This was so fantastic! So detailed and clear and easy to follow. Thank you so much for all the care and attention you put into this video. I am grateful!
What you planted is a non-split coriander seed. They do come in a "pod" that has more than one seed. You can split them yourself and get the two out of the "pod" before you place them in the hole.
Hi JUDI,😃 beautiful cilantro plants, 😃 I have mines on mason jars covered with👍 newspaper. this was a 👍great progression 🎥video. GOD 🙏🙏BLESS YOU. EDUARDO MIAMI FL 🇺🇸
Hi Eduardo! Thanks for watching and commenting! I appreciate your comments on the video. It was a long one in the making. I have two more similar ones in progress (lettuce and kale). Hopefully they will help someone out there! Take care and God bless you and yours :)
Judi I’m starting a project using lucazade bottles with net cups same a you with the foil but I put an old sock over the foil rather than tape as does not damage / fall off easy. Trying on my window sill. Great video and well explained hopefully I will get good results 😂🤞. 👍
So helpful! I was hoping to figure out exactly what solution to use because there are so many to choose from. Is there a certain type? I don't mean the brand name. But I need to know something more specific than "nutrient solution". That's too vague and I assume different plants need different types/kinds of nutrient solutions or is it just a generic product I can go into a store and ask for and they won't ask me anything else because there is only one generic type of nutrient solution all plants grown hydroponically need?
Hi! Great questions! There are a number of brands of hydroponic nutrient solutions. I don't know that any one is any better than the other. Initially, I started using General Hydroponics MaxiGro and I've simply stayed with it ever since. If you have a good quality tap water, that alone should be fine with the MaxiGro (which is what I had when living in Iowa and where I made the video on cilantro). Now we're in another state and the household water system is "softened" with salt. That's not acceptable for hydroponics because the salt will kill the plants. Because of that I'm forced to use reverse osmosis water for my hydroponics. That water is totally void of any nutrients whatsoever, so I must add calcium/magnesium to the water first, before adding the MaxiGro. The Cal/Mag I use is also a General Hydroponics product. But again, "regular" tap water would have minerals in it, so that would not be needed...only the general nutrient mixture (MaxiGro). The MaxiGro is designed particularly for leafy greens and herbs, so that should serve you well with your cilantro. Again, there are other brands out there. Any any one designed for leafy greens (i.e. lettuce) should serve you well. I don't see your question above that I saw in my email with your comment regarding cilantro, but I'll attempt to answer it. Actually it's really hard for me to say how many plants to raise and when to start them. It depends on how much cilantro you use at one time. You may have to do some experimenting to learn for yourself how many plants to raise and how often to start new ones to keep a ready supply available. If you cut back one plant at a time for your recipe and you use it several times a week, then it seems you would need to start three plants at one time. Considering they can regrow after being cut, you'll need to allow some time for regrowth before harvesting it again. You may need to allow them 1 to 3 weeks to regrow before harvesting again (my estimation), which means you'll have to have other plants growing at the same time. This will amount to quite a few plants going at once, over time. You may need to start 3 plants a week for several weeks, then allow some time for regrowth (2 or 3 weeks), then start again, planting 3 plants a week for several weeks. It will take time to determine the schedule of planting/harvesting that is needed to keep you in good supply. I do something like what you propose with cilantro, but with lettuce. We eat a large salad for lunch every day and I raise my own lettuce, hydroponically. Every 2 weeks I start 12 (or more) new lettuce plants. Twelve is the minimum. I like to start extra in case some don't do well. By the time I'm ready to harvest a couple trays of lettuce, I have new seedlings ready to replace them. I have 6 trays (of 6 plants each) that I rotate through, harvesting two trays every other week. It keeps well for me in the refrigerator and I rarely need to buy lettuce. With some time, patience, and documenting of plant growth, etc, you too can develop a schedule for your cilantro like I have for my lettuce. Again, it takes dedication to get it going. But once the routine is figured out, it's very do-able. I hope all this helps you out! Thanks for watching and asking. Best wishes to you in your endeavors :)
Thanks for this video! Do I need a very large jug like the ones in your video? I only have a shallow pan. How much room do I need to give for the roots?
