國外聲樂老師對比 孫楠 鄧紫棋 汪峰《存在》舞台 VocalCoach Rozette's Comparison Reaction of Existence
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.ย. 2024
- Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili...
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on TH-cam: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia....
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #孙楠 #邓紫棋 #汪峰 #rozette
Gem的「存在」 真的嚇死人， 第一次 在電視看的時候， 嚇了一跳， 唱得這麼厲害， 把原曲的難度 提升一倍
但我還是喜歡汪峰唱的…雖然他後期嗓音真的不行了😂這首是汪峰自己做的詞所以更能唱出這首歌要表達的！我到現在還是很常聽汪峰唱的存在，因為歌詞真的超棒！
汪峰的沙啞高音難度也不亞於GEM
That performance of GEM in the 2nd round of The Singer was one of gem's bigger rounds. I have heard it many times and I really like her version. Though Wang Feng wrote the song and should sing it with more feeling. He's getting on now. I think the years of straining like that has taken its toll. Funny thing is that he was in Singer 2018 with Jessie J, Hua Chenyu and KZ and got through to the final, though he came in 5th I think. He even won a couple of rounds and came runner up and 3rd in two others. I thought that he was really good then. He also wrote a song for the Olympics some years ago. There was a singer called Beibei on the voice who sang this song on the battle round Wang Feng was the first one to turn round for her. I think she got through to the semis. Anyway, He invited GEM to come help her with this song for the battle round. I really liked her voice. Though I haven't heard much of her since the voice.
并没有啊，GEM确实很强，但是这首歌而言她的表现力也顶多和汪半壁持平。GEM的声音确实更华丽，但是汪峰唱的更像一个普通人的呐喊。
@@Valen2CN 沒錯！汪峰這場不是他最巔峰的時候，還沒看我就知道老師一定選GEM😂汪峰強的是寫詞作曲！這首存在我到現在都在聽但一定是聽汪峰原唱的，而且這老師都是沒看過歌詞翻譯的不然這首歌詞放到現在都是神歌詞
看老師給鄧的表演這麼高的評價，還滿驚喜的~我自己本來對鄧的演唱還好，但她唱的存在直接圈粉
每個歌詞都被賦予了力量，彷彿跟著她的聲音看了一場電影，聽完都想起立鼓掌了
今天在澳門演唱會也有唱 真的好好聽❤❤
他本來就是我是歌手紅的
推薦GEM的你不是真正的快樂
尤其是最後一段的改編
终于盼到老师react邓紫棋存在了
Gem唱的存在真的很有生命力，很有靈魂
G.E.M唯一的問題就是唱完存在之後……再也沒有任何一個表演對我來說能贏過這首……最強最愛的一個舞台 😂😂😂
那不算是一個問題丫，🤣🤣🤣，歌手最大的問題是唱了一輩子都沒有讓人驚艷的舞台，
GEM的存在絕對是目前她現場最難的一首歌，也是我最愛的一首歌，很難超越了。
--
補充一下，難點就誠如老師所說，她幾乎從歌曲的一半到最後，都保持在高強度的強混聲區，(大家可能會認為最後那顆高音很神，確實很神，那顆#G5用強混真的是神級高音，但從頭到尾「保持」高強度這件事情其實對歌手來說才是最可怕的)這個對體力還有肌肉、聲帶控制力的要求真的是非常高，這種難度的歌能夠唱完就已經感謝天地了，何況GEM是完美了它、完成了它，真的是太難辦到的一件事情。
邓紫棋还有一个很厉害的是和五月天在鸟巢演唱会上合唱的盛夏光年。太炸了😊
那年高一還是高二，她真的是香港驕傲，現在聽還是會掉眼淚，感染力好強
你把我灌醉！！If I were a boy！！还有总决赛的we will rock you都可以 邓紫棋神级现场
專業的女人永遠都 雞蛋挑骨頭😂😂由其是對著女人🎉🎉🎉
真的想看老師去看一次鄧紫棋演唱會，真的很絕，在現場更能知道她的真實情況🎉
邓紫棋的神级舞台降临🔥
+1
但我私人 感覺 這個頻道不太敢 高度評價鄧紫棋, 大家都是歌手, 誰會喜歡別人比自己強， 所以一直很奇怪為什麼這個簡單的 題目視頻 拖了這麼久到現在還不發佈❤😂
@@chanlok5025 其实他们b站有发了上片档期 前面确实是都排满了，无可厚非啦 哈哈哈
我還是覺得老師的反應好真實好可愛喔~
I still feel,
The teacher's reaction was real and cute.
