@@cole3243 Idc, I always separate art from artist. I don't like the Christina version and I don't like her either lol. Instead of lesser of two evils I choose lesser of bad sounds.
when ARTPOP came out i was in middle school bullied for being gay on a daily basis. it was hard to go to school but listening to this album literally saved my life. this album taught me so many things about myself and i will forever be thankful for that.
I genuinely started to tear up towards the end. This album was my teenhood. I remember the day Aura leaked, Applause then Swine… Even Venus I believe. I was lucky enough to go to Swinefest & it’s one of the best shows I’ve ever been to, including her big arena shows. It was the last time I remember feeling so close to Gaga, after ARTPOP, she wasn’t the same, and I don’t blame her. The fans, the media, her own management…. ARTPOP FOREVER
Girl I cried editing it. The part at the end really got me cause you can FEEL her emotion in that album and she’s describing everything she was going through. It’s incredible and I don’t think anything like it will ever happen again.
This entirely. I have a little hope for a similar version in the future though, should Gaga ever want to. Technology has come a long way and so has she. If anyone can recreate this kind of immersion, it's Gaga. But only if her heart and health were over a thousand percent in it.
To me. ARTPOP was her highest she ever got. It ripped the world and no one knew what to do. If we get act 2 I personally do not care if it is a terrible album. I just want it. I want every bleeding moment of it!
Artpop is a really good album, it's a shame it was overshadowed by all of that media frenzy. It was a bad time for her life as well, in her personal life. I'm glad she's happier now
. Applause sounded like a song from Sesame Street by the Count Dracula puppet. Applause, applause, appplause, pppppplause, plause. Just repeat and repeat like a puppet.
Can I just say how beautifully this video was constructed and edited? The transitions, the visuals, the hours and hours of research and dedication is amazing and I’m in complete awe. Thank you Jake, for this album never got the appreciation and respect it deserved until just recently and even then, most of the world won’t even know how much time and energy it took create such a masterpiece
Actually, the vomit show was really about her wanting to make people feel disgust and shame like she felt when she was r* worded. She explains it in another interview what the true intentions was, it was much deeper than what she said in that interview you showed.
@melpot4296 I believe what the original comment says, but I don't believe that vomiting is the answer. If Gaga had just said she had a horrific experience, that would have touched the hearts of more people who were in the same position. That would have helped many. Instead, the conversation was about vomit. Opportunity missed.
@@BombshElle_7yes and no, it was very much a metaphor and that time of pop culture was about pushing the boundaries right past the limit, literally everyone was doing insane things, Gaga’s just really good at selecting the ones that’ll garner the biggest reactions. But coming forward about SA in a pre-MeToo world, that was a death sentence, and given that she is Gaga, how sexual her work was viewed already, they would’ve said, “look how you dress/perform, what did you expect? You were asking for it. Honestly surprised it took this long for someone to do so,” 10000%. And I know this because they said this about other, less “controversial” women coming forward about their SA experiences. Or they’d say you’re lying or exaggerating or it’s just part of the business. Most of her fans might’ve stood by her but the industry side wouldn’t have. So while I found the v**** artist to give a visceral reaction (also, that’s incredibly unhealthy, I hope her teeth and esophagus are okay today), it did exactly what it was intended to do because we’re STILL talking about it a decade later.
Off topic, but why can’t we say certain words or phrases on TH-cam. Time for me to be a “Trump Dump,” THIS IS AMERICA, LAND OF FREE SPEECH. Meaning, I CAN SAY WHATEVER I WANT TO SAY, HOW I WANT TO SAY IT, WHERE, WHEN, and WHY.
Artpop came at the wrong time for me. I was so obsessed with The Fame era and when Born this way came out, I felt let down as I did not enjoy any of it. Artpop was exactly what I was expecting her to release when she released Born this way. So when it did come around, my interest had already waned. I’m glad I revisited it a few years later because it is definitely one of my favorites now.
what made you dislike the Born This Way era? That's when I become a huge fan but I know a lot of people who enjoyed her Fame era didn't like the BTW one. She lost a lot of fans and people thought it was just too "weird" and dark😭😭😭
I didn't understand Gaga in Born This way but I was in love.. I just love her art. Same as Joanne then I started loving it, I feel I can get close to her through her art.
Greetings from Indonesia. I was 17 when the tour was cancelled and was very upset that my people - called “the extremist” would do such unimportance public movement against her tour. That was a truly crazy moment. I defended her back then in a live news show on TV through a phonecall but it was a huge heartbreak for us as Indonesian little monsters still. Gladly I made to Europe to see her live in the Chromatica Ball!! Anyway, thank you for delivering a heartfelt deep dive documentary of this masterpiece. We are still awaiting for these unreleased projects for sure but we believe in her own wellbeing upon this project. Love from Jakarta-a-a!
It's crazy they wished death upon a woman for her lyrics and looks that's just insane I feel bad for the fans hlwho we're so excited probably saved up to see her just to not be able to because her safety was in danger. I still myself would love to see her performing live.
at the same time itu aslina era era peak fpi like. 😭😭 idk what would be their equivalent in other countries (in terms of sheer force and power alone) tapi sampe sekarang aja w masih trauma gak berani makan di luar pas bulan puasa, saking parnonya digrebeg dan diseret keluar. 🥲
@@thecinemawithjames recently he posted something saying not to ask hum about ACT II, saying he's finished or something. Maybe Gaga really doesn't want it to be released 🙁
@@eduag7 noooo he posted the blue gazing ball said this same time next year I will delete the post and give y'all something special it's on the tenth anniversary what else could that mean he's the main producer on that album him and Gaga know the most about it Gaga just finished filming joker I'm certain she will announce it herself come August for Applause tenth anniversary same way she announced it ten years ago except it'll be a re-release similar to btw but we're getting Act 2. I know we are DJWS wouldn't say something like that making us wait a whole extra year just for the anniversary to give us like one song after we have awaiting to hear act two for ten years I'm certain it's coming EDM seems to be making a comeback in the mainstream
ARTPOP is so bittersweet for me. I adore the album itself and sometimes it even rivals Born This Way for my favorite Gaga album overall, yet sometimes it truly feels like this was the last time I saw the Lady Gaga I fell in love with in 2009. I even met her during the tour. Still such a surreal experience to me. It truly feels like she has never been the same since. One could hardly blame her for the hell the media put her through during that time. This album will always be so special to me. I even got a matching tattoo on my left wrist just like she has for the first anniversary in 2014. ARTPOP forever.
