I was hoping for more based on the title. It’s one thing to say that Naturei Karta are a bit much, and it’s another thing entirely to call them paid actors. One can almost hear the triple-parentheses with that phrase, if you know what I mean… 😕 Why is it that everything always seems to come back to shlilat ha’golah? Negate, negate, negate! Never actually make an affirmative argument!
I love it when you guys speak as you have never been Nazis for 47 years hurting every Palestinian person or kid (I truly love this type of self-trust when someone is a killer but speaks like a victim ) 👏
@@Sajjadmurad-y5r careful, don’t poke the Kahanists! As for Zionism and the Nazis… my attitude is that Zionism is primarily about shlilat ha’golah: the negation of diaspora Jews. Hence Zionists breaking the Jewish boycott of Nazi Germany by signing the Haavara Agreement in 1933 and Rudolph Kastner bribing Adolph Eichmann in 1944 to let him evacuate Hungarian Zionists while leaving other Jews to their deaths. Or, for a more modern example, Zionists negating Jewish anti-Zionists like Neturei Karta or the Satmars or the majority of young Jewish Americans who at the very least think Israel has lost touch with reality. As for the Palestinians: if Amalek did not exist, then Amalek should have to be created. Hence the Israeli government cultivating and even sometimes openly providing material support for Hamas in order to sabotage the Oslo process. Netanyahu made international headlines for bragging about this back in 2019! The perverse thing here is that the repression of the Palestinians is just a means to an end. Zionism isn’t about protecting Jews. Zionism is about being the second-to-last Jew left standing and being able to say “I told you so!”
@@elsiehupp dont you think its quite blasphemious to say this about God who is almighty and knower of all things? He is not your buddy, he is your God.
@@sharoozasghar4956 I was making an attempt at sardonic humor. It’s difficult to *mock* blasphemy without accidentally doing it (at least a little bit) at the same time. 😬 Obviously, *obviously* G-d doesn’t like being pushed around. (That’s something Zionism got from Protestantism. See, for instance, the “prosperity gospel”.) If G-d doesn’t like it when people find dishonest loopholes in one place, why should G-d like it when people try to trick G-d into sending the Messiah? (Again: this is a thing Zionism got from Protestantism, though in Protestantism it’s a second coming rather than a first.) Oh, and guess where the idea comes from of G-d being all buddy-buddy? (Yep! It’s from Protestantism! Half of all modern Christian music is about Jesus being the singer’s boyfriend.)
@@elsiehupp I agree, people have become way too okay with making jokes on religion and God. I am muslim and even though Jesus peace be upon him is a prophet, he is far from what the christian claim him to be. He is the messiah but not God. I believe jews have a different view on him. But we muslims are very strict on the oneness and majesty of God. It would never cross our mind to make jokes on the laws and attributes of God and trying to outsmart God's laws which is always amusing to me as well when people try to do it. The ban on swine for instance has been 'circumvented' because verses have been interpreted according to the wims and desires of people. Like, dont you understand who you re dealing with(not you but the person that do these things)? Unfortunately, christians most of the time have forsaken their principles long ago.
@@sharoozasghar4956in Judaism Jesus is viewed basically as a false prophet. There have been many “possible” messiahs throughout the history of Judaism including shimon bar-kohkba of the Revolt against the Roman Empire, all the way to the Zionist rabbis in 20th c Israel like Rabbi Kook who was viewed by many as a messianic figure
It’s fascinating as in London there are so many Jewish people who protest what the government of Israel are doing. I mean even in Israel there are people protesting their government, yet because these protestors stand out because of their overtly religious attire they must be paid actors? It’s possible for people from every walk of life and religion / ethnicity to recognise when atrocities are taking place without being a paid actor. For a truly balanced and reformed opinion from someone who survived the holocaust and was raised Zionist, I would recommend people seek out the talks from Dr Gabor Mate on the topic 🙏🏼
100% right. We were all in deep shock for months. There were prayer gatherings and tehillim said in all Satmar shuls and schools. A medic was on standby when the Satmar rebbe was told out of fear that he may have a heart attack.
"Medic on standby" seems a bit extreme. While some Rebbe's of the past (R' Yoelisha, Kloizenberg, Bobov, etc) had the capacity to empathize & perhaps even develop a medical condition from the news, the post WWII Rebbe's of today are not made from the same cloth as the originals. It's not a put down of these Rebbe's. It's just the reality of growing up in Post-Holocaust America.
@@Bulvan123 he does have a heart condition and this is what I heard from credible sources. If it took me two months to get to myself and I’m an ordinary woman I can absolutely imagine it. He is after all only one generation post holocaust.
Yup true story. I was there for the holiday, and after the holiday ends there's usually music and dancing, but this year they didn't have music nor dancing because of the massacre...
Any decent human being from any background would and should be shocked at the atrocities. I cannot fathom what goes on in the minds of those supporting Hamasnikim.
Many years ago when Israel was attacked by Iraq a group of reporters went Williamsburg thinking they'll see them all dancing that Israel is being bombed. Instead they saw cars going around asking people to pray, we are all Jews no matter what we hold.
