I have watched every deposition in this case and I cant believe how everyone is risking their own careers to cover for this rookie cop!! Rookie cop that deserves to be locked up and fired. THIS IS ABSOLUTELY CRAZY!!!!!!
They are justifying blaming theirs protocols and trainings. True theirs careers are in the line. They should affect their failures pays and promise to train
They've deposed just about everyone, haven't they? I would like to see them deposed the other inmate who was standing there, handcuffed, watching the whole thing. I watched him do an interview and he was very adamant about who he saw do what.
Those blinking shifty eyes will reveal his Lies everytime. That poor girl needed help so badly but he neglected his duty to her for a Gone to Rot Cop friendship not worth the salt in his bread.
The fact she was unconscious when they got there and they had to use smelling salts to bring her back, doesn't jive with his testimony that she was just fine and didn't need help.
With great certainty I say Joshua needed guidance to find his way home. His loss of memory is a huge concern he can even perform his duties for any patient in need. There is help for that tho. It's called disgraceful unprofessional behavior. Personally I wouldn't hire Joshua to mind my cat.
So if the guy wasn’t there to see what happen you want him to take someone to the hospital with no injuries if that were the case you could never get into a hospital well Don you really thought that one out
As a Paramedic years ago, all people we didn't transport we had sign an AMA "refusal". Lawyer dance around it but never asked (might have missed it) why did someone need to sign AMA "Against Medical Advice" for her if your medical advice was that she did not need to be transported? Seems like that box could be used against you A LOT. First rule of clinical notes is ..... "if it ain't written, it didn't happen". I she was denying transport, "yelling I don't need you as soon as we got there", I think he would have written it.
EMT Joshua of 18 yrs didn't write or is not required to write thorough details of calls, especially police related calls as this one. Why didn't he take her inside the EMT truck to examine her?! He is definately a 'relucant' witness!
This guy's lying through his freaking teeth. You could see his demeanor and his head down trying to hide his face like he's doesn't want to answer. Yeah he's covering for the crooked JSO Department ‼️
From 🇨🇦. What kind of firefighter is he ? Would he call his Chief to get the permission to open the water valve in front of my house, while his truck is idling in front of my burning house ??? HILARIOUS
35:15 he is saying that if someone is not seeking help he is not going to force them. when he is trying to help after the police called you as they did something that they were worried about?
So nice to meet you Lawyer Phillips. Obviously I'm a bit dense as I've never identified you as the Lawyer in your videos😂feel free to laugh with me😂 ps. You sure are one heck of a smart highly intelligent Lawyer no matter how hard they try to outsmart you. Thankyou for posting sir I love courtroom drama
When EMS is called they should be totally in charge in deciding if a patient to be transported. Officers should also have no imput into the treatment of the patient as in giving them injections or assaulting them in the back of the ambulance.
He isn’t protecting the cop. That cop was fired that night. None of the people giving depositions in this case are protecting that cop. They are protecting themselves and the department.
I happen to know a person who works in the Emergency Services business. He told me that where he works, a LEO can sign a refusal for a patient. BUT he takes the liability. Secondly, if you’re in custody, you can only be transported if the LEO agree to let it happen. Also, if a person has no medical complaint, they are technically not a patient. Example: You get in a wreck and the airbag struck your head. It doesn’t hurt at all. No bleeding or bruising. Then, you are not a patient and do not need to sign a refusal. He also said he documents his patient care reports VERY thoroughly.
Thankyou for your comments. I trust your words as You are a good person to even comment what you know to be a truth. Videos cannot Lie. Unlike this Liar who obviously followed the Cops Instructions before he went near the unconscious lady. May God Protect us all from the Rot of Joshua
All the PROFESSIONALS FAILED this woman after she was very much assaulted by that rookie officer and its insane that if this were anyone else that man would have been arrested its sad that all of them prob been on a demestic call and helped where as here because he was a stranger to her they did nothing shame on everyone of them boys there they prob are all women beaters. I pray none of there sisters or daughters or any female in there fams never get treated the way she was
So if a person was pinned under 400 pounds of equipment and bleeding and said she needed no help you would leave?, or would you think she was not thinking straight? Are you unaware of problems with concussions, drugs, mental illness, etc.?
I always thought first responders were supposed to be half honorable! Jacksonville needs to get their house in order. What an embarrassing mess just to avoid saying what everyone else in the world who watched the videos already know. excessive...excessive force!