yep, everything following artpop... shes like on another level. my teen self related so closely to her, but now, not so much. i'm no longer watching her as much as I used to when I was younger. it's like we've all grown up
@@tryingnot2bdumbi agree with them and I can explain, i don’t know if I’ll speak for everyone but from my point of view it was like this : I was a fan of lady Gaga not only because she was eccentric and a really good artist, it was the art behind the songs … I couldn’t explain it very well but when a gaga song dropped and you listened to it it had a meaning, with the video clip it had even more depth and once she spoke about her art, you would be proved wrong or right and it was ALWAYS such a statement I mean just look at Born this way / You and I / Judas / and Alejandro on my god, this one was really special … etc … Some of her song were just pure art and it’s why it’s hard to explain because Gaga is her art, a living canvas and to me she lost her edge / her it factor but not totally I would say …Chromatica surprised me quite a bit especially with Babylon it was a fresh album but still missing the « old » lady Gaga vibe that I think she might have left behind because it might have been the hardest thing to keep up, to out do yourself every time, to satisfy a fan base that can be really hard on her sometimes even with all the love, but the hate from the press and the people who don’t get what taking a risk means… You know they would bash her for days and she was really the target EVERYONE loved to talk about and disrespect because it was her, and specifically her because it was fun to « not get it » to them. In short she’s still our lady Gaga but we look at her old era like a diamond because at THAT specific time she did what no one would even DARE to do and today it’s like « who will be the most trashy for the art of it » but not successfully doing it … Only Tyler The Creator to me has that Gaga vibe today, and I’m not even a fan of him but you must admit he’s dedicated to his art ! Hope that made some sense :’D
Being a part of Gaga history will always be my greatest life achievement. The Aura leak was one of the best nights of my life… the fact that Gaga saw it and let us preview GUY, Mary Jane Holland, and the title track ARTPOP because of our Aura reactions… that was the ultimate moment of being a fan.
As someone who's just became a GAGA fan and was curious about the controversy around this album, thank you for making this. What a fantastic video. The world wasnt ready for this album.
I was at the concert where she broke her hip in Montreal and we had met her briefly when she pulled into the venue prior to the show. It’s something I will never forget!!
11:50 as a fellow Indonesian little monsters, that tragedy completely destroyed me…I was so ashamed and embarrassed that a mere satanic panic and blind hatred could be a fuel for them to protest her tour. They were so quick to conclude she was a demon worshipper/illuminati and those religious organization justifying the hatred so easily. It’s really putting a bad name for us until now even after the religious organization was disbanded. I just wish she acknowledged that Indonesian little monsters still love her and hoping she would visit us one day
what a great documentary, with respect, harsh truth and the full circle of the mystery, which ironically will never be fully circled. that's why she is a living art piece and i believe people will talk more about that project. sometimes the story has no end.. if you know, you know.
I remember the whole protest of her upcoming concert here in Indonesia... IT WAS RIDICULOUS. Let me tell you those religious people were not holy themselves at all. The things they do behind closed doors to innocent people are sick, way worse than what they deemed Lady Gaga could ever do or "spread" through her concert. It's insane how corrupt those leader/religious figures are. I am so bummed she's basically blacklisted from this country.
Artpop is phenomenal. I can't listen to that album without dancing like a psycho. It immediately empowers me and makes me feel so positive. Some people say it was overproduced, overdramatic but...was it?
Can I just say something slightly reductive; if this album wasn't delayed by a year it would've been a commercial success. Gaga's mega success was largely due to her extreme factor not wearing out when she allowed no room between major album releases.
I totally agree! I think she would have had the continued exponential climb after BTW. It was a tragedy that she was injured but it is just good that she can still do as she wants. That was a serious break. She is very fortunate, and Im grateful it all worked out anyway, and she rebounded. ARTPOP gets her flowers now!
I think her being able to break that work cycle and have more freedom in frequency of releases has been healthier for her well being in the long run, though
Why did I write my final paper in Gender, Race, and Pop Culture on the Burqa controversy??? My teacher was also as big a stan as me and gave me an A even though I think he knew I barely had to do additional research… Hay Professor Kizer! Won’t be surprised if you are in these comments too lol
I really hope DJ White Shadow keeps fighting for ARTPOP. He’s literally all we got to make it happen and I hope Gaga recognizes the power that album has on us. Such a masterpiece. I just hope we get something
@@nolaray1062 he got jumped on by fans for no reason and i guess he couldn't handle all this hate which obviously makes sense i really think he doesnt mean those words since it was a moment of anger or sadness most likely.
@@nolaray1062 found this while looking in the comments. 'DJWS deleted his post and had to clarify under a gay news site article (GayTimes) that he wasn’t making a statement about the second act’s future, but was not wanting to talk solely about ARTPOP. He he has worked on other projects and is buzzed about act 2 literally every day'
Never knew about Artpop’s controversy but I’m officially joining the standom! She’s is so fiercely independent and always pushing the envelope a true Artiste! Love Gaga! 💕
This is the only channel I regularly noticing getting unsubscribed from? I swear, I’ve subbed like three times at this point. Thank gawd y’all are putting out the kind of videos I want to see, the algorithm HAS to acknowledge you
The whole ARTPOP era were such a joyful, happy, crazy, misterious and dark experience by all of the things that were taking place all at once, but all i got to say is that i got blessed by witnessing it. I'll always cheer and defend this album with my entire being.
