...she's got a number in that category & our dear Mr. Rawlings has taken up writing his own as well! Another great one is "I Dream a Highway". Or how about "Annabelle", "Caleb Meyer"? :]
@@CaalamusTubeThey are all amazing, but Caleb Meyer is an exceptionally astounding song. They slay that song so strong and hard it takes your breath away.
@@debrabeck9630 Indeed! ...you heard "Cumberland Gap" ? Yikes! It's beyond me how these two are obscure... yet mumble rap gangbanger bullshit & brain dead blow up dolls top the charts! :[
We have tickets to see Gillian and Dave soon. They haven’t been out touring since covid. We bought the new album and when we got word that they are playing some shows, we got tickets! My wife and I try to learn a few of their songs. It’s music therapy and it’s fun. We just try to learn how to fly around the way they do. So nice.
These two are best musician-singer-composers since the Beatles. Look at how they face into one another, look at one another, and become one singer and player. They sing this piece in unison during the verses; they are perfectly in tune. They nail their pitches again, again, again. Their harmonies melt my heart. Wow!
So beautiful. Their performances are even more amazing when you realize they're playing unamplified guitars into stage mics. And Rawlings' guitar is a 1935 Epiphone Olympic he rescued off the floor in a friend's garage.
Gillian Welch and David Rawlings have to be considered one of the best two piece bands of all times. I’d put them up there with Muddy Waters and Little Walter even.
..... This is the beauty of harmony, that mysterious third voice that can be heard between the two vocalists.... i love this , keep playing it over.......
I saw these two wonderful artists together at The Three Rivers Music Festival years ago, and they are still one of the best duos in music history. They blend together so well!!
Many comments seem surprised at the Welch/Rawlings talent! They have been performing like this for YEARS, buy their music,and there is lots of it,and see them live! You will be blessed!!
I had the honor to play bass on the side of Chris Whitley for years. This couple ... how they play and feel together ... it's nothing less than the power of music: The power of love
Chris was something, I played with him just a couple of times by chance - just jamming buddies when he was starting out in Greenwich Village, he had a buddy Warren or something played a mean blues harp - I was a good player even then, but man he totally smoked me.
so cool... chris and gillian/david are in a very similar lane when it comes to naturally amazing song writers in my opinion, its like theres another level to every song compared to other people, P&L
I walked in to a record store in 1990 and over the sound system I heard "We still runnin'?" and I just knew I was about to hear something special! Saw him live a few years later in Glasgow, Scotland. The real thing.
The simplicity, yet power of unison vocals. Synchronized and brooding. Harder to execute than most would assume. They go into harmony, also, but man that unison hits you.
I only recently came across this masterpiece. It's been on my mind ever since. The performance is stunning, and the quality of the recording is incredible ... but THE SONG... the song is firmly planted in my mind. I can listen to it a dozen times on repeat, always hearing something magical I missed before. Truly Breathtaking.
Maynard mentioned her name, so I looked her up, and it came to this video. By the middle of the song tears rolled down my face just how connected they were with each other and everyone's expressions. Priceless
Gary MacMillan - at 3:22 he starts a very short riff that sounds like harmonics but it’s really unusual. Fits perfectly with the song, of course. Talk about complete, nearly unconscious, mastery of your instrument,ent.
The first time I ever saw or heard (of) them was live when they opened for someone else. Dave's playing made my head and body want to explode. It was fricking amazing. I've been a fan ever since.
Life in Middle Tennessee: “Hey let’s go get lunch. Oh what’s that? Just two of the most amazing artists on the continent playing a heartbreaker. Yes. I’d like fries with that.”
Amazing, simply amazing. And live. I don't think I've heard any artists sound this epic live in my entire country life. It takes me back to places I wish I never left. Blessing from South Australia 🇦🇺
Jesus h Christ so perfect. I've been playing this song over and over- these two are my favorite musicians ever. Gillian is so beautiful and David is soooo beautiful too.
