@@driedautumnleaf Actually not. It depends on the glass. Hit a glass with a spoon and listen the "note" it sounds, you must be singing the same note the glass produce with a high volume. That's the theory, I don't really know if Mariah or any person who can do whistle might break a glass, again, it requires a really high volume.
@@PRNOBTCH she’s not a alto , first of an alto are the voice in the back in a choir . A contralto is what you meant and she’s definitely not cuz a contralto could NEVER hit the notes she hits even with her every practice that you want . She’s a light soprano who can hit very high and low notes which is impressive for a human . She’s literally a goat !!
@@ulradeja5380 The end of the year is approaching and...AND THE AWARD FOR MOST ANNOYING OF THE YEAR GOES TO.... 🥁🥁🎊🎊🥳 Pam, pam, pam, pam,...... 🥁🥁 : "ULRADEJA 🍎🕶️ Uhuuuuuuuuuu wwwoowuww iiffiiiuuuu fiuuuu (laughs in whistle register), (applauses) . And obviously, her iconic legless entrance 😂🎊👌🏽.
i imagine her mother must have been so frustrated with her. her mom, the technically trained opera singer Julliard alum and vocal coach, having Mariah Carey for a daughter lol MC doesn't know anything about her own octave range, just that she can hit notes really well lmao. girl is naturally gifted.
Sara It's obvious that she knows a lot; she doesn't want to come across as a "know it all" eg. she obviously knows it's called a "whistle register" but she wants to relate to the common person so she refrains from calling it that...
Well I imagine her mother was frustrated because Mariah wasn’t using head voice. She was in the operatic range, but she wasn’t doing it traditionally. So I assume her mother immediately assumed she was using improper technique and that she would lose her voice if she kept doing it.
omg that lost interview gave me so much life. Proof that she is very intelligent and articulate. I think TV is just a lot of pressure, especially live TV, and she can only think of her go-to's when she's on air. She's definitely more comfortable just talking to someone with a tape recorder.
Christine Donley I wish she’d guest on a podcast or something so she could have the time and no pressure (and not be on the constant move lol) to go into full detail about these things or anything at all. I would die for something like that
@8:00 That is the first time I've EVER heard her actually admit she has vocal nodules. And I'm a LONG time fan. I've never actually seen/heard really any of these interviews.
She's mentioned the nodules on her vocal chords before when people question why she doesn't sound like she did in the early 90s. She explained that using that whistle so much and singing so powerfully was stressing her vocal chords causing the nodules to form. She also admitted that sometimes they work against her and other times they work in her favor.
I mean I’m sure she knows and is humbled that no other celeb/singer gets asked this so she tries to explain it as easy as she can for refusal humans to understand it loo
Yes Mariah is like black Canary from DC lmbo but fr her voice is a super power and she can bend it in like almost a infinite amount of ways it's just so cool to me
I taught myself how to hit a lot of her whistles by ear. The problem with that is without hearing the note being performed, I can't do it myself. I think thats called a false note or something but I know its not out of my capability because in the process of learning to do her whistles by ear, I learned how to do high head voice notes like Debelah Morgan without needing to hear them. I just wish there was a stable, healthy technique to get my voice to switch into that register smoothly. This maybe a stupid concern especially since I know of a singer who can do both, minnie riperton, but I'm afraid of losing my ability to go up like Debelah Morgan in the process of learning to whistle freely.
