I saw a comment somewhere which said that the farmers matching to Delhi for their demands should also include mrfa as one of their demands 😂😂 was funny when I read it 🤣
Defence Secretary himself admits the economy can support Defence Spending. DRDO chief himself said it openly on camera they need R&D. IAF said they are equally responsible “we in uniform are equally responsible”
R&D में इंफ्रा स्ट्रक्चर बनने शुरू हो गए है ये अच्छे चिह्न है। हालांकि सफर लम्बा है। 70 साल में पड़ी गेप भरनी है। पर जरूरत के अनुसार , प्रयोरिटी अनुसार काम शुरू हो रहे है। पर 0 से शुरू करने के कारण समय लग रहा। सब निर्माण एक साथ शुरू नही कर सकते , बजट व इकोनॉमी पर दबाव न बन जाए, इस लिए जरूरत अनुसार प्रयोरिटी दी जा रही।
@JakeNick2 India should have more than one DRDO for competition. It doesn't matter if Sukhoi and Shenyang are private or government; USA, Russia and China have multiple major companies.
@@Pablo_the_hedgehog since your English is so immaculate maybe go ask the Goras if they will treat you like one of their own ie. a " White Protestant Christian " Get treatement for the colonial mindset you have.
A country like Turkey is coming up with 5 gen fighters and is ready to export to the UAE. And a third largest economy by purchasing power parity is finding it difficult. What a blunder
@honestpetvideos9307 americans. I think they are using general electric but still you need to applaud them for at least making one. And our projects are just getting delayed
Why are you mentioning purchasing power parity here? Purchasing power parity is effective for comparing the cost of low-value consumables because it accounts for price differences between countries for basic goods and services. However, it becomes less relevant for advanced technologies, which often involve high costs for research, development, and specialized components. Countries importing such technologies for local development may face additional challenges, as PPP does not reflect these complex factors, including the reliance on global markets, intellectual property, and skilled labor. Therefore, PPP is less accurate for assessing the true cost and accessibility of advanced technology.
If 51 kN Kaveri Engine certified in future and if it would able to proceed 80-85 kN with afterburner. Should we consider a twin Kaveri Engine fighter jets like medium category Rafael ?
Again, kar sakthe hai, ho saktha hai, karenge, hoga.... HAHHAHAHAHAHAHAA.... nothing is happening. Nothing at all. Congress was faster than this in all perspective. They did a lot of India than BJP who has just lied and propaganda. Sorry but it is a hard truth.
Buying Blanket during summer 😅😅😅😅. Our Tejas mk 2 prototype may be ready this year and may also be inducted at 2030 so what's the point of buying Rafael now that will be delivered at 2028-29 and will take at least 2 years to form a squadron It's like digging a well when there is fire in your house 😅😅😅😅
They explicitly mentioned the reason: India lacks the infrastructure and talent to properly utilize additional funds. Misusing funds would only add to the burden for a country already carrying a high debt, about 80% of its GDP.
@@SpectZ-eu5zj bro then don't you think that buffed budget can be also be used to build infrastructure and talent. It cant be done in 1 fiscal year. but eventually we will need to do it sooner or later
@@krishnamurari-q2x Of course, India might consider this later (likely once its GDP reaches a certain mark). The challenge is that properly utilizing the increased funds would require significant boosts not just to the defense budget, but also to the education budget over many years. Simply increasing the defense budget alone isn't the real solution. You also need to consider that much of India's top talent in science and technology leaves the country, making the situation even more challenging. Simply offering salaries comparable to those in developed nations isn’t the real fix if they don’t find the quality of life in India appealing. In short, the situation is more complex than it seems, and simply increasing the defense budget won’t have the expected impact. One of the key reasons the defense budget hasn’t grown significantly is the lack of infrastructure investment over decades, unlike China. India is now paying the price, forced to allocate over 20% of its funds to infrastructure alone, which naturally impacts its ability to invest in the defense sector. For comparison, the US spends no more than 1% of its central budget on infrastructure, benefiting from decades of focused investment in its infrastructure.
Policies made by our "leaders" have been reactive in nature and with no long term vision for as long as I remember. This have been the case not just in defense sector but in all sectors. Our leaders failed to understand that without r&d and basic infrastructures, hi-tech stuff just dont drop out of the sky. Yes, its an risky investment but theres no other way, no country will share their latest technologies without any compromises or restrictions. Also, as we have seen in russia-ukraine war, modern war will be a war of attrition and relying on foreign countries will be a risky gamble. We have to be self-sufficient and build our own jets and engines but dont have even basic engine testing bed for that. If this attitude continues then we will continue to play catch-up while the rest of the world is steaming ahead.
