How Horrifying Is Caning In Singapore? Offenders Tend To Weaken After 3 Strokes
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 มิ.ย. 2023
- Singapore is renowned as one of the safest countries globally, primarily due to its strict laws and severe penalties for various offenses.
One notable form of corporal punishment employed in Singapore is caning. It has been observed that offenders tend to weaken after experiencing three strokes, with fewer remaining conscious after six strokes.
How horrifying is caning in Singapore?
Why do offenders prefer to stay in prison rather than face sentencing? - บันเทิง
to clarify on micheal fay, he also vandalised 18 cars. while this may not sound that serious for those in other countries, cars in singapore are VERY pricey to own (the car itself costing an average of $125300 (sgd) in 2021, and the cirtificate of entitlement to own a car ranging from $65000-106000 (sgd). note that the certificate of entitlement is only for 10 years and not a lifetime)
It’s around 60-67 cars.
@@iMoreno man that makes this sm worse :/
edit: typo
@@sub.titles Thats’s why. It’s crazy. Even at that time there’s a lot of gang clashes and dismembering of body parts too.
If that was done here in the US, our crime rates will go down.
Yes, it would!
We’re not animals
@@xavier5664 You might be right, because animals are more civilized than a lot of people.
@@xavier5664maybe it'd be safer if you were
probably has no impact
The way I remember it many Americans strongly approved of Michael Fay being caned for vandalism! Most Americans considered the caning to be justice for the crime.
he did
Yes and people also get Cained for demonstrating in a public place, a true democracy lol
@@wallenbergphoto: who said Singapore was a democracy?
That's also the way I remember it. Do the crime, spend the time...being caned, that is.
I remember the Michael Faye incident here in the US. Everyone that I knew felt that he deserved it, and if he didn’t like it well maybe he shouldn’t have committed the crime in the first place.
I bet he never forgot& I think that's the main object of the exercise!
Agree. Teaches the western crooks a lesson . Singapore 's judicial system is far stricter than USA. Simple stuff like carrying a pocket knife in public can land one into jail.
@@HomelandSecurityUSA01 why should it be illegal to carry a pocket knife in the public? i use it to cut stuff and for self defense.
@@ms9001 in Singapore, Can I Carry or Possess Weapons for the Purpose of Self-Defence?
You are not allowed to carry weapons for the purpose of self-defence. Under the right of self-defence, you are allowed to defend yourself, or your property, against an offence.
However, you are not allowed to use greater force than necessary to defend yourself. Thus, the use of a weapon to defend yourself, whether the weapon is an imitation one or real, might be considered excessive if the attacker was not using a weapon against you.
Even if you do not use the weapon, possessing a weapon for self-defence (e.g., simply carrying it in your bag) will still be a criminal offence.
If the police finds the weapon on you, and you have no lawful purpose for possessing it and do not have a permit to carry it out of the house, you may be charged with an offence punishable by up to 3 years’ jail and at least 6 strokes of the cane. The weapon will also be disposed of.
If a police officer has reasonable grounds to believe that you are in possession of an offensive weapon (i.e. any item that is likely to cause hurt), he may stop and search you or your vehicle without a warrant for it.
Even Being in the company of, or consorting with, someone who is carrying offensive weapons such as knives in public, which presumes that you knew that the other person carried the weapon, you oso will be given the same sentence he/she gets for carrying the offensive item/weapon..
So means even if u are not the one who is in possession of a knife, but ur friend is, and you know about it, if they get caught and arrested and charged in court.. you too will be implicated n get the same charge as them.
As my mom would always say when I was a kid: better get smacked at home than to the cops
Expect it factually doesn’t do anything and teaches kids that being violent is alright
I wish we had these laws in my country.
