'Indian soil unfit...': How Ashwini Vaishnaw slammed TMC MP Nusrat Jahan for remarks on Bullet train
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 มี.ค. 2022
- Big face in Lok Sabha between TMC MP Nusrat Jahan and Union Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw over bullet train project in the country. A day after Nusrat said that Indian soil is not fit for the bullet train to operate, Ashwini slammed Nusrat and called her statement shameful. He invoked TMC's 'Maa, Maati, Manush' slogan to attack Mamata's party for having doubt in our country's ability. Watch this video to know more.
#NusratJahan #AshwiniVaishnaw #FaceOff #BulletTrain #Parliament
![[Full Episode] Hell's Kitchen Thailand EP.12 | 28 เม.ย. 67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xCjbu5t25Pw/mqdefault.jpg)
As an engineer and keeping everything else aside, "Because the soil is not fit for such types of trains to operate" is the most ridiculous and hilarious comment I've ever heard in my entire career.
😂😂
Ignore them asmani kitab Readers think they are beyond any science
She is a beautician and rough politician she don't know about the soil and national interest
TMC wale hai; Unke Gole pe esa hi hota hai! 😁
Dats the knowledge of madrasa😆
She's teaching to IITian, MBA, IAS, Founder of a company, Principal director of Siemens ...lol 😂
I have never seen Ashwini Vaishnav ji getting so angry. His nature is calm and compose. If he's getting angry then matter is serious.
She is not talking about soil , actually she raised a question against India's potential and capabilities to build bullet train by own engineering
Nusrat a MAD-Asrha Gradute . The Banladeshi Bus-al-mann elected her to become a MP..
Which is, he is an educated fool...they do exists unlike Gods!
@10varunr I know brother these type of people are obstacles not only development but as well as biggest challenge for India's security
@@gautamyadav10 She actually married a Dharmic person(Jain) in traditional mantras and attire with Bindi but later she divorced him, that's a different matter.
However what she told about soil and construction not suitable is one of the most hilarious thing I heard. It's not science, it's whatsapp science.
Mahua and Nusrat are soul example of how knowing English doesn't necessarily mean being knowledgeable 😂
Add Moitra's high decibel and melodramatic style of speech to that too. 😂
@@warnpassion 😂😂😂
😂😂
You forgot Mimi MP of our area . don't worry I didn't vote for him. It was my first time vote for professor Anupam hazra . But my vote was not enough 😃
@@warnpassion Indian soil only fit for illegal Bangladeshi Rohingaya immigrants 🌹🌹🌹🌹
According TMC Momta dengam🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ashwini: IIT, IAS etc. (Trust me there are a lot in this list)
Nushrat: Failed regional actress and Instagram influencer 🤣🤣
Really 😅😅
@@bloodeagle2445 you can Google
@@Hoax69696 yes I know bro
@@bloodeagle2445 okay. Good for you
@@Hoax69696 I didn't comment "really" as an interrogation but as an appreciation 🤧
As a Structural Engineer, the sentence "soil is not fit for such type of trains" is out of the topic for me, Engineers of India have the capability to build structures in the bad soil conditions also, don't know how these types of people become MP.
From West Bengal and Nusrat Jahan, ek so called actress,jiska politics ke bare me kuch nehi pata,bo kya samajta hai Bharat ke bare me. TMC jis tarah ke party hai uska MP usi tara ki honge.As a bengali girl I don't like this type of Woman, lekin hamare State me jo ho raha hai bo ek natak ki alaba aur kuch nehi. Kisi ki upar nehi bolna chahiye, lekin kuch time ese hote hai to bolna hi parte hai.
Her way of speaking is absurd she she can put this in more specific terms .
@@iitn8437 you are expecting brothel to be a sacred place. Nope can't happen
These fools mostly join politics for the sake of political power, appeasement politics, casteist politics, etc & not for the ZEAL or WILL to transform the Nation.
They always have Excuses😑
Excuses to not develop Border Infra at the LAC,
To not strengthen the Armed forces,
To not fight natural calamities, Terrorism & many more of such things.
Sir she’s from Bengal momta party 😃😃
Being an engineering graduate to hear that soil is unfit is the most hilarious and stupid thing I have heard in my career till now 🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻
I am not an engineer..and I still find it illogical.
@Sebastian Christ aa gye flat earth wale😂 ricebag community🤣
@Sebastian Christ
Maybe your head transplant is failure👎
@Sebastian Christ Aur jo christian countries ke head Virgin marry se jesus aane ki baat krte vo scientist hai?
@Sebastian Christ Jaake Padri ka chutad chaat nahi to ricebag nahi milega.
IITian, IAS officer, MBA from Wharton Buisness of School and a Rss worker. This is Ashwini sir. What a qualification he has .
Aswinijee you are great we trust you one day bullet train will run in india people will see
I'm an Indian born MIT graduate architect, I've worked with Japanese engineers in various projects in India and abroad. There's nothing Japanese engineers can't achieve. I've seen them design and plan hydro projects, railways, buildings in the most difficult terrain with efficiency and skills. Nobody can compete with Japanese engineers 🙇 and Indians on the other hand, we've got the brightest, the most intelligent engineers and the most innovative (jugaad) but we lack opportunity in our own country. Hence we work abroad for better opportunities.
