@@Okay__And Ik groups use it but not a lot of them FULLY depend on it. Well, it's hybe girl groups we are talking about except Fromis_9..they are amazing). So...
This is actually making me a bit mad tbh, them getting this much recognition and there are other groups who can actually sing didn't get to be recognized with their talents and now we have these girls who can't actually do their job.
@@gintokichan5158 hey! there are a lot of gg in the 5th gen that has talents and beautiful vocals that deserves on the top spot. most of them are from small or new companies. their debuting talents, unlike hybe. dont get mad, just saying
Suposedly...they were the most talented out of hybes trainees?? That was the point of that reality show? Trying to make us believe that, right? Why make such young girls go through hardship, singers need to be trained better.
มันเว้นได้จ้าอิแก่ ไม่จำเป็นต้องร้อง เข้าใจปะ มันเป็นท่อนเล็กๆ ใครมันจะไปร้องทุกคำ คือตลกปะ it's not they can't sing but it's not necessary to sing anyway jaaa EBAH คือไปอยู่โลกไหนมาอ๋อ แงๆวๆวๆวๆๆๆๆ 😭😭😭😭
@@PolluxieVTam i an idol? No. Do i get vocal training to be able to sing the song? No. Are they an idol? Yes. Do they get vocal training to be able to sing the song? Yes, so they should be able to sing this song then! I'm not hating, just saying maybe they need more training
they don't care if their vocals are not good...their company has a lot of money to buy their awards for them..😂😂 their artist are being back up with money..hahaha
cant believe popularity over skills does matter. As kpop fan, this is alarming that this kind of group is gaining too much attention despite of thier poor singing skills not even a pinch in the singing skills of babymonster and other idols. Other idols deserve more attention and popularity because they have the skills that idols must have and showcase
@@Doing-it- You know that trendings can be 'managed' too, right?! Big companies have money power for promotion and have better connection. And this is Hybe. Not Big Hit. Hybe main investor is George Soros.
Seems 1 girl can sing decently… the song really does not have a wide range, or riffs and runs… maybe a more challenging song can bring out that girl’s singing better…
@@firavun8943listen with headphones, there's a huge "electronic sound" effect through the whole performance. Listen to G-IDLE or kiss of life, you'll see the difference, sound will be a bit rougher but more... Live
3 of them used to train for almost 6 years,and they can't sing. I thought they were trainee one month,but when you spend so much time on training and can't sing, it's better not to become an idol
Will there be live stage band version? I think they are not required to dance there. I would like to hear their real live vocals without studio editing.
they used pitch corrector here you can tell if you were in a band.. also they sounded so bad on their encore too, I'm just tired of people patronizing them that they can sing when there's only like 2 members who can. don't get me wrong I like magnetic but please tell it as it is.
I mean anyone can tell they aren't good singers it's not even about whether it's a girl or boy group lol. The song slaps but they really need voice lessons @@Itoshimi
Baby Monster, Unis at Young Posse nag Stand Out sakin ngayong Buwan sa Live Vocals. Recommend ko din sayo ung Live Vocals ng Young Posse sa Radio Guesting nila Mas Stable at Confident din sila pagdating sa Live Vocals at para sakin Mas Paborito ko sila kaysa sa BabyMonster at UNIS ngayong Taon 💖
Hahahha sabi pa nang mga fans nila. They will improve in the future daw.. yeah they will.. pero magpa iiwanan na sila sa mga kasabayan nila na halimaw ang mga live vocals😂
You are right, they are not dancing and yet they cannot sing the entire song and their voices are common, they do not stand out, the song may be good but their voices are horrible.
Because of the voice effect that part has. It's edited to be really quick and high pitched because it's more part of the instrumental than the melody of the song.
Nowadays songs like this is hard to hear in Acapella coz they just don't sound like the parts are meant to connect without the background music, especially because it is sang by a group part by part..I am trying to like this group 😭 but I guess it will take some time.