Because just 20 years ago, they were been criticised for only 30% ToT and were not contributing more than doors and windows in the main platforms. HAL can be criticised but we have to remember it that they have came a long way from just manufacturing few matel parts for the project in the name of ToT.
Exactly, most of the elite countries stole the tech from German scientists from world war 2 and has decades more experience than us, or you gotta be like china and steal tech from Russia and USA.
Why is HAL still a government organisation is astonishing to me, its like we dont wanna become better ourselves, as long as it remains under the control of babus, it will be a shit show no matter what. I dont see any reason why tata aviation can't be a manufacturing partner for HAL TEJAS and future development, you need money, better get a company that can pay, but no they will never let that happen.
For the past five years, we have been saying that we should purchase what we need from outside in a timely manner and spend it on our own industry as per the requirements.
For the past decade I have been recommending an alternative for HAL, it would be( NAL+Indian Automotive OEMs) which would make HAL to run for money instead of being a couch Potata when it comes to delivery
Similar thing happened after India pulled out of FGFA, did we get 5th generation ? No. After 2020 priority was self sufficient but towed artillery indigenous still not inducted and armoured vehicle we waned from USA, thankfully Canada happened the process was paused. Till the time there's nothing on ground or results are there...its just empty words for me nothing else.
Ge stopped making 404 engine and tejas mk1a is going to use that engine. Is mk1a future proof? Ten years down the line if we need 10 to 20 more engines, from where are we going to find it?
Pahele to Ye Tejas mk1 ,Tejas mk1A, Tejas mk2, Tedbf, Amca mk1 4.5 gen, Amca mk2 5th gen ka zholam zhall band karo koi ekk world class product banao aur uske varients banao😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
I have a question Astra mk3 is supposed to have a 390 km range while it will use similar technology as a meteor so how are they supposed to manage the size meteor has a official range 200 km so when this missile enters service other than su30mki which other aircraft can even carry such a large missile AMCA is probably out of the ❓
Look a most big reform rajnath can give to make himself popular is bring such new system of procurement which make procurement not only easy but fast without corruption of senior soldiers and import lobby and another thing change entire system of office one remove import one from list make more R&D center for defense and allow weapon procurement which is brand new give some ease on battle proven weapon title import lobby use that to much
For National Security, There Should not be any Mercy. Either Administration or Pvt/Govt Organization. Hardest Penalty should be Applied. "Commitment & Requirements is Always Priority ".Jai Bharat
Is it possible to buy whole of embrare company. Indian government said to launch development of passenger aircraft. And we need transport aircraft. Should we consider buying the company. It can boost our industry.
This is a very very golmall PSU their recruitment process is also not transparent,they don't provide answer keys they directly publish merit list .. recruitment happens in just two months don't even let engineers to study for exam 😅😅😅This only happens if candidates to be selected are already selected so no requirement of competitive process where you let people to prepare for atleast 3 months....I am talking about their Desiggn trainee and Managgement trainee exams..and even recruiting so fast not delivering on time...a big big corruption is happening there
@@AliSherrr beacause modi wanted to promote make in india. We had alot of money but we order 36 rafale as a stopgap for 8 billion dollar including some funds to Dassault so they can set up Joint venture with Reliance. But rahul gandhi came and started blaming corruption in the JV so it didn’t move ahead.
Increase r&d is required by 10x. Bureaucracy needs to be thrown out. defence budget itself mustbe tripled to over 200 billion. And R&D should be atleast 15% of this : That means we need 30 billion dollars year for that.
India should only concentrate on 100% IAEM Indian Aircraft Engine Manufacturing . Not only for the Airforce but also for commercial airlines and force Boeing and Airbus to use it in Indian commercial Aircraft .
So put private firm with tax benefits, big firm like Adani, Ambani and Tata, we will be the next America, If firm gets tax benefits there will be a flood of new startups
But where the budget goes. Even today Pak defence budget is less than us but how pak is having better equipment ? This is not ek din bro, it is already become 20 years no less time.
India should have 160 Billion Dollars defence budget needs, at least India's GDP 4%. 160 Billion 37.5%-38% {60-61Billion} Going to Revenue Expenditure, Salary, Allowance, Pensions etc.And Reast of Defence Modernization.
