It's crazy... Radio shows used to be the platform for idols to prove their singing skills. Now even radio shows aren't safe from lip syncing or pitch alteration. Modern KPOP is really regressing the industry. Edit: no one said lip syncing is a new concept. I'm talking about how radio shows rarely, if ever, allowed lip syncs or this much vocal alterations. These girls aren't just singing over a backtrack. There's very clear post-processing being done and fans are delusional if they try to deny it.
It's also crazy how y'all can't still differentiate lip sync from live w/ backtrack🥹 Or do y'all expect them to also sing the edited parts like the "you you you you you" part🥲🥲
Hi, I'm new to k-pop and always see or hear comments like this. So could you explain why modern kpop is bad and also recommend some good girl k-pop groups?
@@inacio6030I’m pretty sure the reason there are so many bad gg’s is because training isn’t the same as it was for previous years, like there isn’t proper vocal training anymore and that is the down fall for many gg’s. Anyways the gg’s I would recommend are Itzy,Aespa,Stayc,babymonster,new jeans,twice,gidle,IVE and girls generation are really talented groups with good singers! Hope this helps❤❤
윤아가 원래는 파워풀한 목소리를 가진 멤버였는데 오디션 프로그램 출연 당시 '우주를 건너' 미션곡을 불러야 하는 걸 계기로 목소리가 달라졌어요 원래부터 목소리가 예쁜 것보다도 노력해서 예쁜 목소리를 내기에 더욱 정제된 좋은 목소리가 나오는 것 같아요 윤아 우주를 건너 영상으로 한 번 찾아 보시길 추천 드려요
@@긍정의손바닥 아마 윤아라면 그림체가 같아지려고 노력할 거예요 그러기 위해서 자신을 죽이려고 하지 않고 보컬에 변화를 준 것처럼 자신이 가진 큰 키 늘씬한 몸매 예쁜 얼굴 등 많은 장점을 이용해서 자신을 돋보이게 하고 그룹의 매력을 한층 더 끌어올렸으면 좋겠어요 윤아 별명이 치타고 맹수 닮았다는 말을 많이 듣는다는데 그런 이미지와 멀어지도록 표정 연습을 해 주었으면 하는
@@jayjoswasabi4945lmao wtf lol. If you think they actually sound like this you’re drunk af… they literally came in at a wrong timing… first of all and second, this shit just sounded pre recorded
Because ILLIT has gained so much popularity in China, there are attempts within China to erase ILLIT's presence as part of their efforts to diminish Korea's influence under communism. They are trying to tarnish ILLIT's image by labeling it as a copycat or claiming that it cannot perform live. While foreign fans may not be familiar with this, Korean fans are very used to the Chinese government's moves to keep us in check. Korean dramas, songs, movies, culture, and history unite the younger generation and evoke a sense of freedom, which is enough to cause the collapse of Chinese communism. For countries living in democracy, Korean content is a channel of communication and a part of our memories. However, for Chinese communism, it poses a risk of regime collapse.
I just watched BM performance here and come here if they really match the hype and yup this is very backtrack heavy! 👀 They are jusr whispering at the microphones. Only one girl i see that has a little power on singing. But this is all backtrack.😅
Minju is gonna make me stan them fr. Such a gorgeous and unique vocal color. It's Iroha standing next to Minju right? She has a really pretty falsetto.
@@Jiminbonito1995_ si estan cantando pero el AR esta super alto tanto que su voz no se escucha por lo que no cuent en si como Live, ya que es mas AR que su voz en vivo
Yunah has a deeper husky voice, while minju has that sweet husk almost “cursive singing” vibe. Wonhee’s voice is so pure and moka has a cute nasally almost baby voice. Iroha does her thing too. I didn’t see it at first but they fit well so together
Because ILLIT has gained so much popularity in China, there are attempts within China to erase ILLIT's presence as part of their efforts to diminish Korea's influence under communism. They are trying to tarnish ILLIT's image by labeling it as a copycat or claiming that it cannot perform live. While foreign fans may not be familiar with this, Korean fans are very used to the Chinese government's moves to keep us in check. Korean dramas, songs, movies, culture, and history unite the younger generation and evoke a sense of freedom, which is enough to cause the collapse of Chinese communism. For countries living in democracy, Korean content is a channel of communication and a part of our memories. However, for Chinese communism, it poses a risk of regime collapse.
