Honestly I never liked Garden of Eyes mod simply because you have to pay for it, which is bullshit but trying to be as objective as possible I have to say that most of these weapons look pretty uninspired, a lot of them just have a different (simetimes very very slightly different) models and different vfx but pretty much identical to others, it just feels uninspired, quantity over quality. if anything I have to say that this video just makes me appreciate the Convergence mod even more and I am really thankful to the dev team for the awesome work they have put out.
It's worse knowing they make you pay for it MONTHLY in the case it updates, not just one and done. They also claim to "make the mod free when its done", but have said this for previous mods before they rebranded as GoE but never actually followed suit in doing that. They actually have current mods under the GoE rebrand that are complete yet force you to sub still. The mod also hardly even does any overhauling and is just a content dump, adding armors from previous games to even having bosses from previous games. Their original bosses aren't that great either, which most are either projectile vomit or burning your retinas with excessive effects, or just "previous souls boss but X theme" (the Helphen bosses have no unique attacks. they literally ported a cut boss and put a coat of ghostflame paint over it. the animations arent new and are reused from the cut boss that originally comes from Bloodborne.) Oh, and aside from this mod being uninspired and paywalled, they're also generally scummy and GoE's lead has done shady things before. Modding community generally just does not like this guy, and for good reason.
@@FlightoftheWicked Agreed, the worst part about people falling for the flashy trailers is that this will set a precedent and unless there is heavy backlash more people will try to paywall their mods.
Convergence is a really good mod, it's well worth the time of anyone who wants Elden Ring to feel fresh again! Plus it can give you a real power trip late-game, it's great. Whatever's in the video above isn't worth the attention.
Fun fact: Garden of Eyes is a scam. You have to pay a subscription in order to get updates on a monthly basis, some of the content is stolen from other modders, and the rest are just asset rips from other souls games. There is nothing original, and since it's payed, it's illegal. Do not get GoE.
I hope you understand that there is no single content stolen from other modders at all in the mod (if you want to mention Seamless Coop, it was since removed and apologized for 1 year ago), over 20 completely new designs for armors, over 50 completely new designs for weapons, and dozens of brand new areas and bosses created by our team.
@@GardenOfEyes And I hope you understand that charging money for modded content is not only scummy, but also illegal, which might bring a firm crackdown on all modding. Meaning your greed might harm the entire fromsoft modding community
No matter how hard those modders try, they'll always be compared to convergence and they'll always be down there. I hope they can think of reducing useless things and developing them further.
Convergence did it so much better... with more creativity, more coziness. And after all Convergence does pretty much everything new or at least with some differences while GoE borrows more ideas from other games and mods.
Borrow is quite an understatement when the "Creator" is literally taking credit for things he didn't do and also just payed others to do the work for him and the ones he did do work on, info and tutorials were spoonfed to him since he doesnt know how to do it yet he claims to found/learn it himself and that he taught it to someone when in fact that someone taught it to him. Not to mention the fact that paywall mods are literally against terms of service of 'monetizing Fromsoft's product with no permission' Even the word stealing, thief, and liar doesnt do it justice
This mod's getting a lot of hate because it's locked behind a paywall, and I feel like that's a bit of a deserved criticism. It's one thing to modify a game and have a patreon/donation option for people if they like the mod, but people can't even play this without shelling out $5/mo. Other mods like Convergence have more content, fit in the game's setting more, and have more polish while being completely free and thus attracting a WAY bigger fanbase than this is getting. From a profitability standpoint alone - there's a reason why WinRAR is free but suggests you pay. They earn 10x the profit by getting word of mouth out there and having people pay of their own volition instead of putting up a paywall and creating instant dislike.
Thanks for showing this! Now I know why I don't have the mod, it's very poorly made, damn. The effects look like ass and sear my eyes out. What a shame it's behind a paywall. I'm now not even gonna playtest it for free.
If it wasn’t bad enough that a lot of this stuff is just copy-pasted weapons from ER and Dark Souls, the creator is also ripping content other modders, then selling it all as paywalled half-assed content. Convergence does it better for free, and actually puts effort into what they create.
