We aren't trying to get rid of Garnacho. If someone offers us crazy money, fine. But he's got years on his deal, he's clearly got talent, is young with room to develop and adapt to Amorims style. Same as Mainoo, Hojlund, Collyer, even Zirkzee. He is clearly working on developing them. If he decides that they are done, fine, but he doesn't appear to have said that about any of then. So there's no pressure to sell them, they are playing, developing, have talent value, age value and contract value. So... absolutely no need to accept offers that don't meet our valuation. Cas, Rash, Eriksen, and Linda are all the ones definitely with no future. Antony unlikely to be salvaged under Amorim and so probably off too. Sick notes Shaw and Mount might be at risk too. The issue is they are all overpaid and so getting rid is gonna be hard. Clubs won't pay those wages, so they are within their rights to sit back and take our money, instead of a pay cut to move and us getting a fee. Eriksen and Linda go in the summer for free anyway. Rash might go because he wants to play to get back into the Englad squad. Cas might go to Saudi for the money and he's at the end of his career. But don't expect sudden miracle deals where we get rid of our unwanted, high wage players quickly and easily.
Well it depends doesn’t it, on his attitude. We don’t ‘need’ to do anything, the power dynamic ‘needs’ to shift where players ‘need’ to prove they are worthy of the privilege of playing for this club. If he thinks he’s bigger than the club, then he needs to go, regardless of his ability. That was the fundamental part of Ferguson success and it is also the fundamentals of Amorim. The successful Portuguese academy system highly prizes attitude.
It would be stupid for Garnacho to leave if United start performing again. I mean, they are already picking uo some momentum now. As for Rashford, he should do what Garnacho has done and do his job cause he has the speed, power, physicality & crossing ability to be a good winger for United. If he does what Garnacho is doing based on the past 2 games, actually oassing the ball, Rashford will rack up a lot of assists.
Maguire has started every game we have looked good in. He stays no question. I trust this manager to do exactly what this club needs regardless of time frame. As fans we must endure and be patient it’s the only way. There’s is very few managers that would have the balls to come into Man Utd and rip it all up. We should want him to stay for this alone
We have been on the backfoot most those games, so it suits Maguire. As soon as we start getting in some players and becoming agressive he will fall off.
Napoli seem to have an eye for snatching transfers. Tominay is there, & they're enjoying him. Now they've come back for more that's if the move goes through. We need to sell, & buy well. Goodnews is skysports said no EPL club has PSR issues. If Anthony is open to a move its a good thing.
Napoli interested in Garnacho only for a serious decent prize, if United tries to pimp up things, you can keep it! Plus, no Napoli players will ever take the road to Red Manchester!
The best thing is to be patient.when we are patient then all will be well and we will see what happens by the end of the window nothing to worry about.If we did not have transfer rumours of any form then we should be worried.I think Amorim and the board are in agreement 🤝.We just signed Leon so we are still ok considering the psr
I think the big problem is that certain players are on far too much money and as such don’t want to move on.I don’t think that the board are the problem on this occasion. As for Garnacho I don’t want him to move on…yet at least
Here's the thing..sell garnacho for £50 million and you can buy 5 £50 million players on a five year deal.. according to PSR rules.. that doesn't account for 5 lots of wages so you realistically buy 3 £50 million players with the money..mad innit
I'm sorry Alice i don't buy for 1 minute that our manager gave a hard fast deadline for anything to our owners. You might as well resign because there's not 1 job where the employee can give the employer ultimatums.
I believe if a bid north of 50m came in, we would sell Garnacho extremely fast. The implications for PSR are incredible, we'd be stupid not to do it. Would effectively allow us to buy 2-3 top players because of amoritization rules and how homegrown talent is counted as pure profit on the books. He's not even a regular starter anymore so his value will probably be lower in the summer.
I will be gutted to lose Garna. That iconic overhead goal showed exquisite talent. However, I do think he is impressionable and needs marure and wise heads to mentor him and keep him focussed.