I really wish people would stop saying things like "we're all jews" or "we're all Muslim" How about "we're all human"? and we stop only having compassion and humanity for those who look and believe as we do All of humanity has value, and all life is precious
@@mannygutierrez7654 Because the Talmud clearly says nonjewd are not humans (Just download Talmud Pdf and you will read a lot like that) Search by yourself don’t just listen to others (search and u will find the deep hidden secrets)
This was interesting. As a non-Jewish American, I’m really curious what is the stance on Israel and the war? I honestly don’t have a stance because I’m not educated enough on the issue. I have read about it, read history and follow news articles, tried to discern bias, got more confused. I watched videos about it. But I often hear totally conflicting viewpoints and history. That’s why I don’t understand how so many Americans have a super strong view, to the point of major protests… I’ve spent hours trying to learn the issue, and still don’t know what “side” I’m on. Have all these protesters also spent hours studying this complex longstanding issue? They seem to have no doubts, how? So far, I feel that Jews are vilified more than the Muslim terrorists are, by some. That scares me. I’ve never been to Israel, but have been to Muslim countries and find the way they operate and treat women, dissenters and non-believers to be abhorrent, so I have some bias. But is Israel wrong for the war? Did they go way too far and violate human rights and war rules? What’s the solution? No idea. Hoping to hear from those more educated on the issue, and learn more
The ones in the army are our brothers, husbands and sons. They tell us that they don’t even see women and children, only men. Unfortunately hamas indoctrinates them very young (with tv shows and in their school textbooks) so there are teens fighting as well. The majority of us support our soldiers in every way but the media will only show the crazy few who do not. As for the world media they vilify Israel out of antisemitism.
One of the biggest problems though is conflating all gazans with terrorists and it happens all the time. Hamas is monstrous, there’s no question and they do want to destroy Israel. At the same time Benjamin Netanyahu is an evil monster. One of the most corrupt people on earth who enjoy blowing little brown children in Gaza to bits. They’re all monsters and Netanyahu constantly claiming he speaks for all Jews is making anti semitism worse and making Israel less safe. I’m not a Hamas supporter (that’s ridiculous) and I believe Israel deserves to resist, but anyone who thinks what Israel has done to Gaza since the October attack is ok is lying to themselves or a genocidal lunatic like Netanyahu. Don’t forget before this attack happened Netanyahu was convicted on massive corruption charges by his own Israel courts. The only reason he’s still in power is because of the war in Gaza and he wants it to go on forever because when it’s stops he’s going to prison. Normal everyday Israelis and Gazans both deserve better. They’re both caught in the middle of a battle between the evil monsters that control both of their governments.
I used to be unsure like you until I did some research. Here are your answers 1. Israel did not start the war. What they are doing is defending themselves. Some people say they are going too far because of the Gaza casualty statistics but those are unreliable because they are coming from the word of Hamas terrorists. 2. They did not violate any rules of war. They did strike some civilian buildings because Hamas was using them to send missiles at Israel. Because Hamas was using them for that makes them legitimate military targets under international law. Israel has to strike or else Hamas will continue attacking there people. Hamas is using human shields which is a War crime
Veery few indeed exist. I've never met any Haredi that was on the side of Hamas. All were mourning the loss. In terms of protesters some could be actors, don't think all are.
I love how he puts this! Perfect! And most importantly to differentiate bet these few crazies and Satmar just bec they dress alike. So unfair to the Satmar chasidim. And not only that, even in EY these are not the real people called Neturei Karta.....these are a bunch of people with no home misappropriating others name.
Hi Frieda. I'm Protestant Christian. You do a great job on these videos. I learned a tiny bit about Jewish culture when I was a butcher in a kosher deli and butcher shop in St Louis in the 90's. Ever since I was fascinated with Orthodox and Conservative Jewish culture. I was interested in Neturei Karta ever since I heard the traveler Rick Steves barely mention something about an anti-Zionist Jewish group in Israel in one of his PBS shows during a a trip to Israel as he quickly explained the different Orthodox and Haredi organizations there. Are the Neturei Karta protesters paid actors? I doubt it. I understand Tuvia Tenenbom's disgust with Neturei Karta. But revolting disgust at something can lead to a distortion of the facts. Just as love, kindness and compassion is a part of humanity, so is hate. To those who don't understand the history of this interesting organization, 'Neturei Karta's original mission to oppose efforts in the Old Yishuv to establish an armed force during the 1936-1939 Arab revolt, arguing that such a force would be destructive and that Torah scholars are the true guards. Today, the Neturei Karta understand it to mean that they defend their interpretation of Halakha against that of other rabbis who support the State of Israel.' ➡➡ en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neturei_Karta (I want to learn more about Rabbi Amram Blau and Rabbi Aharon Katzenelbogen and their 'disagreement with Aguda's accommodationist stance to Zionism in the 1930s in response to European antisemtism.')
This is the actual process of the final redemption. Both the Jewish people and the nations are going through a refinement, improvement and unification in order to serve the Creator of us all together. תיכף ומיד ממש!
@@arilayno-moses5332 My first suggestion would be for you to read the lengthy letter that the Lubavitcher Rebbe wrote to Elchonon HaKohen Cohen on this subject in Volume One of his Igrot Kodesh. Make sure that you read thoroughly all the sources that he brings in that letter. That will give you a general “lay of the land”. Follow that with reading letter 130 from volume 1 of the Igrot Kodesh of the fifth Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Shalom Dovber. That will explain to you a critical event marker that occurs in what are generally called “The Days of Moshiach”. That event is referenced by many Rishonim, including Ramban, Rabbeinu Bechaye and others, in connection with Shir HaShirim chapter 8:12-14 and is also found in the Zohar cited in the Rebbe’s letter mentioned above. It is also discussed in Sefer Emek HaMelech at the end of Sha’ar HaTohu, by Rabbi Naftali Bacharach of Amsterdam. After looking at this material, let me know if you still have any questions.