@@vchaversetv I'm not saying they sound bad. I'm saying they sound fine with mr removed because they're not dancing and moving like some other gg. So it doesn't count.
What the heck is this? Someone singing or someone chocking? And people really like this song and goes viral? Omg...HYBE please make your girlgroups training vocal again. The downfall of Kpop is begin.....
@@EMGEE864 ITZY, BOYSNEXTDOOR, NMIXX, B1A4, VIVIZ, Wheein from Mamamoo, TXT, Stray Kids, GIDLE, ENHYPEN... The difference among each group in their live performances on the radio is the volume of the backtrack. Some groups' are louder than others but it can also vary through songs, a group can sing live with louder backtrack in one song and in another it's lower or none at all. The group themselves don't get a say in whether they want the backtrack or not or how loud they want it though, it's the shows, companies, or both that choose how high they want to crank the backtrack, sometimes specifically tune the volumes of members' mics too to accommodate for certain members because not all members are equal in terms of vocality. Although I did notice that beliftgroups' backtracks are kinda loud but it's no surprise there, belift is certainly... a company lol
why hybe loves debuting group that are not stable in vocal like there's two gg with crack voice and they helped by other members is it only one or two member that good in singing???? sihyuk and hybe you're so embarrassing
This is not a matter of hating groups who cannot sing. Actually, it's more like they can sing BUT just ordinary vocals like everyone else. There is very little sound dynamics in their vocals, some vocal skills but unimpressive. They all sound the same, very bland, no power. Playing it safe with their garden variety vocals.
1 minute in and I don't get why everyone is so mad. Sure, they make mistakes and this doesn't sound very pleasant (well, even Mamamoo songs don't feel the same acapella), but it's not that terrible. I heard how bad Illit girls were from other k-pop fans and was expecting something much worse, yet they were actually pretty fine. But I agree that Hybe is almost completely ignoring idols' vocal skills. This company also needs to stop debuting minors. These premature groups didn't even have enough time to develop their vocals.
Sings better than izone, ive, aespa, fromis, baemon, le sserafim and red velvet. And their visuals is top 0.00001 in kpop. Wonyoung will wet herself if she meet them
It is suggested to watch Dreamcatcher Primavera performance to clean your ear😂. Btw please make an MR Remove for Dreamcatcher Primavera, the one thats uploaded by Morbo 🙏😭
![쿨룩 LIVE ▷ 아일릿(ILLIT) ‘Magnetic’ / [이은지의 가요광장] I KBS 240326 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/x65yMUdj0hw/mqdefault.jpg)
![ILLIT|| Magnetic but you are Yunah & Wonhee [Color Coded Lyrics Romanized karaoke]](/img/n.gif)
Original video: th-cam.com/video/x65yMUdj0hw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=6OdvBsKdRx_SFRhK
Only one can sing . Hype is this for real ? Haha they are even from a survival show like wtf
Fr
yess R u next for noting to present ?
@@Nellaxchux r u next was a hell of a lot of lip syncing
Only can sing and is an ex-YG trainee lol
there were candidates with top tier vocals but they were "too old" 😄
Ain't no way they used pitch corrector even for a radio show
It’s hybe what do you expect?
@@ggstan2439 wdym its hybe?? ? Is just girl grub from hybe the problem is just that, and why did u say like all hybe artist are bad singer?? Tf
@@skinnyg2821 sakuraaaaa, kazuhaaaaa, eunchaeeeee
You underestimate kpop
@@Okay__And Ik groups use it but not a lot of them FULLY depend on it. Well, it's hybe girl groups we are talking about except Fromis_9..they are amazing). So...