엠넷 데뷔쇼 볼 때만 해도 안 그랬는데 가만히 서서 라이브 무대하는 거 보니까 알유넥에서 매 라운드마다 무대하고 탈락하는 친구들 지켜 보면서 울고 그거 보면서 같이 울고 응원하고 하던 날들이 떠올라서 울컥.. 정말 잔인한 오디션이라고 느꼈는데 다 이겨내고 이렇게 좋은 모습으로 팬들 앞에 서 주어서 너무 예쁘고.. 보고 싶었어 정말 데뷔 너무너무 축하해
im inlove with minju's vocals! its seriously the best! it made me watched all their performances and now i say she is one of my ult idols i love her sm
@@tanlafuvoTrue. Vocal range of Moka and Iroha are below the standard of Minjoo, Wonhee and Yunah. No offense to Japanese vocals but most cases are they weaker than a average Korean vocal. It's just that Koreans in the idol scene sings better than Japanese idols. If I have to rank current groups with Japanese members in them. Rei > Iroha/Moka > Kazuha > Sakura
They are Great performaners and have nice voice with good song . What else you want?? Now don't say they are not good compared to BM lol. In comparison 1 side is always bad , but in general that is wrong in so many ways.
How cool is Minju? You can see her giving support to Iroha. She has a very nice way about her. I like Yunah voice but she sounded slightly out of key. I was surprised by how good everyone else sounded. Minju is obviously an angel. The rest of them are good enough.
This (lofi x girl anime?) concept fits them so much, I hope they can keep this concept for a long time and not easily go for "girl-crush" so fast 😭 And as expected from a survival show group, their live singing is so good!! ❤
@@urhypeboy lmao, personally i also don't vibe with that concept but no one can deny the fact that many gg tend to change their concepts after debuting. that, and also other 5th gen gg public know atm are probably only baemon & kiss of life, which both are doing girl-crush so... yeah, i just hope they are keeping this concept and make it their identity bcs they fits really well
@@stevenchen9852Do you think you can sing? Couch critic, Aillit has at least achieved something in life, and you're stupidly sitting on the couch and bullying them
@@ilovek-pop-o2o not bullying them but learned music theory as a minor in college while majoring in computer science. I have some experience with music because I worked with a company called soundhound AI. It isn’t that big but I worked to produce music volume so I can understand somethings about how music and pitch/tune works. I listen to kpop as a hobby because I enjoy it and just came across illit singing live. They aren’t on pitch or on tune with their own music which is a massive problem and it’s making kpop look very bad. Not being on pitch with your music is totally fine because I understand for a human being finding the pitch isn’t an easy feat. But not being on tune is just…. Especially with your own music many people can find the tune connected to their voice with the music if they just listen to it 20 or so times. But for illit not singing on tune is a very big problem especially when it’s their job. I can’t imagine someone coming to work for IT and not knowing basic data structure, you’re gonna get fire instantly. Same case here, I’m not trying to disrespect them just to disrespect them. I’m just stating the true. The only girl that was on tune but not on pitch was minju and you can see even just being on tune how much of a difference that is. Vocal range is not my job but I do understand it but I do not need to practice it because it’s not making me money. But for these girls, it’s their job and making them money but they do not practice it. You see the difference
@@ilovek-pop-o2o also I would like to add for their job and even for IT it doesn’t matter if someone knows or don’t know how to do it. The audience is the ones making them money, and have the right to say things about what they’re doing and if it’s good or bad. If a iPhone came out with a dogshit design software engineers aren’t just gonna tell you well you don’t know anything about type script so you don’t have the right to say anything.. so the term couch critic doesn’t make any sense at all.. also do you generally think their singing is acceptable for being already the 5th of kpop….
![쿨룩 LIVE ▷ 아일릿 (ILLIT) ‘Cherish (My Love)’ / [이은지의 가요광장] I KBS 241022 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bC-5kcWFQAM/mqdefault.jpg)
![쿨룩 LIVE ▷ 아일릿 (ILLIT) ‘Cherish (My Love)’ / [이은지의 가요광장] I KBS 241022 방송](/img/tr.png)
It's crazy... Radio shows used to be the platform for idols to prove their singing skills. Now even radio shows aren't safe from lip syncing or pitch alteration. Modern KPOP is really regressing the industry.
Edit: no one said lip syncing is a new concept. I'm talking about how radio shows rarely, if ever, allowed lip syncs or this much vocal alterations. These girls aren't just singing over a backtrack. There's very clear post-processing being done and fans are delusional if they try to deny it.
I could pick up on how edited their voices were going into that mic it was INSANE.
lip sync when ? u slow?
