I need to see Incendies. I think Sicario might have been my first Villeneuve film. Then Arrival. After that I just *had* to see his works and I just LOVE his craftmanship. I've also kept in stride with Nolan's releases and am a huge fan too 😊
It was Nolan's decade, the next decade will be Villeneuve's. They are a separate generation of filmmaker. Christopher passed the big blockbuster Hollywood acid test back with batman begins, ever since then he's made massive movies in scale and funding. dune is Villeneuve moving into big movies. They're separated by about a decade. Also tenet is really boring and nearly unwatchable.
Such a rarity listening to somebody from Hollywood have so much respect for source material. “We’re not here to express ourselves, we’re here to bring Herbert to the screen” “we referred back to the bible”. Respect Denis 🫡.
The film I felt that respected the sources material and gave the film a sense of TLC was Peter Jackson's LOTR trilogy. It's so refreshing to read a comment that understands that there are only a few movie directors that actually care about the artistic side of cinema rather than the business side.
Nolan calling Blade Runner 2049 "an incredible piece of work" is no small thing. he absolutely adores the original & told Denis he was nervous when he heard they were doing the sequel in a previous interview. a great conversation to listen in on thanks for posting.
@@tannernelson1510 Denis referenced what Nolan told him on the happy sad confused pod episode he was the guest on during Dune promo. he says Nolan warned him before filming that he was "walking on sacred territory". im sure i've heard Nolan talk about BR2049 elsewhere but im not sure where.
I had never heard of Dune prior to seeing the movie. Now, I find myself diving into 4 hour long Dune lore videos. He was absolutely correct when mentioning the fact that he had hoped this movie brings in new fans
My brain is melting!! All these last days I couldn't stop wondering who is my favorite director between these 2 and little did I know TH-cam algorithm probed my brain and shows me this where they are praising each other. I just can't! 🤯🤯🤯
"I told... the whole crew we're not there to express ourselves but to bring... the words of Herbert to the screen." Welp, that explains why the movie was so good.
@@valentin7693 I'ma have to disagree with you there. I believe Peter Jackson was trying to some extent, but there is a 0% chance he thought dwarf tossing jokes were part of Tolkien's vision. And then there's taking out all of the poetry, taking out the scouring of the shire, Faramir being corrupted by the ring, Aragorn being caught flat-footed in the wild by a girl.... I mean, it's fine if you like those movies, but Tolkien's vision they are not. I should say I don't think Denis Villeneuve did a flawless job either. The scene where Paul is incapacitated by a vision while rescuing the crew of the spice harvester was a big mistake, because it makes Paul look like an unreliable flake. I'm just happy to see a book adaptation with only one mistake like that :|
@@valentin7693 What would it take for you to call it a major change? Gandalf is clean shaven? Gandalf tells Frodo to kill Gollum if he gets the chance? Frodo doesn't falter at the end? Sauron wins? Tolkien without poetry is like Quentin Tarantino without over-the-top violence, or Conan the Barbarian without people being absurdly underdressed. You are entirely welcome to think any of those is an improvement, but they are not minor changes.
Wow, it's so refreshing to hear someone say they wanted to "bring the authors words to the screen", rather than "update it for the modern audience". Explains why Dune is a masterpiece surrounded by a sea of garbage adaptations, a rare gem polished by an inspired, respectful craftsman that truly stands out from the unwatchable profanations and self-parodies excreted by shallow, narcissistic sociopaths.
The last 15-20 minutes make it a bit less of a masterpiece, easy on the big words. And I loved the movie mind you. This works better as an epic HBO series.
I like Denise's line about you're only as good as your last film and him talking about how blade runner wasn't a financial success so the studio was hesitant to green light him filming two dune films back to back. I think it gives a good insight into the business side of making movies. To me, blade runner 2049 was amazing and profit or not, if i was a studio exec, i would've been clamoring to get denise to make dune
I think blade runner is one of the most visually magnificent movie that I have ever seen. I unfortunately didn't see it in movies but it was a huge mistake. That movie was made for theater.
I loved that film. I love all of his films. I always feel confident that a movie directed by Denis is going to be a reliably good watch. He clearly loves is art, and that isn't always appreciated by the masses fed on a diet of mediocrity.