我永遠忘不了我是歌手時期鄧紫棋帶給我們的驚艷❤
抱歉了，只要有GEM的，我也是先Like再看片的
Eventually, GEM's version of 存在！！！
想看a-lin 目前為止只有一首~太少啊....
推她！我也想看A Lin ，她的表演都很精彩
其實是兩首（另一首是在陶喆演唱會上當嘉賓跟陶喆對唱）😂
老師講頭髮的時候好好笑
真是萝卜青菜各有所爱
推薦老師看gem 在歌手唱的你不是真正的快樂
GEM❤❤❤
Wong Cho Lam version 😂😂 That's the best version! Even GEM thinks so.
gem❤❤❤❤
Yepp ...G.E.M !!
汪峰🤟🤟🤟太多好听感人的经典歌曲了
天啊，终于要评紫棋的神级存在了吗😂好期待
老师讲段子💯啊😂😂
谁知道woman
嫉妒邓紫棋的腰细
很喜歡紫棋人美唱歌又好聽，她是可以和深深同併的女歌手。
求老師評鄧紫棋在我是歌手上的如果沒有你😍
十年了，人生有幾個十年。❤❤GEM🎉🎉😊😊
希望可以給老師看看 蕭煌奇 感覺老師應該會很喜歡
推荐ivy lee 李艾薇这个歌手！希望你们可以听听她唱歌😊
希望介紹‘’動力火車‘’的現場演唱給老師認識。。。不但是台灣原住民，也是台灣合唱組合的OG＞＞現場真的很猛！
是该时候了！！
Loved the one and only in the end ❤❤❤
For the longest time, Wang was consider one of the best live singer in China because he refused to use editing on stage, but as a result his voice takes a pounding and has started to brake down over the last few year. Is it just me or it seems like all Rock singers went through this kind of struggles in the latter part of their careers?
期待啊
Recommend 建議老師把巔峰年會的reactions也做了，不再比賽狀態，大家都不太一樣了，而且也多點其他的好歌手在台上，比方黃綺珊，比方那個民歌串燒表演都非常棒
Her voice in this song triggered my tears
用阿妹以前剛出道演唱來做講評！
你就知道阿妹奪強 鄧紫棋的鼻音太重 聽久了會刺耳沒感情
期待期待！！❤我想看那個還是意氣風發的楠哥！\m/🎸
一句就听出修音😂
I’m glad that you guys are doing a Wang Feng video. He is certainly one of the most talented Chinese rock musicians. IMO, His strength lies in his creativity as he wrote basically all his songs and lyrics (including this one) where he discuss his views of life and society, unlikely many Chinese songs which are dominated by love songs. For example, this song questions the purpose of live. Some of his other works such as 再见二十世纪，忧郁的眼睛，信仰在空中飘扬are true masterpieces! His singing skills might not be as great, but he is definitely a capable singer (at least when he was younger). And I also think that the true meaning of his songs are best expressed through his ‘unscientific’ singing. I feel that it is unfortunate that you have chosen this particular performance which is clearly not his best. There are many other great performances of this song from him, including one on TH-cam which has 5 millions views (compared to this one which has 25k), where his singing actually works! However, I do respect your decision as this is his performance at the end of the day.