It's also crazy how y'all can't still differentiate lip sync from live w/ backtrack🥹 Or do y'all expect them to also sing the edited parts like the "you you you you you" part🥲🥲
@@mxromeLol they are practically in playback. Really do they need the ar in the radio?? They're only standing.
You mean HYBE is regressing the industry.
If its real voice not recording, their encore will good too..
But you all know how their encore
Its not live...at the beginning of the song u can see wonhee started singing at "im just tryna play it cool"
What do you want them to do. Sing like how they did during their encore, can that even be published😂😂😂
I realized from that that when he said "baby" it was a live recording that was deliberately taken before they sing live
@@AlsiaAmandi Love the side eye the member next to her gives. I don't care tho this song is so amazing!!!!
Hi, I'm new to k-pop and always see or hear comments like this. So could you explain why modern kpop is bad and also recommend some good girl k-pop groups?
@@inacio6030I’m pretty sure the reason there are so many bad gg’s is because training isn’t the same as it was for previous years, like there isn’t proper vocal training anymore and that is the down fall for many gg’s. Anyways the gg’s I would recommend are Itzy,Aespa,Stayc,babymonster,new jeans,twice,gidle,IVE and girls generation are really talented groups with good singers! Hope this helps❤❤
Minju getting recognition for her beautiful voice I'm going to cry. Go Minju!
It's so good! And it sounds great live as well
she deserves it
which is she?
@@jackman4004 the most left one, shirt with lots of writing and skirt
My bias🩵🩵🩵
민주 음색 최고다... 진짜
ㄷㅇ
진짜 ㄹㅇ❤
진짜 너무 좋아요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
역시 와이지 출신ㅋㅋ
@@usor-ti9id2cc9h블링크세요? 데뷔년도부터 블링큰데 로제음색이랑 전혀다른데요
그냥 가수가 살아 있어서 라이브라고 한 것 같습니다.
EXXACTLY
😂😂😂
WAHAHAHAHAH
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
개추 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
윤아는 비주얼이 이 팀에 있기 너무 성숙하다 싶은데 목소리 들으면 반드시 있어야 될 멤버네. 윤아 목소리 되게 예쁘다. 따뜻하고 포근하고 러블리하고 살랑살랑한 느낌이 윤아 파트에서 확 사는 듯
윤아가 원래는 파워풀한 목소리를 가진 멤버였는데 오디션 프로그램 출연 당시 '우주를 건너' 미션곡을 불러야 하는 걸 계기로 목소리가 달라졌어요 원래부터 목소리가 예쁜 것보다도 노력해서 예쁜 목소리를 내기에 더욱 정제된 좋은 목소리가 나오는 것 같아요 윤아 우주를 건너 영상으로 한 번 찾아 보시길 추천 드려요
윤아가 연생들 사이에서 실력 1, 2등하던 애임. 그냥 뭐든 다 잘하는 애라고 보면 됨.
혼자 그림체 너무 다르긴 해요
@@긍정의손바닥 아마 윤아라면 그림체가 같아지려고 노력할 거예요 그러기 위해서 자신을 죽이려고 하지 않고 보컬에 변화를 준 것처럼 자신이 가진 큰 키 늘씬한 몸매 예쁜 얼굴 등 많은 장점을 이용해서 자신을 돋보이게 하고 그룹의 매력을 한층 더 끌어올렸으면 좋겠어요 윤아 별명이 치타고 맹수 닮았다는 말을 많이 듣는다는데 그런 이미지와 멀어지도록 표정 연습을 해 주었으면 하는
영서 있었으면 냥이즈인데 ㅠㅠ...
I can see now why their backtrack was louder than their actual voice.
especially the blue one😂
Its match the lyrics
baby...
"Baby, I'm just trying to play it cool
But I just can't hide that" 😉
LOL
@@arleighburke6692 whaha bruh, I just realized that! Thanks! LoL
Why?😳😳
@@shankseusopp you mean the🐐🐐
이게 무슨 라이브냐;;다시보니까 음원이랑 다른게 없는데?;
라이브 맞는데 멍충아 ㅋ
@@overvieweffect알바야 얼마받고 하냐 나도 실드 잘 칠 자신 있는데 채용좀 해줘
@@네르찌 시급 2만원이다 왜 ㅋ
@@overvieweffect 나 채용좀 해줘…
웬만하면 쉴드 치고 다니는데 이건 안되는듯.. 다른애들은 적게나마 목소리 두개 겹치는데 모카는 부르려는 노력조차 안 하는것 같음... 아예 안들려..립싱크 너무너무 티나...