What country should have this in anyway? What country? Have you studied in anyway what this do to a person that people end up in ICU, for 5 grams of Weed, or grafiti 10 x 10 cm hello on a toilet wall...=? Must be Psycopath. I guess at the same time, you complain when Saudi arabia has same laws haha
@@wallenbergphoto Don't break laws and you don't have to worry about it. I think that's kind of the point, right? Obviously, it's working for them to have the 3rd lowest crime rate score in the WORLD.
@@wallenbergphoto don't commit crimes or do/deal drugs..
problem solved
@@user-ol9ck7ig2fstfu u sound stupid
@@user-ol9ck7ig2f The world is not controlled, this punishment only remains in uncivilised countries like singapore, we have the power of protest and revolution for our freedon
Robot channels should be demonetized
Weird music for this type of video
failing to flush toilets after use? I can only imagine how many people would be caned in the US.
Thats a fine!
They don't cane you just because you don't flush. For that offence, they'll just fine you.
@AlexSDU yeah I hate how people think that any offense will get you canning even tho that's not true
What if the toilet will not flush? Lol
What if it’s broken and can’t flush?
Drug dealers ? No repeat offenders !
Yep… because that’s a death penalty
Very intelligent .@@natk0s1y82
Singapore and many of the other SE Asian countries have the death penalty for trafficking or dealing or importing. And they carry the sentences out. A firearm is used for this. Also, don't get caught with an illegal firearm in these countries. Or use them. In some cases the same penalty applies.
Really . My God you 're intelligent -@@natk0s1y82
In 2015, a British man was sentenced to 350 lashes in Saudi for drinking homemade wine 🍷
yeah, but he was probably causing a problem and the police were called, and then they discovered he was drunk........ it is legal to drink there in a bar for foreigners, but definetely not, if you are causing problems!!! And no home brew so that there is no unsupervised drinking.
@@colonelfustercluck486 since when? Maybe more recently thanks to MBS’ reforms
@@colonelfustercluck486yep most definitely, English people tend to get really rowdy when they’re drunk
@@colonelfustercluck486"But"?! "But" NOTHING! That's perverted Saudi "justice"!!
In the USA we should have caning as a punishment. It appears to work great!
Yeah, prisons don't anything except give culprits free food and statistically yield repeat offenders. The free food that prisoners normally get should all be redirected to the country's starving children and others impoverished
@@HardcoreMasterBaiter Whoops, that sounds like Socialism. Steady on Stalin...
Its regressive!
@@nicholasong2760 nah, it's Western countries that are regressing backwards
@@Demonmixer Remind me how exactly the workers owning the means of production rather than the capitalists has anything to with medieval feudal punishment techniques? I think you'll find such feudal techniques to be far more common in far-right hyper-capitalist military dictatorships than anything remotely resembling socialism.
I think it's arrogant to visit another Country and feel so entitled. U went to Their Country, broke the law and refuse to acknowledge their punishment. Sorry, doesn't work like that. They have every right to uphold their Laws and Culture
Singapore is a beautiful place. I love it there. Just respect their laws and customs and you'll have a wonderful experience
@matthewmorrison3703 bro is laughing about absolutely nothing
THEN GO AND LIVE THERE IF YOU LOVE IT SO MUCH
That place is as HOMOSEXUAL as all hell itself! Note how women are NEVER punished for very much....
@CARLOSVILLALOBOS-gh5jr loved it here as a singaporean ahhaha. 0% dividend tax 0% capital gain tax low income tax.
A quirky world indeed. Here I am trying to enjoy this video, but the unnecessary constant background noise would drive anyone mad, so I had to flee. I would really like to know why a youtuber would spend time making a very informative video, THEN sabotages it with music, one seemed to have started it, and like sheep they all followed to a man
I am reading the Lee Kuan Yew book and got to this part. Amazing how some countries already have solutions for so many problems and we simply fail to copy it
I know 3 women here in Melbourne who actually enjoy this and have many clients using their services.
How ironic.
Some of those images aren't Singapore.
That is SO UNFAIR...it should be controlled automated with newton force control like 55HP.