Interesting to hear how he’s loved dune so long and the aliens from arrival now make more sense as something similar to the space navigators! Can’t wait to see them in Dune and his interpretation!
I'm literally waiting for the part 2 like it was The Messiah, all of us are here i guess, i follow Mr Villeneuve work since i've discovered Incendies in 2014,i caught Enemy and Blade runner on theater(virus held me from Dune..), i watched all of his long featured films; his versatility,sensitivity&awareness makes him one of the finest cinema artist of today.
I first discovered him with Enemy, then went to watch Incendies and Polytechnique. Incendies really showed his narrative and editing capabilities, while Polytechnique really showcase his camera movement and placing. When I watch Blade Runner 2049, the movement and pacing really reminded me of Polytechnique.
I’m so happy Dennis Gave Oscar Isaac the reprise he deserves from being in Star Wars. This franchise is as impressive as the 77 Star Wars and I’m glad these guys got a shot. This movie worked for all audiences without pandering or any bullshit. It was awesome.
Oscar Isaac had a big hit in Moon Knight. It has a level of maturity and dealt with mental illness in a way that got me interested in it, when I usually don't gaf about comic book stuff. I'm the kind of pretentious a**hole who only likes the Dark Knight Trilogy. I can't stand the MCU. I really admired Dune because it took itself seriously. It honoured the source material and combined blockbuster with arthouse better than anything I've seen since LOTR. Frank Herbert was tripping balls as hard as JRR Tolkien when it came to deadly serious thematic worldbuilding and the f*cked up sh*t they dreamed up.
Christopher Nolan's DUNE: Nolan shoots the desert scenes in Nambia and builds life-size animatronic sandworms for proper line-of-sight reactions from the actors...
I’m absolutely angry at myself that I didn’t watch dune on the theater. Watching it at home literally killed the magical experience. Netflix will never replace the cinema experience. Great movies are suppose to be watched on the theater.
When I watched both version of Dune, all that I could think about, part from what I was seeing, was the book or books. Every scene I referenced back to the books and how closely the two visions were. I never thought about any other sci-fi movie I had seen, not once.
I love Dune Part 1 but it does make me mad when people talk about Dune and its history on screen that the sci-fi channel version is never mentioned. I think its way better the the Linch version but it seems at least to me that it doesn't get the respect it truly deserves.
The movie wasn't long enough. Should've been 1 hr longer there were many scenes in the book that weren't included that would've added so much to the movie, and I seriously can't imagine how they're going to condense last "half" of the book. He absolutely needs to make an extended version like Peter Jackson did for LOTR.
The movie is just a visual treat. Nothing more. The litmus test of the movie should've been the scene when Paul experiences his "historical vision" (or whatever the name is) for the first time, sees infinite possibilities, ways, dead ends, the possible future. A great scene, very abstract, any real artist would kill to try himself at it. And what Denis did is just the black girl with bloodied hands. Test failed.
@@hulking_presence Actually, many artists didn't want to try it, since Dune has such a rich history of failures in cinema. Denis's goal was to make a movie that would be faithful to the book, but also appeal to the masses. The test was a success
@@Darklife66by "appealing to the masses" people always mean well, but only end up tarnishing the product and making it a bit too easy to understand. What Denis did was cut Dune's legs off. A d I love the film. I just wish there was more of it. Almost as though it shouldve been a TV show. And if WB is smart(😂) they'll make a 6-10 episode unrated HBO cut and call it "Frank Herbert's Dune"
Unfortunately the studio forced him to cut scenes because we live in a time where people have attention spans of a gnat. I'd sell an organ for the 5 hour version
@@hulking_presence Seems you're misremembering. This scene happens when he's in the tent with his mother and he sees many of the exact things you're mentioning. Maybe try to pay attention next time.
I wonder if Scarsgard had that stance on Prosthetics over CG because of the Davy Jones role. Thats still one of the best pieces of character CGI to date, But he might have had a rough experience portraying it.
YES!!!! Or Nolan and James Cameron! I'm writing a YA novel trilogy that is a post apocalyptic dystopian sci-fi epic (an earth plagued by toxic air/humans having to live in fortified cities and space colonies) that I would hope would be adapted into a film series with one of these two as the director/producer of the trilogy!