Not possible for now, so stop dreaming. 25% of India's annual expenditure (160 Billion Dollars ) going toward defense is unrealistic at the moment. As of now, India's defense spending accounts for about 13% of its total government expenditure, which is already a significant portion. The reality is that a large defense budget would limit the funds available for other crucial sectors like healthcare, education, infrastructure, and social welfare, leading to tough choices on priorities. While GDP reflects a country's overall economic output, it is the actual government expenditure that determines its spending power. Currently, India's total expenditure capacity is around $576 billion. Allocating $160 billion solely for defense would be impractical, unless the public is willing to accept significant cuts in other major sectors, which would be a pretty bad idea anyway.
Yeah! give 15 orders for one type of fighter and 15 orders of other types of fighters. And 10 trainers. Brilliant IAF. Even after a decade long mmrca evaluation they don't know what the hell they want.
Sarkar ki soch ka baniyan. Unko read toh sale item chahiya wo v dusro ki develop kiya huwa..😂😂😂.. defence technology koi kisi ko deta ha ??? R&D ma kanjusi karta ha sarkar... babu logo ko import se chahiya cut money.. 😂😂😂
Bharat spends less than 1% on research. 0.64% of its GDP on R&D during 2020-21, as per Department of Science and Technology. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) was around 2.7%, according to data published last month. In 2021, China spent 2.4% on R&D, according to World Bank data. An optimum number for R&D is triple the current amount. But the government need not foot the bill! In 2022, the private sector contributed, on average, 74% of OECD nations’ R&D spending and 66% of such funding for the 27 members of the European Union. So offer the same tax concessions for R&D other countries offer. The Nature Index Research Leaders 2024 released today shows the rapid progress Bharat has made in research output. The country is seeing a higher percentage growth in contributions to Index journals than China. If Bharat continues to beat the strongest adversary that will also translate into high tech advances like what China already has!
@@subhakantrout8346 I am referring to the Government. Isn't it obvious that Aero Engine Development need funds? What's holding them back from releasing funds? Are they again to go form another useless Committee to study the same old things?
No country will share their Crown Jewels like Jet Engine. It was stupid on part of HAL to pitch for export orders when HAL can’t meet IAF quantity order. Naturally Uncle Sam stopped Engine supply because Tejas will directly compete with F16 whose sales have already amortized the costs for the manufacturer Martin. Depending on one agency to develop that to lazy bums is supreme stupidity even Soviet Union had multiple agencies to develop aero engines the ideal way is to form a consortium of private industry with heavy capital infusion interest free and heavy tax subsidies once the product is accepted most important assured orders and payments in time be in written into MOU.
अरे भाई जब अमेरिका इंजन की delivery ही नहीं कर रहा है तो क्या Baiden के विरुद्ध action लें. कम से कम 24 तेजस हर साल बन सकते हैं. लेकिन purey पैसे देने के बावजूद wo delivery नहीं दे रहे. जय हिन्द 🇮🇳 🇮🇳
Immediately buy F15 EX equivalent to number of aging Jaguar and MIG 29. Divert money from upgrading these aircrafts to buy F15EX. I think they have highest manufacturing rate. Rafale should set up factory in India with objective to manufacture aircraft with 5th generation technologies and ongoing upgradation. This will take 6 to 7 years. With F15EX buy 4 squardens of F35 varient. Build Tejas MK 1 with F404 and Kaveri engine. Tejas MK 2 with F414 engines and Kaveri high thrust engine. AMCA 5.5 to 6 generation can join the IAF from 2032 onwards. By that time Miraj 2000 will come for retirement. For Third largest Economy by 2047 60 squardens of modern aircraft is must. We have to be ready to fight war on 5 fronts. Similar approach has to be adopted for Submarines. Three foreign vendors French 6 +3, two more foreign manucturers 9 each with Indian partners. Simultaneously build only nuclear submarines in India under government supervision. Two more aircraft carriers and 3 helicopter/drone decks. For these projects the major payout will happen 5 years down the line after initial signing payout. We need to see Modiji hugging other country leaaders as country with Economic and Military might . 💪
China KO 25 Saal lagay proper infrastructure bananay main j20s proper 5th gen aircraft hai jabki j35A ab jakay refine hua agar Indian airforce AJ finalize karay to minimum 4 say 5 Saal lagay gain but hosakta hai it's not too late
Kuch nahi hoga. Old wine new bottle. 😂 Kutte ka tail hamesha teda hee hai. Mei bhee ek Indian hu. Magar ye defence ke ghatiya system dhekke politics hee achha lagta hai 😢
4th generation engine😂😂😂 now start to make 6th generation😅😅😅😅 After 40 years not even 40 Tejas produced and planning to make 6th generation fighter jet
We need Ladla Rafale Yojna and Gareeb Aero Engine yojna.