This is actually making me a bit mad tbh, them getting this much recognition and there are other groups who can actually sing didn't get to be recognized with their talents and now we have these girls who can't actually do their job.
true. just because they come from a big company. if ever they're from a small company idk if they will be recognize 😅
Fr fuck hybe
they literally can do their job, yall just like to hate on these girls for dumb ahh reasons
are you talking about BM not being on top? 😅
@@gintokichan5158 hey! there are a lot of gg in the 5th gen that has talents and beautiful vocals that deserves on the top spot. most of them are from small or new companies. their debuting talents, unlike hybe. dont get mad, just saying
Suposedly...they were the most talented out of hybes trainees?? That was the point of that reality show? Trying to make us believe that, right? Why make such young girls go through hardship, singers need to be trained better.
The point of the reality show was exposure
They already pick the winners of that survival show,, they just need fanbase and exposure.. coz they know knetz like cute and pretty kids
baemon is their age ad the maknae is 09 liner but if you are talened, you are talented sometimes you can't teach that
Disappointing to hear their vocals. I just stumbled upon a newly debut group called UNIS and they sound great during live performances.
UNIS are talented.. please also listen to Babymonster :)
My opinion baby monster, vvup,unis proud of them
Stan UNIS❤
That's because most of them are actually Vocalists 😊
You should listen vvup too, please
Hybe is just a dancing company after all 💀💀
yeah😂 they should stop being idol agency, just be model agency, no one will get hurt
@@whinnc fr I agree 😂
Only New jeans and seventeen can sing
yall kpop stans always forgetting txt im always wondering why
@@MuthiaKhansatxt and bts from big hit, I guess that’s why it’s obvious that they can sing
like singing without a soul,
🤖
😂 fr
💯
I cant describe it well but they look like cute robots
Fr 🤖
They even couldn't sing the "babe Babe babe" part or "you you you" part with no adilbs😂 i got scammed
yeah. kinda funny when highlight of the song is just backtrack. lmao
True
have you tried doing it??? it puts you out of breath? you're insane
มันเว้นได้จ้าอิแก่ ไม่จำเป็นต้องร้อง เข้าใจปะ มันเป็นท่อนเล็กๆ ใครมันจะไปร้องทุกคำ คือตลกปะ it's not they can't sing but it's not necessary to sing anyway jaaa EBAH คือไปอยู่โลกไหนมาอ๋อ แงๆวๆวๆวๆๆๆๆ 😭😭😭😭
@@PolluxieVTam i an idol? No. Do i get vocal training to be able to sing the song? No. Are they an idol? Yes. Do they get vocal training to be able to sing the song? Yes, so they should be able to sing this song then! I'm not hating, just saying maybe they need more training
i can’t moka’s voice is so painful to listen to i’m sorry
Yeah she sounded great at first but I don’t know what happened
Hybe is making her sing a certain way which makes it very annoying. She’s such a good singer
Can’t sing to save her life unfortunately
@@affluenza9167 stfu delulu, she is bad and no one can deny that. These girls arent prepared -_-
I got secondhand embarassment listening to this. Cant even sing well standing like that.
Lol Hybe must think they created supestars😂😂😂😂
indeed....omg i really can stand Hybe girlgroup, only have viral songs but lack abilities....i miss the old kpop day
@@jasonwats3035watch out for katseye ❤ hybe and geffen records global girl group
they don't care if their vocals are not good...their company has a lot of money to buy their awards for them..😂😂
their artist are being back up with money..hahaha
cant believe popularity over skills does matter. As kpop fan, this is alarming that this kind of group is gaining too much attention despite of thier poor singing skills not even a pinch in the singing skills of babymonster and other idols. Other idols deserve more attention and popularity because they have the skills that idols must have and showcase
Shows that most fans are just NPC’s
@@Doing-it- You know that trendings can be 'managed' too, right?! Big companies have money power for promotion and have better connection. And this is Hybe. Not Big Hit. Hybe main investor is George Soros.
nah, they had a great song. they wouldn't have gained this much popularity if Magnetic wasn't such a vibe.
