tripathi, human right activitist, socialist philosopher, and water energy expert Gopal Siwakoti Chintan , Historian Professor Dr. Ramesh Dhungel, writer and political analyst Saurav please bro.... 😢😢😢
Fact is : Tibet was Never Part of China . There was Nepal Tibet border not Nepal China border. BRI is bullshit ! जहा जहा चीनले पुग्यो त्यो देश कँगाल , उदाहरण : पाकिस्तान , श्रालँका , बर्मा , उत्तर कोरीया , अफ़्रीकी देश हरू । यी चीनीयाहरूले पाए पछी केही छोड्दैनन । तिब्बत त कब्जा गरे गरे , हुँदा हुँदा सगरमाथा पनि कब्जा गर्न खोजेका थिए ( उत्तरी सीमानाका पीलरहरू पनि सार्नेकाम गरे) । एक चीन निती भन्छ तर नेपालको आन्तरिक राजनितीमा छीरेर शाँसद किन्न पनि भ्याए । यीनीहरूलाई Hello , Hi भन्ने तर बिश्वास गर्न योग्य चाँही छैन ।
Nepal is multi lingual society. If you have problem in english comprehension then learn english if not then dont just watch. No one is forcing you nor should you force anyone!
Mulmi ji unfortunately is trying to project, esp in regards to India's influence in Nepal's politics being non-existent or miniscule. On the contrary, evidences suggest that every "major" political event in Nepal was backed, aided and abetted by India, to a degree or other.
Totally agree with you man ! Did you see his hesitation when answering about Indias involvement with the Maoist ? He knows it’s a fact India helped the Maoist, but refuses to acknowledge publicly for reasons we don’t know.
Hmm. So per treaty nepal was supposed to come to help tibet in 1950 when communist China start invading tibet. This is new to us and we will remember for this long time
Why would Nepal help Tibet?? Nepal had maintained good relationship with Qing and their predecessors, whereas Tibet was a dying state. It would be illogical to help tibet at that point.
Neither did help from Tibet and China came when Britain invaded Nepal in 1816 AD so called Anglo Nepal war. According to Betrawati treaty help should have been sent but the Qing emperor and the ambans in Lhasa said it’s none of our business. And at that time it would have been foolish to against China. Nepalese army was not that powerful and modernized to deal with the Chinese army. If we helped Tibet we would have been annexed by China or at least the entire northern part of Nepal
@@Hithere-qj1wj that was part of the treaty no matter whether tibet was strong or weak. You guys go where the money is. That's y your minister are danced by communist m9ney
@@tenzchd971 Lol sorry to burst your bubble! But why did your own people call for Qing's help when war came to your door?? Later, your saviour devoured your territory and now you're trying to put the blame on others?? And did Tibet or Qing came to our rescue during Anglo-Nepal war? You cant expect from others while not doing your part anyways.
Tibet was an independent nation the whole Dalai lama choosing ritual basically has Qing as protectorate So why would Nepal come to help ? Were the Kings of Nepal crowned as Protectorate of Tibet ? Highly doubt about the newar traders having monopoly over Tibet which was subservient to China Monopoly over what ? Silver gold salt for the economy of a religious town whose population size is not even what 100-300k ? Also Tibet itself has ruled over China and some parts of Kashmir You should be asking Dhotis why they didn't come save your Tibet's hypothetical ass from the mythical powerful India that has forever been united
So you mean you have much more insight about the topic on China-Nepal-India relations than Amish Mulmi? Really? How much prideful do you really have to be to claim that you are able to point "Many misinformations and misconceptions" against a person who has spent a long period of time researching the topic and has gotten praise for that? Please you should go on this podcast, after all you must be a well known researcher.
@@nawoxare5194 yes i do. Thats why i'm telling. Whenever i got free time i will rewatch this podcast and debunk the misinformation with the fact with time eg 30:07 ....misinformation. .....debunk with the fact......
