Bought the 160cm Skarska yesterday. Your review was helpful for my decision. At the lowest position the desk is really very stable. NO wobbling. At the highest position at which I am typing right now with the upper edge of the desk at the height of 125,5 cm the desk is still stable. Yes, there is a little shaking of the 32 inch Monitor, but nothing I would describe as inconvienient. No problems at all. A nice desk, good price-performance-ratio. Cranking works well. One advantage of manual cranking is that you can position the desk precisely.
I've owned mine for the last 3-4 years. I rarely raise mine up but am considering upgrading to an electronic desk but it's a tough call since this desk is almost good enough. All of these 2 leg designs, even the much more premium electronic desks suffer from wobbling/shaking at height. I would even say this Ikea might be more stable than some of the competition. One small thing I think that could be improved is the lowest height setting. I wish it could go down a couple more inches at the minimum height setting. This would be beneficial to shorter users looking to dial in an ergonomic sitting position without the use of a foot rest.
Thank you very much for posting this, you helped me decide on the Trotten desk 120cm/160cm (same make, they appear to be rebranding). My experience, I haven't bothered to level after putting it together and probably never will. After one week, I find there is no wobble when typing standing up (I'm 5 foot 8), even if my arms are resting on the desk top (I usually hover my hands). If I put my hands on it and push back and forth, as I see people doing in some videos, then it moves, but then I'm deliberately moving it. Just now I had both my hands resting on the desk while properly swaying about to Love Shack without a hint of desk wobble. One issue. After just one day, the grip on the crank doesn't stay on. It's supposed to clip into place, and it did, but it doesn't anymore. I phoned IKEA but it can't be replaced on it's own, I'd have to send the whole thing back. The good news is that it's superfluous, the crank is smooth and can be turned without it.
I have the Skarsta and I have the opposite issue. I was trying to remove the grip on purpose to customize my crank but I could not remove it by hand with all my strength.
Thanks for your review! I bought a used one today (47.25" wide) and am very happy with it. I tightened a number of the bolts and have no wobbling. I put "dry" silicone lubricant on the crank parts. So far, the piece that's giving you problems is staying put for me. I was careful to tighten the screw to that part really hard on the indentation at the end of the crank. We'll see how it holds up over time. I think I may tighten all the bolts, etc. a few times a year. One thing I noticed is that I have an older model in which the tabletop attaches to the legs in a seemingly less secure fashion with four ~1/4" plastic doodads (I've no idea what they're actually called) instead of 8 screws shown in IKEA's online instructions for the newer models. This, and the fact that my already-assembled used model had some loose bolts and "pins" when I got it, makes me think regular tightening will be wise.
GREAT review! Would like to see you review all of the many different white supply/file cabinets/boxes you have there next to your desk as well as the Alex Cabinets.
Nice review. I've had this desk for about a week and am really enjoying it. The build quality is amazing. My trick for getting it to the right standing height is to position it 2 inches below my elbow, which is where I like having it. This is my first standing desk, and might look at motor assist versions in the future, but for now I'm loving the Skarsta!
honest review.. many just flatter...u agreed u suffer by daily crank operation. and woobbly table.....thanks..cleared my confusion... i will go for electric version and stabler...i hit table badly...finally...good honest review
I thought I was sold on the Idasen but after watching your review, I might be getting this Skarsta. Plus the Idasen does not have the white table top/leg option like I want. since I'm not handy, I'd like to purchase the desk and table as a set with the pre drilled holes. Thank you for such a thorough review!
Ah yes, very good point about the depth, so i dont have to worry about my kids grabbing my scissors, definitely an upside (me, 22 year old single student) jokes aside, great review!
I got a desk converter and returned it to get this standing desk instead. I like it but I must admit I miss how much easier it was to raise or lower my work station with the pneumatic desk converter. I would just push a lever and it went up really quickly. With the crank it takes a lot of time to raise it or lower it to my liking. The problem with the converter though is that it takes up a lot of space. There's much less usable space in your desk. I love how much cleaner my desk is with a standing desk.