Wow, my situation is so similar to Mariah's! I hit whistles mostly in the morning when I was a kid. (The only time when I hit whistles is when I'm tired)
Same. I can not tell you the note(s) that I reach, cause here, in France, we don't write notes in numbers, like you. But for the example, I can make the "Someday" whistle, and the "Lead The Way" whistle, too. But there are days "without"... As you know :)
But I've always had a hard time with the whistle from "Dreamlover", and "There's Got To Be A Way". Oh, and "Vanishing". Not because of the note itself. But because of how she slips from a belted note with vibrato to a whistle. I need to gain agility in my technique. Yet, I still don't know how to aquire it....How does a singer work on their agility / how quick you jump from one note / register, to another. That's the toughest part to me...And of course, my dream is to be able to hit that note she did for MTV's commercial, you know with her Dog, dubbed by Snoop Dogg. Now, THAT final note...Is my dream. Workin' on it ! ^_^
Catherine VAZ Having a whistle register is amazing whether you can control it or not! If you do learn to control it, I would love to hear some videos of it. Also, the "Someday" note is the B (B6) above a Soprano C (C6), which in itself is a very high note. :)
THANK YOU 4 UPLOADING THIS! Ive been looking for her talking about this bc i have a whistle register too andall im really finding out is we have similar experiences but it still helps for me to hear her experiences too! ty!
Actually the same for me. The clearer my chest voice the less good my whistle is and of my chest voice is raspy and hoarse my whistle is so much better.
I learnt how to whistle the exact same way. When I would wake up with a hoarse voice, I can whistle all day long. Sometimes when my voice isn't hoarse it just doesn't happen.
Must record, but that is how I found my whistle register while singing; but I recommend singing within the range you have for the lower voices and higher voices: like alto, finding a tenor digging deep; or a countertenor for looking up; either a first or a second of a voice. Some whistle notes are outside of the singing range, doesn't mean other notes aren't in there.
Head voice works like in a flute (where instead of vocal cords, the air flow bounces in the headroom and makes it resonate The Bee Gees' Staying Alive is argueably the best example for that. I think Mariah's whistle is just a head voice where her head contains narrower tunnels so it reaches higher frequencies
i can make a squeaky sound with my voice if it's dry and a little swollen. So sometimes I want my voice to be always hoarse so can make those squeaky sounds.
Y'all might not believe me but one time my voice was hoarse and broken lol and I was hitting high notes and I thought I unlocked my Mariah voice lol but my voice became normal and it stopped working lol
I can do whistle and I'm under 14😊😊I'm super happy bc I can sing all MARIH songs with whistle😍😍😍😍for me it's simple,but before....😑😑😑😑was really hard....you must has a very control of your whistle and you must know use at the right moment(bc when I talk and Smile,I sometimes do a whistle stronger like a bird and my friends look me in a strained mode)😂😂😂😂😂sorry guys,isn't my fault👍👍
She was so much more down to earth back then and didn't talk in that fake voice that she does today. And don't hate! I like her and her music but anyone that listens to her old interview then the new ones can tell the difference. I mean, obviously she's gonna change through the years, everyone does and that's okay. I just can't stand when celebrities talk in that fake ass voice.
I looove her new show! Shes definitely a diva, she has fun with it, lol, but shows another side to her, a little deeper. I love her! She seems like she'd be a good girl friend & fun to hang out with. Loove Mariahs World.
I think there is a greater risk to the surgery than just not hitting whistle register. But I would rather keep my abilities in my power range than do some whistles and not be able to belt out a regular high note.
It's not as hard as one might make you believe. You don't push it like you would falsetto and then try to go higher. You push hair through the vocal cords like you would when you whistle out of your mouth. Try doing it by inhaling first
Markiese Franklin Yep. I always talk in it at College and then people always get me to swear in it or see how high I can go cause it 'amuses' them -_- Lol But yeah, talking in it is a nice ease into singing into it. That is how I learned
SilentAssassin01234 cool I jus learned it by constantly screaming and then I slipped into it😂😂😂😂 but befo I learned I used to use falsetto and thot I was doing it but then I learned I wasn't doing it so I screamed and slipped in it ( keep in mine in took me overall like 3 years to finally discover my whistle)
She must be so sick of hearing about glass shattering
Lol true, I doubt a whistle note can shatter a glass. There's a certain frequency that does that
Iiiikkkkkrrrrrr
TennilleF1 EXACTLY what I was thinking.
@@driedautumnleaf Actually not. It depends on the glass. Hit a glass with a spoon and listen the "note" it sounds, you must be singing the same note the glass produce with a high volume. That's the theory, I don't really know if Mariah or any person who can do whistle might break a glass, again, it requires a really high volume.
it's funny because she has to answer same questions over and over again
can u do the high notes for us?Like do the interviewers not watch her interviews before asking her these questions??!