They don't support the state by any means, but like tuvia points out, demonstrating in public on behalf of Arabs is an entirely different level. And if they're not paid actors on stage, how do you explain wearing shteimel on a weekday
@@renag9475 who says they even do that? there are plenty of times they come in weekday clothes. and even if they do, doesnt mean they are actors...maybe they do it for respect.
They are not actors per se. But they ARE actors. Let me explain - these people do NOT support the Palestinians or Hamas or Iran. They are extremely anti Israel as they believe only when the messiah comes Jews could enter and reestablish and resettle Israel. Them being against Israel is not acting BUT them being pro Palestine is 100% an act they do not believe in.
I hear you Barbara. I was wondering on their veracity of a shtreinel during the week. I did see a young child with a costume shtreimel though which I wasn’t sure what it was about.
Nonsensical. They do not represent Judaism one tiny bit. They rely on the 3 oaths which we can dismantle, a step by step. They represent a niche minority and were excommunicated by Satmar and that is for a good reason. They go against Judaism, not the other way around.
FALSE, the Torah says NOTHING about not entering Israel or a messiah, those came later in other books. Stop pretending to be informed about judaism or useful, you're neither.
And they see the sin only in Israel and think that Israel should be destroyed and its citizens from each race who are living there have to be octobered? Wow. I guess they are not reading the Torah but Mein Kampf
@@sheilaswan1650 I debated them and they know NOTHING about the facts/history. A few read the jewish texts but thats it - they know nothing about the history of arab terrorism and attacks since 1920. All they can do is spout the talking points they were given, and when you expose them for lying, they walk away.. They are paid garbage.
Thank you. There is a difference between not believing in the state of israel and supporting those who seek to destroy it. I can respect people that may not believe that israel may not represent a true return. To be zealous towards the destruction of the modern state, however, is abhorrent and disgusting.
Try to put yourself in the shoes of persecuted people that do above and beyond to reach peace diplomatically and in return get massacres of civilians. And I’m talking about Jews. And everything can be backed up historically. Put yourself in the shoes of Jews who during the holocaust were not allowed to immigrate to Israel because of the white paper by the Arabs who forced the brits, violently, to not allow Jews run away from Europe. If you prefer wearing the shoes of Nazi collaborator followers in the likes of hajj Amin Al husseini, you are the problem.
גם אם הם מוחים הם מוחים על המדינה לא על הישראלים רק על השילטון . אני גם מוחה בשילטון הציוני והלא יהודי אבל שמפה אתמוך באוייב או במי שנגד ישראל זה פסיכי לגמרי זה לא יעלה על הדעת . חרדים רגילים ניחשבים אנטי ממסדים ושילטון מוסדות משלהם חינוך אוכל כשר הכל בלי השילטון אז לא חייבים להיתצרף לאוייב ולהכריז על אנטי . בשקט חי תחיים שלך
@@FriedaVizelBrooklyn to me this segment feels propagandistic because you just take Tuvia’s word for it that Neturei Karta are paid actors. If you wanted to be journalistic about it, you could have interviewed people from Neturei Karta, as well, then edited together the relevant bits of the different interviews into a coherent whole. And if you don’t want to provide them a platform, remember: this isn’t a live video; it’s a clip you chose to cut from the larger recording in order to make a rhetorical point. You can interview people you disagree with, and then because you are the person who controls your own channel, you can choose what you want to share and post here. Anyway focusing on the few crazies-whether or not they are paid actors-seems like a distraction from younger Jewish anti-Zionists who have much more normie reasons for criticizing Israel, who don’t advocate for violence against Israeli Jews, and who just think Israelis should chill the f out a bit for once. None of this is new! Oct 7 didn’t happen in a vacuum! The war has been ongoing for over a century now!
Thank you for shopwing that clip. The long interview was wonderful. But this is a needed reminder. It gets so frustrating to see protesters dressed like Hasidim but standing with the judenhassers like that. From what you've shown in your videos, I appreciate the real Hasidim.
I must disagree with you. It is hopeful that again, like in the 1940's, there is resistance against state terrorism. Without resistance, the Israel project will end. If anyone in power wants Israel to survive, they múst hear, again and again, that retreating to the 1967 borders is the one and only way.
Ok apart from all of those religious crap. I believe the only solution is to unite everyone in that part of the world and together make a secular nation where everyone has equal rights and any religion can be practiced in public. It's not about who's land it is, it's about the number of lives lost!
Just one correction: what hamas did on 7//10 is not what th n4zis did to our grandparents, is what arab grandparents did to our grandparents in 1517 (Safed attacks) in 1834 (looting of Safed) in 1920 (Nabi Musa riots) in 1929 (Jerusalem riots) in 1948 war, in six days war, Iom kipur war, the two intifadas etc.
Important things to hear. I am not on the side of these kind of demonstrators. Odd,someone wants sow quarrel and hatered. I'm sad and sorry for that kind of things happens nowadays.
Naturei Karta is waiting for the Messiah ,then they are going to build Israel with the Arab help ,,,, Some Chabad members believe that M.M.Shneerson will come back as the Messiah... I think those 2 options are very bad , wandering which one is worse !