Here as Indian
I think to become a job creator 😀
Hey! Just a discussion if you are aware of the Joshimath issue (soil subsidence) in Uttarakhand... any (engineering expert) opinion on how the place can be saved from subsiding?
Perhaps Japan has similar topography problems? If yes, then is there a way out?
Sirf aise logo ke wajah se
@@rashi_exe991 nope, it's beyond saving. We were late when all these things came to light that's all I'll say.
Indian Soil means Indian People, that is what she meant..
Didn't you understand that?
Every Indian knew that Japan soil is vulnerable for its natural calamities.
I just remembered the words of Dr. Ambedkar.
She conveniently forgot our Railways minister is an IIT, an- BTech, also has Mtech, MBA from Wharton university, Pennsylvania.
She is from TMC. Where Mahua Mutra comes..
ASHWINI VAISHNAW
Mtech - IIT Kanpur
IAS - All India Rank - 27
MBA - Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.
Managing Director - General Electric Transportation.
Vice President - Siemens (Locomotives & Head Urban Infrastructure Strategy)
Deputy Chairman - Mormugao Port Trust.
.. and also was an IAS officer
IAS bhi hai
@@gautamnayak4767 Ashwini ji is diamond of our country..
This is a man who is an M.Tech from IIT , an IAS officer, an MBA from Wharton and most notably was the MD of GE transportation and later Siemens India locomotives. Keeping this in mind, I am sure he has far greater technical proficiency to comment on the subject of bullet trains than Nusrat. It was clear she was reading verbatim from a speech surely prepared by someone else. What a joke to see such parliamentarian representing Bengal . The answer of Ashwini ji was absolutely befitting when he said it is shameful. I am not a political supporter but any educated man will scoff at this kind of a light headed remark.
Don't underestimate the power of tick tik toker 🤣
Long live Bengal!!!👍
@@BeenaKK bengal is doomed now. isis breeding hub next to kerela. Khelaa hobe🤹♂️
🙏🙏🙏
@crypto boi Don’t underestimate Kerala unity in social issues,unity of Kerala shown every in the world,if he is Muslim, Hindu or christian bjp agenda will not grow in Kerala.
Japan has a high frequency of earthquake and tsunamis, still they were able to build and operate it....why can't we
It’s same as ur mother able to get up early in the morning and take care family needs , but why you can’t do same🧐
@@manttest India has different type of soil varying region to region.....so its different from the point what u are implying to say
@@manttest I see a triggered TMC supporter
phele apni gau mata ko railway patri pe jane se bachao😂 phir banana bullet train..jhute sapne
BJP supporter chup hoja
Ashwini Sir, 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I appreciate your patience n we are blessed to have leaders like you,
Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳 Vande Matram 🇮🇳🙏🏻
This happens when Model MP teaches science to IITian Minister 😂
best comment
Ashwini Vaishnaw indian railway minister ,IIT graduate , top MBA school graduate from the US
is answering instagrami graduate Nusrat (neoliberals),poor girl should read his profile then talk about soil , He is an Engineer🤣🤣🤣
@@govindr3140
He emphasized that india should not depend on foreigners and this shows how much he wants to contribute to india even after being a graduate from usa.
@@kumarabhishek1064 I wish all our youth should think like him. Jai Hind
@@kumarabhishek1064 bruh he just went and studied whats wrong
"Hume apne engineers pe pura vishwash he!"
As an engineering student, after hearing our honorable minister it is proved that ek engineer hi engineers pe trust kar skta he! 💯
Konsi college se ho ?
Our engineers are capable of building engineering Marvel's overseas. Then they can definitely do that here too and they really dont need a validation from some tik toker turned into a politician
Desh ka Engineer IAS bna ja rha hai,bullet train??
No wonder u're unemployed!
Same here brother 🔥
I join the discussion as a civil engineer and find these "unfit soil " debates as childish and out of sheer negligence from the issue. How come such people become MP. Even if the soil is weak, Indian engineers are sought worldwide to build structures on any terrain whatsoever. Such people make an insult on Indian engineering discipline when they make such comments. Shameful
This type of ridiculous questions come when the person is a politician only without having a proper technical degree...and try to mess with a technocrat who have a b tech degree from iit kanpur.....Jai Hind 🇮🇳 ❤❤
How someone from peaceful community can talk about science.
😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
🤦
science is haram in Izlam
can you see beyond religion?
Abdul Kalam was from which community
That's what happens when you make an actress/tiktoker a 'sangsad'.....and in reciprocal Ashwini Vaishnav is an IITian and and an IAS officer 🔥and also got MBA degree from Wharton school of business management
What use those degrees infront of the painted face 😈
@@govindrajan9887
Ask yourself, he is doing great
@@rahulkukreti1862 my comments were sarcastic.
Chiding the painted face of Nachne wali.
@@rahulkukreti1862 you misunderstood my comments
Any one by name Rahul seems to be Pappu.