I love these weapons bhut i honestly think that Garden of Eyes would be better off fusing with convergence. Convergence has a lot more new content and it's free, but some things like bosses from dark souls and these weapons are pretty cool.
excessive, flashy, janky, uninspired and impractical as ever. Thank you, Garden of Slop. 💀 Anyone reading: save yourself the trouble and play Convergence or Reforged.
While I do agree with the unpolished component people are now going as far as saying that this creator is completely terrible for copying even though some weapons in convergence are copies from other games
Damn I hope eventually you feel the want to bring back the sanctum mace and bone fists in the sense of the ridiculous knockback and down but the ruinous flame fist arm amazing with the almost same 2 handed moveset. Best thing in the game was that mace though it was my baby.
It's like those toy adverts where they show all this shiny stuff but once you buy it, it's dog shit. What you want are those free passion projects, like Convergence.
It took a very long time, I have been meaning to include snippets. Never did because of time to do it and added time on the video but the latter doesn't really matter now
Woulkd really love some bow and arrow action ngl, bow and arrows are heavily nerfed and bad in elden ring I would love it if they make some unique and OP bow and arrow
As much as I'd want to try the mod, no thanks. Yeah it costs money which is total bs by mod standards, but so many of these weapons are very unpolished with their animations and MAAAN I can NOT handle how overdone the effects are! I'm going to use Convergence as a comparison. One of the weapons Convergence introduced in their mod is a one handed magic axe and it's ash of war is basically multiple bright blue ray slashes with a follow up (I'm pretty sure Snuggly has it in a video.) What I love about that AOW is that even though the effects are bright, it's NOT BLINDING. Or even worse, because of the amount of effects going on, it covers way too much of the surrounding area which could lead to many punishes to the player. So many of the Garden of Eyes weapons are way too blinding or have WAY too much going on too the point it's very uncomfortable to the eyes.
It's a shame this mod never worked when I tried it. Broken garbage! Not even functional on a fresh installation on latest drivers and a modern system. Permanent black screen sim, go play Convergence where it's FREE!
it's because the game updated to 1.10.1 that's why the convergence mod broke. stop complaining since it's free for everybody. if you really can't wait for new update on convergence then look up how to downgrade elden ring and then you can play with convergence mod.
@@eternaldarkness2590 You didn't even read what I fucking typed how do you even do that LMAO bro I said GARDEN is broken. PRIOR to the update my friend. As in it is a shit mod and doesn't work even when it IS up to date. Convergence is fine I've played it since ds3. Great mod.
I think of the garden of eyes stuff as previews of cool mods, and because theyre all stolen and you have to pay for them i see which stuff is col and install that instead
great work here! just, may I make a suggestion? it would've been nice if the animation of the buff of the gloamed-eyed greatsword was similar to the one of the dark moon greatsword, with the power coming from the skies...
Yes, these issues have been caused due to an older tool being used, and have been addressed alongside Margit's Cane and Gravity Ore Blade, and many others, and fixed in the latest patch. Thanks for noting :D
Crazy how people have this negative of a reaction to someone asking to be paid for their work If you dont want to buy it you can simply not buy it and move on
Convergence is a really good mod, it's well worth the time of anyone who wants Elden Ring to feel fresh again! Plus it can give you a real power trip late-game, it's great. Whatever's in the video above isn't worth the attention.
I really like the fact that Margit's cane randowly swaps from right to left hand without any animation 15:02. And this is also behind paywall.
Honestly I never liked Garden of Eyes mod simply because you have to pay for it, which is bullshit but trying to be as objective as possible I have to say that most of these weapons look pretty uninspired, a lot of them just have a different (simetimes very very slightly different) models and different vfx but pretty much identical to others, it just feels uninspired, quantity over quality.
if anything I have to say that this video just makes me appreciate the Convergence mod even more and I am really thankful to the dev team for the awesome work they have put out.
