ARTIST vs PHOTOSHOP AI - Are We Being Replaced?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ต.ค. 2023
- (#ad) Find out more about Adobe's Ai features here: ►►tag.gs/BennyAFF
#Adobepartner #adobefirefly
In today's video we're experimenting with Photoshop Generative Fill and Adobe Firefly to see what's possible. Many people fear Ai is going to replace artists, but today I'm here to show you it's not that plain and simple! Adobe's Ai features are a great help and serve simply as a tool to make our life easier and faster. I believe artists will always stay relevant as we express our ideas in different ways.
__________________________________________________________________________
Instagram:
►► / benny_productions
Discord server:
►► / discord
Subreddit:
/ bennyproductions
TikTok:
►► / bennyproductions
My website:
►►www.bennyproductions.net/
Twitter:
►► / theactualbenny
Merch:
►► / @bennyproductions
__________________________________________________________________________
Subscribe to my gaming channel:
►► / @benjisadventures
__________________________________________________________________________
Unlimited Photoshop loot with Envato Elements: ►►1.envato.market/c/2016462/298...
Music in this video provided by Epidemic Sound!
Sign up today for a huge library of quality sound via this link:
►►share.epidemicsound.com/bennyp...
__________________________________________________________________________
Order original metal prints via Displate:
►►displate.com/bennyproductions...
__________________________________________________________________________
Hardware I use:
►Gigabyte TRX40 Aorus MASTER
►AMD Ryzen Threadripper 3970X, 32Core @3,7 GHz
►Gigabyte Aorus Liquid Cooler 360
►G.Skill DDR4 Ripjaws-V 8x32GB 3200Mhz [F4-3200C16Q-128GVK]
►GeForce RTX 3090 iChill X4
►ASUS ProArt PA329C, (+2)
Keyboard and mouse:
►Razer Pro Type
►Logitech G502
Audio:
►Razer Blackshark V2
►Shure SM7B Mic (with Focusrite Scarlett + Cloudlifter)
►Samson G-track PRO
Webcam/Camera:
►Logitech Brio
►Panasonic S5 - บันเทิง
I just feel that artists don’t get much attention for their dedicated hard work. You can get this man to create phenomenal art which some people would want to copy and redraw and get no views and likes and attention whereas someone just types a few words and everyone will like it. Really love your work
The reason is he's not that consistent as he was check other videos views
@@jester6789yeah but things happen sometimes people can't be perfect or always consistent especially when it comes to art which can take weeks to make or just a couple hours.
This is sad,
Honestly I am so bored with AI "looking" material. It just looks fake and plastic. I want to see real artwork, like this dude made. Props for him!
@@gamergridsthat's why he gonna be obsolete and gonna be replaced
The only problem I see ever being a serious threat is AI "Artists" claiming their work is 100% self made.
Genuine Artists will always be valued.
Nobody claims it's 100% their work. Just like you say "i took that photo with my phone" they say "i made that image with ai".
@@OlivioSarikas Nope, AI-bros claim that they made pics what AI did.
There is thousands that claim it's "their art", they are the one who even made the result happen. These kind of people are lazy rats trying to make a quick buck and pretend to themselves they are doing a "tough job". Rats.. just rats honestly.
@@pr1sm55 And even worse, they steal the visibility of real artists.
I'm not trying to defend the AI artist that claim their stuff is 100% made by them, but I'm just curious, do you consider the image at 3:05 in this video 100% made by Benny? Did he go out and take all the photos that were used in its creation? Did he blend different pigments to get all the color gradients required for the shadows, or did he allow PS to do the heavy lifting there? These questions are not meant to take away from the art created here, but rather to point out that just because someone uses the tools available to create shortcuts in their workflow does not mean they are not the one creating the final art. The reality is, the only way any piece is 100% created by the artist is if they lay pigment to paper, chisel to stone, fingers to clay, etc. There is very little that is "100% self made" these days.