At one point here Nolan describes Dune as "such a long book", and that's quite a common belief about the novel, but it really isn't that long. It's around 500 pages, depending on typesetting.
I found it rather short. Same with Children and God Emperor. They might feel a little slow sometimes but not really long. 500ish pages feel about the sweet spot
It's a short but dense book, plenty of complex scenes with lots of stuff happening inside the character's heads. The most impressive thing about Denis's version is that we don't hear the character's thoughts, half of the book is inner monologue, but the film manages to show all the political stuff by showing it instead of saying it.
@@dirkdiggler.You're right in a way but i think it could still be possible to see them on a common project. They seems to share the same vision on a lot of point. Maybe in something like a choral movie or an anthology could be something possible.
Well idk i get the impression a lot of ppl hate Dune, from book purists, to boomers whining about wokeism, to general audiences who get confused, to more boomers who love the Lynch movies. It just isn’t a film that speaks to the general public, thats what John Wick is for, i doubt part 2 will do well unfortunately. People complain about Hollywood being shit but its more the audiences that refuse to see the good stuff that gets made and only flock to the dull crap that makes box office rankings, and then they whine afterwards about how ‘nothing good gets made anymore’
It’s not a “podcast” it’s a on stage with audience audio hearing of the event but we can’t have the video at all due to copyright I think. Something along those lines. This is still a FANTASTIC video to hear and see in clips regardless so people should at least be grateful for that as we can hear this fantastic interview!
Two of my favorite directors in Hollywood right now. They could probably remake that GARBAGE Battlefield Earth, and make it watchable. That’s saying something!
After Paul meets Chani the next part starts 2 years later. This was done for the Method acting 2021-23. Also real Sandworms were used. That's why the actors performances were so realistic. The sandworms are actually vegan in real life but sacrificed to eat real humans just to work with Villaneuve and Chalamet.
I find strage a french canadian doesn't speak english so well. anyway these two people are the best directors out there at the moment they are two masters really. and they're not american.
In Quebec it's almost entirely french except in Montreal where there is some english, and onsidering it's his second language, he's almost perfectly bilingual, I'm from the same province and I wish my french was as good as his english. Dude is amazing all the same.
@@watdood6905 speaking with a good pronounce is part of speaking well and he seems to struggle sometimes to find the right words so I think my impression isn't wrong. Anyway I said "he doesn't speak english so well" which I think it's not an insult and that I found it strange since Canada is predominantly populated by english speaking people amd that's not an insult either.
@@littlemouse7066 and having an accent isn't having poor pronunciation + even if Canada mostly speaking english, you said it yourself, he's french canadian
The battle scenes were generic and underwhelming. He read the books in French which diluted their meaning. His vision of the Fremen is the opposite of what the authors was.
Сразу видно по посадке кто из них альфа, а кто омежка Даже обратите внимание как мямлит француз и как по-хозяйски, можно сказать открывая дверь в диалог ногой, говорит англичанин
The movie Dune is not good. It is sooo superficial. That movie doesn't have real depth to it. Denis Villeneuve did not attempt to go deep with the themes of the story. He was maybe too scared to mess up the story or did not know how to do it. But to say, as he said it in the interview, that he treated the book as "the holy bible" is not true. He left out soo much of interesting story plots and dialogues. Denis Villeneuve also spent the second half of the movie with a ridiculously amount of time for action sequences. Time he could have used to give the story a firm foundation. The argument of saying "The book is not possible to make a movie out of it" is not valid to me. I read the book and it certainly is easy to make a movie out of its story. Look at Pter Jackson LoTR adaptation, it is perfect!! And LoTR is as vast in its world building as Dune.
You can certainly criticize the movie for some of the adaptation and creative choices, but claiming that it was „easy to make a movie out of its story“ sounds pretty arrogant, especially when only justified with „I read the book“. And then you follow that up with LotR as an example, as if the LotR movies were any closer to the source material. I don‘t think that‘s a fair assessment of the film
@@tlsgrz6194 OPs post ,and reply to you, demonstrate a lack of supporting examples and is ironically a “superficial” critique of the film. Simply stating it should’ve been better is a weak criticism. I do agree with your assessment of his assessment lmao Dude really said he didn’t wanna even have a discussion lol wow
It’s fascinating hearing two of my favourite directors interacting with each other. I could listen to 100s of hours of this and not get bored.
