Herin 2015 " I love Koeun, Hina and Lami so much, you guys are my BFFs!!! " Herin 2017 " I miss Koeun, Hina and Lami so much, you guys are my beautiful MEMORIES "
Koreans must explain why Herin only got 69.8. Like wth the girl slayed in this performance, she was not the main vocal but she did her parts well and did the real main vocal(Bada)'s adlibs so why are you all sleeping on this girl? She deserves more
Herin never really has screentime on the show and Koreans like pretty, fresh, cute girls like that smiley girl, Jiheon rather than the ones with skills. Herin's beautiful, but not according to Koreans' standards.
I love herin but honestly, she looked much much confident and smiled brighter in her Mickey Mouse Club performance of the same song. She looked like she was enjoying then, but not now. And if you aren't already a fan, you are going to prefer whoever looks like they enjoy themselves, which in this one is the girl who smiled a lot.
Maybe Herin remembers when she performed with Koeun, Hina and Lami in Mickey Mouse Club and yes, I also thought of that she looks more energetic in her former perf than here.
C'mon the only reason she got this amount of popularity is cuz she was from SM, I'm not saying she's bad but like 90% of the ppl that r supporting her r there cuz of her background, she would've gone unnoticed for me if she didn't have that kind of background, and Korean fans might be obsessed with visuals but international fans r obsessed with labels like company backgrounds and propaganda
I feel bad for herin, she left sm and now she is one of the lowest rank in idol school. She just flopping herself and after eliminated, i hope she got new agency that will explore her skill and debut 😇
Ranxy Lex idk if this is a good news or bad news for u but after idol school, she decided to stop her journey in the kpop industry and chose to live a normal life. I dont really know the reason but i watch some clips that kinda explain why she’s not in the industry anymore and that’s because the kpop industry is very toxic? Please correct me if im wrong yall🙏🏻
Eunha Banjjak Banjjak So Cute what are your fucking problem when the SM shit same sentence I'm getting tired of people like you who think that they are more that because of Gfriend and I really hate buddy like you I'm so glad that I don't stand that group that only sing cute songs always I hate it
StanKings_ StanSeventeen she is not that old. do you know wanna one? The leader is 26 and he's older than haein but still debut with cute boys like jihoon
Jiheon definitely fits the song the best, while Herin and Haein did a bomb ass job on those vocals! This performance gave me so much joy. Everything about it felt right. These girls truly benefitted from this show's purpose, which was to help them improve and become proper idols, and these three are definitely at that level! Major props to Jiheon for her improvement though, she got stuck in two of the weakest teams before so people thought she was the problem. In reality, she's actually a great performer. Finally she got put with a great team and she really proved herself!
Herin :( This stage tho, Herin (a former SM trainee practices this song before and performed with other SM rookies) performing this song while infront of Bada (S.E.S. former SM artists) and Heechul (SM Artist) are watching. My SM stan heart 😢 Herin didn't deserve the treatment she got in Idol School.
This bring me back to Herin's smrookies days when they did a studio version of this song. Herin might also remember her smrookies aka mickey mouse club friends while doing this. ㅠㅠ *always here for you Herin!*
I really miss Herin dancing and singing on the stage like this...My one and only pick in this show...However, I actually feel so, so happy since she finally can do things that she wants and loves. Love you so much, my baby girl...
This performance really shows that Herin is better in singing and dancing than the other two girls.. but why damn shit happen that Baek jiheon girl still got the spot. I understand Haein. But seriously, your visual ain't going nowhere if u got no talent
Please Support Yoon Yongbin in Produce 101 season 2 nahh.. I studies vocal so I know their rank in vocal.. and you can totally see the difference in their dancing skill right after this performance start so don't u dare denying me
Adinda Kirana u hater and what are your facts? siyeon was the one being selfish she wanted to be main vocal when she cant even reach the note that was asked for her to sing, and haein was only there to cast vote whos going to be the main vocal,, study korean first before judging haein u dumbo
Cyrus Parallag why I must dance better than her? I must dance better than jiheon so I can write my opinion in this comment coloum? Haha. Once again, It's my opinion. I compared herin with jiheon that herin have a great dance skill, good voice and pretty face. Herin and haein Not just show her smile to attract the nation. And I'm not fan of haein and herin
Jiheon is so precious I could cry, she's so cute ㅠㅠ though you're nowhere near Haein and Herin's vocal skills right now, you can be one day. grow well and practice lots until then, lil Jiheon, fighting!