I don't get how some of the audience are not paying attention and eating, their backs to the musicians. What an incredible performance. Yep I felt the power of this.
This song absolutely gutted me the very first time I heard it. My first listen through Harrow & Harvest. I got to this track, and I just kept replaying it. Later played it for a musically gifted singer and friend who'd recorded some albums. He sat there nodding and said, "I like the way they doubled her vocals." I grinned and said, "Huh-uh. That's her *and him*. Probably live in the studio." Thrilling to see them do it live. And the song STILL guts me. One of the most beautiful things I've ever heard. Thanks for posting it.
I love The Harrow & The Harvest but I only just discovered this vid. I thought she had double tracked her voice as well. Seeing them doing it like this is just off the scale - love it!
John Prine says when he goes to heaven he's going to open up a bar called the Tree of Forgiveness, let's all meet there sometime, drinks should be cheap in heaven and maybe no hangovers.
These two have honed thier craft in such a way as to rip me open, expose my secrets and have helped me understand more closely what real love costs. While bittersweet this absolutely works it’s way into the fabric of the human soul!!
Gillian and Dave. A truly glorious and lasting musical collaboration. Makes one feel honored to be fortunate enough to be hearing them.
Every time I come back to this, I’m always disappointed that I can’t add another thumbs up.
I love it too....
@@MargaretHillsdeZ I can... there ya go, love it...
Same here ...
you can make another comment like "back here again" and wait for people to thumb that up
Totally, it’s hypnotic!
I come back to this vid every season to be reminded that magic exists in this world.
Same bro. Also.. I love your videos. Now I love you more knowing that you love this video😂
Can't tell where one voice ends and one begins
Sublime
“I lost YOU awhile ago...and I still don’t know why. Can’t say your name without a crow Flying By.” That’s How you Open a Song. Whew
Especially wild because it's been happening to me since a very painful break-up a few months ago. I wanna know what those crows know.
If ever there were two people meant to perform music together it’s these two
This is so impeccable that it's almost overwhelming.
veronica maggio on the verge of tears the entire performance -- she is all of us
Ans dave playing that old cheap guitar! He makes it sound so amazing.
This has to be one of the most beautiful songs ever written. And how many vocalists nowadays can pull off a live performance that perfect?
The lyrics are magic, like so many of theirs are. It is beautiful...🎩
Amen! And VERY nearly NONE!
...she's got a number in that category & our dear Mr. Rawlings has taken up writing his own as well!
Another great one is "I Dream a Highway". Or how about "Annabelle", "Caleb Meyer"? :]
@@CaalamusTubeThey are all amazing, but Caleb Meyer is an exceptionally astounding song. They slay that song so strong and hard it takes your breath away.
@@debrabeck9630 Indeed! ...you heard "Cumberland Gap" ? Yikes!
It's beyond me how these two are obscure... yet mumble rap gangbanger bullshit & brain dead blow up dolls top the charts! :[
The puzzled faces of a confused and dazed audience - unaware they were going to become significantly more human on this day... well it's pure gold.
We have tickets to see Gillian and Dave soon. They haven’t been out touring since covid. We bought the new album and when we got word that they are playing some shows, we got tickets!
My wife and I try to learn a few of their songs. It’s music therapy and it’s fun.
We just try to learn how to fly around the way they do. So nice.
Thank you God for the gift of hearing.
Regardless of what genre you come from, whether you listen to classic, punk, or techno: This is impeccable musicianship.
seeing them live was so memorable. I love Gillian and Dave!
Veronica Maggio looks close to tears. That's how I feel every time I hear this.
These two are best musician-singer-composers since the Beatles. Look at how they face into one another, look at one another, and become one singer and player. They sing this piece in unison during the verses; they are perfectly in tune. They nail their pitches again, again, again. Their harmonies melt my heart. Wow!