Damn, honestly, no ai can ever be better than one of bennys insane artworks.
This is crazy, thank u Benny. 🙏
"Benny with the power of AI is the only one who can go equally with Benny" 😎
"ever" 😂 here we go again
You need to use a better AI model and you'll know XD PS AI is shit.
@@soulxslayerchan what ai do u recommend?
i commented 3 times with huge details but yt is not adding those comments here. idk whats up.@@juliankaiser3086
I started my own channel and I was really scared to do that because of AI and I realized something, no matter how good AI gets, It's all about the process, I watch Benny, PhaseRunner, Encreate etc. all the time and I enjoy it more and more, I don't care if computer creates the most amazing paintings I'm still watching Bob Ross.
One thing I notice from those who use AI for AI is the lack of knowledge about composition, it depends a lot on the machine providing this and without composition the best techniques seem amateurish. A guy who uses AI and has a sense of composition goes ahead.
Lol AI can’t touch Bob Ross he’s cool ole school
Yep your right! Also, AI still cant do a human job as a human and it will never do it
As a non-artist with no artistic ability, having played with AI art for a few months now, I think I can say that AI art will not (can not) replace artists. Anyone can easily use AI to churn out generic, non-meaningful 'art' all day, but it will always take a true artist at the helm to create anything of artistic value. It will be an amazing tool to improve the workflow of an artist, but it will never make someone an artist if they weren't before.
As they say, don't use the word "never" when it comes to technology. Especially not when this technology has changed drastically in just a decade, and continues to improve. For all you know, these systems could become just as good as any artist in another 10 years, with incorporated knowledge about aesthetics, style, and creativity. As of now, they are miles behind.
I don't agree at all. It's an empty rhetoric from people being scared being replaced by AI. I think it will be as unique as any human artist if not even more so.
@@kalumanderI highly agree, many people say this yet cannot tell the difference between AI and non-AI generated art, an AI generated art piece won an art competition as a proof of concept, meaning it can quite easily make superior and more 'creative' art pieces than humans, however to get consistently good results, you must actually be rather experienced with AI, which is something many peole fail to understand.
Somehow I feel like this take will age like milk in about 5-10 years.
@@TrueOracleSo, bring together a guy who knows composition, art direction, the fundamentals of drawing, it can be image editing, you can be an expert in AI, an artist will have twice as much knowledge and application, it will be like this guy who won the competition but even more turbocharged, since art is still a highly subgetive process and not just the technical part technology can evolve and artists will evolve with it and surpass themselves.
I think it'll be interesting to see Benny vs. Midjourney
I don’t think he will because he knows how good it is. Generative fill is nothing compared to midjourney and dalle 3
yep
@conhuir Yeah, but it'll still be very interesting
just tried dall-e3 and it almost got everything perfect except for the sign haha but with some manual tweaking i think i could create the same result like benny (at least form a disctance) in less than 15min. But i still think, ai wont replace us but makes our life much easier
@@conhuir
And Stable Diffusion, also for upscaling
Great video, and I agree with your points! In my field of work (thumbnails), the Generative Fill has proven to be one of the best tools ever. What was usually a mundane process before is just a breeze now. Best examples are removing small objects, expanding the image/objects or adding the shoulders when clients send a cut-off selfie for a thumbnail 😂 Lots of saved time!
I've been waiting so long for Benny to make a video like this! Awesome video dude!
Great vid man! Your version was top notch 🔥
Wow, I'm just now finding your videos... Incredible work! I'll definitely be watching more.
Benny, I wish you create a Full Photoshop course to teach us all (I'd buy it no matter the price) . You're an absolute legend and your skills are unmatched.
Yours is definitely the best looking. I agree, it's more a tool to simplify work around some areas or a tool for inspiration.
Love your content bro. Would you mind sharing what your audio setup is? Sounds so crisp! Is that just your mic and sound foam or do you mix and master your sound as well?