@@nawoxare5194 bhag dhoti half of his content is India sponsored almost every word this joker speaks is on behalf of India ani Naxalite movement re Hahahahahahaha Are you serious Birendra was holding back because his people were getting forced into war who had no reason or idea for war backed with weapons Most counselors wanted complete eradication of Maoist but he knew Dhoti supported them so he knew it was pointless Had Naxalite movement actually gained momentum in Dhoti land there would be Degenerate Lundia company v2 on steroids
You want India to take over nepal simply because you have large number of hindu? Every country has gone through darkness but over the time it can be recovered and developed
@@prithbilimbu5314 definitely upgrade ta bhako nai Hola ni. Ile ko Nepal tyo Bela bhanda ta dherai dherai Ramro cha bro 😂 Tara I understand your anger. Afno bare j bhane ni mutu ma tuchha Chai huncha 😂
@@JayDConq पनौती तर्क दिएर हुन्छ मूला। किराँत शासन तेरो मल्ल भन्दा कयौ गुणा राम्रो थियो। हिन्दू पसे पछि सबै बर्बाद भाको नेपाल। नेपाल मात्र होइन इंडिया पनि त्यै हालतमा छ। समयले स्वतः ल्याएको परीवर्नत नेपालको परिवर्तन upgrade भाको रे। तिनीहरू नभएको यो भन्दा धेरै राम्रो हुन्थ्यो नेपाल। बिगारेको चाई हो वास्तवमा।
😂😂 just basic knowledge about Tibet and Nepal history that's information easily tell you other people . If you reply want to know then you have to go back pre history about Tibet , 30000 years old history about Tibet during Zhang Zhung Dynasty . You will blow your mind . These are mediocre informations.
How did the Maoists get arms and ammunition? Some ammunition was looted but the nepali state forces have record on how.much exactly was looted. they used much more than they looted. How did they get it?.From.where? MCC and PWG also didnt have it and they were requesting from Nepali Maoist. Without knowledge, such interview sounds so shallow and hollow
Mate which country do you think has always had ill intentions toward Nepal since 1950s till present day. Your answers lie there. Also it’s no longer a secret who supported them. A search in google, TH-cam interviews, various books have revealed who is the reason for all the troubles in Nepal
Hawa dhoti khali misinformation dine , Nepal biswako dosro jalsrot dhani vanne khalaka bakamfuse kura garne ra khali ullu banaune, jaba arkale hanepaxi poko puntro bokera Rohingya bhayajhai bhagne yo dhoti baun chhetriko jat. 😂😂😂😂😂😂 free tibet movement lai support garata Nepal kasto thiyo vanera dekhinxa Nepal map change hunchha. 1947 American embassy esthapana huna aghisamma KTM lai Nepal vanthe Tarai bhag Nepal ko thiyena aru himali pahidi sablai bhot bhanthe , jati pani Natives Nepali harule bolne bhasa chhan ti sabai himali range ka mixed bhasaharu hun, British le himal wari pari vanera sa sana maps banayeka thiye tara teskai adharharu study garera kehi EU, America Raj mahindra ra Mao Zedong ko haruko conspiracies asti bhakhar jasto nepal ko Simankan vako 80 barsa panu vako chhaina.
Thank amish for coming and sharing. Nice listening to you in retrospect.
Tibet Nepal relationship is not only view from trade but you should look from religious point of view. Lot of Bajracharya used to teach vajrayaan Buddhism to Tibetan in lichivi and malla dynasty.
Bajracharya are maithili brahmin convert
Mac Mahon line in 1914, Tibet declaring independence in 1913 and British general younghusband attacking Tibet in 1904, Nepal war with Tibet, and you miss Zorawar Singh rajput attacking Tibet and taking ladhak but he also died during the war. Tibetan were force d to sign 17 point agreement. India supporting Nepal defense during that time (early 50’s).
Thank you for highlighting all this. Definitely I will buy your book and learn more.
The speaker is so humble not like your previous speaker (the hydro expert) so mush condescending.
"the hydro expert". He never come to realize that he has been spoiled by Gyane.
@Sushant_Pradhan could you please have a podcast about Bhutanese refugee case and foreign influences that caused that crisis.
I first thought of the speaker - being Indian trained/educated - to have more exposure to India and a focus on Npela-India dynamics. Nice to know about his research into the Nepal-China dynamic as well!
BTW there are some extensive audio issues, which I had not encountered with the podcast before, with some words getting out of hearing range -- maybe the speakers moving out of the microprohone's effective range/direction. Please pay attention to this.
