DM:The dingy bar had a scene of unsavory bunch of folk, from cutthroats, lowlifes, scoundrels and much more, but the band played some ear worm of a song. You all step into the space cantina named the smugglers' cove. With that out of the way, what do you all do?
Well, quite honestly, I don't think that was very good. It was a bit blurred and fuzzy in the middle.. and ragtime needs to be crisp and distinct in order to show how syncopated it is. Proof? Here is an Icelandic orchestra doing a MUCH better job. (Play from 1-10 to avoid preamble) th-cam.com/video/dO4nGkDEfqc/w-d-xo.html And bear in mind it is 'phone footage.. and still a clearer sound than this.
If you "don't think that was very good," then you're setting your standards unreasonably high. This is a fully orchestrated arrangement of a jazz-based tune.
@imfsresidentotaku9699 I will admit that the orchestra did pretty well, considering the difficulty of so many instrumentalists endeavouring to remain so PRECISELY synchronised as this particular number requires. They made a valient effort, and that is to be applauded... All the same, I think this rendition demonstrates that the symphony orchestra is not the right 'instrument' for all kinds of music. To be honest, I find that massive church organs in massive reverberrant spaces, like, say, inside a cathedral, (just as a suggestion) also totally "scramble" the music being played.... but much MUCH worse than this orchestra trying to play this piece of ragtime. A pet hate is The Entry of the Queen of Sheba, which can be so bad as to be a completely muddled cacophony.... as if all the keys are being played at once.
@@leoholder7839 English isn't my first language, perhaps that may be why. That, and I am not too familiar with the semantics of music, I just go with the vernacular terms. Would suite be a better word?
dont know if you guys cares but if you're bored like me during the covid times then you can stream pretty much all of the latest movies and series on instaflixxer. I've been watching with my brother during the lockdown :)
Listening to this jaunty tune over and over today because the orchestra doesn't play it live at the 'Star Wars in Concert' film series (apparently you can't play it with a regular orchestra 🤔)
@@viniciusmarcellino No, it isn't. John Williams always intended for it to be played by four guys, because that's how it's performed in-universe. The idea behind the piece was what it would sound like if aliens from the future discovered a Benny Goodman jazz piece and tried to interpret it. Calling this the "complete version" is second-guessing Williams.
Yes, he would've. He's Han Motherf*cking Solo! Where did you get the idea that the version of the tune used in the film would've had any impact on whether or not Han shot first? That just doesn't make sense.
Harry Coleman The arrangement is by Sid Ramin. The Boston Pops Orchestra has occasionally performed this version under the baton of Keith Lockhart and John Williams himself.
You are in no position to demand that people "leave it to John Williams." There's no rule against making a different arrangement. Even Williams himself conducted this arrangement. And no, this doesn't have "too much flute." This is a jazz piece, and jazz uses a lot of flute.
You KNOW that something exciting is happening or about to happen, when all the flute players switch to piccolo ...
Or when a percussion plays a slide whistle
ThaSchwab when you say piccolo I think of piccolo from Dragon Ball :/
I have to play piccolo for marching band next year
nnnnnneeeeeeeeeeeeeeerddddddd XD
Finally, an orchestral recording of this song where people aren't clapping offbeat in the middle of it.
And just so happens to be without a single goddamn saxophone. This song must be somehow cursed
@@bacaw2856 i agree
but after all this is an orchestra lol
that said, there shouldn't really be a drumkit
It sounds like a Tom and Jerry opening style. This is my favorite arrangement of the Cantina Band.
The cantina doesn’t play this anymore so I came here.
The brits know what’s what when it comes to music 😁 Proud to be British!
If I’m not mistaken, that’s the Boston Pops.
Finally! A version where nobody ia clapping!!!
Such a bop.
Brilliant
cantina band its jus pure Jazz music
May the 4th be with you....
DM:The dingy bar had a scene of unsavory bunch of folk, from cutthroats, lowlifes, scoundrels and much more, but the band played some ear worm of a song. You all step into the space cantina named the smugglers' cove. With that out of the way, what do you all do?
0:30 Matthew Perri
Charleston charleston.
Society when haves mumble mode, retro mode, and civilian GNKs
tempo feels iffy
No, it doesn't.
Yes. The tempo is wrong and it just doesn't swing. Felt wrong in the first few measures as I'm sure you felt too.
It doesn't "swing" it's too halting...unsure, perhaps under rehearsed, can be a real problem with a big orchestra
@@imfsresidentotaku9699 You're right, I must be mistaken as to what I subjectively experienced.
/s
another addition to songs that get white people excited
Жалкая пародия
c’est horrible
Its ok
Well, quite honestly, I don't think that was very good. It was a bit blurred and fuzzy in the middle.. and ragtime needs to be crisp and distinct in order to show how syncopated it is. Proof? Here is an Icelandic orchestra doing a MUCH better job. (Play from 1-10 to avoid preamble)
th-cam.com/video/dO4nGkDEfqc/w-d-xo.html
And bear in mind it is 'phone footage.. and still a clearer sound than this.
If you "don't think that was very good," then you're setting your standards unreasonably high. This is a fully orchestrated arrangement of a jazz-based tune.
@imfsresidentotaku9699 I will admit that the orchestra did pretty well, considering the difficulty of so many instrumentalists endeavouring to remain so PRECISELY synchronised as this particular number requires. They made a valient effort, and that is to be applauded... All the same, I think this rendition demonstrates that the symphony orchestra is not the right 'instrument' for all kinds of music.
To be honest, I find that massive church organs in massive reverberrant spaces, like, say, inside a cathedral, (just as a suggestion) also totally "scramble" the music being played.... but much MUCH worse than this orchestra trying to play this piece of ragtime. A pet hate is The Entry of the Queen of Sheba, which can be so bad as to be a completely muddled cacophony.... as if all the keys are being played at once.