@@bvbxiong5791 Magnetic just isnt a vibe, especially with girls who cant sing.
give moka an oxygen tank
🤣🤣🤣 Fr
She always sounds like she just got done running a marathon
Hybe investing in autotune machine than their vocal lessons
Vocals fail😂
you failed to make me laugh
But let someone make fun of your favorite boy group and you start throwing light sticks
FAXXX
@@Itoshimi agree♡
@@SeojinYui you failed a hearing test orr something?!
wtf did i just watched? and some people are comparing them to UNIS lmao
UNIS is out of their league, bro. On every stage, UNIS, you can hear their vocals over their background track.
UNIS much better than Eyelit 😂😂😂
Seems 1 girl can sing decently… the song really does not have a wide range, or riffs and runs… maybe a more challenging song can bring out that girl’s singing better…
the one ex yg trainee who trained with babymonster is the only that can sing
even 3 years old can sing this
Girl 2 aswell
i dont know why they still uses pitch corrector
Because they're not idols they just dancers acting like idols 😂
How do you understand that ? Its a genuine question. I dont know this group.
@@firavun8943listen with headphones, there's a huge "electronic sound" effect through the whole performance. Listen to G-IDLE or kiss of life, you'll see the difference, sound will be a bit rougher but more... Live
This is not high song, but why voice like this😢,, sorry ILLIT😭😭😭😭
Hybe wanted to create a "new jeans" but created le sserafim instead 😅
You are forbidden to stan anyone but Minju until the others learn to sing
But Wonhee is so cute tho🥺
But yunah can sing😰
Girl you ain't these people mother they can stand who they want tf?
Yunah's voice reminds me a lot of An Yujin's 😭💞💞 I LOVE IROHA'S VOICE 💗
I thought the same thing
EXACTLYYY!!! It’s so clear
@@mrremovedbycleo 🙈
@@senyu1540 😊
imo yunah's voice reminds me with yeri
They already inside the studio plus with minimal movement 😢 really?
Honest opinion, i like their voice but this song they are hardly singing. More like rapping and talking. Singing parts are so short.
so real, i feel like it's that way so that it'll be good to use on tiktok, which will promote their song 😭😭
Even Mr remove can't remove heavy auto tune , it doesn't sound acapella at all that it should
It's an insult for UNIS to even be compared to a group like this
Yunah and minju…you did a great job
Not a lot of lines actually...
3 of them used to train for almost 6 years,and they can't sing. I thought they were trainee one month,but when you spend so much time on training and can't sing, it's better not to become an idol
go girl give us nothing
I thought they were praying. 😂But Minju sings better than anyone else.
Minju and Iroha have some major singing chops!!!❤❤
So mostly they don't have much lyrics only backtracks, this is not a song😢
what you expect from a tiktok song
Hybe debuting dance crew
Minju sounds great as always ❤
Will there be live stage band version? I think they are not required to dance there. I would like to hear their real live vocals without studio editing.
they used pitch corrector here you can tell if you were in a band.. also they sounded so bad on their encore too, I'm just tired of people patronizing them that they can sing when there's only like 2 members who can. don't get me wrong I like magnetic but please tell it as it is.
There’s a channel that does ‘live’ stage band version but it’s not live. Even if the vocals are pre-recorded
@@pwehDuraSaFaceI wonder if people would be this harsh if this were a boy group. “Not my oppar! Hes just tired”. Give me a break.
There are barely any idols who does sing live without backtrack or autotune. Sadly.
I mean anyone can tell they aren't good singers it's not even about whether it's a girl or boy group lol. The song slaps but they really need voice lessons @@Itoshimi
Kung di lng malaking agency sila galing di sila sisikat mas maganda ang vocal ng babymonster at Unis
Trauma malala pag ito kumanta sa pinas😂😂😂 land of singers😂 marami judges
Baby Monster, Unis at Young Posse nag Stand Out sakin ngayong Buwan sa Live Vocals. Recommend ko din sayo ung Live Vocals ng Young Posse sa Radio Guesting nila Mas Stable at Confident din sila pagdating sa Live Vocals at para sakin Mas Paborito ko sila kaysa sa BabyMonster at UNIS ngayong Taon 💖
Hahahha sabi pa nang mga fans nila. They will improve in the future daw.. yeah they will.. pero magpa iiwanan na sila sa mga kasabayan nila na halimaw ang mga live vocals😂
@@cyruss9455panalo nga to old-school hip hop
@@BoyKoiking wait nyo ppunta yan sa mag cconcert... at maraming pinoy gusto sila marining, na lip sync sa concert at puru dance performance hahaha
Their vocals aren’t even terrible hearing this do they need more practice, yes are they the best,no but we can only hope for more from them
Their faces tell: “Ok, were singing live again. Were fvcked.”