Watching all of these depostions for wet bus ticket is painful. There have been many "I know nothing " statements that should have been made perjurios.
When a city employee is called to someone that the city has taken freedom from. All revelient care and double the effort when checking anything the cops did to that person. FTP
This EMT is being shady, if he recommended that she go yo the hospital then that’s what he meant. He is dodging the fact that he allowed someone other then the patient to sign the AMA. Only the patient can sign that document that’s why it says patient it doesn’t say or officer if she is handcuffed that’s ridiculous
That’s incorrect. It’s preferable that the patient signs, but if the patient is not able to understand the consequences of their actions, if the patient is deemed incompetent, if the patient is altered, etc. there are a multitude of reasons the patient does not or shouldn’t sign. and in that case witnesses, family members or people in position to provide care and services to the patient can sign.
@@dogma39-c4j yeah none of those things you mentioned apply! This person was completely able to sign. You either are a bit slow or disingenuous to pretend this thug in blue didn’t sign that AMA to cover up his behavior. He knew a trip to the hospital would generate more reports and possible in investigation. Let’s not play stupid
He was a terrible witness, doing all he could to be ambiguous and non responsive, protecting his abusive buddies and he's an EMT. I deffo wouldn't want him treating me n mine...... No way!
What happened to the videos of the police brutality involved Officers Vickers and Albad? It happened in Atlanta. I was watching it and I went back to finish it and it was gone..
Am I the only one who thinks this dude seems pissed he's there? Like he's put out & they're wasting his time. His answers are kinda snarky & condescending
he was a 'EMT lieutenant' in 2016 .. and still is .. in 2020 ... Jacksonville you have a problem!! do you take the pulse from a person whose handcuffed from behind?? 🤔 would it be medically reasonable to do so?? I mean she's not Hannibal.. if the cuffs were in the front.. ms..m could sign any forms and her pulse reading would be possibly accurate (?) this 'EMT lieutenant' has shown dereliction of medical duty .. and seems part of a cover-up.. for the good ole boys the blue thin line .. He's just another Liar Liar 👖 on 🔥 .. Don't get sick in Jacksonville.. or arrested!!
I though just the police were corrupted but I guess fire and rescue are corrupted as well sounds like he didn’t want to do his job and was selecting options in his report that would make his job easier then actually accurate
@sunswept58 For as long as I live, I will never understand why one, just ONE police officer could or would not have stepped in the help this woman ,,,, Why don't all the officers get a copy of the video where the woman was being beaten, have all your daughters sit with you, like its family night,,, Pass out the candy, popcorn, and soft drinks,,, Just roll the film and let them know what they have to look forward to in life when you are in the hands of someone who was to supposed to protect her,,, but beat her instead,,,,, as you, her father just watched it all happen ,,,
For those accusing this EMT of lying. I did some basic math to estimate how many calls he has gone on in the last 4 years (and even purposely estimated low). In 4 years he could have been on 84,000 different calls. I would challenge anyone to be picked apart on a call that happened before those 84,000 calls to remember exactly everything that happened on that one call.
So you say that he goes on a call about 56 times every day, bear in mind I've countrd each and every day, and he for sure have free days and vacations and possibly was sick. 😵
I don’t think anyone is saying he should remember every detail of any call but as medical professionals we are taught to very meticulously document every interaction. Even if he only documented the highlights of this call he was absolutely negligent in his documentation. She was hit in the stomach and he never even exposed her abdomen to look for bruising. And that’s just one example. If this was your daughter or sister would you be satisfied with the care provided? WTF! I certainly wouldn’t be.
I know he's fire/rescue... but this proves... bodycam IS A MUST. I don't recall is criminals favorite line. Well... if you don't recall... you need bodycam. Just think how many people have been put in prison for years because all these corrupt criminals lie.. and lie to cover for another person.
After watching all the depositions in the case there is one common thread. I cant recall, I don't remember, I don't know. The truly sad thing is no one was held responsible for their action's except for the woman beater. And he got off with simple battery and a small fine. Taxpayers got to foot the bill. Hooray for the Taxpayers, that's why we can do what we do.
I have watched every deposition in this case and I cant believe how everyone is risking their own careers to cover for this rookie cop!! Rookie cop that deserves to be locked up and fired. THIS IS ABSOLUTELY CRAZY!!!!!!
Two words for you: Watch Serpico
They’re covering for the department, not even the rookie
Because there is absolutely no accountability inside the USA law enforcement department and accurately especially inside this city/county governments.