Yes, I think he should be given to the end of the season to show he can improve consistency level Alice. On his day, can be lethal. But needs to show he will battle every game. @@AliceTalksFootball
NOTHING changes. Glazers have us burdened with debt, no liquidity, players who are ridiculously overpaid, a rotting stadium, etc. BUT Jim rides in to the 'rescue' on a broken old stick horse and buys his way into the Glazer family. Just what we needed: ANOTHER Glazer! GLAZERIOS OUT OUT OUT OUT OUT!!!!!!!!
If we do nothing in January so be it. We have seen what these players are capable of now it’s time to support the manager and his decisions which in turn means any player he selects for the first team !!
if garnacho wants to go ,he should be let go. like klopp like pep always say, if someone wanna go they can go. unhappy player is worse than no player. and for rashford, just freaking go already, im tired of this guy. making interviews "im ready for new challenge" "i may stay" ..like just kick him out, this club is not rashford fc . give him free.
Garnacho is one of our gems, if you have only watched football for 5 mins then you gotta learn from experience! We need garnacho maino amad amas collyer out youth system is the best in the world! Gotta sell the bang average players and over 30s casemiro Maguire Lindelof Shaw dalot rashford Erikson malacia Antony these, if we sell these deadwood players we can add world class strikers midfielders left back wingers and defenders
@jimwatkins3134 Because of Psr and ffp selling the over 30's won't do anything to improve our finances and our ability to buy players. Garnacho struggles to control a football. He's not a gem by any stretch of the imagination. And he doesn't even fit into the system. He should be sold asap. We need to bring in a left wing back and an attacking player.
We have a supposed United fan who financially rescued the parasitic Glazers & only owns 28% of the club. Why is anybody surprised about anything? I wish I could genuinely be that innocent again.. It's horrid being cynical.
It depends on Garnacho, if he wants to stay, he can, if he wants to leave he can too, but it’ll cost him £70mill, otherwise bench him till contract ends. If rashford can be outcasted, so can garnacho.
Garnacho is a huge talent, we need to build around him and not sell our gems, do you want to sell all our youth? Sell Maguire, casemiro rashford shaw Antony dalot Erikson these are the player we gotta get rid
Alice clubs were never doing business before the 13th of Jan because of PSR rules unless they were certain of complying so you gotta give ineos a break with that.
We aren't trying to get rid of Garnacho. If someone offers us crazy money, fine. But he's got years on his deal, he's clearly got talent, is young with room to develop and adapt to Amorims style. Same as Mainoo, Hojlund, Collyer, even Zirkzee. He is clearly working on developing them. If he decides that they are done, fine, but he doesn't appear to have said that about any of then.
So there's no pressure to sell them, they are playing, developing, have talent value, age value and contract value. So... absolutely no need to accept offers that don't meet our valuation.
Cas, Rash, Eriksen, and Linda are all the ones definitely with no future. Antony unlikely to be salvaged under Amorim and so probably off too. Sick notes Shaw and Mount might be at risk too. The issue is they are all overpaid and so getting rid is gonna be hard. Clubs won't pay those wages, so they are within their rights to sit back and take our money, instead of a pay cut to move and us getting a fee. Eriksen and Linda go in the summer for free anyway.
Rash might go because he wants to play to get back into the Englad squad. Cas might go to Saudi for the money and he's at the end of his career. But don't expect sudden miracle deals where we get rid of our unwanted, high wage players quickly and easily.
Who gave you information that Amorim gave Utd 2 wks to sign players?? Amorim is an employee and doesn’t give orders to the owners 😊
We need to get rid of Rashford, Eriksen and Casemiro and KEEP GARNACHO
That should be the focus for January but who knows!
@@AliceTalksFootballmust happen not only waffle
Well it depends doesn’t it, on his attitude. We don’t ‘need’ to do anything, the power dynamic ‘needs’ to shift where players ‘need’ to prove they are worthy of the privilege of playing for this club. If he thinks he’s bigger than the club, then he needs to go, regardless of his ability. That was the fundamental part of Ferguson success and it is also the fundamentals of Amorim. The successful Portuguese academy system highly prizes attitude.
