Does Sinding DESERVE To DIE In Skyrim AE 2024

Thank you for watching! please consider subscribing to my channel to see more skyrim content :D
Support my channel for exclusive perks! / @okappu2
My second channel: / @okapptwo
Thanks for watching!
TAGS:
#Skyrim #skyrimae #skyrimanniversaryedition
skyrim skyrim anniversary edition skyrim legendary survival skyrim legendary playthrough skyrim survival mode lyle shnub skyrim let's play skyrim legendary

[@D_Angelo_Da_TMNT]

Does he deserve to die for killing the girl yes and no. Morally and objectively I see both Sinding as well as the girl as unfortunate victims in Hurcine's games. When he is explaining the situation he says he stole the ring to help him control himself and is obviously shaken about his curse which leads me to believe he was attacked, survived at some point recently and was trying to escape his fate to try to continue to live a normal life by stealing the ring not knowing just how badly he messed up. Throughout the entire questline he keeps this remorseful tone and never denies or belittles his mistake only tries to find a way to atone by ultimately isolating himself and or dying at your hands. Also just assuming that because he is cursed that he must have killed other people is straight speculative nord paranoia imho but he very well could have. Does the man really deserve to die for something he quite literally cant control? idk. Could he have just gone full werewolf hermit mode before the murder? Yes but who is to say that there wouldn't have just been a different victim and with no one around he just goes fully feral like most other werewolves before being hunted like Hurcine planned all along? It just doen't make sense to me to try to take revenge on someone who is obviously also being hurt by the situation to what make the parents feel better? The only winner in this is Hurcine even you the db drew the short stick pretty much.

[@rench55]

"Deserve's got nuthin' to do with it."
William Munny, Unforgiven

[@chadalpha7983]

Obviosly he killed the girl on purpose 1. He talks to you normal while in wolf form
2. He had to install mods in order to kill a child

[@andrewhazlewood4569]

He could not control himself and was acting out the nature of who he was at the time when he killed but he still did kill. That could be said of Parthurnax too.

[@cheesaliciousable]

From an acievement perspective...you have to spare Sinding. Because the Savior's hide does not count towards the Oblivion Walker achievement.
Now, you CAN get both, by initially sparing Sinding, but then walking out of the conversation and going back in to kill him.

[@williamtanner2184]

No , dogs in skyrim are fare game its the chickens the damn gaurds and people go nuts about.

[@_Silent_Moon_]

Honestly, I mever really cared for this quest. Depending on the rype of character im olaying, I never thi k of it.
Its purely just -
If i want the outfit I slay him if i wsnt the ring, i spare him.
So it reslly just depends to me on what i prefer in thr playthrough.

[@MadMamluk88]

I usually spare him first and when I complete the quest I go back and kill him; you get two Daedric artifacts at the same time toward the Oblivion Walker achievement. That way you can either spare Erandur or kill Eola in Markarth and not feel guilty (Ring of Namira is not that great and Skull of Corruption is actual dogshit in Skyrim)

[@_Silent_Moon_]

Sasly i canr gst achievements. I play on switch. Lol

[@arifhossain9751]

Maybe you guys are the REAL evil

[@_Silent_Moon_]

I typically tend to play evil characters anyway so lol

[@rahovartiv3464]

Yes because if anyone actually believes hes not going to hurt anyone ever again is incredibly naive.

[@WhiterunGuard001]

I don't care what anyone says sinding deserves to die...
I normally don't kill him, mainly due to the fact that it's either choosing him or a deadric lord... And if I have to choose one or the other I'm choosing sinding.
But here's my issue, the fact that he hurt a child under any circumstance, no matter what it is, children are off limits. I understand that it's just a game, but even if it wasn't in it, it was based on real life. I don't fuck with that shit at all.
You hurt a child, you deserve the worst of the worst, I don't care what anyone says... And if you think otherwise, you're defending people who hurt children. You're just as bad.
But besides all that... I want this to be clear, I'm aware it's a game that's why I choose sinding over the deadra.
The Deadra cannot be trusted under any circumstance in the only 2 that you can trust to uphold their end of the bargain are Azura and Sheogorath all the others can not be trusted at all.
Especially Lords like Clavicus Vile or even MAEPHALLA... Those 2 cannot be trusted at all, and it is extremely foolish to trust them.
Clavicus Vile is the lord of deals, Problem is those deals will always stab you in the back, because he's kind of like a genie.
He will fulfill the deal, but it will not be what you want exactly... For example, Elder Scrolls, 5 Skyrim, you can ask him to you end the civil war.
That seems pretty good, right? That's a good cause, good reasoning, and it has purpose, the civil war does need to end... Buuuuuuuut she would tricked you by destroying and killing both sides.
It would end the war, yeah, but all those lives would be killed just for his own amusement.
And as for Maphalla she's the daedric lord of deceit... I don't think I need to describe that betrayal is literally what her job is😂😂