Are Maalik🙏😂🤣
I saw a comment somewhere which said that the farmers matching to Delhi for their demands should also include mrfa as one of their demands 😂😂 was funny when I read it 🤣
Remove UPSC babus from defence industry and give those jobs to engineer's and scientists
Perfect solution
It is not that easy
@@ajaydhakar7431 no doubt it's not easy but not impossible either
Lateral entry laye the tho collition walo ne gand mar di a gov without majority can't do much
Our dalit engineers with 34% marks will make 7th generation fighter jet and Ambedkar engenie for that jet
Defence Secretary himself admits the economy can support Defence Spending. DRDO chief himself said it openly on camera they need R&D. IAF said they are equally responsible “we in uniform are equally responsible”
🎉🎉🎉🎉
Yo zoro how r u doing
R&D में इंफ्रा स्ट्रक्चर बनने शुरू हो गए है ये अच्छे चिह्न है। हालांकि सफर लम्बा है। 70 साल में पड़ी गेप भरनी है। पर जरूरत के अनुसार , प्रयोरिटी अनुसार काम शुरू हो रहे है। पर 0 से शुरू करने के कारण समय लग रहा। सब निर्माण एक साथ शुरू नही कर सकते , बजट व इकोनॉमी पर दबाव न बन जाए, इस लिए जरूरत अनुसार प्रयोरिटी दी जा रही।
@@sanjayhiremath9297I’m good :)
We are on right path then...
India needs proper private defence companies like Lockheed, Sukhoi & Mitsubishi, lack of competition is an issue here.
Shenyang? And also you can't say Sukhoi is a proper private defence company because its majority of shares are owned by the government
@JakeNick2 India should have more than one DRDO for competition. It doesn't matter if Sukhoi and Shenyang are private or government; USA, Russia and China have multiple major companies.
@@unknown_5107 not DRDO but companies like HAL
I really broked ,when Defence secretary said , Many foreign friend wants indian product but we make difficult for them 💔💔
70 yrs of bearecrecy need to be dissolved if we want to see so e more progress
He really broked 🥺
I also berry brokened
@@Pablo_the_hedgehog since your English is so immaculate maybe go ask the Goras if they will treat you like one of their own ie. a " White Protestant Christian "
Get treatement for the colonial mindset you have.
@@Pablo_the_hedgehog it's so brokening 🥺
@@courage04 bro is so brokened 💔💔
Kick out masterji from defence ministry and ias officer from manufacturing
All talk no action. Ten years down the line and still nothing will change.
A country like Turkey is coming up with 5 gen fighters and is ready to export to the UAE. And a third largest economy by purchasing power parity is finding it difficult. What a blunder
And whoes engine will power it ?
@honestpetvideos9307 americans. I think they are using general electric but still you need to applaud them for at least making one. And our projects are just getting delayed
Why are you mentioning purchasing power parity here? Purchasing power parity is effective for comparing the cost of low-value consumables because it accounts for price differences between countries for basic goods and services. However, it becomes less relevant for advanced technologies, which often involve high costs for research, development, and specialized components. Countries importing such technologies for local development may face additional challenges, as PPP does not reflect these complex factors, including the reliance on global markets, intellectual property, and skilled labor. Therefore, PPP is less accurate for assessing the true cost and accessibility of advanced technology.
kaan is not a true 5th gen fighter jet.
Turkey is a NATO member and semi-industrialised economy. They share and receive technology with NATO members.
Buddy trying for 8min mark for algo 😂
Why 8
If 51 kN Kaveri Engine certified in future and if it would able to proceed 80-85 kN with afterburner. Should we consider a twin Kaveri Engine fighter jets like medium category Rafael ?
For what mission? We have 200+ sukhois. 200+ tejas, For the future you need futuristic fighters.
@@james4807Mthe navy requires a twin engine fighter like the rafael and we have tedbf concept for it
Again, kar sakthe hai, ho saktha hai, karenge, hoga.... HAHHAHAHAHAHAHAA.... nothing is happening. Nothing at all. Congress was faster than this in all perspective. They did a lot of India than BJP who has just lied and propaganda. Sorry but it is a hard truth.