So, I keep hearing "male", but what about female offenders? Surely there are female offenders too, yes?
But all crooks in the governments get away with murder this has nothing to do with punishment its power over others
Or The Belt THATS Painful
We got the cane at school,sometimes there was blood but we had huge respect for teachers,never make spelling mistakes,never lost a game of cricket in 2 years.If the cane would come back gang culture would evaporate into thin air immediately at schools .😊😊😊❤
You got caned for losing cricket matches?
@@paulorocky Yes,when we played away and had lost the bus would go dead quiet about 10 minutes out from returning to school.
As I say we never list a game in 2 years.
We got caned for talking as a bell was ringing,hair too long etc.
We learned respect.
@@markbrown-sb2zmNo thank you. That sounds like something North Korea would do.
We know our place. @@markbrown-sb2zm
@@madcube1581... Aww poor baby can't handle physical punishment... Need a time out...??
The US should introduce the law. I am sure the crime rate will drop precipitously.
YES-THEN MAYBE YOUR OWN FAMILY WOULD NOT HAVE TURNED OUT TO BE CRIMINALS
People always says that until some close to you or yourself end up in the situation, your have no idea how harsh this punishment is. One girl from England, just got off by pure luck when they stopped doing it to women, else she would have gotten 40 lashes, and instead got 10 years because her friend forgot 5 grams of weed in HER bag. ANYHTING connected with drugs is bad in Singapore, thats why people in hospital and healthcare in general also is very very! under treated for pain in Singapore bec. the Stigma is so huge!
@@wallenbergphotoThe original JACKASS commenting in support of such SEXUALLY PERVERTED punishment needs to lay off that subscription to the BDSM sex channel....
Prostitutionis legal but chewing gum isn't in Singapore? Lol
Chewing gum is legal in singapore selling gum in singapore is not
as long as the cheque doesn't bounce....... that's fraudulent
Yes but thats how a very strict patriarchal and corrupt society works :)
but its safer. I don't really care what the name of the system is. results count not talk......
@@colonelfustercluck486 Have you read about those ending up in ICU after this? It's not safe, only the most people will not die. They do the uttermost so people wont die, but that the pain will get the worst you ever could imagine. This is old Colonial middle age ways... And people complain on countries like Saudi Arabia, when you could end up in ICU in Singapore for throwing a gum on the street. Let say everyone could do that mistake and then you done.
What's with the studio 54 hits playlist during this narrators delve into Singapore's gruesome canning punishments
It's barbaric and wrong but so is subway crime here in nyc. Singapore has very little crime. Hmm.🤔🤔🤔
it's safer in Singapore than in my country. I wonder why... duh.
It's simple, all people in general have good schooling, good salary, no ghettoes and poor neighborhoods. Most people have a good economy and do not need crime. Those who do go abroad mainly. Punishments like this might detour, yes Vandalism, Grafitti, Use of Weed, Haroin etc. But not Murder, rape etc... Becuase this things happen anyway, just then people get life in prison or death penalty
@@wallenbergphotoBut it NEVER happens to women; this is what makes me believe that Singapore is a secretly HOMOSEXUAL society....
I get the notion that no one should be allowed to cane anyone else until they have been caned. However, this seems like a viable IN-PRISON way to cut down on jailhouse foolishness.
I agree with the first part of your comment; however, the last part made very little sense....
it is a part of the judicial sentence........ not just on the whim of a jail official. A medical doctor is present during the execution of the sentence. If there is a medical problem, the caning is stopped so that the criminal can recover. In which case "that's it".... no more caning for that person. He doesn't have to return to get the caning finished.
@@colonelfustercluck486 Except that when it was allowed in prisons in the United States, there were increasing levels of violence directed against prison staff from the inmates; because of the violence first being directed at them from the staff.
@@user-dj7wv5ok2x... and the prison staff in the US don't use violence now and the violence from prisoners to jail staff has increased or decreased?
