Shocked, open mouthed silence - that's the Taemin Effect 👍 Literally everything about this comeback is perfection - thank God artists like him exist 👑👑👑 x
Shocked, mouths agape, silent awe, because empathetic souls felt something haunting, powerful and majestic that was lost in translation. I made an explainer video for that, because Taemin's truth wants to be heard.
Taemin slayed us with this comeback. No one does it like him. His vocals are hauntingly beautiful and don't get me started on his dancing. The king is back!✨️
kpop's one true ace for real for real. like taemin is beyond kpop, he is an artist in his own right. he may not produce his own music, but he takes these songs and make them HIS. he's actually insane, i can't even describe how i feel. only taemin can evoke these emotions in me. he's just built different idk.
When you said 'I missed this feeling' I felt that. Nobody can really compare to Taemin. It's hard to imagine other effortlessly doing this kind of concept/theme/genre. It could look trying hard let's be honest LOL Others can also try doing a 'sexier' concepts, but Taemin has like a different level of sensuality it's so hard to explain. And when others cover his choreo, I'm always like 'Taemin really moves differently'. he adds a flair on his movements
I was SO shocked when I first saw the mv, one of the most moving, evocative things I've seen in a WHILE. The storytelling is insane, I've been obsessed with all the theories.
You said everything there needs to be said about Taemin. He is THE ARTIST of a lot of people’s lives, including mine. He’s not only inspirational to K-pop idols but to regular people. Every time he releases new music there’s so many layers to his art. I love this man.
This is the perfect reaction to the genius of Taemin! Your expressions were priceless. They remind me so much of my own response when I first watched the mv. I sat open mouthed in absolute awe. The whole album is amazing. He is without doubt the greatest Male Solo kpop artist in kpop history IMHO. Perfect reactions! ❤❤❤
I named him the best soloist in kpop ever since I listened to Advice and Idea, and my man just keeps on getting better like bruh don't overslay the entire industry now
I am so happy for everything that you both said about Taemin. Sometimes I feel sad that SHINee and their members are not known more worldwide as they should since they are so amazingly talented and I want more people to appreciate them. Thank you for your reaction ❤
This is it. Periodt. He is the undefeated Idol's Idol; the Lee Taemin. SHINee and Taemin always prove us one thing "when talent and hard work come together, the outcome is always a masterpiece." Yes talent matters the most. This is a Masterpiece. Honestly I am always proud of being a Shawol. I am lucky to know SHINee music also I am truely blessed to experience the artistry of Onew, Jonghyun, Key, Minho and Taemin. Always 5HINee!! 💎💎💎💎💎
The sheer amount of emotions this song brought out of me while listening/watching the MV. My body was tensing at every high and every low, the push and pull, the drama, the explosive satisfying release. Goddamn Taemin, this might honestly be a contender for #2 all time fav kpop song after RV Psycho
Taemin was the artist that got me to finally give kpop a chance and then he immediately left so this comeback has been a lot for me and oh my gosh... the stunned silence is so real. every time i watch the video i feel like i cant breathe until it's over. he is such an incredible artist and performer
Same! I got into Kpop because a blessed TH-cam algorithm showed me Taemin’s Advice. Like, two months after he left. He’s my ult of ult/higher power by this point and I have been BLESSED by this comeback!
Breathless, awe, silence, speechless, yep, for a reason. GUILTY means a lot to Taemin, but specific messages have been lost in translation. I made an explainer video to rectify that, and to justify the artist of artists.
I know a lot of ARMY would disagree (I’m an ARMY) but I just think that BTS themselves would say the exact same thing about Taemin being the king/trendsetter lmao. It’s just a fact 🤷🏻♀️ someone below said it right: bias aside, it will always be Taemin This music video and the song was jaw dropping and I’m stoked he got a win for the song
"He and Shinee put the bar where it is today". Amen. The talent in Shinee blows my mind... Onew, Taemin, Key, Minho... and Jonghyun of course... 15 year performance veterans. Just go back and watch their debut "Replay" when they were babies.. They hit the road running. Taemin's Danger set his direction, his work on "Move" with the Japanese dancer Koharu Sugawara really levelled up his dance... he has worked so hard on his voice. I've been waiting for his return and I love Guilty. The Rizzness is also great.. The recent KBS live performance where they did Move and The Rizzness with La Chica dancers Rian and Gabee was awesome.. Check it out!