森林北～
想聽Matzka
想請老師聽聽蕭煌奇唱歌🎤😊
好期待❤
許願老師講評澤野弘之製作的進擊的巨人經典神組曲 , Hiroyuki Sawano / Project【emU】 “Attack on Titan” suite
我是歌手時期的G.E.M.聲音真的很棒，甚至應該說，比真正大紅之後要更棒
老師 如果不點評音樂 ，跑去做綜藝 也是 可以 😂😂 可能 更受歡迎😊
汪峰這場已經不是巔峰期了😂201X年有一場才是巔峰….這樣對比有點傷
声音里的疲惫感很明显
KZ Tandigan “say something”
bridge over troubled water by so hyang , 这个真的超级感动、 已经二推了🙏🙏
Will there not be a reaction for singer 2024 additional episode
我覺得 貝貝 的版本 最震撼
A little bit sharing about GEM. Purple represents GEM, because her stage name is 鄧紫棋 , and 紫 means purple
歌手巔峰之夜的點評還沒好嗎，期待評測黃媽 我的美麗
我也想看
真的！
小霞唱的超好聽的～～～～
@@user-id8kc8kr1z期待😢
15:31这里怎么这么好笑哈哈哈
推薦GEM和五月天的盛夏光年
希望每天都有上片
紫棋真的超棒❤️
有點興趣知道黃明志的飄向北方會有甚麼評價
这是第一次老师评价汪峰吗？ 好期待老师如何看待这样的唱法哈哈
拜託我覺得一定要讓橘老師聽聽看李宗勝的"說"歌方式 也算是在華語中少見的
鄧紫棋老師說不簡單
汪峰的高音聽起來都很緊 扯嗓子的感覺
50多岁的人了，技巧成分不多，靠天赋喊到这个岁数很难保持状态了，怒放的生命那个年代稳很多
给老师看汪峰德车祸现场啊哈哈哈哈，卡痰那个
大推！必看的😂
拍這集的時候歌手2024吧 不然老師應該會知道孫楠啊😂
gem is amazing ❤❤❤
GEM!! 💜
She loves Christina Aguilera, while Beyonce is her idol.
蠻想看老師點評張雨生
可以敲碗評論 艾薇 嗎
老師片尾自彈的是什麼歌？真好聽
推荐谭维维的鱼鸟之恋
汪峰還是有厲害的地方啦，他的歌都自己作詞作曲，而且他從小學音樂，很多歌都是他國中時期寫得，所以音樂還是很有天份，只是嗓音越來越差
1:15 Totally! It's like Photoshop 🤣 Not a sin to use PS as long as you don't see it being used
Thank you for all your interesting reaction videos.
If you haven't already, I would like you to listen to the song "Life hates us now" (Life hates us now) by Mahumafu.
th-cam.com/video/eq8r1ZTma08/w-d-xo.htmlsi=0gCrknFuOkjw77Dz
th-cam.com/video/46_DEq3dA90/w-d-xo.htmlsi=L_XDl8jkEZAhwHu-
It is a song that resonates with me when I feel that life is hard with quite sensational lyrics.
He debuted as an artist in the 2010s when Vocaloid was all the rage in Japan and he became very popular by covering Vocaloid songs. Although he did not write this song, he performed it on a prestigious Japanese music show as his signature song.
Although he is a man, he sings in a high pitch like a woman.
預告片裡彈奏周董《Secret／Intro》的是杰凱的兒子吧？彈得很棒👍
比起史坦威，個人更偏愛FAZIOLI的音色
Please do a reaction video on Elaine Duran singing "Can't take that away from me" or any from her cover songs🤗 I know you will enjoy hearing her. New subscribere here from the philippines! Elaine is also a filipina 😁.
做比較影片的話應該都是表演壯態最好既情況下做對比會比較好吧、否則就有少少引導老師同觀眾偏向其中一位歌手，唔太公平
應該給老師看看這首歌歌詞
介紹 這個節目 日韓歌王戰 這個節目 50多歲冇人認識的日本女歌手 rie yatsuka, 唱了很多九十年代被中文改編的日文歌
艾薇～失重前幸福
React to the Land of the greatest singers Philippines
橘老師的配色好像 腦筋急轉彎的樂樂
汪峰：我谢谢你们🤦🏻♂️
9:33 LOL
敲碗 張韶涵的 阿刁
修音痕跡太重 老師可能會很反感
許願張韶涵🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
汪峰汪峰🤘🤘🤘
😂😂😂
I would like to see their reaction to all Ha Hyun Woo’s shows in mask singer please
推薦老師點評鄧紫棋翻唱beyonce的if i were a boy
希望老师可以评一下李安的《逝去的爱》
怎麼沒有加入張惠妹版本哪？
you can try listen to ''hachi'' live！！
覺得不該選汪峰這個版本，他明顯聽起來嗓子很累了...應該選他嗓子好點的視頻
汪峰状态好不好他颤音都是那个颤法，技术方法又不会变
他嗓子有好過？😂
這片會不會是 歌手2024 前錄影的嗎 ？
強推~你不是真正的快樂
Hi, able to review some Aska Yang Songs ?
Please react Gento and MaPa by SB19 on THE FIRST TAKE
每次見到topic都要等2個月. 不要這樣引誘我好嗎