Buying Blanket during summer 😅😅😅😅. Our Tejas mk 2 prototype may be ready this year and may also be inducted at 2030 so what's the point of buying Rafael now that will be delivered at 2028-29 and will take at least 2 years to form a squadron
It's like digging a well when there is fire in your house 😅😅😅😅
Thank you defence secretary for clarification and thank you defence matrix for spreading genuine awareness
All hopes will be dashed on the day Nirmala Chechi presents budget
IAF kept changing its requirements after giving orders. Also initially, IAF kept dragging their feet about accepting Tejas Mark 1A.
LCA is failed. 5th gen needs to be focused on with LCA experience to avoid same mistakes.
if funds is not a problem, then why govt is not buffing def budget?
😂😂 because of dumb scroll bots like you... Bro has made a whole video for it but you are asking the same thing
Cuz they are busy looting public money
They explicitly mentioned the reason: India lacks the infrastructure and talent to properly utilize additional funds. Misusing funds would only add to the burden for a country already carrying a high debt, about 80% of its GDP.
@@SpectZ-eu5zj bro then don't you think that buffed budget can be also be used to build infrastructure and talent. It cant be done in 1 fiscal year. but eventually we will need to do it sooner or later
@@krishnamurari-q2x Of course, India might consider this later (likely once its GDP reaches a certain mark). The challenge is that properly utilizing the increased funds would require significant boosts not just to the defense budget, but also to the education budget over many years. Simply increasing the defense budget alone isn't the real solution. You also need to consider that much of India's top talent in science and technology leaves the country, making the situation even more challenging. Simply offering salaries comparable to those in developed nations isn’t the real fix if they don’t find the quality of life in India appealing.
In short, the situation is more complex than it seems, and simply increasing the defense budget won’t have the expected impact. One of the key reasons the defense budget hasn’t grown significantly is the lack of infrastructure investment over decades, unlike China. India is now paying the price, forced to allocate over 20% of its funds to infrastructure alone, which naturally impacts its ability to invest in the defense sector. For comparison, the US spends no more than 1% of its central budget on infrastructure, benefiting from decades of focused investment in its infrastructure.
Policies made by our "leaders" have been reactive in nature and with no long term vision for as long as I remember. This have been the case not just in defense sector but in all sectors. Our leaders failed to understand that without r&d and basic infrastructures, hi-tech stuff just dont drop out of the sky. Yes, its an risky investment but theres no other way, no country will share their latest technologies without any compromises or restrictions. Also, as we have seen in russia-ukraine war, modern war will be a war of attrition and relying on foreign countries will be a risky gamble. We have to be self-sufficient and build our own jets and engines but dont have even basic engine testing bed for that. If this attitude continues then we will continue to play catch-up while the rest of the world is steaming ahead.
the statement about the R&D is significant, I think it is the most important aspect of any weapon, it is good that we are thinking about it
Keep hoping. Nothing is gonna change
1st step Invest
2nd co develop with reliable ally
But no one will offer you free knowledge until then buy established war toys to stop gap
We have been assembling MIG21 onwards but why HAL, DRDO, GTRE, NAL Couldn't absorb the technology and mastered our own engine and fighter platforms.
Because just 20 years ago, they were been criticised for only 30% ToT and were not contributing more than doors and windows in the main platforms.
HAL can be criticised but we have to remember it that they have came a long way from just manufacturing few matel parts for the project in the name of ToT.
Exactly, most of the elite countries stole the tech from German scientists from world war 2 and has decades more experience than us, or you gotta be like china and steal tech from Russia and USA.
Why is HAL still a government organisation is astonishing to me, its like we dont wanna become better ourselves, as long as it remains under the control of babus, it will be a shit show no matter what. I dont see any reason why tata aviation can't be a manufacturing partner for HAL TEJAS and future development, you need money, better get a company that can pay, but no they will never let that happen.
For the past five years, we have been saying that we should purchase what we need from outside in a timely manner and spend it on our own industry as per the requirements.
Meanwhile Mig 21 >>mai. Upgrade hoonga
You are blaming on airforce. Dont we know we needed 126 Rafale jets. How many we ordered?
India really needs to learn from China on how to develop indigenous defence technology.
For it, we need qualified individuals and the correct type of environment.
"Realisation is the first step towards growth "🗿❤️🩹
100% sahi bhai !!