As someone who grew up in Korea and was there when SES was huge, it's great to see this stage done well. I'm not even JiHeon stan, but she has that captivating charm that you just can't teach. Definitely would like to see her make it.
Seeing this again really make me feel sad now, knowing how actually Herin really did so great here, but she got the lowest score. Honestly Herin voice is so stable and her stage presence also looks good even I won’t be lying I prefer her performance when she covered this song with her fellow MMC girls, but seriously Herin deserves better, damn Mnet just being Mnet, always doing this dirty thing in their survival show… I also feel bad for Haein, she really deserve her #1 position. Herin and Haein actually really did great job performing this song, they really make a good foundation in this performance, huh, Mnet is really stupid like always
Herin😻😻😻i thought that she was going to debut from sm😿but i will still continue to support her no matter where she is🤗she is really talented in singing👍🏻did anyone even notice her singing some high notes at 3:12💓
Herin ga usah debut disini please, belum apa apa udah di "anak tiri" kan. Gue rasa bakal ditarik lagi sama SM(semoga) . Dan Kita lihat jadi apa ni grup yg isinya cuma ngandalin visual, visual, visual dan nyengir. Bagi gue banyak Dari top 9 ga deserve untuk jadi top9. Cuih lah emnet.
gue juga pengen herin balik lagi ke sm, kasian dia talented banget tapi gak masuk debut line. sedangkan si jiheon yang modal nyengir doang masuk debut line -___-
Mereka jadi gg sukses kok, apalgi setelah masuk hybe dan diatur 100% sama pledis. Dan ingat ya, fromis_9 bukan punya visual doang, mereka juga punya banyak bakat. Bahkan knetz aja pada bilang fromis_9 itu TALENT_9, VISUAL_9.
High note last part from Herin makes me cry omgg 😭 Her voice still the same with I'am Your girl sm rookies version. when she singing with Mark,Donghyuk,Yeri,Goeun,Hina,and Lami 😭😭
haein's voice never fail to give me this calm and sweet vibe, think I can listen to her singing all day long!! our ibi leader let's debut and live happily for now on~💗
It is really sad that she was eliminated but atleast I hope she will be back at SM Rookies because she really have great potential vocally and in dance.
![Idol School [6회]반전 드라마! 아름다운 하모니'꿈을 모아서'김나연,신시아,이다희 @학업성취도평가(보컬) 170824 EP.6](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wYmLprUGMYk/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol School [6회]반전 드라마! 아름다운 하모니'꿈을 모아서'김나연,신시아,이다희 @학업성취도평가(보컬) 170824 EP.6](/img/tr.png)
![(ENGsub) [MMF2016] S.E.S - I'm Your Girl+Remember, MBC Music Festival 20161231](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_YXje4NfOgM/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol School [9회]칼군무의 정석 ′여자친구′ 선배님의 핵심 콕콕 ♪시간을 달려서 특강! @아이돌위크 170915 EP.9](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jXDYCtZVfuk/mqdefault.jpg)
Herin 2015
" I love Koeun, Hina and Lami so much, you guys are my BFFs!!! "
Herin 2017
" I miss Koeun, Hina and Lami so much, you guys are my beautiful MEMORIES "
Sarah Min 😭😭😭😭
This comment made me emotional....
Is this true ?
pcy girl2000 I doubt it
pcy girl2000 it’s true she left, but I’m not sure about the comment
when ex-SM trainee(herin) danced SES's song and SES watched her:( and also heechul:( :( 😭😭😭😭😭 i really like this song..!!! oh my god:(
Sm family😭
and also her ex vocal coach :')
@@onlycho102 Bada
@@trio7717 Not only her, but the male coach is also debuted from SM and now teaching SM artists
@@wendy5903 who pls?