Good luck! Please keep bringing more about Nepal and regional geopolitical history... People need to know more.
Something was wrong with the audio this time for sure..
Amazing podcast! Very insightful.
Tibet was Never Part of China . There was Nepal Tibet border not Nepal China border.
BRI is bullshit ! जहा जहा चीनले पुग्यो त्यो देश कँगाल , उदाहरण : पाकिस्तान , श्रालँका , बर्मा , उत्तर कोरीया , अफ़्रीकी देश हरू ।
यी चीनीयाहरूले पाए पछी केही छोड्दैनन । तिब्बत त कब्जा गरे गरे , हुँदा हुँदा सगरमाथा पनि कब्जा गर्न खोजेका थिए ( उत्तरी सीमानाका पीलरहरू पनि सार्नेकाम गरे) ।
एक चीन निती भन्छ तर नेपालको आन्तरिक राजनितीमा छीरेर शाँसद किन्न पनि भ्याए ।
यीनीहरूलाई Hello , Hi भन्ने तर बिश्वास गर्न योग्य चाँही छैन ।
Best podcast so far !
दाई ईतिहासविद, मानवशास्त्री, भाषाविद डा. अजित मान तामाङ ज्यूलाई पोडकास्टमा डाक्नुपर्यो। मलाई लाग्छ हामीले नेपाल र काठमाण्डु (नेपाल-नेबाल) भ्यालीको पाईला पाईलाको बारे र हर एक मौलिक शब्दको अर्थ सहित प्रमाणित ज्ञान प्राप्त गर्न सक्नेछौ। धन्यवाद 🙏🙏
Very interesting !
❤thank you for informing the history @amish mulmi
Padma Sambhab is very important figure on Bajrayan Buddhism in Nepal valley too. Newar traders had business for thousands of years. But proof? The research must be done in this subjects.
Wasn't Padma sambhab from Swat Valley of Pakistan?
@@dipakmandal2248 I did not know so detail but he was teacher of Nalanda/Bikramshila. He went Tibet through Nepal Mandal where he stayed few years there. Big influence on Newar Bajrayan Budjism in Nepal Mandal.
@@NiranjanMalakar I have heard this from some Nepali Buddhist in podcast that Padma Samba was from Swat valley and was born out of lotus.
@@dipakmandal2248 Right, he might be from Swat Swat valley because North Pakistan and East Northern Afghanistan were Buddhist Areas. When you dig, you will find mostly Buddhist artifacts. Takchhesila Mahabihar was there. Gsndharv Buddhist art developed there. It was Buddhist trail to China. PADMA SAMVAB was historical person. You know where historical person is usually born. Mythological and historical explations are two different things. Buddhism is most scientific religion. We must promotion scientifically. Buddhism does not give any preferenser where he comes from but what you do.
@@NiranjanMalakar Padma samba born out of lotus. That's history. Nice joke 😂😂🤣🤣.
A great research based podocast on nepal tibet relation highlighting socio eco -politico dimension not covered in text book of history of Nepal-came to know something new not elaborated in my five decade of study as a student of socio - politico and eco on hlmalayan belt
Brother, till date NO NEPALI has had the courage of telling the true story about our socio-economi-politico relationships with Tibet for more than thousand years. Sadly, currently, almost all of us believe and subscribe the Chinese version of the narrative which is based on a big lie. More so the Bahun/Chettri power apparatus is completely unaware of the vibrant relationships that existed between the two people of Nepal and Tibet. Tibet was taken over by China and Tibet is no longer a free country-its that simple! What can one do if we all like the emperor's new cloth !
@@rijgurung5638
Well one cannot isolate China if we are talking about the relationship between Tibet and Nepal.
Tibet and nepal were like brother and sister until nepal backstabbed and started being moneyminded and later ruined the century old good relationship 😑😑😑
Tats y my grand parents always tell us not to trust Nepali 😮😮😮
Must watch episode,
Tibet was Never Part of China . There was Nepal Tibet border not Nepal China border.