Hahahaha seriously.
노래 못하는 목소리 들으면 귀 아프지 않나요??? 비주얼만으로 아이돌을 고르는게 참 이상해요
well your countrymen voted for them thats why they are always winning on music shows hahah
ㅋ 비주얼도 데뷔전 보다 못해요…
You are right, they are not dancing and yet they cannot sing the entire song and their voices are common, they do not stand out, the song may be good but their voices are horrible.
Illit fans, where are you? can you listen to this?😢
they can only sing in monotone HAHAHA
moka's voice is awful. it's like she's scared all the time, just like sakura
Which one is moka
@@Solo-kf9mpthe one with glasses
@@yuzu0882 tysmm
yunah❤❤❤
민주가 확실히 좋네
child.. not singer yet
wait, why are they not singing the "you you you you" part? lol. is this still recorded?
It's a full on backtrack they are just singing along. You can hear from the original that the only thing you can hear is the backtrack. 😅
Because of the voice effect that part has. It's edited to be really quick and high pitched because it's more part of the instrumental than the melody of the song.
Are they singing a pre schoolers song ? Hahaha
I can’t breathe
now what's the next excuse 🤣 why there is still pitched corrector , common just sing (not all of them , some had great vocals Idk which who is who)
please make nowadays mr removed
my ears hurt
Nowadays songs like this is hard to hear in Acapella coz they just don't sound like the parts are meant to connect without the background music, especially because it is sang by a group part by part..I am trying to like this group 😭 but I guess it will take some time.
Half of their songs has that " you and bae" part so you mean they are only singing for 1 minute 💀💀💀
Wonhee and minju voice is so ❤❤❤❤ all voice is so oretty
They we're all lip syncing like bruh💀
minju is safe but others💀
@@norapple4557 fr 💀
😢 vocal flop
why does Moka reminds me of Sakura
Omo they did good 💗🎉 illitville will always be there for these girls. Love Minju's voice sm.
Hi, can u do mr removed to all dingo live and it's live? Tq ❤
1:13 Wonhee sings so heavenly in this part ❤
It is annoying how mid their voices are and yet they are so popular. Maybe it is true that hype is payola
fame is 20% luck 20% connections 20% talent 20% visuals and 20% hard work hahahahah guess we know which of those they havee lol
They're not even dancing, how does this even count compared to other groups dancing and singing live
They sound fine I don't understand?
@@vchaversetv I'm not saying they sound bad. I'm saying they sound fine with mr removed because they're not dancing and moving like some other gg. So it doesn't count.
@@maiherojj It just proves they can sing. Stability isn't everything. It still counts, just doesn't show their singing endurance.
@@gumoa2866 of course all singer can sing just standing or sitting. It is common knowledge.
@@maiherojjeven your Bille eilish lip sync while she just sit, I don’t understand why you have problems when it from K-pop
noob question, how can we tell if they're using pitch corrector?
No, only reverb and echo
They are not, but in this original video it's a full on backtrack you can't really hear their voices. 🤣
What the heck is this? Someone singing or someone chocking? And people really like this song and goes viral? Omg...HYBE please make your girlgroups training vocal again. The downfall of Kpop is begin.....
do current generation really like a song like this?