Herin finally showed us how good she is .
Haein slayed.
Jiheon is so cute.
Daetaeng ss *jiheon
vitamin somi oh thank you:)
😂 tru
Koreans must explain why Herin only got 69.8. Like wth the girl slayed in this performance, she was not the main vocal but she did her parts well and did the real main vocal(Bada)'s adlibs so why are you all sleeping on this girl? She deserves more
franzleaszt l ikr! I feel the same too
There's a conspiracy going on about Herin 😱
This is a Korean show for Korean audiences. They don't need to explain anything to international fans. lol
Sparkling You misunderstood. I'm not literally asking them to explain
Herin never really has screentime on the show and Koreans like pretty, fresh, cute girls like that smiley girl, Jiheon rather than the ones with skills. Herin's beautiful, but not according to Koreans' standards.
herin didn't deserve low rank
leehyukjaes SM
ikr
TRU
Totally😿she suits the song best like her movements and her voice 😻
true
I'm crying ㅠㅠ Seo Herinㅠㅠ
herin deserve better.
My baby Herin. I remember her and the other SM ROOKIES performing this for Mickey Mouse Club 😭😭
Same😭😭
Herin sings soooo well... please dont give up, we love you :)
Hmmm, if you guys are talking about the girl that ended the song with her vocals, she sounded a bit flat actually.
Briguy1027 well i personally dont judge someone only by how she ended that song :)
lipsync, maybe
@@Briguy1027 sorry? The girl that ended this song isnt herin. Its the girl in the middle at the end.
She actually gave up on the idol thing but oh well...
I love herin but honestly, she looked much much confident and smiled brighter in her Mickey Mouse Club performance of the same song. She looked like she was enjoying then, but not now. And if you aren't already a fan, you are going to prefer whoever looks like they enjoy themselves, which in this one is the girl who smiled a lot.
Maybe Herin remembers when she performed with Koeun, Hina and Lami in Mickey Mouse Club and yes, I also thought of that she looks more energetic in her former perf than here.
Finally herin's high note 😢❤️
Ouytong Liv she did 2 high note in idol school
International fans really like herin.....because we stan talent not visual....herin fighting!!!
but herin's visuals is also 💯
bc herin from sm lol
Because she is was from SM :)
I think she is beautiful too
C'mon the only reason she got this amount of popularity is cuz she was from SM, I'm not saying she's bad but like 90% of the ppl that r supporting her r there cuz of her background, she would've gone unnoticed for me if she didn't have that kind of background, and Korean fans might be obsessed with visuals but international fans r obsessed with labels like company backgrounds and propaganda
Herin 😭😭😭 I remember her dancing to this on mickey mouse club w/ the others, she's grown so much my British bby💕💕💕
YESS I remeber it too!! I miss Herin being with the smrookies 😭😭
Oh my god I remember it either. Am I still got a hope that Herin is still in SM??
rose I remmeber it too, watching this makes me quite emotional.
This brought me to tears 😭
yes, i remember it too:')
Throwback 2 years ago, Herin did a cover to this song on Mickey Mouse Club with the SMROOKIES girls. She's grown so much since then!
HERIN!!!!!!!
WATCH EXO - KOKOBOP when she did the intro...reminded me their disney videos..kkk...so hard to guess which 9 will be debutimg..
which one is herin?
Farah Bbs The girl at the begining of the video.
Farah Bbs she used to be the part of SMrookies in Mickey mouse club
try to watch mickey mouse club sm rookies
Mentor: S.E.S x Blackbeat from SM
Teacher: SuperJunior from SM
Competitor: SM rookies
Sm family 😭
Herin!!!
the way all of the comments were filled with herin, shows how popular herin is, she doesn’t deserve that low rank:(
yeah kinda crazy .. and kinda see the outrage about the scandal
That why 😭😭😭, it all because of money rigged the voting 🤬🤬
Herin adlib is the best
HERIN AH You've grown so much!! I'm so proud of you!!!