이게 뭔 라이브야.. 그냥 음원 깔아놓고 같이 부르는거쟎아요.. 첨 시작할때 입도 뻥긋 안했는데 목소리 고대로 다 나오는데…
다들 한통속 사기꾼들임, 사기를 쳐도 1위하면 장땡이란 마인드, 사기범죄1위국가 대한민국의 현실
뉴진스 르세라핌 아일릿 다 라이브 필요한 무대 이따구로 채움 ㅋㅋ 졸부 회사가 만드는 오합지졸 멤버들
ㄹㅇ.. 모카는 해린이 닮아서 첨에 호감이었는데 노래 졸라못하네
음원이 라이브였네 ㅋㅋㅋ
요즘 아이돌 노래실력이 너무 없어요
Just found out that Minjoo is a former YG trainee whose vocals are extraordinary, the others are like backing vocals
They must be back dancer soloist minju
Hahahha vocals? It's a 1 woman group.
@@BoyKoikingFor real. Their encores sucks, except for Minju's vocals.
not even backing vocals bruh 😭
@@navidawg165 hahahha dont be harsh bro their fans might bite you😂😂😂
The backtrack sound too loud... i barelly can hear them O,o
minju and moka are so pretty
I see Minju, I click ❤
Same
If this is even live, their encores should have sound the same.😂
they dont dance here ofc itll be stable. use ur brain 😭
they also dont dance during encores
@@jayjoswasabi4945they dont dance during encores. the fck u saying
@@jayjoswasabi4945lmao wtf lol. If you think they actually sound like this you’re drunk af… they literally came in at a wrong timing… first of all and second, this shit just sounded pre recorded
Hear from the first start. She failed
0:07 0:14 minju and iroha lines are just heaven
good luck girls i miss the rest of r u next girls :(
AR 다 깔아놓고 하는데 라이브라고 하면 안되지요... 너무 당당하게 풀로 깔아버리니 도리어 살짝 당황스러운;;
MR 이겠찌
@@jamespark1582ㅋㅋㅋmr은 순수 반주구요 ar은 가수목소리가 깔리는거에요;;
Because ILLIT has gained so much popularity in China, there are attempts within China to erase ILLIT's presence as part of their efforts to diminish Korea's influence under communism. They are trying to tarnish ILLIT's image by labeling it as a copycat or claiming that it cannot perform live. While foreign fans may not be familiar with this, Korean fans are very used to the Chinese government's moves to keep us in check. Korean dramas, songs, movies, culture, and history unite the younger generation and evoke a sense of freedom, which is enough to cause the collapse of Chinese communism.
For countries living in democracy, Korean content is a channel of communication and a part of our memories. However, for Chinese communism, it poses a risk of regime collapse.
@@jamespark1582바본가..
I just watched BM performance here and come here if they really match the hype and yup this is very backtrack heavy! 👀 They are jusr whispering at the microphones. Only one girl i see that has a little power on singing. But this is all backtrack.😅
Same 😂
The backtrack is way louder
the one can sing is Minju ex trainee from yg
she was unselected in baby monster project
Why don't we compare red velvet and BP? Now don't run out of vocals cause Iren solos BP lol. Stop crying because you lost
@@Rita-Vela1what about Iroha and Yunha they are also singing pretty well.
@@__h__- they sing like speaking fast and you can watch other performance of them
0:13 막내 짱짱한 라이브 🥹 목소리가 맑다 맑어
시작할때 원희보다 음악이 먼저 시작했는데 이정도면 라이브가아니라 걍 ar90%론데ㄹㅇ
Yes
100ar
딴팀거 들어보니 숨소리 들리는데 얘넨 모카 입열때 헉 숨 소리 들린 뒤로 음소거됨 자기들이 안부르는 거임 지금 춤만 추고
모카 부분 ar 틀어논거 실화냐
모카 🐐 인건 다들 아는 사실이니............😂😂 완전 음치
Minju is not only very prertty but I also like her voiceee
0:06 민주가 도입부에서 확 잡아주고 가는게 진짜 대박임 음색 너무 좋아
모카 존나 눈에 띈다 체형이나 얼굴이 트렌디한데 귀여운 느낌을 잘 살리는 듯
옷이 한몫하는데
@@이준서-d1h 응 니가 입으면 바로 광녀됨
저 안경이 한몫함
딱 내생각이랑 같음
힙합임
Minju is gonna make me stan them fr. Such a gorgeous and unique vocal color. It's Iroha standing next to Minju right? She has a really pretty falsetto.