Hi! The roots will need some room and I'm not sure if a shallow pan will do. Also, with a shallow pan, you will need to monitor them closely since they will drink up the solution relatively quickly. If it runs dry, it may kill the plant. Another option might be to use a bucket that has a lid. Drill or cut a 2" hole in the lid (or the size needed to hold your net pot). Many people have used buckets with lids for this type of hydroponic method. I hope this helps! Thanks for watching and asking :)
How high do you full the nutrient/water solution initially, should it just barely touch the bottom of the mesh pot, or higher? And do you constantly keep it at that level, or how do you know when to refill it? Thank you!
Hi Tyler! That's an excellent question! Sorry I wasn't clear enough in the video. INITIALLY, I fill the jug up enough so there is liquid just above the bottom of the net pot. This is so the tiny roots can get their nourishment. As the plant grows (any hydro plant), it develops two types of roots...those that continue to lengthen so then can stay in the nutrient solution as it goes down, and another set of roots that extends into the air within the vessel so the plant can get the oxygen it needs. So, when you add nutrient solution after it has gone down in the jug, ALWAYS leave a gap between the solution and the bottom of the net pot, so the air roots can continue to get oxygen. If you refill the jug to the level it was filled initially, the plant will likely die because it will "drown" and not get enough oxygen. The general rule of thumb is to leave at least a couple inches below the net pot for air whenever refilling the jug. Thanks for watching and bringing up those points! Happy growing :)
Hi Buffy Plays! I would harvest outer leaves leaving the inner leaves, where new grow comes from alone so they can grow. That way you have continual growth. If you want to cut the whole plant, you can, but if you cut it deeply (toward the base) it may not grow back. Honestly, I don't think any plant will live forever. I have not attempted to grow cilantro for an extended period of time, so I can't say how long it will live until it goes to seed (bolts). Cilantro grows best in cool temperatures and will bolt (go to seed) if it gets too warm. So, for extended life, be sure it's in a cool environment and harvest only the outer leaves, leaving the inner leaves alone so they can grow. I hope this helps! Thanks for watching :)
Hi .I use my windows sill for natural sun light. Do I have to also get a grow light. I was trying some lettuce, but I ended up with thing stem ,later the plant died ,for too thin.i want exactly what was in the video.salad or herb grown at home .I can only do hydroponic. Please give advice.
Hi! Placing the plants in natural sunlight is excellent. However, because the lettuce ended up with thin stems indicates that it was not getting enough light. That would be the case if the sun was not direct, but indirect or simply just not enough. So, you may need to change tactics and place plants elsewhere under a grow light. I use LED grow lights because they are inexpensive to buy and run. So, they are very cost effective. Here's a link to the lasted LED lights that I've purchased. They are thin and a bit flimsy, but very effective, so overall I really like them... www.amazon.com/dp/B08SHYR1RR?ref=ppx_yo2_dt_b_product_details&th=1 Of course you'll also need some sort of shelving unit to place them on. The wire rack units work well for me. They can be found at Menard's, Lowe's, or stores such as that. You may be able to use other type of shelving, but I found these to be very easy to use and hook lights to, etc. I hope this helps! See also my playlist on hydroponic videos. There may be some information there that would be helpful to you... th-cam.com/play/PL_wTljBLE7FXg_TqSBq6Hz-eea55JvhIm.html Thanks for watching and asking :)
In the rockwool cubes it wouldn't do much good under light, so I don't put them under the light until they emerge beyond the cube. Then I put them under the light. Thanks for watching and commenting!
@@JudiintheKitchen Thank you for replying ! I am having some issue in germinating my cilantro seed. After like 21 days, the cilantro is still not sprouting at all. Not sure what I did wrong. I placed my cilantro in a sponge (Similar to rock wool), and place them in a container with the lid slightly open in the dark but it won’t germinate.
@@damienong1462 Have you kept the sponge moist during all this time? Seeds won't germinate if they dry out. You should have seen growth by now. If the sponge was kept moist, then the temperature is another thing to consider. Cilantro likes 65 to 70F. Too warm, too cold may affect their germination. If that's not the issue then it's possible your seeds are duds. Not all seeds will germinate. The germination rate is often tested by the packer of the seeds and the rate is usually on the package. If not, perhaps the seeds are old and just not going to germinate. I'd start over and try again with different seeds (from the same package) to see if they grow. I hope this helps!!
celery seeds are chambered. They have a membrane down the center and a seed on each side of that membrane. Think about how if you cut a tomato just right all the seeds will be on one side or the other.