BUT, anyway... who gives a s^*t about that. They could be charged with assaulting an officer and sentenced to caning again.... people will tire of getting their arse whipped. But that's a USA problem.......... I merely commented on how well it goes for Singapore, just to keep it relavent to this YT article.
meanwhile some teachers beat kids like this if they make a mistake in class... :(
No they don’t shut up kid
@@FlyingKlutchKick what do you know kid?
Back to Inquisition times in Singano pure?
Imagine if they arrested those in India for dumping filth everywhere🤔?
I can't believe that Singapore could release a video defending this barbaric practice. Shame on Singapore!
Singapore has low crime rate. If you dont wanna get caned, just dont commit crimes. Its literally that simple. Be a civilised human being and you won’t have any problems. All these warnings yet people commit crimes. So….whose fault?
No its wrong its just orople getting off on hurting people
Oh my
Para as mulheres também né!
YES! NO ARGUMENT HERE!!
This probably isn’t going to boost tourism.
Well last time i went to singapore in 2018 it was truly a world class safe city - as long as you dont commit any crimes or even minor infractions, you will be okay, again no vandalism of cars, illegal possession of narcotics or firearms, and other serious issues.
Singapore is same as Saudi Arabia for their strict rules
Plenty of nations that still use corporal punishment still have terrible standards of living and rampant crime. And plenty of nations that do not use corporal punishment have wonderful standards of living and lower crime rates.
So don't make the mistake of associating violent punishments with improved behaviour.
This is why western countries now are weakening. You guys went too soft.
"Plenty of nations"
Can you give some examples?
*Doesn't change the fact about Singapore's low crime rate. Corporal punishment is needed.*
@@matthewmorrison3703 That way of thinking is precisely why those countries will never have a low crime rate
According to the map in this video, caning is also a form of punishment in Somalia, Nigeria, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Sudan. Are you saying those countries have low levels of crime due to their use of corporal punishment?
For the record, I kind of think a less severe form of caning could be useful in the US, but I don’t think it will solve all crime.
Countries with no repercussions tend to attract the worst people. Just look at Japan with nuisance youtubers.
My understanding is the canes are soaked in horse urine.
If that was done in chicongo
Who introduced caning as a form of punishment tho? That’s right, british colonialism… and now they want to act like they’re the more evolved human and say this form of punishment is barbaric pppffffftttt….
Singapore was part of Malaysia. A few decades ago it broke away and became a new, stand alone , independent country (1965). The new prime minister Lee Kwan Yew (Spelling?) wanted to clean up what was becoming a corrupt crime infested s^*thole, and imposed strict laws, a policy of prosecuting criminal offenses, and the imposition and execution of the penalties. I am unsure who or when or how the rattan punishment started off. But it has definitely been under publicly elected Singaporean control for those decades, and they appear to be happy with it. Otherwise their parliament would have prohibited this punishment. They have a democratic vote over there, a system they inherited from the British. (Historically a lot of the countries and parts of countries had leaders that just ruled by decree of that person, so they have it pretty good these days)
Britain did introduce caning/rattan to SIngapore in mid 19th century, at a time when the British had caning and whipping punishments in their own country. So the Singaporeans weren't being singled out.
According to Wikipedia : Caning remained on the statute book after Malaya became independent from Britain in 1957, and after Singapore ceased to be part of Malaysia in 1965. Subsequent legislation has been passed by the Parliament of Singapore over the years to increase the minimum strokes an offender receives, and the number of crimes that may be punished with caning. And: The cane must be under 1 inch thick. Maybe the Singaporeans are better at caning than the British? Why? Because the public peace, law and order in general appears to have been restored to a large extent in recent years. Of course there is still crime, but everyone knows what will happen if you are caught for certain offenses.
@@colonelfustercluck486 thoughts on zs
@@eskimode2022 z's are great. I'm just off to catch some.
