It’s so good. I’ve watched all of them up until I was a regular viewer, and it didn’t even take that long. Only about a month and a half of watching a couple hours a day in college
Oh wow, in 2009 I watched the whole backlog during the school summer holidays to catch up and I thought it was a lot of videos back then!! I felt so behind and out of the loop!
My favorite part of the horseradish challenge was the couple who made a response video roasting John for eating watered-down horseradish mayo "intended for gentiles and young children."
I piled up some st Helen's ash and my dad planted a horseradish in it. Every now and then we would dig up a chunk and eat it. I remember a lot of bugs eating it too.
As a Jewish person of mixed Ukrainian and Galilean descent, I can confirm that this couple was correct. Horseradish must be spicy, unless you are either a toddler or some white bread milquetoast neutral person who thinks boiled potatoes are too spicy. When I'm eating my gefilte fish after the seder, I better get some strong horseradish, none of that weak stuff.
I saw the title and then did a double-take when I saw it was just uploaded. The whole energy in this video made me emotional - TH-cam may have changed a lot, but opening a vlogbrothers video will always feel like slipping under your favourite blanket with a nice hot drink.
It's something about the way John is acting, this manic, overconfident energy is something I'd expect from him 5-10 years ago, so I'm glad he still has the capacity for that in him these days.
Idk what's funnier, the beginning being the most brotherly thing ever withthe tackle, or Hank being a full grown adult who still says 'frick' and 'shoot'
i just google image searched for the shirt Hanks friend must’ve actually just made that for him or his friend knows a really cool queer shop in Tallahassee
@jjunior48 having lived in Tallahassee in the early 2010s, if there's even one queer shop in that town today something has gone horribly right in the last decade.
Then you are also impressive! But it sounds like he would have missed the peanut butter face one if Hank hadn't changed the country being discussed, so perhaps you're more impressive.
@@runningcow But he was able to recall specific details about filming them and their content, which in most cases I couldn't remember anything about them.
I love that these big goofy brothers say, "We've had, like 18 years together" like they aren't, you know, big goofy brothers. One of you have had your WHOLE LIFE with the other, and the older had the BEST of his life with the younger.
I think he remembers doing peanut butter face but doesn't expect he would have done it whilst discussing global politics... because now he would probably find that insensitive.
@@HarshitWiseThat was one of the fake titles Hank made up in the video, but the commenter is saying it’s so realistic/good that no doubt we might see it as a real video title next week heh
I can't find the video but way back in like 2008 John had a head cold and described it as feeling like a bunch of tiny chickens were pecking at his brain
@@Quintinia it was Hank. He was at the Detroit Auto Show and came into contact with a chicken and it laid its tiny chicken eggs in his brain giving him Tiny chicken disease Mentioned again in the Anglerfish video he did for Masters of Song Fu
That tackle hug brought me back to the very beginning of Dan and Phil with a visceral slam of nostalgia. I'm so glad it was a nostalgia video so I didn't have to leave that feeling behind right away.
Very proud of myself for getting 100% since like John, I've seen all the videos. I even went "he DID do peanut butter face, but that was a different conflict"
Look, Bon Jovi is still a great band to see live and still put out new music, but also they've been a nostalgia act for a long, long time. You're the Bon Jovi of TH-cam and that is great!
This video title feels really special to me in particular because October 11th is the day when I first discovered Brotherhood 2.0! I remember because as I was starting to watch the backlog of videos (on the Brotherhood 2.0 website lol), a new video popped up and it was Hank's video about national coming out day, which is Oct. 11.
The parasocial effect is strong with this video. I feel so attached to Hank and John, like we are old friends. Fun to watch these two guys I like and respect so much.
I loved some of the memories this brought up. I love being a part of this community and can't wait for what the future brings. I started watching when I was in school and now I'm in a place where I was able to pledge to the Book of Good Times Kickstarter. We are all growing up together and I'm so happy to be a part of it. DFTBA!
I've been around since Accio Deathly Hallows made it to the front page of TH-cam. I was loosely an adult when that happened and it regularly reminds me that I am in fact, 507 years old. We should have an elder nightfighter secret handshake.
Awww this video was so fun. It is much more daunting to do a full vlogbrothers watch through now, but if anyone wants to try, there are some absolute bangers in vlogbrothers' history!
What a NICE video! Seeing this just makes me feel... happy. (Thanks for making this.) [I'm really surprised John got 100%. To miss a couple would be understandable. Wow, you know your stuff, John! Well done.]
But you DID do the cinnamon challenge, John, in one of your World History Crash Course videos, because I saw it about 12 times in the years I taught high school world history. Great job not getting those two confused!
