The singer is not good? What do you base that on? I'd never heard of Tony until I heard him with Toto, and I have to say he brings a lot to the band...he's got a terrific voice, he plays guitar like a pro, and he's good looking...what more could you ask for? I love this version of the band; Greg and Tony both fit perfectly with an already stellar lineup, Steve, Simon and Mike are legendary players in their respective fields...
Agreed that I like Tony on this song. Sounds like his throat might be a little irritated here. A lot of the other concerts where he sings this song, his voice is more clear.
Chlapci trepete pôvodne skladbu naspieval Joseph Williams a vyšla na albume THE SEVENTH ONE a samostatne vo feb. 1988......tento spevák sa doslovne trápi pri jej interpretácii...otrasná verzia
for me..Joseph Williams is the best for this song. I am not familiar with Tonny Spinner's voice...his voice was like the vocalist of blues rock band, Black Crowes or Ugly Kid Joe.
It's TONY SPINNER, he toured with TOTO for almost 10 years replacing Joseph Williams on this song, which I think he does a bang up job.......easy on the eyes too!
greg phillinganes is an AMAZING (and may one of the best) pop/blues/rock piano player ever, but also one of the WORST keyboard player...his focus on searching the correct sound for each part of the song is ZERO...always rock piano and piano+strings...what he hell man!!
This song doesn't even rock, it's weak!! Toto Rocked on Toto IV, & Falling in between, & that's pretty much it, except for maybe some of their late '70's stuff!
FYI Toto is not a full fledged classic rock band and they have experimented with many genres throughout their discography so it's not necessary for every song to 'rock' as if they are playing ACDC or some shit. It's still enjoyable.
![Toto - Africa / Hold The Line / Stop Loving You (live) [2024]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5tppmuRLNkc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Toto - Africa / Hold The Line / Stop Loving You (live) [2024]](/img/tr.png)
![[FULL EP.14] เซียนหรั่ง สอน มาร์ชจุ จับปูนา ฮากระจาย | เฮ็ดอย่างเซียนหรั่ง | One Playground](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/M8mPjd_T2lo/mqdefault.jpg)
Tony Spinner the best!
Great singer with a great range !!!!!
i love this song :) it makes me happy
dank je toto voor 1000 mooie songs
toto....rocksss
tony spinner lovely! ;)
Mike porcaro on bass!! Tight tight!!
SIMON ES IMPECABLE!!
Come back Tony and especially Simon!
in my oppinion they should have given Tony at least one song where he is on leadguitar
Fuck yes
Yeah...and it could be very interesting tour of those bands together - Rush, Dream Theater and Toto...damn, that would kick some asses!
The singer is not good? What do you base that on? I'd never heard of Tony until I heard him with Toto, and I have to say he brings a lot to the band...he's got a terrific voice, he plays guitar like a pro, and he's good looking...what more could you ask for? I love this version of the band; Greg and Tony both fit perfectly with an already stellar lineup, Steve, Simon and Mike are legendary players in their respective fields...
Bobby Kimball (dark hair/mustache) is the lead vocalist, Tony Spinner is backing vocalist
O Joseph Williams já está com os Toto novamente desde 2011! Muito melhor - adoro os dois. o Joseph Williams e o Bobby Kimball nas vozes agudas.
Thats a nice video
Steve Lukather always reminds me of an older John Petrucci
It's like a car wreck, you don't want to look, but you can't help yourself!
They're different, both HUGE legends (:
It's Tony Spinner. Obviously.
Check the 2008 Paris Concert, Lukather introduces him before this song.
Agreed
Agreed that I like Tony on this song. Sounds like his throat might be a little irritated here. A lot of the other concerts where he sings this song, his voice is more clear.
ci vuole coraggio, tanto coraggio, per fare il lead vocalist dei Toto.... Ma c'era Steve!!!!!!!!!
tony spinner, he also has his own band.
The blonde!! and it's Bobby Kimball
Simon Phillips is the best drummer
Jeff Porcaro was the best
and same "MUSICMAN" guitar... SL & JP 2 genius
Jon Anderson on backing vocals...check wikipedia.
this three guys have similar face i think : John Petrucci, Steve Lukather and young Dave Grohl :D
on this song Ian Anderson sings
thanks. well,i do like the original one of Joseph Williams
Simon ride like hell..
@babyhempel do you have the rest of the Concert?
Gostei. mas cá entre nós, o Joseph Williams arrebentava!!!
that is Tony spinner not Joseph.
Tony Spinner
simon phillips on drumm¡¡
4:00 desafinación...
joseph william,where are u?
+ali justino he wasnt in the band at the time
What are Mr. Spinner doing now a days..?
Ok. tô sabendo. pena que ele já não está com a mesma voz de antes.
Valeu!!!!!
desculpe. entre nós.
Chlapci trepete pôvodne skladbu naspieval Joseph Williams a vyšla na albume THE SEVENTH ONE a samostatne vo feb. 1988......tento spevák sa doslovne trápi pri jej interpretácii...otrasná verzia
02:10 Steve Lukather is pist off ahahaah :)
your both wrong it's not Joseph or Bobby, it's Tony Spinner who toured with Toto for almost 10 years '99 to '08!
esta modelito rubia quien es? no canta mal... en fin
for me..Joseph Williams is the best for this song. I am not familiar with Tonny Spinner's voice...his voice was like the vocalist of blues rock band, Black Crowes or Ugly Kid Joe.
as if petrucci was so much younger than him
Simon Phillips is good...but to be honest, Jeff Porcaro (RIP) is the best.
Sapete il nome del solista?
Alla voce c'è Tony Spinner ;)
It's TONY SPINNER, he toured with TOTO for almost 10 years replacing Joseph Williams on this song, which I think he does a bang up job.......easy on the eyes too!
Tony Spinner sounds ALOT like Steve Perry....should've tried out for the Journey front man.
wait.... this is not the original singer... is he?
Then why do you watch it -.-
Is that Joseph?
Нет
greg phillinganes is an AMAZING (and may one of the best) pop/blues/rock piano player ever, but also one of the WORST keyboard player...his focus on searching the correct sound for each part of the song is ZERO...always rock piano and piano+strings...what he hell man!!
That is what toto told him to do, most of their keyboard parts are piano string and or horns.
This is a moment you want to go back in time..where is Jeff Porcaro..what a sissy singer..Change his diper!!
why didnt they just let Bobby Kimball sing it?
Because Tony Spinner sings it better.
Tony Spinner sings everything better than Kimball.
This singer looks really ridicoluos...Please someone alerts him that this is not a " Beautiful scene ".
Incredible....!
Non non ça vaut pas la voix de Joseph williams désolé🥺😥
j'accroche pas 🤷♀️
Joseph the Best 😍💖💋🍀
Don't like this singer at all ... 😓
Nicola Sapere their Majano 2012 singer I guess is more spot on. This one has nice voice but not for this song (my opinion)
Tony Spinner, put some respect on that name.
I think he did just fine. After all he was hired by Toto themselves.
@@onzkicg that is Joseph William's who originally sung the song played in the video
This song doesn't even rock, it's weak!!
Toto Rocked on Toto IV, & Falling in between, & that's pretty much it, except for maybe some of their late '70's stuff!
FYI Toto is not a full fledged classic rock band and they have experimented with many genres throughout their discography so it's not necessary for every song to 'rock' as if they are playing ACDC or some shit. It's still enjoyable.
this Tony sings like a gay..it's a powerless voice not even close to Williams's,don't know why they choose him to sing this song..
the singer is not good
Tony Spinner