Usually with hydroponics, one plant is kept in one pot. If you overcrowd the pot, the plants won't grow well. One will be dwarfed by a dominant plant and it won't grow properly. The dominant plant may not even grow well because it's being crowded. You're welcome to try it. With cilantro, since there are often two plants per seed, MAYBE the two will grow OK. However, I would not put more than that in there because they simply won't have enough room to grow properly. Thanks for watching and that excellent question! :)
Hi Tess! Thanks for watching and asking you question. I use simple LED grow lights. I prefer them since they are inexpensive to buy and inexpensive to use (regarding electricity). I don't recommend any particular brand. Whatever fits the price point at the moment is what I opt for. Most that I used initially appear "pinkish" when looking toward the light. Lately, I've discovered ones that appear "white" when you look toward them. The white light is much easier on the eyes, so I've grown to prefer them (but only for that reason). Either type of light will grow plants very well. Here is a link to a video I did a while back on my hydroponic setup. Lights are covered in there... th-cam.com/video/hQ-BTkVv8T4/w-d-xo.html I hope this helps! Happy growing :)
Hi Judi , Excellent video thanks a lot. I am from Canada- I am struggling with where should I keep the jar? We have dry air indoors due to heating and frost outside.
Hi! Thanks for watching and asking! I would absolutely keep the jar inside. The frost outside would kill the plant. Hopefully it will be fine, as long as you keep it away from heating ducts, etc. I grow hydroponically indoors year round and with most plants, I have no serious issues. I'm in the Midwest (USA), so I too experience 4 seasons of weather. I hope this helps! Best wishes and happy growing :)
Cilantro plants you can leave them no need to take one out i plant 5 to 6 seeds and i get a big bush of cilantro like the ones at the supermarket or bigger good job though
This is too complicated. It is much simpler to heavy layer of Cilantro seeds in the bottom of a fine mesh basket. Place the basket in a bowl or bucket filled with rainwater or chlorine-free water. The water should barely touch the seeds. If preferred put a tissue paper at the bottom or place a thin layer of cocopeat. Regardless, coriander roots will reach the water through the holes, and draw nutrients from it. Place it near a window (avoid direct sun in the hot summer days). Spray, as needed, to keep the seeds moist. Germination starts in a few days. Change the water every week, and fertilize with seaweed. In 45 days 8-10" tall cilantro crop is ready to harvest.
This was so fantastic! So detailed and clear and easy to follow. Thank you so much for all the care and attention you put into this video. I am grateful!
You're welcome! I'm glad this video was so helpful to you. Thanks for watching and commenting :)
What you planted is a non-split coriander seed. They do come in a "pod" that has more than one seed. You can split them yourself and get the two out of the "pod" before you place them in the hole.
Thank you, Ken! I have since learned that. We live and learn every day! Thanks for watching and sharing :)
Fantastic video! Exactly what I needed. Wasn't sure if it was going to sprout that many stems from one seed.
Hi Peter! I'm glad this video was so helpful to you. Thanks for watching and sharing! :)
Ah thanks so much for this video! I'll be following your method. Thanks for taking the time to make this video :)
You're welcome Chi! I'm glad this video was helpful to you! Thanks for watching and commenting :)
Hi JUDI,😃 beautiful cilantro plants, 😃 I have mines on mason jars covered with👍 newspaper. this was a 👍great progression 🎥video.
GOD 🙏🙏BLESS YOU.
EDUARDO MIAMI FL 🇺🇸
Hi Eduardo! Thanks for watching and commenting! I appreciate your comments on the video. It was a long one in the making. I have two more similar ones in progress (lettuce and kale). Hopefully they will help someone out there! Take care and God bless you and yours :)
@@JudiintheKitchen Exelent I will be on the look out for those videos.