A journal is your past self communicating with your present self. It can be nostalgia, but it also always more. The past videos can be nostalgic, but they are also enlightening about how the world and Internet has changed and a great reminder that it will change.
I love the old timey vibe of the video I get that there are a lot of serious things to talk about these days, but it is nice to see a video like this once in a whilec
Nostalgia acts can happen throughout the lifetime of an entity. Sometimes we can look back on what we've done, without compromising on the future of what we will do. So many excellent year behind us, and so many excellent years to come.
Nostalgia-act wise, brotherhood 2.0 has been one of my favorite things to watch and rewatch again. There was a brotherhood 2.0 on the exact day I was born, meaning I can look back and see what these random guys in a whole other country were thinking about on any day of my life.
I love how the whole video they're both looking sorta wistfully off to the side. I'm sure it's out the window or something, but it really adds to the nostalgia feel for the video
It's good to see Hank and John, but it's even better to see them together
And John laughing
Proof that they're actually different people!
shame Dave couldn't make it
@@WiseGuy57 poor Dave. Always left out
How did you do that
This video makes me want to pause my life for ~2 weeks and watch every single vlogbrothers video in order so I'm aware of all lore ever
I am on this journey and it's worth it, do itttt
It’s so good. I’ve watched all of them up until I was a regular viewer, and it didn’t even take that long. Only about a month and a half of watching a couple hours a day in college
Oh wow, in 2009 I watched the whole backlog during the school summer holidays to catch up and I thought it was a lot of videos back then!! I felt so behind and out of the loop!
I’ve only found this channel during Covid, that’s a LOT of videos to watch. I need crochet a blanket I’m thinking….
It took me two weeks to catch them all up in 2011. Godspeed.
My favorite part of the horseradish challenge was the couple who made a response video roasting John for eating watered-down horseradish mayo "intended for gentiles and young children."
this is my favorite comment on this video
Well, he is definitely at least one of those things.
I remember being disappointed he didn't have fresh horseradish root to eat, so I'm glad I wasn't alone!
I piled up some st Helen's ash and my dad planted a horseradish in it.
Every now and then we would dig up a chunk and eat it. I remember a lot of bugs eating it too.
As a Jewish person of mixed Ukrainian and Galilean descent, I can confirm that this couple was correct. Horseradish must be spicy, unless you are either a toddler or some white bread milquetoast neutral person who thinks boiled potatoes are too spicy. When I'm eating my gefilte fish after the seder, I better get some strong horseradish, none of that weak stuff.
I saw the title and then did a double-take when I saw it was just uploaded. The whole energy in this video made me emotional - TH-cam may have changed a lot, but opening a vlogbrothers video will always feel like slipping under your favourite blanket with a nice hot drink.
SAME! Something about the tan paneled walls and the arrangement made me think it was an abundance of Katherines tour or something 😂
same here!
Nothing changes.
It's something about the way John is acting, this manic, overconfident energy is something I'd expect from him 5-10 years ago, so I'm glad he still has the capacity for that in him these days.
Idk what's funnier, the beginning being the most brotherly thing ever withthe tackle, or Hank being a full grown adult who still says 'frick' and 'shoot'
He has a young child, so. 😂
Oh Hank 100% curses. Just not on vlog brothers lol
Bro is forgetting that this is a video on TH-cam and the censoring is for monetization
@@jasminegates9314 he saves that for guest appearances on Dimension 20 and on various LA-area podcasts lol
@@jasminegates9314Yes - the f bombs are a sure sign you clicked on a "hankschannel" video instead of vlogbrothers lol
As a queer person from Tallahassee, I am VERY envious of Hank’s shirt and need to know where it was acquired.
It was given to me by a friend from Tallahassee!
I assumed it was merch from drive away dolls, it was the only explanation I had for a shirt that says Tallahassee in rainbow color.
i just google image searched for the shirt Hanks friend must’ve actually just made that for him or his friend knows a really cool queer shop in Tallahassee
@jjunior48 having lived in Tallahassee in the early 2010s, if there's even one queer shop in that town today something has gone horribly right in the last decade.
Following for more info from said friend ❤
VlogBrothers
-nostalgia act
-current and relevant
-makes me excited about the future
Quite an awesome thing
+++ phenomenal comment
One might say, it's an absolutely remarkable thing
@@Shrooblord Beat me to it!
I was rooting hard for John, you love to see the completely well-placed confidence
French the llama! This video really felt like a classic one. Truly a great video - banter, vlogbrothers history, and a reunion video!
I was positive "Another Word for Thesaurus" was a title of one of John's videos. Even after finding out it isn't, I'm only 50% convinced.
Brothers sometime change titles after a few minutes/hours for algorithm purpose. It might very well would have been a vlogbrothers video.
I also got all of these questions right, but John's recall of the details of 17 year old videos is impressive.