100%. Two absolute visionaries with mutual admiration for the other’s craft. I hope they do this again.
💯😊
(My 2 favorite Directors/IMAX Directors)
Nolan could learn a thing or two regarding mixing the sound tho. As a audio hobbyist Nolans movies are the worst.
LMaooo nieece b8 mai8@@IngoGarza
The 2010's was the decade of Nolan and Villeneuve.
2010 - Incendies
2010 - Inception
2012 - The Dark Knight Rises
2013 - Prisoners
2013 - Enemy
2014 - Interstellar
2015 - Sicario
2016 - Arrival
2017 - Blade Runner 2049
2017 - Dunkirk
2020 - Tenet
I need to see Incendies. I think Sicario might have been my first Villeneuve film. Then Arrival. After that I just *had* to see his works and I just LOVE his craftmanship. I've also kept in stride with Nolan's releases and am a huge fan too 😊
They're a beacon of light in the age of superhero blockbusters, most of them are super forgettable.
@@glorioustrump245
I'd be glad to learn about some superior movies, can you recommend me a few ?
It was Nolan's decade, the next decade will be Villeneuve's. They are a separate generation of filmmaker. Christopher passed the big blockbuster Hollywood acid test back with batman begins, ever since then he's made massive movies in scale and funding. dune is Villeneuve moving into big movies. They're separated by about a decade. Also tenet is really boring and nearly unwatchable.
@@tysonngubeni8545 Incendies is his best film. Absolute Masterpiece
Such a rarity listening to somebody from Hollywood have so much respect for source material. “We’re not here to express ourselves, we’re here to bring Herbert to the screen” “we referred back to the bible”. Respect Denis 🫡.
The film I felt that respected the sources material and gave the film a sense of TLC was Peter Jackson's LOTR trilogy. It's so refreshing to read a comment that understands that there are only a few movie directors that actually care about the artistic side of cinema rather than the business side.
Nolan calling Blade Runner 2049 "an incredible piece of work" is no small thing. he absolutely adores the original & told Denis he was nervous when he heard they were doing the sequel in a previous interview.
a great conversation to listen in on thanks for posting.
is that previous interview on youtube?
@@tannernelson1510 Denis referenced what Nolan told him on the happy sad confused pod episode he was the guest on during Dune promo. he says Nolan warned him before filming that he was "walking on sacred territory". im sure i've heard Nolan talk about BR2049 elsewhere but im not sure where.
@@flangeslammer thanks
If you get to feel admiration and praise from someone like Christopher Nolan, you know you have done something special
tbf both are genius
Denis Villeneuve discussing Hans Zimmer with Christopher Nolan... Perfection
Magnificent discussion. Dune is utterly sublime. Denis and Christopher .... Masters Par Excellence.
I had never heard of Dune prior to seeing the movie. Now, I find myself diving into 4 hour long Dune lore videos. He was absolutely correct when mentioning the fact that he had hoped this movie brings in new fans
Just read the godamn books man.
@@pwotectmaballz what's read?
@@pwotectmaballzwhy read when a rando on TH-cam can waffle their interpretation instead?
Watched the movie 4 times...and since then have read the first dune book. Starting the second shortly...so yes Villeneuve has brought in a new fan
My brain is melting!!
All these last days I couldn't stop wondering who is my favorite director between these 2 and little did I know TH-cam algorithm probed my brain and shows me this where they are praising each other.
I just can't!
🤯🤯🤯
"I told... the whole crew we're not there to express ourselves but to bring... the words of Herbert to the screen." Welp, that explains why the movie was so good.
That's how you make an adaptation. Too many movie and show producers are using adaptations as an insert for their own inferior ideas.
Sort of like what Peter Jackson said with The Lord of the Rings ings
@@valentin7693 I'ma have to disagree with you there. I believe Peter Jackson was trying to some extent, but there is a 0% chance he thought dwarf tossing jokes were part of Tolkien's vision. And then there's taking out all of the poetry, taking out the scouring of the shire, Faramir being corrupted by the ring, Aragorn being caught flat-footed in the wild by a girl.... I mean, it's fine if you like those movies, but Tolkien's vision they are not.