So beautiful. Their performances are even more amazing when you realize they're playing unamplified guitars into stage mics. And Rawlings' guitar is a 1935 Epiphone Olympic he rescued off the floor in a friend's garage.
I was wondering what he was playing. They kept close up on hers but bad angles on his. Thanks for point this out
I come back to this an awful lot.
Me too. Stunning
I do, too.
Every time I find my way back here I'm blown away all over again.
This is a song I will come back to hear every so often for the rest of my life.
Dave Rawlings is my favorite living guitarist. Totally uniquely expressive and technically brilliant as well.
Yes, I agree. But I love Derek Trucks as much. And Warren Haynes, and Jimmy Herring and...
Agreed . . no pedals here
One of my favorites too, but if you like him you should check out Molly Tuttle….probably the best acoustic guitarist in the world right now…
He and Julian Lage are pure taste. I’d put Nels Cline in their category too.
Billy Strings humbly enters the chat
Two of the most underrated artists of all time. Especially Gillian. I consider myself blessed to be British and know who she is. Lol
Gillian Welch and David Rawlings have to be considered one of the best two piece bands of all times. I’d put them up there with Muddy Waters and Little Walter even.
The way the blond-haired woman looks at 1:09 is the way my heart feels every time I listen to this song. Sorrow, awe, and beauty all wrapped in one.
And she is one of the best and most popular popsingers/composers in Sweden.
She looks like Lady Gaga!
She's a musician too !
@@Macosciswho is she?
@@9NailsVeronica Maggio
Beautiful sound of old archtop epiphone!!! but...the artist..he is a great guitar player.
Somebody really needs to give that blonde lady a hug.
So beautiful, honest, naked and fragile. An act of true masterpiece art and musical craft.🙏❤️
I love the emotion Veronica Maggio (blonde) shows on her face. It is like she feels every ounce of sadness written into this song.
We are all blessed that these two found each other!!
They're so real. No plastic shiney veneer. Thank God for the musicians that don't sellout to the big label crap.
Nerves of steel to be that perfect for all of their career.
Yep. And no scandals. No controvery. Just pure love of the music .
This is one of the most beautiful songs & performances - Outstanding!
..... This is the beauty of harmony, that mysterious third voice that can be heard between the two vocalists.... i love this , keep playing it over.......
I saw these two wonderful artists together at The Three Rivers Music Festival years ago, and they are still one of the best duos in music history. They blend together so well!!
yo bro.i,ll drink a pint of scrumpy to that. makes me wanna play my fiddle. Superb musicians raw ready robust.
Many comments seem surprised at the Welch/Rawlings talent! They have been performing like this for YEARS, buy their music,and there is lots of it,and see them live! You will be blessed!!
I had the honor to play bass on the side of Chris Whitley for years. This couple ... how they play and feel together ... it's nothing less than the power of music: The power of love
Chris,,,Such a Fine Man
Chris was something, I played with him just a couple of times by chance - just jamming buddies when he was starting out in Greenwich Village, he had a buddy Warren or something played a mean blues harp - I was a good player even then, but man he totally smoked me.
so cool... chris and gillian/david are in a very similar lane when it comes to naturally amazing song writers in my opinion, its like theres another level to every song compared to other people, P&L
I walked in to a record store in 1990 and over the sound system I heard "We still runnin'?" and I just knew I was about to hear something special! Saw him live a few years later in Glasgow, Scotland. The real thing.
This is a profound moment in space and time.
The harmonies are unbelievable! This song is the benefit of making music together for many, many years.
The simplicity, yet power of unison vocals. Synchronized and brooding. Harder to execute than most would assume. They go into harmony, also, but man that unison hits you.
right! I wasn’t watching the screen at the beginning, and for a moment I actually thought it was only one voice with reverb. Just breathtaking.
Not to mention Dave is weaving these fills that seems so effortless while meeting Gillian in a heartfelt moment. These guys are breathtaking.
