The book “The Origins & History of Judo” is now available on Amazon worldwide in English, French, and Japanese, not just the links below. You can search for it in the Amazon of your own country. Amazon EU: amzn.eu/d/bfEkJmQ Amazon US: a.co/d/dNyMInt Amazon Asia: amzn.asia/d/aRU8ZXn French version: amzn.eu/d/8SN3DNs Thank you all.
10th Planet warmups are basically kata for nogi BJJ. Maybe you should do a video on those. They're not like traditional kata in the sense that tori and uke are well-defined throughout the drill, but they are pre-arranged sequences
Kata/poomse/bunga/alike is the ancient form of memorization. Books and ink are expansive. Even if they have the materials they still need to hire artists or scribes to draw and write down stuff, they're expansive. So the most practical way is to create all these movements to memorize, it must be done carefully and repititively to maintain the form to be pass down for generations. It is not free from flaws as we can see katas will have slight difference over time and in different places. For example, we can see in Karate, the form changes from White Crane Kung Fu to whatever in the Karate styles. It is because when slight changes happens along the way, it becomes like the butterfly effect. Many traditional MA suffer this, but the positive side is it becomes diverse and open up to new posibilities. The negative side is, later the form becomes exclusive to each styles and protected secret, becomes rigid. Majority of MA practitioner today only memorize them to past the belt test without really know what behind the movements. Today, it is not that important, we have the technology to record everything and we can simply "steal" eachother's MA by watching videos. It is only important as cultural identity, to preserve. The rest of things can be replaced by modern equipments and sport science.
There have been a few, individual, modern attempts to open Judo dojos that focus on traditional self-defense or combat Judo, which openly teach Atemi-Waza (percussion strikes), in contradiction of Jigoro Kano's successors who limited Atemi-Waza instruction to first-degree black belt Shodan holders. I have a copy of a 1944 book co-authored by an American and Japanese-American Judo instructors who focused the book's curriculum on self-defense and combat aspects of original judo. They extensively included Atemi-Waza in the book. Some Jujutsu Ryu's of the past relied heavily on Atemi-Waza strikes while other ryu's were light on Atemi-Waza or hardly included any. Tenjin Shinyo Jujutsu relied much on Atemi-Waza. Jigoro Kano's new Judo derived from his instruction in two major Jujutsu Ryu's, Tenjin Shinyo Ryu and Kito Ryu, both of which included strikes and low kicks. My point is Kano's Judo was a new martial art that could be executed without resort to any strikes or low kicks yet still included a separate syllabus for Atemi-Waza, unlike classical Jujutsu in which Atemi-Waza was integral to the total curriculum.
Chadi, do you have any B roll of Judo Kata being performed? I would like to see how it compares to Swimming Dragon taolu from Shuai Jiao and Kung Fu. Don’t see any her, just drills.😊
Kata in this case means those drills. In Japanese culture it's not always referring to taolu that fixed association is really a misconception after the adoption karate to mainland Japan from okinawa
"BJJ practitioners will do drills on the ground without a partner, learning to move from their backs onto their front etc. Why is this any different from learning tenshin/taisabaki (principles of body movement) in traditional martial arts? One of the principle purposes of forms/kata is to teach (and provide a means of isloating and practising) such movement..." Source:
Judoka de haut niveau dans les règles pourries du judo moderne : mais dans le vrai judo originel c'est en combat libre qu'il faut être fort ! Mon judo restera toujours plus fort que ce "judo" si ils continuent avec leurs croyances absurdes (les katas-strophes, qu'on s'énerve pas je fais juste une toute petite blague 😅). Puis purée sérieux Bruce Lee il a déjà expliqué 5000 fois que les katas traditionnels ce n'est pas le summum pour gagner en efficacité 😮 Dans un vrai combat martial comme du MMA ou TOUT PEUX ARRIVER à la seconde : striking, lutte, cage control, lutte + coup de genou, sol, sol + striking avec la pression des coups au visage et rapides à la seconde allez ! Qu'on vienne M'EXPLIQUER MARTIALEMENT comment ca peut servir ces chorégraphies codifiées jusqu'à la moelle sérieusement ? La réponse est simple : à rien 😊
The book “The Origins & History of Judo” is now available on Amazon worldwide in English, French, and Japanese, not just the links below. You can search for it in the Amazon of your own country.