4. 56 hundred lashes on black buttock didnt bother them but 6 canes on white buttock is considered too much. what an hypocrite
And NEGATIVELY HOMOSEXUAL t'boot!!
They need to do this here for vandals and DUI's. Bet that would cut down on the offenses here big time. But also subject women to it as well, not just males
And THAT'S been one of my arguments throughout this entire post!!
I wish we had this here in India. This is far better than death penalties. Human Rights commissions all over the world, have no kindness towards the plight of present and future victims...
Singapore executes more people per capita than just about anywhere else.
I disagree
Many Indians from India shout during canning in Singapore but Singapore Indian did not
So now we understand that had it not been for this canning thing. Singapore would be triple worse in the crime rate over the United States.
The BULL has hit the SHIT to tht comment....
We need the cane master in the US.
Look bad but we Singaporean who received the cane never utter a sound during the process.its painful but we Singaporean can take it.unlike many foreigner that shout when take it.i say this because I took it .& I saw how strong Singapore criminal are.if only this criminal were army.but whether we are a Singapore criminal or ex criminal,i damn sure even our criminal will stand by our country because of one thing.WE ARE TRAINED NS MEN.
But it's still people even getting the cane at workplaces right>? I heard its legal for the boss to do it if they want. And almost sell out canes becuase school exames to hit the kids with. the pink, blur ones hahaha. Am I right= ?
GOOD! Then let your nation-state show the world how REALLY great it is, and apply such SEXUALLY PERVERTED BDSM to EVERYONE, and not just males; this makes you appear HOMOSEXUAL in a negative fashion!!
@@wallenbergphotonope workplace violence can be reported to the ministry
Offhand, I believe the last caning in the USA was in Delaware in the 1950s for the crime of wife beating. Worked on criminals then; works in Singapore now!
@matthewmorrison3703Regardless of whatever implement of PERVERSION they used, the effect was the same.
Canada needs to implement this punishment.
There’s crime in Canada? They’re a much nicer and more civilized people than Americans! I’ve never heard of anybody saying they grew up tough on the streets of Toronto or Montreal.😂
@@jondstewartJust in case you might've mised it, we're ALL "Americans", from Alaska to the Magellan Strait....
Singapore learned a lesson from the British. If you spare the rod, you'll spoil the child. We need to not be so lax in the USA. Start replacing longer jail sentences with canings. Not a lot of reoffenders that way.
The US has plenty of harsh punishments; multiple states still use the death penalty. Has that improved the crime rates? I'm all for discipline, but not by violent means. Violence should not be used outside of defending against attack.
@@sotiriosnovatsis4529 The US's harsh punishments are just prison time or the death penalty. Most states have moved from executions and that's caused a spike in reoffenders especially since they know they won't die for their actions. Our 'harsh' punishments are mere slaps on the wrist compared to Singapore.
@@John198041 I agree. The world seems overrun by spoiled children.
@@sotiriosnovatsis4529*Caning is fine, death penalty on the other hand is disgusting!*
US prisons are overcrowded. Ramp up the execution rate, less crowding, less criminals, lower reoffending rate, prison gang members will be wittled down, safer streets. Less drug addicts, less crime. USA just throws criminals in prison, gives no rehab, releases better, connected criminals who go out and commit more crimes. Unfortunately, US prisons are a business to make money, there's your problem.
This seems somewhat barbaric. PTSD for everyone involved. It'll either harden you in a not great way, or simply mess you up.
... and I'm fine with that!
Being Soft on crime in America is not working . I approve to implement this in the good ole USA 100 percent 💯
If being kind and reformation does not work then this is the answer. If they don’t respect you they should fear you.
Don't commit the crime. Simples.
Another boo hoo sympathizer. How about DONT DO THE CRIME, rather than make excuses for all the morons out there doing wrong?