You girls have made my day! And yes, to everything you've said and more. Taemin is a once-in-a-lifetime artist. I've said it before, and I'll not tire of saying it again. Thank you for your Taemin appreciation 💖
Taemin stays true to himself as an artist and performer. I have the utmost respect for him and how he is authentically himself in his music and delivery. I agree with you both that the direction of kpop has shifted towards more western sounds which takes away of why we listen to kpop in the first place. I'm so glad he's back and I can't wait to witness the continuation of his artistry.
So relatively true- bias aside it will always SHINEE. they paved the way for KPOP. where the time inter fans can only see them through youtube. and for TAEMIN consistently serves quality artistic music since day 1- even 5th gen will witness. His B-side tracks were gold too!! KING👑
This is a fucking masterpiece. I love the whole album, but especially "Blue". It's GORGEOUS. If you haven't watched his "Suchwita" episode yet, I highly recommend it. Yoogi basically spends the whole episode telling Taemin how great he is and how many idols look up to him. And there's another special guest! 😉🐣
I love the part where he tells Jimin that he wants Taemin n Taemin just there listening been shy.. suga b like we meet few more times we b closer than ur friendship with him Jimin 😂😂 n the bombastic side eyes Jimin keeps giving 😂😂😂
This and Advice were contenders for Taemin's title track before leaving for the military, SM and Taemin decided it was too early and I agree. Can yall imagine if Guilty released in 2021 and they just LEFT US LIKE THIS FOR 2 YEARS??? We would NOT have been ready for it in 2021, literally everything lined up for this comeback and it was executed perfectly
This reaction is everything, thank you ladies for your words and relatableness This MV, song and concept.... TAEMIN is the representative, he is the art, he is the moment, HE NEEDS TO BE WORLDWIDE FAMOUS!!!!!!!!!
when i saw criminal i felt so many things i felt i was drawn to him i felt oh my is this taemin i now know wy so many k pop artists have taemin on the topm of the lists they make for k po idols they love
It's so true what you are saying about Taemin as a solo artist and SHINee! I've been saying that for years but still, they don't get the recognition they deserve. ESPECIALLY, Taemin! SHINee men 17+ years consistent in the industry, Taemin 10+ years as a solo artist and they're STILL on 🔥🔥🔥!
The way half of the population doesn't know about this song still amazes me, how come people didn't make this chart? This song deserves so muchh moreee. It's an actual masterpiece.
Taemin is a goat!!! His dancing is undeniably superior and his vocals are amazing!!!! I knew the after military Taemin was going to be a force to be reckoned with but this comeback exceeds my expectations!!! 😳😍❤️
yes UNDEFEATED !!! kpop representative surely..and SHINee is the bar, nobody compares, agreed people and taemin said this body blame Minho ..he trained Taemin like in military
My mouth is open. He is in kpop industry years and years but they always surprise me. They are still amazing. He deserve all awards. He is the best of the best.
GRACIAS POR ser la voz de muchas personas que pensamos lo mismo de TAEMIN. EL ES LA SUPREMACIA DE LA INDUSTRIA .Llore cuando lo vi por primera vez ,. sentía un nudo en mi corazon TAEMIN logro atravez de su maravilloso arte transmitir lo que queria en cada parte del video. Pocas personas en el mundo pueden hacer eso. Y TAEMIN es uno de ellos. ,por no decir el unico .BIENVENIDO REY. 👏👏❤️
A si quedamos todas o . Con este regreso del REY .Demostrando porque es el ídolo de los ídolos .SUPREMACIA ARTE en toda la extensión de la palabra..GRACIAS por regresar extrañaba muchisimo tu ARTE ❤❤
Differently alike I love your reaction so much I was just like you when I saw this MV I'm speechless until now it's a lot of art a lot of beauty Taemin is pure art I love him so much I was missing him so much this comebcack is perfect the album It's perfect, please react to Rizzness on his new album, you're going to love this song, it's very good
I don't know if its better than move,but this song made me feel emotions I have never ever felt from a song ever.This was a pure cinematic experience.Guilty was phenomenal.