Thank you for English subtitles. I had a feeling (judging his body language) that Gentle man was actually struggling to answer that stupid question. Well Answered.
Gradually becoming ur fan Ashwini ji 🙏🏻
When he said he has faith in his engineers that's more than enough an engineer wants to hear after all the comparison done by society.
Hat's off to u sir
Well that's how truly educated people speak... There's a huge difference between an IIT graduate and a 4th fail..
Oh wow, I never heard how qualified Ashwini Vaishnav was. He's only 51 years old as well. Infact, he's much more educated than Kejriwal, and younger than him too. IAS officer with an all India rank of 27 🔥🔥🔥. He's a perfect candidate to be the prime minister of India after Modi 🔥🔥🔥. A perfect reply by the BJP to Kejriwal. I find Yogi Adityanath to be popular, but he cant stand up to this man. India needs him as PM! Yogi can be a great campaigner in UP, but I cant imagine Yogi representing India on the world stage.
Don't know about bullet train or soil, but she's hot as Fuck
@@arkapanghosal854 4th fail na bodhoy. tobe sudhu 12th pass. se a bar argue korche ekjon IITan er songe...!!Jotto shob !!
@@saptarshiadhikary3736 kotha sune tmn e moneholo bhai...The way she speaks without knowing anything makes me angry...Now she will come back in Bengal with this new logic and many people will believe it because they have the majority here along with a hell lot of blind supporters..
Our railway minister is very educated . He knows what is right for India and its people
Ya
He is IAS officer what do You expect... he is smarter than whole congress combined
\
@@sanketnaik20 On top of being a former IAS. He is MTech from IIT Kanpur and MBA from Wharton.
Yes that's why I want them to be pm of india after modi
A whore who got in parliament by sleeping with ministers is teaching economy lessons to others.
Proud for Mr. Aswini Vaishnaw for supporting our nation.
Reply is extraordinary 🔥
Jai hind
If the soil of an island that is extremely prone to earthquakes and tsunamis has the ability to run bullet trains, then why can't a nearly 75,000,000 year old piece of land that has been sustaining nearly 1,000,000,000 (today) since it's human inception 65,000 years back run them
She have failed her 12th class bro leave it.
Exactly. Good answer 😃
🔥🔥🔥
@@abhay3976 don't know about her 12th but in reality she failed 4th class. 😂
💯best answer👏
"it is the science"
It's better if she presents a valid paper or proof to make a point. As an engineer myself, I find it utterly absurd that the soil of Ahmedabad-Mumbai belt can't sustain bullet trains.
Probably she wants to run a bullet train from her home to Mumtaz Begum 's home.
Both the soil are dry, probably.
Oye, NusratJahan Nobel prize winner h engineering mein, faltu kaise bol rha h
@@nischaltyagi8672 loh aaygaye tmc blind supporter
@@optimistictoon5010 sarcasm smash mere bhai
Abe gadhe agar hai jaise ye keh rhi hai... To engineers pr bharosa rkkna chaiye ya nhi??... Dusre tareeke se bullet train bana lenge!! Lekin aisa kehna sahi nhi hai..... Pta nhi kya padhi hai likhi hai
It is very sad to hear such things that such people are MPs, I am also a civil engineer, I can understand that there is no shortage in the soil of our country, but in the thinking of such MPs.❤❤india❤❤
First time saw vaishnavi ji to talk to someone with higher voice. But what can we say when opposition is talking BS 😂
Anyone can lose their cool when we have such brain-dead opposition with no nationalist and future ready vision all they do is caste reservation and freebies 🤦🤦
Being geologist, hearing this made my brain cells die😭
😂
😂
Aru ok now it brain is dead?even moti was criticizing petrol hike adhar fdi gst before 2014 how people brain would gave been now
Hii geologist
yes ,I think she did not clarify her point. perhaps she was just given the statements to speak like script in a TV show. Perhaps lost in translation and not enough research done.
Irony is that Japan was able to deploy bullet trains despite having lots of earthquakes every year, she could at least point out why she thinks it cannot be done in Indian soil despite producing loads of engineers.
Not only Japan see uae also
Dubai made Burj khalifa on desert land
@@ytuser9876 yep
Low IQ, lady leave it waste of time
@@mukul_valorant exactly, the thing is this kind of people don't have brain, or they don't want India to be a developed country, but they forgot people now a days r not fools.
@@syamvasana I despise her for not accepting her mistake, but IQ is not a credible concept or measure just like Nusrat's statement about soil quality and construction.
There should be some exams for MPs/MLAs/ministers.. then only these stupidities from politicians will stop
It's like me giving a presentation on disadvantages of bullet trains unprepared🤣
This is a learned leader whose background can tell you everything about him. Great leadership. Jai Hind
@Sun Moon Idiot most of the tracks will be on elevated levels that's why he mentioned pillars. This has nothing to do with soil and as for the minister I suggest u look up for his qualifications u will understand whether he has the grasp of the subject or not.
@Sun Moon Jitna uske pass knowledge hai utna tere pure khandan ke pass nahi hogan
She is 12th pass.