For the past decade I have been recommending an alternative for HAL, it would be( NAL+Indian Automotive OEMs) which would make HAL to run for money instead of being a couch Potata when it comes to delivery
There's a saying, "Hope leads to disappointment." Have a Plan B when that doesn't work out.
Similar thing happened after India pulled out of FGFA, did we get 5th generation ? No. After 2020 priority was self sufficient but towed artillery indigenous still not inducted and armoured vehicle we waned from USA, thankfully Canada happened the process was paused. Till the time there's nothing on ground or results are there...its just empty words for me nothing else.
Mitro aaj rat 9 baje se drdo legal organization nahi rahega😂😂
Is there any private company capable of replacing HAL in the future, or can we privatize HAL?
Indian air chief kya keh raha tha Ap singh kal ki news sunno
Aaj hi news aai hai economy slow down 6% last 6 years.
Let's wait for upcoming budget and we will see if this means anything or if it's just empty talks.
Ge stopped making 404 engine and tejas mk1a is going to use that engine. Is mk1a future proof? Ten years down the line if we need 10 to 20 more engines, from where are we going to find it?
Pahele to Ye Tejas mk1 ,Tejas mk1A, Tejas mk2, Tedbf, Amca mk1 4.5 gen, Amca mk2 5th gen ka zholam zhall band karo koi ekk world class product banao aur uske varients banao😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
What is diff between 4 th, 5th and 6 th gen aero engine
HAL ... HAL ... THE ONLY BALI KA BAKRA 😂
6:35 2001 se 2014 congress ki govt power me rahe hai unko dhyan dena tha kaveri engine me paise lagana tha
Haa toh 2014 seh 2025 mea konsa bjp ne paise lagaye???😂😂😂
10 साल बहुत ज्यादा होते हैं 10 साल में सब कुछ बदला जा सकता है कभी-कभी मोदी जी की भी बुराई कर लिया करो दोस्त
Kash mrfa 1 ko hi execute kr dena tha kam se kam abhi tak hame rafale mil to rahe hote.
Aur production line bhi bn jati.
I have a question Astra mk3 is supposed to have a 390 km range while it will use similar technology as a meteor so how are they supposed to manage the size meteor has a official range 200 km so when this missile enters service other than su30mki which other aircraft can even carry such a large missile AMCA is probably out of the ❓
Politics in drdo too should stop.People should not feel insecure if juniors are performing better than them.
Look a most big reform rajnath can give to make himself popular is bring such new system of procurement which make procurement not only easy but fast without corruption of senior soldiers and import lobby and another thing change entire system of office one remove import one from list make more R&D center for defense and allow weapon procurement which is brand new give some ease on battle proven weapon title import lobby use that to much
For National Security, There Should not be any Mercy. Either Administration or Pvt/Govt Organization. Hardest Penalty should be Applied. "Commitment & Requirements is Always Priority ".Jai Bharat
No problem they will just have a chai biscuit session and say new reform
Private company and startup ko involve karna chahiye taki wo bhi technology absorbed kar sake...nakara government psu se nahi ho pa raha hai
Is it possible to buy whole of embrare company. Indian government said to launch development of passenger aircraft. And we need transport aircraft. Should we consider buying the company. It can boost our industry.
How our defence industries grow when we keep importing though? Did China did that or they invested and made it themselves instead of keep importing?
This is a very very golmall PSU their recruitment process is also not transparent,they don't provide answer keys they directly publish merit list .. recruitment happens in just two months don't even let engineers to study for exam 😅😅😅This only happens if candidates to be selected are already selected so no requirement of competitive process where you let people to prepare for atleast 3 months....I am talking about their Desiggn trainee and Managgement trainee exams..and even recruiting so fast not delivering on time...a big big corruption is happening there
🛑We also need ministry of efficiency in India.
"Funds issue ni hain". Acha? Phr 120+ Rafale ki deal ko 36 units py kuon limit kiya by siting lack of funds as the reason? Next level gaslighting :D
@@AliSherrr beacause modi wanted to promote make in india. We had alot of money but we order 36 rafale as a stopgap for 8 billion dollar including some funds to Dassault so they can set up Joint venture with Reliance.
But rahul gandhi came and started blaming corruption in the JV so it didn’t move ahead.
@@killer-lordsmobile7099werent they supposed to buy 114 rafales proposed by congress govt?
If we had 114 jets by now we need not worry about china
Increase r&d is required by 10x. Bureaucracy needs to be thrown out. defence budget itself mustbe tripled to over 200 billion. And R&D should be atleast 15% of this : That means we need 30 billion dollars year for that.