BRI is bullshit ! जहा जहा चीनले पुग्यो त्यो देश कँगाल , उदाहरण : पाकिस्तान , श्रालँका , बर्मा , उत्तर कोरीया , अफ़्रीकी देश हरू ।
यी चीनीयाहरूले पाए पछी केही छोड्दैनन । तिब्बत त कब्जा गरे गरे , हुँदा हुँदा सगरमाथा पनि कब्जा गर्न खोजेका थिए ( उत्तरी सीमानाका पीलरहरू पनि सार्नेकाम गरे) ।
एक चीन निती भन्छ तर नेपालको आन्तरिक राजनितीमा छीरेर शाँसद किन्न पनि भ्याए ।
यीनीहरूलाई Hello , Hi भन्ने तर बिश्वास गर्न योग्य चाँही छैन ।
Tibet and nepal had a golden relationship when nepal was a bhudist region . After the arrival of hindu ruler in nepal , and the decline of bhudism in nepal , the relationship between gorkha of nepal and tibet become intolerant and hostile .
Today nepal play a very cheap role as a puppet of china .
Nakara bardi.
After the arrival of Hindu rulers re.
First Historical King Of Nepal vanera chininey Mandev was a Vaishnavite.
Atibadi Angkaji Putra khali dharma ra jaat gari bascha.
Stfu Nepal was never buddhist region every buddhist monuments present in nepal are made by indian and tibetian rulers during their nepal visit
@@pratik11-v7x
Lmao so you mean Swayambhu or Boudhanath were erected by Indian rulers?
@@xenonezio5188
Mandev was buddhist. His gupta ministers were vishnavate or whatever shit is that.
@@sigmabean If he was buddhist. Why was there need for him to stop his mother from doing sati? Or are you telling buddhist performed sati too?
Very good information for beginners....👍
Can't agree more when you said Nepal was never an independent country but an offshoot of British influence though it was ruled by Ranas who pretended to be independent
How dare you say that?
Nepal was always independent 🤧 🐑
*they would come for you lol
@@Hithere-qj1wj history is the proof.if someone licked the boots of Ranas, the situation could be defined differently
Tibetan bigyaharulai Nepal bhot 1718 history sodhata mula timiharu sab British le bhari bokayera layeka indians Himali range ma borders brders ma rakhiyeka bhariya haru hun, timbro bajelai sodha timro gauma 1 ghar athawa katera vanda ghar thiyena yo sav Nepal united nation ko member bannu aghi banaka kalpanik kathaharu hun. Same story Tibetan lai layera sodha timle Nepali nagarikta xodera vagnu parne abastha aucha
shushant must have at the least read the book and his questions would have been better. nonetheless its a pleasure reading and listening to Amish. Kudos
Very insightful
Why wqsnt i taught my nations history 😭😭
The audio output is quite bad in this particular podcast and it's very much noticeable.
Worms - please understand. Language cannot be restricted and be barriered. Neither both are paid salaries by you (worms).
When he says India is displeased with "fast tracking" of the constitution drafting. The issue is with Madhesi discontent. It is primarily with sighing of the pact with Madhesi Movement, that ultimately made possible for first CA elections, with Indian Ambassador as a witness, to give ek madhesh-ek pradesh. Kuro ko churo yo ho bhai.
We have 2 nepal one urban nepal where everything is taught in english, spoken english in schools and other one is rural nepal where everything is taught in devanagari. So its not our fault we speak like that. fault is our national school policy.
अहिले सम्मको घाँस अन्तरवार्ता।
🥱🥱🥱🥱
Kasari Vai ?
Because you’re an illiterate .
ghans khane le ghans dekhnu it is natural, nothing unusal.
Read the book "all roads lead north" first
Bahun lai bhot sabda sunney bittikai allergy huna thaalxa. Bloody racist people. It was a excellent history of Nepal, Himalaya and Tibet. So sad Indian hindu fugitive kings Destroyed it all and even try to suppress this history
Part 2 please
yo podcast kasko lagi ho... nepali ko lagi ho vane ... english matra bolxa kasare bujne
nepali bata sabda thyana ke bolnu na ako ho
There are several Nepali languages in Nepal. Khas Parbate/Gorkha language is only one of Nepali languages. Calling Nepali language is 2nd main Discrimination in Nepal after caste discrimination. English should use pararell communication language with Khas Parbate/Gorkha language.