That's good that means she's not lying
For different sources
Well I would too they dont realize that takes alot of your voice she was sick of it but she got the gift she is a alto but her range is phenomenal
@@PRNOBTCH she’s not a alto , first of an alto are the voice in the back in a choir . A contralto is what you meant and she’s definitely not cuz a contralto could NEVER hit the notes she hits even with her every practice that you want . She’s a light soprano who can hit very high and low notes which is impressive for a human . She’s literally a goat !!
Mariah is so magestic. She's been singing in the most challenging key yet her speaking voice is low. Very magical. 😍
*She's the greatest voice ever dubbed in music history. Her dubbed vocals are perfectly dubbed and successfully presented as authentic*
@@ulradeja5380 HAHAHAHA
Ironic, right?
@@ulradeja5380 The end of the year is approaching and...AND THE AWARD FOR MOST ANNOYING OF THE YEAR GOES TO.... 🥁🥁🎊🎊🥳 Pam, pam, pam, pam,...... 🥁🥁 : "ULRADEJA 🍎🕶️
Uhuuuuuuuuuu wwwoowuww iiffiiiuuuu fiuuuu (laughs in whistle register), (applauses) . And obviously, her iconic legless entrance 😂🎊👌🏽.
@@ulradeja5380 LOL you are soo obsessed omggg. Why are you on every Mariah video?!
i imagine her mother must have been so frustrated with her. her mom, the technically trained opera singer Julliard alum and vocal coach, having Mariah Carey for a daughter lol MC doesn't know anything about her own octave range, just that she can hit notes really well lmao. girl is naturally gifted.
Sara It's obvious that she knows a lot; she doesn't want to come across as a "know it all" eg. she obviously knows it's called a "whistle register" but she wants to relate to the common person so she refrains from calling it that...
Quit ironic
An Uncontrollable gift that become a legend
Well I imagine her mother was frustrated because Mariah wasn’t using head voice. She was in the operatic range, but she wasn’t doing it traditionally. So I assume her mother immediately assumed she was using improper technique and that she would lose her voice if she kept doing it.
@@whitneyhoustonstan2472 her mother was actually quite jealous of her, she once told Mariah that Mariah will never become the singer that she was
Well, her mother should have taught her then. 💁🏿♂️
her whistles are heavenly
some of these are SOOO RARE. YASSSSS
yasss
All for me 😭
She mentioned Minnie Ripperton @4:30 ❤️❤️❤️
Both Legends 👍
Finally!
She’s been mentioning her since 1990….
Mariah is so natural like she doesn’t need to force her voice to do whistle like others its just coming even she doesn’t need to.
wow. these interviews made me realize how eloquent she is. her speaking voice is also beautiful!!
omg that lost interview gave me so much life. Proof that she is very intelligent and articulate. I think TV is just a lot of pressure, especially live TV, and she can only think of her go-to's when she's on air. She's definitely more comfortable just talking to someone with a tape recorder.
Christine Donley I wish she’d guest on a podcast or something so she could have the time and no pressure (and not be on the constant move lol) to go into full detail about these things or anything at all. I would die for something like that
Mariah Carey is truly talented and has a powerful high whistle register voice
@8:00 That is the first time I've EVER heard her actually admit she has vocal nodules. And I'm a LONG time fan. I've never actually seen/heard really any of these interviews.
tangled55 b
She's mentioned the nodules on her vocal chords before when people question why she doesn't sound like she did in the early 90s. She explained that using that whistle so much and singing so powerfully was stressing her vocal chords causing the nodules to form. She also admitted that sometimes they work against her and other times they work in her favor.
@@pw6160 she literally never said that she had then since a kid 🙄🙄
@@strangerthings88 Exactly! Imagine blatantly lying about what Mariah has said about her voice to push a false narrative.
@@GarageStudio7 soo many people do it it’s insanely odd
You have the most beautiful high notes Mariah.
