@@ponchogom9339 Well, I refer to Wilhelm Furtwängler and Hans Knappertsbusch. Both conductors were the epitome of subjective conducting in the first half of the XX century., mainly in the core symphonic germanic repertoire. Here Christian Thielemann delivers a very subjective rendition, one that Furt and Kna would have been very proud of.
@@bapchaIndeed. Carlos Kleiber’s 1974 legendary recording of this Symphony with the Vienna Philharmonic received unanimous acclaim from both critics and the public. It was a remarkable interpretation which launched Kleiber’s wonderful career as one of the greatest conductors of the century.
The spirit of the 2nd movement's free fantasia eludes many; not so here in an interpretation worthy of Klemperer / Phiharmonia or Pletnev / RNO. Thank you for the opportunity to hear this wonderful performance.
There are people that do not listen to classical music make fun of the 4 notes of Beethoven Fifth. Sometimes it is quite offensive. Maybe they do not know what "Fate" is all about. Once "Fate" knocks on the door of those individuals, sooner or later, they will understand the 4 notes are serious stuff.. Only Beethoven can write "Fate" as a piece of music and share with the world. Thank you!!!
To jest muzyka cząsteczką pięcio nutowej Galaktyk Nikt nie jest wstanie nazwać tych dzwięków które miał w sobie zdalekich galaktyk kompozytor zanotował w swoim warsztacie kompozytorskim. Pozdrowienia z Minneapolis 🇺🇸🇵🇱🙏🙏🙏🙏
This is the first Symphony that I’ve ever heard in my life. And it’s incredible that every time I hear it, a find a new passion. It never, never tires. You can call me a cliché person, but I really see beauty in Classical Music, even if I don’t understand it fully yet. And with Thielemann!? He is one of the best conductors that I have ever seen! Germans and Austrians with Beethoven, always an excellent combination!
BRAVO CHRISTIAN ! Génial et l'orchestre aussi ! ET la 5ème magnifique de Ludwig ! BEETHOVEN FOR EVER AND EVER ! Génie pour l'éternité ! des opus inoubliables! WUNDERBAR !
What a great finale funeral march, outstandingly brilliant and influential. It is my favorite movement of the symphony and one of my absolute favorites of the early Romantic period up there with Schubert's unfinished.
Agree 100%. Beethoven with the 5th symphony finale invented the great finale so influential that even Bugs Bunny used it, and Schubert which his grandiose finale in his Große symphony was influenced by Beethoven.
Baythoven for symphony, Verdi for opera, and Mozart for melody . However; speaking about symphony, Giuseppe Verdi did write a magnificent piece of symphony called: I vespri Siciliani, or the happy Sicilianins. Just a beautiful piece.
Tal vez el entero universo desaparezca algún día, pero esta música sobrevivirá. Porque es más grande que este universo u otros infinitos universos que a Dios le plazca crear. La seguiré escuchando después de mi muerte, abrazado a mi padre que me la hizo escuchar por primera vez hace mucho tiempo. Y seré feliz eternamente.
Sehr gute darstellung von christian thilemann beethoven symphonie nr 5 c moll op 67 der erste satz allegro con brio sehr toll gespielt von den wiener philharmonikern karajan war noch viel besser mit seiner darstellung viel energischer und durchdringender trotzdem gut gespielt
I share not joy with listening to this Symphony. The Joy is with the 9th at long last. The means to the Joy are not found in this one. This man is unable to desire the one that men desire. The one that is desired by men of all nations is unable to be what this is. The Crucifixion would be appropriate for the 2nd as to person, but you need to approach it faithfully through the 3rd Person, but many wouldn't view that as a heroic deed. The 1st Symphony is the one who knows more than the 2nd and the 3rd. Captain Picard is tortured by the 4th, just because. The difference between Mendelsohn's Italian Symphony and the Reformation Symphony starts on October 31, 1517. On June 30, 1530, the Augsburg Confession was read to the Holy Roman Emperor Charles III, who was also King of France at the time. The German Electoral Princes and Dukes chose him. Nothing new to these poses.
No, this is NOT the "fate symphony", that would be P. I. Tchaikovsky's Symphony #4. Anyone with any musical knowledge would know that the symphony is based on 3 short notes and a longer note. That goes from the first notes all the way to the final 3 notes. Otherwise, I see/hear nothing wrong with the performance!
@@c08lam What I disliked was the super slow exposions of start of the 4th movement and unpersuasive fast tempo. I heard he is famous but I dunno why he is now ….
@@pkbum-nj3ec He had these slowing downs and quieten downs all over the place, in some cases so extreme as to create dead spots. This is not Bruckner man.
In my humble opinion, one of the greatest pieces of music
Yes it is, it is the Genesis of all great Symphonies that came afterwards
@@liauchungren848 No it is not.
