I first went through RDR2 and then RDR1 and vice versa. It would be better to know the plot if I first went through RDR2 and then RDR1, it was very sad to watch Marston's best friends, or the same Dutch who was a good person but went crazy and John was just used and then killed, and most likely we won't see anything about the Van Der Lynde gang again@@abdullrahman-xh5pc
@@Harutix he said it hits harder for the ogs, the comment he replied to said playing rdr1 after playing rdr2 hits harder and the guy said it hits harder for the ogs.
@@memoryloss4327I think he only says it because he was just betrayed by his brother who he lived with for years. It felt so bad to see him like that because he was a decent guy in rdr2
Rdr1 and Rdr2 show absolute realism with how this world is, one second your friends with someone, the next you despise them and want nothing but the worst for them.
Yeah, he originally was meant to know, but we can imagine that he says that because john left his gang life behind and so possibly has a growing family
@user-hx6gs9rq7u No, he certainly wipes a tear from his eye. Go rewatch the scene. He does so and then immediately spits on Javier in an attempt to neglect his care for his former brothers and to try and bury his past with him completely.
@@dsfgdg2740javier left his close friend john for dead, and has a bad behavior in camp near the end And, just to say, if you look fram by fram, you have this scene of javier pointing up, then focus on arthur and john, then you see javier and other reacting to the approach. When the screen pass from arthur and john to the rest of the gang, javier is aiming at them just before reacting
@@vincent-lm8svnot a plot hole. There’s an interaction between John and Abigail in the rdr2 epilogue where she’s knitting something small and pink. John asks “Who’s that for”, she says “You’ll see”. The baby was born and died at some point between 1907 and 1911.
I love in the first one you just assume it was a small gang that John was in until RDR2 came out and then you realize it was a whole ass gang and family🥲
Dutch saying "They'll just find anohter monster like me" and saying he is part of a paradox shows how aware he is about the changing world and knows that any action he takes has no meaning anymore. Dutch was already ready to die
RDR1 is so fascinating, I played this first then RDR2. Both are absolutely perfect, but sadly RDR1 doesn't get as much love and respect that it deserves.
the only thing i hate abt rdr2 is that, they didnt make john with javier/bill moments ,and it doesnt give the vibe that the were "brothers " (if that make sense)
John never let go they left him to die, you can tell that was it for him. Javier, Bill were just men that wronged him at this point, not brothers anymore
The moment that hit me hardest in RDR1 was when John hugged his son hard before the Army arrived. I didn't know what was coming. Once that mission was finished I couldn't even see clearly cause of the tears
dutchs best plan yet, if hed only done it the first time he visited ambarino and not the last we could’ve had morgan & marston cattle co. instead of a fuckton of corpses and crippling depression
I have already Fully completed RDR2 and about to finish RDR1 I don't know how to feel but I know this I feel upset and sad because I love this story so much.
The amount of care Dutch has for John and Arthur is so nice he just leaves Arthur on the cliff with Micah and eventually leads to his death and John he definitely had some guilt after leaving his brother on top of a cliff with a rat
I played rdr at 2014 for the first time, it was a great was game, i didn’t felt sad chasing Javier, bill and Dutch, then i played rdr2, after that i replayed rdr and just felt empty, no gang, no friends just John all by himself.
John in the second clip sounded like Arthur when he told sister: 'I had a son, he died. I had a girl who loved me and threw that away. My momma's gone and well my father, well I watched him die'
rdr1: a fascinating story mode game
rdr1 after playing rdr2: complete depression
Rdr1: Depression
Rdr2: Depression 9000
@@OGGrubKill3r if you played rdr1 after rdr2 then it hits way way way harder then if you didn't play rdr2
I first went through RDR2 and then RDR1 and vice versa. It would be better to know the plot if I first went through RDR2 and then RDR1, it was very sad to watch Marston's best friends, or the same Dutch who was a good person but went crazy and John was just used and then killed, and most likely we won't see anything about the Van Der Lynde gang again@@abdullrahman-xh5pc
"HIS DEPRESSION LEVELS ARE OVER 9000!!!!!"
