What can India learn from the Russia-Ukraine war? | Grand Strategy With GD Bakshi
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ม.ค. 2024
- In this edition of the 'Grand Strategy With GD Bakshi', he talks about the Russia-Ukraine war heading towards its decisive phase. He talks about Russia having an upper hand in the war and the possibility of a ceasefire. He believes as the war heads towards its decisive phase, it may also be moving towards a final intensification.
#russia #ukraine #russiaukrainewar #gdbakshi #warnews #russiaukrainewar #trendingnews #breakingnews #topnews
Republic TV is India's no.1 English news channel since its launch. It is your one-stop destination for all the live news updates from India and around the world. Republic TV makes news accessible for you at your convenience, at all times and across devices. At Republic we keep you updated with up-to-the-minute news on politics, sports, entertainment, lifestyle, gadgets and much more.
We believe in Breaking the story and Breaking the Silence. But most importantly, for us ‘You Are Republic, We Are Your Voice.’
Also, Watch ►
Republic TV Live News Updates ►bit.ly/RepublicTVLiveNews
The Debate With Arnab Goswami ► bit.ly/TheDebateWithArnabGoswami
Patriot With Major Gaurav Arya ► bit.ly/PatriotFullEpisodes
Exclusive Sunday Debate With Arnab Goswami ► bit.ly/SundayDebate
Checkmate With Major Gaurav Arya (Retd.) ► bit.ly/3EtPj0s
The Grand Strategy With Maj Gen G.D Bakshi (Retd) ► bit.ly/3EPZ6xF
R.Explained ► bit.ly/3sOLT5K
R.Uninterrupted ► bit.ly/34isZdh
You can stay connected with Republic TV on -
Facebook - / republicworld
Twitter - / republic
Website - www.republicworld.com
Instagram: / republicworld
Disclaimer: Republic Media Network may provide content through third-party websites, operating systems, platforms, and portals (‘Third-Party Platforms’). Republic does not control and has no liability for Third-Party Platforms, including content hosted, advertisements, security, functionality, operation, or availability.
Finally, I was wondering when Mr. General Bakshi would share his knowledge about future of special military op. in Ukraine.
Puler is pay him very well 🤑
People of India bee proud! GD Bakhsi he is an treasure.
Quality analysis from the general ! Thank you sir for your excellent work.
As usual he is roaring like a lion i salute my indian general
I have much respect of this General ❤❤❤❤ he is the Best with the Best Analysis. Thank you so much
Very nicely analysed, studied & observed war. By our strategist who is indeed a veteran & professional in his own ways.
Thanks General❤
General Bakshi's analysis is not only clear and excellent, but most importantly based on logic and facts.
India really needs to push very very hard for high technology, manpower and military might, because this will be the era of great powers. India needs to revolutionize its manufacturing base, that very weakness that it followed the west into (IT IT IT IT IT IT!!!).....now we feel the pain. Todays wars will be those of attrition, self sufficiency, quantity, strategy and tactics to use the tools, rather how much stealth per square inch does my plane have etc etc.
Until this time diplomacy will be required and India needs to keep its time tested non-alignment policy to ensure the large powers and their serfs eat each other into oblivion. India needs to emerge as a new civilizationation, intellectual, economic, cultural and most importantly military super power with ambitions without repeating mistakes of past Asian powers (Meiji Japan).
JAI HIND!
One thing INDIA should learn from these wars. Is that INDIA shouldn't get sucked or get involved in any of these wars. Never ever to fight anybody's dirty war. But, be prepared & adopt the hi-tech technology.
Very interesting. But one nonsense: china will never take Taiwan by force, because if they just wait Taiwan will fall into their arms like a ripe fruit die to chinese economic and money power
I would say the opposite. India can't defeat Xi's aggression by herself. It makes sense for India to lead a coalition of countries to contain Xi. Including Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Vietnam, Philippines, Indonesia, Sri Lanka, Australia, France, USA and whoever else is willing to join.
This means that in the event of Taiwan, India has to help her allies.
If you mean that India should try to ween Russia away from China and try to stay out of the Israel / Gaza war . . . then we agree.
@@AnAn___ AnAn probabil că înseamnă anus.
In such case India will open it's front to settle score with china ????????.-jaihind har har mahadev mahadev.
But Mr modi is not wise opportunistic and autocratic will cost India dearly I have no two minds about it -jaihind god bless my country defence forces harhar mahadev.
The guy is truly a general and he demonstrate the level of his credibility.
Thank you sir , salute !
Wise man.
GENERAL GD BAKSHI ji Retd. Kindly advise our MODIJI. To make all the preparations to get back our POK & GB at rhe earliest.