@Sun Moon Indian hoke aisa bolte hai ab tumko sharam aani chahiye
@@amazingdude9042 now you just did same comment like her lol
Last statement shows the spirit of bjp gov who is believing in our own people's and not any cheap foreigners
Bjp ke liye Ijjat baad jaati hai ayse ministers dekh ke And On the other hand Hamare pyaare bengal ki RULLING party ki ye jo bhi hai r@@ndi si aurat Itni Besharam hai uske baap ki personal dusmani lagti hai Bullet train se Loksabha me booli too booli tweet bhi karrhi saat me hey bhagwan inko buddhi dena
Ashwini Vaishnaw indian railway minister ,IIT graduate , top MBA school graduate from the US
is answering instagrami graduate Nusrat (neoliberals),poor girl should read his profile then talk about soil , He is an Engineer🤣🤣🤣
Then why did modi buy 2 cars Worth's ₹12 croes from America??
@@shayakguha1793 2 tata garuda are on order to replace them
@@shayakguha1793 are u stupid?? Ur comment doesnt even make sense.
So now a model-turned MP is going to teach 'SCIENCE' to an IITian Minister who has 10 times more qualifications than her...
LOL :-)
As a Bengali ,I am ashamed of what has become of our community. Glad ,I was raised out of Bengal.
Our railway minister was genuinely displeased on hearing such a remark and this was not a politician that was angry it was an engineer who has worked in this area for such a long time.
Even How these Types of People become MP
What a joke
Soil is not fit for Bullet Train 😂
Oh wow, I never heard how qualified Ashwini Vaishnav was. He's only 51 years old as well. Infact, he's much more educated than Kejriwal, and younger than him too. IAS officer with an all India rank of 27 🔥🔥🔥. He's a perfect candidate to be the prime minister of India after Modi 🔥🔥🔥. A perfect reply by the BJP to Kejriwal. I find Yogi Adityanath to be popular, but he cant stand up to this man. India needs him as PM! Yogi can be a great campaigner in UP, but I cant imagine Yogi representing India on the world stage.
@@sup1801 true. I like nitin gadkari and ashwini vaishnaw more than yogi.
@@samritichoudhary714 but in India even educated are illiterate. His competitor candidate will eat him in election. We have seen with sreedharan sir and even jaishankar sir would have lost against fools.
@@GoodBoy-rw9bi true
Logic of TMC MP's is Incredible!
Hats off! 😶
Ashwini Vaishnaw indian railway minister ,IIT graduate , top MBA school graduate from the US
is answering instagrami graduate Nusrat (neoliberals),poor girl should read his profile then talk about soil , He is an Engineer🤣🤣🤣
😄🤣😂😆
@@govindr3140 Also a retired civil servant 😇🇮🇳
Well, Japan being such vulnerable land for earthquakes run bullet trains with sound engineering.
Ok. If the honorable MP knows more, let she show the proofs to the railways and government. Safety of people is most important.
They are killing bengali youths from inside day by day. I am a youth from Bengal but a very very proud Indian and unapologetic follower of Sanatan Hindu Dharm. Now think what's our condition!!! They are destroying our mindset by giving freebies to those peacefuls.
Tell this minister to Look at the potholes on roads and flood like situations during monsoon in every major town - “ Indian engineers pe se vishwaas hi uth gaya” na keh de toh naam badal dena ..
In Japan earthquakes are frequent yet bullet trains run there
In India no earthquakes but we do have fertile soil
Being a civil engineer hearing that "soil is not fit for such type of trains to operate" Is just lame, had she ever seen japanese terrain?
This is the result of Madrasa chaap education.
When a madrasa Chaap get elected as MP in parliament this will be the result.
@@umbrellacorporation5723 not all are pundit and madrasa students 🤣 damn bro ur too funny
Inka bas chale toh Locomotive ko haram bolke , bullock cart laga ke train chalyega.
She is not talking specifically about soil
She is talking (Indian is not financially fit for bullet train)
@@Nkihgf stfu and go get some punctures done, abdul
As a Bengali, I am ashamed of such nuisence comment made by her. The country first at any case. She doesn't represent us neither Mamata.
Ofcourse she represents u n ur momta jihadi didi....
U bongs are shame on this earth.
Whole india witness brutality of momta Begum after winning election on Hindus...just wait h watch...we will show u ur aaukat
@@20vivekpandey Netaji Swamiji Rishi Aurobindo Raja Rammohan Roy Rabindranath Tagore Bankimchandra Chattopadhyay Amartya Sen Abhijit Vinayak Bandyopadhyay Rasbehari Bose Pandit Rabishankar Satyajit Ray Acharya Jagadish Chandra Bose all are shame on this earth?
I will slap you so hard, bap ka nam bhul jayega...
Don't dare to reply to my comment even you are an Anti India element.
@@sugayoongi7420 Talk about present Bangladesh aka west bengal doesn't represent any of legends you are mentioning.
Still u people don't have guts to get rid from Mamata begam party from bengal
She very much represents ur jihadi islam terrorist mamta begum shame on you too.