Then you are also impressive! But it sounds like he would have missed the peanut butter face one if Hank hadn't changed the country being discussed, so perhaps you're more impressive.
@@runningcow But he was able to recall specific details about filming them and their content, which in most cases I couldn't remember anything about them.
Hank: I don't remember all the videos I did
John: I DO!
John's smile and laughter when he's with his brother is always much brighter than in solo videos.
I love that these big goofy brothers say, "We've had, like 18 years together" like they aren't, you know, big goofy brothers. One of you have had your WHOLE LIFE with the other, and the older had the BEST of his life with the younger.
They were not really close. The point of the project Brotherhood 2.0 was to bring them closer.
18 years together professionally! The reast mostly unprofessionally p:
As a longtime nerdfighter, this was a fun walk down memory lane
They got me on peanut butter face!
+++
+
i am literally shaken to my CORE that john does not remember doing peanut butter face!!!!! that's like a legendary stunt John did!
And didn't he do it more than once?
I think he remembers doing peanut butter face but doesn't expect he would have done it whilst discussing global politics... because now he would probably find that insensitive.
Eagerly awaiting ‘Another word for thesaurus’ next week!
Sorry, did I miss a joke?
@@HarshitWiseThat was one of the fake titles Hank made up in the video, but the commenter is saying it’s so realistic/good that no doubt we might see it as a real video title next week heh
I love a channel that comes to me in eras almost as much as a video in parts
+
Or a human in multitudes
I'm impressed that John got them all but not surprised. DFTBA!
I know for a fact that when i get sick, i still call it ‘tiny chickens disease ‘
Dude same, and when the weather gets hot, you know what song gets stuck in my head.
newer nerdfighter here, what's the tiny chicken disease? lmao /pos
I can't find the video but way back in like 2008 John had a head cold and described it as feeling like a bunch of tiny chickens were pecking at his brain
@MinurielLai
@@Quintinia it was Hank. He was at the Detroit Auto Show and came into contact with a chicken and it laid its tiny chicken eggs in his brain giving him Tiny chicken disease
Mentioned again in the Anglerfish video he did for Masters of Song Fu
You guys are the superior fish beings
Intellectual sushi... with legs and stuff.
Stephen Jay Gould would agree.
I love how happy you guys look together here :) tackle hugs FTW
I rewatched the tackle hug twice because it made me laugh😂
October 11, 2024 is our first child’s birthday! What a treat after my wife and I have watched you guys since the beginning.
That tackle hug brought me back to the very beginning of Dan and Phil with a visceral slam of nostalgia. I'm so glad it was a nostalgia video so I didn't have to leave that feeling behind right away.
love the title so much
I didn't even realize they did that until I saw this comment. Nice catch.
"...because I've seen everyone of your videos!"
Same.
This is data discrepancy.
Very proud of myself for getting 100% since like John, I've seen all the videos. I even went "he DID do peanut butter face, but that was a different conflict"
Same russia different country 😢
"Another Genre of TH-cam" sounds like a good video title!
Thank you for the memories and sibling silliness.
I remember the peanut butter face John! That was a wild time for sure
Same!! I think, partly, because I found it so disgusting. It’s wild to me that John has no memory of it
0:02 Hank's face is priceless 😂😂😂
You don't know how many times I rewatched that beginning
Look, Bon Jovi is still a great band to see live and still put out new music, but also they've been a nostalgia act for a long, long time. You're the Bon Jovi of TH-cam and that is great!
This is perfect. 😙👌
THIS IS THE BEST START TO A VLOGBROTHERS VIDEO E V E R
The date in the video title is a nice touch
2:24 John did the cinnamon challenge in a Crash Course video tho!
I for one am definitely looking forward to the vlogbrothers nostalgia act era, where we go back to the beginning.
"Good morning, John, it's Fri----"
BROTHERHOOD 2.0 CLOTHESLINE
There are few things that give me as big of a dopamine hit as seeing Hank and John interacting in a video. Love you guys
I forgot you used to date your videos but seeing the date in the title filled me with so much nostalgia it was crazy.
Good morning everyone
Makes me sooo happy that this videos has the date in the title!
i just realised i don't think i've ever clicked off a vlogbrothers video due to disinterest... well done team. Been here for ~10 years
My god this video catapulted me back a decade, I started watching in 2009 and all your videos are hugely comforting for me
Now I need a list of all the genres vlogbrothers have done over the years.
I love reunion videos!! 🥹
+
every time!
This video title feels really special to me in particular because October 11th is the day when I first discovered Brotherhood 2.0! I remember because as I was starting to watch the backlog of videos (on the Brotherhood 2.0 website lol), a new video popped up and it was Hank's video about national coming out day, which is Oct. 11.
this video made me giggle, i appreciate the nostalgia vlog.
impressed but not surprised john got them all correct.