The pain isn’t as bad as this guy says. But it’s true after about 5 hard lashes you’ll start getting dizzy from the pain because it’s a lingering sting. Kinda like eating spicy food
Watch caning in Malaysia. They have real canings on TH-cam. It’s pretty gruesome.
The caning showed is misleading. It is done in a private cell for your info.
Every country should have this!!
Eiser to move to Singapore or Saudi Arabia you get your wish :)
No.
@@leighluvsratsYES! If someone wants such SEXUALLY PERVERTED BDSM as a punishment, what they REALLY need is a serious round of inpatient psychiatric confinement!!
No
Every country already has it----on BDSM websites!!
Is it the caning that causes Singapore's crime rates to be so low, or is it that the justice system follows the caning by rehabilitating ex-offenders in humane ways, including through connections with institutions outside the prison (temples, mosques, employers) that can guide the offender back into society?
Also note that Toronto beat Singapore in safety -- Canada does not cane.
Canadians are lazy to commit crimes from being too high to have the crime rates that we do here in the US.
My answer is CCTV
It's maybe a little of both..And I don't trust Canadian Stats,because their allowing all manner of strange s#'#t to pass,and the Cops are failing to do their Jobs! Trans performers doing stories at Kindergarten and churches,Teachers turning dressed in all manner of strange guises! but Truckers are arrested& have their Bank Accs put on stop!
Are you sure about those stats chief? It was a mostly homogenous culture, but you're being invaded by those who don't respect it.
Theres few repeat offenders for sure. Caning makes them impotent. They dont wanna lose their balls.
Canada needs this
Why wasnt, in Alberta made it illegal as late as 2004, was Alberta a heaven before that? lol..
Canada is crime free. Ever heard of anybody that said they grew up on the streets of Halifax or Charlottetown? 😂
@@jondstewart come out west
@@PowerSoilder Vancouver? Yes, I was being sarcastic. But you never hear of Canada having crime like the U.S. I live in Alaska and crime is very high here.
@@jondstewart seems like things are changing drastically in North America.
sg gov must consider remove the sparing for people 50yrs and above from caning...more more cases of raping and crime punishable by caning are done by people above this age group...age can no longer be excuse
It’s good for them to have strict rules as especially the younger generation are a lost cause in the world now
We need this in the US, it will improve our declining society.
There's also capital punishment in some US schools.
@@Demonmixer u mean corporal. Capital punishment is death. Corporal is caning
Maybe you need a better economy for everyone, remember the 50's and how much gangs you had then when people had it much better? Thats what Singapore has, good jobs, people educate themselfs with the help of. gov. everyone is included, and almost no one need to be out of a job and descent salary.
I'm always amazed at Americans appetite for cruel and unusual punishment.
Great video with lots of information. Lower crime rates are worth the punishment of caning the offenders...except for not flushing! Or spitting. The memory of the pain would prevent criminals from reoffending.
How would you like undergoing this punishment in case of judicial error? Or do you think courts are right 100 % of the time?
@@AKuTepion in singapore we have never caned or hanged anyone wrongly before. Unlike countries where the western society is mainly residing, the sense of public serving positions are taken with pride and integrity in the first place. And i don't see how we can wrongfully cane someone if evidence is there
@@verycursedplane6557 When international cartels ship drugs from one country to another, they don't just ship it in one huge container labeled "drugs". They hide it inside something else. And sometimes they screw up and there have already been cases of random people accidentally discovering drugs e.g. in a box of bananas.
Do I have a 100 % certainty that I don't have drugs inside my backpack right now? No. It's extremely, extremely unlikely, but it's theoretically possible that I bought a backpack that was used to smuggle drugs and someone forgot to take them out.
If this happens to me in the EU, I'll spend many years in prison, but at least they'll treat me humanely. They'll encourage me to study, to develop some good hobbies and to stay in close touch with my family. If they figure out that I'm not a risk, they'll release me earlier or at least move me to a low-security prison, where the conditions are better.