HERIN has always been so good on stage, her performance is always so lit!! Makes me emotional!!
Herin look like idol. So sweet
i hope herin will be back with sr17g :( herin-ah you deserve better
just cant believe why her rank always dropped. ya'll slept over talent. if i could vote, i would vote for her
anindita oppo herin right?
Teayones ofc :(
i think people dont slept over her talent but mnet just setting and making a drama with her.
I'm still hoping that SM is behind this and she's just getting exposure so that she'll be more popular once she debuts with the other SR17G.
TintedRhythm i hope so but not really expecting to much :')
Haein voice so sweet , I think this team is Visual team.
Herin my baby~ fighting! 💟🌸
Herin , u better debut soon 😘
M farrasaroes in 2015, SM said that the girls would debut in 2018. Its 2018 and there aren't even teasers. TT
Haneul Saxton I heard she left SM
El Lee yeah thats true,everyone who is contestant in this survival show was hasn't a agency.
SEO HERIN💓
sm rookies vibe's
I feel bad for herin, she left sm and now she is one of the lowest rank in idol school. She just flopping herself and after eliminated, i hope she got new agency that will explore her skill and debut 😇
Ranxy Lex idk if this is a good news or bad news for u but after idol school, she decided to stop her journey in the kpop industry and chose to live a normal life. I dont really know the reason but i watch some clips that kinda explain why she’s not in the industry anymore and that’s because the kpop industry is very toxic? Please correct me if im wrong yall🙏🏻
@@grandylicious really?? She will not continue as an idol?
michelle yes, unfortunately that’s true 😭
Nisarga Shetty yes, she said that she would be back as an idol if the KPOP industry has changed their system
@@nikitanurazizah6410 so sad😢
I love Herin adlib.
Herin,korean fan support her not much but she has so many inter fan.
Rainbow Flavor bc she from sm.. lol
Eunha Banjjak Banjjak So Cute what are your fucking problem when the SM shit same sentence I'm getting tired of people like you who think that they are more that because of Gfriend and I really hate buddy like you I'm so glad that I don't stand that group that only sing cute songs always I hate it
SNSD & TWICE I not talking about your fav group.. I talking about SM.. nah.. now I hate your snsd.. fuck snsd shit
SNSD & TWICE hahahaha.. you hate cute,?why you stan twice? funny
SNSD & TWICE please dont stan twice.. Gfriend and Twice are friend now.. you dont like cute concept right?
This song is really really for herin
Please vote for herin 😭 I really want her to debut 😭
How much you paid me..just kidding he..he..
Haein
Watasy Wahyo she's gonna be too old for the group. So no
Cao Lu debuted with Fiestar at her 25. She and Haein (and Tasha) aren't too old.
StanKings_ StanSeventeen she is not that old. do you know wanna one? The leader is 26 and he's older than haein but still debut with cute boys like jihoon
I'm just concerned with the age gap is all. Sometimes that can mess up group dynamics.
StanKings_ StanSeventeen you should know about wanna one. and their age gap
Seo Herin ❤️
HERIN DID THAT ♡
My herin 😭❤️ you did great bb ❤️
Lee Haein lets debut. Your voice tho... ❤❤❤
What's wrong with herin's score and rank.. She deserves better than this..
Herin fighting !! don't give up
I love your smile Herin ✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌
Herin fighting！！ let debut！😢
Herin is literally Bada first daughter their smile is really pretty
Its ningning
@@aespaforever1034 ngộ ha
Herin fighting!!
SeoHerin💓
*1st* Lee Haein (score 77.9 ) 1:02
*2nd* Baek Jiheon (score 72.7) 0:43
*3rd* Seo Herin (score 69.8) 0:53
is herin considering high with this score ?
compare to other girls in other performance ?
ade ade herins score is pretty low even among the other girls in other teams
yall stop sleeping on choi seunghyuk but is she got last among all the girls on others team?
Oh i can recalled now. Only herin, wonhee, n jenny got score below 70.