This was great but there’s a few things that were a bit off. Gaga was millions in debt for the first run of the Monster Ball because she was supposed to have teamed up with Kanye West to help alleviate the cost. That didn’t work out, but she made it back with enough money to revamp the tour. That wasn’t the creator of Minecraft in G.U.Y., he was a content creator that Gaga found after a Minecraft parody of Applause was uploaded. Lastly, DJWS deleted his post and had to clarify under a gay news site article (GayTimes) that he wasn’t making a statement about the second act’s future, but was not wanting to talk solely about ARTPOP. He he has worked on other projects and is buzzed about act 2 literally every day. Man needs a break.
Well done. Been sick, so long videos are helping me stay distracted. I always had love for this album, but was aware of how sloppy it was. But I wasn’t aware of her personal struggles until I got older; so this project means something different now.
Wow! I read this comment and wanted to listen to this track. 2 hours later: this is my favourite Lady Gaga song too! 😂 I have no clue why this is not as popular as freaking paparazzi
Thank you for featuring Radio ARTPOP, my little show that could ❤ Apologies to the fans who want the episodes back on TH-cam, I've had to remove most of them for work.
I dealt with severe depression during the ARTPOP era - a kind of sharp and pervasive emptiness that I still struggle to describe and make sense of. Listening to that album, going to the ARTrave, and witnessing so much of the sadness and rage of that era….it all felt like I was being understood. And so I come back to that album and enjoy it year after year because you have to honor your experiences. All of them. Like Kesha said, “Our scars make us who we are.”
I'll admit I became a monster later (2020) just because I was too preoccupied with boybands, but Artpop is literally the reason why I took a deeper dive into her career and discography (album got me through the 'Pan Dulce' tbh). I heard Swine and immediately fell in love with the production. Went looking for the rest of the album, been hooked since. This deep dive is something I didn't expect, but as always, you came through & killed it 🫶
Artpop is my favorite album ever. Like I would play her iTunes festival performance twice a day before the full album came out cuz it was the only way to hear the songs. It was the first tour of hers that I saw too. I’m still kinda sad that Venus didn’t get its own space adventure video, and that Brooklyn Nights didn’t make it on (but Jewels n Drugs did smh). But I still adore this album and wish we could’ve seen Gaga’s full vision for it. Then again, I understand that she was having such a hard time during that album and may not wanna revisit it again for Act II or something.
Jewels N Drugs is actually a pretty good song, only the ending of Twista's part became a bit messy. I'm sure if it wouldve been a unreleased song like Cake Like Lady Gaga (which is great too) EVERYONE wouldve been obsessed with it. Don't deny it.
"Thank you for celebrating something that felt like destruction" Ohh that just makes me love it even more, in spite of all the faces and "Really?"s I've gotten when I've said "fuck yeah Artpop is my favorite Gaga album!"
It’s crazy reading these comments and seeing everyone praise this album, because when it first came out and years after, all I ever saw was people talking shit about it and how terrible of an album it is. I was a huge Gaga fan before and after this album, I always felt bad for how this era played out for her and I still listen to artpop to this day! I wish we could go back in time and fix it so the album could play out exactly how she wanted it to (with the exception of DWYW and Terry.) cuz she most definitely has not been the same since this album. But then again, she probably needed this experience to open her eyes to how things were playing out in her life and humble her a bit.
I think it goes to show that 1) media controls the narrative 2) sheep will follow the herd even if they're secretly rockin' out to the song in their bedroom :p 3) that the most outspoken are the haters. Several million haters sounds like a lot until you realize just how many hundreds of millions of fans she has. I don't think I knew a single person who didn't adore the album, Miley Cyrus on the other hand... 😅
I dont understand how Gaga even entertained "Do What You Want" with R Kelly and for the video being so bad. Love Gaga, but this perplexes me.. I dont understand.
She said that she was in a dark place and that she wanted to make people upset. She apologized and pulled it in 2019 after apologizing to the victims of R. Kelly. Some of them spoke out and thanked her for her apology.
ARTPOP is completely misunderstood in it's time, it's chaotic, a war of everyone, a party, a drug, an experiment at is finest and a pain. If ARTPOP ACT 2 is set to be released (even tho djws didn't want to talk about it anymore) it needs to be loved, respect and make it feel that it's understood from the first day. JUSTICE FOR ARTPOP 🔵✨
What an amazing video. Wonderful edition, you really did a great research omg. I'm one of those monsters that did fight all the internet defending ARTPOP, but dang here I discovered so many things and stuff said about that era that I didn't know for all these time. Spectacular work
I watched this so many times and I just wanna cry. So many little monsters stood by this album and This does give me hope for ACT 2. I really hope she worked with DJWS secretly to do the touchups for the second act. I’m sitting at the edge of my seat for this piece of art that never really got its recognition it really deserved.
Hearing “Princess Di” live as a 16 year old was something I didn’t understand, if I heard it now, I would completely understand. I remember crying the entire time during the whole performance, she gave in the show was so heartfelt we knew she worked so hard. I didn’t know she was in pain at the time and she didn’t show it. She gave us everything she knew we would love and we will always love her for the love she gives to us.
Artpop made me feel all sorts of things. Disgust, happiness, inspired, etc. It was truly a representation of herself at that time. I didn't like everything about the era, but I love/respect it as the artistic expression it is and what it did for me.
I don't know why people are so weird about this album. Venus, Donatella, Manicure, SexxxDreams, Swine, and even Jewels and Drugs are bops. I don't think I will ever get tired of the first three songs on that list.
I felt emotional when I saw DJ White Shadow's post at the very end of the video... It's just some text on a colourful background but it feels like the door of a vault sealing forever, and the vault is full of potential, ambitions, hardship, tears, and broken dreams... But I feel like the Artpop album itself, what was released, escaped the vault just before the doors shut. Because in recent years so many people, including myself, have given it a second chance into their hearts and started to appreciate it for the cultural moment it was. So now there is some justice for their work on it, and thankfully Gaga made it through and has had 4 number one albums since.