I wanted to ask you if its not too annoying if you could tell me how long is the space between legs... I can find the exact max measurements of the outside but not the measurements of the metal support and cannot calculate it :) thanks and no problem if you cant do it. Thanks for the video
Thanks for this honest and thorough review. I have to say, I'm surprised how much you have to crank it to be standing height since you're 5'2". I'm around the same height and had seen some relatively tall men using the desk so I figured that's why they had to crank it so much lol. I'm still trying to determine how much I'd actually use a sit-stand desk which is why I was considering the cheaper/manual options, but now I'm thinking it may be worth it to save up to a motorized one if I get one...
Great review. I bought the 160cm version. Stability is not perfect, but that can be overlooked for the price. Working with the desk fully extended with a 34" ultra wide monitor is no problem. With some cable management trays in place this desk is a winner.
Hey, thanks for the great review. It's basicly the best one online and I really appreciate it, I think you helped a lot of people a ton. Could you please tell me is it possible to "lean" on it while sitting without flexing the top? One thing I'm scared of is that top rated to 50kgs/110lbs.
Great review!!!! I just ordered a desk from Office Depot. I was looking for cable management video and found yours. I viewed yours because of your awesome set up!!! I am a Stampin Up Demonstrator. Did I miss your sizes?
desperate times so I have to ask...does anyone still have the manual for this desk that shows the part numbers!? trying to order a replacement part for the plugs that attach the top to the base and can't find anywhere..help!
You look like your roughly between 5'3 to 5'6 max but this desk only goes down to 27in minimum so wouldn't you have to lift your chair off the floor to get into ergonomic position. For example if your elbows are at your waist and your typing wouldn't the table still be to tall at its lowest position? I know you could lift your chair or desk considered but while sitting with your feet off of the floor even with a foot rest does it make you uncomfortable. I need a desk that goes down to 22" because I'm only 5'6 the problem is standard desk are minimum 27.xx and usually 28" minimum.
Hello Seng, Great video, thank you! Just wanted to ask you if the Table top I can made it myself or it has to be the Ikea one. My country IKEA site only offers Bambu color, and I want white. Also could you please share the dimensions of your table?
3 ปีที่แล้ว
Just ordered mine. Read a lot of bad reviews about the motor of the electric one so I opted for the crank.
Hey man, how is the wobbleness? Do you tend to game and get any sort of shakiness?
3 ปีที่แล้ว
@@Munchkinz I will receive it this Wednesday. Don't know yet. Based on this video I think I will be happy with it. Will try to remember to update you about it .
3 ปีที่แล้ว
@@Munchkinz Received it yestaray. about half an hour to build. I find it more stable than expected. Yes, my monitor swing a bit but that's more the monitor stand than the desk... the stopper that fall is not true for me. I think she forgot to install a screw that force the stopper to stay in place. Overall very happy with it.
This was really useful and engaging, thanks. I was just wondering also, how do you deal with dust (since you leave a lot of things out and not in cupboards or drawers)? If I leave anything out, it gets covered in dust in just a few days...😁
Exactly. I have the same desk but with the beige top and I have never had an issue with the crank and that is because it’s actually screwed in properly lol.
Thanks Rich. I actually have an updated video how I am still using the Skarsta tabletop, but using it with an Amazon purchased electric stand - check that out. Less expensive overall!
bought this late june and assembled in july. After 1 month of light usage, the table starts to slant (and stay slanted when I put some body weight on it). Turns out the screws connecting the bracket on the table and leg is damaged?! The screw is loose and won't tighten, it'll screwing...raised a support case with Ikea so it'll be interesting to see what they do in this instance...hopefully an easy swap/fix at their cost since I paid $50 for delivery duirng lockdown!
Hi, but the depth is 70cm. Is it enough to place a 27 inch monitor? I feel like it would be just on the very edge of the table to give you comfort distance from the screen.
Have you seen any issues with Monitor arms attached to the desk? I have a different Ikea desk and the arm has bent forward over time wondered if this desk is any better.