@@NiranjanMalakar ayo feri english vutdoi ,,,, k sochxa manxe la yr
criticism for the sake of criticism! Bhannu ko tatparya bujhey bhayena..
@@NiranjanMalakarI am also Maithili speaker . Still I think Nepali should used for communication because more than 70 % people can understand Nepali. On the other hand only few people can understand English properly. And why to love foreign language more than our own country languages.
😂😂😂 k bolxa @@NiranjanMalakar
तिब्बत चिन को भूभाग नभएको भए, नेपाल आज भारत को प्रान्त हुन्थ्यो।
मङ्गोलिया लाई चीन बात अलग गर्ने राष्ट्र रूस हो।
Western were interested in Tibet, so it became a part of china.
Western were interested in Sikkim, so it became a part of India.
Same can happen to ........
Tibet was Never Part of China . There was Nepal Tibet border not Nepal China border.
BRI is bullshit ! जहा जहा चीनले पुग्यो त्यो देश कँगाल , उदाहरण : पाकिस्तान , श्रालँका , बर्मा , उत्तर कोरीया , अफ़्रीकी देश हरू ।
यी चीनीयाहरूले पाए पछी केही छोड्दैनन । तिब्बत त कब्जा गरे गरे , हुँदा हुँदा सगरमाथा पनि कब्जा गर्न खोजेका थिए ( उत्तरी सीमानाका पीलरहरू पनि सार्नेकाम गरे) ।
एक चीन निती भन्छ तर नेपालको आन्तरिक राजनितीमा छीरेर शाँसद किन्न पनि भ्याए ।
यीनीहरूलाई Hello , Hi भन्ने तर बिश्वास गर्न योग्य चाँही छैन ।
Such an stupid argument. If so why is Bhutan still a country ? I will never understand Neplese aryan people hated towards tibetan/Bhotey people.
Sushant Bro can you please invite Senior journalist Dev Prakash Tripathi, human right activitist, socialist philosopher, and water energy expert Gopal Siwakoti Chintan , Historian Professor Dr. Ramesh Dhungel, writer and political analyst Saurav please bro.... 😢😢😢
Audio is not good
Fact is : Tibet was Never Part of China . There was Nepal Tibet border not Nepal China border.
BRI is bullshit ! जहा जहा चीनले पुग्यो त्यो देश कँगाल , उदाहरण : पाकिस्तान , श्रालँका , बर्मा , उत्तर कोरीया , अफ़्रीकी देश हरू ।
यी चीनीयाहरूले पाए पछी केही छोड्दैनन । तिब्बत त कब्जा गरे गरे , हुँदा हुँदा सगरमाथा पनि कब्जा गर्न खोजेका थिए ( उत्तरी सीमानाका पीलरहरू पनि सार्नेकाम गरे) ।
एक चीन निती भन्छ तर नेपालको आन्तरिक राजनितीमा छीरेर शाँसद किन्न पनि भ्याए ।
यीनीहरूलाई Hello , Hi भन्ने तर बिश्वास गर्न योग्य चाँही छैन ।
Let me give perspective on why Jung Bahadur invaded Tibet in 1855: Nepali traders were harassed in Tibet while on route to selling opium in China.
Lol, some random chapri wanna refute historian himself 😂😂
@@dreamadventure8220 do a bit of reading on the life history of Dhama Sahu - a childhood friend of Jung Bahadur from Arkonatayansthan.
नेपाली कम गोरे भाषा बढी बोल्यो सुन्न मन लागेर पनि घृणा लाग्यो यी बिध्वान संग
अंग्रेजी पडा न त l
Intro music ramro vayena video back garam feel vako thiyo
कार्यक्रम त राम्रो हो तर सम्पूर्ण नेपाली ले बुझ्न सक्ने बनाऊ। की नेपाली बोल्न आउँदैन की लाज लाग्छ बोल्न लाई।
Sampurna Nepali le bujhne kunai testo bhasha nai chaina..
यो अन्तरवार्ता बिदेशी को लागि लिएको कि नेपालीको लागि कि यउऊटा शब्द नेपाली नबोली अङ्ग्रेजी मात्र बोल्नु नी कि आफ्नो मातृी भाषा मा बोल्नु ।
School ma english paday na ho?