BLESSINGS❤🙏🙏
@@eduardosalcedosr1727 Thanks Eduardo :)
Judi I’m starting a project using lucazade bottles with net cups same a you with the foil but I put an old sock over the foil rather than tape as does not damage / fall off easy. Trying on my window sill. Great video and well explained hopefully I will get good results 😂🤞. 👍
Thanks for watching and sharing! I love the tip about the sock...GREAT idea!! Blessings and happy growing :)
Have you ever tried to just pull one of the plants instead of cutting them apart? Or even break apart the rock wool to see which root is longer?
Hi Laura! No, I haven't tried that. But why not? Thanks for watching and sharing :)
Put pods in a cloth roll with a rolling pin pods break in half then two seeds inside goes twice as far try it
Thanks for watching and sharing! Yes, I've since learned of that technique, and it works! In fact, I'm growing cilantro right now :)
@@JudiintheKitchen Ive just started some off 3 days ago first one showed today
@@DiscusRussell GREAT! That's fast germination! Good for you :)
So helpful! I was hoping to figure out exactly what solution to use because there are so many to choose from. Is there a certain type? I don't mean the brand name. But I need to know something more specific than "nutrient solution". That's too vague and I assume different plants need different types/kinds of nutrient solutions or is it just a generic product I can go into a store and ask for and they won't ask me anything else because there is only one generic type of nutrient solution all plants grown hydroponically need?
Hi! Great questions! There are a number of brands of hydroponic nutrient solutions. I don't know that any one is any better than the other. Initially, I started using General Hydroponics MaxiGro and I've simply stayed with it ever since. If you have a good quality tap water, that alone should be fine with the MaxiGro (which is what I had when living in Iowa and where I made the video on cilantro). Now we're in another state and the household water system is "softened" with salt. That's not acceptable for hydroponics because the salt will kill the plants. Because of that I'm forced to use reverse osmosis water for my hydroponics. That water is totally void of any nutrients whatsoever, so I must add calcium/magnesium to the water first, before adding the MaxiGro. The Cal/Mag I use is also a General Hydroponics product. But again, "regular" tap water would have minerals in it, so that would not be needed...only the general nutrient mixture (MaxiGro). The MaxiGro is designed particularly for leafy greens and herbs, so that should serve you well with your cilantro. Again, there are other brands out there. Any any one designed for leafy greens (i.e. lettuce) should serve you well.
I don't see your question above that I saw in my email with your comment regarding cilantro, but I'll attempt to answer it. Actually it's really hard for me to say how many plants to raise and when to start them. It depends on how much cilantro you use at one time. You may have to do some experimenting to learn for yourself how many plants to raise and how often to start new ones to keep a ready supply available. If you cut back one plant at a time for your recipe and you use it several times a week, then it seems you would need to start three plants at one time. Considering they can regrow after being cut, you'll need to allow some time for regrowth before harvesting it again. You may need to allow them 1 to 3 weeks to regrow before harvesting again (my estimation), which means you'll have to have other plants growing at the same time. This will amount to quite a few plants going at once, over time. You may need to start 3 plants a week for several weeks, then allow some time for regrowth (2 or 3 weeks), then start again, planting 3 plants a week for several weeks. It will take time to determine the schedule of planting/harvesting that is needed to keep you in good supply.
I do something like what you propose with cilantro, but with lettuce. We eat a large salad for lunch every day and I raise my own lettuce, hydroponically. Every 2 weeks I start 12 (or more) new lettuce plants. Twelve is the minimum. I like to start extra in case some don't do well. By the time I'm ready to harvest a couple trays of lettuce, I have new seedlings ready to replace them. I have 6 trays (of 6 plants each) that I rotate through, harvesting two trays every other week. It keeps well for me in the refrigerator and I rarely need to buy lettuce. With some time, patience, and documenting of plant growth, etc, you too can develop a schedule for your cilantro like I have for my lettuce. Again, it takes dedication to get it going. But once the routine is figured out, it's very do-able. I hope all this helps you out! Thanks for watching and asking. Best wishes to you in your endeavors :)
Thank you!!! God bless you
You're welcome! Thank you for watching and commenting. Blessings to you and yours also :)
Thank you.
You're welcome! I hope it works well for you. Thanks for watching and commenting :)
Thanks for this video! Do I need a very large jug like the ones in your video? I only have a shallow pan. How much room do I need to give for the roots?