What else can you expect from someone who doesn’t have a background in this field, she is speaking from her experience 😄
In the Indian Parliament, is it permissible for a BCom graduate to rubbish the knowledge of an IIT MTech, on a matter pertaining to engineering!
Lesson - don't mess with civil servants
Ashwini Vaishnaw indian railway minister ,IIT graduate , top MBA school graduate from the US, IAS officer
is answering instagrami graduate Nusrat (neoliberals),poor girl should read his profile then talk about soil , He is an Engineer🤣🤣🤣
@@govindr3140 instagrami graduate 😂😂😂😂😂
Your comment is too good. 👏🤟🏻
He was an ex civil servant
He is entrepreneur now
Kejriwal was a civil servant. Yaswant Sinha too
Teacher : what is the meaning of fake Beauty😁 without Brains ?
Student : Nusrat Jahan🙄😂
@@reminiscence4142 exactly. Dont knwo hpw she is beautiful🤣
I want to beat my 'Didi' so much rn
@@Tillu_dream16-39 Arey Didi Kyun? BJP ka Yash Dasgupta bhi responsible hain.
Nah Emma Watson is Beauty without Brains. Nusrat Jahan has neither beauty nor brains.
Imagine if Mumta becomes PM and Nusrat Jahan is the railway minister
Jab dil ko lagti hai jabhi kam karte hai ye mantry log jab tak desh ki development mein koi interest nahi hota...hatts off
Vaishnaw did his schooling at St. Anthony's Convent School, Jodhpur, and at Mahesh School, Jodhpur. He graduated from MBM Engineering College (JNVU) Jodhpur in 1991 with a gold medal in an electronic and communications engineering course and then completed his M.Tech from IIT Kanpur, before joining the Indian Administrative Services in 1994 with an all-India rank of 27.[7] In 2008, Vaishnaw left for the US to do his MBA from Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.[8]
After his MBA, Vaishnaw came back to India and joined GE Transportation as Managing Director.[9] Subsequently, he joined Siemens as the Vice President - Locomotives & Head Urban Infrastructure Strategy.[10] Previously, he has also worked as deputy chairman of the Mormugao Port Trust, and thus has experience in both public and private sector enterprises.
In 2012, he quit the corporate sector and set up Three Tee Auto Logistics Private Limited and Vee Gee Auto Components Private Limited, both automotive components manufacturing units in Gujarat.[7]
In 1994, Vaishnaw joined the Indian Administrative Service in the Odisha cadre, and has worked extensively in different parts of Odisha including serving as the District Collector of Balasore and Cuttack districts.[3] He worked in Odisha till 2003 when he was appointed as deputy secretary in the office of former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee. After his brief stint in the PMO where he contributed to creating the public-private-partnership framework in infrastructure projects, Vaishnav was appointed as Vajpayee's private secretary after the BJP-led NDA lost the election in 2004.[11]
In 2006, he became deputy chairman of Mormugao Port Trust, where he worked for next two years.[12]
He took educational loan to complete his MBA at the Wharton Business School. He realized that it will take him years to payback educational loan and eventually he left civil service in 2010 to join private sector.[13]
AND YOU DOUBT HIS ABILITY.
Source Wikipedia
"soil is not fit" is a lame excuse . Engineers have overcome those problems . Even if there might be some places where it is not possible but not a problem for all over the India .
Topography is headache..but quality of soil...🤣🤣
A c grade actor turned MP is telling an iit graduate minister that soil is not fit for operating bullet trains.
As the Romans once said "keep entertainers away ". But Today in India we have entertainers who are party leaders and representatives.
Don't know about bullet train or soil, but she's hot as Fuck
Japan is much worse than India in terms of terrain where they have unstable topography and frequent earthquake
A proud Alumni of our college M. B. M. Engineering College, Jodhpur and an IAS officer. He is himself an engineer. It was really satisfying to see him taking stand for our engineers as everyone is busy making memes about engineers.
Proud to be from his college ♥️
@@TASTY251 well said ..
@me hey idiot when i commented about wearing sindoor???
@me & every 1 knows that she is characterless..
@me don't try to defend such anti social elements just bcz of ur wife liked that🤣🤣🤣
@me did u forget what she did with her husband???
As a Bengali i wanna say sorry to whole Bharat that we elected wrong government in west Bengal.....now a days Bharatiyas can't expect good things from Bengali people time has change my friends... Bengal is Bangladesh now a days you can't expect another Subhas Chandra Bose, can't expect another Rabindranath Tagor, can't expect another sherya goshal, can't expect another scientist, can't expect another Pranav Mukharji.... Instagram influencer want to teach IITan , Wharton graduate 😢
It is more shameful when this comes from the mouth of those who claim to talk about " Maa, Maati, Manush".
When u elect ppl just because of looks, religion or party with ZERO engineering knowledge this is how the debate standard goes down.
Muslims ko toh burqa wali pasand hai
True
@@varshakaurav btw she is Muslim n not wearing burqua or hijab ... but they say school students should wear it because its an integral part of their religion 🙄
She has engineering knowledge of going and dancing in front of camera with non indian traditional dress. Hey nusrat, where is your hijab yar☺️
You don't need to have engineering degree to know she's an idiot
I mean Nusrat is an actor, understandably her idea on engineering and how things are actually built, or challenges around it is pretty poor. The problem is, we have given them authority to comment on an engineering Marvel called Bullet trains... And to whom? Ashwini V, probably one of the finest SME ministers we have in the current administration.