I love all the artpop youtube documentaries! Spread the word of this brilliant record Such a brilliant album, and it was so misunderstood Love it with all my heart
Ngl im kinda glad that they decided to leave Lady Gaga off of Dont Kill My Vibe Love her but she didnt really fit the vibe of the song like yeah it was bad, i fully agree 😭 But had no idea artpop had so much controversy
SOOOOOO fascinating. Why do I love watching videos about things I have no/little clue about? Gonna listen to this whole album tomorrow!! She is truly an artist, so talented me honestly has given a voice to so many things that are wrong with that industry behind the scenes. LOUDLY!! So we’ll executed and your editing is NEXT LEVEL! 🤯
I saw the artpop rave tour twice! Once in NYC and once in Philadelphia….it felt like a burst of color after a dark period…I enjoyed the show I even painted Gaga an abstract painting with a real seashell in the center and one of her dancers picked it up on stage and danced it all the way to the back. I always wonder what happened to this painting inspired by artpop :)
Art Pop is really ahead of its time, even after her other albums. Lady Gaga has always stepped outside the box which no other artist has done, at least not at her level creatively
Artpop is so important to me, It came out while I was still struggling with my own sexuality, I was 12/13 years old, I used to be a "huge little monster" but I stopped due to religion stuff, my mom infecting my brain with catholic bs for years, all of that was ERASED when I saw Gaga performing Applause during the VMAs, I got so obsessed about it that it reconverted me into being gay, it truly set me free, y'all ARTPOP ERA saved my life
Artpop and Mariahs Glitter are two albums that flopped but I enjoyed and appreciated when they came out! But they still both went Platinum some artists never go platinum in their whole careers!
Go to my sponsor aura.com/deepdive to get a 14 day free trial and see if your
personal information has been leaked online
we need one of the flop JOANNE
Please do a video exposing how Justin Beiber plays the role of the Weeknd!! (Serious request)
Wow this was 👍 good. Great channel. Great documentation & visuals.
@@KtCleansAlot popppoooppo😮😊 pooooooo oo
@@KtCleansAlot yesssssss👁️👁️👌🏽
The fact that she almost performed this album in space, but couldn’t for safety purposes is iconic
i heard of that a couple of years ago that’s such a queen move
Not really, she's an old lady now.
@@rydz65638 aint old lmao she ain't dust with silicone like cher! 😂
Old really??? I dispare
@@rydz656 She's not. And even if she was, it doesn't matter. Talent never gets old c:
Please don't ever delete this video ♥ This is history. This is what 2013 was.
I love do what u want I don’t sing Kelly’s verse but I love it
@@cole3243 Idc, I always separate art from artist. I don't like the Christina version and I don't like her either lol. Instead of lesser of two evils I choose lesser of bad sounds.
@@areudivaidc what anyone says this is so cringe 😂
“maybe her hip was torn this way” 5:12 was so out of pocket 💀
☠️☠️☠️
i gasped
Out of socket.
@@NunyJr pls 😭
It was an ass surgery.
when ARTPOP came out i was in middle school bullied for being gay on a daily basis. it was hard to go to school but listening to this album literally saved my life. this album taught me so many things about myself and i will forever be thankful for that.
Me 2
same here !
you're not alone, and neither are those going through that (still) right now
I genuinely started to tear up towards the end. This album was my teenhood. I remember the day Aura leaked, Applause then Swine… Even Venus I believe. I was lucky enough to go to Swinefest & it’s one of the best shows I’ve ever been to, including her big arena shows. It was the last time I remember feeling so close to Gaga, after ARTPOP, she wasn’t the same, and I don’t blame her. The fans, the media, her own management…. ARTPOP FOREVER
Girl I cried editing it. The part at the end really got me cause you can FEEL her emotion in that album and she’s describing everything she was going through. It’s incredible and I don’t think anything like it will ever happen again.
I remember when Aura leaked and it was called Birca 😭 I knew the album was going to be AHEAD OF ITS TIME !
This entirely. I have a little hope for a similar version in the future though, should Gaga ever want to. Technology has come a long way and so has she. If anyone can recreate this kind of immersion, it's Gaga. But only if her heart and health were over a thousand percent in it.
A fuckin men
ARTPOP FOREVER!!!!!
To me. ARTPOP was her highest she ever got. It ripped the world and no one knew what to do. If we get act 2 I personally do not care if it is a terrible album. I just want it. I want every bleeding moment of it!
I want it to. I would pay a hitman to get me that damn album.
AGREED😊
ARTPOP😢❤
I think act 2 should be out of the publics hand since the view is already distorted and it will be just sinister and rude.
Sadly it confirmed by the producer that no more act II
Artpop is a really good album, it's a shame it was overshadowed by all of that media frenzy. It was a bad time for her life as well, in her personal life. I'm glad she's happier now
Yas babe
. Applause sounded like a song from Sesame Street by the Count Dracula puppet. Applause, applause, appplause, pppppplause, plause. Just repeat and repeat like a puppet.
@@eduardochavacanoYou sure only focus on applause huh? The whole album is good, we all know it
This!!
@@maxim_vogelyour pfp and the fact that you agree with this comment makes me believe you’re super cool
Can I just say how beautifully this video was constructed and edited? The transitions, the visuals, the hours and hours of research and dedication is amazing and I’m in complete awe. Thank you Jake, for this album never got the appreciation and respect it deserved until just recently and even then, most of the world won’t even know how much time and energy it took create such a masterpiece
this is FANTASTIC;
please do one for every of her eras, especially The Fame
Yes this!
Yes...I want this for Britney too
Britney Spears too please
PLEASE go through Gaga’s eras! I agree, there’s so much to say
Yesss please all eras
Actually, the vomit show was really about her wanting to make people feel disgust and shame like she felt when she was r* worded. She explains it in another interview what the true intentions was, it was much deeper than what she said in that interview you showed.
Sure it was 😂
@@Void_1984 obviously you dont do your research either🙄
@melpot4296 I believe what the original comment says, but I don't believe that vomiting is the answer. If Gaga had just said she had a horrific experience, that would have touched the hearts of more people who were in the same position. That would have helped many. Instead, the conversation was about vomit. Opportunity missed.
