kxrimxr actually sometimes the fans' promotions is as important as the agency ones. But still if the agency doesn't promote artists they can easely be fogotten by the audiance.
I got a heart attack. I thought f(x) finally made a comeback and I was so exited! guess we still have to wait, but regardless this was really well edited!
Holy shit i actually squealed when i read the title and saw the logo on the thumbnail then saw it's only fanmade 😭😭😭 Great job though!!! You do better than SM ❤
Sydney Travis yeah I guess that’s true because I think all the members are doing separate things. Sulli is just done lol. Victoria is doing a solo I think. Amber is a llama so. Krystal is busy being beautiful. Luna is hanging out with the llama and singing with her vocals.
SM have to be ashamed such a great group like fx is being ignored Anyways I really liked it you did so great I've heard about this MV by fan a lot but it's so much better
Im really surprised when I saw the title but then I read that it was fanmade it made me so sad but guys lets stream this and don't let f(x) be disbanded and so that they will have a comeback 💕 Plus to thank the one who made this. 😊 #f(x)signal 💓
When a fan made fx MV had me clicking on it faster than the speed of light... The thirst for a fx comeback is real and long overdue! Come on SM! Give us a fx comeback!
오징어 이런거 보면 댓글 달아요. 제가 다 일일이 확인하진 못하니까요. 아이유 가을 아침 팬메이드 뮤비가 있는데 가을 아침은 공식 뮤비가 없어요. 근데 팬메이드에 들어가는 영상 소스가 다른 뮤비에서 갖고 온다든지 그런 경우가 많고 제가 말했던 아예 동영상 제목은 '팬메이드'라고 하면 되는데 그런걸 똑바로 언급을 안해서 사람들이 공식 뮤비인 줄 착각하는 사람이 많았어요. 그래서 아이유 뮤비 감독이 자기 동영상을 무단 사용해서 그런식으로 조회수 장사를 하는 것에 불편함을 느끼는 글을 sns상에 올리시기도 했고요. 실제로 그 동영상 조회수는 수백만이 넘었던 걸로 기억합니다. 그게 아니더라도, 이 동영상의 문제는 기업에서만 사용할 수 있는 워터마크(sm마크)를 대놓고 쓴다는 겁니다. 기업 윤리 의식이 없는 분이라는거죠. 직장 경험이 없으신 분이라는걸 알 수 있습니다. 삼성같은데서 저런 짓하면 기업 스파이로 고소감이죠.
I don't even know what to say at this point. I woke up, looked at my phone, and there it was...The announcement that sulli was found dead. I could not believe what I just read and most of all I didn't wanna believe it. I've been their fans since their debut day and I've watched them grow up and I've watched their bad days and their best days and now...I just read something that said one of the members killed themselves. I'm disgusted to the people who are still hating on kpop members and kpop groups. If you didn't notice already famous people have emotions too. Rip angel 💔💖 we love you so much sulli.
*Watches the whole thing* Me: omg I love the song and the MV, I'm so glad they're back, and Sulli too! *Reads the comments* Me: OMFG ITS A FAN MADE VIDEO?!?!?!
I was actually fucking pranked. I legit thought Sulli was back and SM cared again, my heart actually stopped. WhY YOu GOtTA PLaY mE LiKE DiS??!!!!!! MEAN!
Im very sad because I'm reading the other comments the other said f(x) is not real comeback I'm very very very sad 😭 f(x) is not active now I think busy schedule...i miss #sulli😭😭😭😭 we love you @sullichoi@jinrichoi i miss you so much.. 😘😘😘😘😘
I miss them so much I could force myself to believe that this was real. SM what's happening?????? Sulli leaving f(x) is still hard for MeUs & F(x) not being active as a group is harder. 2019, it'll be f(x)'s 10th year anniversary, it wouldn't kill us to expect that by then, we'll be able to see them together again right? It won't be too much to ask right??? MeU's are ready to show and make a periwinkle ocean, our 💜 hearts are still alive. Please make f(x) active again...
![f(x)_에프엑스 “Beautiful Goodbye" [RIP-SULLI] MUSIC_VIDEO](/img/n.gif)
When the fans serve you a better comeback than SM has failed to do for three years.