Its more of a figurative statement, rather than a literal one. She's trying to say that bullet trains are not suitable for Indians.
The only actor who was capable of being an all-rounder was our dear Sushant Singh Rajput. I bet he would have been an asset to our country's infrastructural and scientific development. He had the potential and the makings, and in the right party, he would have worked wonders. Sadly, good people get taken away and we are stuck with morons.
@@abhishekjee919 true that!!! And again, that's because he was a brilliant engineer first... Became actor by choice..
@@ChandramouliGhosh01 But it's because of his interest
(SSR)which grew towards arts taking him to dancing and then in cinema..But anyway he was very humble and kind to everyone.Heck there are some gangs who didn't tolerate and erased him unknowingly,and again doing same with recently released good films like the kashmir files.Shame on those gangs who can't digest the good for the bad😡.
Nusrat ne thik kaha hai rss bjp sab barbaad kardiya hai
Mister RAILWAY Minister please make your Bullet Train Project Fast don't Shut in Parliament.
I am form West Bengal and TMC rules the state for which( killing of bjp party members and common people, Frauds, illegally muslim from bangladesh enters our territory, etc) happens in the state . For which our state is least developing
There goes the TMC mp who always confuse her REAL life to world and in assembly too
Ashwini Vaishnaw indian railway minister ,IIT graduate , top MBA school graduate from the US
is answering instagrami graduate Nusrat (neoliberals),poor girl should read his profile then talk about soil , He is an Engineer🤣🤣🤣
PEACEFUL COMMUNITY CAN NEVER TALK ABOUT SCIENCE AND LOGIC
Ye log logic mai nahi sirf magic mai mante
hai 🙏
Science is haram in ixlam
@@BEASTRex13 YE LOG RANGELA RASOOL MAI MANTE HAI
@Binyamin exception
@HAI I’M PAJEET PATEL popat Mohammad kid spotted 🤣
I would love to share my facts being a Civil Engineer...
The design of every structure is made keeping the Capicity of Soil.., for which a SBC (Soil bearing Capacity) test is performed by geotechnical team ...
Every point is kept in mind before designing and practically constructing
My maths teacher once used to give tuition lessons to nusrat, he used to regret everyday as he never came across such bimbo.. what a shame!
Is it true???
@Soumya Sarkar all the Sarkars in comment section 😂😂😂
@@abantisarkar2055 Here's is a Ganguly
I think every one of us is probably bengali
@@somnathganguly8609 😁😁
Excellent reply by Railway Minister who is qualified and knowledgeable person. We can’t try to explain people and those who don’t belief their Nations strength. Jaihind
Oh wow, I never heard how qualified Ashwini Vaishnav was. He's only 51 years old as well. Infact, he's much more educated than Kejriwal, and younger than him too. IAS officer with an all India rank of 27 🔥🔥🔥. He's a perfect candidate to be the prime minister of India after Modi 🔥🔥🔥. A perfect reply by the BJP to Kejriwal. I find Yogi Adityanath to be popular, but he cant stand up to this man. India needs him as PM! Yogi can be a great campaigner in UP, but I cant imagine Yogi representing India on the world stage.
This is the result of Madrasa chaap education.
When a madrasa Chaap get elected as MP in parliament this will be the result.
@@sup1801 jus Modi improved himself over the years. Yogi will do the same..we want a leader and educated MPs to run the country..
@@umbrellacorporation5723 china ka airport India ka bolney kya.. 😄
बेचारी को एक प्रश्न किसी ने लिख कर दे दिया होगा पूछ लेने देते ।
Everyone here is either an engineer or a geologist or something
Me: left the chat
As a civil engineer, i am utterly embarrassed and disappointed by such a statement.
Learn and have knowledge before you speak, this statement is best suited as an advice for her.
Am just out of words to speak after this🤦♂️
Fir to nadi me bridges bhi nahi ban sakte the because paani pillar ko nhi pakad paega 🤣. Kahan kahan se aate hain ye log.
@@IshanKesharwani Exactly, not only rivers. Even Mumbai TransHarbour Sea bridge is almost ready now.
Actors should not enter parliament
Specially actors belonging to TMC
Yes, absolutely. She is there as an ornament only.
@@rukmanikridshnan6338 Amethi me ground work and people se connect bahut hai unka. Dusri baat politicians face bas hote hain or zariya logo tak deliver krne ka. Asli kaam bureaucrats karte hain. Even policy making.
This is stupid . Whoever can win elections should enter parliament . It's not like non actors have done India much good . Modi himself is an actor . When the teleprompter didn't work he had no idea what to say and he went silent .