I love the fact she barely ever calls it whistle register or whistles note
Its definitely not "whistle tones"..its register..or "notes"
@@jaypaidincash but the person has mentioned “notes” only
@@jaypaidincash it is tones
@@ethanevans810 u have Ariana as your profile pic...can't take u seriously.
@@jaypaidincash shut up. Ariana's OG fans know a quite a lot of vocal pedagogy.
7:59-8:12 MARIAH TALKING ABOUT HAVING NODULES.
you be on every video lamby lol L4L
Mesmerized 4Life lol yes I am!!!!
ImperfectbutRedeemed You got a channel lamby? :-)
Mesmerized 4Life lol just click on my username and you will get the answer
It’s annoying that she kept encountering the same old questions. But she’s a good sport about it.
I mean I’m sure she knows and is humbled that no other celeb/singer gets asked this so she tries to explain it as easy as she can for refusal humans to understand it loo
7:34 she mentioned LISA FISCHER. yassss
+ImperfectbutRedeemed how can i ease the pain
+Mia mchugh lol I know
yh i know u know just saying it so ppl see silly x
+ImperfectbutRedeemed she had humility, i like that about her
Lisa Fischer=the reason Luther Vandross will always have the best background singers (80s)
During interview at 6:24 and so on, her voice was so much clearer and now she speaks with this thick raspy voice
Nodules got worse
B Angel also age. That interview is from 1999, 20 years ago. She’s almost 50 now, if her voice didn’t change at all, I’d be worried
So cute when she talks in that high pitch
6:05 I love that she was saying things like _'singer singer'_ even way back in the day. 😁
her voice is one of a kind and shes beautiful too
Yes Mariah is like black Canary from DC lmbo but fr her voice is a super power and she can bend it in like almost a infinite amount of ways it's just so cool to me
lol she's always been such a diva. Love her!
What a gift of a singer she is
I taught myself how to hit a lot of her whistles by ear. The problem with that is without hearing the note being performed, I can't do it myself. I think thats called a false note or something but I know its not out of my capability because in the process of learning to do her whistles by ear, I learned how to do high head voice notes like Debelah Morgan without needing to hear them. I just wish there was a stable, healthy technique to get my voice to switch into that register smoothly. This maybe a stupid concern especially since I know of a singer who can do both, minnie riperton, but I'm afraid of losing my ability to go up like Debelah Morgan in the process of learning to whistle freely.
Wish this video was a whole long documentary about her voice
I love mariah carey. With or even without those whistle notes ❤
oh my god! i have never seen some of these! so interesting.
9:16 super clean Whistle
Hi arianator :)
@@nickimojicabutera385 hiiiiieee
Love the analysis on her whistle register
Wooowww in 3:30,little whistle and a very very agile runs😮😮😮
The legendary range .y'all fave could NEVER
My said "Marian Carey can do the whistle better than you" I said "she can do it better than anyone who's ever existed".
Mariah: Well its just a part of my voice.. Like its just whatever & normal 😂
Wow, my situation is so similar to Mariah's! I hit whistles mostly in the morning when I was a kid. (The only time when I hit whistles is when I'm tired)
it's easier because less space in between vocal chords cause higher notes. your chords are swollen or inflamed
i can do whistle notes but not all the time
Englebert Villegas I feel you
Englebert Villegas same
Same. I can not tell you the note(s) that I reach, cause here, in France, we don't write notes in numbers, like you. But for the example, I can make the "Someday" whistle, and the "Lead The Way" whistle, too. But there are days "without"... As you know :)
But I've always had a hard time with the whistle from "Dreamlover", and "There's Got To Be A Way". Oh, and "Vanishing". Not because of the note itself. But because of how she slips from a belted note with vibrato to a whistle. I need to gain agility in my technique. Yet, I still don't know how to aquire it....How does a singer work on their agility / how quick you jump from one note / register, to another. That's the toughest part to me...And of course, my dream is to be able to hit that note she did for MTV's commercial, you know with her Dog, dubbed by Snoop Dogg. Now, THAT final note...Is my dream. Workin' on it ! ^_^
Catherine VAZ Having a whistle register is amazing whether you can control it or not! If you do learn to control it, I would love to hear some videos of it. Also, the "Someday" note is the B (B6) above a Soprano C (C6), which in itself is a very high note. :)
aww my puppy looks directly at me when that intro played
That is amazing.
love her😍😍💖
I like it when she is answering about her whistle register. Like how I like answering about my speed and flexibility.