You’re very right. It blew me away off the bat.
You are right - the power of unison vocals is just incredible ....
You said exactly what I feel. Greetings from Germany 🤗
i have watched this so many times....
I only recently came across this masterpiece. It's been on my mind ever since. The performance is stunning, and the quality of the recording is incredible ... but THE SONG... the song is firmly planted in my mind. I can listen to it a dozen times on repeat, always hearing something magical I missed before.
Truly Breathtaking.
The way Rawlings plays those solos on that old Epiphone speaks to my soul. Earth shatteringly beautiful.
Maynard mentioned her name, so I looked her up, and it came to this video. By the middle of the song tears rolled down my face just how connected they were with each other and everyone's expressions.
Priceless
Me too, me too man, just overwhelmed
Maynard? TOOL?
@@chrismartin3197
Yes
Dave Rawlings is an amazing guitarist.
I love his style!
Yes he is
Yes he is. Just came across this interview with him and how he started playing
th-cam.com/video/PyWTzAoZhzE/w-d-xo.html
Gary MacMillan - at 3:22 he starts a very short riff that sounds like harmonics but it’s really unusual. Fits perfectly with the song, of course. Talk about complete, nearly unconscious, mastery of your instrument,ent.
And check out the harmony line he sings. Absolutely perfect
Reminds me of Cosby, Stills, Nash and Young ... beautiful.
I come back here every so often..good for the soul.
At age 65 I have been blessed to hear one of the finest live acoustic performances ever. Thank you both.
When they switch voices after the four minute mark, who else could do that? It's just astounding.
David's use of chromatics and dissonance in his playing is unique among musicians. Beautiful.
The first time I ever saw or heard (of) them was live when they opened for someone else. Dave's playing made my head and body want to explode. It was fricking amazing. I've been a fan ever since.
Love the way he uses open notes
It really adds to the beauty and mystique of the songs as opposed to just sounding like imposed sophistication
In his harmonies, as well. Really unique note choices.
See these two perform every chance you get. 100 years from now there will books written about their music, their chemistry. This is magic music.
I keep coming back to this beautiful sad tale....What beautiful music.
Life in Middle Tennessee:
“Hey let’s go get lunch. Oh what’s that? Just two of the most amazing artists on the continent playing a heartbreaker.
Yes. I’d like fries with that.”
I really have to visit sometime. I'm from Wales but all my fav music is from the southern US
These 2 were destined to be together. They compliment each other perfectly.
Fantastic, every time. Props to the audio people who worked during this shoot for capturing the vocals so perfectly.
Who else is on listen # ?? What?! 25 times now ?! i love this song , a true blessing from the music Gods
Does not get better than this. Those lucky people sitting there eating!!
Amazing, simply amazing. And live. I don't think I've heard any artists sound this epic live in my entire country life.
It takes me back to places I wish I never left.
Blessing from South Australia 🇦🇺
Hi! Another big fan of Gillian and David here in Adelaide. Gerry.
Gillian and Dave are truly great! Thank you for posting.
@gregnormal9075 My husband and I are huge fans!
Jesus h Christ so perfect. I've been playing this song over and over- these two are my favorite musicians ever. Gillian is so beautiful and David is soooo beautiful too.
The haunting harmony of Welch and Rawlings will quiet a room - and that's the way it will always be.
Chills and tears through the whole damn thing. Their voices are like one voice.
I don't get how some of the audience are not paying attention and eating, their backs to the musicians. What an incredible performance. Yep I felt the power of this.
Magic and wonder humbly pass among us.
Prefect. Makes me a little sick to my stomach from it's realness. Thank you both for being real.
Just discovered this and watched it for the fifth time in a row. Wow.
May we all find someone that we are in sync with the way these two are.
These guys are the best there is. Anywhere at any time.
Listen to this & you will never again be satisfied with anything else.