Impressive, most impressive
darth vader
Nyx the force is strong with this one
Lord Pyrous babababababaabbaabbaabbabababaabbaab
ha g you smelt it wrong xD before
The people of the 1920s/30s/40s unfortunately missed this song, it would have been perfect for that time period.
I can imagine people from the Victorian era listening to this too
+Joshua Sinogaya Victorean era? Not likely. The kinds of scales used here originate from North America a little bit later.
Through no fault of their own of course.😊
@@leoholder7839 English isn't my first language, perhaps that may be why. That, and I am not too familiar with the semantics of music, I just go with the vernacular terms. Would suite be a better word?
dont know if you guys cares but if you're bored like me during the covid times then you can stream pretty much all of the latest movies and series on instaflixxer. I've been watching with my brother during the lockdown :)
When us Brits have nothing better to do. So we decide to do some orchastrated Star Wars
Personne Lambda Yeah. why not
It was a rookie mistake
As a team I think this song fits us well, yes?
There isn’t anything better to do
John Williams is the greatest composer in world history.
yup
+Brennon Guilbeau Woah, let's not go overboard here. He is a great composer, but the greatest? That is a bit hyperbolic.
+queb92 He is unmatched.
+queb92 He's probably the greatest living composer. But certainly not in history....
+adam4757 No, in history (from the time of the Sumerians to the present day)
"Yeah, sorry...we only know one song".
gavsky23 is that family guy?
2:09 the basses though, so epic!
I know it's really cool it's my fav part
Chaos I play the bass
cool bro
ikr
I hear this arrangement for the first time - awesome!!!
This is the catchiest song in the entire damn series!
Best theme from star wars
A very tricky piece for an orchestra but they did very well.
OMFG this is the best version ever.
The best thing Ive seen all day
Bass was on fucking point!
impresionante !!!
impressive, this is
Great...just great!!
Like the sound of R2D2!! 1:55
Awesome!
The Force is strong with this one
Awesome.
a surprise to be sure but a welcome one
any other band players get chills while hearing the piccalos first play??
nope. I play rock and heavy metal lol so I rarely hear piccolos and flutes😁
sublime (Y)
Sounds like it was a 1940s version by Glenn miller
Oh my god I wish I was there
No disturbances to the Force were reported that day.
See with 1.25x speed!
Star wars otaku heaven
Listening to this jaunty tune over and over today because the orchestra doesn't play it live at the 'Star Wars in Concert' film series (apparently you can't play it with a regular orchestra 🤔)
And then someone goes the extra mile…. th-cam.com/video/k6zCLs1_LnI/w-d-xo.html
Vileness
Gooodddddddd
i should be studying my finals now
oh wait, i don't have to study, because they are over! important videos here i come again
2:09 omg too much epicness
it's way better then the film version!
WOT M8? Jk I respect your opinion I personally like the film version more.
*than.
Not "better," just different.
@@viniciusmarcellino No, it isn't. John Williams always intended for it to be played by four guys, because that's how it's performed in-universe. The idea behind the piece was what it would sound like if aliens from the future discovered a Benny Goodman jazz piece and tried to interpret it. Calling this the "complete version" is second-guessing Williams.
Sounds like Wallace & Gromit music.
Or Mary Poppins music
Was this song made with cheese?
Song meiner Kindheit.. xD
good video
Had this been the version in the film, Han would never of shot first.
Yes, he would've. He's Han Motherf*cking Solo! Where did you get the idea that the version of the tune used in the film would've had any impact on whether or not Han shot first? That just doesn't make sense.
Who arranged this version
Harry Coleman The arrangement is by Sid Ramin. The Boston Pops Orchestra has occasionally performed this version under the baton of Keith Lockhart and John Williams himself.
Cheers
Does anybody know what arrangement this is?
My music teacher showed me this song!i go to north Falmouth elementary
1:30 Franz Beckenbauer an der Geige 😂
Listen to Sound Nomadens electro swing version it’s great
do or do not there is no try
Francina Smith EPIC
2:09I think I just grew a pinstripe suit.
wowowowow| arrangeb by???
Alguem me envia a partitura para violino
Not the droids you're looking for.
Whose orchestration/arrangement is that? Williams' own?
GGbreizh Arranged by Sid Ramin, but I went to a Boston Pops concert where Williams himself conducted this arrangement.
Looks Like Something From An 40’s Cartoon
kyoto tachibana from japan
Spielt den selben Song nochmal !
Instrument at 1:57?
+TheFishMeister It's a slide whistle
BlueSeriin Thanks :D
I find the presence of 19 dislikes disturbing.
This sounds as would be perfect in the 1920's to dance to. Do you agree like if you do.
Lord Goddrid Well, it is Space Jazz.
not much people agree... only 3 people at this current time do
Han Solo shot first!
GRWAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAWWW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
😂👌
I think han shots first
Is it me or the bit rate a little off?
he doesnt like you.
i dont like you either. you just watch yourself. were wanted men. i have the death sentence on 12 systems
He doesn't like you. I don't like you either!
Mozart then Beethoven then Williams
no leave it to John willaims.. btw good but too much flute, or whatever xD
I think also :)
You are in no position to demand that people "leave it to John Williams." There's no rule against making a different arrangement. Even Williams himself conducted this arrangement. And no, this doesn't have "too much flute." This is a jazz piece, and jazz uses a lot of flute.
no sax triggerd
It annoys me that they had flutes instead of clarinets
Cool niet saai
Is it just me or is the conducting off?
he was conducting on the 2s and 4s i think
1:19 why is Karen playing the violin
Disliked due to copyright infringement by stealing the Cantina Band's music without their consent. Plus, they didn't use the correct instruments