Still my favorite singer
THANK YOU 4 UPLOADING THIS!
Ive been looking for her talking about this bc i have a whistle register too andall im really finding out is we have similar experiences but it still helps for me to hear her experiences too! ty!
Every body has the same joke
OMG! I love your channel sooo much!!
+Daria Oliver wow thank you !!!
"omg i bet you can break glass!" lol she must be so annoyed
Great video!
+Thi Hills Yeah it sounds too high ahah
+Thi Hills on 0:15-0:16 did she hit the whistle while talking?
Thi hills would you make Mariah Whistle range without singing for us?
To me it sounds raspy! like she sang too much and then gave the interview
Thi Hills Music yes. I was actually thinking her speaking voice here seems higher than normal
Its for non copyright reasons
I love her
I think it's beautiful!
I have a whistle register but I have a hard time controlling it
shes so perfect : DD !!!!
Actually the same for me. The clearer my chest voice the less good my whistle is and of my chest voice is raspy and hoarse my whistle is so much better.
I can do them now whenever i please, but i usually have to warm up a couple times. It took a couple years to get it to come out that easily tho
Great video.
My high notes come out like wheezing when laughing to the point of not being able to breath, but still breathing.
SAMEEEE ... I breathe in ... When I yawn ...while I was sick... I figured it out
I learnt how to whistle the exact same way. When I would wake up with a hoarse voice, I can whistle all day long. Sometimes when my voice isn't hoarse it just doesn't happen.
Joshua Hoy Be careful, you could have nodules; Mariah is one of the only people who have learned to sing through them as well....
GarageStudio girl if having nodules means sounding sexy while speaking and also being able to do whistles like that then GIMME DEM NODULES !!
@@MariosPOS hahahahahhahah
5:14 Mariah talking about her oversinging.
She never oversang. Christiana Aguilera or Jessie J are the very definition of that
3:34😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Must record, but that is how I found my whistle register while singing; but I recommend singing within the range you have for the lower voices and higher voices: like alto, finding a tenor digging deep; or a countertenor for looking up; either a first or a second of a voice. Some whistle notes are outside of the singing range, doesn't mean other notes aren't in there.
Head voice works like in a flute (where instead of vocal cords, the air flow bounces in the headroom and makes it resonate
The Bee Gees' Staying Alive is argueably the best example for that.
I think Mariah's whistle is just a head voice where her head contains narrower tunnels so it reaches higher frequencies
I think Stayin Alive is in falsetto.
@@whitneyhouston1122 Before I saw the video I was convinced I hear women singing
3:34...cool when she explained what she does when the whistle doesnt come out. She justs drops way down.
she's so talented guilty again big fan since I was a kid Hi mimi!💖 no I can't do the whistle note! geez!
shakira kinda looks like the young mariah carey
Well they're both South American, so perhaps that's why🎁
Ciarra Johnson Mariah is american
Ciarra Johnson shes african american
How come? White like that?
Kelly França she's half white
The clips from KBS lol. Kdrama fans know what I'm talkin bout 😂
What you're talking about?? Tell me
'4:51 is there today? Coz its not always there' Relate😂 Yaah whistle is not always there
i can make a squeaky sound with my voice if it's dry and a little swollen. So sometimes I want my voice to be always hoarse so can make those squeaky sounds.
Vladimir Pereira She never said "dry" she has a naturally raspy voice, some days it's more hoarse...
Y'all might not believe me but one time my voice was hoarse and broken lol and I was hitting high notes and I thought I unlocked my Mariah voice lol but my voice became normal and it stopped working lol
Her voice really changed 7:43 shookt
That’s the interviewer talking at 7:43.
