Alhamdulillah ..this time ustade mohtram has answered in the same manner as they were asked . May Allah bless him with long life ,good health n more wisdom. True scholar of Islam. Love from India
An Indian Religious Scholar was once sharing his travel episode to a European Country. After Boarding off he hired a taxi.Drivet put the meter on and started driving to the destination. In the middle of journey he put the meter off for some time... 20... to 30 minutes and then again set it on. When Moulana reached his hosts residence he said to him, "Please ask the driver in his Language why kept the meter closed for the intervel while I would have paid him full hire for the journey as per the running meter reading. The driver explained that he went on the wrong route in between the journey by mistake and that he didn't want to charge Moulana for the mistaken route till he returned back and restarted driving on the right route. He thought it immoral to charge for his own mistake. Moulana remarked, "I saw Islam in Europe but no muslims and Muslims in Asia but no Islam."
This may be story for you but I have personally experienced the same… They are more Muslims than we… if only they could recognise Allah and Prophet saws.. they would be better Muslims.
I acknowledge that by listening to ghamdi sahib has increased love and understanding of Quran even though I am a Sufi student. May Allah pak give him best reward for his efforts. Ameen
He has drawn me towards religion with undertanding of it! A scholar presenting logic, knowledge & reality. He clarifies so many myths and unanswered questions. please don't criticise just for the sake of it because it threatens the regime of old so called mullahs.
اسلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ سچ بات تو یہ ہے غامدی صاحب ! حق بہت کم لوگوں پر واضح ہوتا ہے سچائی کو کم ہی لوگ قبول کرتے ہیں ! ولقد ذرانا لجہنم کثیرا من الجن والانس
حیرت ہے کہ مسلمان جہموریت، انسانی حقوق، قانون کی حکمرانی، اقوام کی آزادی و خودمختاری کو کفر سمجھتے ہیں۔ جب تک قرآن کو بنیادی مرکز و منبع و مآخذ اور حکم نہیں مانا جاتا، دین کی بجائے پروہت کی مرضی چلتی رہے گی۔
I admit with zeal and zest that It was He (Ghamidi), also a name of a program once was on air on Geo..... " Concept of God" that was the turning point of my life.... Though many scholars are around and even they give their best to prove the existence of God by philosophical, scientific arguments but that discussion was unbelievable, the attraction of Ghamdi with the students and the way he was answering the questions, the fluency of arguments, everything was adorable and I use to listen that whenever I feel a little weak in faith..... Thank you Sir, and I am a witness of his efforts here in this world and would be hereafter IA.
Hassan ilyas is the best critic, explains all the criticism so clearly and so openly, even Ghamdi sahab has given him authority to put any kind of criticism. Respect
Well Said Ghamdi Sahab feel like saying Hum sa koi hai tou samney aiye 👍👌 Im sure criticise kerney waley apni bhagley jhank rahey hongey ! I totally agree with Ghamdi Sahab his arguments and challenges he discussed -v well said Mera kaam Chupa hua nahi Chapa hua hai 👍
Here s how Ustaaz as always politely destroys the criticizers ;) 11:57 Iss ke siwa Mazahabiyaat mein koi aur tanqeed ka rasta ikhtiyar kiya hi nahi jaa sakta... Jo aadmi karega, woh apne aapse guftugu karega. Aur hamkalaami par mein koi tabsara nahi karta 12:25 Woh dil mein bura jaan kar istemal karte hein Allah ne mujhe iss munafaqat se bachaya huwa hai
Very well said.Great Scholar,God Bless ,You are a Blessing of Allah upon mankind and your work towards Islam and its understandings.God Bless Ghamidi Shahib.
Masha allah... Salam hai muhtaram ghamidi sahab k tahammul ko. Allah pak ta dair aap ka Saya sahet o afiyat k sath hum per qayam rakhe. Pata nahi kyun Mujhe dar lag raha tha k kahin muhtaram hasan sahab ko is tarha k sawalat per dant na pad Jaye...