It's worse knowing they make you pay for it MONTHLY in the case it updates, not just one and done. They also claim to "make the mod free when its done", but have said this for previous mods before they rebranded as GoE but never actually followed suit in doing that. They actually have current mods under the GoE rebrand that are complete yet force you to sub still. The mod also hardly even does any overhauling and is just a content dump, adding armors from previous games to even having bosses from previous games. Their original bosses aren't that great either, which most are either projectile vomit or burning your retinas with excessive effects, or just "previous souls boss but X theme" (the Helphen bosses have no unique attacks. they literally ported a cut boss and put a coat of ghostflame paint over it. the animations arent new and are reused from the cut boss that originally comes from Bloodborne.) Oh, and aside from this mod being uninspired and paywalled, they're also generally scummy and GoE's lead has done shady things before. Modding community generally just does not like this guy, and for good reason.
Paywalling for asset flips is always a stupid thing to do. Makes me kinda sad that so many people fall for it though...
@@ValomyrsLight Couldn't have said it better my self honestly.
@@FlightoftheWicked Agreed, the worst part about people falling for the flashy trailers is that this will set a precedent and unless there is heavy backlash more people will try to paywall their mods.
Convergence is a really good mod, it's well worth the time of anyone who wants Elden Ring to feel fresh again! Plus it can give you a real power trip late-game, it's great.
Whatever's in the video above isn't worth the attention.
Fun fact: Garden of Eyes is a scam. You have to pay a subscription in order to get updates on a monthly basis, some of the content is stolen from other modders, and the rest are just asset rips from other souls games. There is nothing original, and since it's payed, it's illegal. Do not get GoE.
I hope you understand that there is no single content stolen from other modders at all in the mod (if you want to mention Seamless Coop, it was since removed and apologized for 1 year ago), over 20 completely new designs for armors, over 50 completely new designs for weapons, and dozens of brand new areas and bosses created by our team.
@GardenOfEyes Yea but charging a subscription service for a mod is pretty scummy
@@GardenOfEyes And I hope you understand that charging money for modded content is not only scummy, but also illegal, which might bring a firm crackdown on all modding. Meaning your greed might harm the entire fromsoft modding community
@@GardenOfEyesAs someone who works on the Convergence Mod, you really do out every at risk. Making it paid
@@GardenOfEyes get out of here you scammer
An absence of sheathe animations on meteoric ore blade made made me laugh my *** off, i mean, that's the quality they ask us to pay for?
This folks, is quantity over quality.
And even quantity isn't something impressive compared to things like The Convergence
No matter how hard those modders try, they'll always be compared to convergence and they'll always be down there. I hope they can think of reducing useless things and developing them further.
I like that theres a bunch of unique stuff then just the firelink greatsword
smelter demon swords too. at least they look good in elden ring, maybe i would get this mod if it wasnt behind a freaking paywall.
@@spicymeatandseafoodfry6648 yeah I watched it through and a lot are just reused assets
Fromsoftware and Namco should sue this guy.
How is it that Garden of Eyes hasn’t gotten into legal trouble yet?
Convergence >>>>>>> Garden of eyes
Imagine making us pay for mods that's crazy
@@DaddySaddo that barely works😩
@@DaddySaddoWell, it's incredibly easy to download GOE if you know where to look. It's not worth it even for free.
Thanks!
He deleted my comment lol.
Convergence did it so much better... with more creativity, more coziness. And after all Convergence does pretty much everything new or at least with some differences while GoE borrows more ideas from other games and mods.
It’s DS3 cinders vs convergence all over again.
Borrow is quite an understatement when the "Creator" is literally taking credit for things he didn't do and also just payed others to do the work for him and the ones he did do work on, info and tutorials were spoonfed to him since he doesnt know how to do it yet he claims to found/learn it himself and that he taught it to someone when in fact that someone taught it to him. Not to mention the fact that paywall mods are literally against terms of service of 'monetizing Fromsoft's product with no permission'
Even the word stealing, thief, and liar doesnt do it justice
@@ThatOneGuyYaKnow I just tried to be more polite, y'know. But in most of your words... I kinda agree.