Hi Frieda! Thank for video. It’s so triggering chapter, that’s even hard for me to watch this video. But I saw his full interview. And you did great job, and I love his Yiddish. I think it’s time to talk about another situation in community. What about Coca-Cola? Why it’s so necessary on every Chasidic party? Combination of Chalah-bread and Cola. Maybe one time you will add this product to your video review about Chasidic diet and food.
That was an important interview. I live in Israel and we see these anti Israel Hasidic only on tv in reports from all over the world. In Israel they do not protest (or when they do, no one showing it?). I read one of the Tuvia’s book and always wondered what he looks like, talks like, what his opinions are. Thank you Frieda, for this interview.
Thanks for watching. Tuvia has a jolly santa look, and I think he leans into it, it allows him to get away with some large and sometimes edgy statements. I think he sometimes talks big but it's definitely true in my experience that the Haredi Jews who are protesting with the pro-Palestine movement are a minority of a minority. It's also true in my experience that the majority of Hasidim in Williamsburg have a great love for Israel even if they are not zionist.
@@FriedaVizelBrooklyn You know, I don’t think that every Jew must love Israel. It’s ok not to be Zionist and it’s even ok not to love Israel. But there is a bond between Jews that can be easily explained through the mutual history, and it hurts when it breaks. Unfortunately, a fate of one Jew usually just a start of something that finally will get us all. We taught in Israel that every Jew in the world is our family and it’s our duty to protect a country that will never refuse a Jew. That’s why we are automatically (and maybe wrongly) expect from every Jew in the world to mourn when we are being octobered. Tuvia’s ‘edgy’ statement in the book I read (in Hebrew it called ‘get the Jew’) brought a huge anger from Israeli lefties. Their anger made me to look for the book and read it. They made him a very good advertisement with their crazy reaction. 😂
I think this is not good because Yisrael must defend his people and they are not representig Devekut when you are demonstrate against Judaism, but the IDF defends Devekut because Zionism is a normal part of Judaism so if you are against Judaism you are against Devekut. But Devekut is for all in Combination with Torah Study!. Why do you demonstrate?. 😌
My ‘book’ and the Torah says God gave to Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph…. Aaron and so on. Period. Before Christianity. Before Islam. It’s why Isa/Jesus born there. A Jew.
@@lovescent46 all the Jews in the world come from Judea. Israel should be larger to be historically accurate. And 1 million Muslims live in Israel outside of the Gaza and West Bank areas. 2 million Muslims target not only half of all Jews alive but also 1 million Muslims. Abraham was there, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph.. then they went to Epgyt. Then Aaron brought them back. Before Christ a number of occupiers some with dispersement and some without dispersement controlled the area. Did the Jews during the dispersement suddenly become Persian and Syrian and Babylonian and Greek? Christ didn’t become Syrian for some reason. He was never Palestinian. That is a made up word by the Pagan Roman Emperor during their occupation. You are saying cause some Jews went to Europe they are somehow not Jewish, all their ethnicity just ran away? Riddle me this. If a Muslim in England claims to be Palestinian in 2K years. Still Muslim. He stops being Western Asian and suddenly becomes European? What year? 400 years later? 1,000 years later? God said it goes to Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Aaron and so on. He didn’t take it back in the New Testament. It is the oldest document on the matter. Before Christianity and before Islam. They are the indigenous to the area.
For Tuvia's book about his time among the ostensibly anti-zionist Hasidim of Mea Shearim, click here:
amzn.to/4d9xncv
Your family from maramarosh
Romania ?
They are not paid for it. I was married to one in fact he used all his money to support it.
So you knew one of them and that means that all of them were never paid even though we know they are😂
@@thecowboy2541 they are not propaganda.
@@maxtryme1508 they are just lies
Its best for you to get some pro Palestinian rabbi to explain their stance in detail. I suggest Rabbi Yakov Shapiro.
Even most of those rabbis support Israel’s government over Hamas and Palestine
I was hoping for more based on the title. It’s one thing to say that Naturei Karta are a bit much, and it’s another thing entirely to call them paid actors. One can almost hear the triple-parentheses with that phrase, if you know what I mean… 😕
Why is it that everything always seems to come back to shlilat ha’golah? Negate, negate, negate! Never actually make an affirmative argument!
They are paid to hate their own community
I love it when you guys speak as you have never been Nazis for 47 years hurting every Palestinian person or kid (I truly love this type of self-trust when someone is a killer but speaks like a victim ) 👏
@@Sajjadmurad-y5r careful, don’t poke the Kahanists!
As for Zionism and the Nazis… my attitude is that Zionism is primarily about shlilat ha’golah: the negation of diaspora Jews.
Hence Zionists breaking the Jewish boycott of Nazi Germany by signing the Haavara Agreement in 1933 and Rudolph Kastner bribing Adolph Eichmann in 1944 to let him evacuate Hungarian Zionists while leaving other Jews to their deaths.
Or, for a more modern example, Zionists negating Jewish anti-Zionists like Neturei Karta or the Satmars or the majority of young Jewish Americans who at the very least think Israel has lost touch with reality.
As for the Palestinians: if Amalek did not exist, then Amalek should have to be created. Hence the Israeli government cultivating and even sometimes openly providing material support for Hamas in order to sabotage the Oslo process. Netanyahu made international headlines for bragging about this back in 2019!
The perverse thing here is that the repression of the Palestinians is just a means to an end. Zionism isn’t about protecting Jews. Zionism is about being the second-to-last Jew left standing and being able to say “I told you so!”