@@abdullrahman-xh5pc Rdr1 after Rdr2: Depression 9000000000
Seeing uncle die hit me the hardest.
Omg they killed him 😂
He would’ve lived only if he didn’t have lumbago 🥲
Man, When i played the game the first time and saw him dying, I'ill be honest i cried, It was so sad, Dude😢
❤❤🥲
Fr rip the one shot kid
Me playing RDR1 in 2010 watching Bill, Javier, and Dutch die: 🤠
Me playing in 2024: 😥
Exactly it hits harder for the ogs
@@gwapboogiebro what rdr2 came out in 2018
@@justxtroAre you dumb?
@@justxtrohe was talking about RDR1
@@Harutix he said it hits harder for the ogs, the comment he replied to said playing rdr1 after playing rdr2 hits harder and the guy said it hits harder for the ogs.
Bill: you always did think I was an idiot!
John: That ain't fair, Bill.
We all did.
😂😂
Was my first thought too😂
Bill deserved better
"I got a plan John."
"This is a good one"
Throws his pistal away.
@@Ujjwal_Gamer_007I don’t doubt it
@@Ujjwal_Gamer_007 jumpes down the cliff
@@Ujjwal_Gamer_007didn’t need it for what he was gonna do.
"he always has a plan dutch"
Seeing Javier die after rdr2 was quite hard, he didn't betray us in the end but got captured by his brother 💔.
Honestly tho, after he told John that he hopes his family rots in hell, it's kinda hard to feel bad for him
Thats why i feel bad for him.@memoryloss4327
@@memoryloss4327I think he only says it because he was just betrayed by his brother who he lived with for years. It felt so bad to see him like that because he was a decent guy in rdr2
@@eligunnels9905he sided with Dutch in the end Javier was the Enemy
@@xfilms2503he sided with Dutch because he didn't know what was going on
In the face off he didn't even point his gun at anyone
Seeing Arthur die or seeing the first death of a gang member Sean really changed my perspective 😢
That's rdr2
Its rdr1
@itsumair9681 it's rdr2.
@@ruinous_powers6387”changed my perspective”
Technically its was Davey but I know what u mean.
You mean hardest hitting moments after playing rdr2 in rdr1
Playing red dead 2, then replaying red dead 1 changes so much.
@@I_Am_Q1000 exactly
I’m one of them!
Fuck that. Play them in order
@@morbiusmale2347 release order that makes no sense the full experience of rdr1 is better after rdr2
Bro when you see jack will live the rest of his life alone and grieving for his family and the people who love hit's hard
He marry and have a children
@@GardG4m3r who knows
Thank's for the likes
In GTA5, you’ll find a book called Red Dead by J. Marston
@@train4693 yeah I know
Dutch always has a plan.
T A H I T I
Rdr1 and Rdr2 show absolute realism with how this world is, one second your friends with someone, the next you despise them and want nothing but the worst for them.
"The day John Marston stopped shooting"
Don’t do that to me
The Dutch death scene hits even harder after playing that scene in RDR 2 where Dutch and Arthur jump into the river to escape the army
Notice how Javier said “children” as if he new of Johns daughter
Yeah, he originally was meant to know, but we can imagine that he says that because john left his gang life behind and so possibly has a growing family
John wiping a tear away after putting dead Javier in a cell
Wiping the side of his face doesn’t mean he’s wiping a tear away
@user-hx6gs9rq7u No, he certainly wipes a tear from his eye. Go rewatch the scene. He does so and then immediately spits on Javier in an attempt to neglect his care for his former brothers and to try and bury his past with him completely.