Hi! The roots will need some room and I'm not sure if a shallow pan will do. Also, with a shallow pan, you will need to monitor them closely since they will drink up the solution relatively quickly. If it runs dry, it may kill the plant. Another option might be to use a bucket that has a lid. Drill or cut a 2" hole in the lid (or the size needed to hold your net pot). Many people have used buckets with lids for this type of hydroponic method. I hope this helps! Thanks for watching and asking :)
madam one seed has two seed combined.. you can separate it using your hands if wants.
Thank you for that tip!! Thanks too for watching and sharing :)
So when you refill it do you have to use nutrition water again?
Absolutely! Thanks for watching and asking :)
How high do you full the nutrient/water solution initially, should it just barely touch the bottom of the mesh pot, or higher? And do you constantly keep it at that level, or how do you know when to refill it? Thank you!
Hi Tyler! That's an excellent question! Sorry I wasn't clear enough in the video. INITIALLY, I fill the jug up enough so there is liquid just above the bottom of the net pot. This is so the tiny roots can get their nourishment. As the plant grows (any hydro plant), it develops two types of roots...those that continue to lengthen so then can stay in the nutrient solution as it goes down, and another set of roots that extends into the air within the vessel so the plant can get the oxygen it needs. So, when you add nutrient solution after it has gone down in the jug, ALWAYS leave a gap between the solution and the bottom of the net pot, so the air roots can continue to get oxygen. If you refill the jug to the level it was filled initially, the plant will likely die because it will "drown" and not get enough oxygen. The general rule of thumb is to leave at least a couple inches below the net pot for air whenever refilling the jug. Thanks for watching and bringing up those points! Happy growing :)
@@JudiintheKitchen Thank you for the detailed reply!
@@TaladranWoW You're welcome, Tyler! I hope it works well for you :)
thanks
You're welcome! Thank you for watching and commenting :)
how long does the cilantro take to re-grow every time you harvest it? and does it keep growing forever?
Hi Buffy Plays! I would harvest outer leaves leaving the inner leaves, where new grow comes from alone so they can grow. That way you have continual growth. If you want to cut the whole plant, you can, but if you cut it deeply (toward the base) it may not grow back. Honestly, I don't think any plant will live forever. I have not attempted to grow cilantro for an extended period of time, so I can't say how long it will live until it goes to seed (bolts). Cilantro grows best in cool temperatures and will bolt (go to seed) if it gets too warm. So, for extended life, be sure it's in a cool environment and harvest only the outer leaves, leaving the inner leaves alone so they can grow. I hope this helps! Thanks for watching :)
@@JudiintheKitchen thanks for the response 🦝
@@buffyplays2577 You're welcome! I try to help, if I can :)
Hi .I use my windows sill for natural sun light. Do I have to also get a grow light. I was trying some lettuce, but I ended up with thing stem ,later the plant died ,for too thin.i want exactly what was in the video.salad or herb grown at home .I can only do hydroponic. Please give advice.
Hi! Placing the plants in natural sunlight is excellent. However, because the lettuce ended up with thin stems indicates that it was not getting enough light. That would be the case if the sun was not direct, but indirect or simply just not enough. So, you may need to change tactics and place plants elsewhere under a grow light. I use LED grow lights because they are inexpensive to buy and run. So, they are very cost effective. Here's a link to the lasted LED lights that I've purchased. They are thin and a bit flimsy, but very effective, so overall I really like them... www.amazon.com/dp/B08SHYR1RR?ref=ppx_yo2_dt_b_product_details&th=1 Of course you'll also need some sort of shelving unit to place them on. The wire rack units work well for me. They can be found at Menard's, Lowe's, or stores such as that. You may be able to use other type of shelving, but I found these to be very easy to use and hook lights to, etc. I hope this helps! See also my playlist on hydroponic videos. There may be some information there that would be helpful to you... th-cam.com/play/PL_wTljBLE7FXg_TqSBq6Hz-eea55JvhIm.html Thanks for watching and asking :)
I wonder if you germinate it under the light or in the dark.
In the rockwool cubes it wouldn't do much good under light, so I don't put them under the light until they emerge beyond the cube. Then I put them under the light. Thanks for watching and commenting!