They are justifying blaming theirs protocols and trainings. True theirs careers are in the line. They should affect their failures pays and promise to train
So prisoners are beaten up by the police so often that the firefighters can’t keep track of it in their memory
How sad, to relinquish personal credibility to be accepted into any group.
They've deposed just about everyone, haven't they? I would like to see them deposed the other inmate who was standing there, handcuffed, watching the whole thing. I watched him do an interview and he was very adamant about who he saw do what.
He could not be any more unhappy about being there. The looks and answers are disturbing.
Those blinking shifty eyes will reveal his Lies everytime. That poor girl needed help so badly but he neglected his duty to her for a Gone to Rot Cop friendship not worth the salt in his bread.
He is scared to go against the cops.
What, does he handle so many police brutality calls that they all swim together in his head?
He had little to no credibility
Agreed!
He don't remember anything, he's a liar
The fact she was unconscious when they got there and they had to use smelling salts to bring her back, doesn't jive with his testimony that she was just fine and didn't need help.
The EPA should investigate because there must be something in the water at the police station and the fire station that causes memory loss
With great certainty I say Joshua needed guidance to find his way home. His loss of memory is a huge concern he can even perform his duties for any patient in need. There is help for that tho. It's called disgraceful unprofessional behavior. Personally I wouldn't hire Joshua to mind my cat.
Funny he can remember everything about cops yet, nothing about victim. This one has no business as a EMT. Covering for cops
3 separate beatings displaced spine and no injuries.
No COMPLAINT OF INJURIES, DOES NOT, EQUAL REFUSAL OF TRANSPORTATION. 🤦🏻♀️
Excellent point :-)
So if the guy wasn’t there to see what happen you want him to take someone to the hospital with no injuries if that were the case you could never get into a hospital well Don you really thought that one out
Dang, they have all lied in this case. What he's saying makes no since. I don't know and alot of I don't remembers. If she was ok why call EMTS
boreshade admitted that he was the one that denied her transfer…pointless for this man to lie and risk his reputation smh
Holy hell... it got worse.... He just basically said, "I don't understand girl bodies.... they're confusin' to me."
As a Paramedic years ago, all people we didn't transport we had sign an AMA "refusal". Lawyer dance around it but never asked (might have missed it) why did someone need to sign AMA "Against Medical Advice" for her if your medical advice was that she did not need to be transported? Seems like that box could be used against you A LOT. First rule of clinical notes is ..... "if it ain't written, it didn't happen". I she was denying transport, "yelling I don't need you as soon as we got there", I think he would have written it.
Lots of lying and drinking of water by cops and this guy. NERVOUS
This interrogator is good at working around the I don’t recall answers
Shame on you sir!
EMT Joshua of 18 yrs didn't write or is not required to write thorough details of calls, especially police related calls as this one. Why didn't he take her inside the EMT truck to examine her?! He is definately a 'relucant' witness!
Yep , just another corrupt paid liar 🤬
This guy's lying through his freaking teeth. You could see his demeanor and his head down trying to hide his face like he's doesn't want to answer. Yeah he's covering for the crooked JSO Department ‼️
Oh and absolutely Well Done to this brilliant respectable Lawyer!!
Deliberate and indifference to human life. This guys evil
From 🇨🇦. What kind of firefighter is he ? Would he call his Chief to get the permission to open the water valve in front of my house, while his truck is idling in front of my burning house ??? HILARIOUS
35:15 he is saying that if someone is not seeking help he is not going to force them. when he is trying to help after the police called you as they did something that they were worried about?
So nice to meet you Lawyer Phillips. Obviously I'm a bit dense as I've never identified you as the Lawyer in your videos😂feel free to laugh with me😂 ps. You sure are one heck of a smart highly intelligent Lawyer no matter how hard they try to outsmart you. Thankyou for posting sir I love courtroom drama
When EMS is called they should be totally in charge in deciding if a patient to be transported. Officers should also have no imput into the treatment of the patient as in giving them injections or assaulting them in the back of the ambulance.
Why is he lying for the cops. I thought EMT had more honour !
The second the second you say that you are not a doctor. One should have been notified
He might be not liking his TH-cam fame at this point. People are still looking up this case years after the fact.
If all EMTs were like this there would good reason to never call for an EMT.