Gen. G.D. Bakshi is a God given gift to our beloved nation and us. He is a highly educated, very talented, deeply patriotic soldier who fought and won several wars. He is one of the few, if not the one, who is an expert military strategist of our times. His analyses and opinions are of such great military value. Dr. Bakshi is such a great motivational speaker that he could hold anyone’s attention for ever. May Gen. Bakshi be blessed with a long, healthy and active life, for the sake of our country and us. JAI BHARATH
General is full of understanding for Russia.
Very insightful analysis
I enjoy the generals honest fact based talk.
Thank you, General, for your analysis update.
Ukraine is where the most hardcore and bloody battles are happening which test the whole nation's willpower correctly stated by him.
Quality content !!
The best analysis by far by our Rtd. General! I follow Ruissia Ukraine War news everyday. I can say, with full conviction, that anyone watching this full interview will get the best analysis what happend so far, why happened & what's the way forward for them & lessons for us!!
incredible analysis.
GENERAL PLEASE PLEASE COME ON ❤❤❤❤ WY ARE TAKING LONG TO CONE BACK WITH YOUR Best analysis?????Please we need you please GENERAL ❤❤❤ we wish you all d best. Please come gor another Analysis please. Many love General thank you
What would be Major Gen Bakshi's recommendations on how many:
---HAL Prachands India need?. Currently only 171 are planned. Many more, in my view, are needed.
---Weaponized HAL HTT-40s India needs for CAS? Far too few are planned. These are far cheaper for CAS than other options.
---heavy lift rotary wing aircraft India needs? And what skews?
---K-9 Vajra-T 155 mm arty are needed (Gen Bakshi said a lot more)?
---DRDO Advanced Towed Artillery Gun System (ATAGS) 155 mm arty are needed (Gen Bakshi said a lot more)?
---Pinaka MBRL multiple rocket launchers needed?
---NAMICA? Are more than 200 needed?
As Gen Bakshi said, the Hal Tejas Mark 1A and Mark 2 are major game changers. And India plans to buy many hundreds of each skew.
Tell Modi to bring back our strong manpower.
The lesson is to stay the heck out of this war as they have been .period full stop .....!!
Im very much agree with Mr bakshi in world scenerio.. current govt is not serious about war to pak and china, instead engulged in home war like destroying democracy and opposition. I must say this is very surprising what we need and what we are doing 😢.. time to remove present government and have a peace..im indian and proud to be ❤
Always on point sir cudos sir thank you 🙏
What India learn. 1/ make your own weapons. 2/invest in drone and anti drone Technology, 3/war can last years, 4/ need mass storage of artillery and missiles, 5/ Don't let polictions dictate military strategy 5/ have allies.
I don’t agree here with all his analysis but I do like this guy ❤
SORRY! DIDNT THE ROMANS ALSO HAVE DIVISIONS IN THE FORM OF LEGIONS?
As allways brilliant analysis by Mr bakshi
Two things to learn: ONE, use tactful and DEFT diplomacy with public relations specialists, trained diplomats (including foreeign minister Jaishankar), and communication specialists creating both tactics and strategies to mitigate trouble with China and Pakistan and other countries. TWO - keep nuclear weapons projects highly ambitious and fast-tracked with changes in nuclear weapons poilcy and posturing. Using reactor-grade fuel (or AVLIS laser technologies if they are developed) can increase the nuclear weapons to over 500 weapons - and top-notch missiles like K-4 (which can maneuver all the way to the target) and Agni-5 (with Mach 25 top speed) can generally beat anti-missile defenses - and Brahmos cruise missiles are supersonic and capable of flying below in a terrain-hugging mode at supersonic speeds. A few hundred of these weapons will be a good deterrent.
With reactor-grade fuel, the use of a thermal bridge will allow a fission bomb with yields of 2-8 KT easily and the hydroden bomb's boosted fission primary can eliminate pre-detonation problems and allow a yield of 14-17 KT - ALL these yeilds are very powerful weapons when used in MASS SWARMING ATTACKS and precision strikes. Use of artificial intelligence using Israeli software would build extra nimbleness and speed. The main thing is training forces and developing anti-corruption/anti-espionage/anti-sabotage processes to keep highly efficient and distributed agile nuclear attack teams. The policy must also specify redlines when the no-first-use policy can be eliminated without notice. This is to build a DETERRENT and it does require boldness and brilliance that develops use cases and edge cases to work with.
Excellent video
6:25
Sir -- Please show the BOOK for an extended period on the screen so people can see what it is.
It was on-screen for less than a fraction of a second.
Nobody even got to see its cover let alone anything else.
The Title :
"Russia-Ukraine War Lessons Learned"
published in October, 2022.
if selenskyi ask for 500 000 chevrolet cars before war, USA would say, are you out of your mind, but weapons, no problem.