Amazon EU:
amzn.eu/d/bfEkJmQ
Amazon US:
a.co/d/dNyMInt
Amazon Asia:
amzn.asia/d/aRU8ZXn
French version:
amzn.eu/d/8SN3DNs
Thank you all.
Nice job with the book!
@@robertjakobson thank you
Ukemi, uchikomi, nagekomi, kata, randori, shiai like a pyramid
That's what makes judo, even more than the technique curriculum
10th Planet warmups are basically kata for nogi BJJ. Maybe you should do a video on those. They're not like traditional kata in the sense that tori and uke are well-defined throughout the drill, but they are pre-arranged sequences
Kata/poomse/bunga/alike is the ancient form of memorization. Books and ink are expansive. Even if they have the materials they still need to hire artists or scribes to draw and write down stuff, they're expansive. So the most practical way is to create all these movements to memorize, it must be done carefully and repititively to maintain the form to be pass down for generations. It is not free from flaws as we can see katas will have slight difference over time and in different places.
For example, we can see in Karate, the form changes from White Crane Kung Fu to whatever in the Karate styles. It is because when slight changes happens along the way, it becomes like the butterfly effect. Many traditional MA suffer this, but the positive side is it becomes diverse and open up to new posibilities. The negative side is, later the form becomes exclusive to each styles and protected secret, becomes rigid. Majority of MA practitioner today only memorize them to past the belt test without really know what behind the movements.
Today, it is not that important, we have the technology to record everything and we can simply "steal" eachother's MA by watching videos. It is only important as cultural identity, to preserve. The rest of things can be replaced by modern equipments and sport science.
@@MizanQistina we have more tools now, but practicing and feeling the intricacies will always be more valuable than watching videos.
There have been a few, individual, modern attempts to open Judo dojos that focus on traditional self-defense or combat Judo, which openly teach Atemi-Waza (percussion strikes), in contradiction of Jigoro Kano's successors who limited Atemi-Waza instruction to first-degree black belt Shodan holders.
I have a copy of a 1944 book co-authored by an American and Japanese-American Judo instructors who focused the book's curriculum on self-defense and combat aspects of original judo. They extensively included Atemi-Waza in the book.
Some Jujutsu Ryu's of the past relied heavily on Atemi-Waza strikes while other ryu's were light on Atemi-Waza or hardly included any. Tenjin Shinyo Jujutsu relied much on Atemi-Waza.
Jigoro Kano's new Judo derived from his instruction in two major Jujutsu Ryu's, Tenjin Shinyo Ryu and Kito Ryu, both of which included strikes and low kicks.
My point is Kano's Judo was a new martial art that could be executed without resort to any strikes or low kicks yet still included a separate syllabus for Atemi-Waza, unlike classical Jujutsu in which Atemi-Waza was integral to the total curriculum.
Chadi, do you have any B roll of Judo Kata being performed? I would like to see how it compares to Swimming Dragon taolu from Shuai Jiao and Kung Fu. Don’t see any her, just drills.😊
Kata in this case means those drills. In Japanese culture it's not always referring to taolu that fixed association is really a misconception after the adoption karate to mainland Japan from okinawa
Kodokan have a videos about Judo Kata, you can look at their channel.
"BJJ practitioners will do drills on the ground without a partner, learning to move from their backs onto their front etc. Why is this any different from learning tenshin/taisabaki (principles of body movement) in traditional martial arts? One of the principle purposes of forms/kata is to teach (and provide a means of isloating and practising) such movement..."
Source:
Judoka de haut niveau dans les règles pourries du judo moderne : mais dans le vrai judo originel c'est en combat libre qu'il faut être fort !
Mon judo restera toujours plus fort que ce "judo" si ils continuent avec leurs croyances absurdes (les katas-strophes, qu'on s'énerve pas je fais juste une toute petite blague 😅).
Puis purée sérieux Bruce Lee il a déjà expliqué 5000 fois que les katas traditionnels ce n'est pas le summum pour gagner en efficacité 😮
Dans un vrai combat martial comme du MMA ou TOUT PEUX ARRIVER à la seconde : striking, lutte, cage control, lutte + coup de genou, sol, sol + striking avec la pression des coups au visage et rapides à la seconde allez !
Qu'on vienne M'EXPLIQUER MARTIALEMENT comment ca peut servir ces chorégraphies codifiées jusqu'à la moelle sérieusement ?
La réponse est simple : à rien 😊
Привет Чади