Hi, how is the monitor arm clamp on the desk so far? I have read that the skarsta can’t handle the weight of the clamp due to too much pressure, but i see u have the super ultrawide with a laptop arm stand as well, are they all still intact? How are they holding up? I already bought the skarsta and looking for a monitor arm for my 34” and laptop, but was turned off by the arm clamp pressure issue, thinking of returning the skarsta but such hassle due to lockdown. But your setup is giving me hope, hope you can reply to this comment oh pls oh pls. Thank you.
Do you think this would fit 2 25 inch monitors and 2 jbl 305 speakers? I honestly don't even want the desk for the standing part, I just like the t shaped feet
@@sengnickersontech my desk specifically has an issue with what the screws go into from the side. So screwing the top to the base is the issue. Inside the base that holds the top is stripped it seems. So I’m unable to tighten the top to the base itself and it’s terrible. Zero ways to fix it.
Nice video! I have the same desk and was thinking of arm mounting my monitors. Do you think its safe? Have you noticed any damage or denting with your set up? Thank you!!
size is not matter, matter weight dispertion on worktop itself ...for this reason when you crank its squiking ...each desk have weight max described on packaging ....2 motors 300-400 desks 2 or 3 memory setting can lift even 120kg i think is 57 Ib. do prper research guys as desk not desapier like french pastry hahahah. in usa you have many choices in UK LIFT DESK ARTE ALMOUST IMPOSIBLE TO BUY .
Standing desks I've heard of Autonomous, Jarvis, and Uplift. However, there are a ton of great reviews on the Amazon third party vendors that sell on there that are also top notch (like Vivo).
Ikea likes to make you feel illiterate...... You: Where are the Ida-sen desks? Ikea: Ida-sen? uh?...oh.. the Edison they are on isle 56 You: ye uh watevr..... IDÅSEN Edison Bekant Beckon Galant Gallant Skarsta No clue.....go ask I'm sure you will feel stupid when they pronounce it.....
Thanks Tiago! I have a 3 and 5 year old at home, so I don't want them misplacing the scissors somewhere the littles can potentially get their hands on. Preventative measures as as a parent of 4 :)
![เปิดบ้าน พี่ตูน Bodyslam หลังใหม่คนแรก ที่ภูเก็ต l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/flFwcmyDQSk/mqdefault.jpg)
Bought the 160cm Skarska yesterday. Your review was helpful for my decision. At the lowest position the desk is really very stable. NO wobbling. At the highest position at which I am typing right now with the upper edge of the desk at the height of 125,5 cm the desk is still stable. Yes, there is a little shaking of the 32 inch Monitor, but nothing I would describe as inconvienient. No problems at all. A nice desk, good price-performance-ratio. Cranking works well. One advantage of manual cranking is that you can position the desk precisely.
I've owned mine for the last 3-4 years. I rarely raise mine up but am considering upgrading to an electronic desk but it's a tough call since this desk is almost good enough. All of these 2 leg designs, even the much more premium electronic desks suffer from wobbling/shaking at height. I would even say this Ikea might be more stable than some of the competition. One small thing I think that could be improved is the lowest height setting. I wish it could go down a couple more inches at the minimum height setting. This would be beneficial to shorter users looking to dial in an ergonomic sitting position without the use of a foot rest.
Thank you very much for posting this, you helped me decide on the Trotten desk 120cm/160cm (same make, they appear to be rebranding).
My experience, I haven't bothered to level after putting it together and probably never will. After one week, I find there is no wobble when typing standing up (I'm 5 foot 8), even if my arms are resting on the desk top (I usually hover my hands). If I put my hands on it and push back and forth, as I see people doing in some videos, then it moves, but then I'm deliberately moving it. Just now I had both my hands resting on the desk while properly swaying about to Love Shack without a hint of desk wobble.
One issue. After just one day, the grip on the crank doesn't stay on. It's supposed to clip into place, and it did, but it doesn't anymore. I phoned IKEA but it can't be replaced on it's own, I'd have to send the whole thing back. The good news is that it's superfluous, the crank is smooth and can be turned without it.
I have the Skarsta and I have the opposite issue. I was trying to remove the grip on purpose to customize my crank but I could not remove it by hand with all my strength.