Tero matri bhasa ,usko Nepal bhasa ho yad garis
Nepal is multi lingual society. If you have problem in english comprehension then learn english if not then dont just watch. No one is forcing you nor should you force anyone!
Mulmi ji unfortunately is trying to project,
esp in regards to India's influence in Nepal's politics being non-existent or miniscule.
On the contrary, evidences suggest that every "major" political event in Nepal was backed, aided and abetted by India, to a degree or other.
Totally agree with you man ! Did you see his hesitation when answering about Indias involvement with the Maoist ? He knows it’s a fact India helped the Maoist, but refuses to acknowledge publicly for reasons we don’t know.
Hmm. So per treaty nepal was supposed to come to help tibet in 1950 when communist China start invading tibet. This is new to us and we will remember for this long time
Why would Nepal help Tibet??
Nepal had maintained good relationship with Qing and their predecessors, whereas Tibet was a dying state.
It would be illogical to help tibet at that point.
Neither did help from Tibet and China came when Britain invaded Nepal in 1816 AD so called Anglo Nepal war. According to Betrawati treaty help should have been sent but the Qing emperor and the ambans in Lhasa said it’s none of our business. And at that time it would have been foolish to against China. Nepalese army was not that powerful and modernized to deal with the Chinese army. If we helped Tibet we would have been annexed by China or at least the entire northern part of Nepal
@@Hithere-qj1wj that was part of the treaty no matter whether tibet was strong or weak. You guys go where the money is. That's y your minister are danced by communist m9ney
@@tenzchd971
Lol sorry to burst your bubble!
But why did your own people call for Qing's help when war came to your door??
Later, your saviour devoured your territory and now you're trying to put the blame on others??
And did Tibet or Qing came to our rescue during Anglo-Nepal war?
You cant expect from others while not doing your part anyways.
Tibet was an independent nation the whole Dalai lama choosing ritual basically has Qing as protectorate So why would Nepal come to help ?
Were the Kings of Nepal crowned as Protectorate of Tibet ?
Highly doubt about the newar traders having monopoly over Tibet which was subservient to China
Monopoly over what ? Silver gold salt for the economy of a religious town whose population size is not even what 100-300k ?
Also Tibet itself has ruled over China and some parts of Kashmir
You should be asking Dhotis why they didn't come save your Tibet's hypothetical ass from the mythical powerful India that has forever been united
Foreign secretary lai linu hjr ko poadcast ma
yes
Many misinformations and misconceptions from this speaker. If i point out then there are so many that my day will be wasted.
So you mean you have much more insight about the topic on China-Nepal-India relations than Amish Mulmi? Really? How much prideful do you really have to be to claim that you are able to point "Many misinformations and misconceptions" against a person who has spent a long period of time researching the topic and has gotten praise for that? Please you should go on this podcast, after all you must be a well known researcher.
@@nawoxare5194 yes i do. Thats why i'm telling. Whenever i got free time i will rewatch this podcast and debunk the misinformation with the fact with time eg 30:07 ....misinformation. .....debunk with the fact......
@@nawoxare5194 bhag dhoti half of his content is India sponsored almost every word this joker speaks is on behalf of India ani Naxalite movement re
Hahahahahahaha
Are you serious Birendra was holding back because his people were getting forced into war who had no reason or idea for war backed with weapons
Most counselors wanted complete eradication of Maoist but he knew Dhoti supported them so he knew it was pointless
Had Naxalite movement actually gained momentum in Dhoti land there would be Degenerate Lundia company v2 on steroids
@@sigmabean when can we expect you to debunk this?
@@sigmabean still waiting for that "debunk with the fact".
पृथ्विनारायण शाहले दिब्यउपदेशमा उत्तरको छिमेकी चिन र दक्षिणको छिमेकी अंग्रेज किन भने होलान?
It's good that China took Tibet, otherwise it would be stayed still in the darkness.
You want India to take over nepal simply because you have large number of hindu? Every country has gone through darkness but over the time it can be recovered and developed
It's good that the malla kings took over the llimbuwan kings, other wise Nepal would still have stayed in the darkness. Kuro testai khako bhayo Hai 😂
@@JayDConq गौमुते जाठा। अनि अहिले तिब्बत भन्दा विकास भयो त नेपाल मल्ल ले साशन गरेर?