Assalamoalikum MashAllah you prepared detailed questions in response to Javed Ahmed sahib "GUFTUGOO" program.Where later mentioned that how Ghamdi sahib is inclined by western thought and philosophy.Ghamdi sahib products are also westernized,while what GUFTUGOO guest mentioned that all other Deeni salf produces standard deeni statures. Ghamdi sahib answered straight that religion is not a philosophy or your or someone's thoughts or comments. It's straight Allah SWT word,His majesty messenger sunnah and though Ghamdi sahib mentioned Hadith this time too,but that's the only one answer. I don't know why our religious scholars have lost in side conversations. But that's different point,I wanted to say many many thanks to you,I make Dua for my Ustad Ghamdi sahib all the time,May Allah SWT bless baraka in his life and we see him around us for long long time with his good health,Amin. Last thing: My qurb with Quran and Prophet Muhammad SAW has increased many many times after connecting with Ghamdi sahib,as he connects me with Allah SWT through Allah SWT words and making my concept clear that it's only the life of prophet SAW which can lead to hidaya and no one else. This is the crux of the religion, "BAQI BABA SUB KAHANIAN HEIN" Salam
جاوید غامدی صاحب کاموقف درست ہے وہ دلیل حقیقی جو قرآن ،سنّت،پر ہے یہی ہے وہ کوی نبی نہیں ہیں ان سے بھی غلطی ہو سکتی ہے جس کا وہ اقرار کرتے ہیں ۔۔۔سوچو🤔🙄🤗☝🏿✊🏾🇵🇰🇨🇳🇷🇺⚔️🌹
Nice conversation and dialogue to listen to, as always, ma sha Allah. However, sometimes it feels the emphasis is more on the choice of beautiful words and expressions than the content that could summarise and explain in a way that a common man would be able to understand easily. We also see this in the West, who in many situations emphasize on beautiful words and expressions, lengthy discussions and loses focus from the things that should matter actually. What I love about and struck me the most is that Prophet Muhammad PBUH explained matters in a very very simple way, and the similar style of expression we see in the Quran.
Ghamidi sahb gave logical answers. But you are right, the words used in these conversations are not commonly used even in common spoken Urdu. But it's difficult to thoroughly analyze these matters without using such terminologies. Simple answer was that the critics should point out where his interpretations are against Quran o hadees
دین ھی نے دنیا کو تہزیب دی یہ تہزیب سب کے لیے برابر ھے آگے گروپ ھمارا تعصب ھے کسی بھی کلچر میں کہیں اچھاٸ ھے یہ اسلام ھے اللہ کا ایک منشإ ھے میری بخشی اچھاٸ پر دین اسلام کے راستے سےآٶ راستہ اور کوٸ قبول نہں بس یہ سوال ھے جیسے ھمارےتعصب نے مسلہ بنا رکھا ھے
*کم پڑھے لکھے لوگ ایک سادہ سی بات کرتے ھیں کہ جو عالم دین اپنے ھموطنوں پر ھونیوالے مظالم کی وجہ سمجھتے ھوے بھی ان پر کھل کر کلام نہ کرے اس سے کنارہ کشی کر لیں*
Everyone has a logic of its own, Ghamidi Sb is moving the deen mixed with western culture, but Islam is no more to change for the situation or time. Once a couple asked Rasool ALLAH ﷺ that a lady told them that she fed them herself (so they are brother and sister) and now they are married and having children, so Rasool ALLAH ﷺ asked them to separate even having children at the time. This incident is a clear message that there is no concession in deen for anything any time any situation. Ghamidi SB is a Munkir of Ahadees and the rest is not negotiable.
اولیا اور تصوف کے بارے میں ایک سچے اور علمی مسلمان کا جو موقف ھونا چاہئے غامدی صاحب کا وھی موقف ھے، نام نہاد اولیا اور عاشقان اولیا کا ہاضمہ درست کرنے کے لئے غامدی صاحب کے پاس بہتریں پھکی ھے ،
Watch the playlist "response to 23 questions on religious thought of Javed Ahmed Ghamidi". That playlist is present on this very channel. He has explained his thought process in detail in those videos on the concepts of interest, parda, return of Hazrat Isa, emergence of Imam Mehdi and a lot of other objections. That series is still on going.