From now on I trust small company like F&F talents Unis Fighter when it comes to performance singing while dancing so hard❤❤❤
lets be honest here their voice is sucks😂
My god the vocals😢😢😢,
that's hilarious. they really sang over backtrack in a RADIO station
so did the other grps om the show
@@fwhni name them 😂
@@EMGEE864 ITZY, BOYSNEXTDOOR, NMIXX, B1A4, VIVIZ, Wheein from Mamamoo, TXT, Stray Kids, GIDLE, ENHYPEN... The difference among each group in their live performances on the radio is the volume of the backtrack. Some groups' are louder than others but it can also vary through songs, a group can sing live with louder backtrack in one song and in another it's lower or none at all. The group themselves don't get a say in whether they want the backtrack or not or how loud they want it though, it's the shows, companies, or both that choose how high they want to crank the backtrack, sometimes specifically tune the volumes of members' mics too to accommodate for certain members because not all members are equal in terms of vocality. Although I did notice that beliftgroups' backtracks are kinda loud but it's no surprise there, belift is certainly... a company lol
why hybe loves debuting group that are not stable in vocal like there's two gg with crack voice and they helped by other members is it only one or two member that good in singing???? sihyuk and hybe you're so embarrassing
its sad to see a group who cant sing getting this much praise and winning
This is not a matter of hating groups who cannot sing. Actually, it's more like they can sing BUT just ordinary vocals like everyone else. There is very little sound dynamics in their vocals, some vocal skills but unimpressive. They all sound the same, very bland, no power. Playing it safe with their garden variety vocals.
1 minute in and I don't get why everyone is so mad. Sure, they make mistakes and this doesn't sound very pleasant (well, even Mamamoo songs don't feel the same acapella), but it's not that terrible. I heard how bad Illit girls were from other k-pop fans and was expecting something much worse, yet they were actually pretty fine. But I agree that Hybe is almost completely ignoring idols' vocal skills. This company also needs to stop debuting minors. These premature groups didn't even have enough time to develop their vocals.
too powerful on the autotune
What auto tune?
@@vchaversetv can't you hear it? I'm pretty sure 2 was singing live 3 was backuped with autotune, you can hear the difference
@@asdasd-fu3gz bruh they literally sound the same just like when they sing in runext lmao
AUTOTUNE AT ITS BEST
@@akharimaeda wow... maybe your ears has full of wax bro.. look at the reaction of the people on comments, that says something
this MR HAS VOICE CORRECTOR ADDED. STOP PLAYING WITH US
Why is there an MR removed for something that's supposed to show off live vocals? Omg this is crazy
Sings better than izone, ive, aespa, fromis, baemon, le sserafim and red velvet. And their visuals is top 0.00001 in kpop. Wonyoung will wet herself if she meet them
HAHAHAHAHA
I love Minju voice
Being cute doesn't add to the quality of their singing🙃
Moka shouldn't debut no voice at all dang
I feel sorry for these girls looks like they're still practicing 😂😅, except for Minju she's the only one who can really sing right! Tsk2!!
only the second girl can sing in this video
I have to come here becuz the original video has way too many backing track and is heavily polished
PreciousWonhee !!
This is a sign to look for another group from a small company who has a good quality in their singging vocal.
I can only hear minju and wonhee's singing
I feel like only Minju and Yunah can sing while the others are there just for the dance and visual
They have potential but usually this is what I would say to people before debut.
Moka's voice on tomboy cover is so good wtf happened to this
😍😍😍
Wonhee and minjoo
I thought my phone got muted. So i go to comment section. What is this
Moka 🥲🥲
Overhyped group as always
Fortunate they came from Hybe .. who can buy good songs .. 💯
สภาพคือไม่ไหวเลย เป็นแค่เกิร์ลกรุ๊ปเสียงสังเคราะห์
It is suggested to watch Dreamcatcher Primavera performance to clean your ear😂. Btw please make an MR Remove for Dreamcatcher Primavera, the one thats uploaded by Morbo 🙏😭
"who's gonna sing?"
IllIt gonna sing ❤
Like how they sang this part " "