@@HimanshuGupta-bc3jy she doesn't talk like shit nusarat begum who doesn't know her child's father name
@@J7pat7 if you are winning an election then you should talk like elected representative
If she's right then Dubai is not fit for anything 😂😂😂
There are enough engineers in our country mam
First of all how could a tictoker became mp!!!! It's more shameful than anything else
After listening to Nusrat's speech LOGIC be like: " thik hai bhai.. ab mai chalta hun"
🤣🤣
Everyone who has watched the movie "Shool" will know, there is a scene where the politician says, agar paani se bijli nikal gayi to pani me kya bachega. She has done the same kind of blunder but this time not on reel but in real. Shameful.
hahahaha
@yamete kudasai tou tu chal ja desh chod kar!
@yamete kudasai chutiya dp kya lagaya hai
@yamete kudasai 😂🤣😅😆
Well said sir ❤
ये भारत की मिट्टी करके दिखाएगी 💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿
Man, Ashwini sir always speaks in sweet voice, first time I am seeing sir shouting makes it obvious what kind of level this opposition has fallen to that they have to oppose every good thing.
Big salute to the TMC MP. After studying science and geography for so many, never anyone taught me about this concept. First, Indian soil is not fit for bullet train. Second that all that concept of black soil, red soil, alluvial soil, laterite soil, etc was bullshit. Madam needs to start a youtube channel and teach us the real classification of soil.
Yup 😂you are absolutely right 😂
she will teach how to shake the ass on instagram and ticktok
R a sir try to understand ma'am must be got something for this type comment. She read out that line only.
*she is a madarsa chap jihadi mindset girl, same girls of her community today want BURKHA OVER EDUCATUON*
You are right bro 😂😂
Ticktoker nachaniya vs. IITian, IAS, MBA graduate, Entrepreneur Highly Qualified rail minister 🙏🙏🔥🔥🔥
This is why we need some aptitude/common sense exams before letting them into the parliament... If we make clearing UPSC mandatory before standing in elections then our country will become unbeatable in few decades
I mean has she done any research on our soils to come to that conclusion. Who was she, a scientist??
Madarasa scientist
GAWAR thi
Just a adult actress 😂🤣🤣🤣.
REFUGEE FROM BANGLADESH WITH FAKE AADHAR CARD .
@@govindrajan9887 🤣🤣
This girl is Muslim and every Muslim dreams of going to Dubai ones in life, she went there and said dubai's desert is not fit for burj khalifa 😂
@MENACE YT uneducated dumb actress became leader.
🤣🤣
@@zoyaelizavetahafeez2 waise vi , hindu muslim se koi fark nahi parta , jo chor hai toh wo chor hai , every hindu respect Apj Abdul kalam but not bin laden . But a lot of Muslims respect bin laden and not apj abdul kalam.
@@zoyaelizavetahafeez2 if you are a muslim and are educated and live peacefully then we respect you. But if you are a muslim and want to kill and convert peoples of other religions then i really condemn you.
@@zoyaelizavetahafeez2 you will be astonished to hear that 90 % ra$pists and criminals are from a particular religion . This are statistics. And hindu population from 2010 to 2018 have decreased drastically to 83 % to 79% . In Pakistan once hindu population were about 30 % . In 2010 if was 13 % ,now it is 0.3 %. In Bangladesh hindu population was about 55 % during independence, now it is about 5 % . So sad to say , my grandfather was also from Bangladesh, they were brutally tortured and so they fled to india in 1950s.
Yes! We believe on our engineers.
My stomach is not fit for this type of word digest 😂😂😂.
Leave all the Engineering knowledge just consider simple Geography, Japan is the most Earthquake prone country, it is a collection of over 6k islands yet they have Bullet trains whereas India is not so much of earthquake prone and Definitely isn't an island. Just this Basic Geography defies her claim although it might be possible than in certain areas it could get a little difficult to erupt pillars due to geographical conditions but it definitely isn't Impossible.
How dare you question TMC's choice of parliament candidate 🤣😅
Exactly sir , I was just about to point out the same (that Japan is one of the most earthquake prone countries) and I came across your comment. The opposition parties have become so desperate and intolerant that they are blindly opposing whatever Modi govt proposes to do.
Exactly my thoughts too given that Japan is so earthquake prone and they have had it for the last 50 years
Even my thoughts on Japan . Second you brother
This is the result of Madrasa chaap education.
When a madrasa Chaap get elected as MP in parliament this will be the result.
I can't believe this MP belongs to a state that once " a long time ago" produced scientist like JC Bose and Meghnad Saha etc Facts without data points are as good as biases and opinions. My concern is that surely this must have been discussed by TMC, and everybody concluded on this. Was there nobody within TMC to oppose such statements??
she is a bimbo and has no knowledge about ground reality, She should stick to her acting and her affairs and cheating her partner
She's a Muslim, she hates india lol
@@kartikeyatiwari2502 toh hindu se kyu shaadi ki
@@cryptoboi9584 I think months later she said they just married but never registered the marriage. Meaning she was just sleeping around.
The sindoor and saree was a complete fake drama.
TMC is headed by a moron who understands only communal politics..She doesn’t care about facts and logic
when education enters politics
I got failed in my geography subject in all standards and I want to become MP like Nushrat !!