Look, lol, Hassan is very clever. I asked him question about science and religion and he cleverly diverted it to Ghamidi Sahib. Ghamidi Sahib, Hassan se beghawat ki boo aare he. Lol❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Actually Traditional ulema nay yeh Asal Deen ( Asaani ) sirf apnay tak rakhi hai, baqi logo k liay sb kuch haraam hai, Sirf ulema hi ko pata hay k unho nay kese balance rakhna hai, baqi sb ko maximum level ki practice krni ho ghi, ulema khud land cruiser, BMW pr beth kr b ayashi nahi karin gy lekin aam admi cycle pr hi guzara kre , ulema 5 canal k ghar main b reh saktay hain un k dil main phr b dunya ki muhabbat nahi aye ghi , lekin aam admi jhonpri main hi rahay or paisay ikathy kr k apnay aalim peer ko dey taa k wo rah lay banglow mein. Aam admi isha ki 17 rakaat hi parhay lekin Imaam sahab khud bs farz parha k peechay ja kar baatayn gupayn b lagata rahay , witr b na parhay, koi prob nahi, Aalim k liay itni ibadat b ALLAH k qurb ka zariya hai. lekin aam admi ko yeh kaafi nahi. bas har mamlay main 2 deen hain, AAM k liay aur and KHUWAAS k liay aur.
غامدي صاحب سے متفق ہو کہ قرآن و سنت کے بنیاد پر متعین کرکے تنقید کیا جائے البتہ اخذ معنی میں غامدی صاحب میں ٹیڑھ ہے مثال کے طور پر حضرت مریم کو جو کھانا آتا تھا غامدی صاحب نے اسکا ترجمہ ہی بدل دیا حالانکہ وہ خوداسکے بنیاد پر غلام پرویز پر تنقید کرتے ہے مجھے اس سے انتہائی مایوسی ہوئ
Actually agr is sawal pr ghor krin to isko REPHRASE kar k yeh kaha ja sakta hai k MAGHRIB ISLAM K RANG MAIN DHALL CHUKA HAI.😀 imaaniyat k ilawa jitne asool hain as far as the Muaamlaat are concerned we only find in western society. lahaza jab hum islam ko sources QURAN SUNNAH SAHI HADITH main se parhtay hain ya logo ko batatay hain to wo kahtay hain k yeh konsa islam hai yeh to sb MAGHRIB ki baatain hain. kion k un ko yeh sab kuch Practically physically maghrib main exist karta nazar ata hay, and its missing in muslim world. Lahaza yeh sawal kr k phr hamain dhoob k mar jana chahiay.
Quran was interpreted and acted upon by the Holy Prophet SAWS. It was conveyed by the companions. Whatever one presents about Islam must be referred to Quran/Sunnah and the examples of Sahabah.
christianity,islam hinduism many other religions were followed by humanity for thousands of years, a time came when things froze and humanity was looking for a change rennaisance started and changed everything and every body is following that se we all look like and do same things no religion likes it, that is why ghamdi is being challenged because he proves that religion supports change
21:00 iske lie aapko unki tanqeed ka mutala krna padega na..jinhone kari silsilewar tanqeed kari hai.. sirf video me ektarfa apne ans dene se to bat ni banegi na hazrat.
السلام علیکم غامدی صاحب میں جاننا چاہوں گا آپ خود نماز حنفی طریقے پر ادا کرتے ہیں یا رفیع الدین سے جیسے میں نے ویڈیو میں دیکھا ڈاکٹر اسرار الحق صاحب رفیع الدین سے نماز ادا کر رہے ہیں جواب سے تشفی ضرور فرمائیں جزاک اللہ
Quran tells us to ponder to reflect so why do people want their minds to stand still. Those who criticise Dr Ghamidi for letting him mind grow should stand in stagnant water for a few hours they would under their minds better.
Thanks!