It would be stupid for Garnacho to leave if United start performing again. I mean, they are already picking uo some momentum now.
As for Rashford, he should do what Garnacho has done and do his job cause he has the speed, power, physicality & crossing ability to be a good winger for United.
If he does what Garnacho is doing based on the past 2 games, actually oassing the ball, Rashford will rack up a lot of assists.
Maguire has started every game we have looked good in. He stays no question. I trust this manager to do exactly what this club needs regardless of time frame. As fans we must endure and be patient it’s the only way. There’s is very few managers that would have the balls to come into Man Utd and rip it all up. We should want him to stay for this alone
Maguire is not good enough , that is true, but their is value in having him their in a rebuild
We have been on the backfoot most those games, so it suits Maguire. As soon as we start getting in some players and becoming agressive he will fall off.
Some people had unrealistic expectations, January was always going to be quiet.
I really can't believe we're letting garnacho and mainoo go, loan maybe but not for good😥😥😥
If Liverpool got their hands on garna we may live to regret it They will make him better.
Let's hope the glazers don't give us the normal conciliatory last minute one foot player or a has been
No outs no ins simple
I would be sorry to see Garnacho go, better decision making I accept is needed.
Napoli seem to have an eye for snatching transfers. Tominay is there, & they're enjoying him. Now they've come back for more that's if the move goes through. We need to sell, & buy well. Goodnews is skysports said no EPL club has PSR issues. If Anthony is open to a move its a good thing.
Napoli interested in Garnacho only for a serious decent prize, if United tries to pimp up things, you can keep it! Plus, no Napoli players will ever take the road to Red Manchester!
The best thing is to be patient.when we are patient then all will be well and we will see what happens by the end of the window nothing to worry about.If we did not have transfer rumours of any form then we should be worried.I think Amorim and the board are in agreement 🤝.We just signed Leon so we are still ok considering the psr
I think the big problem is that certain players are on far too much money and as such don’t want to move on.I don’t think that the board are the problem on this occasion.
As for Garnacho I don’t want him to move on…yet at least
It's really only the last 7 days of any transfer window that matter... that's when buyers have the power.
Here's the thing..sell garnacho for £50 million and you can buy 5 £50 million players on a five year deal.. according to PSR rules.. that doesn't account for 5 lots of wages so you realistically buy 3 £50 million players with the money..mad innit
The only one not sellable now is Amorim,if Amorim doesn't want them sell them
Gonna be interesting to see what happens 👏
Couldn’t Rashford accept a lower salary whilst on loan ? - I guess that’s a silly question
I'm sorry Alice i don't buy for 1 minute that our manager gave a hard fast deadline for anything to our owners. You might as well resign because there's not 1 job where the employee can give the employer ultimatums.
I believe if a bid north of 50m came in, we would sell Garnacho extremely fast. The implications for PSR are incredible, we'd be stupid not to do it. Would effectively allow us to buy 2-3 top players because of amoritization rules and how homegrown talent is counted as pure profit on the books. He's not even a regular starter anymore so his value will probably be lower in the summer.
the focus should be on players in to help win europa
I will be gutted to lose Garna. That iconic overhead goal showed exquisite talent. However, I do think he is impressionable and needs marure and wise heads to mentor him and keep him focussed.
I think he’s been hit and miss but I want him to stay a bit longer before making a decision to sell.
Yes, I think he should be given to the end of the season to show he can improve consistency level Alice. On his day, can be lethal. But needs to show he will battle every game. @@AliceTalksFootball
He can't live off that goal forever. Fact is, no part of his game has improved since he broke through into the first team.
Can he dribble? Does he have ball control? Can he receive in tight spaces? Can he play as a 10??
Good assist for Bruno goal Sunday.