Accusing Jews of being Nazis is beyond stupid especially when Palestinians have a chain of stores dedicated to memorializing Hitler🤦♂️
are you not forbidden to create a state according to the torah and exiled until the messiah comes? isnt that true?
I dunno, it really seemed like G-d liked being pushed around in all the Bible stories I grew up with…
@@elsiehupp dont you think its quite blasphemious to say this about God who is almighty and knower of all things? He is not your buddy, he is your God.
@@sharoozasghar4956 I was making an attempt at sardonic humor. It’s difficult to *mock* blasphemy without accidentally doing it (at least a little bit) at the same time. 😬
Obviously, *obviously* G-d doesn’t like being pushed around. (That’s something Zionism got from Protestantism. See, for instance, the “prosperity gospel”.)
If G-d doesn’t like it when people find dishonest loopholes in one place, why should G-d like it when people try to trick G-d into sending the Messiah? (Again: this is a thing Zionism got from Protestantism, though in Protestantism it’s a second coming rather than a first.)
Oh, and guess where the idea comes from of G-d being all buddy-buddy? (Yep! It’s from Protestantism! Half of all modern Christian music is about Jesus being the singer’s boyfriend.)
@@elsiehupp I agree, people have become way too okay with making jokes on religion and God. I am muslim and even though Jesus peace be upon him is a prophet, he is far from what the christian claim him to be. He is the messiah but not God. I believe jews have a different view on him. But we muslims are very strict on the oneness and majesty of God. It would never cross our mind to make jokes on the laws and attributes of God and trying to outsmart God's laws which is always amusing to me as well when people try to do it. The ban on swine for instance has been 'circumvented' because verses have been interpreted according to the wims and desires of people. Like, dont you understand who you re dealing with(not you but the person that do these things)?
Unfortunately, christians most of the time have forsaken their principles long ago.
@@sharoozasghar4956in Judaism Jesus is viewed basically as a false prophet. There have been many “possible” messiahs throughout the history of Judaism including shimon bar-kohkba of the Revolt against the Roman Empire, all the way to the Zionist rabbis in 20th c Israel like Rabbi Kook who was viewed by many as a messianic figure
It’s fascinating as in London there are so many Jewish people who protest what the government of Israel are doing. I mean even in Israel there are people protesting their government, yet because these protestors stand out because of their overtly religious attire they must be paid actors? It’s possible for people from every walk of life and religion / ethnicity to recognise when atrocities are taking place without being a paid actor. For a truly balanced and reformed opinion from someone who survived the holocaust and was raised Zionist, I would recommend people seek out the talks from Dr Gabor Mate on the topic 🙏🏼
100% right. We were all in deep shock for months. There were prayer gatherings and tehillim said in all Satmar shuls and schools. A medic was on standby when the Satmar rebbe was told out of fear that he may have a heart attack.
I hadn't heard this before! Which Satmar Rebbe?
@@FriedaVizelBrooklyn r’ zalmen leib
"Medic on standby" seems a bit extreme. While some Rebbe's of the past (R' Yoelisha, Kloizenberg, Bobov, etc) had the capacity to empathize & perhaps even develop a medical condition from the news, the post WWII Rebbe's of today are not made from the same cloth as the originals. It's not a put down of these Rebbe's. It's just the reality of growing up in Post-Holocaust America.
@@Bulvan123 he does have a heart condition and this is what I heard from credible sources. If it took me two months to get to myself and I’m an ordinary woman I can absolutely imagine it. He is after all only one generation post holocaust.
Yup true story. I was there for the holiday, and after the holiday ends there's usually music and dancing, but this year they didn't have music nor dancing because of the massacre...
I've always wondered about Naturei Karte. It never occurred to me that they might be paid. It does make sense. After all travel can be expensive.
Any decent human being from any background would and should be shocked at the atrocities. I cannot fathom what goes on in the minds of those supporting Hamasnikim.
FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸
From Hamas’s dictatorship
@@thecowboy2541no from israel too.
@@maxtryme1508 Israel is the one freeing them
Many years ago when Israel was attacked by Iraq a group of reporters went Williamsburg thinking they'll see them all dancing that Israel is being bombed.
Instead they saw cars going around asking people to pray, we are all Jews no matter what we hold.
this gave me chills. thank you. 🙏
I really wish people would stop saying things like "we're all jews" or "we're all Muslim"
How about "we're all human"? and we stop only having compassion and humanity for those who look and believe as we do
All of humanity has value, and all life is precious
@@mannygutierrez7654
Because the Talmud clearly says nonjewd are not humans (Just download Talmud Pdf and you will read a lot like that)
Search by yourself don’t just listen to others (search and u will find the deep hidden secrets)
@@mannygutierrez7654 we should all stand together against terrorism
@@thecowboy2541 did you see support of terrorism in my statement?
If the answer is yes, you need a psychiatrist
This was interesting. As a non-Jewish American, I’m really curious what is the stance on Israel and the war?
I honestly don’t have a stance because I’m not educated enough on the issue. I have read about it, read history and follow news articles, tried to discern bias, got more confused. I watched videos about it. But I often hear totally conflicting viewpoints and history. That’s why I don’t understand how so many Americans have a super strong view, to the point of major protests… I’ve spent hours trying to learn the issue, and still don’t know what “side” I’m on.