The parasocial effect is strong with this video. I feel so attached to Hank and John, like we are old friends. Fun to watch these two guys I like and respect so much.
I loved some of the memories this brought up. I love being a part of this community and can't wait for what the future brings. I started watching when I was in school and now I'm in a place where I was able to pledge to the Book of Good Times Kickstarter. We are all growing up together and I'm so happy to be a part of it. DFTBA!
There's something so wonderful about this and the fact that John really did get it.
This made me realize how old of a Nerdfighter I am (been here since early 2011). Crazy to think I’ve spent half my life watching you guys.
I've been around since Accio Deathly Hallows made it to the front page of TH-cam. I was loosely an adult when that happened and it regularly reminds me that I am in fact, 507 years old. We should have an elder nightfighter secret handshake.
My Pizzamas gear arrived today and it is all fantastic. Also, the Pizza Hoodies are enormous!
The new timeguesser!!
+++
Happy Friday everyone! 🎉
Still can't get over how awesome this is!
Reminds me of when the brothers wrote letters to their high school selves. This is like a letter to their 2007 selves.
I love watching y'all videos so much, it's almost a reason to keep going. Always wishing the best for y'all
Awww this video was so fun. It is much more daunting to do a full vlogbrothers watch through now, but if anyone wants to try, there are some absolute bangers in vlogbrothers' history!
Hi Hank! Hi John!
Here's to another thousand years of vlogbrothers!
The giggles and smiles between you two are an amazing example of strong sibling bonds! Makes me miss my brothers (hi Bob!)
This brought me SO MUCH JOY
Finally saw "turtles all the way" on sleep deprived flight to Toronto and was shocked/delighted by Johns cameo 😂
This is so wholesome for some reason
@01:34 I keep replaying this part of Hank laughing in such a genuine way! It's like pure uncut joy for the soul! 😭
John?
I’ve read every one of both of your books and yet never been as impressed as I am right now
love this
Hank outsmarts himself so that John gets them correct
It's always good to see Hank and John together 😊❤
Hey, i got 10/10 too! Yes!
You guys have the same relationship as me and my brother and we are also your ages. It’s great to see it!
2,200 videos and he didn't miss any of them.
I still love john's sing a magic orchestra
I love these two brothers like I love my own family.
What a NICE video! Seeing this just makes me feel... happy. (Thanks for making this.)
[I'm really surprised John got 100%. To miss a couple would be understandable. Wow,
you know your stuff, John! Well done.]
Vlogbrothers Era Tour!
Love seeing you too together!
That was so fun! Very impressed by your memory John. Have fun together!
The vibe in this vid is perfect!
I can’t believe I’ve been watching you guys for so long- I look forward to having this kind of back catalogue with my collaborators today ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Living for the high quality brother content recently
I love it when you guys make videos together!
But you DID do the cinnamon challenge, John, in one of your World History Crash Course videos, because I saw it about 12 times in the years I taught high school world history. Great job not getting those two confused!
i enjoy John's confidence that he was going to get them all right
Great video. Looking forward to the thesaurus one as well.
Nice laptop stickers!
i love john's laugh and i love hank for making john laugh
The closer at the end is just genuine and precious.
This warms my heart
Reunion videos are the best
I so desperately want another nerdcon nerdfighteria for the 20th year anniversary, I have grownup job money now!
A journal is your past self communicating with your present self. It can be nostalgia, but it also always more. The past videos can be nostalgic, but they are also enlightening about how the world and Internet has changed and a great reminder that it will change.
I love the old timey vibe of the video
I get that there are a lot of serious things to talk about these days, but it is nice to see a video like this once in a whilec
Nostalgia acts can happen throughout the lifetime of an entity. Sometimes we can look back on what we've done, without compromising on the future of what we will do. So many excellent year behind us, and so many excellent years to come.
Nostalgia-act wise, brotherhood 2.0 has been one of my favorite things to watch and rewatch again. There was a brotherhood 2.0 on the exact day I was born, meaning I can look back and see what these random guys in a whole other country were thinking about on any day of my life.
So good to See u BOTH together and soooo happy, looks from the outside you r in good spirit - Thank u is Not quite enough, all best wishes
I love how the whole video they're both looking sorta wistfully off to the side. I'm sure it's out the window or something, but it really adds to the nostalgia feel for the video
Seeing you two together is just so wholesome!
John's memory is incredible.
I really enjoyed this one. And John gets an A+.
Yet another category the Green brothers excel at - comfort videos, and seeing you together is like hanging out with family (that I actually like)
So happy about this nostalgia video. I played along and got most of them right!