If this happens to me in Singapore, they could torture or kill me.
There's no such thing as 100 % confidence in the real world. If you don't have doubts, you're not thinking deep enough.
We're not using these barbarians punishments here in the Czech Republic and still have lower general crime rates than Singapore. Intentional homicide rates are higher, but the vast majority of these cases are extended suicides within a single family. It's not really useful to threaten to kill someone by law if they are going to kill themselves all on their own...
@@verycursedplane6557But you HOMOSEXUALLY apply the punishment; it SHOULD also be applied to WOMEN as well!!
@@user-dj7wv5ok2x thing is firstly women don’t commit crimes usually warranting caning anyway. And secondly the singaporean society still sympathises with women due to them being more subjected to sexual crimes by men which warrant caning
We need caning here in the USA for less crime and spoiled, entitled people.
Just LG o to virtually ANY BDSM website, and get your rocks off....
I wish we had caning here in the US, but only for violent offenses.
You are caining children legally in many states still... Why isnt that helping "but" as science shows give a much higher risk becoming violent as an adult... maybe stop hitting kids, and get more like Scandinavia..
Not horrifying at all. It needs to come to the US and be TELEVISED.
So you can MASTURBATE while watching it?!
Weird ass
Fantastic punishment, its direct, shameful and will teach the punished a lesson they will never forget.
Chicago, LA, Detroit, Memphis, and NY need to be in line for this punishment.
Why isn't corpral punishment in USA by parants in some states still in Schools helping then? How come the Nordic countries, who have no Corporal or Capital punishment... Why do they have so much less violence, and in groups where kids are beaten at home have a huge risk ending up in gangs, criminal activities. Is it then only in their DNA? lol hahahaha...
YOU DROP YOUR UNDERWEAR AND BEND OVER FIRST!!
gonk
Toronto has a better crime rates and isn’t harsh
drug use and violent crimes is not as low as singapore
@@verycursedplane6557 it’s still low and without it
@@devinbutler3271 I’m comparing it to Singapore not just low by itself
In the USA, however, things are no better. The death penalty there is much worse.
How can a death penalty be worse? Do they throw a stink bomb into the gas chamber?
Singapore executes not a few people every year too... and for much less, the other year like 20 grams of Heroin gave death penalty for a poor and addicted Indonesian man... But Yes US have executed both minors and Down syndrome people, breaking many human rights.
they should do this in seattle
We need this in MEMPHIS immediately ❗️❗️
This should be a global standard
Its Like Getting Getting Spanked
You eman the guy 2011 who ended up 2 month in ICU? The canes a very hard only specialized very strong personnel gives the punishment so the person hurts as much as possible, so keep your.. Hobby "I know" for yourself lol.
That guy who spray-painted those cars His ass still twinges when he walks past a paint alisle 😂
I wish every country would adopt Singapore’s whipping law
If such a wish were a horse, it appears to have KICKED YOU UPSIDE THE HEAD!!
Usa needs this 40 yrs ago.
So if your son wrote, "hello" with spray you wish he gets whipped, so he might end up in ICU? Ok humane..
And it was eliminated more than a CENTURY AGO in prisons, and for VERY GOD REASON!!
Europe's issues with street gangs would be significantly reduced if this was applied here.
It was applied in schools for the LONGEST TIME, until KARMA ran full circle, and those administering the punishments quickly found themselves on the receiving end of the abuse they dished out.
@@user-dj7wv5ok2x i dont think u know how different school caning compared to actual flogging.
@@jonathanchia9167 Actually there's NO difference at all as far as the deliberate infliction of pain is concerned....
Then it is simple... you only get the cane when you break the laws.
I want this in my country.
Except that it's HOMOSEXUALLY APPLIED; women are given a slap on the wrist in comparison....
The pentictor in humane store degrading. The actions of the criminal were great in quiet often in humane. We need caning as a punishment here in the US. We need to have penalties that get the perps whole, focused attention.