The images that Ai did in this video are impressive, however my favorite is the one that benny did, it is just so well made and beautiful and has a lot more action.
although he could use AI image and do his job to improved it
could have been so much better
The AI creates that image if he used his hability to improve some sort of things like
shadows, positions the result would be magical
At the same level of his work who was amazing,
the thing is U can't expect the AI to create something u have in your mind
without changing things, layers, and improve it
@@whoamit46429:37
He competed against himself. He deliberately made the AI one bad.
Benny I'm so glad you're back! and this video was sth that I really needed to see ! please never stop creating, you inspire many artist and definitely AI can not do that! Loved this video, and Hope to see you more in this channel
Literally today I was going to give myself a heart attack over AI, but now I'm inspired! Never underestimate the power of your inspiration, Benny! Thank you very much for your hard work
I don't even have Photoshop I only have PicsArt but I been watching Benny's channel for a very long time and he's editing tips like how he apply shadow, elements really helps me in traditional art.....I'm using this as an opportunity to learn and get better at how to draw and see things realistically...❤❤
oh my god!, i wasn't expecting this, i thought the recent video was the last, but THERE YOU GO!, thanks for this one dude!
Benny where is Halloween edit submission video?😢😢😢 I loved that series please bring back...love from INDIA 🇮🇳
So glad you’re making more videos on the main channel again!
Wow thanks alot
U really answered the question I av been asking in my heart
Thanks
Even if it was only ever designed as a stepping off point for real artists, there are countless things that end up being used in ways beyond what their intended purpose was. In other words, this is definitely going to be used as a cheap and fast alternative to hiring an artist. We artists are definitely going to be replaced in the eyes of many clients.
Imagine where it will be in just a few years from now.
Awesome video Benny, your attitude in the beginning was a little different towards A.I. but you have risen above many other artist and embraced it. Can you imagine what painters and drawers felt like in 90's when photoshop came out? Watch photoshop 1.0 debut on television, its the same conversations as today for A.I.
Great video🔥🔥i have one question though, no Edit War Contest this year?😅😅
very cool vid! i've been using it for restoring old photos and it's pretty good at that with some sharpening
Broooo your art is mindblowing !!! your level have gone up so mutch !!!
BENNYYYYY 😊😊😊😊 man i'm too glad each time i look at one of your videos!!
Have you ever considered using Camera Raw Filters on your images (especially landscapes) to change the colour before putting them into Photoshop?
Finally a new Video!!! I'm so happy. Thank you very much
We missed you bro hopefully the spookiness is coming back
AI is here to help can't replace a Pro like you 😄 Is there any Halloween video coming up?
I'm glad that benny's starting to upload again
keep doing what you do my man, awesome content
I mean. . . this is only how AI is NOW. I think people should consider that this is kind of stuff is going to evolve and advance dramatically and we need to prepare for that.
Benny a tip if you want more realistic results of the AI, be specific as hell. On every detail.
If you want the most similar ground put dead grass, sand ground, desert, etc.
Sunset with orange and purple tones of colors, this kind of stuff. Specific.
I am glad you see ai as a tool for artist. Remember you had an idea for a bus on a train track with a jet engine on it. That is when the artist is at work. Getting all the light right in the image is borderline tedious. There is still a neural filter in the making that would do that, using ai. Another great tool, to get to the image you have in your head.
I am never using ai images out of the box. Always changing the colors, removing artifacts, adding details or atmospherics, etc. And sometimes using a Firefly image as input for a Leonardo, Midjourney or Dall-E 3 image.
Hey benny i recently started watching you and you have jnspired me to learm phtoshop thank you ❤❤❤
Actually gutted there wasn’t a Bennys Spooky Edit War this year. Cmon Bennie just come back lad
Killer work!! Only thing I would add to your van on tracks would be motion blur
My biggest issue with some of these AI models is lack of transparency. Where are the images that are being used to train the model being pulled from? Were those original artists/photographers compensated? I'd assume in many cases they haven't so it's borderline theft
Do you compensate every artist that has inspired you?