@@prithbilimbu5314 definitely upgrade ta bhako nai Hola ni. Ile ko Nepal tyo Bela bhanda ta dherai dherai Ramro cha bro 😂 Tara I understand your anger. Afno bare j bhane ni mutu ma tuchha Chai huncha 😂
@@JayDConq पनौती तर्क दिएर हुन्छ मूला। किराँत शासन तेरो मल्ल भन्दा कयौ गुणा राम्रो थियो। हिन्दू पसे पछि सबै बर्बाद भाको नेपाल। नेपाल मात्र होइन इंडिया पनि त्यै हालतमा छ। समयले स्वतः ल्याएको परीवर्नत नेपालको परिवर्तन upgrade भाको रे। तिनीहरू नभएको यो भन्दा धेरै राम्रो हुन्थ्यो नेपाल। बिगारेको चाई हो वास्तवमा।
PLS RE SOUND THIS VIDEO
I think you should tstart a English podcast channel
सुशान्त संग गफ गर्न बस्यो पछि अङ्ग्रेजी नजान्ने ले त अङ्ग्रेजी बोल्न थाल्छन्। टीकाराम यात्री को अन्तरवार्ता लिनुस् न सुशान्त जी😅
Language bhanda k bhanna khoje KO bujhnu na.
Has he ever visited China to talk about China in such detail? Its hundred percent anti-Nepal interview
Have you ever visited this podcast studio to comment about it ?? 😂😂 What an absolute dumbasss
Sankaspad
😂😂 just basic knowledge about Tibet and Nepal history that's information easily tell you other people . If you reply want to know then you have to go back pre history about Tibet , 30000 years old history about Tibet during Zhang Zhung Dynasty . You will blow your mind . These are mediocre informations.
These definitely its not mediocre information not especially in Nepal where aryan dominated barely allows lights on Mongloid people history.
@@dreamadventure8220 Tell me where’s aryan come from and who are they ?
सके सम्मा शुद्ध नेपालीमै बोलेकोभएदेखि सुनमा सुघन्ता हुने थियो।
What ??? Learn english bro , Nepali/khas is not even your language. What an lousy fellow
Free Tibet
How did the Maoists get arms and ammunition? Some ammunition was looted but the nepali state forces have record on how.much exactly was looted. they used much more than they looted. How did they get it?.From.where? MCC and PWG also didnt have it and they were requesting from Nepali Maoist. Without knowledge, such interview sounds so shallow and hollow
Mate which country do you think has always had ill intentions toward Nepal since 1950s till present day. Your answers lie there. Also it’s no longer a secret who supported them. A search in google, TH-cam interviews, various books have revealed who is the reason for all the troubles in Nepal
Raw and cia bro
Yauta kura chhai I don’t believe uhako bhanai ma India didn’t support moist bhane
The fact has been twisted so do your own research.
Ki English matra bol ki nepali matra tero remix interview wakka lago sunna
Gwach hos ta
Hawa dhoti khali misinformation dine , Nepal biswako dosro jalsrot dhani vanne khalaka bakamfuse kura garne ra khali ullu banaune, jaba arkale hanepaxi poko puntro bokera Rohingya bhayajhai bhagne yo dhoti baun chhetriko jat. 😂😂😂😂😂😂 free tibet movement lai support garata Nepal kasto thiyo vanera dekhinxa Nepal map change hunchha. 1947 American embassy esthapana huna aghisamma KTM lai Nepal vanthe Tarai bhag Nepal ko thiyena aru himali pahidi sablai bhot bhanthe , jati pani Natives Nepali harule bolne bhasa chhan ti sabai himali range ka mixed bhasaharu hun, British le himal wari pari vanera sa sana maps banayeka thiye tara teskai adharharu study garera kehi EU, America Raj mahindra ra Mao Zedong ko haruko conspiracies asti bhakhar jasto nepal ko Simankan vako 80 barsa panu vako chhaina.
Truth is bitter bro. History dont give a F about people sentiment.
talk in english only 😂😂
नेपाली मा बोल न
English sikh na pakhey 😂😂😂