I’ve been wondering as to how we explain our clean sheets, and aside from the move to 6 for tonali to control the game and shield the defence, I wonder whether having a keeper with better feet at the back almost stops attacks coming back at us and putting us under the pressure we concede goals under. I know dubravka hasn’t been tested much, but is his inclusion actually prevent shots coming at him because we can now play out to a dominant midfield?
@ naturally. My point is that whilst Pope is a good shot stopper, he’s not been needed because we’ve not had shots to deal with. My theory from there is that we’ve not had shots to deal with because the midfield has been doing much better and having a better ball player at GK has meant we aren’t bringing pressure onto ourselves
Someone tell me why does Saudi super league clubs help the cartel 6 by taking their players, which helps them with PSR. It seems counter productive for Newcastle.
Happy new year all. Pope being away and having dubravka in has brought it home that we just cannot go on with pope, he looks to me utterly shot since his injury woes, and his inability with his feet makes him a liability. We get a top drawer keeper and a similar quality right winger, and with a bit of luck around injuries, we’ll get top 4 and I did not think I’d be saying that! 😊
I think would be a positive signing for us, I like Pope but I do get nervous just watching sometimes so goodness knows how our back line feels. As said I like Pope but we are not going to proceed as a club by winning personality popularity contests. all the best for the new year everyone.
So how much are we prepared to pay for him?? £30m? £40m? £45m? There is no way he would go for a similar fee to Trafford, as he has much more (and better) experience. Plus we have competition for his signature.
Kelleher could be a great signing for us. He hasn’t been linked I don’t think but the player I’ve always thought would be quality for us is Marco Carnesecchi from Atlanta. Looks like exactly what we need and is young enough to have time to develop under howe’s game. Hopefully Tonali has some Italian pull in the matter as well if it ever came to light. Happy New Year Chris and Mark and let’s gan get some silverware this time round 🎉🎉
Would he not cost more than the lad from Burnley? I would take Trafford ahead of Kellerher. Cole Palmer said last year that he is the best keeper he has ever played with which tells me he must be special
I think Kelleher would be a great addition, very inexperienced game wise for his age, but any goalkeeper would find alisson hard to dislodge, so he's literally been learning from one of the very best in the world. I think for the fee he would command, I think he's a huge upgrade on all our current options, and even though he didn't have his best game recently against us, every player has a bad game so I don't think people should dwell on that, I would take Trafford as a #2 though, but would you wanna spend potentially up to £40m on 2 gks. But kelleher and Trafford for me, are an upgrade on Pope and dubravka. And keep signing players like ruddy for 3rd choice because you never really pay anything for a 3rd choice. And our #1 & #2 positions could be sorted for potentially 5-10yrs. Absolutely gutted/fuming we missed the boat on Mamardashvili though, what a keep he is.
Agree we need a new young goalie who Eddie can coach and mould into the best ball playing goalie in the world who firs our system. Pope hasn’t been the same since his shoulder injury but will do us for now, Dubravka I would like to see gone but we need him up to the summer unless Eddie is willing to give Vlakodimos a go. As for the other 27 goalies, get rid.
I've thought highly of Kelleher for some time and thought he'd be great for us, however we already have 6 'keepers on the books already, I think we must be keen on buying all the worlds goalies! Having said that, we do need a clear out this month before buying another one, but Dubs is doing a great job, who, out of the other 5 is his understudy right now? I hope we don't go for Trafford. Kelleher is head and shoulders better than him.
I know Dubs is leaving, but so many keepers is a head scratcher. Just the last few weeks results I'm not going to question Eddie's ambitions again. He's definitely a winner. We definitely can't run Eddie out of town. He's got a high ceiling.
I was just thinking earlier today that with Marmadashvilli’s imminent arrival on Merseyside, Kelleher will” be surplus to requirements. Irish goalkeepers have served Newcastle very well in the past, Iam McFaul and Shay Given being two fine examples.