Heard someone point out that they felt/saw/heard Move and Criminal within this mv. I went back and watched Guilty again and I could see Move movements here, not the exact movements but the feel, the patience before performing the move. Not sure if this make sense. lol
i really love what u said about taemin, cuz that's the truth i've been waiting for someone to say out loud, and i wanna say that, it's the same for SHINEE,but, unfortunately, few people know that, so plz react to more of SHINEE, especially old songs, cuz they deserve to make everyone know who was the one who created everything what k pop groups nowadays enjoy , and tey r sill setting the bar soooooo high despite of all what they have been trough , and thank uuuuu
I felt the same way when i watched it, I just had to sit there with it before i could even rewatch it, he's such an artist and he puts so much into what he does. I love that you can take different things from watching it each time. Small note, his body is not from the military, he actually had very bad mental health during that time, and had to be moved to civil service, he actually gained weight during that time. His body is all his own work after leaving the military.
He is my baby boy ultimate from the begining I feel like his Kpop mom is is a amazing performer artist he is the one and only thete is no Othet Taemin Iam so proud beyond the universe 👑🔥☄🎆
I love your reaction! Taemin is on another level (all of Shinee actually). The sad part though about the korean music industry, is that their awards are a popularity contest where all the elementary school kids do the voting, or people that are only fixated with one group and never care to listen or be objective to anything else, almost like they are in a cult.
this was the quietest differently alike reaction like you can tell they were trying to process everything and how good this song is 😭😭😭
Its definitely so good like wow 😧👏🏼👏🏼
Shocked, open mouthed silence - that's the Taemin Effect 👍 Literally everything about this comeback is perfection - thank God artists like him exist 👑👑👑 x
Shocked, mouths agape, silent awe, because empathetic souls felt something haunting, powerful and majestic that was lost in translation. I made an explainer video for that, because Taemin's truth wants to be heard.
12:35 "SM would be nothing without this man. The Kpop industry would be nothing without this man." Preach it girlies !!!!!!!! Where is the lie?
For me it is song of the year 2024 ❤❤❤❤
Taemin slayed us with this comeback. No one does it like him. His vocals are hauntingly beautiful and don't get me started on his dancing. The king is back!✨️
kpop's one true ace for real for real. like taemin is beyond kpop, he is an artist in his own right. he may not produce his own music, but he takes these songs and make them HIS. he's actually insane, i can't even describe how i feel. only taemin can evoke these emotions in me. he's just built different idk.
The silence was LOUD AND CLEAR. This is masterpiece, album as well. "The Rizzness" got me FERAL.
This song is a MASTERPIECE ✨ Taemin gave his soul to this song! His vocals and expressiveness in his dance moves show how talented and unique he is 🙌
Taemin is a genius in every sense of the word
The idol’s idol for a REASON. This man is a whole work of art, and everything he does is a masterpiece.
Taemin deserves to be recognised by the entire world
When you said 'I missed this feeling' I felt that. Nobody can really compare to Taemin. It's hard to imagine other effortlessly doing this kind of concept/theme/genre. It could look trying hard let's be honest LOL Others can also try doing a 'sexier' concepts, but Taemin has like a different level of sensuality it's so hard to explain. And when others cover his choreo, I'm always like 'Taemin really moves differently'. he adds a flair on his movements
I was SO shocked when I first saw the mv, one of the most moving, evocative things I've seen in a WHILE. The storytelling is insane, I've been obsessed with all the theories.
Taemin is SM's ACE for a reason. His performances, vocals, everything are always at the highest level
KING BACK
The silence, lol. Taemin is just something so different. I love this man!
You said everything there needs to be said about Taemin. He is THE ARTIST of a lot of people’s lives, including mine. He’s not only inspirational to K-pop idols but to regular people. Every time he releases new music there’s so many layers to his art. I love this man.
This is the perfect reaction to the genius of Taemin! Your expressions were priceless. They remind me so much of my own response when I first watched the mv. I sat open mouthed in absolute awe.