اللہ تعالی آپ کو لمبی عمر عطا فرماۓ اور ذیادہ سے ذیادہ دین کی خدمت کی توفیق دے۔ آمین
الحمداللہ آپ کی باتیں سن کر دل مطمئن ہو جاتا ہے اللہ تعالی آپ کو صحت اور تندرستی دے
آپکی ہر بات مدلل ہوتی ہے ۔۔۔ ۔آپکی زہانت لاجواب ہے اللہ جزاے خیر دے سلامت رکھے
سورج کو جالی سے نہیں ڈهانپا جاسکتا ۔ غامدی صاحب کی فکر و نظر نے واقعی سامع و ناظر کے گردن سے مذهبی جبر کی بیڑیاں اور طوق کو اتار پھینکا ہے۔
Every Firaun of modern time thrown to Garbage , by this discussion
Alhamdulillah ..this time ustade mohtram has answered in the same manner as they were asked . May Allah bless him with long life ,good health n more wisdom. True scholar of Islam. Love from India
An Indian Religious Scholar was once sharing his travel episode to a European Country. After Boarding off he hired a taxi.Drivet put the meter on and started driving to the destination. In the middle of journey he put the meter off for some time... 20... to 30 minutes and then again set it on. When Moulana reached his hosts residence he said to him, "Please ask the driver in his Language why kept the meter closed for the intervel while I would have paid him full hire for the journey as per the running meter reading. The driver explained that he went on the wrong route in between the journey by mistake and that he didn't want to charge Moulana for the mistaken route till he returned back and restarted driving on the right route. He thought it immoral to charge for his own mistake. Moulana remarked, "I saw Islam in Europe but no muslims and Muslims in Asia but no Islam."
This may be story for you but I have personally experienced the same… They are more Muslims than we… if only they could recognise Allah and Prophet saws.. they would be better Muslims.
this is in japan not Europe
@@mrsasif14 Mrs.Asif, Ye waqia jo hua, wo kounse MAULANA SAAB ke saath hua. Agar aap bata sakhe?
i am not sure about the story but the quote is by Muhammad Abduah, an egyptian scholar.
I think it was Sheikh Muhammad Abduh
I acknowledge that by listening to ghamdi sahib has increased love and understanding of Quran even though I am a Sufi student. May Allah pak give him best reward for his efforts. Ameen
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is an authentic scholar of Islam, and his teachings are genuinely Islamic.
He has drawn me towards religion with undertanding of it! A scholar presenting logic, knowledge & reality. He clarifies so many myths and unanswered questions. please don't criticise just for the sake of it because it threatens the regime of old so called mullahs.
Same here
جزاک اللہ غامدی صاحب خوبصورت انداز بیان
اسلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ
سچ بات تو یہ ہے غامدی صاحب !
حق بہت کم لوگوں پر واضح ہوتا ہے
سچائی کو کم ہی لوگ قبول کرتے ہیں !
ولقد ذرانا لجہنم کثیرا من الجن والانس
حیرت ہے کہ مسلمان جہموریت، انسانی حقوق، قانون کی حکمرانی، اقوام کی آزادی و خودمختاری کو کفر سمجھتے ہیں۔
جب تک قرآن کو بنیادی مرکز و منبع و مآخذ اور حکم نہیں مانا جاتا، دین کی بجائے پروہت کی مرضی چلتی رہے گی۔
100💯%
I admit with zeal and zest that It was He (Ghamidi), also a name of a program once was on air on Geo..... " Concept of God" that was the turning point of my life.... Though many scholars are around and even they give their best to prove the existence of God by philosophical, scientific arguments but that discussion was unbelievable, the attraction of Ghamdi with the students and the way he was answering the questions, the fluency of arguments, everything was adorable and I use to listen that whenever I feel a little weak in faith..... Thank you Sir, and I am a witness of his efforts here in this world and would be hereafter IA.
Hassan ilyas is the best critic, explains all the criticism so clearly and so openly, even Ghamdi sahab has given him authority to put any kind of criticism.
Respect
He is an Aalim. No doubt about it. He is very cool. I pray for his health and happiness.
السلام علیکم ورحمۃ اللہ وبرکاتہ
بہت وقت لگتا ہے ، جدوجہد اور جذبہ ، محنت و صبر
سچائی کو پہنچانا عظیم کام ہے
اللہ کریم قبولیت سے نوازے اور بابرکت بنائے
Well Said Ghamdi Sahab feel like saying
Hum sa koi hai tou samney aiye 👍👌
Im sure criticise kerney waley apni bhagley jhank rahey hongey !