Teayones no wonhee and juhyun had lower scores
the comments are all full with Herin. this prove that Herin did REALLY well, but yeah dont know why they did her dirty like that. gosh
In my opinion Jiheon was the one who suited this song the most, Herin did this performance very well and Haein gave the flavour to this performance.
YJH.ZEN Yah true...
buddies 96 she is only 14 y/o she still have time to improve her voice
HERIN :' What the heck she got the lower score when she showed amazing vocal? Reallyy K-netz..
Herin
Jiheon definitely fits the song the best, while Herin and Haein did a bomb ass job on those vocals! This performance gave me so much joy. Everything about it felt right. These girls truly benefitted from this show's purpose, which was to help them improve and become proper idols, and these three are definitely at that level!
Major props to Jiheon for her improvement though, she got stuck in two of the weakest teams before so people thought she was the problem. In reality, she's actually a great performer. Finally she got put with a great team and she really proved herself!
TaemyYong ^preach
TaemyYong everyone needs to see this and stop talking about just her smile
Lee Haein !!!
Herin :(
This stage tho, Herin (a former SM trainee practices this song before and performed with other SM rookies) performing this song while infront of Bada (S.E.S. former SM artists) and Heechul (SM Artist) are watching. My SM stan heart 😢
Herin didn't deserve the treatment she got in Idol School.
This bring me back to Herin's smrookies days when they did a studio version of this song. Herin might also remember her smrookies aka mickey mouse club friends while doing this. ㅠㅠ *always here for you Herin!*
Haerin, star quality T_T
Herin, my sweet girl T_T
These 3 seriously need to debut together. For Me, Jiheon suited the concept most. Then Herin and Haein.
Lee haein look like a really idol ♡♡
I really miss Herin dancing and singing on the stage like this...My one and only pick in this show...However, I actually feel so, so happy since she finally can do things that she wants and loves. Love you so much, my baby girl...
This performance really shows that Herin is better in singing and dancing than the other two girls.. but why damn shit happen that Baek jiheon girl still got the spot. I understand Haein. But seriously, your visual ain't going nowhere if u got no talent
Frederica fcj haein not talented?How do you even evaluate her!Please go back pd101 okay
Frederica fcj Haein is even more talented than herin
NIGHTWINGS OFFICIAL since when I said Haein is not talented? I'm just saying that Herin is better than the two of them in terms of singing and dancing
the B in LGBT stands for Babadook so? you think just because she is in the top 9 she is more talented than herin? Tf no
Please Support Yoon Yongbin in Produce 101 season 2 nahh.. I studies vocal so I know their rank in vocal.. and you can totally see the difference in their dancing skill right after this performance start so don't u dare denying me
SLAY HERIN!! LOVE YOU HERIN!!
I wish Haein can be in Top 9 in final. Her voice is so sweet 😍
guys support Lee Haein solo performance cam here, follow link th-cam.com/video/mHUwNeBPEgQ/w-d-xo.html
Which one is Haein?!
lolitahitomi The one who makes the first high note .
Yes Haein,she Will be 2😊
Adinda Kirana
u hater and what are your facts? siyeon was the one being selfish she wanted to be main vocal when she cant even reach the note that was asked for her to sing, and haein was only there to cast vote whos going to be the main vocal,, study korean first before judging haein u dumbo
hi mnet i just want you to know that i keep coming back to this because of herin.
Herin deserve better
Honestly Haein's voice fit this song so much
I came back and realized no one talk about Jiheon, ur so pretty and talented baby!
Haein and Herin lets debut! They are so talented. Jiheon just have a great smile 😩
It's just my opinion
Agree
fadlilla noor rahmawati agree
really? meh...
no offense but can you actually dance better than her?
why she/he must dance better than her so she/he was allowed to comment ?
And I bet that I can dance better than her so don't show me again that sense
Cyrus Parallag why I must dance better than her? I must dance better than jiheon so I can write my opinion in this comment coloum? Haha. Once again, It's my opinion. I compared herin with jiheon that herin have a great dance skill, good voice and pretty face. Herin and haein Not just show her smile to attract the nation. And I'm not fan of haein and herin
🎀Herin💕💕
JIHEOOONNNNN.... SO Pretty
Jiheon is so precious I could cry, she's so cute ㅠㅠ
though you're nowhere near Haein and Herin's vocal skills right now, you can be one day. grow well and practice lots until then, lil Jiheon, fighting!