The whole album is amazing. He is without doubt the greatest Male Solo kpop artist in kpop history IMHO. Perfect reactions! ❤❤❤
This is the most artistic music video I've seen from a kpop artist. Gives me chills every time
I named him the best soloist in kpop ever since I listened to Advice and Idea, and my man just keeps on getting better like bruh don't overslay the entire industry now
As long as I been here, I don’t think I’ve ever seen you guys this silent 😭💚 it’s the Taemin effect . Even during the science rewatch lol
Omg the shock on their face is crazyyyy
I am so happy for everything that you both said about Taemin. Sometimes I feel sad that SHINee and their members are not known more worldwide as they should since they are so amazingly talented and I want more people to appreciate them. Thank you for your reaction ❤
yes! They should be as big as BTS. they amazing.
This is it. Periodt. He is the undefeated Idol's Idol; the Lee Taemin. SHINee and Taemin always prove us one thing "when talent and hard work come together, the outcome is always a masterpiece." Yes talent matters the most. This is a Masterpiece. Honestly I am always proud of being a Shawol. I am lucky to know SHINee music also I am truely blessed to experience the artistry of Onew, Jonghyun, Key, Minho and Taemin.
Always 5HINee!!
💎💎💎💎💎
The sheer amount of emotions this song brought out of me while listening/watching the MV. My body was tensing at every high and every low, the push and pull, the drama, the explosive satisfying release. Goddamn Taemin, this might honestly be a contender for #2 all time fav kpop song after RV Psycho
th-cam.com/video/TM1l-_-jLUg/w-d-xo.html best live stage ive ever seen for this song. Man came out of it like he finished directing a damn Symmphony!
amazing taste
Taemin was the artist that got me to finally give kpop a chance and then he immediately left so this comeback has been a lot for me and oh my gosh... the stunned silence is so real. every time i watch the video i feel like i cant breathe until it's over. he is such an incredible artist and performer
Same! I got into Kpop because a blessed TH-cam algorithm showed me Taemin’s Advice. Like, two months after he left. He’s my ult of ult/higher power by this point and I have been BLESSED by this comeback!
Breathless, awe, silence, speechless, yep, for a reason. GUILTY means a lot to Taemin, but specific messages have been lost in translation. I made an explainer video to rectify that, and to justify the artist of artists.
No one could be like TAEMIN
TAEMIN is the different level forever. His vocal is so insane
THE KING of kings
hehe their mouth was open the whole time !!🤣🤣 hope you'll see his killing voice too ! love y'all🥰
i literally had to lay down and just stare at the wall after watching it for the first time I WAS NOT READY
its the way i feel like i need to have a masters degree in high art to even THINK about this video. i dont deserve it, i am not worthy.
He’s INSANEEEEEE
I know a lot of ARMY would disagree (I’m an ARMY) but I just think that BTS themselves would say the exact same thing about Taemin being the king/trendsetter lmao. It’s just a fact 🤷🏻♀️ someone below said it right: bias aside, it will always be Taemin
This music video and the song was jaw dropping and I’m stoked he got a win for the song
@@emrykin7127 I hope army stop bothering taemin…pls…
Él es el rey del mundo osea aún no proceso ESTA OBRA DE ARTE, nadie más lo hace como Taemin, sin duda es un ser único está fuera de este mundo🫶🏻
Half the industry looks up and became an idol because him or him and his group 😂😂😂
I agree totally with you, he is alone in the top. But in the music programs, other very normal songs and performances are winning :(
"He and Shinee put the bar where it is today". Amen. The talent in Shinee blows my mind... Onew, Taemin, Key, Minho... and Jonghyun of course... 15 year performance veterans. Just go back and watch their debut "Replay" when they were babies.. They hit the road running.
Taemin's Danger set his direction, his work on "Move" with the Japanese dancer Koharu Sugawara really levelled up his dance... he has worked so hard on his voice. I've been waiting for his return and I love Guilty. The Rizzness is also great..
The recent KBS live performance where they did Move and The Rizzness with La Chica dancers Rian and Gabee was awesome.. Check it out!
You girls have made my day! And yes, to everything you've said and more. Taemin is a once-in-a-lifetime artist. I've said it before, and I'll not tire of saying it again. Thank you for your Taemin appreciation 💖
The idol of idols. Period!
Taemin stays true to himself as an artist and performer. I have the utmost respect for him and how he is authentically himself in his music and delivery. I agree with you both that the direction of kpop has shifted towards more western sounds which takes away of why we listen to kpop in the first place. I'm so glad he's back and I can't wait to witness the continuation of his artistry.