This song absolutely gutted me the very first time I heard it. My first listen through Harrow & Harvest. I got to this track, and I just kept replaying it. Later played it for a musically gifted singer and friend who'd recorded some albums. He sat there nodding and said, "I like the way they doubled her vocals." I grinned and said, "Huh-uh. That's her *and him*. Probably live in the studio." Thrilling to see them do it live.
And the song STILL guts me. One of the most beautiful things I've ever heard. Thanks for posting it.
The entire album is a masterpiece.
@@mikelabomusic7782 Hear hear
I love The Harrow & The Harvest but I only just discovered this vid. I thought she had double tracked her voice as well. Seeing them doing it like this is just off the scale - love it!
I now have a picture of what heaven should look like. A friendly bar with Gillian Welch playing and an empty seat on the table for me.
There is some real magic going on here.
Next drinks on me lol
Yep...my heaven
Boring.
John Prine says when he goes to heaven he's going to open up a bar called the Tree of Forgiveness, let's all meet there sometime, drinks should be cheap in heaven and maybe no hangovers.
The blonde lady's emotions are just beautiful to see.
She knows the deal.
Yeah and the fact she got Meagan markle there was impressive
Magnificent. The way the verses are all in unison, and the choruses are harmonized for emphasis. The switch grabs you every time.
Gillian looks so elegant with graying hair.
James Smith it suits her spirit & songwriting, which are full of so much experience, wisdom, sorrow, time gone by...
Yeah I don't know why celebrities try to avoid that. She looks so... dignified.
@@pauljones5066 lol why?
I wished more people would realize how beautiful natural is. It looks good on anybody.
Majestic wooden music hits you at a cellular level
Really enjoyed this. Been a fan 25 years. Aging gracefully and talent keeps increasing. Love you two. God bless you and keep you.
Reminds me of a CSN tune, the tight harmonies. Excellent tune.
We have hardly ever known this couple in Sweden. I just saw the clip and loved it right away :-) Gillian & Dave will be on my radar now :-)
blown away every time I watch this.
We all seek something Holy. This is it folks.
Vonnegut wrote what we actually want is "non-epiphany" where we can be free from any godness.
Feminism is not '"Holy".
@@sunnyjim1355 Are you that triggered by this talented woman?
No words except one: stunning.
These two are one of a kind, incredible ❤
The beauty of that woman burns so brightly from within that you fear she may burst into flame at any moment.
Music is sacred!
Some
Somebody posted that the Gillian beat is just like a heart beat. Slow and sad. “I’ve never been served anything that tasted so bad.” Wow.
I can't believe this was recorded live, it's too good
Gillan and Dave, as real and as good as it gets! ❤️
Dave and Gillian are artists of the highest order
wow immediately struck me how perfectly in unison they sing and how well their voices fit together
Beautiful, moving song, tears
This a beautiful song, and incredibly well-executed. I'm speechless.
You so rarely see unison singing used effectively, but their tones blend together so well. So warm, sweet and light
Acoustic perfection. There is nothing better.
The way Dave orchestrates the song, I love it ...Love these two
these two have such perfect flow. You can see these two know each other well.
My God these two make music and harmonize like no one else, captivating, powerful and as beautiful as it gets.
👍🏻 There you go brother. Love and peace from Lancashire. Will pop in there one day.
X
They make beautiful music together. His picking is truly unique.
These is REAL country music.
Holy smoke. I can't stop watching this. Hypnotizing.
"I've never been so disabused, I've never been so mad; I've never been served anything that tasted so bad."
These two have honed thier craft in such a way
as to rip me open, expose my secrets and have helped me understand more closely what real love costs. While bittersweet this absolutely works it’s way into the fabric of the human soul!!
The audio is immaculate. The song that had to be sung.
Good unison is harder than harmony. This is awesome.
How special these two are together. Amazing. 🤙🤙❤️
Such a beautiful duet, with each partner read in the yes of the other and play sing accordingly. Priceless as they say. I love them.