@@liauchungren848 Number 3
Conductors always seem to be in a rush to get this symphony started. This one doesn't even wait for the applause to end.
Thielemann' s quickly start is occurring a good orchestral response.
That`s right
Probably the best 5th I’ve heard in many, many years… much in the Furt/Kna style. Awesome.
Glad to hear this! Thanks for watching 😊
What is Furt/Kna style?
@@ponchogom9339 Well, I refer to Wilhelm Furtwängler and Hans Knappertsbusch. Both conductors were the epitome of subjective conducting in the first half of the XX century., mainly in the core symphonic germanic repertoire. Here Christian Thielemann delivers a very subjective rendition, one that Furt and Kna would have been very proud of.
Carlos Kleiber's is brilliant too!
@@bapchaIndeed. Carlos Kleiber’s 1974 legendary recording of this Symphony with the Vienna Philharmonic received unanimous acclaim from both critics and the public. It was a remarkable interpretation which launched Kleiber’s wonderful career as one of the greatest conductors of the century.
The spirit of the 2nd movement's free fantasia eludes many; not so here in an interpretation worthy of Klemperer / Phiharmonia or Pletnev / RNO. Thank you for the opportunity to hear this wonderful performance.
Our pleasure, thanks for watching 😊
Perfect! Bravo!
Long Live Beethoven 🎶
There are people that do not listen to classical music make fun of the 4 notes of Beethoven Fifth. Sometimes it is quite offensive. Maybe they do not know what "Fate" is all about. Once "Fate" knocks on the door of those individuals, sooner or later, they will understand the 4 notes are serious stuff.. Only Beethoven can write "Fate" as a piece of music and share with the world. Thank you!!!
O, the orchestra and song is absolutely wonderful and sacred. 🎼🙏🙌💛
Beethoven inmortal!!! gracias por compartir esta maravillosa sinfonìa, para mì, una de las màs hermosas!
Our pleasure, we're glad you enjoyed it! 😊
Truly revolutionary,long live Beethoven ❤
To jest muzyka cząsteczką pięcio nutowej Galaktyk
Nikt nie jest wstanie nazwać tych dzwięków które miał w sobie zdalekich galaktyk kompozytor zanotował w swoim warsztacie kompozytorskim.
Pozdrowienia z Minneapolis 🇺🇸🇵🇱🙏🙏🙏🙏
This is the first Symphony that I’ve ever heard in my life.
And it’s incredible that every time I hear it, a find a new passion. It never, never tires.
You can call me a cliché person, but I really see beauty in Classical Music, even if I don’t understand it fully yet.
And with Thielemann!?
He is one of the best conductors that I have ever seen! Germans and Austrians with Beethoven, always an excellent combination!
BRAVO CHRISTIAN ! Génial et l'orchestre aussi ! ET la 5ème magnifique de Ludwig ! BEETHOVEN FOR EVER AND EVER ! Génie pour l'éternité ! des opus inoubliables! WUNDERBAR !
Fantastic performance!
I'm glad there are no extremes in his interpretation of the 1st movement and it still sounds interesting and pleasing to my ears.
I am very grateful to have exposure to such artistic expression. Bravo!
Fabulous ❤👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
참 좋습니다(very good)!
His excellency Ludwig van with his unrepeatable masterpiece for all time
What a great finale funeral march, outstandingly brilliant and influential. It is my favorite movement of the symphony and one of my absolute favorites of the early Romantic period up there with Schubert's unfinished.
Agree 100%. Beethoven with the 5th symphony finale invented the great finale so influential that even Bugs Bunny used it, and Schubert which his grandiose finale in his Große symphony was influenced by Beethoven.
Ah, Beethoven. 💛
maravilhoso!
Exceptionally well done!
WONDERFUL!
Glad you liked it! 🥰
@ ı love it :)
Beethoven will shine forever! Thanks.
Baythoven for symphony, Verdi for opera, and Mozart for melody . However; speaking about symphony, Giuseppe Verdi did write a magnificent piece of symphony called: I vespri Siciliani, or the happy Sicilianins. Just a beautiful piece.
It’s actually an overture (or sinfonia). Not a symphony in more than one movement like this
I love this performance!
Bravo!
Belíssima música!
Спасибо за великолепие исполнения ❤
Perfection!
Beethoven was not born on this Earth. He is much more than a human being. Next!
Elegant.
Могу только благодарить всех испонителей🎉🎉🎉🎉
слышатб
Bravo Beethoven por siempre .
I like this, especially the 2nd movement ❤
Una preciosidad de Beethoven. ✅️
Muchas gracias
Con mucho gusto 😊
LUDWIG VAN BEETHOVEN:❤ "The rebel MAGNIFICENT IN HISTORY MUSIC "❤❤❤❤❤🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪
Tal vez el entero universo desaparezca algún día, pero esta música sobrevivirá. Porque es más grande que este universo u otros infinitos universos que a Dios le plazca crear. La seguiré escuchando después de mi muerte, abrazado a mi padre que me la hizo escuchar por primera vez hace mucho tiempo. Y seré feliz eternamente.