0:29 it’s them both nodding their heads when taemin ask if you wanna take a bite of the apple l😅
SM has the best last chorus in kpop history in my opinion, the climax will be so intense you will feel dazed for a moment😂
I mean, from the first to the last second it's a masterpiece, but I think the last chorus is the climax
So relatively true- bias aside it will always SHINEE. they paved the way for KPOP. where the time inter fans can only see them through youtube. and for TAEMIN consistently serves quality artistic music since day 1- even 5th gen will witness. His B-side tracks were gold too!! KING👑
This is a fucking masterpiece. I love the whole album, but especially "Blue". It's GORGEOUS.
If you haven't watched his "Suchwita" episode yet, I highly recommend it. Yoogi basically spends the whole episode telling Taemin how great he is and how many idols look up to him. And there's another special guest! 😉🐣
I love the part where he tells Jimin that he wants Taemin n Taemin just there listening been shy.. suga b like we meet few more times we b closer than ur friendship with him Jimin 😂😂 n the bombastic side eyes Jimin keeps giving 😂😂😂
This and Advice were contenders for Taemin's title track before leaving for the military, SM and Taemin decided it was too early and I agree. Can yall imagine if Guilty released in 2021 and they just LEFT US LIKE THIS FOR 2 YEARS??? We would NOT have been ready for it in 2021, literally everything lined up for this comeback and it was executed perfectly
두 분의 표정 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
귀여워 ㅋㅋㅋ
I like the silence .... 😆
This reaction is everything, thank you ladies for your words and relatableness
This MV, song and concept.... TAEMIN is the representative, he is the art, he is the moment, HE NEEDS TO BE WORLDWIDE FAMOUS!!!!!!!!!
The idol of idols for a reason. Thats lee taemin from SHINee
"perfection". That's it
Undefeated and alone at the top. Exactly.
Taemin you are the one who got me to K -pop , you are genius.
Michael Jackson Fan speaking 🔊 This man is a KING . He's an INCREDIBLE TALENTED ARTIST and Michael would be so Proud!! Respect 🙇🏼♀️
The silent frozen faces in this reaction 😅 taemin is just art.
I have to be honest, this song gives me goosebumps literally from the start of the MV
im here after taemin left sm SO YES SM YOU ARE NOTHING NOW
You were like 😲 the whole time 😂. Yes, I agree, Taemin is extraordinary ❤
i love him like you do wow taemin and i agree with you
when i saw criminal i felt so many things i felt i was drawn to him i felt oh my is this taemin i now know wy so many k pop artists have taemin on the topm of the lists they make for k po idols they love
I keep coming back to this video just to watch you both in awe. It makes the last 15+ (and coming) years of supporting Taemin all the more worth it. 💖
Y’all being absolutely speechless is so relatable
It's so true what you are saying about Taemin as a solo artist and SHINee! I've been saying that for years but still, they don't get the recognition they deserve. ESPECIALLY, Taemin! SHINee men 17+ years consistent in the industry, Taemin 10+ years as a solo artist and they're STILL on 🔥🔥🔥!
Speechless..from start till end of the song.. that's the reality of Taemin Guilty..he want to start again the Move era
Taemin is everything!!
The way half of the population doesn't know about this song still amazes me, how come people didn't make this chart? This song deserves so muchh moreee. It's an actual masterpiece.
Taemin is a goat!!! His dancing is undeniably superior and his vocals are amazing!!!! I knew the after military Taemin was going to be a force to be reckoned with but this comeback exceeds my expectations!!! 😳😍❤️
yes UNDEFEATED !!! kpop representative surely..and SHINee is the bar, nobody compares, agreed
people and taemin said this body blame Minho ..he trained Taemin like in military
The jesus of kpop
The stunned silence is so real 😭
I have been WAITING for this reaction our leader saved the industry
My mouth is open. He is in kpop industry years and years but they always surprise me. They are still amazing. He deserve all awards. He is the best of the best.
POR TAEMIN conoci el KPOP. Pero el es otro nivel. Es la Supremacía de la industria. Mas que un idolo es un gran ARTISTA .❤
Taemin is real artist!!