The way you shade, the object used.
Do you think he compensated volkswagen for using the likeness of the bus?
You obviously can go too far and break copyright but that is not on the ai, you can't sue photoshop when someone scrubs out your signature and used your image, you sue the person that scrubbed it out. Same with ai, if your art is clearly used and breaks copyright you go after who is using the image.
@@group555_ it's not inspiration. they are training the models based on your images TO CREATE A PRODUCT. the closest comparison would be Google with the robots.txt file. You have a choice if you want your site indexed with Googles model. Artists currently have zero transparency or choice in the matter. I don't think you actually understand how these AI models train and work.
Also, to be clear, I have no issue with the people using the AI models. My issue is directly with the companies
that the unfair point,any random dude can throw any prompts and acheive insane art which he wasn't expecting ,because those ai generators are already trained from good artists work
@@group555_ Being inspired by an image and using a stock image without permission are two different things. AI art is doing the latter.
AI is one of those weird topics that I've gone back and forth on a lot. As far as generative fill goes, I love the idea. It's basically just a better version of content-aware fill, and I think it has huge potential to help clean up photos and such, or to fill in empty areas on cropped or rotated images like shown in this video.
We want a Halloween video challenge! Make a selection, select certain images that should be used, if the final image contains an AI image, automatically disqualify it. We need more content like this, we're tired of the dumb AI, everyone is an artist today, and actually what you do is the core of this whole business and you should live all of this!
AI definitely can't replace artists anytime soon. It does however seem to be a really useful tool to enhance certain parts of the image and also can save a ton of time on concept artwork for movies, videogames, ect.
Sooner than you think. It's a bit scary that I still find these kind of comments. The info on current developments in AI is everywhere but it's like no one (maybe the media's fault) is talking about it.
The AI engineers have a totally different mindset about this tech than the people that use it. It's not about tools, it's about control. Creating machines that are indistinguishable from humans. Kind of like playing God. stuff than AGI was the holy grail up until 2016 but it's right at our doorstep.
But that's just the baseline. Before that you will start to see AI (like CRISPR tech) being used to enhance and limit human capabilities. Cancer will become a thing of the past, sexual deviancy etc but... it will also curtail the aggressive nature in populations to make them more docile eliminating the cost and need for policing them. In the end you will have a tyrannical system dominated by machines and genetically engineered human populations that have no incentive to do anything about it. Think Gatica.
And we will comply. We always do. I realized this with Covid.
Hi ! Just to say that you should put the volume
of your videos a little but higher ! with a speaker at the max level it feels kinda low
Great video as always, firefly is not near as powerful as mid journey, but even in mid journey to get exactly what you want is almost impossible even with super prompts, it’s much more random in the end with ai then drawing it, sure it can produce amazing images but they are random I try often to use for work but in the end I need longer in ai then if I would create it, it really depends for somethings it is great but for a real project I’m not sure if it will ever work I was very pessimistic when these things come out though we all gonna loose the job, but don’t really think so anymore you just can’t explain with words our visions and then the ai understating it.
I'd love to see what you think of the other new features in photoshop like select subject and magic eraser.
Only thing missing was you leveraging it as a tool along with your personal techniques to create a fourth final image
Hi benny I've been watching you for 3 years and I love your videos even the theme park tycoon too, but I want more videos of upgrading photoshop realistified, because I loved when you upgraded your phoenix, that was amazingly better (sorry for bad english)
Awesome! Thanks for sharing!