Rhiannon Edwards so fricken true
SAME OMG
Exactly 👌
You are really really really right.
Also I am very thankful they also included Sulli in this f(x) video...
f(x) fans are doing a better job than SM. Funny but actually sad story...
ameyzinghage we call it irony :')
Damn SM!!!
I clicked so fast thinking SM actually did something for F(x) againㅜㅜ
이사타 same 😱😱
SAME TTT
same :(
Me too
me too 💔
I thought this was real for a minute. The video matches well though.
Same
Same ;-;
The impressive part is how well this avoids using clips from their fx title mvs. Makes it feel authentic
When fans are better at promoting f(x) than SM
kxrimxr lmao true
kxrimxr actually sometimes the fans' promotions is as important as the agency ones. But still if the agency doesn't promote artists they can easely be fogotten by the audiance.
Nadia Honorine Kouzabidila facts
아 뭐야 공식뮤비인 줄 알고 보다가 엥 설리는 왜 나오지? 스엠 미쳤나 하다가 크리스탈 클리오 광고 나오길래 엥? 하고 채널 확인해보니 팬 뮤비였네 ㅋㅋㅋ 완전 속음ㅋㅋ어쩐지 이상한 점이 한 두개도 아니고 화질도 안 좋더라 ㅋㅋ 근데 속을만큼 퀄리티 괜찮음.ㄷㄷ
저도 깜짝놀람 ㅋㅋㄱㄱㄱㅋㄱㄱㅋ
222...입니다
@@jio_oeun 인정요
I'm so desperate for a f(x) comeback :((((
4maybeso im too :'(
me too :((
4maybeso *Yeah we all are :,(*
SM now just focus Red Velvet , no care f(x) and SNSD
Me too!
When SHINee's jonghyun preference: Girls Generation or Red Velvet he chose f(x). 😂 I miss f(x) so much.
king with taste
me too :(
He won’t see their comeback! 😭 ...if sm ever gives them one that is...
@@elkieelkie Nah he watching from above
They were his fav undoubtedly
이제껏 본 팬뮤비 중에 젤 맘에 듦ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
let's stream hard like it's a real comeback.
KiMiNiie I'm as inspirit and pinkpanda will be help 😊😊
꼴따당 thats why she/he said "like it is a real mv"
KiMiNiie 😂😂😂😂 lol let's stream and vote for them pls😂😂😂😂
why do i fee so bittering reading your comment even tho I am not a MeU
HAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA
이거 그냥 팬이 만든건데ㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄲㅋㄱㅋㅋ
광고랑 단콘 비디오 짜집기로 만든거잖아ㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱ 잘만들었네
My goodness, i thought this is comeback with or just f(x) project.
My heeaarrttt T^T
Din l this is not a comeback?
Let's wait for The snowball no. Only fans MV
When SM won't give us a f(x) moment so we MeU's have to do it ourself
f(x) has some of the most well rounded albums out of idol groups
컴백하는 줄 알고 기뻐했다...
*THIS MAKES ME CRY :,(*
Rest in peace SULLI. Our beautiful Jin Ri. My bias I cant believe this.
soshi stars why
soshi stars me too(;´༎ຶД༎ຶ`)
Alexis Collins *Because they're no longer active and when I saw this I thought for a second that they were coming back but no :,(.*
soshi stars Why aren't they active?
Alexis Collins *They're busy with individual schedules plus SM (their label) isn't clearly supporting them to comeback anytime soon.*
I got a heart attack. I thought f(x) finally made a comeback and I was so exited! guess we still have to wait, but regardless this was really well edited!
Mayu for real me too😭😭😭😭
Mayu
I EVEN FREAKED OUT BECAUSE SULLI WAS THERE
I thought Sulli came back to the group
@@erikat.6683 XD
The best fanmade video ever
하도 안보내주니깐 진짜 팬들 대단하시다 초고퀄이야진짜
아ㅋㅋㅋ컴백인줄ㅋㅋㅋ근데 알고보니 팬분이 만드신거네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
아름씌 팬이 만든거라구요???? 퀄 오졋다
The quality of this MV is no joking. So niceee
when you're starving for new content so you take matters into your own hands and make one yourself.