Thanks for your review! I bought a used one today (47.25" wide) and am very happy with it. I tightened a number of the bolts and have no wobbling. I put "dry" silicone lubricant on the crank parts. So far, the piece that's giving you problems is staying put for me. I was careful to tighten the screw to that part really hard on the indentation at the end of the crank. We'll see how it holds up over time. I think I may tighten all the bolts, etc. a few times a year. One thing I noticed is that I have an older model in which the tabletop attaches to the legs in a seemingly less secure fashion with four ~1/4" plastic doodads (I've no idea what they're actually called) instead of 8 screws shown in IKEA's online instructions for the newer models. This, and the fact that my already-assembled used model had some loose bolts and "pins" when I got it, makes me think regular tightening will be wise.
GREAT review! Would like to see you review all of the many different white supply/file cabinets/boxes you have there next to your desk as well as the Alex Cabinets.
Great idea! I will definitely do that - thanks for the interest!!
That was quite a detailed review. Really helped me decide on buying the right desk for my home office
Nice review. I've had this desk for about a week and am really enjoying it. The build quality is amazing. My trick for getting it to the right standing height is to position it 2 inches below my elbow, which is where I like having it. This is my first standing desk, and might look at motor assist versions in the future, but for now I'm loving the Skarsta!
Thanks for the "real time" cranking, appreciate the info.
honest review.. many just flatter...u agreed u suffer by daily crank operation. and woobbly table.....thanks..cleared my confusion... i will go for electric version and stabler...i hit table badly...finally...good honest review
I thought I was sold on the Idasen but after watching your review, I might be getting this Skarsta. Plus the Idasen does not have the white table top/leg option like I want. since I'm not handy, I'd like to purchase the desk and table as a set with the pre drilled holes. Thank you for such a thorough review!
Thank you for the straight up and honest review. I guess I am buying this one.!
Thanks for the thorough review.
Glad it was helpful!
Its so hard to find desks with this width and depth. Thanks for the review
Ah yes, very good point about the depth, so i dont have to worry about my kids grabbing my scissors, definitely an upside (me, 22 year old single student) jokes aside, great review!
thanks for the vid! it was super helpful to see that you had a large monitor mounted on it
Thank you for sharing your thoughts on it! Loved the review :)
Great review! A cable tie might make an easy fix for the crank - either on its own or backing up the metal part that’s sliding off.
I got a desk converter and returned it to get this standing desk instead. I like it but I must admit I miss how much easier it was to raise or lower my work station with the pneumatic desk converter. I would just push a lever and it went up really quickly. With the crank it takes a lot of time to raise it or lower it to my liking.
The problem with the converter though is that it takes up a lot of space. There's much less usable space in your desk. I love how much cleaner my desk is with a standing desk.
I wanted to ask you if its not too annoying if you could tell me how long is the space between legs... I can find the exact max measurements of the outside but not the measurements of the metal support and cannot calculate it :) thanks and no problem if you cant do it. Thanks for the video
Thanks for this honest and thorough review. I have to say, I'm surprised how much you have to crank it to be standing height since you're 5'2". I'm around the same height and had seen some relatively tall men using the desk so I figured that's why they had to crank it so much lol. I'm still trying to determine how much I'd actually use a sit-stand desk which is why I was considering the cheaper/manual options, but now I'm thinking it may be worth it to save up to a motorized one if I get one...
I'm surprised the table can bear the monitor weight. Nice Review
Very helpful explanation and sympathetic presentation.
Great review. I bought the 160cm version. Stability is not perfect, but that can be overlooked for the price. Working with the desk fully extended with a 34" ultra wide monitor is no problem. With some cable management trays in place this desk is a winner.
I really like your home office everything just perfect :)
Amazing review! Thanks
Thank you so much for your review!
I think you can think of something with a usropovetr, so that with it you can adjust the height ..
Is the monitor fixed on the table using a c-clamp? I'm just wondering whether the 1/2 inch width table top is able to support my ultra wide screen
Very thorough- thank you!!!
Very nice review.
Hey, thanks for the great review. It's basicly the best one online and I really appreciate it, I think you helped a lot of people a ton. Could you please tell me is it possible to "lean" on it while sitting without flexing the top? One thing I'm scared of is that top rated to 50kgs/110lbs.