I should say I don't think Denis Villeneuve did a flawless job either. The scene where Paul is incapacitated by a vision while rescuing the crew of the spice harvester was a big mistake, because it makes Paul look like an unreliable flake. I'm just happy to see a book adaptation with only one mistake like that :|
@@kjgoebel7098 dude, those are pretty minor changes
@@valentin7693 What would it take for you to call it a major change? Gandalf is clean shaven? Gandalf tells Frodo to kill Gollum if he gets the chance? Frodo doesn't falter at the end? Sauron wins?
Tolkien without poetry is like Quentin Tarantino without over-the-top violence, or Conan the Barbarian without people being absurdly underdressed. You are entirely welcome to think any of those is an improvement, but they are not minor changes.
Wow, it's so refreshing to hear someone say they wanted to "bring the authors words to the screen", rather than "update it for the modern audience". Explains why Dune is a masterpiece surrounded by a sea of garbage adaptations, a rare gem polished by an inspired, respectful craftsman that truly stands out from the unwatchable profanations and self-parodies excreted by shallow, narcissistic sociopaths.
two legends talks about a masterpiece movie
The last 15-20 minutes make it a bit less of a masterpiece, easy on the big words. And I loved the movie mind you. This works better as an epic HBO series.
would love for them to direct and/or produce a film together! Something like an epic combination of "Dune" meets "Inception".
@@coreypack We got something like that. It's called Arrival. What you're thinking off, would be more, like if we saw what the alien planet looks like.
Nolan cast Timothee in Interstellar as Coopers son (young) small part but crazy just a few years later he's working with Denis in the leading roll.
I can listen to these gentleman talk about films all day.
Dune was the best movie I've seen since Interstellar. Thanks for sharing this.
I like Denise's line about you're only as good as your last film and him talking about how blade runner wasn't a financial success so the studio was hesitant to green light him filming two dune films back to back. I think it gives a good insight into the business side of making movies. To me, blade runner 2049 was amazing and profit or not, if i was a studio exec, i would've been clamoring to get denise to make dune
I think blade runner is one of the most visually magnificent movie that I have ever seen. I unfortunately didn't see it in movies but it was a huge mistake. That movie was made for theater.
@@elPufferino it was fantastic in the theaters. My only regret about the film is that I didn't see it again in theaters
"Denise" lol
I loved that film. I love all of his films. I always feel confident that a movie directed by Denis is going to be a reliably good watch. He clearly loves is art, and that isn't always appreciated by the masses fed on a diet of mediocrity.
Interesting to hear how he’s loved dune so long and the aliens from arrival now make more sense as something similar to the space navigators! Can’t wait to see them in Dune and his interpretation!
Please tell me which part was it?
@@minhanhoan6870 1
Nice to see peers to peer conversation for once, rather than the usual mentor-student dynamic...
Great discussion!
DUNE is a masterpiece!
I still love Lynch's version, but this latest movie elevated filmmaking just like Peter Jackson did with LOTR
I'm literally waiting for the part 2 like it was The Messiah, all of us are here i guess, i follow Mr Villeneuve work since i've discovered Incendies in 2014,i caught Enemy and Blade runner on theater(virus held me from Dune..), i watched all of his long featured films; his versatility,sensitivity&awareness makes him one of the finest cinema artist of today.
I first discovered him with Enemy, then went to watch Incendies and Polytechnique. Incendies really showed his narrative and editing capabilities, while Polytechnique really showcase his camera movement and placing. When I watch Blade Runner 2049, the movement and pacing really reminded me of Polytechnique.
When Timmy C-boy screams "THE SLEEPER HAS AWAKEN!" He won't be a boy anymore - he'll be a man. #LongLiveTheFighter
Oh boy oh boy, wait until you hear what the second book is called....
@@sdrawk3611 thank you i wantedto say something similar 😂👍👍
Have you seen prisoners or arrival? Both fantastic movies. I still need to see enemy and sicario
"The god of cinema was with us " denis vileneuve
My two favorite directors joined together what a dream!!
I’m so happy Dennis Gave Oscar Isaac the reprise he deserves from being in Star Wars. This franchise is as impressive as the 77 Star Wars and I’m glad these guys got a shot. This movie worked for all audiences without pandering or any bullshit. It was awesome.