@@BombshElle_7yes and no, it was very much a metaphor and that time of pop culture was about pushing the boundaries right past the limit, literally everyone was doing insane things, Gaga’s just really good at selecting the ones that’ll garner the biggest reactions. But coming forward about SA in a pre-MeToo world, that was a death sentence, and given that she is Gaga, how sexual her work was viewed already, they would’ve said, “look how you dress/perform, what did you expect? You were asking for it. Honestly surprised it took this long for someone to do so,” 10000%. And I know this because they said this about other, less “controversial” women coming forward about their SA experiences. Or they’d say you’re lying or exaggerating or it’s just part of the business. Most of her fans might’ve stood by her but the industry side wouldn’t have. So while I found the v**** artist to give a visceral reaction (also, that’s incredibly unhealthy, I hope her teeth and esophagus are okay today), it did exactly what it was intended to do because we’re STILL talking about it a decade later.
Off topic, but why can’t we say certain words or phrases on TH-cam. Time for me to be a “Trump Dump,” THIS IS AMERICA, LAND OF FREE SPEECH. Meaning, I CAN SAY WHATEVER I WANT TO SAY, HOW I WANT TO SAY IT, WHERE, WHEN, and WHY.
Artpop came at the wrong time for me. I was so obsessed with The Fame era and when Born this way came out, I felt let down as I did not enjoy any of it. Artpop was exactly what I was expecting her to release when she released Born this way. So when it did come around, my interest had already waned.
I’m glad I revisited it a few years later because it is definitely one of my favorites now.
what made you dislike the Born This Way era? That's when I become a huge fan but I know a lot of people who enjoyed her Fame era didn't like the BTW one. She lost a lot of fans and people thought it was just too "weird" and dark😭😭😭
I’m so glad every one of her eras has been exactly what I needed when it came out.
@@madhijkoite6340 weird & dark is the reason why BTW is my fave Gaga album then it’s Artpop
I didn't understand Gaga in Born This way but I was in love.. I just love her art. Same as Joanne then I started loving it, I feel I can get close to her through her art.
Lady Gaga fans styled like how we grew up
Totally Bizarre
Greetings from Indonesia. I was 17 when the tour was cancelled and was very upset that my people - called “the extremist” would do such unimportance public movement against her tour. That was a truly crazy moment. I defended her back then in a live news show on TV through a phonecall but it was a huge heartbreak for us as Indonesian little monsters still. Gladly I made to Europe to see her live in the Chromatica Ball!!
Anyway, thank you for delivering a heartfelt deep dive documentary of this masterpiece. We are still awaiting for these unreleased projects for sure but we believe in her own wellbeing upon this project.
Love from Jakarta-a-a!
It's crazy they wished death upon a woman for her lyrics and looks that's just insane I feel bad for the fans hlwho we're so excited probably saved up to see her just to not be able to because her safety was in danger. I still myself would love to see her performing live.
at the same time itu aslina era era peak fpi like. 😭😭 idk what would be their equivalent in other countries (in terms of sheer force and power alone) tapi sampe sekarang aja w masih trauma gak berani makan di luar pas bulan puasa, saking parnonya digrebeg dan diseret keluar. 🥲
You're so awesome!! Sending Love joy and peace to you!!!
I'm glad you spoke up!
Paws Up ❤
I never knew this era was so controversial, since Artpop is my favorite album by Lady Gaga!!!
@@thecinemawithjames recently he posted something saying not to ask hum about ACT II, saying he's finished or something. Maybe Gaga really doesn't want it to be released 🙁
@@eduag7 noooo he posted the blue gazing ball said this same time next year I will delete the post and give y'all something special it's on the tenth anniversary what else could that mean he's the main producer on that album him and Gaga know the most about it Gaga just finished filming joker I'm certain she will announce it herself come August for Applause tenth anniversary same way she announced it ten years ago except it'll be a re-release similar to btw but we're getting Act 2. I know we are DJWS wouldn't say something like that making us wait a whole extra year just for the anniversary to give us like one song after we have awaiting to hear act two for ten years I'm certain it's coming EDM seems to be making a comeback in the mainstream
@@thecinemawithjames But to begin with just watch the end of this video again please?
@@thecinemawithjames just google him name and ARTPOP, he’s not releasing shit man. It’s time to move on.
@@neuralfloxatine Why are you so certain?
ARTPOP is so bittersweet for me. I adore the album itself and sometimes it even rivals Born This Way for my favorite Gaga album overall, yet sometimes it truly feels like this was the last time I saw the Lady Gaga I fell in love with in 2009. I even met her during the tour. Still such a surreal experience to me. It truly feels like she has never been the same since. One could hardly blame her for the hell the media put her through during that time. This album will always be so special to me. I even got a matching tattoo on my left wrist just like she has for the first anniversary in 2014. ARTPOP forever.
yep, everything following artpop... shes like on another level. my teen self related so closely to her, but now, not so much. i'm no longer watching her as much as I used to when I was younger. it's like we've all grown up
Wait so many are saying she changed a lot, is there any way you could explain? Did she become more private?
@@tryingnot2bdumbi agree with them and I can explain, i don’t know if I’ll speak for everyone but from my point of view it was like this :
I was a fan of lady Gaga not only because she was eccentric and a really good artist, it was the art behind the songs … I couldn’t explain it very well but when a gaga song dropped and you listened to it it had a meaning, with the video clip it had even more depth and once she spoke about her art, you would be proved wrong or right and it was ALWAYS such a statement I mean just look at Born this way / You and I / Judas / and Alejandro on my god, this one was really special … etc …
Some of her song were just pure art and it’s why it’s hard to explain because Gaga is her art, a living canvas and to me she lost her edge / her it factor but not totally I would say …Chromatica surprised me quite a bit especially with Babylon it was a fresh album but still missing the « old » lady Gaga vibe that I think she might have left behind because it might have been the hardest thing to keep up, to out do yourself every time, to satisfy a fan base that can be really hard on her sometimes even with all the love, but the hate from the press and the people who don’t get what taking a risk means… You know they would bash her for days and she was really the target EVERYONE loved to talk about and disrespect because it was her, and specifically her because it was fun to « not get it » to them.