Yes it’s possible to tighten to the point where it does not lean.
@@sengnickersontech thanks a bunch! :)
Hey! What arm are you using for your Monitor? Is that a crg9?
perfect review thank you!
Thank you for the review
what size monitor is that you are using, thanks great review
Great review!!!! I just ordered a desk from Office Depot. I was looking for cable management video and found yours. I viewed yours because of your awesome set up!!! I am a Stampin Up Demonstrator. Did I miss your sizes?
desperate times so I have to ask...does anyone still have the manual for this desk that shows the part numbers!? trying to order a replacement part for the plugs that attach the top to the base and can't find anywhere..help!
nice vid, i really enjoy an evry sec, keep working
Maybe look into a drafting chair so you don't have to constantly raise and lower your desk if you haven't found a solution already.
Can you please share links to the attachment parts like the laptop mount and under desk cord organizer, please?
Sure. Laptop mount: rstyle.me/+yEJAUgyIUFXV3bW4ap03mw and cord organizer: rstyle.me/+PXKS6h-H5HJVUwRg8-JNyA
You look like your roughly between 5'3 to 5'6 max but this desk only goes down to 27in minimum so wouldn't you have to lift your chair off the floor to get into ergonomic position. For example if your elbows are at your waist and your typing wouldn't the table still be to tall at its lowest position? I know you could lift your chair or desk considered but while sitting with your feet off of the floor even with a foot rest does it make you uncomfortable. I need a desk that goes down to 22" because I'm only 5'6 the problem is standard desk are minimum 27.xx and usually 28" minimum.
very useful! can i ask how long are the 2 feet that touch the floor in cm?
Hello Seng, Great video, thank you! Just wanted to ask you if the Table top I can made it myself or it has to be the Ikea one. My country IKEA site only offers Bambu color, and I want white. Also could you please share the dimensions of your table?
Just ordered mine. Read a lot of bad reviews about the motor of the electric one so I opted for the crank.
Hey man, how is the wobbleness? Do you tend to game and get any sort of shakiness?
@@Munchkinz I will receive it this Wednesday. Don't know yet. Based on this video I think I will be happy with it. Will try to remember to update you about it .
@@Munchkinz Received it yestaray. about half an hour to build. I find it more stable than expected. Yes, my monitor swing a bit but that's more the monitor stand than the desk... the stopper that fall is not true for me. I think she forgot to install a screw that force the stopper to stay in place. Overall very happy with it.
What about stablility? Is it wooble?
Definitely wobbly, especially if you hit your desk a lot while working.
This was really useful and engaging, thanks. I was just wondering also, how do you deal with dust (since you leave a lot of things out and not in cupboards or drawers)? If I leave anything out, it gets covered in dust in just a few days...😁
Lots of lysol wipes. I also have an air purifier, which I think helps.
Can u get a marker and mark the leg for the standing and sitting heights?
Your desk is wobbly cause you didn't tighten the screws. We can see its clearly when you show the crank
Exactly. I have the same desk but with the beige top and I have never had an issue with the crank and that is because it’s actually screwed in properly lol.
does your monitor shake a little while typing on the keyboard ?
I love like your setup imma get the electric one though
Thanks Rich. I actually have an updated video how I am still using the Skarsta tabletop, but using it with an Amazon purchased electric stand - check that out. Less expensive overall!
@@sengnickersontech will do 👍
bought this late june and assembled in july. After 1 month of light usage, the table starts to slant (and stay slanted when I put some body weight on it). Turns out the screws connecting the bracket on the table and leg is damaged?! The screw is loose and won't tighten, it'll screwing...raised a support case with Ikea so it'll be interesting to see what they do in this instance...hopefully an easy swap/fix at their cost since I paid $50 for delivery duirng lockdown!
that is terrible!! maybe a sign to get at electric one?
@@sengnickersontech I got a replacement and no issues so far but might need to if it reoccurs.
I got the shorter version of this desk, it's less wobbly. In case people are thinking about getting the short version.
Hi, but the depth is 70cm. Is it enough to place a 27 inch monitor? I feel like it would be just on the very edge of the table to give you comfort distance from the screen.