Oscar Isaac had a big hit in Moon Knight. It has a level of maturity and dealt with mental illness in a way that got me interested in it, when I usually don't gaf about comic book stuff. I'm the kind of pretentious a**hole who only likes the Dark Knight Trilogy. I can't stand the MCU.
I really admired Dune because it took itself seriously. It honoured the source material and combined blockbuster with arthouse better than anything I've seen since LOTR.
Frank Herbert was tripping balls as hard as JRR Tolkien when it came to deadly serious thematic worldbuilding and the f*cked up sh*t they dreamed up.
The sequel trilogy made me realize that I'm just too old for Star Wars.
Dune made me realize that I'm just too old for Disney's bullshit.
@@adam145 Andor must have made you feel real stupid now huh?
@@adam145 Andor might change your mind.
@@adam14530:31 30:31 30:31
Christopher Nolan's DUNE: Nolan shoots the desert scenes in Nambia and builds life-size animatronic sandworms for proper line-of-sight reactions from the actors...
and for some reason hes filming on a helicopter
Two of the most important people in my enjoyment of cinema conversing. I love this.
Great benhind-the-scenes questions from Nolan
THESE TWO!?
This is like a wet dream to me! How does this not have a gazillion views? How did I just now discover this?
This conversation is also a gift! Two giants discussing a masterpiece of the other like bros. I wish I could see more of things like this!
I’m absolutely angry at myself that I didn’t watch dune on the theater. Watching it at home literally killed the magical experience. Netflix will never replace the cinema experience. Great movies are suppose to be watched on the theater.
Lol this was literally the first thing I thought on watching it at home. We know where we will be watching this christmas!
When Villeneuve said in making the movie the book was he Bible, he of course meant the Orange Catholic Bible.
Two of my absolute favourite story tellers...👍🤗🙏😂
2 best Directors rn IMO
yessss
I’d put Robert Eggers over Nolan personally
One of the greatest films ever made.
Two chads supporting each other for 30 minutes
2 of my all time favourite directors mwah
Best 2 directors working right now. They can't miss
really cool to see an interview with one of the greatest directors of today, and Christopher Nolan.
Does Nolan transcend the credit of a director?
This is basically George Washington and Abe Lincoln having a conversation. I mean if there were a Mt. Rushmore of movie directors…
My 2 favorite directors
My third would be Tarantino
@@mikehawkertz9237 Same for both but my 3rd is Martin Scorsese
Two master just having a talk …wow (the audio could’ve had more treble, lows are too much)
Not seeing Dune in a theater is sacrilege.
When I watched both version of Dune, all that I could think about, part from what I was seeing, was the book or books. Every scene I referenced back to the books and how closely the two visions were. I never thought about any other sci-fi movie I had seen, not once.
Kynes was a dude in the book.
@@DeltaAssaultGaming Yes he was but I forgave a little wokeness, this time.
I love Dune Part 1 but it does make me mad when people talk about Dune and its history on screen that the sci-fi channel version is never mentioned. I think its way better the the Linch version but it seems at least to me that it doesn't get the respect it truly deserves.
The movie wasn't long enough. Should've been 1 hr longer there were many scenes in the book that weren't included that would've added so much to the movie, and I seriously can't imagine how they're going to condense last "half" of the book. He absolutely needs to make an extended version like Peter Jackson did for LOTR.
The movie is just a visual treat. Nothing more.
The litmus test of the movie should've been the scene when Paul experiences his "historical vision" (or whatever the name is) for the first time, sees infinite possibilities, ways, dead ends, the possible future. A great scene, very abstract, any real artist would kill to try himself at it. And what Denis did is just the black girl with bloodied hands. Test failed.
@@hulking_presence Actually, many artists didn't want to try it, since Dune has such a rich history of failures in cinema. Denis's goal was to make a movie that would be faithful to the book, but also appeal to the masses. The test was a success
@@Darklife66by "appealing to the masses" people always mean well, but only end up tarnishing the product and making it a bit too easy to understand. What Denis did was cut Dune's legs off. A d I love the film. I just wish there was more of it. Almost as though it shouldve been a TV show. And if WB is smart(😂) they'll make a 6-10 episode unrated HBO cut and call it "Frank Herbert's Dune"
Unfortunately the studio forced him to cut scenes because we live in a time where people have attention spans of a gnat. I'd sell an organ for the 5 hour version
@@hulking_presence Seems you're misremembering. This scene happens when he's in the tent with his mother and he sees many of the exact things you're mentioning. Maybe try to pay attention next time.