Yeah, it's Iroha.
Wonhee is the middle one the third
Fifth is Yunah
The other three still get confused🤦♂️
It’s Minju, Iroha, Wonhee, Moka and Yunah in order
Can someone tell who is the girl on the thumnail she is cute 💗
@@sameerdanishlohano5922 Minju ❤️
민주 음색 ㅁㅊ다…😍
이정도면 이젠 벙어리도 가수할 기세 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
민주 모카가 나라 구한다
ㅇㅈ
미모즈 💖
@@ginetama922 일상생활 가능?
@@usor-ti9id2cc9h 능지 진짜 ㅈ박았나 위에서 욕 쳐먹었으면 멈출줄 알아야지 또 뇌절치네
무대봤는데 민주 모카가 눈에 젤 들어오던데 똑같이 생각하는 사람이 많구나
민주 목소리 너무 좋다 음색이 잘 드러나는 곡도 많이많이 불러줬으면 좋겠음!!
Ar인데요..? 목소리 들려용. ?
다 깔고 부를거면 라디오를 왜나오냐 도대체 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
홍보하려고 나오는거지 멍충아 ㅋ
Minju voice is beautiful
I will never be able to express how much I ADORE minju’s voice her voice will go so far trust
신인그룹 Arlit 이네요. 모든 무대에서 ar로 노래 부른다는 코첼라핌의 후배
웃긴데 댓이없냐 ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
뉴진스 아이브는 다른줄아냐? ㅋ 도긴개긴이야 ㅋ
@@overvieweffect 적어도 주제는 알아서 누구처럼 코첼라는 안나감ㅋㅋ
@@그것이약속이니까좆루팔루자는 주제를 아는 애들이 나가는곳이냐? ㅋ 4세대는 그냥 물로켓이야...
@@overvieweffect 뉴진스 아이브는 라이브 잘한다고 한적도 없는데 얘 왜 지혼자 커버치고 난리임?ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
진짜 중독되서 계속 듣고 있다가 음방 앵콜듣고 짜게 식어버림..라디오 AR 개 사기네..
근데 아이돌 라이브 들으려고 듣는거 아니자나요 ㅎㅎ 얘들 이쁘고 춤 잘추고 노래 좋으면 됐음. 애초에 아이돌에게 라이브까지 기대하진 않음. 물론 잘하면 좋겠지만.
@@산_타는백수 응 너만 그래 ㅋㅋ
@@산_타는백수가만히 서서 부르는데 라디오에서도 립싱크 할거면 도대체 라이브는 어디서 할건지........라디오에서 립싱크 하는거 처음 봄
천하의 블핑도 라디오에서 저랬어 ㅋ
@@산_타는백수동의하고 나도 항상 립싱크하든 ar쓰든 걍 듣는데 그럴거면 라이브 무대를 나가지 말든가 라이브 한다고 거짓말을 하지 말든가 하면 좋겠음
이걸 라이브라 할수있나..
No
Yes
Si, porque están en una radio y esta en vivo
@@Jiminbonito1995_ si estan cantando pero el AR esta super alto tanto que su voz no se escucha por lo que no cuent en si como Live, ya que es mas AR que su voz en vivo
@@Blackhairmlssimp Sigue estando en vivo aunque esa cosa esté alta, se siguen escuchando sus voces
베몬꺼 라디오 보고오니 하필 얘네냐 ㅋㅋ립싱크 잘한다
립싱크 세계에서 제일 잘 치는듯.......통인데예
Minju's voice so good
아일릿은 이제 도입부는 민주확정이다.. 집중확됨
로제 창법 좀 거북한디
@@VirginPride 와이지 출신이니까 그럴 수
밖에....
@@VirginPride쟤 말고 가수가 있냐..
윤아도 그나마넘좋음@@jamesbond-sg3tm
대놓고 사기를 치시겠다?
Minju's voice is angelic like her visual.. She is too Gorgeous!!
민주 음색 너무 좋고 중간중간에 모카 목소리로 나오는 부분 너무 좋음.
아 진짜요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ?
뭐 얘는 막귀냐? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 모카래 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@homi3274 어 앵콜 라이브 전이야
@@cmm612 미안하다
뭐 이거는 air 90프로니까 진실을 알기 전까지는 오해할수있지
The operator work too hard. Good job. He needs raise.
Minju's visuals are some-thing else! Wow 😍 Such a unique beauty and has a lovely voice!
원희는 볼때마다 넘넘 귀여움.....
표정쓰는거랑 체스쳐가 신인같지 않게 넘넘 능숙해서 더 귀여움.....
