So beautiful and sensitive performance. Sounds great with normal instruments. This is my favorite concerto of J.S.Bach. Thank you for sharing, recording also best here in youtube I have found.
A beautiful performance! Incidentally, for all you who think that Bach should be performed ONLY on period instruments, that just doesn't make sense. If Bach had had access to a modern violin and oboe, he would have been overjoyed with the opportunity to write for both the Baroque and the modern instruments. He was the great innovator! Just think what he could have done with a Moog synthesizer! Boggles the mind!
Point being, however, that Bach WOULD have loved to write for those instruments, but he didn't. He wrote for instruments of the period, with their sound and particular quality in mind; so the exact deep subtlety of the piece fits the period instruments better than it fits the modern instruments.
Really, really beautiful performance. Once you hear a performance, it is always difficult for other performances to excel with me. But this one did. Thank you!
Not just that, but this conductor perfectly understood, that it is a concerto ( musical competition between the singing - instruments for a higher level of musical unit) so, He recognised that how much is important to make every melody line sound very clear while they play them against each other, which gives us the whole and unified beauty, transformed it intoBach's baroque polyphony. It is also means the recognition of the importance of the basso continuo! Lovely version indeed, however the third movement is a slightly fast to the musicians, but I love that tempo though. :)
Excelso, profundidad, esencia bachiana conjuntada en ritmo, tempo y sonoridad, maravillosa interpretación, genial, aunque creo que lo tengo en mas de 5 versiones y lo tengo escuhado cientos de veces, me ha emocionado como la primera vez, genial ése directo fresco y vivo bravisimo!!!
It's always more difficult to hear the solo violinist on most recordings, mainly because it blends naturally with accompanied strings and the oboe is naturally more distinctive. One comment mentioned too many strings which is hogwash. Microphone placement would help distinguish the solo violinist and raise it with the oboist. The Adagio is fine because the strings are using pizzicato. My favorite is Harold Gomberg and Issac Stern. In that recording is not such a frantic rushing sensation, but more relaxed yet still moves ahead simply. Who wants this splendid music to end any faster than it needs to?
les violons vous jouez trop forts place aux solistes c'est inacceptable .Il faut jouer piano c'est toujours plus joli .Vous faites n'importe quoi .Finalement vous etes nuls
Que mal colocados los micrófonos o que malo el i g de sonido, el oboe no se aprecia, el violin suena demasiado y la Orquesta tapa todo. Por otro lado el 3er mvto sin gracia como si todos estuvieran apurados por irse. Es concierto pierde su garbo por artistas que por dárselas de virtuosos tocan todo demasiado rápido, que mal.
agreed!!! that is like saying that a Mozart Piano Concerto must ONLY be played on the first pianofortes of that day. Some people just cannot deal with progress. I like period instruments and pitch as much as anyone, but I would never say that something can ONLY be played in a certain pitch, a certain instrument.... how silly to negate anything contemporary as being "less-than"
![[NYCP] Bach - Concerto for 2 Violins in D minor (Xiao Wang & Elizabeth Fayette)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hSNKc2cOBdw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[NYCP] Bach - Concerto for 2 Violins in D minor (Xiao Wang & Elizabeth Fayette)](/img/tr.png)
Finally, a violinist who can keep the tempo in the 3rd movement during the hard parts.
It’s absolutely beautiful and I am over joyed to hear these talented young people playing J.S. Bach’s divine music.
Thank you very much.
Undoubtedly among the best recordings of this remarkable concerto.
Love this so much. Keep coming back to it.
Many thanks! :)
Super ! Bravo ! Bach would be proud. So beautiful. Chapeau.
Glad you like it!
So beautiful and sensitive performance. Sounds great with normal instruments. This is my favorite concerto of J.S.Bach. Thank you for sharing, recording also best here in youtube I have found.
Thanks for listening
This incredible piece has brought my love for chamber music to another level.❤️
thanks for listening!
A beautiful performance! Incidentally, for all you who think that Bach should be performed ONLY on period instruments, that just doesn't make sense. If Bach had had access to a modern violin and oboe, he would have been overjoyed with the opportunity to write for both the Baroque and the modern instruments. He was the great innovator! Just think what he could have done with a Moog synthesizer! Boggles the mind!
imagine him with an electric guitar xD
fydler7640 The problem is, having these more powerful modern strings sort of downplays the solo violin.