I do feel we need to sort out the keeper problem . If we can shift Shakadeemus and pliers. Kellerher is a good keeper and i dont rate Trafford. I agree he is living on past young glories and to me is another woodman type keeper who isnt good enough for the demands of the premier league .
We definitely need a new no.1 but it won't be kelleher sadly, because as soon as other top teams are interested we can't compete with guaranteed champions league football/wages etc.
Kelliher would be a great signing. Really hope we can do a deal - great shot stopper, better distribution than Pope too. He’s experienced & young enough to carve out a great career with us. 🤞🤞🤞
Pope has become a liability and I’ll be honest since dubravka come in been brilliant with feet and shot stopping so far fair play to him but we need better pope can be a sub from here on out x
Nice for sharing Bro..
I’ve been wondering as to how we explain our clean sheets, and aside from the move to 6 for tonali to control the game and shield the defence, I wonder whether having a keeper with better feet at the back almost stops attacks coming back at us and putting us under the pressure we concede goals under. I know dubravka hasn’t been tested much, but is his inclusion actually prevent shots coming at him because we can now play out to a dominant midfield?
Go look at how many shots on target we have actually faced recently its not many so that helps with the clean sheets
@ naturally. My point is that whilst Pope is a good shot stopper, he’s not been needed because we’ve not had shots to deal with. My theory from there is that we’ve not had shots to deal with because the midfield has been doing much better and having a better ball player at GK has meant we aren’t bringing pressure onto ourselves
when pope is in goal i watch the toon from behind the settee
So does our defence
The fact is, defence look much less edgy recently
Pope reminds me of how bad Grobbelaar was when he joined Liverpool
Love it
Imagine if we played a dalek or a cyberman in goal. “EX-TER-MINATE!!!” And the ball would go “poof” in a flash of fire and smoke as it got vaporised.
Great vid as always Chris. I agree “Kevin” will be a fantastic signing for us !
Happy New Year and here’s to 10k 👍🏼
Not another friggin keeper😂R bloody W please🎉
Very good keeper, inheritor of the crown of Shay.
Just watched his highlights. Hopefully, Shay is in his ear.
@@marcusorealllyAye that would be good Marcus.
Agreed
Someone tell me why does Saudi super league clubs help the cartel 6 by taking their players, which helps them with PSR. It seems counter productive for Newcastle.
Not another goal keeper.We have frigging 5 on the books man...
Spewing we missed Mamadashvilli but Kelleher good long term
Happy new year all. Pope being away and having dubravka in has brought it home that we just cannot go on with pope, he looks to me utterly shot since his injury woes, and his inability with his feet makes him a liability. We get a top drawer keeper and a similar quality right winger, and with a bit of luck around injuries, we’ll get top 4 and I did not think I’d be saying that! 😊
Happy new year to all the amazing magpies from Saudi Arabia, I hope this transfer window address the RW and striker problem
No chance we get Kelleher in January with Liverpool pushing for the title. The summer would be a great signing
I think would be a positive signing for us, I like Pope but I do get nervous just watching sometimes so goodness knows how our back line feels. As said I like Pope but we are not going to proceed as a club by winning personality popularity contests. all the best for the new year everyone.
I know Traford (sp) is more expensive, BUT he will be a superstar, and we can have him for a decade plus. Just my opinion. Be well my friends!!!
So how much are we prepared to pay for him??
£30m? £40m? £45m? There is no way he would go for a similar fee to Trafford, as he has much more (and better) experience. Plus we have competition for his signature.