In short she’s still our lady Gaga but we look at her old era like a diamond because at THAT specific time she did what no one would even DARE to do and today it’s like « who will be the most trashy for the art of it » but not successfully doing it … Only Tyler The Creator to me has that Gaga vibe today, and I’m not even a fan of him but you must admit he’s dedicated to his art !
Hope that made some sense :’D
Being a part of Gaga history will always be my greatest life achievement. The Aura leak was one of the best nights of my life… the fact that Gaga saw it and let us preview GUY, Mary Jane Holland, and the title track ARTPOP because of our Aura reactions… that was the ultimate moment of being a fan.
Aura/ Burqa was so good, I was disappointed when she released Applause lol
As someone who's just became a GAGA fan and was curious about the controversy around this album, thank you for making this. What a fantastic video. The world wasnt ready for this album.
Ik I had no idea it was this complicated 💀
I was at the concert where she broke her hip in Montreal and we had met her briefly when she pulled into the venue prior to the show. It’s something I will never forget!!
11:50 as a fellow Indonesian little monsters, that tragedy completely destroyed me…I was so ashamed and embarrassed that a mere satanic panic and blind hatred could be a fuel for them to protest her tour. They were so quick to conclude she was a demon worshipper/illuminati and those religious organization justifying the hatred so easily. It’s really putting a bad name for us until now even after the religious organization was disbanded. I just wish she acknowledged that Indonesian little monsters still love her and hoping she would visit us one day
change your regime and prohibit religion idk
what a great documentary, with respect, harsh truth and the full circle of the mystery, which ironically will never be fully circled. that's why she is a living art piece and i believe people will talk more about that project. sometimes the story has no end.. if you know, you know.
Eh It was okay but also had a lot of misinformation..
@@thisisnotbilly2189 Like what?
Sometimes the story has no end ..........this made my eyes tear. And yesss ,I know.
I remember the whole protest of her upcoming concert here in Indonesia... IT WAS RIDICULOUS. Let me tell you those religious people were not holy themselves at all. The things they do behind closed doors to innocent people are sick, way worse than what they deemed Lady Gaga could ever do or "spread" through her concert. It's insane how corrupt those leader/religious figures are. I am so bummed she's basically blacklisted from this country.
There were also protests in the Philippines. It's hilarious how hypocritical those people are.
Man The R. Kelly Collab Did Not Age Well.
Exactly
Aged like milk
@Baby Doll 💯
@Baby Doll she did with Christina Aguilera
Are you,,..... UNCOMFORTABLE?! rawr
Artpop is phenomenal. I can't listen to that album without dancing like a psycho. It immediately empowers me and makes me feel so positive. Some people say it was overproduced, overdramatic but...was it?
Definitely
Applause, G.U.Y and Venus should’ve been the singles.
this!!
But none of these were better than DWUW, and yes I mean the original one
But G.U.Y. Was a Single
@@Ivan_xx I think they meant that Venus should’ve also been a single
Fashion! Should've been the promotional single or the last one
Can I just say something slightly reductive; if this album wasn't delayed by a year it would've been a commercial success. Gaga's mega success was largely due to her extreme factor not wearing out when she allowed no room between major album releases.
I totally agree! I think she would have had the continued exponential climb after BTW. It was a tragedy that she was injured but it is just good that she can still do as she wants. That was a serious break. She is very fortunate, and Im grateful it all worked out anyway, and she rebounded. ARTPOP gets her flowers now!
I think her being able to break that work cycle and have more freedom in frequency of releases has been healthier for her well being in the long run, though
The vomit girl is named Millie Brown. She wasn't 19. She's currently 37...
Probably mistaken her for stranger things Millie Brown😅
Thank you! I was like 19 doesn't seem right but okkkkkk
@@baytiedyewait r u millie brown?
Wrong girl
Artpop holds a special place in my heart. Rocked out to it all the time with my best friend who’s no longer with us ❤
Love this! So well-made 👏
Yassss 👏🏽
Awww thank you so much gaga daily🙏🔵🙏🔵🙏🔵 I still use my chromatica passport💓
For me ARTPOP is came out from the future, timeless album. The fashion , the art , the artpop vibes, everything so specials in this era.
Lol Nothing future
This was so good. I love the way you narrated it like you were telling a story about a haunted house. The ARTPOP era is haunting truly.
Why did I write my final paper in Gender, Race, and Pop Culture on the Burqa controversy??? My teacher was also as big a stan as me and gave me an A even though I think he knew I barely had to do additional research… Hay Professor Kizer! Won’t be surprised if you are in these comments too lol
There’s a class called Gender, Race and Pop Culture??????
@@marisa8413 yes. Even better, at a small midwestern university!
Do you still have your final paper? I'd love to read it!
“Her hip was torn this way” PLS!!
I really hope DJ White Shadow keeps fighting for ARTPOP. He’s literally all we got to make it happen and I hope Gaga recognizes the power that album has on us. Such a masterpiece. I just hope we get something
Did he ever clarify why he was suddenly done with it and would never talk about it again? Did he have a falling out with Gaga?
@@nolaray1062 he got jumped on by fans for no reason and i guess he couldn't handle all this hate which obviously makes sense i really think he doesnt mean those words since it was a moment of anger or sadness most likely.
@@nolaray1062 found this while looking in the comments.
'DJWS deleted his post and had to clarify under a gay news site article (GayTimes) that he wasn’t making a statement about the second act’s future, but was not wanting to talk solely about ARTPOP. He he has worked on other projects and is buzzed about act 2 literally every day'
@@kpoptimes4987 thanks!
@@kpoptimes4987 So basically there's still hope for some more ARTPOP songs????
Never knew about Artpop’s controversy but I’m officially joining the standom! She’s is so fiercely independent and always pushing the envelope a true Artiste! Love Gaga! 💕
lol VVhere is she pushing the envelope ?
This is the only channel I regularly noticing getting unsubscribed from? I swear, I’ve subbed like three times at this point. Thank gawd y’all are putting out the kind of videos I want to see, the algorithm HAS to acknowledge you
This was so deep and real. Never knew there was so much drama behind the album.