Cool video, also can you continue the remakes from your old Photoshop creations series
Excellent tutorial that inspired me to try and create the scene with a single prompt in DALL-E 3 Bing Image Creator. ‘Here’s my prompt if anyone wants to try it: Hyper realistic photo of retro camper van with graffiti on side , with train wheels, running on railroad tracks, on top of bus an aircraft engine and full throttle reheat, at night, headlights on’
I loved this video because it is honest. I'm tired of people demonizing IAs, they are just another tool that can help creators a lot. To fight against that is to put yourself in the position of those who fought against tractors or sewing machines in the past. AI are not the magic panacea that solves everything, we already see that the results leave much to be desired, they are of little use if you don't have talent and previous knowledge and experience. Good video, thanks.
Would love to see a video where you combine your Photoshop skills with these generations to create something amazing. Show people how AI enhances your ideas and execution!
I was wondering if you could make a video that explains how to submit our designs for realistified
Hey Benny. As it's October the spooky month maybe you could do a Hollywood level Horror poster. I really like your previous ones.
Glad to see another video from you❤
Honestly, no matter how cool the images are, i can tell whether the image is generated by ai by just looking at it. I dont know what it is. But there is something on the ai generated images.
you should photoshop a picture of an actual jet, carrying a vintage van or something on the bottom. that would be cool! keep up the good work!
Benny, these vids relax my soul ^
The desert background is from my hometown Wadi Rum, Jordan :)
I would like to see you redo this episode again. The new Ai form Adobe can take your image for inspiration, and get you closer to what you are thinking of designing. Plus the water marks are gone.
the artistry comes from knowing how to tell it what to do. the more detailed your description, the closer the image will be to what you see in your minds eye. remember it is a tool. the better you are at using it the better your final image will be.
I try to explain to anyone not regularly using generative tools that this is just another tool in your arsenal. Just like power tools can make your work go faster when woodworking, all generative tools can help you work faster and get fast results. You still have to know what a bad and good result is and why. The path to that result might just be heavily reduced.
Do more of this videos please 😁❤️ it's very addictive
Welcome bro we've been waiting for❤❤❤
Benny - you do all sorts of challenges with stock photos. It would be amazing to watch you do the same thing with AI-generated elements. Generate different Firefly images and combine them all using your editing skills. Here is an example. Use AI to generate the following images:
- Farmhouse
- Tombstones
- Pumpkins/Jack o'lanterns
- gnarled tree
You get the gist. I think it would be very cool and freeing to generate your assets with AI, but let the composition and lighting be your domain.
😁
As alwawys Benny never miss🔥🔥🔥
there will no spooky season challenge this year ????
This reminds me of the arrival of image banks. We said to ourselves, "Great, no need to hire a photographer anymore!"... and we could spend days looking for the right images while the client waited for us to present a project.
And finally, the most effective thing was to call on a roughman, then a photographer and finally to retouch the visual.
AI isn't going to change much. At first, the client will say I can do things myself... and then they will call a graphic designer or an agency!
Keep up the good work BENNY
Yeah , genuinely was thinking about adobe graphic artists and video kinda proves how much better human-made shit is. I have never seen any Midjourney image close enough to rival the FIRST image you made, it actually looks finished rather than whatever the hell kinda prompt you’d put in Midjourney and have to accept it because you’re not in the position to complain,,, since you’re not the one making the image.
This would actually be really nice to come up with compositions for real artwork. Just to see it kind of as a rough draft and get some basic ideas and placements for stuff.
Yeah you can actually draw the most simplistic sketch ever, blocking out where you may want things to be, and put that in external AI gen software and it will then use that to create your immediate composition based on what you ask of it. You can then choose to edit it and take it further or use it as a concept.
@@maverick9860 This is when AI is used for good and not bad. I have some skill with photoshop but I'm not the most creative person in the world. But using it like this, I can get a rough outline of a concept in my head and see it before I make it so I don't end up wasting time making something I don't like. really useful.
Congratulations on your return
What you can do (I paused video on the middle): Upload your artwork to latest GPT Vision (Visual?) and ask something like "Describe what you see in the image" and then use its description on Firefly and try to generate AI photo this way :)
Awesome video, you should really try this same challenge with Dalle-3, you’ll be shocked at the results
Their generative AI isnt intended to replace human made artwork or photobashes anyway, its intended to accompany us. You can input some generated stuff into your images, you can also use it as a idea or reference generator perhaps and i see a huge potential for this.