썸네일 진짜 시그널 노래 그 자체 뮤비 속 한장면 같아서 사랑해,,
f(x)で一番好きな曲
TT I'm shocked and excited when I just saw the title of this video!!! Please let f(x) comeback,SM...
What a great fanmade MV for an amazing song of f(x)
we should make this viral!! sm won'r resist money. if this go viral maybe sm will make f(x) comeback
Lazy Cate yes please...
미친 컴백인줄알았잖아
ㅇㅈㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ하긴 4주전에 나온걸 내가 모를 일 없지...
컴백인줄...
나도 낚임;썅 설리 나오길래 다시들어갔나 했네 ㅋㅋㅋ
정재은 ㅇㅈ 저도 ㅜㅠ
@@user-to6is6oh2o ㅋㅋㅋ
2집 핑크테이프에서 가장 좋아하는 곡 💜
This is how much MeU's miss f(x) we start making our own comebacks
Super great job!!! But this is making me too emotional...😢
This is so good, you took a time to do this and I appreciate it, congratulations!
Sm보다 일 잘한닼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
진짜 오랜만에 새로운 뮤비라 허둥지둥 들어옴;
컴백인줄..
ㅇㅈㅇㅈㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
"Better than SMㅋㅋㅋ" Well, Agreed
Still relevant in 2023 ✨
Holy shit i actually squealed when i read the title and saw the logo on the thumbnail then saw it's only fanmade 😭😭😭
Great job though!!! You do better than SM ❤
I thought F(X) HAVE ANOTHER FREAKING COMEBACK
this is a pink tape song lol, anyway, i miss them :(
Mystic A
AND SULLI WAS THERE
I thought we got OT5 back
이정도 시간이엿으면 만족하셧자나요 ㅠ..
제발루 컴백쩜
진짜 다들 너무 이쁘고 잘생겼다... 뮤비도 딱 에프엑스 특유의 그 느낌나서 좋고.. 유후 설리 장발에 웨이브 넣은거 너무 짱짱.... 다들 요즘 미모 물 오르신😄😄😄
You know that fans have been long waiting for a comeback when even a fanmade MV reaches more than a million views in a short span of time
And it's higher than their individual members' official mv views. Lol
I wish this was real.😭❤
ChaesMe Xx its not?
ትንሽ የጨፍር ልጅ እሷ እንደምትወድ ታውቅ ነበር it's a fan made
Someone send this to amber
This has a million views people miss them doesn’t SM knowwww
David Dacus they SHOULD know
David Dacus SM is actually not the problem for once. It's f(x)
Sydney Travis yeah I guess that’s true because I think all the members are doing separate things. Sulli is just done lol. Victoria is doing a solo I think. Amber is a llama so. Krystal is busy being beautiful. Luna is hanging out with the llama and singing with her vocals.
David Dacus no all the members says that is the SM. They also want a comeback
I thought I missed it because it said 1 week ago this almost made me have a heart attack
pepinito 123 ditto, I was shook when I saw this on my recommendation
missing f(x) a lot lately
honestly
이거 진짜 띵곡이야 아직도 핑테 들으면 설렌다
순간 온몸에 전율 개돌았는데...이럴수가..... 고퀄....이면서 눈물난다....스엠 미유말려죽이기....
쑥 쑥 인정..ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 얼마나 스엠이 함수 컴백 안시켜줬으면 하다하다 팬이 만들어줬낰ㅋㅋㅋㄴ
It hurts to know that this isn't a real comeback 😭
컴백인줄 알았자나 ㅅㅍㅠㅠㅠ 설리얼굴보고 읭? ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 3년동안 썩히지 어떻게
Thank you for the video! ❤️
And Sulli is here, I'm so glad! ❤️
I wish they're all happy and healthy... ❤️
Miss f(x) so bad ❤️
Have a good day! ❤️
Sulli 😓
스엠에서 씨그널 노래 뮤비 다시 만들었나 하고 봤다가 첨에 그런 밤 나오자마자 팬뮤비인걸 알아버려따.... 컴백 언제하니ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
BEST SONG ON THE PINK TAPE THANK YOU FOR THIS OML
This is so gorgeous!! Thank you so much for making this, I miss the queens so much 💕💕💕💕
Maritza Jauregui-Wells
SULLI WAS THERE!