There's enough of that bullshit on BDSM websites; keep such insanity OUT of our "justice" network!!
Bring this to the US!
I used to throw a hs discus which weighs about 1.6 kgs, usually 150-160 feet, standing (not even spinning.)
I would be one helluva caner--I can already launch "heavy targets" with a single-handed paddle. 💪😂
Me, with a paddle - 😈🏏😂
Criminals - 😢😢😢
Only criminals using human rights as a lame excuse would disagree that this sort of punishment works to reduce criminal activities.
Militaries in the 19th century realized that corporal punishment makes good men bad and bad men worse and abandoned it. Anyone which thinks that it is somehow "necessary" in the modern age either is wilfully ignorant or one who glories in cruelty.
And yet singapore has one of the lowest crime rates in the world
@@rachaeltan5462 Norway has low crime rates and corporal punishment is banned. Not only judicial and in schools, but also at home. Similarly there are places with corporal punishment with High rates of Criminality and Corporal Punishment.
Similarly Britain in 1800 had harsher punishments than Singapore (transportation to Australia for vandalism, hanging for petty theft) which moderated by 1900 as rates of criminality fell.
@@ImperatorZor so? What is your point Norway's strategy might not work for singapore just because it works for norway does not mean it will work for singapore just like how singapore's strategy might not work for norway and this is a example how corporal punishment can work for some countries like singapore
@@ImperatorZor also one thing i should say is that the caining it to make you never forgot so you wont do it again and it has worked for singapore
@@rachaeltan5462 Point is that "Harsh Penalties=/=Low Crime Rates". One anomalous outlier does not prove that, especially when we have counter examples.
Beyond that, the objective is to minimize human suffering. If you can achieve something through either A: non violent and non painful means or B: by torturing someone, even assuming that they are equally effective, you go for A. It's a simple Utilitarian calculation.
I’m a right wing conservative all the way. But I still think that this is torture.
Fuck that. Bring it to the US. End this degeneracy.
Then just dont Commit the crime
How is this torture? When u don't listen to ur parents, they cane you level 1, and yet you do crime outside, after what ur parents told you. Well canning maximum level will be taught against you for not listening and respecting your own family. It's not torture, it's call rehabilitation. My friends who was a rapist, got cane 24 times and came out become a change men. Imagine he just stayed in the prison for 4 years nothing else just sit sleep shit in the cell, he would have done it again. Look at USA, imagine if canning was it, all those gangs would be crying like a baby , ain't tough anymore scumbags
@@muhammadmuzirharibinmorni-1407 I agree, it definitely is a deterrent.
its not torture. They are not trying to extract a false confession from you..... this is strictly a punishment for the guilty.@@rachaeltan5462
This makes me SICK
USA should adopt this punishment, especially in communist California
Didn't realize any state in the US was Communist. Extremeist Capitalism's a bit shit, so is that like, some sort of experiment? I'll have to look into that. Might even mean money going into schools and hospitals, which would be nice.
Caning
Singapore is the best legal system. Im proud to be singaporean
It's too cruel.
Singapore is great, I wish the UK legal system was as strict
@skylark386 rather have a Strict justice system then have criminals everywhere
@@rachaeltan5462Singapore is no utopia, this makes absolutely no difference. If it did reform criminals then we would do it. Stupid person.
We all know... It's the culture of respect, and good jobs, economy hard schooling thats is making singapore safe not this. I mean executing a poor Indonesian for 20 grams of Heroin he for sure would use on himself is OK? That is very very middleage thinking. And all those blue/pink caners sold toi hit kids with. I mean a boss are even aloud to Cane his employees its sick hahaha... I went to Singapore 2 times, it's just too boring and clean, no imagination robotic and strict ... No thank you
Inhumane.
And since Singapore refuses t apply this same punishment to females as well, this makes their "justice" network appear homosexual.