알유넥때는 표정 굳어있고 뚝딱대는게 눈에 너무 잘보였는데 그새 엄청 늘음..대박이다
원희.. 모카짱.... 카와이..
0:19 Minju nodding here with a smile comes across to me like "Well done girls, you're not doing too bad🫳😅" 😂😂😂
Yunah’s voice sound like Naeun Apink ❤
and IVE'S yujin
@@zzflvrno ive yujin is more strong, yunah tone is more softer just like apink naeun
오~~ 인정
Also sounds like jessica jung
And also jessica
첨 보는 것 보니 신인그룹인 것 같은데 다른 분들도 목소리 좋지만 개인적으로 윤아 저분 목소리가 뭔가 젤 끌리는 느낌이네
아....이걸 라이브라고 하는구나... 기가막혀 말이다...안나온다
Glass girl voice is soo pretty❤
Her name is moka 💕💕
Moka fits this concept so well..
She’s sooooooo lovely
yes. it is so addicted right? 😂
im in love her voice!!
im officially an moka bias
Yunah has a deeper husky voice, while minju has that sweet husk almost “cursive singing” vibe. Wonhee’s voice is so pure and moka has a cute nasally almost baby voice. Iroha does her thing too. I didn’t see it at first but they fit well so together
이게 라이브면 음방 앵콜실력은 대체뭐냐.......
The couch critic again..
Because ILLIT has gained so much popularity in China, there are attempts within China to erase ILLIT's presence as part of their efforts to diminish Korea's influence under communism. They are trying to tarnish ILLIT's image by labeling it as a copycat or claiming that it cannot perform live. While foreign fans may not be familiar with this, Korean fans are very used to the Chinese government's moves to keep us in check. Korean dramas, songs, movies, culture, and history unite the younger generation and evoke a sense of freedom, which is enough to cause the collapse of Chinese communism.
For countries living in democracy, Korean content is a channel of communication and a part of our memories. However, for Chinese communism, it poses a risk of regime collapse.
연습을 많이 했으니까요❤
다른 댓글에서 봤는데 아직 연습생 해야되는 애들이 아이돌판에 내던져졌다는게 딱 맞는 표현인것 같다
선배가수랑 똑같네요...ㅜ
minju's voice though? slayy minjuu
엠넷 데뷔쇼 볼 때만 해도 안 그랬는데
가만히 서서 라이브 무대하는 거 보니까
알유넥에서 매 라운드마다 무대하고
탈락하는 친구들 지켜 보면서 울고
그거 보면서 같이 울고 응원하고
하던 날들이 떠올라서 울컥..
정말 잔인한 오디션이라고 느꼈는데
다 이겨내고 이렇게 좋은 모습으로 팬들 앞에 서 주어서 너무 예쁘고.. 보고 싶었어 정말 데뷔 너무너무 축하해
좋아하는 가수들 라디오 라이브 하는 영상들 여러개 봤었는데 이렇게 AR 심하게 티나는건 처음 보네. 라디오 라이브는 다 진짜인줄 알았는데 얘네 때문에 진짜가 아닌것도 있구나 알게됨
ウォニとイロハがニコニコし合ってんのガチ微笑ましい
HYBE'S rookie groups are talented
BoyNextDoor,TWS ,ILLIT
I totally agree
My favs
Enhypen is nuts too, not a rookie no more though!
&TEAM 😢
tws is pledis
걸그룹보면서 ㅆ 욕 밖에 안나오는건 얘네가 처음이다.
신선하다 유치원생 수준도 안되는 라이브
im inlove with minju's vocals! its seriously the best! it made me watched all their performances and now i say she is one of my ult idols i love her sm
Love minju’s voice such pretty voices
moka's presence is insane, even in this performance my eyes instantly go towards her, her expressions and voice are so cute
I'm already a fan of these girls! And Moka wearing glasses is so Awwww❤
Moka and Minju have the most aesthetically pleasing voices out of all the rookie groups rn. i fr feel like im floating every time they sing 🤩😭
Real
@@tanlafuvoTrue. Vocal range of Moka and Iroha are below the standard of Minjoo, Wonhee and Yunah. No offense to Japanese vocals but most cases are they weaker than a average Korean vocal. It's just that Koreans in the idol scene sings better than Japanese idols.
If I have to rank current groups with Japanese members in them.
Rei > Iroha/Moka > Kazuha > Sakura
@@hbrantdon't sleep on Ito Miyu's vocals from Limelight. I'd say she's more stable than Rei when standing, not quite there yet in moving choreo yet
@@thewolfblazer7104 Never heard of that group. Must be a underground group in K-pop.