That's fair I guess
@@ItJustJacob only difference is GoE is somehow worse than cinders lul
This mod's getting a lot of hate because it's locked behind a paywall, and I feel like that's a bit of a deserved criticism. It's one thing to modify a game and have a patreon/donation option for people if they like the mod, but people can't even play this without shelling out $5/mo.
Other mods like Convergence have more content, fit in the game's setting more, and have more polish while being completely free and thus attracting a WAY bigger fanbase than this is getting. From a profitability standpoint alone - there's a reason why WinRAR is free but suggests you pay. They earn 10x the profit by getting word of mouth out there and having people pay of their own volition instead of putting up a paywall and creating instant dislike.
true I fuck with winrar
Thank you Snuggly. Damn, 50 mins lol. Thank you again friend.
Thanks for showing this! Now I know why I don't have the mod, it's very poorly made, damn. The effects look like ass and sear my eyes out. What a shame it's behind a paywall. I'm now not even gonna playtest it for free.
If it wasn’t bad enough that a lot of this stuff is just copy-pasted weapons from ER and Dark Souls, the creator is also ripping content other modders, then selling it all as paywalled half-assed content. Convergence does it better for free, and actually puts effort into what they create.
I love these weapons bhut i honestly think that Garden of Eyes would be better off fusing with convergence. Convergence has a lot more new content and it's free, but some things like bosses from dark souls and these weapons are pretty cool.
Gardens of eyes steals assets they are very scummy don’t trust them
We will never merge with Garden of Eyes.
@@Detriax good
We don’t really support what they do on the team.
@@Detriax who's "we"?
excessive, flashy, janky, uninspired and impractical as ever. Thank you, Garden of Slop. 💀
Anyone reading: save yourself the trouble and play Convergence or Reforged.
Margit's cane Moveset already existed in Clever's Moveset lol
Meh, convergence mod much better, although, margit cane is really good
We are adding a Margit Cane to Convergence, don’t worry
How it swaps hands without animation? As shoddy as the rest.
@@Detriax Oh for real? Hell to the goddamn yes.
@@WafflesMgee Indeed!
@@DetriaxPEAK
Well good to know that they got sote weapons out before sote
While I do agree with the unpolished component people are now going as far as saying that this creator is completely terrible for copying even though some weapons in convergence are copies from other games
That and he puts this all behind a paywall
@@zachromani3265true on that
Preferred the DS2 smelter swords. Attacks came out faster
50:14 Was Ancient Lightning Charge a typo or is that actually what the ash of war was called in the mod?
Yeah it is a typo, that was my bad!
Damn I hope eventually you feel the want to bring back the sanctum mace and bone fists in the sense of the ridiculous knockback and down but the ruinous flame fist arm amazing with the almost same 2 handed moveset. Best thing in the game was that mace though it was my baby.
How come the jump attacks come out after landing and not on button command?
MORE???
Aw Ensa and that gauntlet look so damn good
It all seems so bloody janky and unpolished, for some reason. I'm willing to bet it's horribly unbalanced too...
It is it’s terrible terrible mod the convergence mod is good though
It's like those toy adverts where they show all this shiny stuff but once you buy it, it's dog shit. What you want are those free passion projects, like Convergence.
My brother in christ, I NEED TO PLAY WITH RAIJIN & FUJIN
Impressive, it must have taken a while to record this! Is there any chance of showcasing the item descriptions?
It took a very long time, I have been meaning to include snippets. Never did because of time to do it and added time on the video but the latter doesn't really matter now
@@SnugglytheCrowDS1Fair enough.
Fume sword is so f*ckin lazy. raime himself would take matters into his own hands if he saw the level of disrespect
The fact that you have to pay to use a mod is ridiculous. Wanting to profit from a work that is not yours is a crime!
13:50 terra magica would go crazy
Woulkd really love some bow and arrow action ngl, bow and arrows are heavily nerfed and bad in elden ring I would love it if they make some unique and OP bow and arrow
hey cool video, may would you do the armor of the mods ?