I got so confused. I thought she came back to the group
at first i think fx have comeback, but i choked when look sulli in this mv.. it's really good i love this :"
RIP sulli u r such an angel we will miss you
나만 이거 ㅜㅜ 좋아했냐고
My f(5) feels
It would be such a grand comeback if Sulli was put back in f(x) I wouldn't mind the wait at all
잘만들어따 옛날 건줄 알고 에펙 뮤비 잘뽑았네 이랬는데 ㅠ 에펙 왜 컴백 안하나여ㅠ
그 스엠 개××가 레드벨벳만 밀어주고 있어서 함수니 언니들이 컴백 못하는거에요
I have a dream that f(x) drop unexpected MV comeback, but that day doesn’t come yet 😌
#missfx
Tony Chopper i mean all four of them are doing their own thing right now
Tony Chopper same dude
this song is for the soul…
지금 들어도 좋다..✨
I thought f(x) comeback
Zaraku Raku me too😔 if just they come back
SM have to be ashamed such a great group like fx is being ignored
Anyways I really liked it you did so great I've heard about this MV by fan a lot but it's so much better
this is fanmade video 😢 i miss u f(x)
Missing my babies f(x) 😭
Im really surprised when I saw the title but then I read that it was fanmade it made me so sad but guys lets stream this and don't let f(x) be disbanded and so that they will have a comeback 💕 Plus to thank the one who made this. 😊 #f(x)signal 💓
Xxx
GOD DAMMIT I FELL FOR IT!😭😭
.... Still a nice video dude
아뭐야 신곡인줄알앗따 ㅠㅠ 제발 컴백 ㅠㅠㅠ
That was great. f(x) for life!
wowwww. this views mv fanmade... you see SM we miss f(x) rn.
Fakhriyah Annisa miss so bad .. ot 5 ❤
When a fan made fx MV had me clicking on it faster than the speed of light... The thirst for a fx comeback is real and long overdue! Come on SM! Give us a fx comeback!
되게 잘 만드셨네요. 가끔 진짜 뮤비 줄 알고 속아 보면 짜증나는데 이건 감탄하고 갑니다.
*IMAGINE THEY REAL COMEBACK HOW THEY WILL SNATCH ALL WIGS UP*
also i miss my Sulli’ssi it’s always OT5
👏🏻😭💜
진심 컴백인 줄 알았자나!!근데 갑자기 처음에 클리오 나오고 설리 나와서 왓??!!
Victoria💜Amber💜Luna💜Sulli💜Krystal💜
Sulli 😢
"Sulli" i am not crying
I love 😍 you so much Sulli ..She's Solo Goblin is so amazing and awesome.. I always support her..
It's such a shame with what happened, there's never gonna be a comeback with Sulli again...
@@cherryice4603
rip sulli 😢
Im sure SM is going to offer you a job oh my god you are so tallented!!!!!
Thank youuuuuu MiU appreciate it♥️
Sm공식 계정이 아니여서 편집해서 만드신 것 같네요
잘 만들고는 둘째치고 팬메이드인데 교묘하게 제목을 공식처럼 쓴다던지 섬네일을 공식처럼 편집한다던지해서 혼동이 오게하는데, 댁들은 팬심이라고 쉴드칠지 모르지만 당사자 입장에선 저작권+조회수 뺏어가는 얌체짓이에요. 이게 수록곡이라 뮤비가 없다 하더라도 엄연히 유투브에서 음원서비스를 하는데 이러면 안되죠.