You should just mark the right leg. Seems easier than a pole on the other side.
Do you have to use that table top? Or can you use any table top with those legs
It comes as a package. You can use any, just make sure you drill the holes.
@@sengnickersontech Awesome, thanks for the video and the reply!
Have you seen any issues with Monitor arms attached to the desk? I have a different Ikea desk and the arm has bent forward over time wondered if this desk is any better.
I haven't had any issues with my Locktek monitor arm, we clamped it down pretty tight.
What are you using to hide your cables please respond!!??
literally cable ties!
Hi, how is the monitor arm clamp on the desk so far? I have read that the skarsta can’t handle the weight of the clamp due to too much pressure, but i see u have the super ultrawide with a laptop arm stand as well, are they all still intact? How are they holding up? I already bought the skarsta and looking for a monitor arm for my 34” and laptop, but was turned off by the arm clamp pressure issue, thinking of returning the skarsta but such hassle due to lockdown. But your setup is giving me hope, hope you can reply to this comment oh pls oh pls. Thank you.
it's still going strong with the desk and clamp!
Warranty of this desk?
not that i am aware of - two years going strong
I think it's a 10 year but there is nothing that can really go wrong with the mechanicals of this desk.
Do you think this would fit 2 25 inch monitors and 2 jbl 305 speakers? I honestly don't even want the desk for the standing part, I just like the t shaped feet
The desk holds up to 110 pounds.
Does it wobble ?
It does have a slight wobble to it when I push against my desk.
I have this desk and after a year it wobbles so heavy that i'm looking high and low on how to fix it.. If not, i'm going to have to toss it out :/
I know! It does wobble, I think it’s the top and not the base. I have the top on an electric stand and it wobbles.
@@sengnickersontech my desk specifically has an issue with what the screws go into from the side. So screwing the top to the base is the issue. Inside the base that holds the top is stripped it seems. So I’m unable to tighten the top to the base itself and it’s terrible. Zero ways to fix it.
Nice video! I have the same desk and was thinking of arm mounting my monitors. Do you think its safe? Have you noticed any damage or denting with your set up?
Thank you!!
We had to put a block between the table and the mount. It definitely did damage the table without the block.
@@sengnickersontech pls pls can u post a pic of how it looks like with the block on?
She has so many Ikea furniture.
what 's the size of this one?
It's 63" by I believe 31 1/2".
size is not matter, matter weight dispertion on worktop itself ...for this reason when you crank its squiking ...each desk have weight max described on packaging ....2 motors 300-400 desks 2 or 3 memory setting can lift even 120kg i think is 57 Ib. do prper research guys as desk not desapier like french pastry hahahah. in usa you have many choices in UK LIFT DESK ARTE ALMOUST IMPOSIBLE TO BUY .
is there ikea in china ? ooh i do not know
and I wanna ask you name of another a Option name for standing desk
Standing desks I've heard of Autonomous, Jarvis, and Uplift. However, there are a ton of great reviews on the Amazon third party vendors that sell on there that are also top notch (like Vivo).
Seng Nickerson do u think the bekant frame and the gerton table top is a good combination???
Just make a hole in crank and stopper will never come out
Yeah it’s wobbly AF
does this table wobble at higher heights from general computer usage?
The table is NOT wobbly, but my stand with the 49" monitor is wobbly, but not enough to notice.
That wobble looks like the wobble of any other desk tho
that makes me feel better :)
Mucho texto
Ikea likes to make you feel illiterate......
You: Where are the Ida-sen desks?
Ikea: Ida-sen? uh?...oh.. the Edison they are on isle 56
You: ye uh watevr.....
IDÅSEN Edison
Bekant Beckon
Galant Gallant
Skarsta No clue.....go ask I'm sure you will feel stupid when they pronounce it.....
a 8 and 9 year old still don't know how to use a scissors? weird... great review though!
Thanks Tiago! I have a 3 and 5 year old at home, so I don't want them misplacing the scissors somewhere the littles can potentially get their hands on. Preventative measures as as a parent of 4 :)
You talked about everything but the desk review