Bro has never heard Hanni and Haerin
첫장면 딱봤는데 헤드셋 정리하느라 입모양 안움직였는데 노래가 저절로나오네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
원래 ar깔고함
원희 진짜 스타성 있는 상임.. 너무 이뽀
진짜 실력이 뭐니ㅠㅜ
If it's their real voice, not recording..
Their encore must be good and better, but you all know how their encore😅
없음
They are Great performaners and have nice voice with good song . What else you want?? Now don't say they are not good compared to BM lol. In comparison 1 side is always bad , but in general that is wrong in so many ways.
라디오 라이브 영상들 많이 봤지만 립싱크는 처음 보네........완전 사기꾼 걸그룹
How cool is Minju? You can see her giving support to Iroha. She has a very nice way about her. I like Yunah voice but she sounded slightly out of key. I was surprised by how good everyone else sounded. Minju is obviously an angel. The rest of them are good enough.
Minju sounds really good live. Wow, is she the main vocal?
Minju voice so beautiful
The first part the "baby" hindi pa siya ready pero meron na agad hahaha
라이브인척 하는 AR립싱크. 1위 앵콜 라이브덕에 뽀록났쥬
얘네는 사기꾼이다. 라디오에서 립싱크 하는거 처음 봤음
캬 민주 음색ㅠㅠ🩷
다시 연습생하러가야할듯
민주 진짜 음색도 얼굴도 계속 눈길이감
Moka with glasses 🥰🥰🥰
shes so cute
신의 목소리네요
한번에 두개의 목소리가 나오니
다른 멤버들은 눈 어디다가 둘지 모르는데 원희는 계속 카메라를 보네 풋풋하면서도 카메라 겁 안 내는것 같아서 좋음 연습생 1개월차에 데뷔한 데는 이유가 있는듯...
Many said Wonhee looks Wonyoung and acting like one.
아무리 아이돌이래도 라디오 라이브에 AR 95%는 좀 심한 거 같음
기초에 파데에 립에 볼터치에 눈썹까지 그리고선 속눈썹 안 붙였으니 노메이크업 이라고 하는 꼴임.
엔믹스는 차트100에도 못들어가는데 왜 라이브 따짐?
흠. 반박하기 버겁다
가수냐 그게 ㅋㅋㅋヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲヲ 댄서지 투자하지마라
ar 아닌데 ㅋㅋ
ㄹㅇ
아니 입만 뻥긋하면 우짜노ㅋㅋㅋ
This (lofi x girl anime?) concept fits them so much, I hope they can keep this concept for a long time and not easily go for "girl-crush" so fast 😭 And as expected from a survival show group, their live singing is so good!! ❤
Who says girl crush is still a thing in kpop?
@@urhypeboy lmao, personally i also don't vibe with that concept but no one can deny the fact that many gg tend to change their concepts after debuting. that, and also other 5th gen gg public know atm are probably only baemon & kiss of life, which both are doing girl-crush so... yeah, i just hope they are keeping this concept and make it their identity bcs they fits really well
the genre is called plugg&b. you're welcome
@@Sundae-ew4sx ooh, i didn't know that haha, thanku!
this is a scam, they use AR. it's not live lol
This is NOT live though. There is just so much backing vocals.
What i dislike about kpop nowadays is the backing track is so loud you can't even hear their actual voices anymore.
민주 진짜 이쁘다
너같은 흑우땜에 이런것도 가수를한다
가수는 실력이 되면 청자의 귀에 어떻게 들릴지를 생각하며 마음으로 노래 부른다
Aha. I thought, "Okay, maybe finally I'll change my mind about ILL'IT if they can perform this well." Yeah, well done in lypsimcing.😑
윤아 뭔가 아나운서상이다!!
girls are their way !!! fighting ILLIT!!!
All i heard was backtrack. It was hard to identify their live vocals
보컬 음색 좋은거 보소… 어쩜 저 비주얼과 목소리들을 모아둔거죠
Yes their vocal tone are so pretty…each of them
they’re like a choir of angels lolol❤️❤️
기계음색이겠지ㅋㅋㅋ
이사람 개멍청하네 ㅋㅋㅋ 아일릿이 라이브한거 한번도 못보신듯 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 어쩜 저런 목소리들을 모아뒀녜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@homi3274 야 똥멍청이 조용히 해
Why they don't sound like that on encore? 😊
😂 it's all backtrack
I'm curious how this is live the backtrack is too loud are they real singers? And they always won in music show I find it odd
민주가 오진다 얼굴도 피지컬도 음색도 라이브도 전부 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 대놓고 에이스멤..... 모카도 예쁘구
모카짱.... 카와이...