Taemin is 🔥🔥🔥 UNRIVALED. There is NO ONE like Taemin.
Completamente same hermanas, SAMEEEE
I'm not even shook that you guys wee quiet the whole time at 1st. I was the same😭😭😭
GRACIAS POR ser la voz de muchas personas que pensamos lo mismo de TAEMIN. EL ES LA SUPREMACIA DE LA INDUSTRIA .Llore cuando lo vi por primera vez ,. sentía un nudo en mi corazon TAEMIN logro atravez de su maravilloso arte transmitir lo que queria en cada parte del video. Pocas personas en el mundo pueden hacer eso. Y TAEMIN es uno de ellos. ,por no decir el unico .BIENVENIDO REY. 👏👏❤️
Masterpiece. And the album…chef’s kiss! 👌🏼😘 This is perfection.
That song is so well done ❤ I m in love ❤❤❤Taemin knows how to make me happy 😁
No one is touching Taemin. He's the king, the emperor.
A si quedamos todas o . Con este regreso del REY .Demostrando porque es el ídolo de los ídolos .SUPREMACIA ARTE en toda la extensión de la palabra..GRACIAS por regresar extrañaba muchisimo tu ARTE ❤❤
"You don't know what you've got 'til it's gone. And then it comes back. 'Oh, i've been missing you.'"
Beautiful. :')
HE IS CALLED THE KING OF KPOP FOR A REASON. REAC TO HIS ALBUM
BEST Non-Reaction -> Reaction -> Appreciation Ever! 😅 👏👏👏
100% agree. Taemin is my Ult of ults and he is ART!
Differently alike I love your reaction so much I was just like you when I saw this MV I'm speechless until now it's a lot of art a lot of beauty Taemin is pure art I love him so much I was missing him so much this comebcack is perfect the album It's perfect, please react to Rizzness on his new album, you're going to love this song, it's very good
I don't know if its better than move,but this song made me feel emotions I have never ever felt from a song ever.This was a pure cinematic experience.Guilty was phenomenal.
Heard someone point out that they felt/saw/heard Move and Criminal within this mv. I went back and watched Guilty again and I could see Move movements here, not the exact movements but the feel, the patience before performing the move. Not sure if this make sense. lol
yeah you're right, how he could get me into that video as if I was in it and feeling it is crazy bro
i really love what u said about taemin, cuz that's the truth i've been waiting for someone to say out loud, and i wanna say that, it's the same for SHINEE,but, unfortunately, few people know that, so plz react to more of SHINEE, especially old songs, cuz they deserve to make everyone know who was the one who created everything what k pop groups nowadays enjoy , and tey r sill setting the bar soooooo high despite of all what they have been trough , and thank uuuuu
this reaction video was everything i need taemin to watch this fr
NOT A SINGLE WORD WHILE RESCTION TIME 😭😭😭😭
I felt the same way when i watched it, I just had to sit there with it before i could even rewatch it, he's such an artist and he puts so much into what he does. I love that you can take different things from watching it each time.
Small note, his body is not from the military, he actually had very bad mental health during that time, and had to be moved to civil service, he actually gained weight during that time. His body is all his own work after leaving the military.
with Minho as a personal trainer 😊
the silence is too loud😂
He’s the best
King of kpop
This is literally his best comeback.
1st listen, same. On the 2nd listen though? Goosebumps all overy my body!!! I felt all of that whatever everything he wanted me to feel!! Wtf
Omg same. I was about to risk it all for this man. I just discovered this song yesterday and it’s been on repeat all day.
Kpop would be nothing without Taemin. NOTHING.
He is my baby boy ultimate from the begining I feel like his Kpop mom is is a amazing performer artist he is the one and only thete is no Othet Taemin Iam so proud beyond the universe 👑🔥☄🎆
Same here haha 😭
Best reaction video. You two never disappoint.
I love your reaction! Taemin is on another level (all of Shinee actually). The sad part though about the korean music industry, is that their awards are a popularity contest where all the elementary school kids do the voting, or people that are only fixated with one group and never care to listen or be objective to anything else, almost like they are in a cult.
Guess you didn't watch the reaction@@idk-yo8ik
Damn then why are you arguing with them?
The King 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