@@majormonkey6653 I’ve seen it many times. All he does is wipe the side of his face, it doesn’t mean he’s wiping a tear
Good luck telling these 5 year olds@@user-hx6gs9rq7u
The only moment we see john crying and he directly forces himself to feel angry again instead
The ones with Dutch and bill hit hard after playing RDR2
Also javier because he didnt betray them he even pointed his gun up in the last mission
@@dsfgdg2740javier left his close friend john for dead, and has a bad behavior in camp near the end
And, just to say, if you look fram by fram, you have this scene of javier pointing up, then focus on arthur and john, then you see javier and other reacting to the approach. When the screen pass from arthur and john to the rest of the gang, javier is aiming at them just before reacting
Didn't knew John had a Daughter 🥺❤️
Just a plot hole in rdr2
@@vincent-lm8svnot true, could’ve tried having one before the events of rdr1
@@AlexTonar there is less than 4 years between the epilogue and red dead redemption 1. What do you mean lol?
@@vincent-lm8sv a daughter can die at 2 years old.
@@vincent-lm8svnot a plot hole. There’s an interaction between John and Abigail in the rdr2 epilogue where she’s knitting something small and pink. John asks “Who’s that for”, she says “You’ll see”. The baby was born and died at some point between 1907 and 1911.
I got a plan one hit the hardest after playing rdr2 when he tells Arthur he has a plan and they both jump into the river
Yea it just hits different because he said the exact same thing to arthur
“That ain’t fair bill. You were as my brother…” that line hits hard
John genuinely didn’t want to do it. These people who he still considers family he has to take care of them because he has to save his family.
Seeing John get shot 21 times made me break down
Talk about hardesr hitting moment.
You eat babies- John marston 1911
RDR1 right after RDR2 is actual pure depression.
"This is the good one"
Let's Go to Tahiti🤠
“I got a plan John”🤣🤣😭😭
“This is a good one…” hit the hardest.
This game hits deeper when you play RDR2
That means john had a daughter betweens 1907 and 1911 and she died before she was 4
No it's before he joined the gang John says that while talking to Bonnie
No... Ur right😂
@@user-wt7nt8pi1v was I right or not
Can you imagine if author didn’t help John at all and John had to hunt author down in rdr1
John threw the person who saved him from the iceberg with his best friend and saved him from the wolfs in prison
Thats so hard 💔
Javier also abandoned, John his family and Arthur later on so he got what was coming to him
I first played rdr1. Then rdr2. Then rdr1 again. Playing rdr1 hits harder after playing rdr2
Ya i needa do that
“Uh……sure”- jim milton
This series has everything like the 5 stages of grief denial, anger, bargaining, depression and acceptance
They could not have changed our emotions about the antagonists any more than they did on rdr2
Tbh playing rd1 after playing rd2 hits harder
"You eat babies!" 🥺🤧👊😔
I love in the first one you just assume it was a small gang that John was in until RDR2 came out and then you realize it was a whole ass gang and family🥲
"That ain't fair Bill, you are an idiot "
You think I'm an idiot!
That ain't fair Bill we all did.
Playing RDR1 after playing RDR2 hits hard
Best game ever
When John admits he'd outgun Arthur Morgan hit hardest especially for the Arthur stans 😢
By outgun are you saying like hunt him down like the rest of the gang or like physically outgun him?
@@TheFreeman570 physically outgun him
I miss you arthur...
Dutch saying "They'll just find anohter monster like me" and saying he is part of a paradox shows how aware he is about the changing world and knows that any action he takes has no meaning anymore. Dutch was already ready to die
Dutch just wanted to go to vacation to Tahiti 😢
"I have I plan john"
"You always have one"
"This is a good one"
it hit me hard in the heart
RDR1 is so fascinating, I played this first then RDR2. Both are absolutely perfect, but sadly RDR1 doesn't get as much love and respect that it deserves.
Hits different after 2
Loved Rdr 1, and after Rdr 2, makes so much more sense.