I totally agree with Ghamdi Sahab his arguments and challenges he discussed -v well said
Mera kaam Chupa hua nahi Chapa hua hai 👍
A great scholar of Islam ❤️
Here s how Ustaaz as always politely destroys the criticizers ;)
11:57 Iss ke siwa Mazahabiyaat mein koi aur tanqeed ka rasta ikhtiyar kiya hi nahi jaa sakta... Jo aadmi karega, woh apne aapse guftugu karega. Aur hamkalaami par mein koi tabsara nahi karta
12:25 Woh dil mein bura jaan kar istemal karte hein
Allah ne mujhe iss munafaqat se bachaya huwa hai
❤❤❤جزاک الله غامدی صاحب ❤❤❤خان احمد سرا ے عالمگیر ❤❤❤
wah wah very nice Ghamdi Sahib
Beautiful explanation 👌👌Ghamdi Sir is all time great 👍
Very well said.Great Scholar,God Bless ,You are a Blessing of Allah upon mankind and your work towards Islam and its understandings.God Bless Ghamidi Shahib.
Sir I am your Follower. You doing great work. Thank you.
I really Ghamdi Sahab's take on disecting issues. On a lighter note today I am thrilled to hear a few english words in his talk :)
Once again, most logical answer.
No he is giving new light to Islam,great spiritual leader,May Allah bless him
Ghamidi sahab phir Jeet Gaye❤️👌☝️🇮🇳
Mashallah ghamdi sahab
Jazakallah
Excellently explained maa sha Allah ❤️ great ustaaz ghamidi sb ❤️
Greatest Mujadid of apps times
Great scholar mashallha
God bless you Ghamdi Sb. Allah apki hifazat fermain. Ameen
Masha allah... Salam hai muhtaram ghamidi sahab k tahammul ko. Allah pak ta dair aap ka Saya sahet o afiyat k sath hum per qayam rakhe.
Pata nahi kyun Mujhe dar lag raha tha k kahin muhtaram hasan sahab ko is tarha k sawalat per dant na pad Jaye...
Mashallah ghamdi sahab .JazakAllah
love you ustaz e mohterm
the onlyعالم دین who is literate n logical
Assalamoalikum
MashAllah you prepared detailed questions in response to Javed Ahmed sahib "GUFTUGOO" program.Where later mentioned that how Ghamdi sahib is inclined by western thought and philosophy.Ghamdi sahib products are also westernized,while what GUFTUGOO guest mentioned that all other Deeni salf produces standard deeni statures.
Ghamdi sahib answered straight that religion is not a philosophy or your or someone's thoughts or comments.
It's straight Allah SWT word,His majesty messenger sunnah and though Ghamdi sahib mentioned Hadith this time too,but that's the only one answer.
I don't know why our religious scholars have lost in side conversations.
But that's different point,I wanted to say many many thanks to you,I make Dua for my Ustad Ghamdi sahib all the time,May Allah SWT bless baraka in his life and we see him around us for long long time with his good health,Amin.
Last thing:
My qurb with Quran and Prophet Muhammad SAW has increased many many times after connecting with Ghamdi sahib,as he connects me with Allah SWT through Allah SWT words and making my concept clear that it's only the life of prophet SAW which can lead to hidaya and no one else.
This is the crux of the religion,
"BAQI BABA SUB KAHANIAN HEIN"
Salam
MA any time when I hear Ghamdi sahib always got new information
How systematically question he asks, a genuine seeker.
Love Ghamidi Saheb.
Ghamidi Saheb rules.
جاوید غامدی صاحب کاموقف درست ہے وہ دلیل حقیقی جو قرآن ،سنّت،پر ہے یہی ہے وہ کوی نبی نہیں ہیں ان سے بھی غلطی ہو سکتی ہے جس کا وہ اقرار کرتے ہیں ۔۔۔سوچو🤔🙄🤗☝🏿✊🏾🇵🇰🇨🇳🇷🇺⚔️🌹
Masha Allah a great scholar who born in centuries May Allah grant him long long life
MashaAllah sir ghamidi sb
i didnt expect such unsubstantial reasoning from Ahmad Javed sb. Glad that Hassan Ilyas took it
Fantastic answering love the way he answers
Nice conversation and dialogue to listen to, as always, ma sha Allah. However, sometimes it feels the emphasis is more on the choice of beautiful words and expressions than the content that could summarise and explain in a way that a common man would be able to understand easily. We also see this in the West, who in many situations emphasize on beautiful words and expressions, lengthy discussions and loses focus from the things that should matter actually. What I love about and struck me the most is that Prophet Muhammad PBUH explained matters in a very very simple way, and the similar style of expression we see in the Quran.