The COMPREHENSION LEVELS OF THE DEFINITION OF WORDS/TERMS USED BY CERTAIN WITNESSES IN THIS CASE,
ARE DEFINITELY LACKING!🤦🏻♀️
This emt is slow and not going to get the cop in trouble.he’s been warned
He isn’t protecting the cop. That cop was fired that night. None of the people giving depositions in this case are protecting that cop. They are protecting themselves and the department.
I happen to know a person who works in the Emergency Services business. He told me that where he works, a LEO can sign a refusal for a patient. BUT he takes the liability. Secondly, if you’re in custody, you can only be transported if the LEO agree to let it happen. Also, if a person has no medical complaint, they are technically not a patient. Example: You get in a wreck and the airbag struck your head. It doesn’t hurt at all. No bleeding or bruising. Then, you are not a patient and do not need to sign a refusal. He also said he documents his patient care reports VERY thoroughly.
Thankyou for your comments. I trust your words as You are a good person to even comment what you know to be a truth. Videos cannot Lie. Unlike this Liar who obviously followed the Cops Instructions before he went near the unconscious lady. May God Protect us all from the Rot of Joshua
All the PROFESSIONALS FAILED this woman after she was very much assaulted by that rookie officer and its insane that if this were anyone else that man would have been arrested its sad that all of them prob been on a demestic call and helped where as here because he was a stranger to her they did nothing shame on everyone of them boys there they prob are all women beaters. I pray none of there sisters or daughters or any female in there fams never get treated the way she was
You have a direct connection to hospital doctors yet you failed
He would have reported patient refused treatment
Do you know how to read your own charting. Medical records are legal and binding statements. I think this so called rescue officer is a cowered
I don’t recall and I don’t remember. Sickening.
She did not refuse, the criminal did. She had a brain injury from being punched and slammed in to asphalt and cement sidewalk.
So if a person was pinned under 400 pounds of equipment and bleeding and said she needed no help you would leave?, or would you think she was not thinking straight? Are you unaware of problems with concussions, drugs, mental illness, etc.?
I always thought first responders were supposed to be half honorable! Jacksonville needs to get their house in order. What an embarrassing mess just to avoid saying what everyone else in the world who watched the videos already know. excessive...excessive force!
Watching all of these depostions for wet bus ticket is painful. There have been many "I know nothing " statements that should have been made perjurios.
The cop knows this is just a formality. The judge and the union will cover his ass all day long
When a city employee is called to someone that the city has taken freedom from. All revelient care and double the effort when checking anything the cops did to that person. FTP
They deduct she did not need assistance because they did not listen to her.
Who’s on first? Round and round we go.
I found Mr. Dixon's to be a lier. And he should no longer be able to work with patients because he is not trustworthy.
My God!! Look at this guy's eyes!! He definitely the definition of a Cop/Fire/EMS gone to Rot. There's no coming back from Rot.
You were never taking her to medical
This guy is an awful liar.
He’s not going to cross the cops.
You can’t tell someone was severely beaten 3 times im so done with this witness
The box is in his head. It’s full of rocks
The officer that knocked her out said she was fine
What was I writing?? Dang it! I don't recall :-(
She had brain injury and they usually want to get away or go home, was she ready for round three with the dirty cop.
After being slammed unconscious
This EMT is being shady, if he recommended that she go yo the hospital then that’s what he meant. He is dodging the fact that he allowed someone other then the patient to sign the AMA. Only the patient can sign that document that’s why it says patient it doesn’t say or officer if she is handcuffed that’s ridiculous
That’s incorrect.
It’s preferable that the patient signs, but if the patient is not able to understand the consequences of their actions, if the patient is deemed incompetent, if the patient is altered, etc. there are a multitude of reasons the patient does not or shouldn’t sign.
and in that case witnesses, family members or people in position to provide care and services to the patient can sign.
@@dogma39-c4j yeah none of those things you mentioned apply! This person was completely able to sign. You either are a bit slow or disingenuous to pretend this thug in blue didn’t sign that AMA to cover up his behavior. He knew a trip to the hospital would generate more reports and possible in investigation. Let’s not play stupid
@@dogma39-c4jnot an officer/police
He was a terrible witness, doing all he could to be ambiguous and non responsive, protecting his abusive buddies and he's an EMT. I deffo wouldn't want him treating me n mine...... No way!
Any person can refuse medical attention or transport. Person or so called patient must be coherent. Gaged by level of consciousness.
What happened to the videos of the police brutality involved Officers Vickers and Albad? It happened in Atlanta. I was watching it and I went back to finish it and it was gone..