India should only concentrate on 100% IAEM Indian Aircraft Engine Manufacturing . Not only for the Airforce but also for commercial airlines and force Boeing and Airbus to use it in Indian commercial Aircraft .
IAF need 10 latest squadrons 5th generation fighter jets immediately if government can give them
Humare Scientist ko engine ka kaam ni ata , accept it. Remove project from DRDO and as private player to work on it
If fund is not a problem, then where's the flying test bed?
India me statements bhut aati hai.. Ground par chije bhut kam dikhti hai..
So put private firm with tax benefits, big firm like Adani, Ambani and Tata, we will be the next America, If firm gets tax benefits there will be a flood of new startups
Meanwhile, with their 5th gen J20 and soon 6th gen J36, China is far, far and far ahead in quantity and in quality the Indian widow makers.
But where the budget goes. Even today Pak defence budget is less than us but how pak is having better equipment ? This is not ek din bro, it is already become 20 years no less time.
India should have 160 Billion Dollars defence budget needs, at least India's GDP 4%. 160 Billion 37.5%-38% {60-61Billion} Going to Revenue Expenditure, Salary, Allowance, Pensions etc.And Reast of Defence Modernization.
Not possible for now, so stop dreaming. 25% of India's annual expenditure (160 Billion Dollars ) going toward defense is unrealistic at the moment. As of now, India's defense spending accounts for about 13% of its total government expenditure, which is already a significant portion. The reality is that a large defense budget would limit the funds available for other crucial sectors like healthcare, education, infrastructure, and social welfare, leading to tough choices on priorities.
While GDP reflects a country's overall economic output, it is the actual government expenditure that determines its spending power. Currently, India's total expenditure capacity is around $576 billion. Allocating $160 billion solely for defense would be impractical, unless the public is willing to accept significant cuts in other major sectors, which would be a pretty bad idea anyway.
Yes, spend $160 billion on defence and go broke like ussr
😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Kash defence equipment vote de paate 🥲
For tech absorption we need private sector participants
Samosa
AirForce forced to quit Su 57 now they are wanting same. Air Force is joke.
Share Market me bhi log Defence Sector Company likes HAL, BEL, Shipyard ne invest kr rahe hai uska paisa kaha ja raha uese hi r&d pr laga do😅
Pvt companies ko lagao ubka proejct managers laao sarkari naukri waalo ko nikalo..apne se sab line per aa jayegneg
IAF is not wrong if they have given the orders it's the job of supplier to fulfill the delivery!
Yeah! give 15 orders for one type of fighter and 15 orders of other types of fighters. And 10 trainers. Brilliant IAF. Even after a decade long mmrca evaluation they don't know what the hell they want.
@@james4807MIAF was clear about what they want it's political leadership which decided to buy only 36 fighters !
Sarkar ki soch ka baniyan. Unko read toh sale item chahiya wo v dusro ki develop kiya huwa..😂😂😂.. defence technology koi kisi ko deta ha ??? R&D ma kanjusi karta ha sarkar... babu logo ko import se chahiya cut money.. 😂😂😂
1st likne walo ki mkc
😂😂😂
First reform should be change in hal company to develop in new goverment + private companies for r&d , production line , test facilities
Bharat spends less than 1% on research. 0.64% of its GDP on R&D during 2020-21, as per Department of Science and Technology. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) was around 2.7%, according to data published last month. In 2021, China spent 2.4% on R&D, according to World Bank data.
An optimum number for R&D is triple the current amount. But the government need not foot the bill! In 2022, the private sector contributed, on average, 74% of OECD nations’ R&D spending and 66% of such funding for the 27 members of the European Union. So offer the same tax concessions for R&D other countries offer. The Nature Index Research Leaders 2024 released today shows the rapid progress Bharat has made in research output.
The country is seeing a higher percentage growth in contributions to Index journals than China. If Bharat continues to beat the strongest adversary that will also translate into high
tech advances like what China already has!
Govt not allocating sufficient funds in every budget. Compare with china.
Big reforms k naam pe chai-samosa k jgah samosa-chai khayenge
Main issue Indians joins DRDO just to get Pakistani girl phone calls.
Randian...❤
Pichle 10- 15 years se sooo 😴😴😴 rhe thhe
Abb jabb china pakistan ki progress se shock 🫨 lga to RR krne lagae
If they really have that much fund, why not give it in R&D.