Ghamidi sahb gave logical answers. But you are right, the words used in these conversations are not commonly used even in common spoken Urdu. But it's difficult to thoroughly analyze these matters without using such terminologies. Simple answer was that the critics should point out where his interpretations are against Quran o hadees
14:10 So true
8:50 epic reply . Great sense of humor Ustad sahab.....
بے شک
A true student of islam
Ustad e mohtaram ❤️❤️❤️
Mohtaram Ghamdi sahab is zamane k mujadid hain
Never seen such POWER HITTING from Ghamdi sahib ☺️
Masah allah jazak allah
Ghamedi sahib aap azeem hain
perfect approach...
دین ھی نے دنیا کو تہزیب دی یہ تہزیب سب کے لیے برابر ھے آگے گروپ ھمارا تعصب ھے کسی بھی کلچر میں کہیں اچھاٸ ھے یہ اسلام ھے اللہ کا ایک منشإ ھے میری بخشی اچھاٸ پر دین اسلام کے راستے سےآٶ راستہ اور کوٸ قبول نہں بس یہ سوال ھے جیسے ھمارےتعصب نے مسلہ بنا رکھا ھے
Ultra Pro Max Answers❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Mashallah very nice message for Nation.
He is an Intelligent Honest and CAMMITTED Person of HIS FIELD
SHARIQ
*کم پڑھے لکھے لوگ ایک سادہ سی بات کرتے ھیں کہ جو عالم دین اپنے ھموطنوں پر ھونیوالے مظالم کی وجہ سمجھتے ھوے بھی ان پر کھل کر کلام نہ کرے اس سے کنارہ کشی کر لیں*
Osstad je,........,
Well done ghamdi sb great
Everyone has a logic of its own, Ghamidi Sb is moving the deen mixed with western culture, but Islam is no more to change for the situation or time. Once a couple asked Rasool ALLAH ﷺ that a lady told them that she fed them herself (so they are brother and sister) and now they are married and having children, so Rasool ALLAH ﷺ asked them to separate even having children at the time. This incident is a clear message that there is no concession in deen for anything any time any situation. Ghamidi SB is a Munkir of Ahadees and the rest is not negotiable.
Masha allah
Javaid Ahmed Ghamidi 🇵🇰❤️🤩🥰👍
الحمد لله آپ کی فلسفیانہ باتیں کسی کی سمجھ نہیں آتیں اور اس طرح آپ ہندوستان اور پاکستان کے لوگوں بہت کامیابی سے بے وقوف بنائے ہوئے ہیں
Great sir
Asslam-o-Alaikum
Sir, can we invest in real estate through crowd funding? Will it be Hilal? Like in Dubai etc.
اولیا اور تصوف کے بارے میں ایک سچے اور علمی مسلمان کا جو موقف ھونا چاہئے غامدی صاحب کا وھی موقف ھے، نام نہاد اولیا اور عاشقان اولیا کا ہاضمہ درست کرنے کے لئے غامدی صاحب کے پاس بہتریں پھکی ھے ،
ماشاالله
Subhan Allah
Subhan Allah
I agree with you what you are saying however what about strong rules of Quran like “interest “
Watch the playlist "response to 23 questions on religious thought of Javed Ahmed Ghamidi". That playlist is present on this very channel. He has explained his thought process in detail in those videos on the concepts of interest, parda, return of Hazrat Isa, emergence of Imam Mehdi and a lot of other objections. That series is still on going.
Janab Ghamidi sahib God bless you .Mr Hassan is a gentleman .
YES
Good
Very good questions raised by Hassan Ilyas... Ghamidi Sahb kisi sawal ka tasali baksh jwab ni de sake
Sir u r great but u should also publish ur writings in top news papers in India and other countries also.
Islam eik munfarid nazriya zindagi ka rekhta hai
If I know what knowledge is it is by listening to ustaad
Look, lol, Hassan is very clever. I asked him question about science and religion and he cleverly diverted it to Ghamidi Sahib. Ghamidi Sahib, Hassan se beghawat ki boo aare he. Lol❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Tasauf is to bring people more close to Allah it’s one way of teaching the love of Allah why you left that
Listen to his vlog on peer parasti and tasuaf.. you ll find the answer..
Tassauf shirk ha
Is tasawwuf derived from Quran or Prophetic sayings?
Tasawwuf ke aqaaid o nazariyaat unke nazdeek ghalat hain. Tazkita nafs se inko koi problem nahi.