I believe Hans turned down Tenet because he was already engaged with Dune.
Two 🐐 in one frame
The Mount Olympus of today's filmmakers right here: Nolan, Villeneuve, Cameron!
Thanks for the tips!! I’m gonna be there in a couple of weeks 🤩
2 modern greats.
I've discovered all I really want to listen to are discussions between my favorite artists. Podcasts really fall short when compared to this.
The f*cking movie is a work of art...as so is the book. Hopefully mote to come.
I wonder if Scarsgard had that stance on Prosthetics over CG because of the Davy Jones role. Thats still one of the best pieces of character CGI to date, But he might have had a rough experience portraying it.
Skaarsgard played Bootstrap Bill.... Bill Nighy was the actor who played Davy Jones.
would love to hear these guys talk about other random movies that they didn't direct
both Christopher Nolan and Denis Villeneuve should collaborate on a movie together
Yes, Christopher Nolan, with original story or screenplay adaption and Denis directing. I'm here for it!
I think they have very different styles, so I'm not sure how great it would turn out.
I love them both, tho
Edit: spelling
YES!!!! Or Nolan and James Cameron! I'm writing a YA novel trilogy that is a post apocalyptic dystopian sci-fi epic (an earth plagued by toxic air/humans having to live in fortified cities and space colonies) that I would hope would be adapted into a film series with one of these two as the director/producer of the trilogy!
At one point here Nolan describes Dune as "such a long book", and that's quite a common belief about the novel, but it really isn't that long. It's around 500 pages, depending on typesetting.
IT is a long book
That's... pretty long, is it not?
@@NavidIsANoobIt's quite normal. Not uncommon for fantasy/SF works to be 1000+ pages.
I found it rather short. Same with Children and God Emperor. They might feel a little slow sometimes but not really long. 500ish pages feel about the sweet spot
It's a short but dense book, plenty of complex scenes with lots of stuff happening inside the character's heads.
The most impressive thing about Denis's version is that we don't hear the character's thoughts, half of the book is inner monologue, but the film manages to show all the political stuff by showing it instead of saying it.
Couldn’t imagine a movie where these two directed it together! Here’s to hoping!
If you have two quartebacks, you have none
@@dirkdiggler.You're right in a way but i think it could still be possible to see them on a common project. They seems to share the same vision on a lot of point. Maybe in something like a choral movie or an anthology could be something possible.
Sad that this has such a low number of views.
The original upload had ALOT of views praising them both!
30 thousand plus now
They’re watching James corden. Everything is broken now
@@damofx I thought everybody hated him?
Well idk i get the impression a lot of ppl hate Dune, from book purists, to boomers whining about wokeism, to general audiences who get confused, to more boomers who love the Lynch movies. It just isn’t a film that speaks to the general public, thats what John Wick is for, i doubt part 2 will do well unfortunately. People complain about Hollywood being shit but its more the audiences that refuse to see the good stuff that gets made and only flock to the dull crap that makes box office rankings, and then they whine afterwards about how ‘nothing good gets made anymore’
Great video
Thanks!
los dos mejores directores de ciencia ficción actuales?
Where can we get a video of this actual master class of these two masters? 🙏 anyone's know where ?
I always wanted them to talk about this. like I used pray for it. why didn't I know this video existed?
There is no Video upload just podcast? I dont get it DGA why wont upload the full video anymore?
It’s not a “podcast” it’s a on stage with audience audio hearing of the event but we can’t have the video at all due to copyright I think. Something along those lines. This is still a FANTASTIC video to hear and see in clips regardless so people should at least be grateful for that as we can hear this fantastic interview!
I’m here for it!
You should add lightnings coming out of their palms.
Is there a video of this conversation anywhere?
Slide show instead of the video?
Two of my favorite directors in Hollywood right now.
They could probably remake that GARBAGE Battlefield Earth, and make it watchable.
That’s saying something!
Hello, thank you for posting that interview. May I get to know where and when it was?
Hello 2022, where I do not know!
DGA podcast!
@@margauxleclerc6593 thats how it called?
bro is that league messaging in the background
Where can i find the original video of this talk?