피지컬이 ㅇㄷ있음
@@homi3274 예쁘다 칭찬 중인데 라이브 얘긴 왜 하노 사람들 다 알음 모카 노래 못하는 거 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@nothinghave1094 모카만 못하나요?ㅎㅎ 다 못하는구만 ㅋ
@@digkang33 앵간하게 다 하는데?
Minju's voice is so crazy good, so clear and fresh!
I'm waiting for Illit to perform on coachella 🥴
Can't wait to hear more louder backtrack while performing
That’s not even the problem. They’re not even singing..
@@stevenchen9852Do you think you can sing? Couch critic, Aillit has at least achieved something in life, and you're stupidly sitting on the couch and bullying them
@@ilovek-pop-o2o not bullying them but learned music theory as a minor in college while majoring in computer science. I have some experience with music because I worked with a company called soundhound AI. It isn’t that big but I worked to produce music volume so I can understand somethings about how music and pitch/tune works. I listen to kpop as a hobby because I enjoy it and just came across illit singing live. They aren’t on pitch or on tune with their own music which is a massive problem and it’s making kpop look very bad. Not being on pitch with your music is totally fine because I understand for a human being finding the pitch isn’t an easy feat. But not being on tune is just…. Especially with your own music many people can find the tune connected to their voice with the music if they just listen to it 20 or so times. But for illit not singing on tune is a very big problem especially when it’s their job. I can’t imagine someone coming to work for IT and not knowing basic data structure, you’re gonna get fire instantly. Same case here, I’m not trying to disrespect them just to disrespect them. I’m just stating the true. The only girl that was on tune but not on pitch was minju and you can see even just being on tune how much of a difference that is. Vocal range is not my job but I do understand it but I do not need to practice it because it’s not making me money. But for these girls, it’s their job and making them money but they do not practice it. You see the difference
@@ilovek-pop-o2o also I would like to add for their job and even for IT it doesn’t matter if someone knows or don’t know how to do it. The audience is the ones making them money, and have the right to say things about what they’re doing and if it’s good or bad. If a iPhone came out with a dogshit design software engineers aren’t just gonna tell you well you don’t know anything about type script so you don’t have the right to say anything.. so the term couch critic doesn’t make any sense at all.. also do you generally think their singing is acceptable for being already the 5th of kpop….
боже.. если их пропустят на Коачеллу, я повешусь. есть огромное количество групп, которых действительно стоит пригласить туда, но это не ILLIT.
Is it really live if they have a backing track? Lol
솔직히 하이브 내에서 라이브 잘하는 여돌 몇명 빼고 없는 것 같은데 얘네는 오디션 때부터 보컬 논란 없었어서 넘 좋고 젤 잘됐으면 좋겠다 얼굴도 예쁘구 하니 이제 실력 없는 그룹들보다 해외에도 안 쪽팔리게 실력 좋은 애들이 잘됐으면 좋겠음 ㅜㅜ
애초에 하이브에 걸그룹 별로 없지 않음? 뉴진스 르세라핌 프미나고 실력 논란있는건 르세라핌 아닌강 프미나 실력은 모름
@@user-ru8gb4ks9k프미나 정도면 잘하는 것 같다
@@YEOLMOOyam폐급ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
르세라핌 ㅋ😂
Nj has good live vocals fromis 8
It's scary how our future will be full of singers just whispering and completely autotuned.
dont worry, we got babymonster
We still got babymonster kiss of life unis vvup and many boy groups
we still got many groups from small companies that slay live vocals, people just don't appreciate them.
Finally someone mentions kiss of life! Lmao I thought their fans didn’t exist
Lol, is it the couch critic again who has achieved nothing in life? Oh, that's it.
何より楽曲が良い🎵そしてILLITの雰囲気にマッチ、間違いなくHITする😊
minju is amazing
How is Minju both the visual and vocal... is she also the main dancer?
원희는 대놓고 계속 이끌려서 보게되네 진짜 아이돌그자체...
ㄹㅇ 완전 동의합니다 진짜
원희.. 모카짱.... 카와이..
너무 부담스럽게 생겼는데; 행동이나 제스처도 "나 너무 귀여워서 미치겠지?" 하는 느낌이라 보고 있으면 항마력 고갈됨