Punjab Maharaja Ranjit Singh’s general Hari Singh Nalwa brought Kashmir back to Punjab after hard fought battle with Afghanistan. Dogra treachery of backstabbing the Sikh army which they were part of gave the British victory over Punjab. Sikh army won Ladakh and would have also won Tibet had the Tibetans not asked help from Chinese. India lost half of Kashmir to Pakistan, losing land in Ladakh to Chinese. During World War 3 China and Pakistan will be launching a two front war on India to take rest of Kashmir, Ladakh and Arunachal Pardesh which China calls South Tibet. So many Maharaja Ranjit Singh soldiers fought and died bravely only to have India lose it all.
Jenerl is grand fire soot
a wise General, just 2 things, 1. the better choice for India is to be A Neutral State. very strong to defend themselves, but avoid all the provocations, and Bribes, specially from the U.S.A. and U.K. because this AngloSphere are very commited to fight proxy-wars , to promote divisions, civil wars, coup-de-etat, and use the another people to fight their wars.
2. in minute 39 I am hearing someone Cooking. so.. Enjoy Dinner General😋🥘
Very factual analysis of ending conflict in Ukraine by our respected General Saheb.
The war showed in Ukraine and Israel that you still need large numbers of infantry who are willing to die. You need kshatriyas. If you don't have warriors willing to fight every meter on the ground, you won't achieve anything. You can bombard the enemy with bombs or rockets, but the infantry must act after that, otherwise you will be stuck like Israel. They left the Gaza Strip in disgrace because they cannot fight the enemy face to face. They are lazy cowards who relied only on high technology, and they have degraded as warriors. God Himself tells Arjuna in the Bhagavad Gita that you can die. He doesn't give him a magic bullet to win. He says, "Rise and fight without thinking about losses or gains." This is a kshatriya. “If you leave, your enemies will always talk about your shame, and for a warrior, dishonor is worse than death.” This is what happened to Israel. So this spiritual knowledge lives today, it is not what happened in the past, it lives always, eternal truth
India should think 10 times before attacking POK, because where the war will go , no one can predict!!!!
If that happens rest assured We have already thought through
Russia🇷🇺 has stamina and capacity for long war because it has Energy products and technology
This is not an Aksai Chin issue which will give up easily...They are Ukrainians,they still have Soviet blood which butcher Putin unable to get it.😆😂
The biggest surprise in this war inmo is the incompetence of Russian military forces. Ukraine had very few trained troops and mostly old Soviet-era equipment. What had been supplied by Western countries were only light arms and in very small numbers. Still Russia haver had tremendous losses, a lot more than Ukraine has. The summer offensive didn't go as Ukraine had hoped and a disappointment for them and the Western allies. They lack some ingredients to perform real combined arms warfare, which to my surprise Russia also do. It is now an artillery and trench warfare with drones thrown into the equation. Russia has used a lot of old Soviet doctrine, which sometimes the Ukrainians have also fell into, with attack (meat) waves. Especially around the battle of Bachmut, were Wagner had access to prisoners who were used as meat waves-10's of thousands mowed down and blown to pieces as they advanced toward the Ukrainian trenches.
Russians proved to be a very competent force, they proved their stamina and tactical innovations, people like you from usa uk have shown their back part and ran away from Afghanistan
Agreed that we are back in the era of trench warfare. Only overwhelming, well-trained boots on the ground backed by massive amount of artillery, missiles, drones will win a war. Even tanks are dead, maybe even aircraft carriers! From the information we civilians get, it looks like the political geniuses are doing everything to make sure we lose a 2-front war. Even though we have the best 155 mm guns made locally, we are only ordering a few dozen of them. I wonder if we have enough missiles like Prithvi, Brahmos, Agni, Nirbhay? We need thousands. And cheap attack drones like the Iranian Shahed? I'm somehow skeptical.
Zelensky will take to his heels
This outdated general desperately backing Putin's loses and embarrassment deserves a commendable Oscar🙌🏅
Woke leftist
The general did not mention that most of the territories occupied by Russia were retaken by the Ukrainians. Russian territory is not attacked, but Ukrainian territory is. Ukraine did not receive any long-range weapons. If the Ukrainians got what they wanted from the West and were allowed to attack Russian territory, this war would look completely different, but then there would be a full escalation.
He did. But he didn't mention your propoganda
Free muslim Khasmir from Indian colonialism 😢
😂😂😂
4th spot: DPRK
Sorry but time, circumstances and place are mostly not the same even if it's slyly different and the outcome eventual different
Ukraine fraught bravely.. And are fighting hard against putin..