Have all these protesters also spent hours studying this complex longstanding issue? They seem to have no doubts, how?
So far, I feel that Jews are vilified more than the Muslim terrorists are, by some. That scares me. I’ve never been to Israel, but have been to Muslim countries and find the way they operate and treat women, dissenters and non-believers to be abhorrent, so I have some bias.
But is Israel wrong for the war? Did they go way too far and violate human rights and war rules? What’s the solution? No idea. Hoping to hear from those more educated on the issue, and learn more
The ones in the army are our brothers, husbands and sons. They tell us that they don’t even see women and children, only men. Unfortunately hamas indoctrinates them very young (with tv shows and in their school textbooks) so there are teens fighting as well. The majority of us support our soldiers in every way but the media will only show the crazy few who do not. As for the world media they vilify Israel out of antisemitism.
One of the biggest problems though is conflating all gazans with terrorists and it happens all the time. Hamas is monstrous, there’s no question and they do want to destroy Israel. At the same time Benjamin Netanyahu is an evil monster. One of the most corrupt people on earth who enjoy blowing little brown children in Gaza to bits. They’re all monsters and Netanyahu constantly claiming he speaks for all Jews is making anti semitism worse and making Israel less safe.
I’m not a Hamas supporter (that’s ridiculous) and I believe Israel deserves to resist, but anyone who thinks what Israel has done to Gaza since the October attack is ok is lying to themselves or a genocidal lunatic like Netanyahu.
Don’t forget before this attack happened Netanyahu was convicted on massive corruption charges by his own Israel courts. The only reason he’s still in power is because of the war in Gaza and he wants it to go on forever because when it’s stops he’s going to prison. Normal everyday Israelis and Gazans both deserve better. They’re both caught in the middle of a battle between the evil monsters that control both of their governments.
There is a whole genocide happening of the Palestinians people as we speak. What do you mean you're not educated enough?
I used to be unsure like you until I did some research. Here are your answers
1. Israel did not start the war. What they are doing is defending themselves. Some people say they are going too far because of the Gaza casualty statistics but those are unreliable because they are coming from the word of Hamas terrorists.
2. They did not violate any rules of war. They did strike some civilian buildings because Hamas was using them to send missiles at Israel. Because Hamas was using them for that makes them legitimate military targets under international law. Israel has to strike or else Hamas will continue attacking there people. Hamas is using human shields which is a War crime
Really really important interview clip! Thank you Freda and thank you Tuvia.
Veery few indeed exist. I've never met any Haredi that was on the side of Hamas. All were mourning the loss. In terms of protesters some could be actors, don't think all are.
Me neither, agreed.
I love how he puts this! Perfect! And most importantly to differentiate bet these few crazies and Satmar just bec they dress alike. So unfair to the Satmar chasidim. And not only that, even in EY these are not the real people called Neturei Karta.....these are a bunch of people with no home misappropriating others name.
Hi Frieda. I'm Protestant Christian. You do a great job on these videos. I learned a tiny bit about Jewish culture when I was a butcher in a kosher deli and butcher shop in St Louis in the 90's. Ever since I was fascinated with Orthodox and Conservative Jewish culture. I was interested in Neturei Karta ever since I heard the traveler Rick Steves barely mention something about an anti-Zionist Jewish group in Israel in one of his PBS shows during a a trip to Israel as he quickly explained the different Orthodox and Haredi organizations there. Are the Neturei Karta protesters paid actors? I doubt it. I understand Tuvia Tenenbom's disgust with Neturei Karta. But revolting disgust at something can lead to a distortion of the facts. Just as love, kindness and compassion is a part of humanity, so is hate. To those who don't understand the history of this interesting organization, 'Neturei Karta's original mission to oppose efforts in the Old Yishuv to establish an armed force during the 1936-1939 Arab revolt, arguing that such a force would be destructive and that Torah scholars are the true guards. Today, the Neturei Karta understand it to mean that they defend their interpretation of Halakha against that of other rabbis who support the State of Israel.' ➡➡ en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neturei_Karta (I want to learn more about Rabbi Amram Blau and Rabbi Aharon Katzenelbogen and their 'disagreement with Aguda's accommodationist stance to Zionism in the 1930s in response to European antisemtism.')
This is the actual process of the final redemption. Both the Jewish people and the nations are going through a refinement, improvement and unification in order to serve the Creator of us all together.
תיכף ומיד ממש!
Where’s your evidence to prove that this is the final redemption?
@@arilayno-moses5332 My first suggestion would be for you to read the lengthy letter that the Lubavitcher Rebbe wrote to Elchonon HaKohen Cohen on this subject in Volume One of his Igrot Kodesh. Make sure that you read thoroughly all the sources that he brings in that letter. That will give you a general “lay of the land”.
Follow that with reading letter 130 from volume 1 of the Igrot Kodesh of the fifth Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Shalom Dovber. That will explain to you a critical event marker that occurs in what are generally called “The Days of Moshiach”.
That event is referenced by many Rishonim, including Ramban, Rabbeinu Bechaye and others, in connection with Shir HaShirim chapter 8:12-14 and is also found in the Zohar cited in the Rebbe’s letter mentioned above. It is also discussed in Sefer Emek HaMelech at the end of Sha’ar HaTohu, by Rabbi Naftali Bacharach of Amsterdam.
After looking at this material, let me know if you still have any questions.
the bit about neturei karta being actors is a lie...what a misunderstanding of the NK shita...