Am I the only one who thinks this dude seems pissed he's there? Like he's put out & they're wasting his time. His answers are kinda snarky & condescending
Why are they all trying to cover for this criminal
He is committed to his lies
Being deemed incapable of making rational decisions, shouldn't she have been taken by EMT anyhow? Chances are Borisade failed to mention that.
All EMS should have audio recorders, that whould cover them in these situations.
he was a 'EMT lieutenant' in 2016 .. and still is .. in 2020 ... Jacksonville you have a problem!!
do you take the pulse from a person whose handcuffed from behind?? 🤔 would it be medically reasonable to do so?? I mean she's not Hannibal.. if the cuffs were in the front.. ms..m could sign any forms and her pulse reading would be possibly accurate (?)
this 'EMT lieutenant' has shown dereliction of medical duty .. and seems part of a cover-up.. for the good ole boys the blue thin line ..
He's just another
Liar Liar 👖 on 🔥 ..
Don't get sick in Jacksonville.. or arrested!!
This thrash is acting like this is a joke.
This man stated in one comment the sum of his fears….. “I have 4 children”
This is so sad!! Unbelievable! WTF
I though just the police were corrupted but I guess fire and rescue are corrupted as well sounds like he didn’t want to do his job and was selecting options in his report that would make his job easier then actually accurate
His shirt should say Liar/Pants on Fire
When u tell the truth, your statements come out smoothly. It’s so easy to spot a liar
@sunswept58
For as long as I live, I will never understand why one, just ONE police officer could or would not have stepped in the help this woman ,,,, Why don't all the officers get a copy of the video where the woman was being beaten, have all your daughters sit with you, like its family night,,, Pass out the candy, popcorn, and soft drinks,,, Just roll the film and let them know what they have to look forward to in life when you are in the hands of someone who was to supposed to protect her,,, but beat her instead,,,,, as you, her father just watched it all happen ,,,
He can't remember what lies he told to cover up. I'm really starting to think they called him to try to cover their tracks.
He needs to resign
It's fun to watch this guy be so annoyed and uncomfortable. 😂
It’s the same I don’t recall anything
Good think he’s wearing that mask so that you don’t see his nose growing!
You can tell the firefighter/emt is a hostile witness. He doesn’t want to say anything that can be used against the police…
For those accusing this EMT of lying. I did some basic math to estimate how many calls he has gone on in the last 4 years (and even purposely estimated low). In 4 years he could have been on 84,000 different calls. I would challenge anyone to be picked apart on a call that happened before those 84,000 calls to remember exactly everything that happened on that one call.
Please show me your math
So you say that he goes on a call about 56 times every day, bear in mind I've countrd each and every day, and he for sure have free days and vacations and possibly was sick. 😵
I don’t think anyone is saying he should remember every detail of any call but as medical professionals we are taught to very meticulously document every interaction. Even if he only documented the highlights of this call he was absolutely negligent in his documentation. She was hit in the stomach and he never even exposed her abdomen to look for bruising. And that’s just one example. If this was your daughter or sister would you be satisfied with the care provided? WTF! I certainly wouldn’t be.
I feel confident this one wud stick in his memory tbf
That's the purpose of documentation!
Epic failure fire him
You chose poorly
I hope he never needs to treat me or my family.
Shame
I know he's fire/rescue... but this proves... bodycam IS A MUST.
I don't recall is criminals favorite line.
Well... if you don't recall... you need bodycam.
Just think how many people have been put in prison for years because all these corrupt criminals lie.. and lie to cover for another person.
Why do they all have such little respect for human beings. Such an evil profession.
Omertà in action, selective recall, slippery, and obviously guilty of something.
After watching all the depositions in the case there is one common thread. I cant recall, I don't remember, I don't know. The truly sad thing is no one was held responsible for their action's except for the woman beater. And he got off with simple battery and a small fine.
Taxpayers got to foot the bill. Hooray for the Taxpayers, that's why we can do what we do.
Lier
JSO cannot transport if patient refuses
For some reason it do not believe this EMT ! 🤦♀️
I thought only the cops lie. I guess I was wrong!
Spell your name Chitty Chitty Chitty bang bang I am employed in the city
Hope I never need that guys help !
I am in shock!
This is bullshit obviously she wasn’t hurt and saw a payday possibility and took it .
Oh my GOD..the Mayra`s Live in Killer cop hands?????