As much as I'd want to try the mod, no thanks. Yeah it costs money which is total bs by mod standards, but so many of these weapons are very unpolished with their animations and MAAAN I can NOT handle how overdone the effects are! I'm going to use Convergence as a comparison. One of the weapons Convergence introduced in their mod is a one handed magic axe and it's ash of war is basically multiple bright blue ray slashes with a follow up (I'm pretty sure Snuggly has it in a video.) What I love about that AOW is that even though the effects are bright, it's NOT BLINDING. Or even worse, because of the amount of effects going on, it covers way too much of the surrounding area which could lead to many punishes to the player. So many of the Garden of Eyes weapons are way too blinding or have WAY too much going on too the point it's very uncomfortable to the eyes.
5:01
Even in the Elden ring, this sword didn't reach its full potential.
04:50 like demon slayer
It's a shame this mod never worked when I tried it. Broken garbage! Not even functional on a fresh installation on latest drivers and a modern system. Permanent black screen sim, go play Convergence where it's FREE!
Oh and to add all that the mods discord is dead and you absolutely will not recieve help when needed. Actual days between general chat activity.
it's because the game updated to 1.10.1 that's why the convergence mod broke. stop complaining since it's free for everybody. if you really can't wait for new update on convergence then look up how to downgrade elden ring and then you can play with convergence mod.
There's an alt save mod that's a workaround until it gets updated. My friend and I can play it again
@@eternaldarkness2590 You didn't even read what I fucking typed how do you even do that LMAO bro I said GARDEN is broken. PRIOR to the update my friend.
As in it is a shit mod and doesn't work even when it IS up to date.
Convergence is fine I've played it since ds3. Great mod.
now you have become a boss
Rajin and fujin is amazing
its like a Cyberpunk 1677, not Elden Ring 😁
I think of the garden of eyes stuff as previews of cool mods, and because theyre all stolen and you have to pay for them i see which stuff is col and install that instead
wow more epic somber weapons with le constant particle effects. not like theres an entire infusion and ash of war system.
I'm annoyed at myself for liking the Ensa admittedly. *"one handed"
They cant even fix the jump attack being double? Lop
Can you showcase the new armors also?
Yeah I might do a showcase down the line :)
Una pregunta ¿Cual es la música de fondo? Me vendría muy bien para dormir
great work here! just, may I make a suggestion? it would've been nice if the animation of the buff of the gloamed-eyed greatsword was similar to the one of the dark moon greatsword, with the power coming from the skies...
He's just showcaser, not author.
Bro the ensa weapon looks so awful😭
Garden of bs. Im not paying for a mod
Convergence and Garden of Eyes I swear to god are works of art
Not an ounce of Garden of Eyes is original content plus it's a mod you have to pay for which is illegal.
Thanks! Everyone works really hard to make the content!
@@broccolin I already knew that I didn’t say it was part of the game
Ok@@dynamo7685
Convergence = Work of Art.
Garden of Eyes = Work of Fart.
i think i need to redownload it
the armor is way too shiny for the world it is in.
where's the daggers at?
You can get them in the new roundtable hold from a statue on the upper left
how to download this mod
Does anyone know if you can summon friends using these mods ?
If you run seamless coop you should be able to, am I'm fairly certain Goe is compatible
most animations even though they look cool, they are overwhelming and not really practical in the game. probably unbalanced also.
Some weapons jump heavy attacks seem to have problems, there are stalls
Yes, these issues have been caused due to an older tool being used, and have been addressed alongside Margit's Cane and Gravity Ore Blade, and many others, and fixed in the latest patch. Thanks for noting :D
Anyone know how to get the models from Demon Souls Remake?
modならタイトルにmodと書いておくべき
me sad, no reapers ;;-;;
Margits cane is awesome
Who the fuck pays for mods? That's why convergence is better😂😊
Can we please have this officially in the game?!
He’s a cheater
Fake
Crazy how people have this negative of a reaction to someone asking to be paid for their work
If you dont want to buy it you can simply not buy it and move on
Is this real or no
Convergence is a really good mod, it's well worth the time of anyone who wants Elden Ring to feel fresh again! Plus it can give you a real power trip late-game, it's great.
Whatever's in the video above isn't worth the attention.