The whole ARTPOP era were such a joyful, happy, crazy, misterious and dark experience by all of the things that were taking place all at once, but all i got to say is that i got blessed by witnessing it. I'll always cheer and defend this album with my entire being.
This was great but there’s a few things that were a bit off. Gaga was millions in debt for the first run of the Monster Ball because she was supposed to have teamed up with Kanye West to help alleviate the cost. That didn’t work out, but she made it back with enough money to revamp the tour.
That wasn’t the creator of Minecraft in G.U.Y., he was a content creator that Gaga found after a Minecraft parody of Applause was uploaded.
Lastly, DJWS deleted his post and had to clarify under a gay news site article (GayTimes) that he wasn’t making a statement about the second act’s future, but was not wanting to talk solely about ARTPOP. He he has worked on other projects and is buzzed about act 2 literally every day. Man needs a break.
Well done. Been sick, so long videos are helping me stay distracted. I always had love for this album, but was aware of how sloppy it was. But I wasn’t aware of her personal struggles until I got older; so this project means something different now.
G.U.Y. is one of my favorite Lady Gaga songs so I'm pretty excited for this
Omg yes G.U.Y. So good
Wow! I read this comment and wanted to listen to this track. 2 hours later: this is my favourite Lady Gaga song too! 😂
I have no clue why this is not as popular as freaking paparazzi
g.u.y. is so iconic
facts
Thank you for featuring Radio ARTPOP, my little show that could ❤ Apologies to the fans who want the episodes back on TH-cam, I've had to remove most of them for work.
I dealt with severe depression during the ARTPOP era - a kind of sharp and pervasive emptiness that I still struggle to describe and make sense of. Listening to that album, going to the ARTrave, and witnessing so much of the sadness and rage of that era….it all felt like I was being understood.
And so I come back to that album and enjoy it year after year because you have to honor your experiences. All of them. Like Kesha said, “Our scars make us who we are.”
I'll admit I became a monster later (2020) just because I was too preoccupied with boybands, but Artpop is literally the reason why I took a deeper dive into her career and discography (album got me through the 'Pan Dulce' tbh). I heard Swine and immediately fell in love with the production. Went looking for the rest of the album, been hooked since. This deep dive is something I didn't expect, but as always, you came through & killed it 🫶
Venus is still my #1 song to jam out to. Lady Gaga’s outfits at that time we’re ICONIC
Omg when the news anchor said "Baby her hip was torn this way" 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
DWUW is so iconic. The solo version is so powerful and yet the officially released version is foul and disgraceful. Astonishing times, ARTPOP.
Artpop is my favorite album ever. Like I would play her iTunes festival performance twice a day before the full album came out cuz it was the only way to hear the songs. It was the first tour of hers that I saw too. I’m still kinda sad that Venus didn’t get its own space adventure video, and that Brooklyn Nights didn’t make it on (but Jewels n Drugs did smh). But I still adore this album and wish we could’ve seen Gaga’s full vision for it. Then again, I understand that she was having such a hard time during that album and may not wanna revisit it again for Act II or something.
Jewels N Drugs is actually a pretty good song, only the ending of Twista's part became a bit messy. I'm sure if it wouldve been a unreleased song like Cake Like Lady Gaga (which is great too) EVERYONE wouldve been obsessed with it. Don't deny it.
Jewels and Drugs is such a great song omg.
I love the Art Pop album. It ashamed the Art Pop sequel never came.
"Thank you for celebrating something that felt like destruction" Ohh that just makes me love it even more, in spite of all the faces and "Really?"s I've gotten when I've said "fuck yeah Artpop is my favorite Gaga album!"
Thank you for this, it was beautifully made! Artpop is a masterpiece, I loved it so much when I was a teen and made me understand so much of myself!
Thank you for making this video! ARTPOP is such an underrated masterpiece
When the album came out, I was 16 and I didn’t understand it. But now, as a 26 year old artist… I understand it now. And I appreciate it so much.
Jake this Deep Dive series is exceptional. Congratulations on documenting moments in pop culture.
All these channels y'all keep creating, my life is so full. THANK YOU ❤
Favorite Gaga album hands down, she was creating something beautiful that the world wasn’t ready for
lol
I'll forever be peeved that Aura didn't get a proper video. I even thought out a fanfic concept for it. 😢😂
It’s crazy reading these comments and seeing everyone praise this album, because when it first came out and years after, all I ever saw was people talking shit about it and how terrible of an album it is. I was a huge Gaga fan before and after this album, I always felt bad for how this era played out for her and I still listen to artpop to this day! I wish we could go back in time and fix it so the album could play out exactly how she wanted it to (with the exception of DWYW and Terry.) cuz she most definitely has not been the same since this album. But then again, she probably needed this experience to open her eyes to how things were playing out in her life and humble her a bit.
Well only fans are probably looking up Gaga vids on YT so obviously it’s mostly gonna be praise
Oh Cute Another Lady Gaga fan with an Avatar styled like Our Cultures
@@ftlegeahcni what culture would you say that is?
I think it goes to show that 1) media controls the narrative 2) sheep will follow the herd even if they're secretly rockin' out to the song in their bedroom :p 3) that the most outspoken are the haters. Several million haters sounds like a lot until you realize just how many hundreds of millions of fans she has. I don't think I knew a single person who didn't adore the album, Miley Cyrus on the other hand... 😅
I dont understand how Gaga even entertained "Do What You Want" with R Kelly and for the video being so bad. Love Gaga, but this perplexes me.. I dont understand.
SAME.
she tends to be full of herself.
People prefer the xtina version, which had some dance remixes, but that got pulled
She said that she was in a dark place and that she wanted to make people upset. She apologized and pulled it in 2019 after apologizing to the victims of R. Kelly. Some of them spoke out and thanked her for her apology.
I feel like. People have really strange trauma responses sometimes. Including doing weird stuff.
The edit of this video can't be real. Awesome workbro
ARTPOP is completely misunderstood in it's time, it's chaotic, a war of everyone, a party, a drug, an experiment at is finest and a pain. If ARTPOP ACT 2 is set to be released (even tho djws didn't want to talk about it anymore) it needs to be loved, respect and make it feel that it's understood from the first day. JUSTICE FOR ARTPOP 🔵✨
What an amazing video. Wonderful edition, you really did a great research omg. I'm one of those monsters that did fight all the internet defending ARTPOP, but dang here I discovered so many things and stuff said about that era that I didn't know for all these time.