오징어 이런거 보면 댓글 달아요. 제가 다 일일이 확인하진 못하니까요. 아이유 가을 아침 팬메이드 뮤비가 있는데 가을 아침은 공식 뮤비가 없어요. 근데 팬메이드에 들어가는 영상 소스가 다른 뮤비에서 갖고 온다든지 그런 경우가 많고 제가 말했던 아예 동영상 제목은 '팬메이드'라고 하면 되는데 그런걸 똑바로 언급을 안해서 사람들이 공식 뮤비인 줄 착각하는 사람이 많았어요. 그래서 아이유 뮤비 감독이 자기 동영상을 무단 사용해서 그런식으로 조회수 장사를 하는 것에 불편함을 느끼는 글을 sns상에 올리시기도 했고요. 실제로 그 동영상 조회수는 수백만이 넘었던 걸로 기억합니다. 그게 아니더라도, 이 동영상의 문제는 기업에서만 사용할 수 있는 워터마크(sm마크)를 대놓고 쓴다는 겁니다. 기업 윤리 의식이 없는 분이라는거죠. 직장 경험이 없으신 분이라는걸 알 수 있습니다. 삼성같은데서 저런 짓하면 기업 스파이로 고소감이죠.
정말 공감하는부분...특히 앞에 FMV하나만 붙여도 되는데 그것조차 안하죠. 제가 더 화나는 건 따로 있는데 뮤비 공개 되었을 때 본인 채널로 고대로 재업로드해서 조회수 분산시키는 사람들이죠. 대부분 해외팬분들은 잘 모르니까 더 문제..
저도 공식인줄알고 와! 하면서 들어왔는데...슬프다
Damn so well made.
I don't even know what to say at this point. I woke up, looked at my phone, and there it was...The announcement that sulli was found dead. I could not believe what I just read and most of all I didn't wanna believe it. I've been their fans since their debut day and I've watched them grow up and I've watched their bad days and their best days and now...I just read something that said one of the members killed themselves. I'm disgusted to the people who are still hating on kpop members and kpop groups. If you didn't notice already famous people have emotions too.
Rip angel 💔💖 we love you so much sulli.
rip sulli, you were so young.. 💗
I thought SM did something good this time and I thought F(x) made a comeback but it’s a fanmade! 😭
We do not wait for SM. We make our girls their own comback. 👌
*Watches the whole thing*
Me: omg I love the song and the MV, I'm so glad they're back, and Sulli too!
*Reads the comments*
Me: OMFG ITS A FAN MADE VIDEO?!?!?!
I thought it was real...I thought Sulli came back Huhuhuhu 💕💗💗 im loving this video looks real💕💕💕😍
remember when whe thought it was an actual mv that's how desperate we are.. *cries*
Let's think that it's the comeback that we wait for a long time, guys
I'm crying, I miss them so so much ;(
Andy me too..
노래 진짜 좋다 ㅜㅜ
one of the best fanmade music videos I've seen in my whole life
Can you actually feed me more Luna in this video? As much as I appreciate and love this, there was only like
Hey.. You watch Sulli solo it was fantastic..
I was actually fucking pranked. I legit thought Sulli was back and SM cared again, my heart actually stopped. WhY YOu GOtTA PLaY mE LiKE DiS??!!!!!! MEAN!
SM could never. This more looks like an official video tbh. Good job!
I legit screamed this looks so good and just their style omggg
This made me cry bc I miss f(x) so fucking bad I hate SM so much 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔.
Yeeesss f(x) is back...my idol sulli your so beautiful I miss you sulli and also f(x)...I love you #sulli
Im very sad because I'm reading the other comments the other said f(x) is not real comeback I'm very very very sad 😭 f(x) is not active now I think busy schedule...i miss #sulli😭😭😭😭 we love you @sullichoi@jinrichoi i miss you so much.. 😘😘😘😘😘
the perfect fanmade MV ever！
I love your editing 😍
Omg f(x) and smtown should see this video, so well dooooooone, love it so much ❤️
It’s better than a lot of kpop MV !!!!!!
I realised the mvs u made for f(x) are always the more views among all!!!! MeU are already very desperate for f(x) comeback SM!!!!
I miss them so much I could force myself to believe that this was real. SM what's happening?????? Sulli leaving f(x) is still hard for MeUs & F(x) not being active as a group is harder. 2019, it'll be f(x)'s 10th year anniversary, it wouldn't kill us to expect that by then, we'll be able to see them together again right? It won't be too much to ask right??? MeU's are ready to show and make a periwinkle ocean, our 💜 hearts are still alive. Please make f(x) active again...