"This is what happens when you didn't understand the concepts of science 🤣🤣"
It's ok since you belong to TMC it is obvious that you will oppose the projects led by BJP government but please don't do and say anything that disrespect our country 🙏🏻
And if the Indian soil is unfit then what are you doing here please leave
no one disrespect our country. listen carefully, every technology from outside doesn't need to be incorporated.
bending words? its the failure of bullet train. when you say you soil if weak and sandy cannot support 24th floor building its not disrespect if you make it may cause catastrophe, its like when you say china has infiltrated our country and our govt was sleeping, BJP said don't insult our Army! so many bomb blast occurred in India Admitting it doesn't insult our Army.
Yaa I am also not a bjp fan but that comment was illogical and disrespecting her own country
Oh wow if someone says this soil is unfit for cultivation or anything you will call them anti national? But yeah I am not supporting her because her statement is utter nonsense but stop showing fake patriotism in the comments. They look cringe asf.
@@abhikbose3100 see i don't agree bcoz i don't know the fact.
But there may be a possibility that our soil and environment may not suitable for such technology to maintain it. We may not be able to use it at full speed or to keep track clear and to protect equipment from harsh environment we may spend more than we can afford. Then what?
You know our trains have capacity to run at 300km per hour but our tracks Cannot handle it. It doesn't disrespect the track or the soil.
Rather than tackling such statements with intellect and surveys they are not even ready to listen. Just make it nationalism issue and be proud Indian. Thats not how it should work. If something happens either you or me will die or pay price from our pocket
She's doing nothing just Marry.. Oppss..😛 😁😁 stay live in with a guy nd get pregnant with another guy..
Well said mr Ashwini🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼Jai Hind
If opposition demands a qualified PM then we have our ASHWINI VAISHNAV
Firstly, Nusrat Jahan should clarify who's the father of her baby. Then she should think about Indian infrastructure.
She also doesn't know..who's sperm laid a track on her fertile land.
Ashwini Vaishnaw indian railway minister ,IIT graduate , top MBA school graduate from the US
is answering instagrami graduate Nusrat (neoliberals),poor girl should read his profile then talk about soil , He is an Engineer🤣🤣🤣
Bullet train can be constructed in Japan one of the most seismic prone region on Earth but not in India. 😂
😂😂😂😂😂
@@YourIndianbuddy_vk madarsa logic😎
What science she is talking about?
Her example Japan is a Tier 1 earthquake prone area.
Only issue we might face would be cost overun and safety
Cost over run is due to maharhastra.
Leave it she is a fool
@@shagnikgoswami9224 *peacefool
Only costs will be a concern. Japanese are implementing the project and Japanese bullet train tech is renowned for its reliability and safety.
Also see uae
Dubai made Burj Khalifa on desert land
I'm surprised to see that this comment section is full of engineers who actually have the knowledge..😂
I don't understand the memes on engineers stating that engineers know everything but engineering!!
Most of them are those engineers who are jobless and have nothing other then targetting religion to earn their 2 ₹ daily from IT cell.
I know she sounds stupid but taking everything to religion is shit as hell this shows the future if great India may god save India.
That kind of MP is we needed?
Educated minister
Former IAS
MBA graduate
IIT from kanpur 🔥
IIT kanpur
Kuch bhi. Well you don't know that Japan has approx 80% land covered with mountains and during winters all those tracks are covered by heavy snows in December still they run Bullet train whole year.
True, only motivation and will power is needed to achieve technological feat. Logistics we can overcome
Also to top it off they have to design bullet trains to mitigate the threat of earthquakes as well, lol now tell her that Japan also should be unfit to run bullet trains 🤣 🤣
@@anuraghsaka8630 💯🤣🤣
Filmi Wale kya soch sakte hai....we are engineers....pls don't mess with our minds
I am super proud to have ashwini vaishnav as RM
Truly this man is a Gem 💎
One of the most literate politicians in India, I trust him as our railway Minister 🙏
As an engineer...I can tell that engineering has excelled in all areas to such an extent that anything can be possible if there is a willingness.
It cannot increase my intelligence to TMC levels, so it's pretty much a waste.
☠️
railway minister instead of explaining how the project will be executed, he went to rant about "maa maati manush". He completely took it out of context. only Bjp People can talk without any sense 🤣🤣... Tmc - I want place to pee.
bjp mp - how dare you saying about peeing on our bharat🤣🤣
@@masternobin please correct the spelling of your name, I D I O T are missing from it.
@@masternobin nobin dustbin lol
@@cryptoboi9584 funny 🤣🤣...
Reminds me of movie shool, wherein the actor says ….what will remain of water if electricity is pulled out of it.
Nusrat was a student of Accountancy not of Engineering !! I don't know why such people should be allowed to talk. Let her act in films.
a 12th fail 3rd class b grade actress with scientific knowledge equivalent to kindergarten kids, lecturing IIT grads about how our soil is not suitable for bullet trains, has to be the most * face palm* moment.
I pray she recovers from the 'after divorce' effect as early as possible.
exactly, can't be better said than this
Good
Kinder garden kids are more talented than this tic-toker
Well said and even he had expert railway knowledge by working in companies