Point being, however, that Bach WOULD have loved to write for those instruments, but he didn't.
He wrote for instruments of the period, with their sound and particular quality in mind; so the exact deep subtlety of the piece fits the period instruments better than it fits the modern instruments.
A key idea for me personally is warmth. The current forms of the instruments have much greater warmth.
i,m in heaven! so beautiful!
Just beautiful performance!
Thanks for listening
The sound of heaven!
Many thanks!
Really, really beautiful performance.
Once you hear a performance, it is always difficult for other performances to excel with me. But this one did. Thank you!
Sounds good , good work 👏👏👏👏🎻🎵🎶🎵🎼
Très bon ! ❤️
Merci
2 solistes d'excellence,haute admiration
Divine!
Que maravilla de música y músicos, que frescura, no parece que deba tener casi 300 años. ❤
¡Gracias por escuchar!
This wonderful music makes me exciting!
Thank you !!!
Wonderful ❤️
Excellent!
why is this so perfect?
George, the explanation is that it is J. S. Bach. Enough said!
Well, I totally agree!
George Ayoub っっq
Not just that, but this conductor perfectly understood, that it is a concerto ( musical competition between the singing - instruments for a higher level of musical unit) so, He recognised that how much is important to make every melody line sound very clear while they play them against each other, which gives us the whole and unified beauty, transformed it intoBach's baroque polyphony. It is also means the recognition of the importance of the basso continuo! Lovely version indeed, however the third movement is a slightly fast to the musicians, but I love that tempo though. :)
And nice resonance!
Genuine players and wonderful venue.
Absolutely I would have been moved.
Excelso, profundidad, esencia bachiana conjuntada en ritmo, tempo y sonoridad, maravillosa interpretación, genial, aunque creo que lo tengo en mas de 5 versiones y lo tengo escuhado cientos de veces, me ha emocionado como la primera vez, genial ése directo fresco y vivo bravisimo!!!
Perfectly!
Beautiful! So well done
Thank you for listening!!
une splendeur d'entre les splendeurs,admiration profonde
This unravels all the confusion found in science, religion, and summarizes it all ... at least for me.
Beautiful execution congratulations for your great work ❤
Thank you very much!
11:32 goosebumps
thanks
music for the Gods.
Esplendida interpretación,bravo
wonderful
Many thanks
Movement 1 is the best!
Saubere Aufführung, klasse
NYCP...명연주 (2)
Замечательное исполнение
I agree..
Божественные звуки дивного оркестра...
Рад, что тебе понравилось!
Совершенное исполнение
Спасибо вам большое
아~~ 소리 좋다.
This is excellent but they have too many strings. This make it very difficult to hear the Solo Violin part.
I think it's because they're using modern instruments.
It's always more difficult to hear the solo violinist on most recordings, mainly because it blends naturally with accompanied strings and the oboe is naturally more distinctive. One comment mentioned too many strings which is hogwash. Microphone placement would help distinguish the solo violinist and raise it with the oboist. The Adagio is fine because the strings are using pizzicato. My favorite is Harold Gomberg and Issac Stern. In that recording is not such a frantic rushing sensation, but more relaxed yet still moves ahead simply. Who wants this splendid music to end any faster than it needs to?
Would have been perfect if a bit slower, great harmony ❤
Thank you!
The baby...-.-
one person prefers maluma
Six * :'/
les violons vous jouez trop forts place aux solistes c'est inacceptable .Il faut jouer piano c'est toujours plus joli .Vous faites n'importe quoi .Finalement vous etes nuls
Que mal colocados los micrófonos o que malo el i g de sonido, el oboe no se aprecia, el violin suena demasiado y la Orquesta tapa todo. Por otro lado el 3er mvto sin gracia como si todos estuvieran apurados por irse. Es concierto pierde su garbo por artistas que por dárselas de virtuosos tocan todo demasiado rápido, que mal.
Why are you playing Bach with modern oboe? It does not have any sense.
Jan Figueras Shut up and enjoy the music
agreed!!! that is like saying that a Mozart Piano Concerto must ONLY be played on the first pianofortes of that day. Some people just cannot deal with progress. I like period instruments and pitch as much as anyone, but I would never say that something can ONLY be played in a certain pitch, a certain instrument.... how silly to negate anything contemporary as being "less-than"
why use a toilet when a chamber pot would do.........?
The most literature of oboes is barock. The moderns are created to make Bach and Handel sound good.
Too fast.