Spectacular work
This video is so nostalgic, I was 12 when I was living through the ARTPOP era and it was chaotic
I watched this so many times and I just wanna cry. So many little monsters stood by this album and This does give me hope for ACT 2. I really hope she worked with DJWS secretly to do the touchups for the second act. I’m sitting at the edge of my seat for this piece of art that never really got its recognition it really deserved.
She's a genius. Artpop was so ahead of its time, I remember how everyone was shitting on the era - only now appreciating it.
right!!
Hearing “Princess Di” live as a 16 year old was something I didn’t understand, if I heard it now, I would completely understand. I remember crying the entire time during the whole performance, she gave in the show was so heartfelt we knew she worked so hard. I didn’t know she was in pain at the time and she didn’t show it.
She gave us everything she knew we would love and we will always love her for the love she gives to us.
Artpop made me feel all sorts of things. Disgust, happiness, inspired, etc. It was truly a representation of herself at that time. I didn't like everything about the era, but I love/respect it as the artistic expression it is and what it did for me.
Artpop was most definitely ahead of its time bc this whole album run would have slayed during the current TikTok era imo
JUSTICE FOR ARTPOP, artpop is literally gaga's best album.
Yessss justice ❤❤❤❤
It is not
The Fame is better
@@Imertdane the fame is definitely in my #2 spot but artpop is #1
Lies
this was such a well done video, i didnt think i would watch a 1 hour video on yt but here i am💜
ArtPop is still my favorite Gaga album, her most eclectic and creative phase.
Holy shit an ARTPOP deep dive and the sponsor is named "Aura"?!
The perfect collaboration haha
Lady Gaga fans with Our Generation's Styles Avatars ?
I would love to see more details behind this! It’s fascinating!
I don't know why people are so weird about this album. Venus, Donatella, Manicure, SexxxDreams, Swine, and even Jewels and Drugs are bops. I don't think I will ever get tired of the first three songs on that list.
I felt emotional when I saw DJ White Shadow's post at the very end of the video... It's just some text on a colourful background but it feels like the door of a vault sealing forever, and the vault is full of potential, ambitions, hardship, tears, and broken dreams... But I feel like the Artpop album itself, what was released, escaped the vault just before the doors shut. Because in recent years so many people, including myself, have given it a second chance into their hearts and started to appreciate it for the cultural moment it was. So now there is some justice for their work on it, and thankfully Gaga made it through and has had 4 number one albums since.
VVhy are you styled like our Generation ?
I love all the artpop youtube documentaries! Spread the word of this brilliant record
Such a brilliant album, and it was so misunderstood
Love it with all my heart
The editing is superior
I love the clips you’re showing. A lot of them are new to me. I wish they got more coverage during the actually Artpop era.
Ngl im kinda glad that they decided to leave Lady Gaga off of Dont Kill My Vibe
Love her but she didnt really fit the vibe of the song like yeah it was bad, i fully agree 😭
But had no idea artpop had so much controversy
SOOOOOO fascinating. Why do I love watching videos about things I have no/little clue about? Gonna listen to this whole album tomorrow!! She is truly an artist, so talented me honestly has given a voice to so many things that are wrong with that industry behind the scenes. LOUDLY!! So we’ll executed and your editing is NEXT LEVEL! 🤯
Jake This was Sooo Good !!! Awesome job. ARTPOP has always been one of my favorites.
Talk about an ERA in Time 😊
She's literally one of the most famous people of all time because of this era
lol
What a damn shame. I've never liked pop as a genre that much but have always considered Artpop an amazingly interesting and fun experience.
Amazing video! Well done guys! Can’t wait for more. ❤️
It's so sad that DJWS said that he's done taking about ARTPOP and he's done trying to get part 2 released.
Artpop and Yeezus are my favorite albums from 2013. But unlike Yeezus, i don't think Artpop is that appreciated today, which is sad.
Discovered her album in 2023...was in shock how good it is. Fashion is my favorite from the record
This is one of my most fave analysis vid in TH-cam.
I saw the artpop rave tour twice! Once in NYC and once in Philadelphia….it felt like a burst of color after a dark period…I enjoyed the show I even painted Gaga an abstract painting with a real seashell in the center and one of her dancers picked it up on stage and danced it all the way to the back. I always wonder what happened to this painting inspired by artpop :)
Art Pop is really ahead of its time, even after her other albums. Lady Gaga has always stepped outside the box which no other artist has done, at least not at her level creatively
lol And you styled like the eighties nineties Generation is also new
Why has this become a comfort video
Justice to ARTPOP. Truly ahead of its time and WHERE IS HER SISTERRRRR
lol Nothing about it was ahead
Deep dive is so good u can’t even tell when the ads r ads
I would love for you to make a video about Chromatica and it's journey through the pandemic to the Chromatica Ball.
literally thank u thank u THANKU so much for ur videos. u can explain things so well and its so relaxing and interesting to watch ur videos
this brought all the feelings and memories gushing back an era I'll never forget it
The sad part is. He recently confirmed for us to basically hang up the idea 😢 💔
This video sent me into an absolute spiral thank you
I love the quick Lena Morgana clips y’all continue to use 😂😂😂
Artpop is so important to me, It came out while I was still struggling with my own sexuality, I was 12/13 years old, I used to be a "huge little monster" but I stopped due to religion stuff, my mom infecting my brain with catholic bs for years, all of that was ERASED when I saw Gaga performing Applause during the VMAs, I got so obsessed about it that it reconverted me into being gay, it truly set me free, y'all ARTPOP ERA saved my life
VVhy are you styled like the eighties Generation is you are a Lady Gaga fan ?
Artpop and Mariahs Glitter are two albums that flopped but I enjoyed and appreciated when they came out! But they still both went Platinum some artists never go platinum in their whole careers!
Great job on this. You are killing it Jake.