Wishful thinking.
Here is the bottom line: You need to churn out creative work that's WAY better than anything you do now, at a faster pace and looking incredible. If you focus on that you might get through this. The only chance you might have is changing your workflow by incorporating more and more AI. The long slow process of craftsmanship will become nothing more than therapeutic. I don't think a lot of people understand how the current tech is working nor what they are planning. It's fine if the tech just stayed the same as it's now. Problem is, the next decade is going to be hell.
@@snaphaan5049it's like wood working. You can get to some specialist paying 1000 for a table or go to IKEA and buy one for 300. Guess what most people do? Creative work will become the same.
They just say that its a tool for artists to deter some of the hostility.
I have a really good video idea where you use Dalle 3 vs your skills! I would love to see that!!!!
I really love your video, I subscribed 3 years ago. And I think AI just can help somebody like me, who doesn't have pro-skills to make a image. But i think you can use it to help make something quickly or more ideas :D
more video like this please benny.
I love how Benny says "him" as if to say AI IS HIM!
THATS SO NICE BENNY OMG❤
Designer nowadays
Designer❎
Generator✅
I love Benny creative work And you are the best inspiration.
Bro finally remembered his Gmail password 😂
انت محترف في كل شيء، لا استطيع استيعاب جودة التصوير والخلفية والإضاءة والألوان،انت ملهم
Bro, I have a suggestion. If you color-grade the background or the primary image, the generative fill might produce images that match it better. it'll look even nicer."
Benny where's Benny's Spooky Edit War 2023? It's so exciting to watch what people can do with their hands!
Hey, just an idea why don't you create some custom eveelutions. Love your videos btw.
Pro tip: if the angle of the van makes more diagonal line and bring more excitement feeling. If he didn’t choose that angle the entire piece would feel very dull/calm. This “angle theory” applies to almost every art or design subject and if you use it I promise it WILL make your your art more exciting.
Ai definitely will replace a lot of designers for the simple reason that most people/companies are cheap and if they can get a result with "a push of the button" they will do that instead of paying for work.
Indeed, I feel like this is what a lot of artists do not understand. They see AI as a good tool for them, inspiration etc. but don't look at it from the lens of a company hiring an artist. These companies might just go for ''good enough'' with AI while paying barely anything for it.
@@luke0346 No, they won't. AI is a blunt tool, it doesn't produce exactly what you want. If you think that you have no idea how these industries work.
Thanks for doing this video Benny! It shows that AI can 'help' slightly but it does NOT replace artists!!! *EDITED TO ADD* Firefly makes very nice work that's a bit scary lol WOW! Argh
Just watched the Bee video of yours and now I can't sleep either so this is a good way to get it off my mind.
Question? Are you doing a Benny's spooky edit war 2023?
i tried to recreate the image with dalle 3 (a more powerful AI) and its a lot better, almost as good as the one you did in photoshop
Your content never get replaced, OG skills
Feel like there should have been a lot of motion blur in your arrwork, to sell the speed
Professional Digital Artists: My workflow involves the use of 10 software where I can go from sketching to 3d sculpting/modelling all the way to a final render where I can composit in photoshop.
Benny: google > someone elses image > copy > paste > hue/saturate
Use the following prompt in Dall E 3 or Midjourney v6:
a vintage Volkswagen van painted with vibrant graffiti, equipped with a jet engine on its roof, speeding along train tracks amidst an explosion of rockets in a dramatic sunset landscape.
Fan of your artworks ❤❤❤
Adding a tiny bit of blur to the van would help sell the speed a little more.
We miss you finally u uploading videos 🎉🎉
Next episode please make your own version of edit based on AI picture. That would be so cool to watch!
where u get the asset?? and can you make tutorial video ho to make design