@@subhakantrout8346 I am referring to the Government. Isn't it obvious that Aero Engine Development need funds? What's holding them back from releasing funds? Are they again to go form another useless Committee to study the same old things?
Ye expect karte hi ki Kaam kiya jaye😂😂🤣🤣
Aur samay par kiya jaye😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😅😂😂😂😅😂😂😂
Jo halat hai mujhe Nahi lagta agle 10 sal tak kuch nahi hone wala😢😢
No. Just sell 50 % to French dassault and helicopter wing to USA ...dilute every thing below 40 % then see
No country will share their Crown Jewels like Jet Engine. It was stupid on part of HAL to pitch for export orders when HAL can’t meet IAF quantity order. Naturally Uncle Sam stopped Engine supply because Tejas will directly compete with F16 whose sales have already amortized the costs for the manufacturer Martin.
Depending on one agency to develop that to lazy bums is supreme stupidity even Soviet Union had multiple agencies to develop aero engines the ideal way is to form a consortium of private industry with heavy capital infusion interest free and heavy tax subsidies once the product is accepted most important assured orders and payments in time be in written into MOU.
Kya wja Hain koye country be Tejas nhi Le raha hai
Thats why they chose only 36 Rafale instead of 114.😢
Hum kar sakte hainnnnn...... lekin hota nahin..........
with this "Boondy" as cover page , this plane is doomed
अरे भाई जब अमेरिका इंजन की delivery ही नहीं कर रहा है तो क्या Baiden के विरुद्ध action लें. कम से कम 24 तेजस हर साल बन सकते हैं. लेकिन purey पैसे देने के बावजूद wo delivery नहीं दे रहे. जय हिन्द 🇮🇳 🇮🇳
Boost private players and r&d in indian premium institute of IIT NIT manufacturing hubs and everything
Immediately buy F15 EX equivalent to number of aging Jaguar and MIG 29. Divert money from upgrading these aircrafts to buy F15EX. I think they have highest manufacturing rate. Rafale should set up factory in India with objective to manufacture aircraft with 5th generation technologies and ongoing upgradation. This will take 6 to 7 years. With F15EX buy 4 squardens of F35 varient.
Build Tejas MK 1 with F404 and Kaveri engine. Tejas MK 2 with F414 engines and Kaveri high thrust engine. AMCA 5.5 to 6 generation can join the IAF from 2032 onwards. By that time Miraj 2000 will come for retirement.
For Third largest Economy by 2047
60 squardens of modern aircraft is must. We have to be ready to fight war on 5 fronts. Similar approach has to be adopted for Submarines. Three foreign vendors French 6 +3, two more foreign manucturers 9 each with Indian partners. Simultaneously build only nuclear submarines in India under government supervision. Two more aircraft carriers and 3 helicopter/drone decks. For these projects the major payout will happen 5 years down the line after initial signing payout.
We need to see Modiji hugging other country leaaders as country with Economic and Military might
. 💪
If we go for mrfa we can't make amca for another 10 years. We will not become self Reliant for another 15 year.
China KO 25 Saal lagay proper infrastructure bananay main j20s proper 5th gen aircraft hai jabki j35A ab jakay refine hua agar Indian airforce AJ finalize karay to minimum 4 say 5 Saal lagay gain but hosakta hai it's not too late
Kya faida, baad mein dubara vapas le lenge. Lol
100 times bhi spend karle DRDO ...kuch nahi kar payega ...chote soch se kuch nahi hota
Kuch nahi hoga. Old wine new bottle. 😂
Kutte ka tail hamesha teda hee hai.
Mei bhee ek Indian hu. Magar ye defence ke ghatiya system dhekke politics hee achha lagta hai 😢
Freebies laughing in corner 😥
भारत को कम से कम सिंगल इंजन फाइटर जैट तो खुद बनाने चाहिए ड्यूल इंजिन बड़े फाइटर जैट दूसरे देशों से खरीदने चाहिए।
HAL ka share le lu kya?
Haan aage khaafi growth hogi tejas mk2 amca luh imrh etc
@@honeybeee23 le liya
No chance for an outdated India to remain on the map of the world
Yeah because pakistan is known for its economic growth and technological advancements
So he disagrees with airforce chief who knows more than any other youtuber. 😂
4th generation engine😂😂😂 now start to make 6th generation😅😅😅😅
After 40 years not even 40 Tejas produced and planning to make 6th generation fighter jet