Inteligente o regente. Os aplausos são para o compositor, e não para o regente ou para a orquestra... Simples assim..😮
It is said the Vienna Philharmonic has been a men's club only traditionally. I finally saw a lady violinist in the first violin section.
It has been possible for women to become part of the Vienna Philharmonics since 1997. But you're right, the number of women is still very low 😔
I enjoy starting with the A440.
Great dynamics! Camera work is excellent!
Sehr gute darstellung von christian thilemann beethoven symphonie nr 5 c moll op 67 der erste satz allegro con brio sehr toll gespielt von den wiener philharmonikern karajan war noch viel besser mit seiner darstellung viel energischer und durchdringender trotzdem gut gespielt
The Brucknerization of Beethoven. And not just any Beethoven. The 5th!
Interesting note. Yes, certain unexpected slow-downs do remind me that now too.
Compositore Beethoven, lui fa entrare ascltatore spettatore, dentro la musica sinfonica
Ta-ta-ta-taaá!
Simplicity.
thank you. I just wish the basic sound was a bit louder.
Thielemann should be the janitor
Thielemann parece querer conducir un coche de carreras.
Para mi un poco acelerado, esta grandiosa sinfonía creo que merece más pausa y contención.
女性がいる！
¡ Oh, sí !
Buena observación. 😂❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I share not joy with listening to this Symphony. The Joy is with the 9th at long last. The means to the Joy are not found in this one. This man is unable to desire the one that men desire. The one that is desired by men of all nations is unable to be what this is. The Crucifixion would be appropriate for the 2nd as to person, but you need to approach it faithfully through the 3rd Person, but many wouldn't view that as a heroic deed. The 1st Symphony is the one who knows more than the 2nd and the 3rd. Captain Picard is tortured by the 4th, just because. The difference between Mendelsohn's Italian Symphony and the Reformation Symphony starts on October 31, 1517. On June 30, 1530, the Augsburg Confession was read to the Holy Roman Emperor Charles III, who was also King of France at the time. The German Electoral Princes and Dukes chose him. Nothing new to these poses.
🔥🔥🔥
❤
💕
Beethoven definitivamente não era deste mundo!
braucht der keine Noten??
🌱
12:53 Build up😂 like in a soccer game?😅😊
¿No podía esperar a que cesara el ruido de los aplausos?
Reger a 5ª deve fazer qualquer maestro perder uns dois quilos...
This time beethoven like Furtwangler when conducted with berliner 😢
大昔の巨匠がいい音で復活したかのようだ。繊細にして熱血である。
Esta música si que es el idioma universal.Tan hermosa.!!!
*34:51** - **34:59** 우울할 때마다 보는 장면. 너무 웃기는 지휘자의 gesture 😮 one of the most banal performances in my humble opinion*
Biscuis fines.
No, this is NOT the "fate symphony", that would be P. I. Tchaikovsky's Symphony #4. Anyone with any musical knowledge would know that the symphony is based on 3 short notes and a longer note. That goes from the first notes all the way to the final 3 notes. Otherwise, I see/hear nothing wrong with the performance!
The 5th is certainly known under that name in Germany.
The opening motif is sometimes called the “fate motif”
The opening motif has famously been described as "fate knocking on the door." It is not wrong to call Beethoven's 5th "the fate symphony."
ベートーヴェンの第九は〜少し話を聞きました〜ベートーヴェンが希望のない所から ベートーヴェン自ら希望を 人類におっくた〜完済〜目も耳も駄目で〜完成曲も〜聴かず〜生涯を終える〜未来に〜希望を贈り……………m(_ _)m
Sinfonía n°5,de Beethowen llamada del destino.
Rather poor sound quality, not the fault of the orchestra, but the very flat recording.
망했을때 나오는 노래
Germans being Germans
Wie bitte!?
Esta sinfonía es llamada la "Sinfonía Trágica".
No. It isn't.
La Tragica è di Schubert
Ce chef n'est vraiment pas le plus charismatique..
Worst experience of Musikverein.
Tempo of the start of 4th movement is the Worst I have ever heard of.
@@pkbum-nj3ec Tempo indication is Allegro for 4th movement and Allegro con brio for 1st movement. But tempo of 4th movement is even faster 😂🤣
@@c08lam What I disliked was the super slow exposions of start of the 4th movement and unpersuasive fast tempo. I heard he is famous but I dunno why he is now ….
@@pkbum-nj3ec He had these slowing downs and quieten downs all over the place, in some cases so extreme as to create dead spots. This is not Bruckner man.
@@tt-ew7rxThen, I can say he is arrogant. Beethoven`s work does not need that kinds of things.
Tieleman’s symphony 10!