Today wars are changing... Big military with old Russian hardware proven to be a big failure against more motivated well trained fighter with high tech anti armor and sophisticated air defense system and artillery units like the Ukraine got from US.. Proved very effective against Russian tanks and Russia air force.
Pakistani generals are reviewing their military doctrine after Ukraine war😎
Is that why Abrams tanks are not allowed on battlefront ? Like British challengers . After German leopards were bbq-ed . Ukrainian army average soldier is 43 y.o . That means there are 50 and 60 years old dudes hiding in the trenches waiting for 155 mm US made wonder weapons .
That’s reality
What is the title of the movie you described?
2 years ago (i.e 24th Feb 2022)
He is the same general which guaranteed that Ukraine will fall within a week but his master Putin kept on disappointing his analysis 😆😂.
Is he on the front
The one thing that's essential is that the military strength and resilience of a nation should be internal. Excessive dependence on arms will certainly hobble a nation's strength, and numbers also matter. Countries with large self sustaining militaries have an advantage over smaller, dependent ones. India should absolutely increase its military to twice its strength and increase the budget massively, making sure that pensions are controlled.
Odd room this old goat is in.
As a Northeastern people which looks different from mainland indians i'm so worried that if the war erupts with China, we the people of Northeastern will face the casualties and the humiliations from mainland indians as we experienced from Covit pandemic.
This General is more sound and intelligent than most of our Idiot US Generals starting with the Defense secretary.
This cannot seriously be considered to be informative, but an extension of "Ruzzian" propaganda. So much of what he's saying is factually incorrect, that any conclusions made from it will be inherently flawed. Disappointing..🧐
🏦🇺🇸🇬🇧🏴☠️🌏🏴☠️🤺🇷🇺🌏🙏🏽
🏦🇺🇸🇬🇧🙅🏴☠️🌏🏴☠️🤺🇷🇺🌏
This is not an Aksai Chin issue which will give up easily...They are Ukrainians,they still have Soviet blood which Putin unable to get it.😆😂
Russia has continuously changed weapons and tactics.
The general is so bias and fact denier
Of course, he don't believe that Ukraine is winning, right?
😂
He kept saying Russia is winning from months. Same old analysis. And we like it because we took carry the same junk. 😂
Exactly 💯...
2 years ago (i.e 24th Feb 2022) He is the same general which guaranteed that Ukraine will fall within a week but his master Putin kept on disappointing his analysis 😆😂.
@@Here4Nowbakhmut and avdiivka
and I will be glad to see that comedian gone
RUSSIA COULDNT ACT BACK IN 2014 BECAUSE THEY DIDNT HAVE HYPERSONIC MISSILES BACK THEN.
incorrect information-Russian had hypersonic missiles since day 1 of the war -glide bombs .it seems it were invasion of scare Ukrainian forces to gave up thier demands of being part of nato -then ties has turn ugly where Russian said fuck ukraine and let’s destroy it .that is what happening now demolishing of the Ukrainian army.no one left to fight alongside Ukrainian forces.nato won’t dare to challenge russia.
just surrender ,
if they surrender in ukrain ,will taiwan be far behind , and if they surrender in both places
god bless us all . and america has lots of troops in korea ,japan ,and now lately in philipines
This is not an Aksai Chin issue which will give up easily...They are Ukrainians,they still have Soviet blood which Putin unable to get it.😆😂
India needs a defense industrial base.
Fully support Yemen houthi, stay need stop all shipping especially indian shipping, Indian needs to learn a hard lesson.
I'm Ukrainian just exploring what people far away from us think about the war.
This man spreads total bs. That makes me laugh.
Look. We have stalemate that is true. Why we have this? Because nor side has enough power to break frontline - it costs too much.
But until you listen to such a "commander" like this who just tries to explain you the thing he doesn't know, imagine if he will lead you in the battle.
You will not survive that battle under such an officer, i bet
He is a war hero who won against Pakistan which is supplied arms by ukraine
Read about the Kargil war. It was a mountain warfare and India was in disadvantage. Mountain warfares are 4 times more difficult than normal warfares. I want Ukraine to win but I don't see it happening.
Assumetric war.
America and Vietnam, America and Iraq, America and Syria, America and Syria, America and Afghanistan, America and Libya.
Hmmm why do I see a common factor in all of these wars.
No worry for India. Ayodhia solved all India’s problems. The black guy in it must be fed, clothed & washed. Concentrate on that rather.
You peddle your leftist-muzzlim narrative elsewhere. That has been tried and refused here.
and YET we are not moved!!!
This joker *TOTALLY* ignores russian losses, very biased reporting.
because nobody cares about russian losses.
❤❤Pakistan zinda abad❤❤
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
17:40 gen praising Ukrainian army