Kelleher could be a great signing for us. He hasn’t been linked I don’t think but the player I’ve always thought would be quality for us is Marco Carnesecchi from Atlanta. Looks like exactly what we need and is young enough to have time to develop under howe’s game. Hopefully Tonali has some Italian pull in the matter as well if it ever came to light. Happy New Year Chris and Mark and let’s gan get some silverware this time round 🎉🎉
I’d have this lad in a heartbeat
This will probably be a move we make in the summer. Itll be easier for Liverpool to sell him then, and we also wont buy 3 keepers in 2 windows haha
Would he not cost more than the lad from Burnley? I would take Trafford ahead of Kellerher. Cole Palmer said last year that he is the best keeper he has ever played with which tells me he must be special
I think Kelleher would be a great addition, very inexperienced game wise for his age, but any goalkeeper would find alisson hard to dislodge, so he's literally been learning from one of the very best in the world. I think for the fee he would command, I think he's a huge upgrade on all our current options, and even though he didn't have his best game recently against us, every player has a bad game so I don't think people should dwell on that, I would take Trafford as a #2 though, but would you wanna spend potentially up to £40m on 2 gks. But kelleher and Trafford for me, are an upgrade on Pope and dubravka. And keep signing players like ruddy for 3rd choice because you never really pay anything for a 3rd choice. And our #1 & #2 positions could be sorted for potentially 5-10yrs. Absolutely gutted/fuming we missed the boat on Mamardashvili though, what a keep he is.
Agree we need a new young goalie who Eddie can coach and mould into the best ball playing goalie in the world who firs our system. Pope hasn’t been the same since his shoulder injury but will do us for now, Dubravka I would like to see gone but we need him up to the summer unless Eddie is willing to give Vlakodimos a go. As for the other 27 goalies, get rid.
Do we have any semi solid leads on any signings or are they just all speculation at this stage
Couple of keepers out of contract at the end of the season, so definitely needed.
I've thought highly of Kelleher for some time and thought he'd be great for us, however we already have 6 'keepers on the books already, I think we must be keen on buying all the worlds goalies! Having said that, we do need a clear out this month before buying another one, but Dubs is doing a great job, who, out of the other 5 is his understudy right now? I hope we don't go for Trafford. Kelleher is head and shoulders better than him.
I agree mate I don't rate Trafford either
I know Dubs is leaving, but so many keepers is a head scratcher. Just the last few weeks results I'm not going to question Eddie's ambitions again. He's definitely a winner. We definitely can't run Eddie out of town. He's got a high ceiling.
Hopefully, this happens. Quality keeper, winger and maybe a right centerback, I'll go apeshit. Maybe, Shay Given in his ear?
I'd prefer Mads Hermansen from Leicester.
I was just thinking earlier today that with Marmadashvilli’s imminent arrival on Merseyside, Kelleher will” be surplus to requirements. Irish goalkeepers have served Newcastle very well in the past, Iam McFaul and Shay Given being two fine examples.
How many keepers do we need..?
England slovinia greek
Byker internationals..
I do feel we need to sort out the keeper problem . If we can shift Shakadeemus and pliers. Kellerher is a good keeper and i dont rate Trafford. I agree he is living on past young glories and to me is another woodman type keeper who isnt good enough for the demands of the premier league .
We definitely need a new no.1 but it won't be kelleher sadly, because as soon as other top teams are interested we can't compete with guaranteed champions league football/wages etc.
Kelliher would be a great signing. Really hope we can do a deal - great shot stopper, better distribution than Pope too. He’s experienced & young enough to carve out a great career with us. 🤞🤞🤞
Dubz has shown what's missing, if Kelleher is the answer then so be it... will LiVARpool sell to us... mmmm!
Liverpool will not sell until summer, I can not imagine them taking any risks , the title is their's,,they can only throw it away now
Agreed mate. That's why I wouldn't let Dubs leave until summer either
He was poor against us and I think we wouldn’t have scored 3 against them otherwise. I’d go get Trafford.
I honestly think Pope has lost his edge and confidence from the injurys we need a top keeper 100%
We've got enuf keepers
not really...
We need quality not quantity.
Pope has become a liability and I’ll be honest since dubravka come in been brilliant with feet and shot stopping so far fair play to him but we need better pope can be a sub from here on out x
Need to rid of 2 goalkeepers at least if we are looking at bringing another in
Never in a million years 😂😂😂 keller not going anywhere
Don't want him
Lets hope so kelleher cherki and that youngan from lens champion