100% 👍
Jaweed shahab has stopped mulla's explained lies.
Wah
Ghamidi sahab ko sawal kaise puchein.... please bataiye
Actually Traditional ulema nay yeh Asal Deen ( Asaani ) sirf apnay tak rakhi hai, baqi logo k liay sb kuch haraam hai, Sirf ulema hi ko pata hay k unho nay kese balance rakhna hai, baqi sb ko maximum level ki practice krni ho ghi, ulema khud land cruiser, BMW pr beth kr b ayashi nahi karin gy lekin aam admi cycle pr hi guzara kre , ulema 5 canal k ghar main b reh saktay hain un k dil main phr b dunya ki muhabbat nahi aye ghi , lekin aam admi jhonpri main hi rahay or paisay ikathy kr k apnay aalim peer ko dey taa k wo rah lay banglow mein. Aam admi isha ki 17 rakaat hi parhay lekin Imaam sahab khud bs farz parha k peechay ja kar baatayn gupayn b lagata rahay , witr b na parhay, koi prob nahi, Aalim k liay itni ibadat b ALLAH k qurb ka zariya hai. lekin aam admi ko yeh kaafi nahi. bas har mamlay main 2 deen hain, AAM k liay aur and KHUWAAS k liay aur.
غامدي صاحب سے متفق ہو کہ قرآن و سنت کے بنیاد پر متعین کرکے تنقید کیا جائے
البتہ اخذ معنی میں غامدی صاحب میں ٹیڑھ ہے
مثال کے طور پر حضرت مریم کو جو کھانا آتا تھا غامدی صاحب نے اسکا ترجمہ ہی بدل دیا
حالانکہ وہ خوداسکے بنیاد پر غلام پرویز پر تنقید کرتے ہے مجھے اس سے انتہائی مایوسی ہوئ
Bohot khoob Pakistan ne sb molana yehi sawal krty hen
Devil evil/Bad evil invite Natural disasters. Please act upon teachings of Holy Quran and Ahle Bait SAWW
Actually agr is sawal pr ghor krin to isko REPHRASE kar k yeh kaha ja sakta hai k MAGHRIB ISLAM K RANG MAIN DHALL CHUKA HAI.😀 imaaniyat k ilawa jitne asool hain as far as the Muaamlaat are concerned we only find in western society. lahaza jab hum islam ko sources QURAN SUNNAH SAHI HADITH main se parhtay hain ya logo ko batatay hain to wo kahtay hain k yeh konsa islam hai yeh to sb MAGHRIB ki baatain hain. kion k un ko yeh sab kuch Practically physically maghrib main exist karta nazar ata hay, and its missing in muslim world. Lahaza yeh sawal kr k phr hamain dhoob k mar jana chahiay.
Quran was interpreted and acted upon by the Holy Prophet SAWS. It was conveyed by the companions. Whatever one presents about Islam must be referred to Quran/Sunnah and the examples of Sahabah.
christianity,islam hinduism many other religions were followed by humanity for thousands of years, a time came when things froze and humanity was looking for a change rennaisance started and changed everything and every body is following that se we all look like and do same things no religion likes it, that is why ghamdi is being challenged because he proves that religion supports change
It's such a shame the criticism on him is so trivial ........he's on a different level,,,,,
👍
21:00 iske lie aapko unki tanqeed ka mutala krna padega na..jinhone kari silsilewar tanqeed kari hai.. sirf video me ektarfa apne ans dene se to bat ni banegi na hazrat.
Kiski tanqeed?
اس میں کوئی شک نہیں
السلام علیکم غامدی صاحب میں جاننا چاہوں گا آپ خود نماز حنفی طریقے پر ادا کرتے ہیں یا رفیع الدین سے جیسے میں نے ویڈیو میں دیکھا ڈاکٹر اسرار الحق صاحب رفیع الدین سے نماز ادا کر رہے ہیں جواب سے تشفی ضرور فرمائیں جزاک اللہ
Quran tells us to ponder to reflect so why do people want their minds to stand still. Those who criticise Dr Ghamidi for letting him mind grow should stand in stagnant water for a few hours they would under their minds better.
But please Ghamdi sir Allah kye kitab ka her lafez hemesha tak kye leye hey
Quran is till end