They don't support the state by any means, but like tuvia points out, demonstrating in public on behalf of Arabs is an entirely different level.
And if they're not paid actors on stage, how do you explain wearing shteimel on a weekday
@@renag9475 who says they even do that? there are plenty of times they come in weekday clothes. and even if they do, doesnt mean they are actors...maybe they do it for respect.
@@renag9475 never on a weekday. These demonstrations were often on Shabbos.
They are not actors per se.
But they ARE actors.
Let me explain - these people do NOT support the Palestinians or Hamas or Iran.
They are extremely anti Israel as they believe only when the messiah comes Jews could enter and reestablish and resettle Israel.
Them being against Israel is not acting BUT them being pro Palestine is 100% an act they do not believe in.
I hear you Barbara. I was wondering on their veracity of a shtreinel during the week. I did see a young child with a costume shtreimel though which I wasn’t sure what it was about.
They are not actors. They are Orthodox who understand the meaning of Judaism. They see all of the sin.
Nonsensical.
They do not represent Judaism one tiny bit.
They rely on the 3 oaths which we can dismantle, a step by step.
They represent a niche minority and were excommunicated by Satmar and that is for a good reason.
They go against Judaism, not the other way around.
FALSE, the Torah says NOTHING about not entering Israel or a messiah, those came later in other books. Stop pretending to be informed about judaism or useful, you're neither.
And they see the sin only in Israel and think that Israel should be destroyed and its citizens from each race who are living there have to be octobered? Wow. I guess they are not reading the Torah but Mein Kampf
Their views should be respected not put down.
@@sheilaswan1650 I debated them and they know NOTHING about the facts/history. A few read the jewish texts but thats it - they know nothing about the history of arab terrorism and attacks since 1920. All they can do is spout the talking points they were given, and when you expose them for lying, they walk away.. They are paid garbage.
Thank you. There is a difference between not believing in the state of israel and supporting those who seek to destroy it. I can respect people that may not believe that israel may not represent a true return. To be zealous towards the destruction of the modern state, however, is abhorrent and disgusting.
Try to put yourselves in The Pal Arabs shoes for ONCE. The blame game won't work.
Try to put yourself in the shoes of persecuted people that do above and beyond to reach peace diplomatically and in return get massacres of civilians.
And I’m talking about Jews. And everything can be backed up historically.
Put yourself in the shoes of Jews who during the holocaust were not allowed to immigrate to Israel because of the white paper by the Arabs who forced the brits, violently, to not allow Jews run away from Europe.
If you prefer wearing the shoes of Nazi collaborator followers in the likes of hajj Amin Al husseini, you are the problem.
❤💯
Beautiful, just Beautiful
satmar are not crazy
they are rashaim
din moser and din rodef
the people protesting Israel are not Satmar, they are Naturei Karte.
גם אם הם מוחים הם מוחים על המדינה לא על הישראלים רק על השילטון . אני גם מוחה בשילטון הציוני והלא יהודי אבל שמפה אתמוך באוייב או במי שנגד ישראל זה פסיכי לגמרי זה לא יעלה על הדעת . חרדים רגילים ניחשבים אנטי ממסדים ושילטון מוסדות משלהם חינוך אוכל כשר הכל בלי השילטון אז לא חייבים להיתצרף לאוייב ולהכריז על אנטי . בשקט חי תחיים שלך
FREE PALESTINE
From Hamas’s dictatorship
@@thecowboy2541 no from israel too.
@@maxtryme1508 Israel is the one freeing them
Tuviah speaks the truth!
paid truth
Nice propaganda piece
What's propaganda about it? This is Tuvia's perspective on the Haredim and zionism. Not sure I understand what your problem is?
@@FriedaVizelBrooklyn his problem is, he is an antisemite
ok troll bot
@@FriedaVizelBrooklyn to me this segment feels propagandistic because you just take Tuvia’s word for it that Neturei Karta are paid actors. If you wanted to be journalistic about it, you could have interviewed people from Neturei Karta, as well, then edited together the relevant bits of the different interviews into a coherent whole.
And if you don’t want to provide them a platform, remember: this isn’t a live video; it’s a clip you chose to cut from the larger recording in order to make a rhetorical point.
You can interview people you disagree with, and then because you are the person who controls your own channel, you can choose what you want to share and post here.
Anyway focusing on the few crazies-whether or not they are paid actors-seems like a distraction from younger Jewish anti-Zionists who have much more normie reasons for criticizing Israel, who don’t advocate for violence against Israeli Jews, and who just think Israelis should chill the f out a bit for once. None of this is new! Oct 7 didn’t happen in a vacuum! The war has been ongoing for over a century now!
Thank you for shopwing that clip. The long interview was wonderful. But this is a needed reminder. It gets so frustrating to see protesters dressed like Hasidim but standing with the judenhassers like that. From what you've shown in your videos, I appreciate the real Hasidim.
I must disagree with you. It is hopeful that again, like in the 1940's, there is resistance against state terrorism. Without resistance, the Israel project will end. If anyone in power wants Israel to survive, they múst hear, again and again, that retreating to the 1967 borders is the one and only way.
Ok apart from all of those religious crap. I believe the only solution is to unite everyone in that part of the world and together make a secular nation where everyone has equal rights and any religion can be practiced in public. It's not about who's land it is, it's about the number of lives lost!
Basically let’s return it to how used to be before the state of Israel was established!