I can't tell you if it's there because I don't know
After Paul meets Chani the next part starts 2 years later. This was done for the Method acting 2021-23. Also real Sandworms were used. That's why the actors performances were so realistic. The sandworms are actually vegan in real life but sacrificed to eat real humans just to work with Villaneuve and Chalamet.
Is this video originally from Cortex Videos?
Yes!
why only audio?
Unfortunately, I couldn't find the video
Holy Christ but aren't intelligence and talent wildly sexy?
Thank you
1984 Dune was the best overall.
8:40
where did this take place?
difficult to answer
why no videoo
unfortunately only this
Should have uploaded video here
Do you know why this interview was deleted from the DGA official channel ?
Why?
@@Stock657 I'm asking 😭
@@simemble9342 most likely due to copyright
@@Stock657 do you have the original video of this? I'm dying to see that 🥺
@@simemble9342 Unfortunately, this is the only one
Give us the extra 16 minutes of Dune footage, Denis. Drop the "I don't do Director's Cuts" ego and do it. We pay your salary.
I'm getting really poor framerate on this video.
Anyone else?
I'm glad Nolan is not doing Dune
11:10
20:20 Well… not exactly.
I find strage a french canadian doesn't speak english so well. anyway these two people are the best directors out there at the moment they are two masters really. and they're not american.
Its because of Canada dumb two languages law, it makes French Canadians lazy
In Quebec it's almost entirely french except in Montreal where there is some english, and onsidering it's his second language, he's almost perfectly bilingual, I'm from the same province and I wish my french was as good as his english. Dude is amazing all the same.
It's unbelievable that because his accent is pronounced you think his English isn't good
@@watdood6905 speaking with a good pronounce is part of speaking well and he seems to struggle sometimes to find the right words so I think my impression isn't wrong. Anyway I said "he doesn't speak english so well" which I think it's not an insult and that I found it strange since Canada is predominantly populated by english speaking people amd that's not an insult either.
@@littlemouse7066 and having an accent isn't having poor pronunciation + even if Canada mostly speaking english, you said it yourself, he's french canadian
They did not want to express themselves and the book was the bible but lets gender and race swap for no other reason than checking boxes.
Is this made by AI
The battle scenes were generic and underwhelming. He read the books in French which diluted their meaning. His vision of the Fremen is the opposite of what the authors was.
Dune was overrated
MCU FAN.
They can talk all they want, too bad they didn’t actually make a Dune movie
are you mentally sane?
Сразу видно по посадке кто из них альфа, а кто омежка
Даже обратите внимание как мямлит француз и как по-хозяйски, можно сказать открывая дверь в диалог ногой, говорит англичанин
Are you insane
The movie Dune is not good. It is sooo superficial. That movie doesn't have real depth to it. Denis Villeneuve did not attempt to go deep with the themes of the story. He was maybe too scared to mess up the story or did not know how to do it. But to say, as he said it in the interview, that he treated the book as "the holy bible" is not true. He left out soo much of interesting story plots and dialogues.
Denis Villeneuve also spent the second half of the movie with a ridiculously amount of time for action sequences. Time he could have used to give the story a firm foundation.
The argument of saying "The book is not possible to make a movie out of it" is not valid to me. I read the book and it certainly is easy to make a movie out of its story. Look at Pter Jackson LoTR adaptation, it is perfect!! And LoTR is as vast in its world building as Dune.
Wait for Dune 2
You can certainly criticize the movie for some of the adaptation and creative choices, but claiming that it was „easy to make a movie out of its story“ sounds pretty arrogant, especially when only justified with „I read the book“. And then you follow that up with LotR as an example, as if the LotR movies were any closer to the source material. I don‘t think that‘s a fair assessment of the film
@@tlsgrz6194 oh wow! There is someone feeling insulted... Sorry, I am not interested in leading a conversation on this level.
@@tlsgrz6194
OPs post ,and reply to you, demonstrate a lack of supporting examples and is ironically a “superficial” critique of the film. Simply stating it should’ve been better is a weak criticism. I do agree with your assessment of his assessment lmao
Dude really said he didn’t wanna even have a discussion lol wow
Thank you 🙏 . Most overrated movie of 2021
Two overestimated directors.