@@JudiintheKitchen Thank you for replying ! I am having some issue in germinating my cilantro seed. After like 21 days, the cilantro is still not sprouting at all. Not sure what I did wrong.
I placed my cilantro in a sponge (Similar to rock wool), and place them in a container with the lid slightly open in the dark but it won’t germinate.
@@damienong1462 Have you kept the sponge moist during all this time? Seeds won't germinate if they dry out. You should have seen growth by now. If the sponge was kept moist, then the temperature is another thing to consider. Cilantro likes 65 to 70F. Too warm, too cold may affect their germination. If that's not the issue then it's possible your seeds are duds. Not all seeds will germinate. The germination rate is often tested by the packer of the seeds and the rate is usually on the package. If not, perhaps the seeds are old and just not going to germinate. I'd start over and try again with different seeds (from the same package) to see if they grow. I hope this helps!!
celery seeds are chambered. They have a membrane down the center and a seed on each side of that membrane. Think about how if you cut a tomato just right all the seeds will be on one side or the other.
Interesting! Sounds like different varieties have different types of seeds. Thanks for watching and sharing :)
Why can't you have more than one plant in the cube?
Usually with hydroponics, one plant is kept in one pot. If you overcrowd the pot, the plants won't grow well. One will be dwarfed by a dominant plant and it won't grow properly. The dominant plant may not even grow well because it's being crowded. You're welcome to try it. With cilantro, since there are often two plants per seed, MAYBE the two will grow OK. However, I would not put more than that in there because they simply won't have enough room to grow properly. Thanks for watching and that excellent question! :)
Grow lights?
Hi Tess! Thanks for watching and asking you question. I use simple LED grow lights. I prefer them since they are inexpensive to buy and inexpensive to use (regarding electricity). I don't recommend any particular brand. Whatever fits the price point at the moment is what I opt for. Most that I used initially appear "pinkish" when looking toward the light. Lately, I've discovered ones that appear "white" when you look toward them. The white light is much easier on the eyes, so I've grown to prefer them (but only for that reason). Either type of light will grow plants very well. Here is a link to a video I did a while back on my hydroponic setup. Lights are covered in there... th-cam.com/video/hQ-BTkVv8T4/w-d-xo.html I hope this helps! Happy growing :)
@@JudiintheKitchen thank you very much! Your channel is very informative and practical.
Liked & subscribed.
@@bestcrossroad Thanks so much, Tess!!
Yes, if you crack the seed of coriander you will find 2 seeds.
Thank you, River! I've since learned that :) Thanks for watching and sharing :)
Hi Judi , Excellent video thanks a lot. I am from Canada- I am struggling with where should I keep the jar? We have dry air indoors due to heating and frost outside.
Hi! Thanks for watching and asking! I would absolutely keep the jar inside. The frost outside would kill the plant. Hopefully it will be fine, as long as you keep it away from heating ducts, etc. I grow hydroponically indoors year round and with most plants, I have no serious issues. I'm in the Midwest (USA), so I too experience 4 seasons of weather. I hope this helps! Best wishes and happy growing :)
i am in Quebec, put it on the window sill of your sunniest window. at best you can use a dedicated light.
@@Francois_Dupont Agreed! Thanks for watching and sharing :)
Cilantro plants you can leave them no need to take one out i plant 5 to 6 seeds and i get a big bush of cilantro like the ones at the supermarket or bigger good job though
Thanks for watching and sharing!
@@JudiintheKitchen love you're videos you have a new subscriber thanks
This is too complicated.
It is much simpler to heavy layer of Cilantro seeds in the bottom of a fine mesh basket. Place the basket in a bowl or bucket filled with rainwater or chlorine-free water. The water should barely touch the seeds.
If preferred put a tissue paper at the bottom or place a thin layer of cocopeat. Regardless, coriander roots will reach the water through the holes, and draw nutrients from it.
Place it near a window (avoid direct sun in the hot summer days). Spray, as needed, to keep the seeds moist. Germination starts in a few days. Change the water every week, and fertilize with seaweed. In 45 days 8-10" tall cilantro crop is ready to harvest.
Thanks for watching and sharing! That's an interesting method...one to try! :)