Just one correction: what hamas did on 7//10 is not what th n4zis did to our grandparents, is what arab grandparents did to our grandparents in 1517 (Safed attacks) in 1834 (looting of Safed) in 1920 (Nabi Musa riots) in 1929 (Jerusalem riots) in 1948 war, in six days war, Iom kipur war, the two intifadas etc.
❤ yes. The idea is the same behind every one of these wars, battles and ter acts. To exterminate a nation.
The Palestinians are descendants of the original Jews not you Europeans who went there and started killing them
❤
Lisa, Gothenburg Sweden 🇸🇪
Important things to hear. I am not on the side of these kind of demonstrators. Odd,someone wants sow quarrel and hatered. I'm sad and sorry for that kind of things happens nowadays.
Mass Formation Psychosis. And it’s spiritual depravity. Their moral compass is broken
Yes, agree
Naturei Karta is waiting for the Messiah ,then they are going to build Israel with the Arab help ,,,,
Some Chabad members believe that M.M.Shneerson will come back as the Messiah...
I think those 2 options are very bad , wandering which one is worse !
Actually , M.M.Schneerson/M.M.Шнеерсон from Mykolaiv, present-day Ukraine .
Hi Frieda! Thank for video. It’s so triggering chapter, that’s even hard for me to watch this video. But I saw his full interview. And you did great job, and I love his Yiddish.
I think it’s time to talk about another situation in community. What about Coca-Cola? Why it’s so necessary on every Chasidic party? Combination of Chalah-bread and Cola. Maybe one time you will add this product to your video review about Chasidic diet and food.
Nothing Jewish about them except name.
Exactly the opposite. They are the real Jews who have morals
@@midloran❤
Tuvia is friends with my wife's Uncle Yitzchok who has a hotel in Geula & his books are for sale there
Let be very clear, these are not jews, these are erev rav,
🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️
We need to support Israel❤
A very small group.
That was an important interview. I live in Israel and we see these anti Israel Hasidic only on tv in reports from all over the world. In Israel they do not protest (or when they do, no one showing it?). I read one of the Tuvia’s book and always wondered what he looks like, talks like, what his opinions are. Thank you Frieda, for this interview.
Thanks for watching. Tuvia has a jolly santa look, and I think he leans into it, it allows him to get away with some large and sometimes edgy statements. I think he sometimes talks big but it's definitely true in my experience that the Haredi Jews who are protesting with the pro-Palestine movement are a minority of a minority. It's also true in my experience that the majority of Hasidim in Williamsburg have a great love for Israel even if they are not zionist.
@@FriedaVizelBrooklyn You know, I don’t think that every Jew must love Israel. It’s ok not to be Zionist and it’s even ok not to love Israel. But there is a bond between Jews that can be easily explained through the mutual history, and it hurts when it breaks. Unfortunately, a fate of one Jew usually just a start of something that finally will get us all. We taught in Israel that every Jew in the world is our family and it’s our duty to protect a country that will never refuse a Jew. That’s why we are automatically (and maybe wrongly) expect from every Jew in the world to mourn when we are being octobered.
Tuvia’s ‘edgy’ statement in the book I read (in Hebrew it called ‘get the Jew’) brought a huge anger from Israeli lefties. Their anger made me to look for the book and read it. They made him a very good advertisement with their crazy reaction. 😂
why interview this paid actor?
everyone accusing each other of being paid actors!
@@FriedaVizelBrooklyn yeah its frigging ridiculous...yet you platformed the guy so he can promote that nonsense
Either they are kofrim or amharaztim both disturbing possibilities.
They are traitors in my opinion
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Chickens for KFC 🐣❤️🍗🇮🇱❤️🇵🇸
I think this is not good because Yisrael must defend his people and they are not representig Devekut when you are demonstrate against Judaism, but the IDF defends Devekut because Zionism is a normal part of Judaism so if you are against Judaism you are against Devekut. But Devekut is for all in Combination with Torah Study!. Why do you demonstrate?.
😌
Best video ever for me to share to ignorant non-jews thank you so much. I try to explain this but everyone wants videos so thank you for making one
Am Israel Hai
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🕎🕎🕎🕎🕎
In India we have the same problem. Paid protesters.
My ‘book’ and the Torah says God gave to Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph…. Aaron and so on. Period. Before Christianity. Before Islam. It’s why Isa/Jesus born there. A Jew.
a palestinian jew yes
@@lovescent46 all the Jews in the world come from Judea. Israel should be larger to be historically accurate. And 1 million Muslims live in Israel outside of the Gaza and West Bank areas. 2 million Muslims target not only half of all Jews alive but also 1 million Muslims. Abraham was there, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph.. then they went to Epgyt. Then Aaron brought them back. Before Christ a number of occupiers some with dispersement and some without dispersement controlled the area. Did the Jews during the dispersement suddenly become Persian and Syrian and Babylonian and Greek? Christ didn’t become Syrian for some reason. He was never Palestinian. That is a made up word by the Pagan Roman Emperor during their occupation. You are saying cause some Jews went to Europe they are somehow not Jewish, all their ethnicity just ran away? Riddle me this. If a Muslim in England claims to be Palestinian in 2K years. Still Muslim. He stops being Western Asian and suddenly becomes European? What year? 400 years later? 1,000 years later? God said it goes to Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Aaron and so on. He didn’t take it back in the New Testament. It is the oldest document on the matter. Before Christianity and before Islam. They are the indigenous to the area.