As someone who grew up in Korea and was there when SES was huge, it's great to see this stage done well. I'm not even JiHeon stan, but she has that captivating charm that you just can't teach. Definitely would like to see her make it.
HERIN 💞💞
most comments are here are talking about herin but what mnet giving a fuck with my baby Manchester she's deserve better.
My little Herin you are amazing!!!!
Herin 😍 Haein
Haein really did a good job ❤ i was worried that her voice will crack coz of the high notes but gurl she nailed it!
Hyerin, You make me cry. Just remember when you sing that song with SM Rookies...
Haein. Let's debut ♥
stabil banget vocalnya herin.... luv deh
Jiheon has grown so much 😭
Herin has a lot of I-fans but has a few k-fans. I hope they open their eyes for this talented girl. I miss her so much w/ the girls. 😭💖
Jiheon deserves more lines
anyway all of them sings very well and are so talented, FIGHTING! 💕
Jiheon is so cute
jiheon fit this song so much and she improved 💙
hyerin the most fit with this song. maybe because she from sm before so she’s really fit with this song
herin😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Seeing this again really make me feel sad now, knowing how actually Herin really did so great here, but she got the lowest score. Honestly Herin voice is so stable and her stage presence also looks good even I won’t be lying I prefer her performance when she covered this song with her fellow MMC girls, but seriously Herin deserves better, damn Mnet just being Mnet, always doing this dirty thing in their survival show… I also feel bad for Haein, she really deserve her #1 position. Herin and Haein actually really did great job performing this song, they really make a good foundation in this performance, huh, Mnet is really stupid like always
Ikr, I love jiheon but I think this is rigged
Herin😻😻😻i thought that she was going to debut from sm😿but i will still continue to support her no matter where she is🤗she is really talented in singing👍🏻did anyone even notice her singing some high notes at 3:12💓
Herin ga usah debut disini please, belum apa apa udah di "anak tiri" kan. Gue rasa bakal ditarik lagi sama SM(semoga) . Dan Kita lihat jadi apa ni grup yg isinya cuma ngandalin visual, visual, visual dan nyengir. Bagi gue banyak Dari top 9 ga deserve untuk jadi top9. Cuih lah emnet.
Annisa Khaerani masuk sm kan byar lagi,
gue juga pengen herin balik lagi ke sm, kasian dia talented banget tapi gak masuk debut line. sedangkan si jiheon yang modal nyengir doang masuk debut line -___-
Annisa Khaerani s7 disband aelah fromis_9
@@nurulaeni9196 2in anjay
Mereka jadi gg sukses kok, apalgi setelah masuk hybe dan diatur 100% sama pledis. Dan ingat ya, fromis_9 bukan punya visual doang, mereka juga punya banyak bakat. Bahkan knetz aja pada bilang fromis_9 itu TALENT_9, VISUAL_9.
High note last part from Herin makes me cry omgg 😭 Her voice still the same with I'am Your girl sm rookies version. when she singing with Mark,Donghyuk,Yeri,Goeun,Hina,and Lami 😭😭
herin 💞💖💖😊👏👏👏
haein's voice never fail to give me this calm and sweet vibe, think I can listen to her singing all day long!! our ibi leader let's debut and live happily for now on~💗
I like jiheon smile
Lee haein 😍
Throwback to when we didnt know why herin dropped in rank... only to find out the whole show was rigged 😭😭 She deserved better
It is really sad that she was eliminated but atleast I hope she will be back at SM Rookies because she really have great potential vocally and in dance.
Once in a while I come back to see how much Jiheon has grown up ☺️☺️
I must say that Haein's voice fits this song very well 😍
I just wanted herin being with koeun hina lami in aespa...
When there's haein in a team it always good.
I love Herin vocal. N also pretty visual too, omg i miss u Herin.