I can do whistle and I'm under 14😊😊I'm super happy bc I can sing all MARIH songs with whistle😍😍😍😍for me it's simple,but before....😑😑😑😑was really hard....you must has a very control of your whistle and you must know use at the right moment(bc when I talk and Smile,I sometimes do a whistle stronger like a bird and my friends look me in a strained mode)😂😂😂😂😂sorry guys,isn't my fault👍👍
💗💗💗💗💗💗
@3:32 Mariah be like she just farted her whistle. 💗 So naturally gifted.
💟
I can do whistle notes when somebody steps on my foot or when I find out somebody touched my stuff.
lol
I think for some people, her method could be the easier way to get the whistle register
ha! Trey had braids!!!! 😅
She was so much more down to earth back then and didn't talk in that fake voice that she does today. And don't hate! I like her and her music but anyone that listens to her old interview then the new ones can tell the difference. I mean, obviously she's gonna change through the years, everyone does and that's okay. I just can't stand when celebrities talk in that fake ass voice.
+Songbird she's a diva that's the difference
+Songbird she earned her title and she's not the only one all divas look it up. Smdh
+MJ JACKSON Yeah I never said she didn't deserve to be where she is. But no matter what you do you never have the right to be a bitch. smh
+Songbird lol mariah isn't really the bitchy diva that y'all think she is, she's actually very nice
I looove her new show! Shes definitely a diva, she has fun with it, lol, but shows another side to her, a little deeper. I love her! She seems like she'd be a good girl friend & fun to hang out with. Loove Mariahs World.
Right
3:39 is such a daddyyyy
It's a part of my voice several times lol
4:40 so that interview explains Charmbracelet era style of singing xd
Minnie mouse could never
This is why she can't have the surgery I guess if the nodules allow her to hit the high notes. What can you do if she can't have the surgery.
Learn to sing around and through them but eventually it gets worse
I think there is a greater risk to the surgery than just not hitting whistle register. But I would rather keep my abilities in my power range than do some whistles and not be able to belt out a regular high note.
It's not as hard as one might make you believe. You don't push it like you would falsetto and then try to go higher. You push hair through the vocal cords like you would when you whistle out of your mouth. Try doing it by inhaling first
8:20 @Can't Let Go's 7th octave whistles, lmao
Mimi 🌹❤☝👍👌👏
Garage door opening
1:47 lmaooo
1:10 my goshh vv::
@TL The interview segment from about 5:00 to 7:40 --where is that from?
Yelena B
Her nodules
(Whisper)
i can do it to it is fun
Can someone tell me who's interviewing her at 3:39? What show was that?
That was her moms karma, to hear her daughter sing that way after years of telling her “you could only hope to be half as good as me”.
at 3:51 what was that interview and what year
what is a nodule? now I have to look that up?
I also didn't know what they are
These bumps that appear on the vocal cords that make your voice crack and very raspy
I can do whistle very easily😀
9:09 what performance is that?? looks live.
David letterman’s 2005
1:42 was natural ?
I can sing a whistle note but not up to a G6 💀💀💀 just a bit lower.
I use the same technique for my whistles
Markiese Franklin SAME.
We're like Mariah :D
Markiese Franklin Yep. I always talk in it at College and then people always get me to swear in it or see how high I can go cause it 'amuses' them -_- Lol
But yeah, talking in it is a nice ease into singing into it. That is how I learned
SilentAssassin01234 cool I jus learned it by constantly screaming and then I slipped into it😂😂😂😂 but befo I learned I used to use falsetto and thot I was doing it but then I learned I wasn't doing it so I screamed and slipped in it ( keep in mine in took me overall like 3 years to finally discover my whistle)
SilentAssassin01234 wats the highest note u've Eva hit in whistle?
No one:
Me when I step on a lego: 0:06
I think your voice range is five and1forth Sing like a love bird.
4:08 Does anyone have the link? Or know how is it named?
th-cam.com/video/18he0V-9ZTI/w-d-xo.html
@@w4ka997 thanksjsj