The reason Javier went on Dutch's side is because he was scared of dutch killing him and he wanted to live a new life in Mexico
Sad song: ❌
Turtle dancing:✅
Javier 1899: 😂
Javier 1911: 😢
the fact that i cant play this game hits me harder than any os these moments :(
Why can't you ?
@@AshleySmyth1212 there's no pc version available
Edit:at least not a trustable one
You know what that's make all RDR series feel sad. We play and feel that's outlaw & Cowboys era is end. And we the only one who still living
2 best games ever
You can't fight nature... John
Rdr2 was the best ever explanation
Lo bueno es que no dejas morir red dead redemption 😢
Turning Javier in dead is hitting harder than turning him alive
RDR1 is one of the darkest games rockstar has ever made
I thought nothing of these scenes before rdr2, but after it hurts😢
Seeing Arthur die in RDR2 hit me the hardest
“This is a good one…”
"Even in this new country, memories don't really fade..." is an underrated quote imo
From the john and bonnie moment we see in this vid
У датча после войны остался маузер
Dutch still having plans in 1911
these moments hit harder than an asian mom after their kid gets an a minus
The last Sasquatch scene. Yesterday i was high af and i played it... Makes me sad 😞
Everything that John went through was painful I can't imagine going through that life 😢😢😢😢😢 I feel really bad for John
The dutch cutscene the whole time:😔
When he hit the bottom of the cliff: 😳😂😂
the only thing i hate abt rdr2 is that, they didnt make john with javier/bill moments ,and it doesnt give the vibe that the were "brothers " (if that make sense)
YOu EaT BaBYS
"I have a son, I had a daughter but she died." How did John say that so casually.
Our time has passed broke me
John never let go they left him to die, you can tell that was it for him. Javier, Bill were just men that wronged him at this point, not brothers anymore
They only hit hard when we played rdr2
Javier never wanted to hurt John 😢
The moment that hit me hardest in RDR1 was when John hugged his son hard before the Army arrived. I didn't know what was coming. Once that mission was finished I couldn't even see clearly cause of the tears
John is my favorite rdr character
I was expecting john to say "That ain't fair bill, everyone thought you were an idiot."
Playing this game for the most recent time makes me wonder how much of rdr2's story they had written in 2010
Real hardest hitting moment: “You eat babies!”
Dutch could have easily manipulated me i always felt bad for the guy
dutchs best plan yet, if hed only done it the first time he visited ambarino and not the last we could’ve had morgan & marston cattle co. instead of a fuckton of corpses and crippling depression
If you kill Javier you see John wipe a tear off his eye and spits on Javier
Dutch always had a plan
At least somebody finally acknowledged Dutch for always having a plan 😂
I have already Fully completed RDR2 and about to finish RDR1 I don't know how to feel but I know this I feel upset and sad because I love this story so much.
" You Eat Babies!! " 😢
In that moment dutch thought of arthur morgan
You forgot
“You eat babies, everybody knows that”
where is “you eat babies”
"This is a good one..."
The fact that Dutch realized in the end broke me
The amount of care Dutch has for John and Arthur is so nice he just leaves Arthur on the cliff with Micah and eventually leads to his death and John he definitely had some guilt after leaving his brother on top of a cliff with a rat
How many times during the 1 and 2 did dutch say he has a plan
The saddest part about red dead one is John had to kill his father and his brothers to save his family😔
The wild thing is he had his daughter after Arthur died that’s what makes it even worse
I played rdr at 2014 for the first time, it was a great was game, i didn’t felt sad chasing Javier, bill and Dutch, then i played rdr2, after that i replayed rdr and just felt empty, no gang, no friends just John all by himself.
John in the second clip sounded like Arthur when he told sister: 'I had a son, he died. I had a girl who loved me and threw that away. My momma's gone and well my father, well I watched him die'
"this is a good one"
He had a daughter?! I've never know that wow