Harry Amass LWB give him a chance and minutes especially against Southampton
AC Milan has dropped interest in Walker.
Why you commenting on the Garnacho story when both the club and player's brother has already debunked this ridiculous story. It's a nothing.
Ineos is same as Glazers!!!
In before Kolo Muani comes and scores 12 goals by end of season...
And Shaw
No way is he Garncho worth 40 let alone 70 ! Same with the wrash. All broken players, surplus to requirements.
NOTHING changes. Glazers have us burdened with debt, no liquidity, players who are ridiculously overpaid, a rotting stadium, etc. BUT Jim rides in to the 'rescue' on a broken old stick horse and buys his way into the Glazer family. Just what we needed: ANOTHER Glazer! GLAZERIOS OUT OUT OUT OUT OUT!!!!!!!!
70 million, sell him definitely......i think Garnacho has caught what Rashford has, so sell him for a good profit
Alice saludo Super cordial ❤❤❤
Presumably Amorim told you himself that he is disappointed? Why do you say things like this
Nothing is gonna happen 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Casemiro out asap
Less talk more action
If we do nothing in January so be it. We have seen what these players are capable of now it’s time to support the manager and his decisions which in turn means any player he selects for the first team !!
You have a point but we need a defensive left back urgently. Or we switch Dalot and martinas
need a goalie
if garnacho wants to go ,he should be let go. like klopp like pep always say, if someone wanna go they can go. unhappy player is worse than no player. and for rashford, just freaking go already, im tired of this guy. making interviews "im ready for new challenge" "i may stay" ..like just kick him out, this club is not rashford fc . give him free.
Yeah true. I don’t think he wants to leave but maybe just exploring just in case INEOS sell to raise funds
Alice your connection not good
Garnacho is a bang average footballer at best. If any club drops 50 million, get rid.
Garnacho is one of our gems, if you have only watched football for 5 mins then you gotta learn from experience! We need garnacho maino amad amas collyer out youth system is the best in the world! Gotta sell the bang average players and over 30s casemiro Maguire Lindelof Shaw dalot rashford Erikson malacia Antony these, if we sell these deadwood players we can add world class strikers midfielders left back wingers and defenders
@jimwatkins3134 Because of Psr and ffp selling the over 30's won't do anything to improve our finances and our ability to buy players. Garnacho struggles to control a football. He's not a gem by any stretch of the imagination. And he doesn't even fit into the system. He should be sold asap. We need to bring in a left wing back and an attacking player.
@richyclubsport5155 You're just a wierdo who creates multiple threads saying a lot of nothing .
@richyclubsport5155 While you're on a keyboard responding to my post. Irony doesn't exist in your wierdo existence
Bro stops making youtube content as United starts winning handful of games 😂
We have a supposed United fan who financially rescued the parasitic Glazers & only owns 28% of the club. Why is anybody surprised about anything? I wish I could genuinely be that innocent again.. It's horrid being cynical.
It depends on Garnacho, if he wants to stay, he can, if he wants to leave he can too, but it’ll cost him £70mill, otherwise bench him till contract ends. If rashford can be outcasted, so can garnacho.
Garnacho is not going anywhere bullshit stories
Garnacho isn’t worth 30. Take the deal at 40. He isn’t worth building around.
Garnacho is a huge talent, we need to build around him and not sell our gems, do you want to sell all our youth? Sell Maguire, casemiro rashford shaw Antony dalot Erikson these are the player we gotta get rid
@@jimwatkins3134 you don"t keep a player just because they are young. He isn't good enough.
Chelsea said the same thing about Salah
@@Noone-m3s not talking about Salah, or any other player who found success at another club. Talking about Garnacho.
Don't sell the NACHO. Ineos only at O.T. to make money not spend. The RAT is a business man not a fan.
By yourself a hair clip,then I'll subscribe
Alice clubs were never doing business before the 13th of Jan because of PSR rules unless they were certain of complying so you gotta give ineos a break with that.
Keep mainoo
Sell Garnacho